99.99% of Indians seem to have a deep rooted hatred for every common pakistani as well. Acknowledging that is the only way forward for peace in the region
hey brother , as an indian i can say most of the talks ur guest has said is true about india , it is hard to find these speakers in pakistan , 2008 -26/11 was watershed moment , if it happened today , modi would have retaliate without thinking , modi is good for us , he is honest , and country believes in him that he can take country where it was before british came , u may say he is little right wing but he is not extremist , he got majority in UP largest muslim state in india with more than 60 percent vote share , talking about pakistan , modi took a risk of his carrier by visiting pakistan in 2015 but know he feels that their is power vaccum in pakistan and most of indians feels that pakistan govt is controlled by army so their is no one credble to start dialogue with , and as ur govt stopped trade with us on kashmir isssue i dont know was helped by that ban , so pakistan is just completely isolated in higher powers because people feels that whenever we have normal relations some attack occur in INDIA ,
Really bro? Modi will attack us? Kulbushan Yadav came Remember what happend Shot down the plane and imran khan sent him back sayin we want peace..international media covered it...wat abt kashmir? Y there's no media allowed in kashmir? Since modi came Islamophobia in India media is at its peak...once we fix our army we can move on as a nation
As a Pakistani, you are speaking Truth. The pakistani people are also fed up with Army control over our politics, election and who comes or goes from power. Unfortunately, we are still fighting our freedom for democracy.
Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
Excellent podcast. Engrossing and Educative. Few quick points. No mention of Hindus of Karachi. Their contribution to Karach and post partition their migration to India and today, Sindhis are very successful businessmen in India. Unlike Mohajir, Sindhis never faced any linguistic or erhnic discrimination in India. Parsi contribution to India is enormous, Field Marshal Manekshaw, Cricketiar Farooq Engineer, Industralist Godrej and many more. Its great tribute to Hindu culture that nobody Jews, Parsis or Ahmedias ever persecuted in India. Even Bohri community never ever faced any negative fallout because of Qaide Azam M A Jinnah role in creation of Pakistan. Problem is deep rooted Hindu hatred that Mr.Ali Chishti has not a word of praise for them.
Hey, good to see Ali K. Chisti. He is someone among some of the best intellectuals of Pakistan. We Indians were very concerned when we heard that he was picked by Establishment and tortured. He is absolutely a thorough gentleman. He is a great guy. God bless him.
Amazing how Danial wanted to argue and disagree but was completely left speechless because he was presented with facts and logic. Ali Chisti is an extremely well read and well informed guy. Neeed more podcasts with him
Seeing Ali Chishti after a long time. He's as crisp and candid and very bold. Obviously, you would need 3-4 podcasts with him as he's one of the best resource and go-to with international exposure to talk on the subject but very well done, Daniyal.
There are lakhs of Hindu Sindhis who have settled in and around Mumbai..they all are part of our city, state and country...they never felt discriminated ..they are very good at business..they flourished after migration.. unfortunately that didn't happen to Muslims who migrated to Pakistan...they are still called as Mohajirs..and face discrimination
It is us who loved to be called Muhajir (in our home not outside Pakistan), it's our identity among other ethnicities living in Pakistan. Discrimination is completely a different matter.
I am from India,and I watched many videos,you are very good human being because you say all truth without any discrimination IND and Pak,love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️
Excellent podcast. Really liked Ali Chisti's take and in a way admiration towards Modi and the hard line foreign policy. No hypocrisy there. Not blinded by patriotism and jingoism - very objective and straight forward. Not easy to acknowledge. God bless!
Excellent podcast covering the much taboo topics. Full marks to Ali Chishti to reminding people about Jamaat-e-Islami as the mother of evil in Pakistan. They can-not wipe off the blood just by Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman. Kudos to the host Daniyal too
As an Indian I am impressed by Mr.Chisti, he spoke truth(26/11). It’s not easy to talk about faults of one’s own country. Wish there were people like him on this side to talk some sense to the rabid bhakts.
There problem was terrorism ours is senseless lynching, riots, censorship,toxic trolling , otherism, communalism, hate mongering, casteism, anti minority politics,etc. All more or less associated with bhakts.
Randi ke... He said ... Al Qaeda did 26/11 to divert pakistan forces from Waziristan... Are beticho ..Al Qaeda chief was doing party in abottabad near pakistani air force base..but bsdk..you believe him? Sare bhakt bhakt terminology use Karne wale tere jaise re ta-rded gawar hi hote hai.
Born and raised in Karachi and still in 2023 face the same prejudice.. started from school to college to university and in office too. I remember when I was child and my friends used to say that our parents say xyz (ethnic) people are bad. Means that's how we nurture our generation and result is that we hate each other.. I'm not only one here many would relate this. mr ali said we should give amnesty to the mqm workers who were involved in many murder cases becz they belong to mqm.. being that intellectual and supports to culprits where he should condemn for everyone who is involved in any criminal activity in karachi or Pakistan irrespective of any ethnic group.. may Allah protect us and Pakistan
As a Mumbaikar 26/11 is one of the most painful experiences we have witnessed, but I am glad to see such a matured discussion on such a sensitive topic, especially how Ali Chisti ji has explained the finer points on the relations between the two countries have deteriorated. Hope his kinds and tribe increases.
Do you think without the help of isi... Such a very well planned attacked could have been executed...? Najam sethi revealed much better information of isi involvement..
I saw young Ali Chisti when he destroyed lal topi where he was emphasizing on solving internal problems. His words were so true. Today Pakistan is going through the same he along with Hasan Nisar mentioned.
Very informative podcast by Ali Chishti. He's a gem of a person in person too. He stated the fact and full marks to Daniyal to bring him as we know he had not being coming or giving interviews. Thanks a lot for this podcast
Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
In Pakistan, the quota system was actually introduced in 1948 when Liaquat Ali Khan was the prime minister who was the real architect of the quota system. A notification issued on September 1, 1948 laid down recruitment policy for the central services. Under the policy 15 per cent quota was reserved for the candidates who had not yet acquired the domicile of Pakistan.
I've moved from Karachi in 2014 I was born and was brought up in Karachi from 1998 to 2014 now when I talk about Karachi I'm being called ghair mukaaami and bashed by people ..... I've immense love for Karachi and it's so heart wrenching to hear all this
@@pluto331 does it matter ???? And if yes why does it matter ??? An individual has lived almost 15-16 years of life in a same place and yet he's bound to give proof of his love for the place ???
Wow, I'm seeing AK Chishti after 7-8 years. He was very active in Karachi news back then on social media. He had a huge MqM related controversy after which he completely went off all social media. Good to see him back.
@@harismansoor5733 Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
Why nobody is talking about India's direct involvement in many suicide attacks in Pakistan. Killing someone innocent can not be justified in any way, but somehow Pakistan failed in showing the world about India's involvement in many blasts in Pakistan.
I don't know if India was involved in any attack inside pakistan..... But if you keep sheltering alqaida, lashkar e tayyaba, jaish e mohmmad type organisations....... Who is gonna belive you..... Even today... Globally declared terrorist hafiz saeed was preaching openly in rawlpindi.......so keep sheltering thses snakes until they destroy pakistan completely.... 👍
Stumbled upon this podcast and loved it. Great to see Ali Chisti after a long time, remember seeing him on Kamran Shahid's show. Sir, with all due respect to both, your understanding of India is way too simplistic. There was Congress govt from 2009-14 and the peace of talks didn't go anywhere even then. This is a foreign policy, doesn't change with govt. By the same token, it was Mr Vajpayee, who belongs to the same BJP/RSS from where Mr Modi comes, who started the peace process which you on your show were gloating on. Second, Mr Modi too tried the peace initiative, first in 2014 with his swearing in and second in 2015, when Mr Modi landed in Pakistan. Within a month we had Pathankot which has created a mood that after kab tak. I'm a great advocate of India-Pakistan friendship. Also, regarding extremism, we had instances in Kerela in 2016 where a professor's hand was chopped by a Muslim mob for saying something on Islam. Again there is no BJP MP or MLA in Kerela. So this frenzy is everywhere. These things are more amplified due to exposure and social media. Also, whenever Sara Ali khan gets trolled for visiting a temple or SRK gets trolled for ganesh chaturthi, check out the names of the people trolling him. Also, regarding media, sir you guys had PPL like Zaid Hamid, whom I know Ali doesn't like, were gloating about the attack and balkanization of India. I know that's not truly representative of Pakistan but this also is true. My msg is apna Zehen istemal karein, behkawe mein mat jaayein. Love from across the border in Delhi.
Yes Daniyal, you rightly said that our roots are the same. I too sincerely wish that the relationships between India and Pakistan are improved. This will definitely benefit the common ppl of both the countries. Hats off to you for talking about India differently from the mainstream media. At the same time, we do understand that it's their "rozi roti." Of course, this applies to our Indian media as well. Lastly, hope to see many more interesting contents in the future.
No thanks, we are not the same " anymore". Best policy is just IGNORE Pakistan and mind our ( Indian) business. Let them do whatever they wish to do. It's their choice. Thank you.
But he doesn't know even pm of Pakistan said osam bin Laden is shaheed where your pm declared terrorist as shaheed then what we can expect from common people
Excellent podcast. Ali Chishti Shb has a treasure of knowledge and I understand reading some comments about the heat Ali Chishti has faced, its obvious. Daniyal keep doing the good work and looking forward for part 2 of Ali Shb.
Pakistani attacked on 26/11 - 1) Hotel taj 2) Oberoi trident 3) Nariman house 4) Cama hospital 5) Max Cinema 6) Chatrapati Shivaji railway station 7) Cafe leopold
One of the best podacast ever, is se pehle yeh batien kbhi zindagi me na suni na pata krne ki koshish ki, srf suni sunaen baatien sun kr bethe rahe itni knowledge is se pehle kahi se ese interesting tareeqey se nhi milinThankyou Daniyal bhai for this❤❤
Some Pakistanis were definitely happy about the 26/11 attacks. On one hand we were celebrating the attacks and at the same time were saying "yeh to India ne khud hi karwaya hai..."
My grandfather had shop in Karachi. He used to travel from Kutch to Karachi via boat and it used to take 9 days i think. He don't use word partition till date. He says "Karachi fetai". It is Kutchi word for Downfall of Karachi. He says we had shop in Saddar Bazar. He lost his eyesight so i will never able to bring him there to see it but I wish I can visit Saddar bazar once.
Daniyal, your response to India's tit for tat policy is wrong. Despite every excuse you guys come up with, the fact is all terrorists were and are trained in Pakistan and India is fed up with your country. We have no time to think about your views and policies as India concentrates on progress. The basic requirement for Pakistan is to set its house in order and forget about other countries.
At 41:48, they said, terrorists blew an Egyptian embassy in Islamabad, Pakistan while the host responded "Hamara Kia Taluq Hy". Really, you're not kid bro! Always non-researched based podcasts by Daniyal shaikh, seems like an interview guide of some old text book.
Being a non-urdu. Our relatives (even non MQM muhajirs ) tell us that they were regularly threatened by MQM's workers & supporters. MQM's people comes and demolish there walls if they didn't gave them Bhata. Yet you think MQM is good. I just can that God bless you with intellect. Muhajir AUR Karachi ko Tabha o barbaad karnay wali hi MQM hai. One more important thing is that Urdu speaking people were in superiority complex that no one can be bigger then them. For example they said Pashtons are controlling Low-level Business in Karachi. They were gaining Control because if they can make money from garbage don't you think they can't do that. You have to understand that your superiority complex killed you....
Which community in Pakistan doensr have superiority complex? Punjabis think they are superior as they dominate the armed forces and cinder themselves more patriotic then anyone else. Pashtuns too take pride in their customs and consider Indus Valley people as inferior daal khors. Sindhis think they are superior and consider Urdu speakers as inferior Panahgir. Enough of this muhajir bashing, no one is saint here and Urdu speakers were literally the last community in Pakistan to ascert their nationalism and that too because others had started to do the same esp after 1971 when muhajirs got convinced that this state doesn’t care for them when we literally threw Urdu speaking Biharis at the mercy of mukti bahini while we shamelessly took lacs of ungreatful afghans for dollars
@@msr7373 First of all if you think our elite or the state is ruled by punjabis, Balochis, Pashtuns or any other ethnicity; so, you are wrong. The Pakistani elite doesn't care about Punjabi, Muhajir, Sindhi, Balochi or Pashtuns.... It's like saying "America is the representative of Christianity"..... Sindhis consider Muhajirs inferior, which Sindhis? The elites one? The waderas? Which don't actually represent the people of Sindh?. Pakistan is a complex country, which ruled by a class which doesn't give a f about you and me. And I think it was meant to be like this.... (And there are historical evidences for this). So stop dividing yourself into ethnicity, no one is against your ethnicity, no ethnicity, caste, religion or race is superior than other..... Try to understand that you are just a puppet, fighting with each other in the name of ethnicity, while your own leaders were made and supported by the establishment/elites. For example: IK, Nawaz sharif, Bhutto, Alt*f hu*s.... And many more. These all were supported, pushed or created(politically) by the state. And we the people of Karachi who have lived her for decades, whose whole family is in Karachi, who abandoned their language just because they want to merge with the people of Karachi, have faced a tremendous amount of violence by MQM. They didn't do anything, they were in power for decades, yet, they didn't do anything(except mustafa's era, which was supported by a dictator). So, I don't have any hopes from them. They always, always brag about ethnicity. I mean is ethnicity the only problem?. Is any human superior to any other human?. Haven't you even read your own religion? .....
@@msr7373 Let me clear again Muhajirs were convinced that some leader would help him by stopping economic activity, k*lling people and using all means of violence.... It's was the dumb thing. If they were to make a functioning Karachi then it would be very great.... But they do it... And at that time the upper-middle and educated class of Muhajirs didn't supported MQM. I know many people who were in MQM, and left after they saw what MQM was upto.... Most of them used to hear firing sounds regular outside their houses, after they left.......
Ali, what you are saying is directly coming from heart and resonating with the hearts of many Karachiites! It is refershing to see that people who speaks truth are still there. Thank you Daniyal for bringing Ali to your show. It has definitely increased the quality even further and I am loving it!
Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
Ye jo banda hai ali chishti isne india pe jo jankari diyi he ye 90% correct hai.pakistan me india ke bare me sahi jankari hone vale bahot kam lok hai isme ye banda hai.very knowledgeble person about india.
Great points by Ali Chishti Shb. I think that a, he's spot on JI relationship with terrorism in Pakistan b, on Mohajir traregdy and institutional relationships etc. He's a great resource . .
1947 ALL MUHAJIRS PAKISTAN JINDABAD NOW " PAKISTAN SE JINDA BHAAG" PAKISTAN IS A DAMNED STATE। ITS KARMA, EVERYONE WHO HAVE ANY ROLE TO CREAT PAKISTAN GET PUNISHED BY PAKISTAN, LIKE JINNAH, LIYAQAT ALI KHAN, FATIMA JINNAH, SIR JAFFARULLAH KHAN, JOGENDR NATH MANDAL, REHMAT ALI ( WHO SUGGEST NAME OF PAKISTAN) AND ALL AHMADI, BANGALI WHO CREATE PAKISTAN।
1:05:40 His name was Omar Saeed sheikh not Khalid sheikh Mohammed..ksm was architect of 9/11. Omar Saeed sheikh was financer of 9/11 , jaish e Mohamed and beheader of Daniel pearl
The same Omar Saeed sheikh was rotting in Indian jail then you guys hijacked ic814 ..and demanded Maulana Masood Azhar, Omar Saeed sheikh and two others.
In an interview I think 1987 or 85 Benjamin Nathan Yahoo gave an interview in which he said that we should stop Islamic fundamentalism or else some militants will blow the world trade center. How he predicted the exact scene 14 to 16 years before?
Yaar what a powerful and informative podcast Daniyal. I didnt know Ali bhai before this podcast but now i have become a fan of his knowledge. Thank you for having him. Keep it up 👍
Best podcast, but i just wanted to correct one thing that Biharis in Bangladesh are more comfortable and happy thier first cricket captain Akram Khan was Bihari, his nephew Tamim iqbal is still main stream player in Bangladesh Cricket tear.. also Biharis families are doing great businesses there
Dear Dani, Very informative podcast, this kind of information is for everyone. Especially about the history of immigrants in Pakistan/Karachi and various communities and the difficulties they face.
Hindus came from sindh /kp/ Punjab , settled in whole of india Nobody calls them muhajir or any other name ill treatment of muhajirs is best rebuttal to 2 nation theory
Your comparison is wrong. Punjabi and Bengali refugees then be Hindus or Muslims were never called refugees as they both had a section of Bengal and Punjab ready to accommodate them in both india and Pakistan. They simply moved from one side of their native province to another. As for Sindhis despite their business acumen Etc their numbers were too small to be a dominant community anywhere except for small towns like adipur and Ulhasnagar. Sindhis in terms of number are a microscopic minority in india at just 0.25% who are sprinkled all over india thus too small to create any sort of challenge or uneasiness for any ethnicity unlike Urdu speaking muhajirs who are one of the largest communities in Pakistan numerically and dominate the largest city and commercial hub of the country. Due to which an ethnic identity was born whcih could assert itself politically. Sindhis in india are too small to assert themselves as a political entity like large groups in india can like Sikhs or Tamils or Gujaratis Etc.
its good that we are talking about all these stuff, we must learn our mistakes and make sure never to repeat such. every great society had made mistakes in past and learn from there mistakes and move forward.
These ignorants are just blabbering without any knowledge about India & Modi. They are ok with Islamic nation n persecution of minorities in Pak, but they have strong conviction that India must be secular and doesn’t have any option.
چشتی صاحب سے پوچھ کر ضرور تحریر کیجئے گا ۔the mahajer tragedy کس پبلشر نے چھاپی ہے۔اور چشتی کا صاحب کا پورا نام کیا ہے۔امید ہے آپ جواب ضرور دیں گیں ۔ میں نے نیٹ پر بہت ڈھونڈا مگر ابھی تک ملی نہیں ۔شکریہ تنویر کوئٹہ
@@jyothishpailla2018lesson yeh hai keh jo abhi pakistan mein horha hai woh kabhi bhi kahin pr ho skta hai Not any specific names but kahin bhi hoskta hai Us cheez ke lye ready raho baby
99.99% of Pakistani has always own version history.but this guy looks knowledgeable , acknowledging truth make u perfect as a nation,
99.99% of Indians seem to have a deep rooted hatred for every common pakistani as well. Acknowledging that is the only way forward for peace in the region
hey brother , as an indian i can say most of the talks ur guest has said is true about india , it is hard to find these speakers in pakistan , 2008 -26/11 was watershed moment , if it happened today , modi would have retaliate without thinking , modi is good for us , he is honest , and country believes in him that he can take country where it was before british came , u may say he is little right wing but he is not extremist , he got majority in UP largest muslim state in india with more than 60 percent vote share , talking about pakistan , modi took a risk of his carrier by visiting pakistan in 2015 but know he feels that their is power vaccum in pakistan and most of indians feels that pakistan govt is controlled by army so their is no one credble to start dialogue with , and as ur govt stopped trade with us on kashmir isssue i dont know was helped by that ban , so pakistan is just completely isolated in higher powers because people feels that whenever we have normal relations some attack occur in INDIA ,
Bro don’t expect any intelligence from them . They live in their own metaversa they think they r important for world but no one gives a shit
Agree
Really bro?
Modi will attack us?
Kulbushan Yadav came
Remember what happend
Shot down the plane and imran khan sent him back sayin we want peace..international media covered it...wat abt kashmir? Y there's no media allowed in kashmir? Since modi came Islamophobia in India media is at its peak...once we fix our army we can move on as a nation
As a Pakistani, you are speaking Truth. The pakistani people are also fed up with Army control over our politics, election and who comes or goes from power. Unfortunately, we are still fighting our freedom for democracy.
@MUHAMMAD Khan yes u r right its our army that never let pak go forward
I am from India and I am impressed with the way @Daniyal Sheikh handles his podcast. Ali Chishti is a very knowledgeable and learned person.
Best podcast, didn't know about Ali Chishti before. He seems like a nice and informative guy, we need more podcasts with him.
Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
Excellent podcast. Engrossing and Educative. Few quick points. No mention of Hindus of Karachi. Their contribution to Karach and post partition their migration to India and today, Sindhis are very successful businessmen in India. Unlike Mohajir, Sindhis never faced any linguistic or erhnic discrimination in India. Parsi contribution to India is enormous, Field Marshal Manekshaw, Cricketiar Farooq Engineer, Industralist Godrej and many more. Its great tribute to Hindu culture that nobody Jews, Parsis or Ahmedias ever persecuted in India. Even Bohri community never ever faced any negative fallout because of Qaide Azam M A Jinnah role in creation of Pakistan. Problem is deep rooted Hindu hatred that Mr.Ali Chishti has not a word of praise for them.
Hey, good to see Ali K. Chisti. He is someone among some of the best intellectuals of Pakistan. We Indians were very concerned when we heard that he was picked by Establishment and tortured. He is absolutely a thorough gentleman. He is a great guy. God bless him.
Amazing how Danial wanted to argue and disagree but was completely left speechless because he was presented with facts and logic. Ali Chisti is an extremely well read and well informed guy. Neeed more podcasts with him
Seeing Ali Chishti after a long time. He's as crisp and candid and very bold. Obviously, you would need 3-4 podcasts with him as he's one of the best resource and go-to with international exposure to talk on the subject but very well done, Daniyal.
There are lakhs of Hindu Sindhis who have settled in and around Mumbai..they all are part of our city, state and country...they never felt discriminated ..they are very good at business..they flourished after migration.. unfortunately that didn't happen to Muslims who migrated to Pakistan...they are still called as Mohajirs..and face discrimination
It is us who loved to be called Muhajir (in our home not outside Pakistan), it's our identity among other ethnicities living in Pakistan. Discrimination is completely a different matter.
Yes racist in South Asia at its peaks
Thats why its called “do kaumi nazaria”
Sindhis felt many difficulties to settle in India but muhajirs take house of Sindhi Hindus which left Sindh after muhajirs attack Hindus in Karachi
@sagarthakker685 not all of them but most of them. You may also find Radical Sindhis of that level.
Bhai sahab 92 blast, kandhar hijack, 99 kargil, 2001 parliament attack, 26/11. Kitane chot mile hai hamane. Hamare leaders ne hamesha hath badhaya hai tumane pith pe chhura gopa hai.
Great podcast. Saw Ali Shb after a long time. He's very knowledgable!
I am from India,and I watched many videos,you are very good human being because you say all truth without any discrimination IND and Pak,love from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️
Excellent podcast. Really liked Ali Chisti's take and in a way admiration towards Modi and the hard line foreign policy. No hypocrisy there. Not blinded by patriotism and jingoism - very objective and straight forward. Not easy to acknowledge.
God bless!
Excellent podcast covering the much taboo topics. Full marks to Ali Chishti to reminding people about Jamaat-e-Islami as the mother of evil in Pakistan. They can-not wipe off the blood just by Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman. Kudos to the host Daniyal too
As an Indian I am impressed by Mr.Chisti, he spoke truth(26/11). It’s not easy to talk about faults of one’s own country. Wish there were people like him on this side to talk some sense to the rabid bhakts.
Do indian Bakths do this ?
There problem was terrorism ours is senseless lynching, riots, censorship,toxic trolling , otherism, communalism, hate mongering, casteism, anti minority politics,etc. All more or less associated with bhakts.
Dude.. literally whitewashed pakistan establishment involvement in 26/11 by blaming it on non state actors and you chugged all that sheet happily??
Randi ke... He said ... Al Qaeda did 26/11 to divert pakistan forces from Waziristan... Are beticho ..Al Qaeda chief was doing party in abottabad near pakistani air force base..but bsdk..you believe him?
Sare bhakt bhakt terminology use Karne wale tere jaise re ta-rded gawar hi hote hai.
Oh just shut up he shunned the establishment role in 26/11
No need of daniyal presence in this conversation, this man is enough by himself totally... Wisdom speaks loudly!
44:15 military training se copy nhi kiya aapki military ne hi unko training di thi
Born and raised in Karachi and still in 2023 face the same prejudice.. started from school to college to university and in office too. I remember when I was child and my friends used to say that our parents say xyz (ethnic) people are bad. Means that's how we nurture our generation and result is that we hate each other.. I'm not only one here many would relate this. mr ali said we should give amnesty to the mqm workers who were involved in many murder cases becz they belong to mqm.. being that intellectual and supports to culprits where he should condemn for everyone who is involved in any criminal activity in karachi or Pakistan irrespective of any ethnic group.. may Allah protect us and Pakistan
As a Mumbaikar 26/11 is one of the most painful experiences we have witnessed, but I am glad to see such a matured discussion on such a sensitive topic, especially how Ali Chisti ji has explained the finer points on the relations between the two countries have deteriorated. Hope his kinds and tribe increases.
The pain is still fresh in our hearts
He whitewashed pakistan establishment involvement in 26/11 by blaming it on non state actors...yet you are praising him. Azeeb haal hai
Non State actors..nope it was isi
Do you think without the help of isi... Such a very well planned attacked could have been executed...?
Najam sethi revealed much better information of isi involvement..
You call this mature? 😂 pure drama.
I saw young Ali Chisti when he destroyed lal topi where he was emphasizing on solving internal problems. His words were so true. Today Pakistan is going through the same he along with Hasan Nisar mentioned.
Very informative podcast by Ali Chishti. He's a gem of a person in person too. He stated the fact and full marks to Daniyal to bring him as we know he had not being coming or giving interviews. Thanks a lot for this podcast
Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
ab tak tak best podcast.. very informative and to the point.. hatsoff
In Pakistan, the quota system was actually introduced in 1948 when Liaquat Ali Khan was the prime minister who was the real architect of the quota system. A notification issued on September 1, 1948 laid down recruitment policy for the central services. Under the policy 15 per cent quota was reserved for the candidates who had not yet acquired the domicile of Pakistan.
I've moved from Karachi in 2014 I was born and was brought up in Karachi from 1998 to 2014 now when I talk about Karachi I'm being called ghair mukaaami and bashed by people ..... I've immense love for Karachi and it's so heart wrenching to hear all this
First of all what's your ethnicity and behaviour and personality and accent and dress code.
@@pluto331 does it matter ???? And if yes why does it matter ??? An individual has lived almost 15-16 years of life in a same place and yet he's bound to give proof of his love for the place ???
If you are not from muhajir community then you are a gair muqaami
@@HAIDER_at_UA-camAllah ke rasool ne farmaya :- ek musalman doosre musalman ka bhai hai , ye baat pakistani q nhi samajhte Islam ko seekhna chahiye.
Wow, I'm seeing AK Chishti after 7-8 years. He was very active in Karachi news back then on social media. He had a huge MqM related controversy after which he completely went off all social media. Good to see him back.
What kind of controversy
چشتی صاحب کا مکمل نام کیا ہے۔
@@harismansoor5733 Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
@3:55 If mqm wasnt fighting the state then it was fighting with its citizens. The terror that MQM spread impacted all of us.
Yes brother Karachi ki awam sab se chutia easily exploit by foreign power
@@traviskalanick196 gaer muqamion ko sahi qatal kiya thaa,
gaer muhajiron ko zabah hi karna chahiye thaa karachi
karachi sirf muhajiron ka hai
@@okbrostartcoping5835 don't be racist Karachi kisi ke baap ka nhi he sab ka he
Karachi sab ka hai lekin Karachi ko koi bhee own nahin karta, itna kachra issi liye bana hai is shaher ka
Brilliant and to the core by Ali Chishti. Few has the grasp on such topics and the bravely to say it is. Well done, Daniyal.
Why nobody is talking about India's direct involvement in many suicide attacks in Pakistan. Killing someone innocent can not be justified in any way, but somehow Pakistan failed in showing the world about India's involvement in many blasts in Pakistan.
I don't know if India was involved in any attack inside pakistan..... But if you keep sheltering alqaida, lashkar e tayyaba, jaish e mohmmad type organisations....... Who is gonna belive you..... Even today... Globally declared terrorist hafiz saeed was preaching openly in rawlpindi.......so keep sheltering thses snakes until they destroy pakistan completely.... 👍
Stumbled upon this podcast and loved it. Great to see Ali Chisti after a long time, remember seeing him on Kamran Shahid's show. Sir, with all due respect to both, your understanding of India is way too simplistic. There was Congress govt from 2009-14 and the peace of talks didn't go anywhere even then. This is a foreign policy, doesn't change with govt. By the same token, it was Mr Vajpayee, who belongs to the same BJP/RSS from where Mr Modi comes, who started the peace process which you on your show were gloating on. Second, Mr Modi too tried the peace initiative, first in 2014 with his swearing in and second in 2015, when Mr Modi landed in Pakistan. Within a month we had Pathankot which has created a mood that after kab tak. I'm a great advocate of India-Pakistan friendship. Also, regarding extremism, we had instances in Kerela in 2016 where a professor's hand was chopped by a Muslim mob for saying something on Islam. Again there is no BJP MP or MLA in Kerela. So this frenzy is everywhere. These things are more amplified due to exposure and social media. Also, whenever Sara Ali khan gets trolled for visiting a temple or SRK gets trolled for ganesh chaturthi, check out the names of the people trolling him. Also, regarding media, sir you guys had PPL like Zaid Hamid, whom I know Ali doesn't like, were gloating about the attack and balkanization of India. I know that's not truly representative of Pakistan but this also is true. My msg is apna Zehen istemal karein, behkawe mein mat jaayein. Love from across the border in Delhi.
Yes Daniyal, you rightly said that our roots are the same. I too sincerely wish that the relationships between India and Pakistan are improved. This will definitely benefit the common ppl of both the countries.
Hats off to you for talking about India differently from the mainstream media. At the same time, we do understand that it's their "rozi roti." Of course, this applies to our Indian media as well.
Lastly, hope to see many more interesting contents in the future.
He also says that he love hafiz saeed
No thanks, we are not the same " anymore".
Best policy is just IGNORE Pakistan and mind our ( Indian) business.
Let them do whatever they wish to do. It's their choice.
Thank you.
@@HOG1070thankyou sir for minding your own business
Kindly remind as many people as you can
No offence🙌❤️
@@dezastrous359
ohh yes sure I will.
He's a dictionary for knowledge hats off the best podcast
and an encyclopedia of fraud! inbox me for details! :)
But he doesn't know even pm of Pakistan said osam bin Laden is shaheed where your pm declared terrorist as shaheed then what we can expect from common people
Excellent podcast. Ali Chishti Shb has a treasure of knowledge and I understand reading some comments about the heat Ali Chishti has faced, its obvious. Daniyal keep doing the good work and looking forward for part 2 of Ali Shb.
Pakistani attacked on 26/11 -
1) Hotel taj
2) Oberoi trident
3) Nariman house
4) Cama hospital
5) Max Cinema
6) Chatrapati Shivaji railway station
7) Cafe leopold
In 90's, On Indian govt TV channel (Doordarshan) news, MQM (Altaf Khan) protests were covered majorly. He was famous in India as a Muhajir leader.
You mean Altar hussain?
One of the best podacast ever, is se pehle yeh batien kbhi zindagi me na suni na pata krne ki koshish ki, srf suni sunaen baatien sun kr bethe rahe itni knowledge is se pehle kahi se ese interesting tareeqey se nhi milinThankyou Daniyal bhai for this❤❤
Some Pakistanis were definitely happy about the 26/11 attacks. On one hand we were celebrating the attacks and at the same time were saying "yeh to India ne khud hi karwaya hai..."
Raw aur Isi ne attacks karaye the India aur Pakistan mein. Iska faida dono countries ki army ne aur dono countries k politicians ne faida uthaya he
One of your best podcast...❤❤
Not just divided by Borders but also Religion, not by Indian side but Pakistan.....
1:05:50 ... jamatio k kpray utray tu siittttiii gum hogyii.. moo se awazz nahi nkl rhi Host sahab k..
My grandfather had shop in Karachi. He used to travel from Kutch to Karachi via boat and it used to take 9 days i think. He don't use word partition till date. He says "Karachi fetai". It is Kutchi word for Downfall of Karachi. He says we had shop in Saddar Bazar. He lost his eyesight so i will never able to bring him there to see it but I wish I can visit Saddar bazar once.
Agar Danish bar bar Interrupt karta I was leave Podcast ... Im Glad to listen Ali Chisti Great Person.....
Where we can find the document which you are talking about
Maturity in your podcasts is supreme
It seems to be lacking due to host's stupid questions.
@@taybawalay1602 then why you are watching its better for you to watch some other cringe things🙏🙏🥱
@@s_abisrazaidi Because of the guest.
Not sure why you are upset 😸
@@taybawalay1602 ok sir then you must do a better a podcast with better host and guests
@@s_abisrazaidi not sure why are you arguing..
Daniyal, your response to India's tit for tat policy is wrong. Despite every excuse you guys come up with, the fact is all terrorists were and are trained in Pakistan and India is fed up with your country. We have no time to think about your views and policies as India concentrates on progress. The basic requirement for Pakistan is to set its house in order and forget about other countries.
As Indian I appreciate your podcast bcoz you providing good information.
47:06 i understand you can't call them terrorists but there's no such thing as non-state actors and they were state sponsored terrorists
This is your best podcast!! Daniyal bhai❤
At 41:48, they said, terrorists blew an Egyptian embassy in Islamabad, Pakistan while the host responded "Hamara Kia Taluq Hy". Really, you're not kid bro!
Always non-researched based podcasts by Daniyal shaikh, seems like an interview guide of some old text book.
ye podcast repeat dekhna bhi achha lagta hai...Ali bhai ko fir jaldi bulaiyega...nice to listen to him
Hello Daniyal bhai , Consider this as an appreciation comment. Nice podcast.
Wow Daniyal, great job, for the first time me and my whole family are watching a podcast together.
I never commented on any you tube video but you deserve appreciation we need more people like in both the countries. Respect from India
List down your topics and questions under those headings and find answer before your ask guests..and review guests profile on linkedin, wiki etc.
Being a non-urdu. Our relatives (even non MQM muhajirs ) tell us that they were regularly threatened by MQM's workers & supporters. MQM's people comes and demolish there walls if they didn't gave them Bhata. Yet you think MQM is good. I just can that God bless you with intellect. Muhajir AUR Karachi ko Tabha o barbaad karnay wali hi MQM hai. One more important thing is that Urdu speaking people were in superiority complex that no one can be bigger then them. For example they said Pashtons are controlling Low-level Business in Karachi. They were gaining Control because if they can make money from garbage don't you think they can't do that. You have to understand that your superiority complex killed you....
Just some cooked up stories you have been into
Which community in Pakistan doensr have superiority complex? Punjabis think they are superior as they dominate the armed forces and cinder themselves more patriotic then anyone else. Pashtuns too take pride in their customs and consider Indus Valley people as inferior daal khors. Sindhis think they are superior and consider Urdu speakers as inferior Panahgir. Enough of this muhajir bashing, no one is saint here and Urdu speakers were literally the last community in Pakistan to ascert their nationalism and that too because others had started to do the same esp after 1971 when muhajirs got convinced that this state doesn’t care for them when we literally threw Urdu speaking Biharis at the mercy of mukti bahini while we shamelessly took lacs of ungreatful afghans for dollars
@@msr7373 First of all if you think our elite or the state is ruled by punjabis, Balochis, Pashtuns or any other ethnicity; so, you are wrong. The Pakistani elite doesn't care about Punjabi, Muhajir, Sindhi, Balochi or Pashtuns.... It's like saying "America is the representative of Christianity"..... Sindhis consider Muhajirs inferior, which Sindhis? The elites one? The waderas? Which don't actually represent the people of Sindh?. Pakistan is a complex country, which ruled by a class which doesn't give a f about you and me. And I think it was meant to be like this.... (And there are historical evidences for this). So stop dividing yourself into ethnicity, no one is against your ethnicity, no ethnicity, caste, religion or race is superior than other.....
Try to understand that you are just a puppet, fighting with each other in the name of ethnicity, while your own leaders were made and supported by the establishment/elites. For example: IK, Nawaz sharif, Bhutto, Alt*f hu*s.... And many more. These all were supported, pushed or created(politically) by the state.
And we the people of Karachi who have lived her for decades, whose whole family is in Karachi, who abandoned their language just because they want to merge with the people of Karachi, have faced a tremendous amount of violence by MQM. They didn't do anything, they were in power for decades, yet, they didn't do anything(except mustafa's era, which was supported by a dictator). So, I don't have any hopes from them. They always, always brag about ethnicity. I mean is ethnicity the only problem?. Is any human superior to any other human?. Haven't you even read your own religion? .....
@@msr7373 Let me clear again Muhajirs were convinced that some leader would help him by stopping economic activity, k*lling people and using all means of violence.... It's was the dumb thing. If they were to make a functioning Karachi then it would be very great.... But they do it... And at that time the upper-middle and educated class of Muhajirs didn't supported MQM. I know many people who were in MQM, and left after they saw what MQM was upto.... Most of them used to hear firing sounds regular outside their houses, after they left.......
Can anyone explain what does Mahazir mean?
Bhai kahan se dhund k latay ho aisai informative log ?
One of the best podcasts ever.
Best one so far
Living and watching from nazimabad no.1 KHI.
Ali, what you are saying is directly coming from heart and resonating with the hearts of many Karachiites! It is refershing to see that people who speaks truth are still there. Thank you Daniyal for bringing Ali to your show. It has definitely increased the quality even further and I am loving it!
Fraudia hai bhai. Do a search on " journalist Ali Kamran Chisti took money from Altaf Hussain fooled him that he can make matter better between Army and MQM" and you will know the reality of this BS con artist! he has also swindled money from investors in his company.
Great Podcast by Daniyal and Ali Chishti whom I had followed for 14 years. He's an excellent human and an extra ordinary author and analyst.
One of the best Podcast I have ever seen in my life. You nailed it broski 🥊💯
A great podcast Daniyal sir, Ali did some great informative talks and would surely love too see him once again in your podcast.
Ye jo banda hai ali chishti isne india pe jo jankari diyi he ye 90% correct hai.pakistan me india ke bare me sahi jankari hone vale bahot kam lok hai isme ye banda hai.very knowledgeble person about india.
Seeing ali chisti after a long time....
Absolute crystal clear source 👏👏👏
Hindu kings gave shelter to Parsis when they fled from Iran due to persecution by Islamic forces from the Middle East.
Great points by Ali Chishti Shb. I think that a, he's spot on JI relationship with terrorism in Pakistan b, on Mohajir traregdy and institutional relationships etc. He's a great resource . .
1947 ALL MUHAJIRS PAKISTAN JINDABAD
NOW " PAKISTAN SE JINDA BHAAG"
PAKISTAN IS A DAMNED STATE।
ITS KARMA, EVERYONE WHO HAVE ANY ROLE TO CREAT PAKISTAN GET PUNISHED BY PAKISTAN, LIKE JINNAH, LIYAQAT ALI KHAN, FATIMA JINNAH, SIR JAFFARULLAH KHAN, JOGENDR NATH MANDAL, REHMAT ALI ( WHO SUGGEST NAME OF PAKISTAN) AND ALL AHMADI, BANGALI WHO CREATE PAKISTAN।
1:05:40 His name was Omar Saeed sheikh not Khalid sheikh Mohammed..ksm was architect of 9/11. Omar Saeed sheikh was financer of 9/11 , jaish e Mohamed and beheader of Daniel pearl
The same Omar Saeed sheikh was rotting in Indian jail then you guys hijacked ic814 ..and demanded Maulana Masood Azhar, Omar Saeed sheikh and two others.
In an interview I think 1987 or 85 Benjamin Nathan Yahoo gave an interview in which he said that we should stop Islamic fundamentalism or else some militants will blow the world trade center. How he predicted the exact scene 14 to 16 years before?
Yaar what a powerful and informative podcast Daniyal. I didnt know Ali bhai before this podcast but now i have become a fan of his knowledge. Thank you for having him. Keep it up 👍
Just one thing i will neglect of ali chishti is that the reunion of the MQM according to him is good but adapting to me it has no benefit 🤷🏻♂️
Rubbish , check your facts ,salauddin, hafiz Sayeed n army / isi colonel , involved and now protected by your army commandos, shame
Best podcast, but i just wanted to correct one thing that Biharis in Bangladesh are more comfortable and happy thier first cricket captain Akram Khan was Bihari, his nephew Tamim iqbal is still main stream player in Bangladesh Cricket tear.. also Biharis families are doing great businesses there
Mission majnu is a periodic film based on the late 70s and early 80s.
It's good to listen to history of Karachi..
were is topic of baldiya factory
Love from🇮🇳
Dear Dani, Very informative podcast, this kind of information is for everyone. Especially about the history of immigrants in Pakistan/Karachi and various communities and the difficulties they face.
Part 2 kab ayega???
Always wanted someone to do podcasts like these you have inspired me and many thank u for your time passion and dedication.
Hindus came from sindh /kp/ Punjab , settled in whole of india
Nobody calls them muhajir or any other name
ill treatment of muhajirs is best rebuttal to 2 nation theory
Your comparison is wrong. Punjabi and Bengali refugees then be Hindus or Muslims were never called refugees as they both had a section of Bengal and Punjab ready to accommodate them in both india and Pakistan. They simply moved from one side of their native province to another. As for Sindhis despite their business acumen Etc their numbers were too small to be a dominant community anywhere except for small towns like adipur and Ulhasnagar. Sindhis in terms of number are a microscopic minority in india at just 0.25% who are sprinkled all over india thus too small to create any sort of challenge or uneasiness for any ethnicity unlike Urdu speaking muhajirs who are one of the largest communities in Pakistan numerically and dominate the largest city and commercial hub of the country. Due to which an ethnic identity was born whcih could assert itself politically. Sindhis in india are too small to assert themselves as a political entity like large groups in india can like Sikhs or Tamils or Gujaratis Etc.
Best podcast ever in my life so far ❤
its good that we are talking about all these stuff, we must learn our mistakes and make sure never to repeat such. every great society had made mistakes in past and learn from there mistakes and move forward.
Hyderabad is also suffering not only Karachi till now
Boy zabrdast ali Bhai ka podcast part 2 b ana chaiye..... Ye topic continue hona chaiye...
Please time stamp bhi daal do east rahega
One of the best pod cast . But few things you have to correct 😊
Guest have so much information so impressed
Great informative podcast. Keep it up brother. Love from India
Daniyal, thanks for highlighting the baseline:)
These ignorants are just blabbering without any knowledge about India & Modi. They are ok with Islamic nation n persecution of minorities in Pak, but they have strong conviction that India must be secular and doesn’t have any option.
There were still some pakistani who
Were celebrated our suffering in 26/11
From Bohras to Parsis, from Jews to Muslims... Anyone who has faced persecution has always found shelter in India
چشتی صاحب سے پوچھ کر ضرور تحریر کیجئے گا ۔the mahajer tragedy کس پبلشر نے چھاپی ہے۔اور چشتی کا صاحب کا پورا نام کیا ہے۔امید ہے آپ جواب ضرور دیں گیں ۔ میں نے نیٹ پر بہت ڈھونڈا مگر ابھی تک ملی نہیں ۔شکریہ تنویر کوئٹہ
The book is to be released in India by Penguin and later in Pakistan this year. There are two books.
Good show...plz share the guests books
Best podcast from Pakistan. Every Indian should learn and take lesson from this video
Achaaa. Konsa lesson baby 🐥 🍼
Yes the lesson would be don't ever believe in Pakistani's even they are sweet talking.
@@jyothishpailla2018lesson yeh hai keh jo abhi pakistan mein horha hai woh kabhi bhi kahin pr ho skta hai
Not any specific names but kahin bhi hoskta hai
Us cheez ke lye ready raho baby
@@dezastrous359 🤧🤧🤧🥱🥱🥱
Achaaaaaa...... Theek hai theek hai
It was a nice discussion
Waiting for next episode with his. He is very intellectual and honest
Part 2 kab ayega
Appreciate your content