The £25,000 Pre-Amp Repair and the Copyright Strike

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 4 тис.

  • @rossmanngroup
    @rossmanngroup Місяць тому +8870

    With your permission, I would like to re-upload your original video to my channel. Then, if a fraudulent copyright claim is filed on my channel, I will fight it to the fullest extent of the law, to the point that a lesson is learned to never do this again. You do good work, sir, I respect your work, and I want to help send a message to companies that do this kind of abuse that it doesn't work.

    • @obd6HsN
      @obd6HsN Місяць тому +930

      Oh my goodness - what a great suggestion! Mark, if you take Louis Rossmann up on his offer, he will show the manufacturer what the Streisand effect really is!!

    • @reps
      @reps Місяць тому +817

      mess with the bull, get the horns 😈

    • @Abeille30
      @Abeille30 Місяць тому +219

      I humbly raise my hat

    • @nicwilson58
      @nicwilson58 Місяць тому +233

      Fantastic Louis, this really needs to happen.

    • @markkrutzmann6862
      @markkrutzmann6862 Місяць тому +104

      From another Mark: I'd love to see how that pans out!

  • @cattflap1447
    @cattflap1447 Місяць тому +3090

    The manufacturer doesn't want people see the emperor has no clothes.

    • @absurdengineering
      @absurdengineering Місяць тому +74

      Yeah. First sale doctrine - this is consumer good not a piece of media. If they are not happy with putting their brand on it - nobody forces them lol.

    • @nickhaddock8658
      @nickhaddock8658 Місяць тому +35

      It's gotta be that. Mark is on it when it comes to copyright music.

    • @absurdengineering
      @absurdengineering Місяць тому +78

      And they acted in an absolutely underhanded manner. Civilized people can discuss this stuff on technical merits alone. They stopped so low the stoop hit them in the head. Absolutely shameful what they did.

    • @Me11oIngenuity
      @Me11oIngenuity Місяць тому +101

      This. The manufacturer got butthurt. Rubbish overpriced perspex anyhow.

    • @darkmatterfalls101
      @darkmatterfalls101 Місяць тому +70

      as 30 year audiophile alot of this so called high end stuff is way overpriced and mark has exposed that good for him, if that TE had sold his phono stage for a resonable price he would have made more units and more money but no they all suffer from greed

  • @colinblank5918
    @colinblank5918 Місяць тому +1731

    Manufacturer - didnt want his shoddy work exposed

    • @DavidFRhodes
      @DavidFRhodes Місяць тому +64

      nor the comments, which were fairly brutal.

    • @charliea697
      @charliea697 Місяць тому +92

      Lol the build looked like a 16 year olds gcse project!

    • @colinmaynard2879
      @colinmaynard2879 Місяць тому +18

      The turtles all the way down design was not impressive.

    • @arjanvanraaij8440
      @arjanvanraaij8440 Місяць тому +26

      Well that was a advanced Vellemann kit.

    • @krillzorz
      @krillzorz Місяць тому +10

      But how can it be the manufacturer that sent the takedown if they were the one who sent it to Mark?
      They somehow didn’t know Mark would put it on youtube. Sounds very unlikely. I think someone read the thread over on diyaudio (which is very supportive of Mark, and somewhat supportive of Evans) and just decided to troll.

  • @danieljones2936
    @danieljones2936 12 днів тому +7

    Thank you Tom Evans for introducing me to this wonderful channel and all the information this kind, knowledgeable man has provided his viewers.

  • @bigclivedotcom
    @bigclivedotcom Місяць тому +1146

    Congratulations on reaching 100K. The copyright and flagging system on UA-cam is very random, and often false flags. Every one of my strikes has been completely nonsensical. I really thought they'd tell you the specific thing that caused the strike though, whether it was music or artwork. Although my recent strikes had no information about the cause and I couldn't get that answer from UA-cam.
    It wouldn't surprise me if entire technical channels get deleted in the future because we probe about in live electrical equipment and it's deemed dangerous.

    • @BatteryCoverMissing
      @BatteryCoverMissing Місяць тому +23

      I believe the manufacturer's name is on the claim when it says the video is unavailable...if you can find the old link maybe you can verify this.🙏 Ps
      Love your videos!

    • @ciprianpopa1503
      @ciprianpopa1503 Місяць тому +9

      deeming electrical current dangerous is copyrighted. There are a lot relatives of the deceased that claimed they have discovered it.
      Yet none claimed a patent after they got bitten.

    • @VlajCo-di8lc
      @VlajCo-di8lc Місяць тому

      And believe in coincidence that only this video has been deleted by chance? Come on.

    • @hydraulic_bat
      @hydraulic_bat Місяць тому

      Dangerously probing around in live wires is copyrighted by @ElectroBOOM I think ... 🤔

    • @apocalypseinfantry5628
      @apocalypseinfantry5628 Місяць тому

      Existing is dangerous. They're going to get a very vocal and well-funded fight if they try and remove the technical stuff from YT. I'll just cancel Premium and move to Floatplane if they pull some BS like that. Actually, I kinda want it to happen. If Floatplane gets much bigger, they'll need more people. I just might be able to get a remote job with Floatplane. I already get my music somewhere else and run a home server to access it anywhere with internet. I can add music remotely, download to my device, give friends access, etc. You might be surprised how much music, videos, and lyrics you can stuff on a 500GB M.2 drive. YT is going to lose their monopoly if they don't stop pushing good creators to other platforms. Twitch is in trouble, too. It seems that these companies couldn't make an intelligent move to save their own butts. It's all just shady, dodgy, underhanded BS. Anything to drive profits, as long as it's not honest or ethical.

  • @bigblueocean
    @bigblueocean Місяць тому +1436

    The video gained a lot of traction on hifi forums. Lots of people were horrified at what you get for £25k. The manufacturer will have claimed the copyright strike. You have revealed his BS for what it is

    • @andymouse
      @andymouse Місяць тому +35

      Well put.

    • @vinny142
      @vinny142 Місяць тому +180

      "Lots of people were horrified at what you get for £25k. "
      Lots of HiFi people are naive :-)

    • @bigblueocean
      @bigblueocean Місяць тому +12

      @@vinny142 ah.... There's always one who knew before the rest of us.

    • @Scott.Newmaster
      @Scott.Newmaster Місяць тому +84

      Uhh, that would be "Audiophools"

    • @bigblueocean
      @bigblueocean Місяць тому +9

      @Scott.Newmaster and the smart arses come crawling out of the woodwork to slag audiophiles off. How novel. Not

  • @mikeselectricstuff
    @mikeselectricstuff Місяць тому +1342

    There is no way they have a valid claim - fight it. There can be significant consequences for people making false copyright claims.

    • @jukkauh
      @jukkauh Місяць тому +178

      There are absolutely no consequences to making a false claim to Google resulting in a strike. That is the problem.

    • @ON8AD
      @ON8AD Місяць тому +27

      Great comeback with this vid. Excellent display of opamp implementation according to reference schematics of the manufacturer 😂

    • @hmartinlb
      @hmartinlb Місяць тому +23

      @@jukkauh Nah, just drag the opponent to court. You'll win. Internet isn't its own lawless free for all. There's ways to take people to court, especially when you know exactly who it is.

    • @Emma__Smith
      @Emma__Smith Місяць тому +14

      MIKE! love your videos!

    • @MrCowering
      @MrCowering Місяць тому +35

      You must fight it. If for no other reason than to not reach the three strikes threshold. If you actually have proof that the manufacturer sent it to you for repair, post that and the strike will go away soon enough

  • @alixxworkshop846
    @alixxworkshop846 Місяць тому +85

    After seeing Rosmann's video and reupload on NickT6630's channel I have to say something. At first BIG respect to you, Sir Mark for doing this repair,reverse engineering It and showing the people about this how do I call It-scam. I mean 25.000 pounds for some garage made science project worth 100eur in material? Plaastic circuit board holders and so badly designed?Not to mention copper "covers" with the holes made by some kid,and "PLASTIC" screws holding cooling for the transistors? NO COMMENT. Come on this is a big shame for our technical field. I as engineer was feeling bad and ashamed what I've seen inside of that "premium" ovepriced junk. I have no words for It. I've seen a lot of bad stuff but this, with that price tag is probably worst I will ever see in my lifetime. Thank you for your video It was really educating and usefull. God bless you Sir!

    • @freyalewis2460
      @freyalewis2460 Місяць тому +6

      You might be able to fast talk me into believing cheap electronics can make audiophile grade hardware. Like if what you were paying for was extreme parts binning for low noise, that would be fine. But for $25k you can build a much better enclosure without cutting into your profit margin too much. There are hobbyists doing much better work just in terms of fit and finish. This is pretty embarrassing and that's probably what the manufacturer is trying to hide.

    • @SharienGaming
      @SharienGaming Місяць тому +2

      @@freyalewis2460 yeah i think you can get some pretty good audio with cheap components and assmebly like this... but none of that justifies the pricetag
      at that price, i would expect the thing to be a fraction of the size with an integrated powersupply and a lifetime warranty (mine, not the devices)... and even then that still feels like a stretch...
      like none of the principles inside of that thing require crazy levels of expertise or skill in assembly... it requires some sure... but im betting if i ask around among the second year university students for engineering faculties, someone could build something like this

  • @mihaischitcu1917
    @mihaischitcu1917 Місяць тому +765

    It was the Tom Evans "MasterGroove". Some things can't be forgotten!

    • @TenFoot
      @TenFoot Місяць тому +30

      This should be higher!

    • @andylewis7360
      @andylewis7360 Місяць тому +82

      You mean TOM EVANS? The guy who “manufactures” MASTERGROOVE?! That TOM EVANS? 😂

    • @tux1968
      @tux1968 Місяць тому +108

      You mean Tom "Copyright Strike" Evans? The one who is embarrassed about the quality of his work and overpriced equipment?

    • @resipsaloquitur13
      @resipsaloquitur13 Місяць тому +16

      More like, "Master Spoof"

    • @ronnetgrazer362
      @ronnetgrazer362 Місяць тому +71

      Can't believe you're all naming and shaming Tom Evans for putting out a shoddy overpriced amp called the Mastergroove. People who happen to google his name could get a bad impression of him.

  • @Joel-st5uw
    @Joel-st5uw Місяць тому +746

    The fact that the copyright claim doesn't specify which part of the video is in violation of copyrighted material is a dead giveaway that the goal of the claim is censorship and has nothing to do with improper use of any sort of copyrighted material. Fight it, Mark. That video was fair and honest and needs to be reinstated.

    • @blev866
      @blev866 Місяць тому +17

      It's 1984-the book!!)

    • @pnnielsen
      @pnnielsen Місяць тому +8

      Find a lawyer. They will prosper from this idiocracy, and give you right although their fees may eat all monetary compensation you get. But at least you get revenge...

    • @leakybean501
      @leakybean501 Місяць тому +1

      🎯

    • @Roads_of_Europe
      @Roads_of_Europe Місяць тому +1

      Agreed

    • @gm3087
      @gm3087 Місяць тому +20

      that guy just can't stand to have his £25,000 soldering project exposed, the audiophile community is very sensitive about their hobby and can't stand to see the nonsense exposed. All that remains for them is to press the "copyright infringment button".

  • @IanScottJohnston
    @IanScottJohnston Місяць тому +605

    The manufacturer is just annoyed his designs were put in front of thousands around the globe, professional EE's included and for what the design really was......a shocking ripoff.
    Mark, you need to follow up with UA-cam and get the video reinstated as a matter of principal. If the manufacturer wins here then a terrible precedent is set........which isn't good for the rest of us.

    • @andymouse
      @andymouse Місяць тому +23

      Damn Right.

    • @luminousfractal420
      @luminousfractal420 Місяць тому +2

      get chatgpt to draw you some frames and do it court artsist style 😂

    • @feedback-loop
      @feedback-loop Місяць тому +11

      right. matter of principle

    • @blackIce504
      @blackIce504 Місяць тому +10

      but his design is not really ground breaking......... plus its almost text book.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +8

      @@blackIce504 But they are 'plastic pillar breaking'...

  • @fabiopolvo039
    @fabiopolvo039 Місяць тому +19

    Despite my 30-year career as an electronic engineer, I have learned and continue to learn a lot from Mark. He is an excellent professional and an excellent UA-cam host. Good professionals are like that, they share their knowledge, they don't hide anything, and they enjoy sharing techniques, methods and information. Everyone wins. Unfortunately for Tom Evans, I am speechless. I don't know him and, frankly, I don't want to. What I saw was a terrible product, assembled in an amateurish way, a disgrace to electronics. 25K euros? What a shame. I wouldn't spend 25 euros... Mr. Tom, please grow up.

  • @michaelnorth3666
    @michaelnorth3666 Місяць тому +403

    TOM EVANS we have all seen that the emperor has no clothes...! Time to get a grip . Good on you Mark...!

    • @Britephartt
      @Britephartt Місяць тому +37

      The copyright strike has made them look even worse.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +2

      @@Britephartt Tekton all over again!
      Tom even made this with a clear cover, so you could see all the bits!!

    • @EyeMac-u8k
      @EyeMac-u8k Місяць тому

      Don't be stupid . . . the guy played 25 full seconds of Elvis . . . why are you all LIBELLING Evans?? How dumb are people

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +1

      @@EyeMac-u8k I listened to it, a few seconds of something, I couldn't tell who it was, fair use anyway.

    • @tomaszwota1465
      @tomaszwota1465 Місяць тому +1

      @@EyeMac-u8k that's not how it works on yt -- you play some copyrighted music that gets recognized by YT automation and your video monetization is claimed by whatever party. It doesn't get completely removed and it is very clearly labelled who gets the money and what music was detected.
      This ain't it, chief.

  • @daveme3582
    @daveme3582 Місяць тому +501

    Im here because of Louis Rossmann's video on this. Was a fan of you Mark before his vid tho. PLEASE take Louis up on his offer to repost your video!

    • @nowave7
      @nowave7 Місяць тому +8

      I'm here because of the Dave Jones' tweet!

    • @jamesprivet
      @jamesprivet Місяць тому +1

      Same

    • @mjklein
      @mjklein Місяць тому

      Me too.

    • @fx-studio
      @fx-studio Місяць тому

      Vid eo is over on r mble.

    • @OggVorbis69
      @OggVorbis69 Місяць тому

      We simply love you ❤Mark. So sorry for what happened. We all stand behind you in this.

  • @mikem9403
    @mikem9403 Місяць тому +235

    The cardboard strip "accidentally" in the shot at 3:32 was my favorite part!

    • @donmoore7785
      @donmoore7785 Місяць тому +11

      Pure genius

    • @snoopythecat3741
      @snoopythecat3741 Місяць тому +9

      Oeps, do I have to cover all cardboard stuff in my house when I make a UA-cam movie due to copyright infringement?😇

    • @Vampier
      @Vampier Місяць тому +8

      that's a bit 'stand off' -ish :D

    • @Paxmax
      @Paxmax Місяць тому +1

      Veri nice touch

    • @sag300674
      @sag300674 Місяць тому +2

      subtle.. very subtle

  • @leonj1106
    @leonj1106 Місяць тому +9

    As an Anglophile, audiophile, and lover of the “can-do” attitude: I shower you with nothing but praise for your content & “cheeky demeanor”. Cheers, Mate!

  • @GoldenSound
    @GoldenSound Місяць тому +404

    As someone who has also recently had to deal with a manufacturer trying to bully me out of showing/saying something they didn't like with legal threats, I sincerely hope you can get this resolved.
    This is an abuse of the copyright system plain and simple, and I really hope you contest the claim.
    Manufacturers should not be able to behave like this, and for those who don't know, an actual copyright strike does damage the channel itself in how the algorithm recommends it, it's not just a case of that one video going away.
    Keep up the great work Mark!

    • @paulb4661
      @paulb4661 Місяць тому +6

      I believe and certainly hope scd learned something, same goes for Notket and I'm sure both lost quite a bit in terms of credibility and... sales. Now this...

    • @user-mv5bu2kk8b
      @user-mv5bu2kk8b Місяць тому

      Old yourube google harassment hard at work mindless idiots

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +11

      Mark also spent a great deal of time and effort on that video. Time to send Tom an invoice..

    • @MladenMijatov
      @MladenMijatov Місяць тому

      Sadly Google doesn't give a shit. All they care about is playing the market and being politically correct to reach widest audience, which also means preparing for another atrocious Rewind video. They have their fingers so far up their own ass they can probably nibble on fingernails. Oh how I wish someone took them to court with class action lawsuit and too millions.

    • @jimfarrell4635
      @jimfarrell4635 Місяць тому +5

      This is the fourth similar case I have heard of now. None turned out well for the manufacturer, including yours, Goldensound. I hope this goes the same way, then maybe companies will get the message.

  • @desperateloner8555
    @desperateloner8555 Місяць тому +246

    This is one of the funniest passive-aggressive response video I've ever watched

    • @Ignaz366
      @Ignaz366 Місяць тому +7

      That's me 'and it's attached to me arm! LOL

    • @smkslpsd
      @smkslpsd Місяць тому +7

      it wasnt passive aggressive at all. it was jovial and light hearted, traits the world will love this man for.

    • @ProfessorMatic
      @ProfessorMatic Місяць тому

      Get a clue dude...

    • @KJ6EAD
      @KJ6EAD Місяць тому

      The subtle mockery is delicious.

    • @jerryjohnson736
      @jerryjohnson736 Місяць тому +1

      The stand-off bit killed me.

  • @COLDMKULTRA
    @COLDMKULTRA Місяць тому +201

    "Tom Evans" should be absolutely ashamed of himself ! ... TOTAL snake oil exposure by Mark. ( which probably explains the video takedown )
    Do not let these scam artists intimidate you Mark ... get the video reinstated!

    • @rossalexander5128
      @rossalexander5128 Місяць тому +8

      It is not snake oil, it does put out a clean signal, it is just not worth what he charges, not even close.
      The manufacturer is just embarrassed that we saw the bad workmanship and how basic it really is. All the parts are basic and cheap, he is charging £24000+ for his research and knowledge which is just insulting.

    • @mamalala8723
      @mamalala8723 Місяць тому +5

      @@rossalexander5128
      "he is charging £24000+ for his research and knowledge"
      Seems that your auto-correct is on the fritz. After all, it appears that it changed "datasheet and copying" to "his research and knowledge".
      Maybe you want to fix that nasty auto-correct app...

    • @chantalslut
      @chantalslut Місяць тому

      @@mamalala8723 There is a bit more involved then copying datasheets. Tom has maybe used the typical setup for an op-amp as shown in the datasheet, but that is only a small part of the total circuit.Is it overpriced? Sure it is. If people pay it, well done Tom Evans. Look at people buying Ferrari's.

    • @eddjordan2399
      @eddjordan2399 Місяць тому

      its not snake oil. it works and it takes a lot of time and effort to measure all those op amps and components to get a low noise output but. the quality and secrecy behind what essentially is just a electronics expert duplicating what the manufacture has recommended then being aggressive toward a person they sent it to tobe fix is not on.

  • @investor.z
    @investor.z 26 днів тому +11

    The way Mark chuckles to himself is so endearing. I wish I had an uncle like him to teach me how to repair things growing up.

  • @GruntUltra
    @GruntUltra Місяць тому +277

    Mark’s response couldn’t be more honest or ‘English’. His humor is only bested by his amazing skills!

  • @patrickdixon4945
    @patrickdixon4945 Місяць тому +288

    Tom Evans, be very ashamed of yourself.

    • @morph-the-cat
      @morph-the-cat Місяць тому +18

      He must have read the comments on the first video. I hope he has a look this time.

    • @dana5865
      @dana5865 Місяць тому +5

      He doesn't know what is a shame.

    • @markianclark9645
      @markianclark9645 Місяць тому +5

      @dana5865 ..exactly what I was going to type..you beat me to it..doesn't feel shame for taking a fiver figure sum for a hand built stereo that cost a couple of hundred to roughly assemble..if only I had the unethical practises of crooked PhD Bsc engineers

    • @bluikkso
      @bluikkso Місяць тому +1

      @@markianclark9645 B-b-b-bbbbut hand-picking all those components! And grinding the etching!

    • @markianclark9645
      @markianclark9645 Місяць тому +1

      @@bluikkso ...all those 4 or 5 years at University..studying..getting a degree..customers then get to pay for what he knows..not what he does..that's what we were told in my early career..you get paid for what you know..not what you do..I guess he applied that principle also..to the Nth degree

  • @blackrifle6736
    @blackrifle6736 Місяць тому +99

    *Louis Rossmann sent me and a "few" others to you, proving the power of the Streisand Effect. Subscribed and Cheers!*

  • @philstevens9914
    @philstevens9914 Місяць тому +20

    There's a growing outcry on the internet and you have an absolute ton of support. I sent a scathing email to Tom Evans HiFi and told him exactly what I thought of him and his product! I believe Evans is taking Legal action. Hat's off to you for exposing this joker. His product is exactly as you described. In the end I believe this experience will put Evans out of business and he'll deserve it!

  • @srOmatic
    @srOmatic Місяць тому +218

    I'm an electronic engineer. And was a technician before. Saw the video too, but I was sick long before the end. This £25K is pure deranged design trash. To add insult to injury, a very difficult thing to maintain and fix. But you have mend it. Mark, my deepest respects from Oleron island France, for your astounding work in any mechanics and electronics. Stef.

    • @paulmichaelfreedman8334
      @paulmichaelfreedman8334 Місяць тому +21

      I was disgusted at seeing plastic standoffs being used on such heavy parts. That's pure greed at work. I heard this conman charged 2,500 pounds for a repair.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +16

      I should have been a single PCB per channel, not difficult to do, and far far better.
      Then scrap the ridiculous power supply..

    • @AudioGuyBrian
      @AudioGuyBrian Місяць тому +15

      The prices charged for Magico and some other speakers like Wison Audio and B&W are insanely marked up. Magico M9's (4 bass drivers and a mid and tweeter in an aluminum can... $800,000! Like 2000% - 10,000% profit. And don't even get me started on amps, and DAC's. The profit margins are insane and people pay it. Audiophools.

    • @sgtgrash
      @sgtgrash Місяць тому

      ​@@AudioGuyBrianOr do what I do, buy used equipment. I have a nice little QUAD setup that I paid peanuts for. Knowledge, patience and discipline is key when buying used gear... 🫡

    • @alexjenner1108
      @alexjenner1108 Місяць тому +2

      Just take a look at the price of pre-amps used in professional recording studios, e.g. SSL, BAE, Universal Audio, Warm Audio and others, some of which are using discrete components and/or valves/tubes. There is no reason that this pre-amp held together with plastic stand-offs and bits of cardboard should cost more than the pre-amps used by recording engineers to record your albums.

  • @andymouse
    @andymouse Місяць тому +333

    I remember enjoying the video enormously and thinking 'how the hell is that pile of junk' worth £25,000 ? It wasn't and now the manufacturer has no sales ! you did a sterling job, and I did think I hope you don't get into any bother. By having he video taken down he has admitted that the price tag for junk is far to high. Keep up the great and honest work !

    • @andrea.dalessandro
      @andrea.dalessandro Місяць тому +13

      Exactly!!!

    • @jim5148
      @jim5148 Місяць тому +19

      The answer is, "It's not worth £25,000." So-called audiophiles love nothing more than to be parted from their money, and many manufacturers are very willing to accommodate them. They all deserve each other.

    • @Elberto71
      @Elberto71 Місяць тому +19

      I hope Mark charged £5k for his repair 😂 a fair price for such High end equipment

    • @halesworth01
      @halesworth01 Місяць тому +5

      I had the same thoughts!

    • @andymouse
      @andymouse Місяць тому +1

      @@Elberto71 :)

  • @basroos_snafu
    @basroos_snafu Місяць тому +183

    What an absolutely delicious way of taking revenge! And congratulations with your 100K!

    • @jdekong3945
      @jdekong3945 Місяць тому +6

      was a work of art

    • @donmoore7785
      @donmoore7785 Місяць тому +3

      Yes this is the perfect response.

  • @bogotta
    @bogotta Місяць тому +13

    If he ain't the sweetest repair guy ever, I don't know. Like a ray of sunshine. Good luck on you Mr. Mark

  • @andrea.dalessandro
    @andrea.dalessandro Місяць тому +218

    I'm really pissed off at those a*holes who made you take down your video for supposed "copyright infringement".
    The truth is that they are selling for £25,000 a device that is worth about £250, and so your video, which explained the circuitry inside in detail, showed the scam.
    We stand with you, as always!

    • @itsonlyme9938
      @itsonlyme9938 Місяць тому +6

      He has aired the circuit on YT which they did not like and the makers did not expect that to happen and those who know about electronics would question why it is so expensive and its not worth the asking price and exposing the over inflated price tag.
      They are also scared that some other manufacture would also copy their circuit.

    • @andrea.dalessandro
      @andrea.dalessandro Місяць тому +22

      @@itsonlyme9938 The manufacturer was sure that - without a schematic and with the components abraded - Mark was not able to repair it. And instead...
      However, they do not need to be scared to be copied: from what I understand and what I remember from the deleted video, the circuit was nothing special.
      Mark also mentioned that at least one part is nothing more than the implementation of the circuit suggested in the application note of the components. So nothing "exclusive" or secret.

    • @tyronenelson9124
      @tyronenelson9124 Місяць тому +15

      @@andrea.dalessandro So basically the manufacturer of that pre amp scrubbed off a load of letters and numbers from a couple of extremely common transistors.

    • @AstrosElectronicsLab
      @AstrosElectronicsLab Місяць тому

      @@tyronenelson9124 pretty much, yes.

    • @EyeMac-u8k
      @EyeMac-u8k Місяць тому

      Don't be dim . . . the guy played 25 full seconds of Elvis . . . why are you all LIBELLING Evans?????

  • @MarkoVanhanenVirallinen
    @MarkoVanhanenVirallinen Місяць тому +157

    After watching the repair video of the original £25k device, I was amazed at how poorly the device was assembled. Such an assembly would not withstand postal transport. This is how Mark revealed a dangerous product in terms of electrical safety that should really be taken away from consumers.

  • @darkstatehk
    @darkstatehk Місяць тому +324

    I'm quite sick and tired of this automated "guilty until proven innocent" assault that we all seem to be subjected to nowadays.

    • @ian-c.01
      @ian-c.01 Місяць тому +19

      Yep, big companies seem to be able to do whatever they like these days and they don't care how that affects individuals at all !
      I'm currently in dispute with Amazon over some bogus nonsense they dreamed up and they are refusing to communicate with me over it, makes my blood boil !

    • @mapgeek6
      @mapgeek6 Місяць тому +24

      The worst part is, guilty until proven innocent, but you have no means provided to actually prove your innocence, so you are always guilty even if you aren't.

    • @alanreynolds5985
      @alanreynolds5985 Місяць тому +14

      I thought that video was terrific. This is not the first time I’ve seen a manufacturer self destruct by thinking that flexing their muscles will distract people from the glaring exposure of their product.
      It only makes it 100 times worse because by taking down the video, they confirm everyone’s suspicions.
      Also you fixed what they couldn’t.
      I love your videos and your approach to fixing things.

    • @ObscuraDeCapra
      @ObscuraDeCapra Місяць тому +6

      You know nothing about how the system works or why it is how it is.
      The DMCA Safe Harbor provisions are what allows sites like UA-cam to eschew responsibility in the case of actual infringement. Standard process for a DMCA claim, anywhere, EVER, is to remove infringing materials and THEN investigate.
      You don't leave a turd in a pool in hopes that it's a Snickers. You fish it out, THEN determine if it's a Snickers. If it is, throw it back in the pool. Kids love Pool Snickers(TM).
      "but..." No, stop. Just learn how this shit actually works before whining.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому

      @@ObscuraDeCapra The DMCA itself is evil and wrong.

  • @jorge-_-reza
    @jorge-_-reza 10 днів тому +3

    Thanks to Louis Rossmann's repost of your video, I found your channel. I must say that, even if im not an electrical engineer, I'm absolutely hooked!
    The removal of your video has backfired tremendously since so many others have reposted it on their channels!!! Bravo 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼, now even more people have been exposed to your excellent work and work ethic.

  • @ChrisWadge
    @ChrisWadge Місяць тому +385

    The utter irony is that I'd have never known about Tom Evans Audio or your channel, Mark, if he hadn't copyright struck you. In any case, glad to be a new subscriber. Keep up the great work.

    • @thedave1771
      @thedave1771 Місяць тому +13

      Yeah. In the end, these idiots may have done Mark a solid. This video is genuinely hilarious too, especially the recreation for demo purposes.

    • @deadadam666
      @deadadam666 Місяць тому +9

      Barby Jo Streisand is that you !

    • @ChrisWadge
      @ChrisWadge Місяць тому +4

      @@deadadam666 They never learn.

    • @fuzzymachinist
      @fuzzymachinist Місяць тому +7

      How true. They tried to hide their overpriced gear, and wound up blacklisted and helped a good creator get some views, so win-win in the grand scheme, get rid of junk products and promote good educational content.

    • @TerryJonesPrinterRepairs
      @TerryJonesPrinterRepairs Місяць тому +2

      UA-cam Copyright striked not tom evans and as a content creator there is no ability to defend your position as it is done blindly. This is an example of why CREATORS MUST UNIONIZE.

  • @magikjoe3789
    @magikjoe3789 Місяць тому +604

    Someone didnt like you exposing their snake oil

    • @zyghom
      @zyghom Місяць тому +7

      AMEN

    • @rogervd666gamer
      @rogervd666gamer Місяць тому +18

      When Mark opened the lid of this totally overpriced underworld craftsmanship the snake's where bathing in oil 😂

    • @derkeksinator17
      @derkeksinator17 Місяць тому +15

      Not snake oil, per se, it's actually good. The circuits themselves aren't a secret either and fairly easy to design, not for the layperson, but for most, if not all, electrical communications engineers. Those will be aware of the difficulty of sourcing, selecting, and matching the parts as well, that's where a lot of time and money has to be spent. It's still way overpriced IMHO. The really shocking thing is the construction. Noone, and I mean NOONE, should be fine with putting their name on a product, built this poorly.
      If they consider this good craftmansship, which they obviously don't, they must be delusional. In this case they're just a greedy narcissistic AH.

    • @magikjoe3789
      @magikjoe3789 Місяць тому +5

      I own a valve phono pre-amp, nice and simple, a pair of ECC83s, a handful of resistors, capacitors, diodes and a simple power supply, built for me by my dearly departed friend Glenn Croft. It cost me £150 as I supplied the enclosure and transformer. It sounds sublime. I'm prepared to state that the Tom Evans Master Groove phono pre-amp is not 166 times better by any metric whatsoever.

    • @planespeaking
      @planespeaking Місяць тому +10

      Snake oil? In hifi products? That's a first 😂

  • @MrEtonmess
    @MrEtonmess Місяць тому +123

    This vid is crazy funny. Mock up of the handcrafted top secret amp is hilarious. Tom has scored a massive own goal.

    • @hamster9135
      @hamster9135 Місяць тому +20

      A mock-up? I couldn't tell the difference.

    • @LilMissMurder3409
      @LilMissMurder3409 Місяць тому +4

      @@hamster9135 Amateur. Clearly Mark used superior components, materials and manufacturing techniques in his recreation.

    • @bobs_ya_runkle
      @bobs_ya_runkle Місяць тому +2

      @@hamster9135 That made me laugh out loud. 🤣😂

    • @menotyou8369
      @menotyou8369 Місяць тому

      @@hamster9135 It's subtle, but there's two differences. The mock-up didn't have any solder . . . and it sounded better.

  • @Ossimann67
    @Ossimann67 Місяць тому +7

    Hello and greetings from Germany from an electronics engineer who also learnt his trade at a university over 35 years ago. You show in an entertaining way how in the past, as well as today, very expensive snake oil was produced and sold in the audio sector. Tom Evans' reaction indicates that he is obviously now realising that he has also produced a little snake oil or, as you have seen and shown, he has simply recognised very well how to create an expensive product using standard circuit designs, some of which are taken from manufacturers' operation manuals. However, I think it's very dubious to strike back via copyrights now and I believe that this action will be pretty bad for him for marketing reasons. So keep up the good work of repairing beautiful old and expensive things. Best regards, Jens

  • @Mr.Rude.
    @Mr.Rude. Місяць тому +152

    The linear phase galvanic isolating quantum cardboard shims are (were) a trade secret. Poor old Tom Evans.

    • @JasperJanssen
      @JasperJanssen Місяць тому +5

      *damping* shims.

    • @Mr.Rude.
      @Mr.Rude. Місяць тому +6

      @@JasperJanssen Proprietary hand crafted statement level damping shim technology, developed through countless of hours of listening.

    • @donmoore7785
      @donmoore7785 Місяць тому +3

      I had forgotten about those silly cardboard shims! Such a cluster.

    • @iatsd
      @iatsd Місяць тому +4

      To be fair, cardboard can be the right choice for shimming. In something priced like that I'd expect it to be museum archive grade acid stable cardboard that will last 1000 years, but the fact of it *being* cardboard isn't in and of itself a real problem IMO.
      No idea if it was, of course....

    • @Mr.Rude.
      @Mr.Rude. Місяць тому +14

      @@iatsd it's more likely cardboard from the bottoms of packets of fig rolls, because it sounds sweeter. This would also help to explain the limited production numbers, as Evans is only able to consume a finite amount of fig rolls per year.

  • @Dustycircuit
    @Dustycircuit Місяць тому +165

    What a pathetic move by the manufacturer.. (Tom Evans)

    • @AG-cg7lk
      @AG-cg7lk Місяць тому +14

      Manufacturer is quite a grand term for one bloke making DIY electronics in his garage 😂

    • @Dustycircuit
      @Dustycircuit Місяць тому +1

      @@AG-cg7lk Agreed! I did not want to risk getting demonetized by writing my true feelings.

    • @Britephartt
      @Britephartt Місяць тому +2

      Yes. They should be ashamed especially as they sent it to Mark in the first place.

    • @batmandestroys1978
      @batmandestroys1978 Місяць тому +7

      UA-cam are the ones at fault here, for siding with the manufacturer! Mark just repaired it, he did not try to make the same preamp!

    • @jtaylor8606
      @jtaylor8606 Місяць тому +2

      You mean Tom Evans?

  • @Adrian_Finn
    @Adrian_Finn Місяць тому +81

    Laughed very hard at this one, thanks mark. The irony here is the manufacturer has just made it ten times worse for themselves. Congratulations on the 100k subscribers, said early on this channel deserved it.

  • @McCormick9000
    @McCormick9000 Місяць тому +2

    I never heard of Tom Evans, neither I heard about you. But these news spread like a wildfire lately on tech-forums and I cant believe I just watched a 40 minute video about technology that I dont use and dont fully understand. Appreciated and very interesting! All the best to you!

  • @ItsAllGoneHorriblyPearShaped
    @ItsAllGoneHorriblyPearShaped Місяць тому +148

    I saw the original video, £25k for that... the designer should be reported under the trades decription act...

    • @thomasstone1363
      @thomasstone1363 Місяць тому +8

      The thing is, the preamp did do what it claimed to do - amplify the very weak signal from a moving coil stylus, without introducing extra noise and maintaining clarity and extension into the frequency extremes. Whether it did it better than less expensive moving coil preamps is open for debate

    • @derkeksinator17
      @derkeksinator17 Місяць тому +15

      @@thomasstone1363 it does better, that's out of the question. I wouldn't even have an issue with them selling it for that price, if the physical construction and layout had me drooling. Sure they slapped on a 400% idiot Tax, I expect that from companies in this niche, even after already applying a 200% niche tax, but the construction is just outrageously shoddy!

    • @petereade4936
      @petereade4936 Місяць тому +4

      Something is worth what people will pay for it. "Artwork" for instance is an example.

    • @hansjanssen3364
      @hansjanssen3364 Місяць тому +2

      Why? The Lithos power supply boards are what makes the unit special. These are Tom Evans-copyrighted designs, and from my recollection of the video, Mark took measures to protect those designs. He discussed the reverse engineered schema's for the main amplification sections, which in itself is not a copyright violation.
      Also, as I said elsewhere, you grossly underestimate the economics of small series production and mark-ups in the chain. The 25k is a retail price. Dealers take a hefty chunk of that. If this is truly hand-built (and there is no evidence to suggest it isn't) then another significant chunk of that money goes to components and time spent. Apparently that, the time and effort to build a brand, perform marketing activities etc. are things a manufacturer is not allowed to be compensated for, in your opinion.

    • @garethonthetube
      @garethonthetube Місяць тому +4

      @@derkeksinator17 It looks like a prototype, not engineered for mass production.

  • @wethermon
    @wethermon Місяць тому +38

    Oh yes Barbara Streisand effect at it's finest 😂.
    This is the reason I no longer give a shit about "audiophile" brands.
    BTW that copyright strike is pure bullying. Yt really needs to fix this BS.
    Much love mate.

  • @paulb4661
    @paulb4661 Місяць тому +36

    British humor at its finest. Splendid work, Mark. You are the real Master of the Groove!

  • @StealthParrot
    @StealthParrot Місяць тому +11

    I saw your video posted by another user and found it fascinating for a number of reasons. First of all, I learned several great tricks I hadn't seen before such as plugging in the shorted device board and watching the overheating component using a flir camera, heating a screwdriver to melt a slot into the broken screw in the standoff, repairing the broken cover, and some great soldering techniques. I found your whole approach to troubleshooting exceptionally efficient and well explained. As for the copyright strike, I truly don't get this at all. With 124,000 subscribers (+1 more) essentially you are exposing this product to a huge number of people who otherwise would never have heard of this manufacturer. Clearly these are being hand built judging by the workmanship, so what is the point ... are they ashamed of their work, the price, the right to repair? Watching the video, honestly I was mostly captivated by the troubleshooting and repair than the actual product. It could have been any electronics equipment really. Chances are this manufacturer does not have deep pockets, it's not like they are Sony or something, so I wouldn't get to concerned about it all. Glad to be a new subscriber.

    • @kirkhamandy
      @kirkhamandy Місяць тому +1

      Pockets not as deep as Sony maybe, but the serial number was 58, so up to the time that unit was sold, he'd earned 58 * £25,000 as a cool £1.45 million. So deeper pockets than me, that's for sure.

    • @StealthParrot
      @StealthParrot Місяць тому

      @@kirkhamandy No, there is no way he is making 100% profit on each sale, that's just not realistic. 100% markup maybe but definitely not profit. You have material, labour, overhead, dealer costs. My point really was more to do with the irony of why a small manufacturer would basically thumb their nose at the exposure to a large group of people who otherwise have likely never heard of them. I would be very surprised if they go beyond a cease and desist letter, if that.

    • @kirkhamandy
      @kirkhamandy Місяць тому +1

      @@StealthParrot, I take everything you said onboard, except "material and labour." That pre-amp's design spared every expense on materials and was built by a lad in a shed. 😂

    • @StealthParrot
      @StealthParrot Місяць тому +1

      @@kirkhamandy Haha, yeah no argument from me on that 🙂

  • @TennSeven
    @TennSeven Місяць тому +53

    I very much enjoyed that video and, as an intellectual property attorney, in my opinion there was absolutely nothing infringing in there. UA-cam is terrible for the way it handles copyright claims.

  • @rupertkingsley
    @rupertkingsley Місяць тому +187

    I think it’s pure embarrassment about the awful construction and soldering. I bet some owners are furious 😂

    • @d64d64
      @d64d64 Місяць тому +45

      A few might be, but when someone is so far down the hifi rabbit hole they pay 25k for a phono preamp, there's usually nothing that can bring them back to their senses. They will defend the designer and manufacturer like a cultist defends their prophet.

    • @charliea697
      @charliea697 Місяць тому +7

      Spot on

    • @jboard3094
      @jboard3094 Місяць тому

      @@d64d64 Like Beatles cultists who can't accept that there were ghost writers and session players, they even admitted they couldn't read music or play very well but you get some dreadful things said to you when you speak the truth about the cinderella story.

    • @dazasc3994
      @dazasc3994 Місяць тому +8

      @@d64d64 IDK man, look at Yamaha and their ultra high end stuff, i'd say that gear is truly worth spending the money on if you can afford it. It's the one man in a shed type companies that seem to take the piss.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +2

      @@d64d64 True, but the act of having a go at Mark, may well get their goat..

  • @MazeFrame
    @MazeFrame Місяць тому +177

    Time to give Louis Rossmann a call, I'd say. Streisand effect and all that jazz.

    • @Tompie01
      @Tompie01 Місяць тому +33

      I would pay to see Louis have a go at this manufacturer :)

    • @Mr_Meowingtons
      @Mr_Meowingtons Місяць тому +15

      @@Tompie01 OMG That shit would be EPIC!!!!

    • @joejoejoejoejoejoe4391
      @joejoejoejoejoejoe4391 Місяць тому +24

      The fact that Streisand has an effect named after her, to that people keep googling it to find out what it means must be INCREDIBLY annoying, it's like a double Streisand effect.

    • @ccllvn
      @ccllvn Місяць тому +4

      lol

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому

      @@joejoejoejoejoejoe4391 Yes, and her cliff top house is amazing, well worth finding!

  • @cowasakiElectronics
    @cowasakiElectronics 5 днів тому +2

    It's properly backfired. I've seen your subscribers increase by 50K :)

  • @vprwave
    @vprwave Місяць тому +116

    You have the best humour, thanks for the laugh! Oh, and congratulations for the first 💯 k!

  • @ainteasybeingwheezy
    @ainteasybeingwheezy Місяць тому +57

    Sounds like somebody at the company saw their backside either with you being able to repair it or showing that it has around £30 worth of parts inside it ! CONGRATULATIONS ON THE PLAY BUTTON MARK

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +10

      £30.10 if you include the cardboard shims..

    • @eddjordan2399
      @eddjordan2399 Місяць тому

      @@G-ra-ha-m well its got 180 quids worth of op amps in it for a start and the fact that he would have had to match them all means for one unit you might be looking at 500 quids worth of op amps to get the right amount also all that testing time etc the real problem is the way he struck marks video and was rude to him at the same time thats not on.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +2

      @@eddjordan2399 Matching? You get a row of boxes, the measure each and put then in the relevant box. All sorted and graded. Then you pull 4 from a box to make a unit. It's not difficult or expensive.

  • @MichaelBritt23
    @MichaelBritt23 Місяць тому +55

    Obviously the opening it up and exposing how it's built was the determining factor. It showed how shoddy the parts were inside. It showed how it was a scam to anyone who purchased it.

    • @donmoore7785
      @donmoore7785 Місяць тому +1

      There are a few possibilities. I think it may be more the case that Mark essentially reverse engineered the design - revealing that the "secret" to its noise figures has been known for decades.

  • @AnthonyUK100
    @AnthonyUK100 Місяць тому +4

    i have become addicted to your channel. im from north Israel. "Learnt" electronics at school 50 years ago. 2 nights ago got home to my home studio and the 16 ch mixer (20 years old) stopped functioning. took it apart, the psu the Electrolytic Capacitors had gone. checked the transistors-ok and the the resistors. went to a local electronic parts shop, the 4 capcitors cost a few pounds (2 were bad but decided to replace also the other two. checked the voltage and connected the socket to the mixer all working better then before . The hardest part is the disassembly . Thanks Mark you're a Pro and an inspiration.

  • @flickerblip9044
    @flickerblip9044 Місяць тому +49

    I own a business selling audio kits. I think the manufacturer didn't want people seeing how crappie the thing was put together. You give it to him Mark!

    • @chucklemken8639
      @chucklemken8639 Місяць тому +5

      Link to your kits, please?

    • @ke0kie
      @ke0kie Місяць тому

      agreed, very obvious

    • @flickerblip9044
      @flickerblip9044 Місяць тому

      @@chucklemken8639 not here for that

    • @redolgreg
      @redolgreg Місяць тому

      But why send it to him?

    • @K2teknik.
      @K2teknik. Місяць тому

      @@redolgreg That is a damn good question, if I got it right them the manufacture (Tom Evans) send this device to Mark with a statement that Mark could not repair it, that sound odd in some way, so either Tom Evans is a raving lunatic or he really believed that this unit was beyond repair which really puts Tom's electronics skills to the test, or he was just drunk and not in control of what he was doing that day.
      There must be more to that story between Mark and Tom?

  • @laurilink7512
    @laurilink7512 Місяць тому +55

    This is a excellent example of how a manufacturer can ruin their reputation. I also saw that previous video and I don't understand how this reputation could have arisen at all for such work.

    • @Rotwold
      @Rotwold Місяць тому +4

      And trying to censor the video will only make it worse. His circuit design and theory might hold some value to Hi-Fi enthusiasts, but, his mechanical design sucks. And it would've been easier for him to hire a junior mech eng. to develop a new mounting assembly. Even I could probably create a better method for routing the wiring. Mounting the PC boards on the top and bottom of a mounting plate that is then mounted to the chassi would make pretty much remove of the problems with his design. He made the assembly overcomplicated and janky by only focusing on sanding numbers off 😅

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +2

      @@Rotwold He simply needed one PCB to lay out each channel. Epic failure.

  • @MrDan144
    @MrDan144 Місяць тому +38

    "Its me drawing it. Look! There's MY arm" hahahaha. Brilliant as usual Mark.

  • @Spaniard47
    @Spaniard47 Місяць тому +4

    Here from Louis Rossmann, and thrilled to say Mend-it Mark is one of few channels that have earned my subscription after viewing a single video.

  • @xjet
    @xjet Місяць тому +60

    Time for..... *THE STREISAND EFFECT* Go to it boys!

  • @sayeager5559
    @sayeager5559 Місяць тому +30

    I don't even own a soldering iron and believe this to be one of the best channels on YT!

  • @symonbuck3911
    @symonbuck3911 Місяць тому +79

    As a builder and repairer of audio amplifiers and pre-amps for some 50 years now I admire Mark's skills and tenacity (and his workshop!). Even though the Tom Evans Pre-amp is built using sound electronic theory I question the use of tantalum capacitors. They are one of the most unreliable components I have found in hi-fi equipment. I wouldn't touch them with a barge pole. Keep up the good work.

    • @Paxmax
      @Paxmax Місяць тому +6

      They sometimes try to set the board on fire! 😂 Well, "the problem" could be solved by a hypothetical 4 year old in my case!
      Me: "So, Andrew, what is the problem here you think"
      Andrew(4): "The smoke, the smell... and the small fire at the corner"
      Me: "That's right!" 😂

    • @g0fvt
      @g0fvt Місяць тому +3

      I have used tantalum capacitors with varying results and would be interested in the observations by others. I have had trouble where they may be subject to high inrush current (ie across a power supply rail) but great results when used for example used for emitter decoupler in a small signal circuit where current is very limited. In my life I have seen too many burnt ones though!

    • @jeffc2190
      @jeffc2190 Місяць тому +5

      @@g0fvt I've serviced thousands of video game PCB's from the 80's and 90's that have tens and sometimes up to 100 or more tantalum caps on each board. These are high current situations and I've seen only a handful of bad tantalums spanning 3 decades of work. They do fail, just as much as any other component. The problem is they usually fail short, and take out other components, instead of failing open. I'm not sure if there is a better component that could have been used in this device or not, I'm not an audiophile. If it works, then use it 😃

    • @g0fvt
      @g0fvt Місяць тому +2

      @@jeffc2190 thank you for your input, yes they do usually fail shorted, I seem to have seen a disproportionate number of failures. They are usually selected for their low series inductance, hence often used on the 5v logic rails.

    • @andyhowlett2231
      @andyhowlett2231 Місяць тому +2

      He probably bought them in bulk about 30 years ago before they all started going pop.

  • @gregorymccoy6797
    @gregorymccoy6797 13 днів тому

    It was a great repair video. I was shocked at how shoddy the construction of that amplifier is. Really takes gall to sell it for that much money.

  • @vdivanov
    @vdivanov Місяць тому +25

    The saying "You can't fix stupid" aptly applies here.
    There's another saying for UA-cam to heed, "Don't bite the Mark that feeds you."

    • @MendItMark
      @MendItMark  Місяць тому +2

      Thanks vdivanov, thats very kind of you.

  • @optimath466
    @optimath466 Місяць тому +21

    I watched the origin vid (I watch all of Mark's videos). The wood mock up with the the tant caps dumped on it had me LMAO. So funny for those of us that saw the home built, first pre-amp project design/quality of the actual device. Good on ya, Mark!

  • @vencibushy
    @vencibushy Місяць тому +29

    This is a clear abuse of the copyright system. There must be a way to fight this. I hope Louis Rossmann of Dave from EEVBlog pick this story up.

    • @EyeMac-u8k
      @EyeMac-u8k Місяць тому

      Don't be lame and quit following dim bulbs like clickbaiters like Rossmann . . . the guy played 25 full seconds of Elvis . . . why are you all LIBELLING Evans?????

  • @elbertli2963
    @elbertli2963 15 днів тому +2

    I had enjoyed your videos and appreciate your effort to reverse engineering the circuitry. The copyright is loads of nonsense. I can’t understand why the greedy people so call manufacturer put to you other than try to make more money to repair that unit themselves. Thanks so much for all the videos you put out.

  • @looseonthemoose
    @looseonthemoose Місяць тому +30

    Blatant abuse of the copyright system. Please counter it once you get in touch with UA-cam.
    Congrats on the play button Mark. Your channel and content are top notch.

  • @AudiophileStooge
    @AudiophileStooge Місяць тому +42

    I'm glad I got to see it before it was taken down.

    • @royalaxe
      @royalaxe Місяць тому

      same here, i was trying throughout the video to work out how the machine gave you a handjob every 5 minutes to justify its price tag. i never did work it out. :P

    • @snoopythecat3741
      @snoopythecat3741 Місяць тому

      Yes, I saw it to, terrible machine for 25k. Removed IC identification ........... But I learned a lot from the vid.

  • @JohnPine13
    @JohnPine13 Місяць тому +26

    Sometimes...YT SUX! :(
    Retired Honeywell engineer here...love your vids!
    Mark congrats on 100k subs...I'm one!

  • @msmith2961
    @msmith2961 17 днів тому +2

    The Streisand effect is strong with this one.
    Poor form for Tom Evans to have (allegedly) abused the copyright system to try to hide the quality of his product from the world.
    But the tables have turned from all the negative publicity that has generated, and how many more eyeballs have gazed upon that original video that maybe would never had done.

  • @mapgeek6
    @mapgeek6 Місяць тому +58

    I'm glad I got to see the video before the manufacturer's embarrassment at overcharging for questionable construction caused them to react poorly.

    • @tsd550
      @tsd550 Місяць тому +3

      Me too!!

    • @justins21482
      @justins21482 Місяць тому +1

      @@tsd550 me three

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому +2

      I want to see it again, did anyone take a copy?

    • @billedifier8584
      @billedifier8584 Місяць тому

      @@G-ra-ha-m Surely Mark would have have made a copy? He could post it on that site that rhymes with apple crumble.

    • @G-ra-ha-m
      @G-ra-ha-m Місяць тому

      @@billedifier8584 I hope he will!!

  • @veerbhogyavasundhra6056
    @veerbhogyavasundhra6056 Місяць тому +86

    We are with you don't back off...
    Love from India

  • @TimDyb
    @TimDyb Місяць тому +28

    BRAVO for receiving the UA-cam plaque!!!🎉

  • @Dutch-Viper
    @Dutch-Viper 9 годин тому +1

    The most beautiful thing is all the support and reuploads! Just keep going Mark!

  • @markhearsey4294
    @markhearsey4294 Місяць тому +17

    Get some consumables on me… Love the content…👍🏻

    • @MendItMark
      @MendItMark  Місяць тому +3

      Cheers Mark!

    • @AnalogDude_
      @AnalogDude_ Місяць тому

      @@MendItMark I need to get my Kenwood Ka-501 fixed someday, i mistreated it as kid a bit.
      It does work, but one channel turns on later and noise can be heard.

  • @wyldfiregames
    @wyldfiregames Місяць тому +13

    That video was my first one I ever watched of yours and it caused me to subscribe to your channel. Shame on Tom Evans for trying to bully you, especially when he is the one that said you couldn't fix it.

  • @OperationNorthwoods
    @OperationNorthwoods Місяць тому +73

    If the manufacturer; the very entity that sent the unit to you for repair, is who filed the copyright complaint against you, they need to be publicly ratted out, shamed, and financially penalized.

    • @luviskol
      @luviskol Місяць тому +8

      If that was the case and they know that mark does have a you tube channel, should have insisted on a NDA before purchasing his services
      Otherwise it's just fair comment about something in the public domain

    • @justins21482
      @justins21482 Місяць тому +1

      Or "united healthcare'd" 🤣

    • @CameraTim-DAMMITDOTcom
      @CameraTim-DAMMITDOTcom Місяць тому +4

      Sounds like a deliberate act by them from the very start. What's next, a copyright claim because the english language was used to describe a circuit? There's nothing new under the sun regarding basic amplifier design (and that's all it was, BASIC).

    • @jimfarrell4635
      @jimfarrell4635 Місяць тому +2

      The manufacturer sent it to Mark on the instruction of the owner, not because they wanted to. Also they were convinced no mere UA-cam engineer could fix it. They had quoted £6000.

    • @CameraTim-DAMMITDOTcom
      @CameraTim-DAMMITDOTcom Місяць тому +2

      @@jimfarrell4635 So... yet another incident of arrogance against the customer by the manufacturer. Rip them off in sales, rip them off in after-sales service.
      Manufacturers have always been dumb with their attempts to stop someone understanding how they built something, to make it unrepairable and try to stop someone cloning their product. Any half-skilled tech could figure out what they'd done, not that they'd done anything spectacular. A bunch of power supplies and op-amps clustered together is little more than a breadboard design shoved in a box, and certainly not worthy of the pricetag.
      If they'd designed an amp from discrete components I might believe they'd really designed it. But to (so badly) put together something from bog standard ICs in a rather uninventive manner...

  • @JAF1N
    @JAF1N Місяць тому +1

    The genius himself hard at work. Now let’s see, where’s the on switch 🐐🐐🐐🐐 Mark, may your video be vindicated. Google really need to provide better information to content producers and perhaps even an innocent until guilty system.

  • @FlyingSi
    @FlyingSi Місяць тому +27

    This, Mark, is a brilliant way of dealing with these awful rip off merchants. £25k for a GCSE electronics project. Look - the emperor has no clothe... *COPYRIGHT STRIKE*

  • @thereeven
    @thereeven Місяць тому +19

    So, I watched the whole video before it was taken down. I didn't even know this brand existed but you can be sure that now that they started this crap, knowing how they deal with criticism, I'll never forget then. Ever. I'll remember to pound them on every forum, every conversation, everywhere, and I'm totally sure I'm far from the only one. And you got one more subscriber, Mark.

  • @bankacihb
    @bankacihb Місяць тому +8

    "The king is naked". The truth is that it is not loved anywhere in the world. But we love you Mark, keep it up.👍

  • @snaredude56
    @snaredude56 Місяць тому +2

    I have watched your channel before, but now I have subscribed to help support what you do. This situation is wrong and I suspect in the long run, the "manufacturer" of that device will regret the Streisand effect that he has launched upon himself.

  • @Nimboid-20
    @Nimboid-20 Місяць тому +61

    Found a link to the original video. If you click it, UA-cam is happy to let you know: "Video unavailable. This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by Tom Evans"

    • @andymerrett
      @andymerrett Місяць тому +5

      It also says this on any website which has embedded the video :)

  • @GeordieAmanda
    @GeordieAmanda Місяць тому +17

    There is only one person that will have wanted that video taken down and we all know who that is. Shame on him, but well done on your subscriber numbers Mark. Keep up the good work :)

  • @AnonymousEuropeanDriver
    @AnonymousEuropeanDriver Місяць тому +17

    This video is hilarious! I think someone is a little sensitive about having their nonsense exposed. Well done Mark we are all behind you 100%.

  • @fredio54
    @fredio54 Місяць тому +4

    Just watched your video on Louis's channel :-) superb job, above and beyond repair with all the refinishing etc. A true craftsman.

  • @radducku
    @radducku Місяць тому +51

    unbelievable!...Don't give up Mark, we stand by you!

  • @tony359
    @tony359 Місяць тому +24

    I did watch that video and you didn't do anything wrong. Shame on the manufacturer indeed, they don't understand that by doing that they're just shooting in their feet. Congrats for the 100K, very well deserved!!

    • @gerrard4215
      @gerrard4215 Місяць тому

      Tom Adam's pathetic actions will only make matters worse. Just Google "tom evans mastergroove" to see how far details of his abysmal build quality has spread.
      The emperor has been shown to be naked 😄

  • @Scout_Wireless
    @Scout_Wireless Місяць тому +28

    Too bad Mark, that was a great video and you did great work on the repair, I was quite astonished on how well the lid came out after gluing and polishing! What a shame.

  • @hpd385tannoylover2
    @hpd385tannoylover2 9 днів тому

    Now I have to add; I had never heard of Mark or this channel. I watch many electronics repair channels, or I did until I found this, thanks to LR.
    I have been binging on Mark's back catalogue, and now have to pace myself so I don't run out. It has been an interesting journey, watching Mark's past three or so years condensed down to a month. What's astonishing is how little he has changed as his subs grow. I notice mainly a growth in his confidence, not in his abilities which speak for themselves, but with his audience. We now see a little more of Mark, when he subtly jokes with us, but the core is a bloke who is totally passionate about what he does and is simply delighted to share it with us.
    I don't watch Mark because he is a master technician ( he clearly is ), as there are plenty of them all over YT, along with many who are not. I watch him as he humbly takes us on the journey, admitting his mistakes, acknowledging his rare failures, and just being a decent, honest bloke who you might meet at a pub with a dart in his hand. I dunno if Mark goes to pubs at all, I am just saying he is an unassuming genius who deserves far more subs than the pretentious people who actually get them.
    I can never do what Mark does, as much as I would love to. I just love his channel, and wish there were more like it. I thank Mr Rossman and a certain Welshman for raising the awareness of Mend It Mark.

  • @funkyuk1
    @funkyuk1 Місяць тому +24

    Hold on. I remember watching the original video and you saying something along the lines of the customer said you wouldn’t be able to repair it, assuming that you may have issues getting support/ schematics because it was an ‘artisanal’ product. I didn’t realise it was sent by the ‘artisan’ (or something) as some sort of gauntlet throw-down. If they can’t even package their goods safely for shipping what hope do we have for the quality of their cardboard shimmed product???
    Congrats on your UA-cam plaque. Hopefully there’s room on the wall to display along with your swimming certificates 😁.
    Once again, many thanks for the excellent videos Mark, keep it up fella

    • @antronargaiv3283
      @antronargaiv3283 Місяць тому +4

      When I build something and it turns out to have a noticeable flaw, the wife and I refer to it as "artisinal". Numbers sanded off the components is a dead giveaway. The company I used to work for, marked their components only with their internal part numbers. Of course, they were all standard parts, ordered from the manufacturer with custom markings. This was done *solely* to prevent third parties from servicing the boards. Odd that the manufacturer should have sent it to you for repair...they were obviously aware of your UA-cam channel. What did they think would happen?

    • @PedroBorgesNH
      @PedroBorgesNH Місяць тому

      ​@@antronargaiv3283 Asus do this in motherboards, graphics cards and possibly other products too. They have their own markings on ICs to mess with people but they're just that, remarking a of common ICs on the market. I think the only goal is to make it difficult to get replacement components so people just buy a new one instead

    • @CaptainRon1913
      @CaptainRon1913 Місяць тому +2

      @@antronargaiv3283 The only way I can think of that happening, ie: manufacturer sending it to Mark is, The customer must have sent the amp to the manufacturer, the manufacturer said it can't be fixed and will have to send it back. The customer must have said, ship it to Mark instead of me.

  • @kyle8952
    @kyle8952 Місяць тому +17

    You were exceedingly kind and polite about this utter pile of shite, and he did this to you anyway.

    • @scotttait2197
      @scotttait2197 Місяць тому

      Too generous on your osrty calling it q pile if shite .... far too kind

  • @martinpasta555
    @martinpasta555 Місяць тому +15

    Fortunately I've seen the original video and and was really shocked what could one try to sell for that money. Also wiping off the names of the components is just really pure and insecure. Good and reasonable manufacturers rather show "inside" pictures of their products that you can appreciate their craftsmanship. Good lesson about to be careful and know what you are buying and spending money for. Many thanks Mark for your great educating and entertaining videos. Keep going.

    • @paulf3353
      @paulf3353 Місяць тому

      I haven't seen the original video unfortunately, who is the manufacturer?

    • @freecycling6687
      @freecycling6687 Місяць тому

      Not just insecure, but outright fraud and deception. "Hand matched, hand crafted, only 10 a year, blah blah blah blah". Nope. Just decent off-the-shelf components using the reference designs.

    • @paulf3353
      @paulf3353 Місяць тому

      @@freecycling6687 I've being checking a lot of high-end stuff in last 20y, I must say there are mainly 2 types:
      1. Re-used quality Japanese/asian electronics in very flashy case
      2. Completely DIY crap which marked as hand made by some voodoo audio cultist engineers

    • @paulb4661
      @paulb4661 Місяць тому

      ​@@paulf3353 Tom Evans, Mastergroove MC pre-amplifier, full video has been uploaded to ody see by some unresponsible individual.

    • @paulb4661
      @paulb4661 Місяць тому

      ​@@freecycling6687The line praising meticulous design, indistinguishable fro alien technology got me.

  • @chowd.a.d.8309
    @chowd.a.d.8309 Місяць тому +3

    Well done Mark. A sweater I bought was picking up static electricity. So, I returned it to the store. They gave me another one free of charge.

  • @David_K_Booth
    @David_K_Booth Місяць тому +4

    Good luck, Mark.

  • @lohikarhu734
    @lohikarhu734 Місяць тому +57

    Rossmann did a nice one on your subject... Nice turn of phrase:"I'm an "audiophile", not an "audiofool!"

  • @Aga4ga
    @Aga4ga Місяць тому +6

    3:20 “wasn’t those ones, it was these ones”. Brilliant 😂

  • @RegularOldDan
    @RegularOldDan Місяць тому +3

    I came here from Louis' channel and I just wanted to say I wish you the best and hope this mess can be sorted in some way.
    Congratulations on the 100k mark. You surely deserve it.

  • @ralphalder14
    @ralphalder14 Місяць тому +10

    Congratulations on the award! As others have said, the manufacturer is probably embarrassed by your previous video showing how shoddy the build quality is for £25k.

  • @MikeSpille
    @MikeSpille Місяць тому +32

    Have a cuppa on me and good luck against the bully!

  • @Jason_playz-u4s
    @Jason_playz-u4s Місяць тому +27

    Hahaha. Mark serving Mr 'Genius' Evans some top shelf subliminals 😂.

  • @AnWe79
    @AnWe79 Місяць тому +1

    Rossman sent me, hat's off, you did very high quality work on less than quality gear. Way more than it deserved in hindsight, but you wouldn't have known that then.