Origin of the Creaking (Lore Theory)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 140

  • @Smile-lores
    @Smile-lores 2 місяці тому +119

    enderman: attacks if you look at it
    creaking: attacks if you don't look at it
    warden: attacks if you're too loud
    friend: attacks if you're too quiet

    • @mahmudhussain3989
      @mahmudhussain3989 2 місяці тому +10

      yeah just imagine a mob with these qualities

    • @Jupiterwupiter
      @Jupiterwupiter 2 місяці тому

      @@mahmudhussain3989 you’d be dead man. When you encounter it.

    • @jc_art_
      @jc_art_ Місяць тому +5

      ​@@mahmudhussain3989 a minecraft monster with all four would be, most of them, actually! A zombie for example, attacks regardless of if youre looking or not looking, quiet or loud.

    • @Flesh-wl7bb
      @Flesh-wl7bb Місяць тому +1

      ​@@jc_art_ what about a mob who stands still until loud movment or prolonged eye contact?

    • @jc_art_
      @jc_art_ Місяць тому +1

      @@Flesh-wl7bb what would constitute "loud movement" exactly? Like, is it everything besides sneaking? If so then this would just be another skulk mob most likely. Something that would become active if you're seen by it too much, or you look at it for too long, would fit in with the stealth idea of the ancient city. I imagine them acting like security cameras, something that would be on the same level as the skulk sensors, just focusing on sight over sound. I dont see this being a mob though, maybe just a living block like the creaking heart or shrieker.

  • @Magicwaterz
    @Magicwaterz 2 місяці тому +96

    Finally! Someone pointed out about the garden part of the biome name. I hear people saying to rename it into a forest. But naming it a garden gives implications that someone planted these.
    My take is that it was the Illagers that planted it until something went wrong, which they abandoned the garden entirely, and are scared of the Creaking.

    • @Smug_K
      @Smug_K 2 місяці тому

      But that automatically removes the implication that it’s a dark oak forest Variation why are the trees the same if it’s planted

    • @Magicwaterz
      @Magicwaterz 2 місяці тому +4

      @@Smug_K It doesn't since this biome only generates beside the Dark Forest, nowhere else.

    • @michaelelischer1565
      @michaelelischer1565 Місяць тому +3

      Considering the illagers base of operations’ proximity to the pale garden, I think this is definitely possible. This could also be backed up by the fact that the new resin clumps can be found in woodland mansion chests

  • @Keaton427
    @Keaton427 2 місяці тому +14

    This is the only channel that I can come to for very good quality theories that are actually backed up by evidence, and not just more theories. Thank you for making your content, it's a really good outlet for me

  • @helenos_152
    @helenos_152 2 місяці тому +23

    Xatrix, you always make my day when you upload, especially if it's a lore theory. In the future, I expect to see a structure added in the Pale Garden, such as a Pale Mansion (variant of the Woodland Mansion) or something completely new that merges End-related concepts with others in the game and possibly even new ones. Though, if the Pale Garden IS the Warped forest of the Overworld, I don't expect much of it. I also think Mojang should consider adding a fog and reducing the amount of normal mobs spawning in there (Endermen would be excluded since they're related to the End).

    • @michaelelischer1565
      @michaelelischer1565 Місяць тому

      I doubt they’d add a structure, unless it’s something like a tree stump. Outside of the corrupted nature of the garden, it appears to be more of an “untamed wilderness” where a structure wouldn’t make too much sense

  • @GuyllianVanRixtel
    @GuyllianVanRixtel 2 місяці тому +32

    I think the creaking is simply just a self defense mechanism for a magical tree. The connections to the end, while there, are not really stong enough. Endermans spawn more often in all end biomes and warped forests, but not pale gardens. The entire phantom thing is pretty strange to me, especially since I never noticed it. Unsure to what connections it creates between phantoms and the end tho, and could honestly be just reusing sound effects considering all of the endlings do the same.

    • @samueldimmock694
      @samueldimmock694 Місяць тому +4

      I think the parallels with the warped forest and the connections between phantoms and other stuff are real and significant, but yeah, not strong enough to tie either the phantoms or the pale garden to the End. My thought is that the pale garden is something like the warped forest, but created by some power other than the End, while the phantoms are tied to whatever power is behind the undead.

    • @GuyllianVanRixtel
      @GuyllianVanRixtel 13 днів тому +1

      @@samueldimmock694 Oh btw, could the power that you are refering to behind the undead be the nameless one?

    • @samueldimmock694
      @samueldimmock694 13 днів тому +2

      @@GuyllianVanRixtel No, I mean the power that fueled the Nameless One's staff. But you're thinking along the right lines.

    • @amelnuri9554
      @amelnuri9554 8 днів тому +2

      I don't think the phantoms are really connected to the end. Maybe they were scouts for the nameless kingdom? Snd have become wild! And the reason that the elytra can be repaired with it's membrane. Could be that endermen harvested the phantoms membrane or the players

  • @TheAbyssalEnderling
    @TheAbyssalEnderling 2 місяці тому +12

    The End is a beautifully corruptive realm and I love it.

    • @KnATv-UchihaGaming
      @KnATv-UchihaGaming 12 днів тому

      its kinda boring tbh

    • @TheAbyssalEnderling
      @TheAbyssalEnderling 12 днів тому +1

      @KnATv-UchihaGaming In the vanilla game, yeah, it's bland.

    • @KnATv-UchihaGaming
      @KnATv-UchihaGaming 12 днів тому +1

      @@TheAbyssalEnderling i think u mean the mc dungons are cool, right?

    • @TheAbyssalEnderling
      @TheAbyssalEnderling 12 днів тому +1

      @@KnATv-UchihaGaming Yeah, the MC Dungeons version of the End is cool. I like that version.

  • @Dilophosaurus2009
    @Dilophosaurus2009 2 місяці тому +22

    Man I love these lore theories.
    We’ll miss you MatPat

  • @Hyperforg
    @Hyperforg 2 місяці тому +17

    I dont think its linked to the end, rather, an experiment gone wrong by the illagers, putting them post-dungeons to now in power

    • @squid1ddy
      @squid1ddy 2 місяці тому +5

      It would explain why they're both found in the same biome

  • @8Eli
    @8Eli 2 місяці тому +6

    Since phantoms only spawn after not sleeping, how they were originally an end mob and how they’re basically “real hallucinations” it makes sense for them to be related to anything warped. Like the pale garden/end
    Also the fact that phantom membrane is what repairs the elytra

  • @user-wi8ld9ki6r
    @user-wi8ld9ki6r 2 місяці тому +14

    The "scatter" sound of Creaking Heart's destruction appears in the sound of the Endersent's footsteps, not fantom...

  • @blueplanet635
    @blueplanet635 29 днів тому +4

    *FINALLY IT ALL MAKES SENSE!!!*

    • @blueplanet635
      @blueplanet635 29 днів тому

      Something we know. Minecraft Legends is part of the general timeline of Minecraft and it all connects. The Seer possesses the Orb of Dominance, which comes from the End. It must have corrupted parts of Crimson Forests, and in the Arch Illager's time in the overworld, he possesses the Orb of Dominance. An ILLAGER. IT ALL MAKES SENSE. Parts of Dark forests were corrupted by this. Ultimately, the Orb of Dominance is shattered, and then the final boss of Minecraft Dungeons the Vengeful Heart of Ender is slain, forever wiping this face of the Orb of Dominance from the Minecraft universe. I spent days upon days trying to crack this. But THIS. *IT'S PERFECT.*

  • @DudeInADinoOnesie
    @DudeInADinoOnesie 2 місяці тому +8

    I thought you were going to talk about how pale usually means something that has lost its color

    • @fumarc4501
      @fumarc4501 2 місяці тому +2

      Pale is also associated with sickness or poor health.

  • @DjDeadpig
    @DjDeadpig 2 місяці тому +10

    New headcanon of mine, but perhaps the creaking were created to counter the wardens and be a means of fighting back against the sculk. I say this since if the creaking moves when not looked at, it would constantly attack the warden for having no eyes and since it’s borderline indestructible, it would always win the battle.
    Kinda like how in the Metroid series, Metroid’s were created to counter X parasites.

  • @comicreaperharry3723
    @comicreaperharry3723 2 місяці тому +7

    I like the parallel comparison between Pale Garden and Warped Forest (they're both distorted but not particularly harmful since Striders eat Warped fungus and The Creaking only appears at night; their only threat is Endermen/the Crackings) and their connection to Ender, but the Illager reaction to the Pale Garden intrigued me; they're afraid of the Creaking but they get along with Endermen (which is weird since theoretically they're both Enderlings). Mayber the Pale Garden did something terrifying to the Illagers once.
    I can't wait for the upcoming big Lore theory (the fate of humanity).

    • @fumarc4501
      @fumarc4501 2 місяці тому +2

      Illagers have always looked “grey”… but maybe they’re just Paler than regular Villagers, eh?

    • @comicreaperharry3723
      @comicreaperharry3723 18 днів тому +2

      @@fumarc4501 So what if, Illagers were villagers who visit the Pale Garden and twisted into Illagers somehow, and this process traumatize them forever, so they scared of the creaking

  • @Bluzers
    @Bluzers 2 місяці тому +13

    I like it! At first I wasn't convinced about the theory that Pale Garden has something to do with Warped Forest, but you presented it nicely without imposing forced solutions, but only stimulated the imagination by presenting real connections like Phantom sound in Heart of the Ender👍

  • @nishthedude
    @nishthedude 2 місяці тому +10

    Xatrix whens the "broken god" part 3 comming out?

    • @Xatrix
      @Xatrix  2 місяці тому +3

      Hopefully within the coming month or so? It's going to be very long and we're putting a lot of effort into it.

    • @nishthedude
      @nishthedude 2 місяці тому

      @@Xatrixawesome! , no pressure btw im just really invested in the lore

  • @Muffinator2018
    @Muffinator2018 2 місяці тому +2

    They are protecting something: the trees themselves

  • @thatoneguy7440
    @thatoneguy7440 18 днів тому +1

    Finally, someone incorporates Minecraft dungeons in a theory. It's crazy that not a lot of people use this game for theory crafting. It's literally canon.

    • @danielloewen2857
      @danielloewen2857 7 днів тому

      I usually try to include in my head canons, but it's difficult enough to make connections in one game let alone 2 and like half a dozen dlcs that have easter eggs that require a second playthrough to find. Also dungeons hasn't had a game drop in a while, do it's not exactly in the public eye rn

  • @Tonglichen-r1l
    @Tonglichen-r1l Місяць тому +2

    Warping is a botanical term, which means that plants are drenched in water and thne the water is filtered out

    • @danielloewen2857
      @danielloewen2857 7 днів тому

      Pretty weird that enderman would like a place where there was water

    • @Tonglichen-r1l
      @Tonglichen-r1l 7 днів тому

      @danielloewen2857 maybe they were the ones who filtered it out

  • @slime-studios
    @slime-studios 2 місяці тому +13

    Also, kingbdox (the creator of the warden and eather mod) ships the creaking and the warden.

  • @Dallas_SilverStar76
    @Dallas_SilverStar76 2 місяці тому +1

    I do like the idea that the Creaking is a subspecies of an Enderman, and as the Creaking Heart might be a corrupted form of amber, possibly a preserved Phantom or Phantom Membrane?

  • @Mesowav
    @Mesowav 2 місяці тому +1

    Hahahahahaha, this was literally what I thought the pale garden might've been as soon as I saw it 👽
    But you managed to somehow find even more connections that I didn't even think of (like them both having "warped" and "garden" in the name)
    Also there is another theory floating around that the pale gardens caused illagers to turn pale, and in MCL we see the horde of the spore piglins who are just as pale from exposure to the warped forests. Very interesting to think about

  • @dinathefossilfighter
    @dinathefossilfighter Місяць тому

    I always thought that "Warped" Forest was a reference to how Endermen can warp through space with their teleportation ability. I kind of assumed that this forest somehow distorts space, making it a location that Endermen love to teleport to.

    • @blueplanet635
      @blueplanet635 29 днів тому

      The presence of endermen is almost definitely tied to the Orb of Dominance.

  • @characterkinginc8935
    @characterkinginc8935 2 місяці тому

    Glad you're back!!!, hope all is well with you!!!, have a good day!!!

  • @foolofdaggers7555
    @foolofdaggers7555 2 місяці тому +2

    Wait, that actually makes sense with the music though? Like I always thought the warped forest was the luigi to the crimson forest’s mario, but no. it’s the wario.

  • @CrazyGamingYT56
    @CrazyGamingYT56 Місяць тому

    Love your content keep up the great work

  • @lifetheorist5146
    @lifetheorist5146 2 місяці тому

    I love these kinds of theories so much

  • @Charlotte-en3wp
    @Charlotte-en3wp 2 місяці тому +4

    15 MINUTES LETS GOOOO

  • @Lumberjack_king
    @Lumberjack_king Місяць тому

    I just had a idea what If the pale garden was some kind of experiment done by the illagers but it went wrong

  • @FireOfPassion46
    @FireOfPassion46 Місяць тому

    I just realized something. Endermen attack you when you look at it and the Creaking attack you when you don't look at them. There's propably a parallel here.

  • @Slothloaf
    @Slothloaf 2 місяці тому +1

    Xatrix awesome lore video 😊❤

  • @cesarsalad417
    @cesarsalad417 2 місяці тому +4

    minecraft lore gose carazy type hype

  • @fried9819
    @fried9819 2 місяці тому

    i have been waiting for this since mincrufftah pre recorded ended

  • @halolover6893
    @halolover6893 18 днів тому

    Update just came out, there's resin bricks inside the woodland mansion chest

  • @aspitube2515
    @aspitube2515 16 днів тому

    To me the biome would drawn links to like the garden of eden or something godly/celestial, (I think the fact that it generates on high altitudes could add up to that too), then it was maybe abandoned, deprived of its holiness and it’s like this now.
    Maybe it hints to the origins of evil and these dark forces on the Minecraft world.
    My take on the creaking would be that maybe he lost the master whom he followed and now it’s just doing the same task that was last assigned to him (to protect the garden), all over and over again, even if there’s nothing to be protected anymore, the place is sick and dying, in ruins.

  • @chasethemaster3440
    @chasethemaster3440 2 місяці тому +2

    No shot you made a theory video already

  • @OhmHobby
    @OhmHobby Місяць тому

    Finally someone talk about the weeping angels

  • @darkreflection9087
    @darkreflection9087 2 місяці тому

    I love these Lore Theories they make Minecraft so much more interesting

  • @dylandubose6961
    @dylandubose6961 Місяць тому +1

    The creaking may be the reason why we don't see the swamp villagers The Witches may have turned the swamp villagers into the creaking

    • @danielloewen2857
      @danielloewen2857 7 днів тому

      No, the swamp and the pale garden are never necessarily close to each other

    • @dylandubose6961
      @dylandubose6961 7 днів тому

      @danielloewen2857 I know I've had some time to look back at that theory and I think I have a better one my new theory is the creaking is a variant of the pillagers version of a iron golem that went wrong that's why they have the iron golems in the cages at the lookout Towers and that's why they have the mushrooms and their mansions and the pillagers have totems of undying and the creaking can't die unless you kill its heart that's why they run away from the creaking because they know the truth and there scared of what it can do

  • @thebonkman
    @thebonkman Місяць тому +1

    matpat v2:

    • @blueplanet635
      @blueplanet635 29 днів тому +1

      Xatrix added a deeper lore to Minecraft's End dimension...this is supported by really, really, really, REALLY concrete evidence. The endermen were also almost definitely manipulated in their own way. The endermen are also neutral in Minecraft, but hostile in Minecraft Dungeons. They were almost definitely manipulated. They also hate the Ender Dragon and Endermites. The Orb of Dominance almost definitely made Endermites and the endermen as stated by the game theorists are the ancient builders after eating too much chorus fruit. They were almost definitely manipulated by the Orb of Dominance. Honestly, all I have to say is this: *This one extremely well crafted theory changes EVERYTHING.*

    • @thebonkman
      @thebonkman 29 днів тому

      @@blueplanet635 brain overload

  • @ZudinGodofWar
    @ZudinGodofWar 2 місяці тому +1

    Am kinda curious about what Game Theorists are going to think about this

    • @sboy2044
      @sboy2044 2 місяці тому +1

      If you’re talking about the video, they’ll ignore it

    • @ZudinGodofWar
      @ZudinGodofWar 2 місяці тому +1

      @@sboy2044 I mean th creaking and Pale Gardens

  • @Campandcabin
    @Campandcabin 22 дні тому

    Pillagers are afraid of the Creaking

  • @robertwhite8298
    @robertwhite8298 2 місяці тому +1

    The ILLAGERS (and Grey skin villagers from legends) HAVE GREY SKIN, AND THE ILLAGERS ARE AFRAID OF THE CREAKING, DO THEY NOT HAVE SOME KIND OF BACKSTORY?? (Not to sound aggressive)

  • @shadowgamer-vq8fc
    @shadowgamer-vq8fc 2 місяці тому

    I’m actually considering the whole mystery within the past of Minecraft within its own law as a somewhat reflection of our own whether it was intentionally done or not by the developers like for an example I considered the present day version of Minecraft as it’s version of today’s modern world and the ancient powerfully advanced past of Minecraft, a somewhat reflection of how I believe things were in the past multiple times because I’ve been noticing things in history that don’t really add up once you know where to look and look deep enough there was an ancient civilization pre-dating all of the other ones and possibly evidence of more predating that and so on ones that are far more advanced than we are currently because they’re the same that I’ve been told control the narrativecontrol the people and i’m not really sure how much of this matches up with Minecraft, but I do find it oddly similar and the disappearance of the ancient builders lining up pretty closely to the disappearance of the previous advanced civilizations of this world that are more advanced than we are so I guess it makes you wonder where the ancient builders the first advanced civilization in Minecraft and I know I might have gone a little off course with the whole thing, but I just thought I’d want to point that out as there is a lot we don’t know of what’s going on within the world of Minecraft just as much as we don’t know what’s going on in the real world as in both of them we know little to nothing as it’s very likely that what we do know is nothing more than a small spec compared to the vast majority of what’s actually out there

  • @Pelousek273
    @Pelousek273 2 місяці тому +2

    LOOOOOORE

  • @dimitree887
    @dimitree887 2 місяці тому

    The illegars leave the creaking because they can’t attack it but it can attack them

  • @gugoluna
    @gugoluna Місяць тому

    It's making pahntom sounds, because phantom is a soul being and magic often utulizes souls. (It's not making sounds pf the phantom, it's making sounds like the phantom)

  • @user-Gooberlino
    @user-Gooberlino 11 днів тому

    Dude the warden is not end influenced. The whole community agrees that it’s an alien from another dimension and the portal they came from is nothing like an end portal frame

  • @frenchrevenge6406
    @frenchrevenge6406 2 місяці тому

    What do you have to say now that the resin is a thing?

    • @Xatrix
      @Xatrix  2 місяці тому +1

      I would just point out that the resin spreads like Sculk veins do, the trigger is just different

  • @CreativelyJake
    @CreativelyJake 2 місяці тому +1

    despite all the talk about colors, im surprised you havent mentioned … that illagers are pale. would it not be a reasonable assumption that they are the same? pale, grey…
    more significance to the illagers designs would be nice

  • @Concept_Dud3
    @Concept_Dud3 Місяць тому +3

    Theory :
    Some villagers were fed up of having the golems protect them , so they crafted weapons and ventured off. They came across the stronghold and entered the end . They spent many years in the end and worked with the endermens ancestors. They discovered the orb of dominance and stole it due to the power it held. War broke out between the villagers and endermen and it ended up with the orb of dominance being destroyed . Due to this it left the end as a barren wasteland with only few plants and species left. The villagers became ill due to end sickness (becoming illagers) and escaped to the portal where they removed the ender eyes and destroyed them. Their main leader in their group was the most I’ll of them all and isolated himself deep in the caves. He used his surrounding blocks to construct a temple with a portal but his sickness took over before he could finish it (he became the warden) he became blind of what he’d become and attacked anyone so they wouldn’t be infected or have knowledge of the portal.
    The rest of the illager group returned to their village but were banished because the villagers thought they were cursed. Frustrated the illagers created outposts and woodland mansions to tell tales of what they had discovered . Generations after the original illagers , the grey skinned illness was passed down and was apart of the illagers dna.
    Another thing is that I feel like the strays and evokers jaws look like they’d be in the pale garden and illagers are scared if the creaking so that could be connected

  • @godlygamer2466
    @godlygamer2466 Місяць тому +1

    You seem interested in lore. Would you be interested in checking out my player-made lore-run death angles Minecraft server?

  • @Bleatnik490
    @Bleatnik490 2 місяці тому +1

    Have u try spawning pillagers and pillagers variants on the creaking
    (Try it it's worth it for the lore and if you have a theory on it i will comment and share my theory too)
    Edit:lol u already figured it out

  • @CalebMickelson-f9j
    @CalebMickelson-f9j 2 місяці тому

    lets go!

  • @EnderJackerith
    @EnderJackerith Місяць тому +1

    I though illagers create the biome in mistake

  • @SixtyStone
    @SixtyStone 2 місяці тому

    Its not even released yet-

  • @thediamondking1999
    @thediamondking1999 2 місяці тому

    LETS GOOO (Under 5 Minutes Gang)

  • @Rip_chris29
    @Rip_chris29 3 дні тому

    What if creakings are mutated enderman

  • @CyraxxNationOfficial
    @CyraxxNationOfficial 14 днів тому

    What about chocolate minecraft?

  • @MikeF-rx6of
    @MikeF-rx6of 2 місяці тому

    Doubt they will add anything cause the warped Forrest doesn’t have anything either

  • @polka_dot
    @polka_dot 2 місяці тому

    Wait it's giving 3rd person front a better chance at being useful

  • @vindicatorschannel7136
    @vindicatorschannel7136 2 місяці тому

    I dont have time rn to watch it so im just gonna assume you know that the creaking looks way to much like the watchling from mc dungeons. They even end with ING

  • @spacemonstersop
    @spacemonstersop 2 місяці тому +1

    The creakling is used for its heart to make trail spawners and vaults as they targeted by looking at them (im cooking?)

  • @simonpitt4632
    @simonpitt4632 2 місяці тому

    minecraft is turning into a horror game

  • @kitkutv495
    @kitkutv495 2 місяці тому +62

    dude made this update more bearable with a single theory

    • @sboy2044
      @sboy2044 2 місяці тому

      There’s no evidence that what we’ve seen so far are the only things in the drop

    • @psychojester8242
      @psychojester8242 2 місяці тому +63

      It was already bearable, you’re just a baby

    • @vindicatorschannel7136
      @vindicatorschannel7136 2 місяці тому +28

      The reply above me is right

    • @kitkutv495
      @kitkutv495 2 місяці тому

      @@psychojester8242 i have been playing minecraft since 2015 and seeing that in six months the best they can do is retextured dark forest with retextures of moss,moss carpet and hanging roots with a mob spawner 3.0 that can only work at night and needs pale logs on top and below it for it to work and only spawns one specific mob these features are disapointing because it should take about atleast 3 months for them to do, the only unique and fun feature in this drop is the creaking

    • @squid1ddy
      @squid1ddy 2 місяці тому +9

      Right above reply me the is

  • @SHADOWReaper347
    @SHADOWReaper347 2 місяці тому +1

    lore theory: how come iron golems attack spiders and skeletons even though they don't hurt villagers, maybe the villagers didn't create the iron golems?

    • @danielloewen2857
      @danielloewen2857 7 днів тому

      If you build an iron golem it won't attack you if you hit it or a villager, unlike villagers golems. This implies that golems are loyal to whoever built them. And it doesn't matter if spiders wouldn't hurt the villager, as they're still afraid of them so the iron golem sees them as a threat

  • @rafabuster12
    @rafabuster12 2 місяці тому

    Under 15 minutes

  • @muhdemilhaziq4882
    @muhdemilhaziq4882 2 місяці тому

    Reported

  • @usersomethings
    @usersomethings 2 місяці тому +2

    First also cool video

  • @fumarc4501
    @fumarc4501 2 місяці тому

    Illagers rediscovered the existence of Ancient Cities and were soundly driven off by the Warden. Seeking a new weapon to oppose it, the Illagers called upon their Witch allies to help them create a new weapon. Provided with what they managed to steal from the Under Dark, the Witches started experimenting in the Dark Oak forests until… Something went wrong and the Creaking Heart was born.