Logitech G923 Teardown, Review & G29/G920 Comparison - IS IT WORTH IT?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 лип 2024
- Logitech's not so new G923 sim racing wheel has caused quite a stir in the sim racing community, so today we take a detailed look and compare it with the previous generation G920/G29, including a comparison of the wheel and pedal internals to find out exactly what's changed. Then put TRUEFORCE to the test to see if it's worth the asking price both for first time buyers and those looking to upgrade.
Introduction: 0:00
Addressing Questions & Myths: 3:07
Wheel External Comparison: 7:56
Wheel Internal Comparison: 13:34
Pedal Comparison: 19:50
G Hub Software: 26:27
Dual Clutch: 34:55
Driving Tests: 37:36
Ergonomics: 41:53
TRUEFORCE Impressions: 44:40
Summary: 48:45
___________________________________________
GRAB YOUR G923 HERE:
Logitech Webstore North America - logi.gg/boostedNA
Logitech Webstore EU/AU/NZ/China/Japan - logi.gg/boostedEU
Prefer a G920 or G29?
boostedmedia.net/go/purchase-...
___________________________________________
Learn more about how TRUEFORCE works here:
• WHAT IS TRUEFORCE? - L...
___________________________________________
Magnetic shifter review video:
• CHECK THIS OUT if you ...
___________________________________________
JUMP IN OUR DISCORD COMMUNITY HERE:
/ discord
___________________________________________
Keen to support Boosted Media? CLICK HERE:
boostedmedia.net/support-boos...
___________________________________________
MY PC SPECS:
boostedmedia.net/technology/b...
#logitech #g923 #trueforce
Music: liquicity.com - Наука та технологія
HEADS UP! Logitech currently have the G920 on sale with a 37% discount: boostedmedia.net/go/purchase-here-logitech-g920/
I literally can't thank you enough. Thank you!
yo what do you mean the 923 is 800 aud? i just checked and its still the same pre order price of 500 cad which is just over 500 aud
@@SSmallwood Because in some countries it costs a lot to ship there which raises cost.
I smell marketing bullshit and a disproportionate price hike for not a lot of difference. A very thorough video, I'm impressed you even bothered given it really isn't worth the money.
Boosted Media to my surprise I got a $60 discount from the normal price $399 USD using the Honey app during checkout tonight for the new G923 on the Logitech website.
I wish Logitech made these with interchangeable wheel rims, would be really cool to have official GT or F1 wheel rims...
Check out 3drap, they makes awesome wheel rims in really good quality and fits perfectly mechanically and visually as well
such thing known as trust Master
There`s amstudio here on YT, He shows you how to make them and sell`s them to.
Driving World pretty sure it’s called Thrustmaster. Knew what you meant though.
@@yourlocalmexicandog don't trust thrustmaster. When you really wanna start sim racing go with Fanatec CSL Elite 1.1 or CLubsport Wheelbase 2.5. When you fall in love with sim racing, the final step is a direct drive wheel base
You weren't lying, this g923 smells goood!
It's a little late for April fool's. $800 for the same wheel basically.
Really liked the review, didn't sugar coat it, just straight to the point and good info.
Where are people getting these 800 dollar figures from? they literally cost 450 straight from logitech's website
@@AntaresSQ01 AUS $
Lol American simp
Video is an hour long…what do you mean straight to the point lmfao
Following since 20K, can't express how valuable and high quality content this is, video edition is also on point, and provided insights cant be equaled without the notable background. Once again hats off!! Keep it up mate!!
Honest and detailed review as always. Again, as I commented on your earlier review, if only they added the ability to plug in an optional handbrake. IMHO, it would have been a more substantial upgrade than "Trueforce", and as you said it would have been so easy for Logitech to include it and the accessory handbrake.
Really appreciate the depth of this review, I didn't watch all of it as I'm not looking for a new wheel, but nice to be able to watch the sections that I was interested in. You were very balanced clearly have done your research so will definitely recommend your channel!
I work in a retail store the the UK and Logitech gave all employs a 50% discount, so I grabbed it for £175.. my first ever wheel.. I’m a new subscriber, love your content making me excited for trying it out!
Kyle Collins haha yea, hard to pass that one up
Damn that’s crazy!
I bought my G29 about a year ago when Curry's had it for I think 180 quid and it came with the h-shifter packed in. One of the best purchases I ever made.
Now though, for this money I'll be tempted to give Thrustmaster a try.
Thank you so much for bringing the dual-clutch up man.
For $800 rrp they’ll have a hard time selling these over the T300 with the T3PA pedals. Or the older G29/920 for that matter.
I assume the older wheel will be discontinued. Some people don't research and already know Logitech so they'll stick to what they know and just get this.
My opinion it's their marketing strategy. Why G923 expensive? They want to clear out the G29/920 stock from the market. Then they will cut the price of these.
Shahrir Idzuan yeah I’d say that’s a fair observation.
@@barters8124 yet they were charging over $400 for the now outdated logitech g920 a month ago because of the pandemic. Logitech can go screw themselves, you raise the price of a becoming obselete product to make more money off of your customers during a global pandemic? I won't buy another logitech product because of this, they and their shitty business model can go pound salt
it's weird since in US the price for G923 is at 399 USD same price with the older G29
Can’t wait to watch the whole thing love your channel will
Thats an extremely detailed internal analysis. Thumbs up great job as always.
The inside of the wheel looks exactly the same as my g27, only the main PCB is slight different ..
And guess what. The G27 looks nearly identical to the G25 with a few differences to the PCB.
Noice I've been waiting for a video like this one. Cheers mate.
I like your new review format, very in-depth!
Still not too complicated for the laymen though ;)
I appreciate the amazing review of the product I had set out to find a solution for that noise but as you basically said it normal in these wheels being that they are gear driven so im gonna stop looking figured maybe id be able to put high temp grease on the gears and quiet it down but not even gonna attempt that now knowing that the sound is just there because of how the wheels are designed.
Amazing Video Keep up the Great Work.
Excellent breakdown and knowledge. Much apprecuated and keep up the hard work!
Thanks mate, excellent review, waiting for my 923 to arrive
I had a G25 more than 10 years ago and the pedals look suspiciously similar. The price is very high for this.
Quickly becoming the master of these types of reviews. Love it!!
Sim racing garage. The king.
I love your videos keep up the good work man!!!!
After watching I ordered the G923 as a first time racer. Thank you.
Enjoy! Welcome to the racing community :)
AndrewDaniele87 thanks 🙏🏼
You like it ?
so you fell for his BS then,,, ah well at least he gets the kickback
Today I noticed a play on the wheel, in the forum people suggested I open it up and tighten the screws. I did and the problem was not the screws coming loose but a huge crack from bottom to top of housing. I just watched your video and thank you for opening them up. This issue has been around since the G27 and well known in terms of failure. Your video showed me the new wheel (in terms of design of this case) is no difference so.. I would not be buying the Logitech again. I’ll rewatch some of your reviews as I search for a replacement. Thanks Will, you saved me making a mistake. I appreciate it.
Wow... such a great in-depth and unbiased review. Appreciate the deep dive into the technical aspects and teardown as well. Great job!
Great video! I purchased one of these for my friends and he is struggling with brake pedal settings in iRacing. Any suggestions for in-game brake settings?
Watching from the UK. Love your channel mate.
One of the best YT reviews I've seen, noice 😊 subscribed
Nice driving over the top of the mount too 🇦🇨🤙
Great Video! Enjoyed every minute! A lot of effort and thank you for the review
Thanks Peter :)
@@boostedmedia no worries!! Great video to keep me interested during Melbourne Stage 4 restrictions
Another awesome video, thanks Will. I truly appreciate all the effort you out into producing these reviews.
Great teardown! What is the point of the custom magnetic shifter thing you held up towards the beginning of the video?
I just got my G923. I was wondering on standard settings in Assetto Corsa Competizione, when the car is idling it shakes quite a lot. It shakes the whole desk. Did you experience this and is it normal. Also the noise sounds like something rattling inside with TrueForce on. I heard that when you tested but the idle shake I am not sure on.
I still think it is a RIP, if they just made it look a bit different then the last wheel people probably wouldnt be so upset, so the only difference is the development of the board inside, .. so how does that justify the extra cost.. yeah it doesnt. Oh well at least Fanatec sales will increase now. :) :)
Exactly, this trueforce sh!t is not true at all lmao
Have you tried purchasing from Fanatec lately?
@@simonolsen9995 i bought a dd2 and a wheel with hub in june both items where in stock and arrived in 6 working days with international shipping
@@FundayXD Well I wish I had your luck. But, good luck to you in any case. But, just imagine how you'd feel if you were still waiting, with no news. I paid on July 2. But I live in hope. Anyway, congratulations on your DD2. I hope you're smashing the lap times and having tons of fun doing it. Life's a lottery, eh?
@@simonolsen9995 no, however I do know someone that got one about 4 weeks ago no issues, took about 5 days to arrive in AUS, but I know they don't have much stock - but again if your going fanatec your wanting better quality so waiting a bit longer isn't an issue for most people I would guess........
AMAZING MATE! Thank you for this great review :)
Thanks Kirk. Glad you enjoyed it.
Great review!!!
I don't like people comparing it to thrustmaster or fanatec gear, a cls elite with a shifter and pedals is 750 dollars plus, while a t300rs gt is around 500-600 dolalrs with a shifter, and the g923 is even at full price thats inflated with a shifter at 450 dollars. the prices are not even comparable, for a fanatec setup you could get 2 g923's.
do u know where i can get a g 920 motherboard to purchase for replacement???? mines damage i'd really appreciate it man tnx much....
I remember I upgrading to a G27 many years ago from a G25. Was not impressed with the FFB compared to the well worn G25 so I kept the old wheel! Bet it's still going strong.
Help! Since you tore these down do you know what the clocking on the encoder is? I can't find any documentation as to what orientation the hall effect sensor should be corresponding to the center gear. If you have any idea please let me know!
Edit: I just realized that since the encoder is skipping anyways but gets fixed on a reset it means that the wheel completely resets position each time so it doesn't matter what orientation the gear is in.
Slightly different question, if you were going to buy a wheel well waiting for Thurstmaster to get back to you on a warranty issue (power supply died) on your T150, still budget conscious, would you recommend the G923 or the T300RS?
Thanks for the vid. The only thing i can say about their new wheel is. You can get the g29 with shifter for half the price.
Can i setup the wheel on my pc and use it on the console? or is the configuration software for pc use only? Because, I can setup the wheel ingame but can I set it up twice? I hope you understand my question :P
Came across one of these for half price and I couldn’t pass it up. Still plan on getting a Fanatec CSL DD but I figured I’d have some fun with this first. Great review!
Currenty I have a G27 modded with a quick release wheel. I am a bit disappointed in that they didn't put some heatsinks on the motors. I had to dial force feedback down because in 1.5 hour races my motors started smelling. A bit more worried for the G923 since it throws more power at it.
Any idea if that overheating issue is still the case for G923 @Boosted Media? Probably if this one breaks down a G920 is a better choice for me because of the lower price.
Fantastic video, many thanks!!
Awesome video, very informative.
Very interesting Will. Thank you.
Exhaustive and specific material ;) I have one question: wasn't there a rubber cube in the brake pedal from the G920 model causing excessive hardness? I had one. Regards
In my two G29 wheels, the wiring loom from the wheel to the PCB in the base failed with the wire/s snapping internally. There are forums dedicated to repairing this by ordering new looms from China and replacing the stock loom with a beefed up loom with thicker gauge wires. When the original wires failed, the wheel wouldn't calibrate properly and display all sorts of strange behaviors. It was thought to be a driver issue but nope, hardware failure/
Great Review! I was waiting for this. But one question: Is the rubber stop in the break pedal, which you didn't show in the video, the same in the G923 as in the G29/920? It's important because it was this rubber stop that had many ppl modifying their brake pedal with some replacing it or removing it entirely.
the g923 does not have the rubber , instead they inserted a progressive spring which is way better
@@tito7021 thank you
Is there any chance that the main board for the g29 is compatible with the g920? I cannot find the replacement main board for the g920 anywhere.
Great video by the way
If you want to compare what the new electronics add to non-TrueForce games, you can turn the closed loop off and back on again with cross+square+circle+triangle+minus and cross+square+circle+triangle+plus respectively.
Do you ask if the Dual Clutch can be firmware updated into the G29/G290?
55 minutes ooof this is gunna be comprehensive
Love it
haha its like sim racing garage
Let’s get to it
@@boostedmedia you forgot the "so..." and pause :p
i would like to know what you guys think. right now i have none of them but between the g29 and g923 with a 30 usd difference. wich one should i buy?
My G27 is getting worn out, however my old G27 pedals and Hshifter are fine. Are G27 pedals and Hshifter compatible with this new model?
It looks like you could swap out the G29 board for the G923 board to get access to the new features.
Thanks for making this video. I'm more comfortable knowing I'm not missing out on a lot by not getting the G923 and sticking with my G29.
BTW whenever I set my G29 operation range to 270 degrees or whatever it does give you a bump stop at that range. Not sure why your G923 wasn't stoping.
Just purchased DOF P3 motion platform, looking to mount a GT Omega RS6 seat, been told by Omega that mounting holes don’t line up, can I redrill
any comments please
Hi i have the g920 and the wire behind the steering wheel on the connetor the red wire has broken off from the connetor how do you replace it as my buttons have stopped working pleasse help
Recently bought a G923 and ACC and I am amazed with the FBB and Trueforce of this combo....I can feel the engine reving, tranny shifts, road surface, debris and FFB is pretty damn strong which i had to lower to half way...the McLaren 720S not only sounds amazing but you can feel the raw power through the wheel. Coming from a G25 about 12 years ago the g923 is a huge step up especially the brake pedal feel.
What about the FFB deadzone? I have a G29 (prev model) and I had to write an entire software to get rid of the huge dead zone and the non linear FFB (my program is named Steering Wheel Master). Without the Trueforce and the "road effects", do you feel an empty zone in the steering during the straight?
@Mr Luken nope no empty zone...my only complaint with it is its noisy...the parts moving sounds like it's broken but it's completely normal.
@@RayRiv73 yes It's a little bit noisy... But the internal build quality is not bad.
I just bought the upgraded spring for the brake pedal
When i setup my g29 in ghub i set my rotation for 180 but when i restart my computer it resets to 900 but shows 180 in ghub. if i move the slider to a new number the wheel twitches then goes to how i want it. I like the g29 but is a constant pain as i always have to set it up again and again
Thank you for the video. Does the break comes with that rubber inside as the old model or just the progressive spring?
Just spring
Is there still a bump stop in the brake pedal like the g29/920?
Hmm so what to make of this?
As someone who still has a G29 for daily use at home, but (until recent lockdown) had regular access to a DD2, given the lack of fundamental changes such as the actual motors/peak torque output this was never going to be the kind of upgrade I was looking to make, but it's good to hear trueforce is valuable even on a product like this - based on your observations in ACC vs iRacing I'm thinking that iRacing is able to use physics/telemetry-driven effects by default (Lawrence Dusoswa's look at trueforce in iRacing earlier this week at least showed that in the app.ini file you can switch between physics-driven effects and audio-driven effects)
The RRP though does it no favours - prices it against Thrustmaster's T300 + T3PA GT pedals going by a retailer such as PC Case Gear in Australia (which I could swear is about A$150 higher than it was pre-pandemic) and I'd rather have a belt FFB system over a gear FFB system with added effects
Was going to say I've seen G29/920's sell for A$360 (last year) vs their RRP of A$500 but that's gone out the window it seems with shortages and logistics - so while i'd hope a similar percentage discount would make its way to retailers pricing I think we're out of luck there for the time being
Good review Will :) though did you mean to talk about the thickness of the wheel rim twice at 9:18 ? xD
P.S. Still want to see Logitech go for a "G Pro" wheel base with a belt drive and some more torque plus a load cell brake package - given they've thrown their support behind some serious Project Cars 2 global tournaments why wouldn't they invest in that market segment which would get them more traction among more enthusiast buyers?
Pretty much mate. Thanks for picking up the editing error too. That’s fixed now.
Yeah there’s two aspects to TrueForce, the audio and the telemetry data. It seems ACC may only be using the audio data from my testing but I didn’t want to elaborate on it too much as it’s likely to change before release.
I wonder if the new Thrustmaster T-LCM's with the T300 wouldn't be the bees knees for $ < fanatec, yes?
@@boostedmedia ACC on Console (PS4) SUX!! I dropped it. NO telemetry data, no audio or video setup, no FoV or seat adjustments AND no keyboard (button box)!
Thomas Rogan problem is the consoles suck in that aspect. They are for gaming but not for this kind of simulators. Rarely a game has fov adjustments on consoles.
@@lupo_aim incorrect. PCars2, AC, etc. Have specific HFoV settings on both PS4 and XBox.
Have any early adopters of the G923 been able to get it working with any PC Forza games? The LG web site says they work, albeit without TrueForce support, but I'm seeing people saying the game flat out won't recognise the wheel.
did they improve the rotary dial? Mine on the G29 skips the click most of the time it's almost useless.
me too
Knowing Logitech... no likely not.
Hi there. Is there any way I can fix the severed wire from my logitech g923 wheel. Can I replace the wire.
I have a g920 and none of the buttons work except the circle Xbox symbol one any ideas how I can fix it
hello, today I bought the g923 to start with the racing simulators in the X series and pc, I am happy with the purchase, it is my first steering wheel that I buy
Is the connector for the wheel the same? I mean the part that attaches from the motherboard to the steering wheel itself
Just got this wheel as a starter into sim racing as it was on offer locally under £200. Thanks for the review!
So like 250 dollars? That's a great price. I just got the t248 for 299 dollars after looking for a wheel for a bit.
I don't think Logitech has made the changes that they have to necessarily entice upgrades, but more to keep their wheel offering relevant for the times. They are doing the same thing they have been doing since the G25 (kind of). They refresh the wheel every 5 years (4 years between the 25 and 27) to give it relevant with modern features and the wheel retails for $400 (US). I think the G25 was more, but when I get a G27 back in the day, its retail price was $400. I didn't pay the retail price. and like the previous wheels if you don't like the $400 retail price just wait a bit for it to go down. It always goes down. It went down really quick (almost immediately) on the G29/G920 (which released at a retail price of $400) because of the competition from the Thrustmaster T300 which was around the same price and had released the year before.
Does the thrustmaster tgt now support the same games trueforce does? I know it’s a similar system
I appreciate your video, is the best one for this racing wheel!
On 30:20, I can confirm that you get mechanical bump stop when adjusting rotation, but you have to be in game to get that. Using G29 btw.
yup, true
i want to upgrade to a csl elite but I dont want to drop the extra cash on pedals. can I use my g923 pedals with a fanatec wheel?
Hello great video!! can you help me with a G920 that the led blinks rapidly and it says Unknown USB Device (Device Descriptor Request failed)? It can be a firmware issue? I would program a dump if I had one. I searched online and found nothing. Or if you have another sugestion, If you want to help. Thanks!
Anyone know what the connector that connects to the back of the wheel is called from the base? I need to get a new cable.
on the UK logitech website it's a £20 difference, seems like it's a no brainer over hear to go for the G923 after seeing your awesome review. will definitely be recommending to my friends that haven't got a wheel yet
Dont buy from logitech directly, wait till its sold through amazon, pcworld or box computers here in the uk. Logitech always charge rrp on their products via their own webstore, but other retailers may lower prices. Especially woth regards to the g920/g29. Which can often be purchased for £200 with the driving force shifter included.
Yes I picked up a G920 3 years ago with the shifter for £150 from PC World
Get it from Box when it releases, you’ll appreciate the big discount
Do the pedals of the logitech G923 have a rubber block like those of the G29? The rubber block in G29 pedals dont like nothing. Thanks a lot and good video.
Snake oil: sim racing version.
That marketing jargon in the previous video trying to sell TrueForce was despicable - like you said, it was technically not really lying if you look at it from their perspective, but it's the kind of thing that would make the uninformed buy this instead of getting the DD they had their eye on before.
this is a random question but would anyone happen to know the size of the 3 silver screws that hold on the paddle shifters I need a replacement for it
Don't also forget that the original wheel that had the layout of those is the DFGT with the aditional +- and twist dial.
I took my G920 apart and put it back together and now my Xbox button is rapidly blinking and when I turn it on the wheel calibrates but stays to the left. Any idea why it’s doing this????
Very good review there my friend
18:50 The plastic tabs isnt what provides spring back on the paddles, they are just buffers for the switch, on the paddles you have 2 bits of extruded sprung metal tabs on each side that provide the spring back for the paddles
Great review. Was there a rubber stop in the brake pedal like there is in the G29/920?
Not that I could see. I did look for it. Just the white plastic bump stops.
I have a problem with my g29 wheel. It resets itself during race as I´m turning, taking a turn; never on a straight line. Sometimes, it gets stuck on acceleration and none of the buttons respond. I actually have to unplug it and plug it back to resume the race. That makes me think there is something wrong with the gears or the motors. I opened the base in order to clean it or find the problem. NOTHING WRONG! Does anyone have the same problem? How do I fix it?
As an entry level sim racer this is the price point and experience that I'm willing to tolerate for an improved experience over a controller. I love my g920 so this was an insta-buy for me. I'm willing to use this for a while before committing to the next tier up.
If you already have a G920, i don’t get why you wouldn’t just save up the extra £200 over what you’d spend on the g923 and get a csl elite or even a clubsport. I just wonder what the thought process is. It’s still a gear driven ff system so it’s going to lack nuance, sounds to me like true force is just a vibrator
@@dreamcrusher112 . I the think true force is a good addition, however, I agree with you that the g920 to g923 makes no sense for the OP. Save the money for that future purchase. Maybe they were wanting it for PlayStation?
If anybody can tell me the usb header connectors name for the g920 and how to get a replacement for it that would be dope c:
Great review. Do you know what the USB polling rate of the new wheel is? (and of the last gen wheels?) I don't mean the new FF polling rate but the actual steering encoder USB polling rate.
The much older Logi wheels were 125hz but I've never been able to get the numbers on the newer wheels.
1000Hz on the new one. I wasn’t able to get an answer on the older ones.
Thanks :)
I hate the progressive spring in the break on the G923 I had the G29 for few years & switching over I just can not get on with it.
what would be a great alternative please help!!!
Manage to pick up a second hand G923 for $200 AUD for my PS5 so a really great entry point wheel at that price. Really enjoying driving with it but I must say the lack of external handbrake is a real issue for game like Dirt Rally. It would be awesome if logitech had a shifter + handbrake combination that worked.
I'm looking to buy this wheel for my series x xbox and don't have a PC, can you setup the wheel without a PC just using the xbox. Thanks
My experience with Logitech software has been much different. Granted I haven't used it in several months since I'm on all Fanatec now but man I had nothing but issues with the G Hub software back when I owned the G920. FFB would constantly be bugged and I'd have to uninstall and reinstall logitech drivers about every other time I played a game. Tried everything I could to fix the issue with no luck What a hassle. The thing that solved it for me back then was actually ditching G Hub and getting the old Logitech Gaming Software. Didn't have an issue after that.
You said that you cannot upgrade the firmware of the old one to the new one due to the difference of the motherboard. I wonder, as the connectors are the same, if it's possible to swap the motherboard with the new one
Hello I have a problem in my g920 I need to know the numbers of some ICs if you can help me please ?
Great video mate not my cup of tea but your reviews are honest and fair. Just upgraded from T300Rs to a TS-PC Ferrari edition and am loving life but my arms are sore this morning lol. By the way Will see you on Sunday race 1 really keen to give the upgrade a good run.🙂🙂
Awesome. See you then :)
Wait how many amps can the G920s circuit board handle? It sounded like you said not.5 amps
Is this compatible with the thrustmaster th8a shifter if using on Xbox one? Thanks
I got the fanatec csl elite recently, laughed while clearing some corners that I wasn't able to clear in maximum attack with my G29 due its deadzone, I wonder if the G923 still has the same issue.
I’m all late. But I upgraded from a g29 to a t300rs Gt and the night and day difference really showed with how much of a smile I had on my face all day drifting and racing.