Scream 5 (2022) VS Scream 6 (2023)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 чер 2024
  • Scream 6 has released one year after Scream 5 which had the insulting death of Dewey. In this video Scream 5 and Scream 6 will face off so we can determine which Scream movie is the superior sequel.
    We will also compare the original four Scream movies from Wes Craven in this versus battle.
    Previous Video: • Kang is a TERRIBLE Vil...
    Patreon: / ecartman12
    Direct Donations: streamelements.com/se-7775612...
    PayPal Donations: goo.gl/ravaVq
    Music in this video:
    • Ave Maria | Epic Trail...
    • Ghostface Theme Song -...
    My Twitch Channel:
    / 3minrevs
    Follow me on:
    Twitter ► / ecartman12
    Facebook ► / ecartman12
    Google Plus ►Google.com/+EricCarterS
    Instagram ► / ecartman12
    TikTok ► / ericcarteryt
    The footage, music and images featured in the video were for critical review and parody, which are protected under the Fair Use laws of the United States Copyright Act of 1976.
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 372

  • @StormyDavis21
    @StormyDavis21 Рік тому +46

    I'm pretty sure the reason Scream 5 has fan fic dialogue is that the 2 killers are basically trying to make fan fiction

    • @LambentEntertainment
      @LambentEntertainment Рік тому +3

      But all of the characters talk like they’re in a fan fiction, not just the killers

    • @CabezasDePescado
      @CabezasDePescado Рік тому

      lol what the dialogues sucked

    • @danwarner7816
      @danwarner7816 9 місяців тому +1

      Sorry even though I liked scream 2022 for resurrecting franchise but it's at bottom of my list now that scream 6 is out 😂

  • @jdkxkkodod7992
    @jdkxkkodod7992 Рік тому +92

    Wes craven said that’s Kirby’s death was meant to be left up in the air. So it’s not a disservice bringing her back. He even added the scene of the basement patio door opening implying it was Kirby as Charlie and Jill were already upstairs

    • @nate3556
      @nate3556 Рік тому +15

      I completely agree. He was literally fighting for her character to stay.

    • @danielmiller9012
      @danielmiller9012 Рік тому +3

      I mean getting stabbed in the stomach numerous times usually isn't fatal if you get medical attention within the hour

    • @danielmiller9012
      @danielmiller9012 Рік тому +3

      Knives aren't as fatal as people think unless its in the heart or a serious artery, which makes it such a brutal weapon

    • @yashsah6531
      @yashsah6531 11 місяців тому

      Scream vi, in one scene, that Reporter lady Gale got shot in the stomach by Amber but still at the end she is shown to be okay sitting and talking...
      I mean they got so many mistakes in that movie.

    • @danhachi3045
      @danhachi3045 10 місяців тому

      Still, her presence in Scream 6 wasn't very important, she didn't need to be there. Mostly because there's no way she didn't work out the relationship between the killers when she's supposed to work for the FBI

  • @Frank_MC
    @Frank_MC Рік тому +26

    “They acted like he was nothing”
    *shows the same scene where Gale mentions Dewy again”.

  • @repulore13
    @repulore13 Рік тому +33

    5:54 Wes craven said himself before his passing that he wanted to bring Kirby back in a potential fifth film, which is why I feel they brought her back; if he hadn’t have said that, I’m not sure if they would’ve or not

  • @iexist7352
    @iexist7352 Рік тому +29

    I disagree with your conclusions on the ghostface killers. While I do agree that the killers motivation in Scream 6 was better and it was a decent homage to Scream 2, I feel as if the killers in Scream 5 are better because they have actual personality and a noticeable presence after their reveal. The killers in scream 6 were practically interchangeable personality wise, which seriously ruined the novelty of there being three killers.

  • @pauldarst1258
    @pauldarst1258 Рік тому +40

    I love the Scream franchise and am happy you’re covering it!

  • @AubreyTheKing
    @AubreyTheKing Рік тому +15

    The first 4 Scream films will ALWAYS be masterpieces on their own! Thank you Wes and RIP.

    • @ShockerTopper
      @ShockerTopper Рік тому +2

      Ya I personally don’t like the 5th/6th movies they’re not real Scream movies because Wes Craven didn’t make them. They aren’t necessarily overtly woke but they just have that modern movie crap to them.

    • @lukemomsen9393
      @lukemomsen9393 Рік тому +3

      @@ShockerTopper lol what part of the new were woke, they follow the same beats as the originals and the only big character difference is that mindy is gay

    • @danielmacdonald9287
      @danielmacdonald9287 Рік тому +1

      5/6 > 3/4. 1/2 >> all of them though, obviously.

    • @theofficialVEVOformu
      @theofficialVEVOformu Рік тому

      @Courtlin Sellers you all call movies woke just because they have a diverse cats and not just white people.

    • @theofficialVEVOformu
      @theofficialVEVOformu Рік тому

      @Courtlin Sellers you all call movies woke just because they have a diverse cats and not just white people.

  • @Andrew_Skywalker021
    @Andrew_Skywalker021 Рік тому +110

    Scream VI was the superior movie.

  • @josiahplummer9051
    @josiahplummer9051 Рік тому +12

    Scream 2022 and Scream VI are being treated as if they are a redux of the original two films. As such, there were several parallels between VI and 2:
    - Chad's brutal attack and apparent murder, in which the viewer is certain he's dead, only for him to miraculously survive at the tail end of the movie, parallels Dewey's seemingly undeniable death in Scream 2, only for the twist ending where he somehow lived through the assault.
    - In Scream (1996), Sidney kills her boyfriend, prompting one of his parents (mother) to return in the subsequent film in an attempt to avenge his death. Likewise, in Scream 2022, Sam (the new main character, a la Sidney) kills her boyfriend, prompting one of his parents (father) to return in the subsequent film in an attempt to avenge his death.
    - In Scream 2, Sidney's new boyfriend is a sweet, wholesome innocent character who nevertheless is treated as a suspect but ends up not being a killer. In Scream VI, Sam's new boyfriend is also a sweet, wholesome innocent character who nevertheless is treated as a suspect but ends up not being a killer. The only difference here is that Derek was killed in Scream 2, whereas Sam's boyfriend in Scream VI survived -- thanks, ironically, to Sam making him leave for the final act due to lack of trust, the same issue that caused Sidney to lose Derek in Scream 2.
    - In Scream 2, Ghostface calls Gale Weathers but Randy answers her phone. (Also, Ghostface hiding in Gale's newsvan would heavily imply that Gale was the target during that scene, and Randy only ended up getting murdered because, as Mrs. Loomis put it, he "spoke poorly of Billy and I got a little knife happy.") It makes sense, then, that in Scream VI, which again is a parallel of Scream 2, Ghostface once again calls Gale and we finally get a Gale/Ghostface conversation, something that even the killer notes has been a long time coming.
    There are several more, but these are a few that I noticed from just one viewing of Scream VI. I'm sure I'll watch it again and notice many more things.

  • @Zeddyboi86
    @Zeddyboi86 Рік тому +15

    I like how when describing the brutal stabs in Scream 5’s opening, Eric is like, “It made me raise an eyebrow.” 🤣

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +10

      "It made me raise BOTH my eyebrows." :P

    • @MarcosValcuende
      @MarcosValcuende Рік тому +3

      @@EricCarter12 Well, that's not a good sign :P

  • @brianJohnxx
    @brianJohnxx Рік тому +15

    Lol Wes Craven wanted Kirby to live on…. It was HIS idea. To say that it’s
    A disservice to scream 4 is ridiculous

  • @nate3556
    @nate3556 Рік тому +37

    3:20 Tara is not a kid who needs to be looked after, she is an adult in college. It is completely understandable that she doesn’t want her sister following her around everywhere acting like her mother.

    • @deepcownewnosh
      @deepcownewnosh Рік тому +7

      THIS

    • @Sunshinestudiosfilms
      @Sunshinestudiosfilms Рік тому +5

      Slay

    • @seanmiles6991
      @seanmiles6991 Рік тому +1

      Nate, I agree with you completely.
      I rolled my eyes when I heard this commentator chastised Tara for telling Sam off.
      Yes Tara may have been a little wasted at that party, but Tara is an adult.
      Frankie asked her nicely to go to his room and Tara agreed.
      If Tara was so gullible not to see, that Frankie was trying to get sex out of her, that would’ve been her problem.

  • @shiykyk7538
    @shiykyk7538 Рік тому +13

    Bro this dude said Judi is a bigger deal than Kirby please just stop watching scream movies 😭😂😂😂😂

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +3

      Then explain to me. Why is Kirby such a big deal?? It makes no sense.

    • @shiykyk7538
      @shiykyk7538 Рік тому +12

      @@EricCarter12 Kirby represented a new form of a horror fan that was not a copy of randy unlike others she was her own person who was badass and knew her own shit. Even was intended By WES CRAVEN to survive with onto the next movie even after Jill’s death was decided so no it was not “a disservice”

    • @jeffcunningham0389
      @jeffcunningham0389 Рік тому +5

      Kirby was literally beloved as much as Randy and fans have expressed their love for over a decade. Youd have to living under a rock to not know this lol

    • @shiykyk7538
      @shiykyk7538 Рік тому

      Ok Courtlin

    • @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334
      @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334 6 місяців тому

      @@shiykyk7538yes it was

  • @jakepark3272
    @jakepark3272 Рік тому +9

    You did NOT just throw in that Jada Pinkett joke like it was nothing. That was so good.

  • @michaelfireheart8300
    @michaelfireheart8300 Рік тому +8

    Kirby was a good character, but the way they used her was utter trash, especially since she had a strong bond with Sydney and should've been the one to take over as main girl, not Billy's illegitimate child. Though a disservice to Wes Craven's legacy was making more Scream films and killing off his favorite character of Dewey.

  • @bggsz4
    @bggsz4 Рік тому +11

    Scream 5's Ghostface was meant to sound like fan fiction, that's the point. Richie was imitating Stab and his love for the franchise.

    • @Frank_MC
      @Frank_MC Рік тому +10

      People complain about anything these days.

    • @bggsz4
      @bggsz4 Рік тому +5

      @@Frank_MC That's why Scream 5's motive is way better than what many people give it credit for. Scream has always been a satire that mocks contemporary things in the real world, and movie-obsessed fans, fighting online and everything else 5 pokes fun at is stuff that happens all the time, just like how 4 used the rise of social media as its background.

    • @Frank_MC
      @Frank_MC Рік тому +3

      @@bggsz4 exactly. I agree

  • @comicbookking3446
    @comicbookking3446 Рік тому +15

    Fun fact : did you know “Scream” was originally going to be called “Scary Movie” ?

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +4

      Yes I did. I'm glad that didn't end up happening.

  • @michaelfireheart8300
    @michaelfireheart8300 Рік тому +17

    I think Scream 4 should've been the final Scream film as it tied up the franchise well and actually handled the take on reboots/remakes well. These two films should've been their own franchise, because they feel so distant from what Scream is about. Billy having a daughter isn't unbelievable, but the fact it was with a random girl never seen on film, made it feel less impactful and feel like fanfiction in my opinion.

    • @professorsaltine2795
      @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому +4

      I mean the newer Scream Movies are what they coined as “Requels” but unlike other Requels they actually continue the story from the whole franchise
      Scream 1 tackles slashers in general, Scream 2 sequels, Scream 3 trilogies, Scream 4 Reboots, Scream 5 “Requels”, Scream 6 Franchises
      of course they’d also feel different, Wes sadly passed away and it’s not the easiest to copy some guys style.
      And for the Billy Daughter… may I remind you we had nothing to tell us Sid had a potential brother besides her mom sleeping around town 💀! Billy was a greasy scumbag so yeah makes sense he’d have a daughter with some chick off screen… just like Sid’s mom 💀

    • @michaelfireheart8300
      @michaelfireheart8300 Рік тому +2

      ​@@professorsaltine2795 Yeah, except Sydney's mother sleeping around did make it very plausible that she had another child and potential trauma in her past to seek out these extra relationships. Billy was an unhinged Mama's boy who killed because his father's cheating pushed his mother away, so why would Billy purposefully commit the very thing he hated Sydney's mother for?

    • @michaelfireheart8300
      @michaelfireheart8300 Рік тому +2

      ​​@@professorsaltine2795 Scream 5 didn't even do requels right, since it felt half-assed in the movie, like the writers had a specific agenda against certain fans, instead of having nuanced commentary. Yes each movie has a specific topic, but it shouldn't be done so differently, that they no longer feel like they're in the same franchise.

    • @professorsaltine2795
      @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому +2

      @@michaelfireheart8300
      Agree to disagree 🤷🏽‍♂️

    • @professorsaltine2795
      @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому

      @@michaelfireheart8300
      He’s a lunatic who clearly wasn’t mentally all there, it’s easy for him to justify himself doing so

  • @foxroberts8624
    @foxroberts8624 Рік тому +25

    As a massive horror fan The main thing that separates these movies for me is in scream 5 I could tell you the killer in the first 15 minutes but scream 6 actually had a good twist and even tricked me which was suprising I do think 6 was superior but I dont dislike any of these compared to other slasher series which has at the most has 1 to 2 bad movies scream has a pretty good track record
    Great video as always👍

  • @robbiejay1646
    @robbiejay1646 Рік тому +4

    Wes said in the SCREAM 4 comanttary that he wanted Kirby's fate left unknown so if they wanted he could bring her back.

  • @georgearch8917
    @georgearch8917 Рік тому +20

    Heavily disagree with a lot of your takes. I mean 1) Kirby is purposefully left up to being alive or not and Wes wanted her to possibly live so letting her live is still letting his memory live on. Scream VI had so much better characters than 5 I'll be honest. Sam's confliction with her bloodline and tendencies is much more interesting, I like how much it has affected her life with it now being in the open and it feels much more subtle than in the 5th film. Tara is also just not at all how you describe her to be in 6. She is not a kid?? She can absolutely look after herself no shit we would be pissed off that her sister isn't allowing her to make her own choices. Chad is much more of a badass and fun character in this movie and interesting to see his development, personally never saw the elderly brother part of that btw.
    As for the whole thing with Ghostface being overpowered and the stabbing lethality.... I don't agree with the Ghostface being overpowered but I guess you didn't bring any examples up so... Though stabbings have never been consistent. I'm sorry but you're complaining how Sam was stabbed and got her knife twisted in but don't question how Sidney still survived 4 by miraculous luck when she was on the ground much longer and suffered more than Sam. Though of course Jada dies after a single stab wound nearly just as deep and in the general same area too. Or we could talk about how Dewey was left to bleed out for the entirety of the finale yet miraculously survived because of "scar tissue". We wanna talk about Scream 3? While I see your point with some of these, especially Chad in 5, in 6 most of his stabbings were not even in lethal areas nor seemingly hit in vital parts of the body whilst a lot of the stabbings seemed to not to go too deep. Speaking of? Tara barely got stabbed on the first round and yes she did get a semi-deep wound with Ethan but again comparing it to Gale as if she was fine is so weird to me. She was fucking shot she should not be fine.
    Though probably the most annoying criticism I see often with 5 is the stupid height difference. I genuinely can't tell if people just forgot that this was a satirical slasher and that Ghostface is a different body height and shape because he is not supposed to fully represent the person behind the mask. You really think Miss Loomis's slim ass could fit the build of Ghostface much less have the upper body strength to FULL ON SNATCH RANDY INTO THE VAN. Or what bout Roman lets say? Dude is a scronny crybaby who took multiple gunshots multiple times to the chest with a bullet proof and was fine. Roman literally destroys Cotton somehow despite his build and nobody talks about it outside of 5.
    Probably the most annoying part of this video to me though is how it perpetuates the "This shits on so and so's legacy" bullshit. You don't know these people, you even got something wrong about Wes's intention in the video. Stop acting like you knew this deceased person to make it seem like your criticism is just so full of passion. You have no clue how they would have gone about writing the movie because again, you're some random on the internet, just like me! Trying to use his legacy as a criticism for a movie is completely disrespectful.

  • @atogon_art
    @atogon_art Рік тому +3

    Hasn't it been like a year since Scream 5 came out? This is like the second time I'm hearing about Scream 6. And it's a bloody review!

    • @professorsaltine2795
      @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому +2

      Yeah the 6th Scream got released not too long ago and man it’s doing well at the box office, only a matter of time till 7 is announced and we’ll see what movie topic is challenged next… like they just did Franchise for 6! What’s next 😭

  • @ASUV3323
    @ASUV3323 Рік тому +6

    Scream 5 had the better ending and the better ghosface reveal. But Scream 6 was the overall better movie, watching experience and had the better kills and acting.

    • @ASUV3323
      @ASUV3323 Рік тому +2

      Also, when I say “Ghostface Reveal” I mean how the actual reveal was executed. I’m not talking about their motivations. The motivations in both of these movies were weak as hell to me.

    • @EliastheKiNg34
      @EliastheKiNg34 9 місяців тому +1

      I think the opening I’m scream 5 was badass and Wes had a pretty pretty gnarly kill scene same with Judy scream 5 was far superior for me I think scream 5 is more brutal In a different way scream 6 had a lot of the off screen stabs scream 5 actually showed the kills but it’s in my opinion

  • @nickvaldez2500
    @nickvaldez2500 Рік тому +3

    Bro you sound like you’d actually be a real life ghost face

  • @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334
    @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334 6 місяців тому

    Loved this vid spot on analysis just subbed

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  6 місяців тому +2

      Thanks Drake! I'm really glad you enjoyed the video! And welcome to the channel! I hope you enjoy my previous and future content!!

    • @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334
      @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334 6 місяців тому +1

      @@EricCarter12definitely, you are one of the few on this platform to be honest about your opinions. And, call it like it is and I’m all here for it.

  • @venkman6160
    @venkman6160 Рік тому +6

    The Ghostface reveal was easily the stupidest thing about Scream VI.

    • @TheSmellymuffin11
      @TheSmellymuffin11 Рік тому +1

      Agreed. Ethan being a killer was such an awful call, and Quinn’s body being “switched out” was something a 6 year old would say.

    • @williamk7517
      @williamk7517 5 місяців тому

      Wow lol yeah so true scream fives was shocking six was pathetic I like scream six!!!!! But nope scream five had a way more revealing ghistface like four!!!! Yes I have six and five on Blu ray but I kept five on my phone my other phone and delete six!!!!!! Five shoulda been the last one

  • @AdoptedAussie43
    @AdoptedAussie43 Рік тому

    great video

  • @raymondteodosbandlabvlog1676
    @raymondteodosbandlabvlog1676 Рік тому +3

    Sam and Tara were reacting to the recent trauma they experienced in different ways. Sam was over protective; Tara was rebellious and taking risks. The “bitchy” side to Tara makes more sense when you’re thinking about how they’re dealing with trauma in different ways.

  • @Jarmix-vq3gn
    @Jarmix-vq3gn Рік тому +3

    Very interesting breakdown and very good points. Yes as a whole the films are good but when you dissect them I can see and feel the differences. Simply just that there's no Wes I guess.

  • @SlutPop-kt3lc
    @SlutPop-kt3lc 11 місяців тому +2

    8:00 Amber missed all the vital organs on purpose to keep her alive so Sam would come back. She admits this in the hospital. "I'll make sure to hit all the vital organs I missed last time"

    • @user-zm6ci5fg4k
      @user-zm6ci5fg4k Місяць тому

      I still feel like she would have bled out by the time the police came. I mean that's a lot of stabs even if they didn't hit vital areas.

  • @aamiraustin5422
    @aamiraustin5422 Рік тому +5

    I really liked both films but I prefer Scream VI over Scream 5.

  • @shikharverma6826
    @shikharverma6826 Рік тому

    Hey Eric! Super excited for your 4 way
    JW vs video! When will it be out?

  • @kjbeast677
    @kjbeast677 Рік тому +8

    We can all admit Mindy is totally the cause of Anika’s death right? I’m still baffled at how Mindy is supposed to be the smartest one of the group with the most horror movie knowledge, yet she tells Sam to crawl the ladder first while her and Anika were the most fatally wounded

    • @0716jane
      @0716jane Рік тому +1

      True but Sam was making the decisions about everyone's safety at the apartment scene but since Anika was so badly wounded she was basically already dead so I feel like Mindy should have gone 1st then sam then Anika just bc Anika was new to the group she had to be killed so that screen time held up to the audience expectations

    • @Mitchcraft.
      @Mitchcraft. Рік тому

      Yeah a bad replacement for the amazing Jamie Kennedy portrayal of Randy.

    • @williamk7517
      @williamk7517 5 місяців тому

      Anika dieing made the movie less desirable!!!!! She is one character that made scream six!!!!!!!

  • @themasterofgaming4149
    @themasterofgaming4149 Рік тому +4

    I thought you wouldn't do it but I'm so glad you did.

  • @joshfactor1
    @joshfactor1 Рік тому +3

    you make a good point; i mean, sure the stone killing was pretty badass but seriously, how is his hand not bloodied & bruised after that?

  • @bradleysaunders1730
    @bradleysaunders1730 Рік тому +3

    it doesnt undo what wes did in scream 4, kirby was never meant to die

  • @Sw33tSara
    @Sw33tSara Рік тому

    I felt the same way immediately.. like how they gonna survive and then walk around like both happened

  • @thefitnesslife4988
    @thefitnesslife4988 2 місяці тому

    8:23 I was thinking the same thing, i was so shocked when they revealee he survived in scream 6 😂

  • @fivenightsattrollsworldtou9417

    Eric ik this is a late request but I’m a BIG monsterverse fan and can you PLEASE do KOTM vs GvK

  • @mckinniesmovies3598
    @mckinniesmovies3598 Рік тому

    Eric Carter now vs ( 2008s) Eric Carter comparison video would be cool

  • @tumulovermelho93
    @tumulovermelho93 Рік тому

    Hauntingly beautiful rendition of Ave Maria, by the way.

  • @SlutPop-kt3lc
    @SlutPop-kt3lc 11 місяців тому +3

    Disrespecting Wes?
    1.Kirby's fate was intentionally left ambitious BY WES
    2. Dewey was originally gonna din in the first one, Wes only added the final scene of him cuz of the audience demanding it after the test screenings.
    3. Dewey and Gale are divorced because they are divorced in real life. Dewey and Gales relationship only happened cuz of their real life romance. Hence 3 adding their marriage like in real life and 5 adding their divorce like in real life

    • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
      @ParkerCS-dh7rf 10 місяців тому +1

      It’s still bad writing. You think Alien 3 killing off newt hicks and Bishop like they were nothing wasn’t bad writing?! Hell fucking no! Example made! Dewey and Gale deserve a happy ending. They are fictional characters! The real life relationship shouldn’t concern the fictional universe.

    • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
      @ParkerCS-dh7rf 10 місяців тому +1

      Scream 4 is the canon ending to the entire franchise! Scream 2022 and Scream VI are elseworlds stories! Therefore, NOT CANON!

    • @SlutPop-kt3lc
      @SlutPop-kt3lc 10 місяців тому

      Your just a hater. Just like scream 5 says... smh you're such a toxic fan thinking the only good movies are the ones Wes made. You should be ashamed of yourself.

    • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
      @ParkerCS-dh7rf 10 місяців тому +1

      It’s my opinion! You’re the real hater. You can like Scream 5 and 6 if you want. But you just a shill if you think I should like a movie I don’t personally care for. I’m just expressing myself! Let me guess: you think Alien 3 was a good movie by undermining the victory of Aliens? No. You think The Last Jedi did a good thing emasculating Luke and making him a bitter old man? No. You’re the real toxic ‘fan’! I respect you disagreeing with me, but you don’t need to force he into liking something I don’t like. I’m just expressing and pointing out bad writing. 😕

    • @CharlieMonkeh
      @CharlieMonkeh 7 місяців тому

      Honestly you two shouldn’t call yourselves toxic at all and honestly there is nothing wrong with the two new sequels, in fact I thought they were not bad, personally I liked Scream 6 a lot better than the 5th one and honestly I don’t think the directors are fans of Rian Johnson I just think there only trying to reference and satirized the way new filmmaking is being produced, and while I may be mixed on Dewey’s death, honestly what’s done is done. Plus I don’t think the 5th film was even woke to begin with, possibly the three ladies in front of the camera was basically supposed to symbolism for the final girl trope, plus wouldn’t you be upset if all three OG scream characters where all killed off in one movie, I mean probably due to bad storytelling. Plus the directors where just doing their gosh darn best to do these movies and what can you say it was really nice, but honestly i just feel really mixed on Eric Carters views thinking that he knows Wes Craven a little too much like he personally knows him as if he met him a lot, and saying that this disrespected Wes Cravens legacy, I don’t think so, it was still very traditional too. Overall just calm down okay guys.

  • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
    @ParkerCS-dh7rf 9 місяців тому +1

    Wes Craven’s estate should take back the Scream rights! They need to!

  • @BrontoSmilodon1
    @BrontoSmilodon1 4 місяці тому

    so the stabs in scream 6 is like a worse version of the last spinosaurus stabbing in Jurassic Park 3 ... on steroids.

  • @professorsaltine2795
    @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому +7

    I had to comment this about the Dewey death, I forgot who made a vid about it but they did a vid on who killed who in the Scream franchise and they mentioned how you gotta take out the characters actual height & weight for the Ghostface stuff because if you don’t well it ruins EVERYTHING!
    Also for the Dewey not saving Gale I think Gale not being present for Dewey’s death was PERFECT! She never got a chance to say “I love you” or “Goodbye”, heck she couldn’t even be there for comfort him which hits hard imo, imagine you’re in Gale’s position, you never get a chance to comfort someone you loved, never got to properly say goodbye, heck never even said I love you during your last conversation with them… man that’d be a nice thing to see in a Scream movie… oh wait they did that for the 5th & had GF tell her this in the 6th! That aside Scream 6 is leagues better than Scream 5 and just like the rest of the franchise they’re leagues better than Scream 3(not really as all of the movies are a 5/10-10/10)

  • @scarecrow2272
    @scarecrow2272 Рік тому +3

    Can you do a QMR of Shazam: Fury of the gods?

  • @wickdaline8668
    @wickdaline8668 Рік тому +2

    Scream 7 talks about the end of sagas if it really is the end of the franchise. But it probably ain't.

  • @danwarner7816
    @danwarner7816 Рік тому

    @Eric carter next do scream 1996 Vs scream 2022
    Edited: btw amber was on ground. So getting stabbed from back and front Dewey body would lift up from knife inside. And same was with Vince, he kneeling over in car, so she stuck him quicky before he raises his head 😅

  • @knightatyourservice7512
    @knightatyourservice7512 Рік тому

    Hey, Eric! So I remember you once saidyou really like Blumhouse Productions for their ways of making low budget movies. They have really pushing a lot of news regarding the Five Nights At Feddy's movie adaptation lately. Are you interested in how the movie will turn out to be?

  • @gregg3744
    @gregg3744 Рік тому +1

    The lack of chase scenes in scream 5 really pissed me off

  • @iambadatstuff5136
    @iambadatstuff5136 Рік тому +4

    That will smith joke….

  • @estebanespada9047
    @estebanespada9047 Рік тому +2

    I personally like Scream 5 a little bit more than Scream 6 but they're both very close to the same rating

  • @rileyprice6058
    @rileyprice6058 Рік тому +1

    14:30 - gale wasnt ripped open lmfao and the emergency services were the right after sam and tara 😂😂

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +1

      Do you know who WAS ripped open. That girl that Ghostface shaked off the ladder.
      She was stabbed and sliced upwards and still she was kept alive. The thing that killed her was the fall.

  • @kotm2021
    @kotm2021 Рік тому +3

    Can't wait to SCREAM from excitement from this video!!

  • @ilovezoom3719
    @ilovezoom3719 Рік тому +3

    I gotta say you do have a point and you make pretty valid arguments especially with the Dewey kill and who killed him but of course I have to accept it and not complain or else I get a lot of shit from people

    • @ilovezoom3719
      @ilovezoom3719 Рік тому

      @marius kristensen thank you at least I have someone’s support because it is very ridiculous if you think about it

    • @heresnegan6825
      @heresnegan6825 Рік тому +4

      I'm completely against modern Hollywood and hate what they did with the new star wars trilogy but I have to say what Eric said at the end made little to no sense whatsoever

  • @DarklordKermit77
    @DarklordKermit77 Рік тому +2

    12:20 Knives Out vs Glass Onion when?

  • @hugoblaz
    @hugoblaz Рік тому +2

    Dewey was getting old, that’s why Tara survived because she was young and isn’t as weak as someone who has a bunch of wounds already

  • @joshfactor1
    @joshfactor1 Рік тому

    thank you for saying what no one else seems to have the gall to say; dewey deserved better

  • @tyyohr1841
    @tyyohr1841 Рік тому

    Well, in Highschool I had a friend get stabbed like 20 times an survived, then I heard of a fatal 100 stab wounds, so it really depends on where your stabbed an how quickly the EMTs can come for help

  • @scarletttyson4622
    @scarletttyson4622 Рік тому

    Do you plan to do Puss in boots? and Avatar?

  • @drakeholly6889
    @drakeholly6889 Рік тому

    Hey eric out of these masked killers who is scarier Ghostface, Jason voorhees, or Michael myers.

  • @pkvanderzee6226
    @pkvanderzee6226 9 місяців тому

    Ghostface: "Hello Sidney I am back"
    Sidney Prescott: "You know what..I'm done with this shit...I am out!"

  • @thefanwithoutaface8105
    @thefanwithoutaface8105 Рік тому +10

    Personally I think they should've ended with 3, maybe 4 if we're being Generous. 3 completed the story and seemed to cap things off, while 4 somewhat tied things to Sidney again, but these last two films just feel like they are dragging it kicking and screaming. I mean Billy suddenly having a daughter we'd never heard of and we went from the killers either being connected to people from the original Scream, mainly Billy, to crazy fans of the Stab movies? It's just too much. Plus the whole killer over the phone thing worked in the 90s and early 2000s cause caller ID, video phones, the internet and the like were barely a thing at that point so there was a true sense of isolation which helped sell the idea. Now it just doesn't fit as well.

    • @alexanderadonyae7937
      @alexanderadonyae7937 Рік тому +3

      Facts🎯

    • @TheSmellymuffin11
      @TheSmellymuffin11 Рік тому +2

      I completely agree. It’s tiresome watching part 5 and 6 and having to ignore blatant logical issues simply for the fact “it’s a movie”. The franchise is just looking to profit and keep this circus going. Just as you had mentioned, the whole Billy having a daughter situation is embarrassing 😒

    • @danhachi3045
      @danhachi3045 10 місяців тому

      Maybe 4? The fourth movie is great

  • @jacindaellison3363
    @jacindaellison3363 Рік тому +3

    17:24 so if they manage to make Scream 10, will it get a 10/10? 😂

  • @BrandontheBeldam2993
    @BrandontheBeldam2993 Рік тому

    Dewey is my favorite character of the original trio and his death scene Did get me when I saw Scream 5 for the first time. Its almost been an inside joke for how many times Dewey has survived Ghostface stabbings, I genuinely thought watching Scream 2 as a kid that he was going to be killed off for real. But a part of me is glad he got to stick around for 3 more movies..
    With that said, I do agree his Death could've been handled better. It only felt written to get Sidney back into the picture. Her one cameo was fine and If it was just the new cast and Dewey and Judy being the 'Legacy characters' that would've been perfect. Its been said, but Sidney and Gale felt shoehorned into the story.
    Not even a memorial service for Dewey, just play some sad stock music and Off we go!
    I like these new Scream movies fine, 5 a lot more than 6, I love the new cast in Scream 5.
    But these new movies don't hold a candle to what Wes and Kevin Williamson did with the original films.
    I kind of wish Williamson was still writing these Scream movies because the writing for these new ones, especially Scream 6, kind of suck.

  • @Linkbatmangosling_1
    @Linkbatmangosling_1 Рік тому +3

    You said all my criticisms and praises of these movies! It’s like you read my mind! Particularly with Ghostface and Dewey

  • @chrissygram
    @chrissygram Рік тому +1

    i dont understand why they cant hire stunt people who at least have similar body types to the killers?

  • @alonsovazquez9017
    @alonsovazquez9017 Рік тому

    I am just waiting for Eric to make John wick 2 vs John wick 4

  • @ORPHAN_HATER411
    @ORPHAN_HATER411 Рік тому +2

    Bro what are you on Eric 💀

  • @abhinavsajitkumar5196
    @abhinavsajitkumar5196 Рік тому

    @Eric Carter, what is your favorite Disney & DreamWorks animated movies?

  • @Sonic-eo1xo
    @Sonic-eo1xo Рік тому

    Did anyone else notice how everyone was dodging ghost faces knife swipes? I mean did the characters unlock the matrix in between movies?

  • @brianJohnxx
    @brianJohnxx Рік тому +5

    Scream 6 is my favorite 😭😭
    Gotta disagree with the character side of things in scream 6 the core 4 we’re the best part of the movie…. Mindys scene when she explains the rules was much better then scream 5 imo

    • @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334
      @draketheblackpillerrobinso3334 6 місяців тому +1

      Lol😂

    • @javierlopez9789
      @javierlopez9789 2 місяці тому

      Huh? Mindy has the personality of a lobster and she is not even a quarter of what Randy was, especially when she tries way too hard to be and Chad should have died in both 5 and 6, his "romance" with Tara literally comes out of nowhere and all s
      he does is being the invencible (literally) muscle guy.

  • @Savagewithaheart98
    @Savagewithaheart98 Рік тому

    9:30 why did you have to trigger my PTSD

  • @ryanhamilton5975
    @ryanhamilton5975 Рік тому +5

    I was digging the vid and thinking some decent points were being made until the whining about “woke hollywood” and “Dewey only died because he was a man” bs

    • @navnav9403
      @navnav9403 Рік тому +2

      same i was so disappointed

    • @shiykyk7538
      @shiykyk7538 Рік тому +1

      People who make vids saying stuff like “woke Hollywood” are always talking out their ass and lose all validity to what their saying

  • @dragongodaaron6460
    @dragongodaaron6460 Рік тому

    Please do Kung Fu Panda vs How To Train Your Dragon next?

    • @professorsaltine2795
      @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому

      Nah fam that’s unfair, how he gonna tackle Peak Fiction & Peak Fiction 💀

  • @tumulovermelho93
    @tumulovermelho93 Рік тому +1

    Charlie and Jill from Scream 4 predicted Jussie Smolett and Amber Heard. lol

  • @lankerator
    @lankerator Рік тому

    I personally really like the motive in Scream 5 because it's these hardcore fans who are so clingy to a franchise they start killing people to get there way and you can see that with things like Twitter where if you say 1 negative thing about their precious franchise they go berserk

  • @TheTombRaider
    @TheTombRaider Рік тому

    My scream rankings from worst to best are: scream 3, scream 4, scream 2, scream 5, scream 6, scream 1

  • @wolfman-hw8yt
    @wolfman-hw8yt Рік тому +2

    Can you please do 1993mario movie verse the 2023 mario when it comes out😊

  • @alexanderadonyae7937
    @alexanderadonyae7937 Рік тому +3

    Scream 6 was waaaaay better than 5.. One thing for sure abt the new scream movies part 4, 5 and 6 gave away the killers identity too soon

  • @HorrorCritical
    @HorrorCritical Рік тому +4

    The main problem I have with Scream 5 and 6 is the dumb plot armor that most of the characters have
    Spoilers ahead for people who are going to read the replies of my comment

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +3

      I have that EXACT same problem! I discuss it in detail in this comparison.

    • @HorrorCritical
      @HorrorCritical Рік тому +3

      @@EricCarter12 I swear, I’m Scream 6, it seemed like Chad or Mindy was going to die, but they some how only get injured, or survive

  • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
    @ParkerCS-dh7rf 10 місяців тому +1

    I should try to make my own Scream fan film for UA-cam one day! 😊Fan films are better than modern Hollywood!

  • @maximilianosanchez1106
    @maximilianosanchez1106 Рік тому +1

    0:08 it looks like M in Scream (5) is supposed to be a V or 5, just ike Scream 6 has the M look like a VI or 6, and just like Fant4stic.

  • @acebud2.040
    @acebud2.040 Рік тому

    When is the john wick review coming?
    Also great fucking review

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +1

      Thanks buddy. The John Wick video is coming VERY SOON. Its gonna be a versus video of the four movies. 😉

    • @acebud2.040
      @acebud2.040 Рік тому

      ​@@EricCarter12 LETSSS GOOOO

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому

      @@acebud2.040 It's already been published on my channel for the last few days. I hope you enjoy it buddy!

  • @itsscience9113
    @itsscience9113 Рік тому +1

    I hear 'the batman' beginning theme in the beginning of this video

  • @Pansinoo
    @Pansinoo Рік тому +1

    Can’t tell if it’s sarcasm when talking about girl power part

  • @TheChooseAName123
    @TheChooseAName123 Рік тому +1

    Largely agree, though the motive reveal in part 5 IMO is much worth than just "stupid". It's a direct attack at the fans!
    Also part 6 lost me pretty much at the beginning when the female main character completely unnecessarily attacked a man with weapon to a vital area and nobody cared at all, im universe or meta. It ruined the character and the story in just a few seconds. Without that the movie would be OK for me, definitely better than the slap in the face we got before.

    • @ethankleinman1067
      @ethankleinman1067 Рік тому

      Part 5's motive is an attack of Toxic online fans not scream fans in general.

  • @noahotero7924
    @noahotero7924 Рік тому +2

    I liked scream 5 and 6 they are enjoyable to watch my issues is with 5 is that the villains sucked when it came to motive and 6 my issues is with the characters plot armor mostly chad for instance should of died but your rating are valid tho

  • @adamgrunther1367
    @adamgrunther1367 Рік тому

    Have you seen the new trailer for Across the Spiderverse?

    • @EricCarter12
      @EricCarter12  Рік тому +1

      Not yet. I'm gonna record my trailer reaction for it for Patreon later today.

  • @namehere6544
    @namehere6544 Рік тому +12

    I love a "man" who blames a bad movie on * woke * Hollywood. jesus christ dude

    • @alfonsoruiz5844
      @alfonsoruiz5844 Рік тому

      Numbers don't lie. Go woke go broke

    • @jeffcunningham0389
      @jeffcunningham0389 Рік тому +1

      Lol as if they didn’t kill off Dewey in part 1(the brought him back last minute during filming) so that gale and sidney could be the heros. That was literally 27 years ago. Why wasnt THAT considered woke?

    • @namehere6544
      @namehere6544 Рік тому

      @@jeffcunningham0389 I don't debate with Jeffries and I also don't care anymore

    • @jeffcunningham0389
      @jeffcunningham0389 Рік тому

      @@namehere6544 i was agreeing with you 🙃

    • @namehere6544
      @namehere6544 Рік тому

      @@jeffcunningham0389 well I guess it wasn't woke for the same reason this idiot thinks the fifth movie is woke: Dewey didn't die in the first movie and did die in the fifth movie. ""Cuz he's a man"". Did that help clear things up, Jeffrey?

  • @roseperera8377
    @roseperera8377 Рік тому

    Is your Shazam 2 review on its way

  • @darthdimitrescu3249
    @darthdimitrescu3249 Рік тому +2

    I'm gonna miss Sidney Prescott being in Scream movies

    • @darthdimitrescu3249
      @darthdimitrescu3249 Рік тому +1

      @Courtlin Sellers Yeah, it be cool if we saw him again in the next Scream movie . Literally one of the OG Ghostfaces

  • @StormyDavis21
    @StormyDavis21 Рік тому +2

    I pretty sure Gale and Dewey are apart because they broke up in real life

    • @professorsaltine2795
      @professorsaltine2795 Рік тому +2

      Yep, the Scream movies loved playing with Dewey & Gales real life love story bc well the stars did fall in love IRL 😂, iirc by the time Scream 4 was out like a year or 2 later the real life couple did indeed divorce, funny enough it’s not bc of some malice but bc they had differences just like Gale & Dewey… one liked the small town and one loved the big city… side note the scene of Dewey loving to see Gale on the tv was so heart breaking and sweet at the same time

  • @ryanramkhelawan6876
    @ryanramkhelawan6876 Рік тому +1

    Spiderman 2002 vs amazing spiderman

  • @daddy_1453
    @daddy_1453 Рік тому +1

    Why tf isn't everyone in the Scream franchise carrying firearms? It's set in the US afterall. You'd think 6 movies in they would have learned.

  • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
    @ParkerCS-dh7rf 10 місяців тому +1

    Scream 4 is the canon ending! However, Scream: Legacy - A Scream Fan Film is the REAL Scream 5! It’s really freaking good!

  • @UndeadSlayer5
    @UndeadSlayer5 Рік тому +1

    Tara was a douche in scream 6 she just wanted to do what she wanted like a selfish teenager

  • @88lilies
    @88lilies Рік тому

    I don’t know if you were playing Ave Maria in the background or not but you sure as heck were playing a song that was a little bit out of place and kind of distracting. Overall, I do prefer scream six, poor Dewey died in an unsatisfying way, in the sense that they did nothing to earn his death, and he did a disservice to a very nice character. And I’m sorry, but if someone gets shot six times in the chest even with a bulletproof vest, the wind would be knocked out of them, and they pass out for the next three hours. My point is while surviving being stabbed so many times is out rages, even when you wear a bulletproof vest, it doesn’t mean bullets can’t hurt you!!

  • @dannyjorde2677
    @dannyjorde2677 11 місяців тому +1

    15:00
    Not only he got killed like he was any other character, he was murder by a frigging teenage girl. And we're supposed to take it seriously 🤦🏻

    • @ParkerCS-dh7rf
      @ParkerCS-dh7rf 10 місяців тому +1

      I don’t consider Scream 2022 nor Scream VI canon. I’ll be boycotting future radio silence films! 🤞one day the Wes craven estate takes Scream IP back!

  • @blooj249
    @blooj249 Рік тому

    Nice video Eric also I have a bit of a question what’s your thoughts on Shazam! Fury of the Gods? in my option I found it pretty good and much better than the poorly written beginning to slowly lose interest Movie Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania.