hang on. it's not all "a"s I thought I was singing wrong bars 51 and 53 where the F at? And 56 and 57 this doesn't sound right. there should be a flat and a sharp.
It may depend on the version you are singing. In some editions, like for the Rutter edited version, m. 51 & 53 are correctly sung. Also in the Rutter edited version, m. 55- through the first note of m. 59, the altos stay on the same pitch (though it’s first notated as an e#, then f-natural).
Ok, looking at what’s showing in the “video,” I see the Fs you are talking about-interesting, because the version I have, it’s written as As, just as the vocalist songs it.
Such ungrateful comments - I found this helpful - Thank you!
I agree with you, Catherine. It did help me and I think her voice is beautiful, with a dark color, dramatic. ❤
The music is the Schirmer edition and the vocalist is the Rutter edition.
Thank you for giving this comment...it makes my search faster.
Thank you, I was trying to work out what was happening
Merci
3:30 (bar 48/49) to skip solos
The demonstration sang wrong in Bar 51, 53.
I agree!
@@1957fongyuan One is the Schirmer edition the other is the Rutter edition
@@suea6245 Thank you for reply！
hang on. it's not all "a"s I thought I was singing wrong bars 51 and 53 where the F at? And 56 and 57 this doesn't sound right. there should be a flat and a sharp.
It may depend on the version you are singing. In some editions, like for the Rutter edited version, m. 51 & 53 are correctly sung. Also in the Rutter edited version, m. 55- through the first note of m. 59, the altos stay on the same pitch (though it’s first notated as an e#, then f-natural).
Ok, looking at what’s showing in the “video,” I see the Fs you are talking about-interesting, because the version I have, it’s written as As, just as the vocalist songs it.
Does anyone else find this alto singing voice unbearable?
Yes! Awful, too slow and the tremolo is not needed in a Requiem