435 Gallon AMERICAN Cichlid Tank vs 240 Gallon AFRICAN Cichlid Tank
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лип 2024
- Comparing my two biggest tanks -- the HUGE American cichlid tank vs the BIG African cichlid tank. I'll be looking at aquarium builds, decor, fish and more. At the end I'll tell you which one is my absolute favorite.
Cichlid Charmer is dedicated to sharing the joy of keeping African cichlids and American cichlids and sharing information about them. Much of my content is not cichlid fish specific, however. It also pertains to all tropical fish aquariums. I will share what I have learned about cichlids and other fish, and everyone is welcomed to comment with their own experiences and information about fish and aquarium practices in general.
Custom Aquairiums: customaquariums.com
Aquadecor: aquadecorbackgrounds.com
00:00 - Intro
00:17 - Aquarium Builds
05:51 - Decor
08:56 - Filtration
12:20 - Stocking
Special thanks to Northfin and Ron's Cichlids for sponsoring this channel.
Here's how you can help this channel:
1. Smash the "like" button
2. SUBSCRIBE and ring the bell for notifications
3. Comment on this video! This helps a lot!
Get 10% off your entire order of food and fish at Ron's Cichlids! Apply the code "CichlidCharmer10" at checkout!
Ron's Cichlids: ronscichlids.com/
My aquarium equipment (If you click on the links and make a purchase, Cichlid Charmer may receive a small commission from Amazon)
FILTERS:
Fluval FX6 Canister Filter: amzn.to/3GHPDeS
Fluval FX4 Canister Filter: amzn.to/48gTonj
Fluval 407 canister filter: amzn.to/3RLhOjH
Fluval 307 canister filter: amzn.to/47Pa4md
Seachem Tidal HOB 110 Gallon Filter: amzn.to/3t8FXqY
Seachem Tidal HOB 55 Gallon Filter: amzn.to/3GLhwmE
Seachem Tidal HOB 35 Gallon Filter: amzn.to/3NsRWq8
BREEDER BOX: www.amazon.com/dp/B07THHY7YP?...
WAVEMAKERS:
Uniclife wavemaker 120-300 gallon: amzn.to/3RsjzAT
Uniclife wavemaker 60-120 gallon: amzn.to/3tlM0sg
Uniclife wavemaker 30-60 gallon: amzn.to/48lo3Qn
HEATERS:
Eheim Jager Aquarium Heaters: amzn.to/3toJYY8
TEMP CONTROLLER:
Inkbird ITC306A: amzn.to/3RJc4H0
Inkbird ITC308S: amzn.to/3RnvFuY
SICCE Ultra Zero Submersible Pump: amzn.to/484mirq
LIGHTS:
AI Prime Freshwater Light: amzn.to/47XEdQp
AI Prime Flex Arm: amzn.to/3v3sWiT
Fluval Sea Marine 3.0 59 watt: amzn.to/3v8UkvJ
Fluval Sea Marine 3.0 46 watt: amzn.to/4anPEm4
Fluval Sea Marine 3.0 32 watt: amzn.to/3v7CZTT
FOODS:
Northfin Jumbo Formula: amzn.to/48dFN00
Northfin Fish Food 3 mm Sinking Pellets: amzn.to/46Z4NaC
Northfin Veggie Formula 3mm: amzn.to/3tiWGI1
Garlic Guard: amzn.to/48loBFV
VitaChem https: amzn.to/4aooPOm
LANDEN RIMLESS AQUARIUMS: amzn.to/3tkZlRw
LUBE FOR FILTER GASKETS: amzn.to/48g5sW2
BREEDER BOX: amzn.to/3TriI5X
Check out this playlist:
• African Cichlid Genera...
#cichlidcharmer #aquariumhobby #aquarium - Домашні улюбленці та дикі тварини
So which is your favorite? Also, what’s your favorite type of cichlid?
I love them both! I lean towards peacock and haps because I deal with them so much and I know you didn’t show your Mbuna tank but the way they sort themselves into little gangs is special. The arrangement you have in san Quinton is very nice and the tree limb decor is yet to play its part if you ask me, it’s gorgeous don’t get me wrong. And Alcatraz is a tad under decorated in my opinion, I have Tons of rock stacked and a tree stump assorted in mine. It’s not for everyone it’s ok everyone does it different and that’s where both seeing and knowing other tanks look different that gives both perspective and appreciation, some make you dream others make you feel at home and some make you run away! In any case there are no rules as long as the fish are happy and healthy! 😊❤
Great video. I kept Africans for over 20 yrs. Primarily Mbuna. Recently went back to SA and CA. I like that you can keep more in a tank, basically I now go for more fish rather than a few large showpiece cichlids. I like the increased activity and to me they don’t seem to be just doing the same laps around the tank. YMMV
Panda and regular uaru of course new tank is almost up stay tuned 😜😜
I built a 240gallon plywood tank,best thing I ever did under $1000. Probably in the direction of building another
Had Jack Dempseys for years and miss having tanks. Beautiful tanks you have!!
Definitely the biggest tank, I would just move the African cichlids there.
Love your channel.
Thank you! I wish the Africans could have a tank that size. Thank you!!
I actually had this exact same question for myself last year when I got my new big tank. The bigger tank was supposed to be for the south Americans. After a couple months, I switched the Africans to the bigger tank and got more 😂 something about the crazies that you just can't get enough of. Even now, I'm thinking about switching my mbuna tank with the American. The mbuna are ruthless 😂
Another awesome video.love the work!
That’s funny 😄. My mbuna aren’t full grown so things will change I’m sure, but right now they aren’t too aggressive. Thank you!
If I had to choose one it would be the big tank.
Also like American cichlids more than African.
First time watching your video Awesome fish and it shows how much you love them
Thank you, Allen 😎
CC,
I love the Central and South American cichlids over AF Cichlids. I am not sure if you are going to get one but if you get a severum that fish is very personable and like a little water puppy also. I love how my Central and South American fish react when I am near the tank and how excited they get and follow you around. You chose some beautiful fish for Central and South American cichlids and as they get older you will see there colors pop. Your salvini looks like a female with all the yellow on the fish. Thanks for sharing this video and for the comparison video.
I had no doubt which tank you would prefer, Jeremy lol. So I actually do have a severum. A mouth brooding severum. It is pretty small still and timid. I might have to move it over to the 180 since it isn’t growing much and the Oscar of course is growing an inch every day it feels like. I still want some geos, but I’ll have to grow them out too.
Navy Submariner here 🙋🏻♂️! Drowning in a submarine is a scary thought. However, sumps intimidate the hell out of me and I think I’ll stick to HOBs and Canisters for now. Lol. Love your channel. Love your tanks.
Oh man, doing the scariest job imaginable. I don’t blame you on the canisters.
I’ll never have too make that choice lol😜
San Quentin for sure. I can’t wait for the inmates to grow and thrive. My fav is the wild Colombian Oscar what are you going to name it? 😂
Me too! His name is Perry, and he is growing amazingly quickly. I like the Columbian more than the other types of oscars.
No doubt that bigger is better, that's what she said!!!! U have way more possibilities with the new tank and not just with the room that is almost the doble is a long list of good stuff against the other one ,now I personally ,if we talk about the fish ,I like Africans, but the set up of course, the big one
Thanks! Africans are really cool, but I’m all about these Americans right now. Who knows, maybe that’ll change. I’ll never buy another acrylic.
Your decor is great. I love it❤😊
I appreciate that. I’m really happy with it
I am a fan of South and Central American cichlids. I like their size and color. If I had the money and time, I would get a massive-- 1000 gallon or more-- tank for American cichlids. I also like some fish from Africa which act like American cichlids. A Starry Night cichlid is a perfect example. If I were to get an African cichlid tank, I would get an Mbuna tank so that I could do some rock work.
On the type of tank, I would go with glass. The idea of having scratches in a tank that costs a ton of money is insane to me. I do not like buying new cars for this very same reason. The filter would depend of the fish. But I also want quiet tanks. I will have to see and hear the difference before finally deciding.
That is such a well thought-out response. Thank you for your comment!
I Love your videos, I think I've watched them all i think. You crack me up man. I usually watch kaveman kev and I found you a few months ago when I jumped to a 125 I got for an anniversary gift in April from a 30... something gal. I'm a lunatic and went mbuna, hap, and peacock in the 125. At least that's what I ordered and . Love it anyway. Favorite cichlid: I've found that I'm partial to the OB variety and have trouble finding them at a price I can afford. Looking forward to much more from you sir! Be well!
Thank you so much! Wow, from a 30 to a 125 - you gotta be ecstatic about that. And all those cool cichlids. The joy of setting up a new tank is addicting. OBs are gorgeous, but they know it and like to beat everyone up. At least they are likely to. Thanks again!
I have two 210's, 1 Central/South American and 1 peacock/Hap tank. I love them both! I love your channel as we share similar interests in this amazing hobby 😎.
Question for you: Have you ever thought about keeping Discus? That may be my next project.
Good size tanks you have there. That’s a great size for Africans. Lots of people go too small imo. I have thought of discus, but after getting bored of my angels, I think they would lose my interest. Beautiful fish though! And thank you 🙏
Another great video. Love the comparisons. One day I’ll do a larger than this 150 I have. I would also not want a sump. I mean I do have diamondback turtles and not fish lol
Thank you. 150 is still decent!
I have been obsessing getting back into the nut job Africans like Elongatus, Auratus and all the psychos. However, after seeing your Haps and Peacocks I am really torn. Building a new 240 and I am starting to think the challenge every time someone has to be rescued, needing a lot more rocks and caves, I could spend weekends redecoration just to save someone. You really have me in a great place though.
Sand, rocks, love the wood, so many options. I will be rewatching a lot of your videos as I get closer to pick up on your successes, places for decor and types of substrate that won’t break the bank.
When I heard you using 3 F6’s, I heard the register ringing. What’s better than 2? 3!
Thanks for the videos. You are my go to at chill time.
Exciting times for you. DIY’s wonderful starting a new tank and deciding what you’d like to stock it with. Thank you so much!
Alcatraz for the win
Lovely
Thank you
There cannot be only 1! There must be many! Great breakdown of the different types of tanks! And for sure scratches drive me crazy but it’s like a pair of sunglasses, once there out even the air scratches them, dumb Oakley. The detail you get into with your description makes me rethink some of my tanks but ultimately they are already here. The fish look great! And you can never have enough friends when it comes to moving! Stay happy and healthy my friend!!! 😊❤
Many tanks 😍 I’m just about out of room for cool tanks, so now I’ll have to get creative if I want more lol. Thank you!
@@CichlidCharmerof course there is a “limit” and I won’t push you any which way you don’t want to go. I personally would have at least 10 more if I had the room. I cannot get enough of them, already at 11, down from 14, I condensed a couple, one was a mistake but only if I want to show that tank on camera, and I can’t even talk about that! Nevertheless, it’s why I like having my wife’s opinion but I don’t like her judgment calls. Everyone is fine just s#*} looking tank.
@@HapiPETSWM Oh make no mistake, I want more, but I have run out of the space my wife has allowed me to allocate for fish. However... I have been eyeing some real estate in the garage lately lol. I'd have to figure out the cost and how to set up a chiller though, because it gets HOT in there in July and August.
Noticed you don’t like the heater in your 240. I added an inline heater using a fx6 filter. Just had to get creative with some epoxy and pvc 😆 but works great and way more efficient!
Good idea. I do like being able to make sure that light indicator is on though.
I order the torn / weathered catappa leaves and my South Americans ate them, I think it was the uarus or severums. Just an FYI.
Wait a second - they are fake leaves from Aquadecor?
Aw Hi Zeke the man, OK, now how in the world can a person pick which tank they like the best, I love them both! I have had both acrylic and glass tanks and I like glass for they are easier for me to keep clean, and I don't break out in a sweaty heartache worrying about scratching glass. I love fish of all kinds thou I do get mad at some of the meaner jerks so it's hard for me to choose, but I'll always go with Oscars they can be mean and also be big bubba's that interact with you. Thank you for showing us the difference in both of these tanks and how each are set up, I love to put plants into my tanks and like you say they get munched on and get pulled out ending up floating on top of the water, or just die because I looked at them, so they are a hassle.. .thanks again David you have kept me loving tanks.
Hi Polly! Thanks for liking both of them. I look back at early Alcatraz and I much prefer it now over then. I think the two tanks are a good compliment to each other. Very different! Glad you’re back into weirdo fish again, Polly.
Hi mate, there both lovely tanks , and I’d happily own both of them but as for fish it’s the nut jobs that I’d rather have if I had to choose. Here in Australia we don’t have those brand of tanks. It took me over a year looking for a tank l liked and in the end I settled for a petworx 210 glass . I also have 2x fx6 plus a third filter 1400lt with a spray bar. Not a sump person but would try one one day.
Thanks, man. I really like them both, but the Americans are a step above. At least right now. Maybe it’s because they are new, so we will see
What’s your opinion on feeding fish every other day? I heard it could extend their lifespan, save money, and also time obviously…
My favor San Quentin !!!!
Awesome mine too!
Mostly beautiful African cichlid tank on UA-cam❤ How’s the mbuna?
Thanks, Sam! The mbuna are doing great, despite my neglect while the new tank project has been underway. I need to get them more rocks.
I have a cade 285g tank with sump & it is silent so I’m thinking there’s things you can do to quiet your tank down 👍 mine has a silencer on it so hopefully you can make something to do the same 👍 I definitely like your big tank more 👍 awesome tank’s & videos mate 👍
Thank you. I am swapping out my pumps to the two Sicce 7.0s today, and I’ll dial in the overflows again. Hopefully that helps. I’ve never heard of a silencer for sumps.
i love both as well, but my oscars are just too personable. i would have to be on the americas end myself. africans are so pretty, but at the end of the day i love my water puppies.
I've never had an acrylic tank but it seems like the scratches would negatively affect the clarity, at least to some degree.
Not so far, but maybe eventually
is the plant on top of the tank help reducing your nitrate level? if yes I would like to know how you set it up. and how frequently you do water change now.
Mine really isn’t doing that much to help. It would probably be better if I had more light on it. It should be growing faster than it is too. I do a 75% water change weekly in the 240. A 50% on the 180.
Alkatraz FTW
Thank you, Paul.
I have multiple sumps and multiple canister filters, i prefer sumps BECAUSE they are quieter i dont know how you have your sump or overflows setup but they can be 100% silent while canisters always have a low (hum) to them
Thanks for the input. I’ll be working on it today. Hopefully I can dial this thing in and get it quiet. I bet the two Sicce 7.0 pumps will help too.
@@CichlidCharmer What kind of drain setup are you running on the overflows of the sump? Herbie? Bean animal ? Or just a single durso pipe ?
@@BillB8 It's a herbie. I'd go bean animal next time.
@@CichlidCharmer herbie is amazing and from what i have found way easier to tune it 100% silent vs bean animal which can be trickier by alot. You may know this already so if you do ignore it but as long as you have a gate valve on the main siphon drain you can tune the water level so its higher in the overflow box on the back of the tank so you dont hear water trickle from the tank into the box AND at the same time BELOW the overflow drain and if you get ur water level right in the middle you will be 100% silent. Best of luck !
@@BillB8 Thank you! Unfortunately, no one at Custom Aquariums suggested I get a gate valve, so I have some economy valves that aren't great by a long shot. I'll have to switch to gate valves some time in the future.
I’m the opposite I will not risk hundreds of gallons of water on the ground lol acrylic for life for me use a microfiber cloth to wipe the inside of tank with won’t scratch oh wow your in Washington 👍 Lakewood here
I bet it will scratch if you press hard enough lol. I’m actually in Idaho, but only three minutes from Washington
Also, I have a small beta tank. It's acrylic and it's somehow scratched to hell. I would not get a large acrylic. Nope!
I feel that!!
But acrylic gets yellow over time right?
That’s a very good question and when I haven’t researched. I keep mine out of direct sunlight for the most part, so I think it would take quite a while for that to happen.
What's that beautiful fish as 12:15, blue striped one.
That’s my electric blue Texas cichlid. Pretty awesome-looking, isn’t he?
He is indeed, my favorite fish of the video, tempted to see if i can find one in the uk. Awesome videos man, keeping me entertained and educated. @CichlidCharmer
@@shaunmarshall4504 Thank you, Shaun. Hope you can find one!
Its all so very personal with fish keeping. Species, Aquascape, fake or real and the list goes on. San Quentin I like a tad more I think. I'd pass on a sump though.
Sumps -- scary and noisy. Thanks for the comment and good to see you back
Fantastic
Thank you!
South and Centrals 100%
I like that answer lol
Mbuna like rocks but you have haps. Some people may not realize that and lots of others rocks maybe benefial
They sure do. I have a video on my mbuna tank and I talk about having lots of rocks. They love ‘em 😍
That jack Dempsey is a female so unfortunately won't get the same beauty as the males but less aggressive and don't get as big so that's a plus.
Good to know! I actually have a smaller one in there too maybe that’s a male.
@@CichlidCharmer if they pair up you will definitely have some problems lol
anyway, you'r super super handsome!!!!
Well thank you 😊
If you’re weak and have a bunch of weak friends. 🤣
You caught that 😂
@@CichlidCharmer hilarious!
@@CichlidCharmer subscribed!
@@ARod-br2ui Thank you!
Had Jack Dempseys for years and miss having tanks. Beautiful tanks you have!!
Maybe it’s time to get back into it? Thank you!
@@CichlidCharmer if I do it will be small community. As you mentioned in another video fish that get big can be tough. You got me wanting to though!