THE BIG DEBATE | Madinah Book vs Bayna Yadayk | You can't compare a syllabus to a book
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 вер 2024
- I have not mentioned every pro and con of each syllabus, but the main objective of the video were 2:
1) You can't compare a syllabus to a book! That isn't fair nor is it justice. One can and should only make a comparison when it is the whole Madinah syllabus being compared to Al-Arabiyatu Bayna Yadayk
2) All syllabuses have their pros and cons, the most important issue is finding a teacher, remaining consistent and finishing it!
جزاك اللهُ خيرا
We can agree to disagree!
آمين وإياكم حبيبي
What does this statement mean?
I've heard it so many times
🤔
@@AANaeem
He basically just agrees not to argue about the difference of opinion.
@@AANaeem the shaykh supports Bayna Yadayk over Madina that's why he said this, lol
This knowledge is actually utmost important to know before starting to study Arabic.
I myself studied the first two books of the Medina Method with a teacher without any complementary books. Halfway through I wanted to test my knowledge in Arabic and that is when I found out what you are sharing now. I then started complementing the medina books with the Arabiya beyna yadayk series by myself. After finishing the second book of the medina method i decided to move over to the Arabiya series since it is a full program and thus focussing on all the aspects of the language.
From my experience if you have no acces to the full syllabus of the medina method you should always chose Arabiya beyna yedeyk. You will learn all aspects of the language.
And Allah knows best
Most important thing is finding a teacher finish the series, stick to the teacher, have patience and finish of the book, Finishing the book / series lies the benefit
The best thing is to find competent teacher) and with him you can learn any book
I studied both alongside each other (2 day Medina 2 day Al Arrabiya):
Medina for new words and grammar
Al Arrabiya for practicality and conversation!
Did you self study?
@@SalmaiChicken no with Sheikh from Egypt!
@@AwaisKhan-oy8rp Did you complete all 3 of the medina and bayna yadayk books ?
How far have you gone?
To me, the ONLY ONE ISSUE regarding Madinah books is that AFTER 8 LESSONS there are taught maybe four verbs only which is inefficient cos they should teach at least 3 to 4 verbs per each lesson.
You're reffering to only the grammar book mainly. We were taught the speaking and reading books simultaneously
Not ONE of them but both for Arabic learners and I’m saying this as a learner from central Europe who had nothing to do ever with Arabic language. Right now I’ve got both of them and believe that they must be used both for effective learning.
Good but then that becomes really long for a beginner learner.
Fair argument…but team Madinah دائما 🫢
I'm doing both إن شاء الله
I finished Madinah Bks (fr not understanding Arabic at all beside can read alQ) by watching Video Bro Asif fr Toronto Canada. Now Im at Bk 3 Baina yadaik.
And I still feel that Madina Bk is the best + very structured. It goes thro grammar rules Lesson by Lesson. Beside the main text bk.. the writer provides .. Key Bks in English that explain details on Rules covered in each Lesson.
While for Bayna Yadaik .. it goes straight into Texts & Conversation with difficult but usefull day to day Vocab while its explanations on Grammar Rules are very random.
Did you have the ability to speak Arabic fluently post studying the three Madhinah books.
In the marakiz in egypt we dont only study arabiyyah bayna yadayk we have side books like ajroomiyah(nawh) sarf and balagha
In Madinah students can also study these books outside such as in Al-Masjid An-Nabawi
Which balagh do you study
@@a.m5892 نحو-أجرومية + متتمة أجرومية + قطر الندى
صرف- صرف الكافي
بلاغة- كتاب خاص للمركز
@@daudajawara6963 what is the markz name
@@a.m5892 مركز العالمي
Very interesting!
بارك الله فيك
Jazakhallah khayran ustadh this was very beneficial
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Ustaaz please share the link or website where to purchase that French madina series
Ustadh is showing us some supplementary books here, What about the Madinah Arabic Reader books? are they of any benefit?
Where can I purchase the complimentary books for the medina course
Dear Respectful Scholar or Sir or sheikh
You initially lost your point of view at Time stamp 9 :14 that Marina book primarily focus on grammar while other book yadak is having vocabulary as well
Please tell me if language or linguistic lost grammar how would I talk if I have sea of vocabulary if I don't make a simple Sentence weather in Nounimal or verbal sentecnce
Please Sheikh back the great contribution of Marina Book Authorand keep in put in brain and that theory that Arabic Authors can't learn Arabic to. Non Arabic
And only the non Arabic will better learn to non Arabic
I my self stands as witness
Thanks akot
بارك الله فيكم
I mentioned there are other books in the curriculum too which focus on vocab, speaking, comprehension etc. To make it a fair comparison please compare a curriculum to a curriculum and not a curriculum to a book. I know only one famous madinah book has been printed in english which makes everyone think it's the whole syllabus. That is completely wrong.
Anyways, my conclusion is that it doesn't matter which curriculum you choose, as I've taught both. The main thing is that you start one with a teacher and finish it. Too many students waste time arguing about which curriculum is better and less time actually studying it. Wallahu Alam.
please tell me the name of the other books that you mentioned
Assalam Alaikum. Any chance you'll teach the whole series and put it on youtube?
I do teach it and so far completed the first two semesters. Scan the QR code on the poster to sign up.
@@MuhammadHuzaifah Baarak Allah feek, where can I find the poster?
As salaam Alaikum Ustadh
Which poster is this?
Do you teach online as I'm in another city and there only seems to be a poster for in class lessons?
I'm looking to study the supplemented side books for Madinah Book 1 or Madinah Book 2 in shaa Allah.
@@crillin570 on my Instagram or telegram
@@LatinowolofKID yes it's online also 👆
Can't we learn it both?
Are Madinah reader books a good alternative to the Side books?
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته يا أستاذ. Please put the link where to purchase these complete set Please please please
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
salafibookstore.com/product/madinah-arabic-curriculum-set-of-4-books/
Or try here:
darmakkah.co.uk/product/methode-medine-en-arabe-tome-1-editions-al-hadith-livre-en-arabe-pour-apprentissage-langue-arabe/
@@MuhammadHuzaifah do those books have translation in Them or is everything in arabic but you go through it with a teacher? Barakallahu fikum
@@user-ry9ro3mw9i everything in arabic
@@MuhammadHuzaifah السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Ustadh, is the arabic lessons going to be publicly be posted on youtube or is it only for those who signed up that get the videos?
@@user-gl2wf6ex6k وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته. On for those who sign up
Study First 2 Medina Books get a Dictionary Than Study Book 3.
which dictionary
@@pointplayzyt2144 Taj al aroos Hans Wehr or lisan al arab.
@@sheheryar3978 Thanks, but how do ik which words to get how much to get and when i get them what to do aftert memorized
لا یقابل ای شیء من غیر المدینة المدینة