This siunds awesome acoustic, Carly' voice is so strong and clear, she shouldn't be compared to anyone as she's just doing her thing and what suits her voice, not many artists today can sing that well acousticly!
Her technique is quite good. And it's a lot more natural when she sings. Her breath support is good, too. I think her voice sounds warmer because of that.
Most likely, there will be no second album "We Are The Fallen" at all. I believe that the former members of" Evanescence " created this band to show Amy that they can exist and successfully make music without her. This was their main goal and they achieved it. There is nowhere to go further, there are no new ideas. So there is no point in hoping for anything, since the main mission of this project is completed.
@@demonkarro7906 be that as it may I’d love to hear Carly Smithson make more music... she is a terrific singer and so much more than an Amy Lee “soundalike”
@@demonkarro7906 there’s only one Carly Smithson, she should be very proud of this song and album. She may have sang Amy Lee’s songs on Idol but she has a different quality to her voice and deserves to move out from under Amy’s shadow 🙌
The fact that they just died because so many people hated them for basically claiming to be Evanescence but better was a real shame. As someone who has been a huge fan of Evanescence for over 20 years I can say this album was INCREDIBLE. They simply aren't Evanescence but that doesn't mean we can't enjoy more music that is a similar style. I wish they kept making music.
The funny part to me is that noone seems to realize aside from lyrics, the guitar riffs, and melodies where at least in part, if not completely written by the band, which in turn means if ben moody wrote every note you hear on a guitar in an evanescence song, he OWNS that!!! If I write a instrumental song and my vocalist in my band writes lyrics for it, he owns the lyrics, I own the riffs. if I leave my band and start another one I can use anything I wrote with the first band with the new one.
Never thought I'd say it because I am one of the biggest EV fans out there..but I REALLY like this band. This girl an sing and sign well and she deserves respect for that. She has mine.
I've heard both versions and I like them both, with and without the high notes. Belting in the rafters all the time does not always mean a better singer. This is still very well sung, in my opinion.
I adore the way Carly sounds live. I adore the way she sounds on cd. Basically I love her voice whether it's live or not. I love the fact that the rest of the band members all play guitar. It makes Rocky that much cooler. I love the acoustic versions of WATF songs and yes, I have to say I love acoustics of Ev as well considering they have been my favorite band for a very long time. Carly looks so gorgeous in this video. People need to stop harassing her and trashing her.
in the begening of the song it sort of reminds me of Heaven's a Lie by Lacuna Coil, specially this acoustic version. I love this band, too bad i got into them a night right after they came to play to my city, i can't beleive i missed it because in less than two days they turned out to be one of my favorite bands.
Alexa Charbonneau Sounds like you're a little mad the band members Amy Lee shunned went and found someone as talented and beautiful to form a band with, if not more so.
Arch Nemesis who said Amy abandoned her fans? Amy Lee is such a nice person, I talked to her on Facebook and Twitter both, she said she wants to make a concert in Kurdistan so she can meet her fans in there!
Arch Nemesis It's true that the success of The Open Door didn't quite match the success of fallen but I *personally* think that, The Open Door rocks. That's why it spend weeks on #1 on the billboard. But the only thing I'm not sure about is the third album *Evanescence* Anyways, Amy Lee wants to do artistic things, different from her other music. I know that for example Call Me When You're Sober from The Open Door was nothing comparing it to Bring Me To Life and Going Under from Fallen. But things have to move on. Amy don't want to do the same shit all over again. I will be a true fan forever - who knows what's in the future of Evanescence? :) P.S. Terry Balsamo left the band and was replaced by Jen Majura.
2,100th liker. I love We Are The Fallen, AND Evanescence equally. But now that I heard more of WATF'S songs, I like them a bit more. This acoustic version of this song is the best! They should do more of their songs like this.
Harringtonize Check out John LeCompt and Rocky Gray's new project on Facebook called Even Devils Die, they have two songs out on iTunes. It's awesome! There's even an interview with him, in it he says that WATF isn't dead.
Damn there are a lot of haters! If any of you saw Carly on American Idol you would know that this IS her style and the great thing about music and fashion is that it doesn't belong to just one person its for everyone! Good job We Are Fallen!!!!
No se trata de q Amy sea mejor. Simplemente es famosa y distinta. Carly como a mucha gente le cuesta emprender el verdadero género cuando no hay apertura... Mucha gente tiene oportunidad de mostrar su oscuro e impresionante talento, q también les ha costado educar. La suerte es diferente para todos... Además gracias a Amy y su voz se crean nuevos sueños y voces; y esto afortunadamente nunca termina... Hermosa y fuerte voz de ella... excelente actitud para este género!
At first I honestly thought that this song was about Amy. Since that 3 of the men in this band were Amy's. I was defensive for Amy, I know pathetic but what can you do? Now that I learned the truth, it seriously opened the doors to another band that I am OBSESSED with! The song is exactly the things that I wanted to tell my best friend (since we were 9) since she up and left me behind for an abusive boyfriend and drugs. I think Carly is going to go far. I'm glad to be a WATF fan! (cheesy I know)
If you came here for a talent show, you've come to the wrong place. If you've come here to listen to a beautiful new take on an already incredibly beautiful song, look no further.
this band is really good... it's album is awesome... since evanescence doesn't decide when to realease its new album, this band's album is really cool to entertain as it happens!!!! can wait anymore for EVANESCENCE'S NEW ALBUM...
To the people saying she can't sing the high notes. You need to stop being so ignorant and realize not all acoustic versions are like the original. It sounds just fine the way she's singing it. She could hit the high notes but she changed it up for the acoustic version.
I think she has a lovely, very unique quality to her voice.
This siunds awesome acoustic, Carly' voice is so strong and clear, she shouldn't be compared to anyone as she's just doing her thing and what suits her voice, not many artists today can sing that well acousticly!
We Are the Fallen is so good live. I really like the acoustic version.
Her technique is quite good. And it's a lot more natural when she sings. Her breath support is good, too. I think her voice sounds warmer because of that.
ua-cam.com/video/M55FY91e2ZQ/v-deo.htmlsi=-y3FqtPoVmh7h8D_
Evanescence is my favorite band but Carly has such a beautiful voice! Can y’all come out with a second Album soon, please?
Most likely, there will be no second album "We Are The Fallen" at all. I believe that the former members of" Evanescence " created this band to show Amy that they can exist and successfully make music without her. This was their main goal and they achieved it. There is nowhere to go further, there are no new ideas. So there is no point in hoping for anything, since the main mission of this project is completed.
@@demonkarro7906 be that as it may I’d love to hear Carly Smithson make more music... she is a terrific singer and so much more than an Amy Lee “soundalike”
@@Gemmagic84 "and much more than Amy Lee" - that's what I totally agree with!
@@demonkarro7906 there’s only one Carly Smithson, she should be very proud of this song and album. She may have sang Amy Lee’s songs on Idol but she has a different quality to her voice and deserves to move out from under Amy’s shadow 🙌
Such a beutiful voice and such a beutiful vocaliss too..😂😂😂
The fact that they just died because so many people hated them for basically claiming to be Evanescence but better was a real shame.
As someone who has been a huge fan of Evanescence for over 20 years I can say this album was INCREDIBLE.
They simply aren't Evanescence but that doesn't mean we can't enjoy more music that is a similar style. I wish they kept making music.
We Are the Fallen is one of my favorite bands. They are so good and sound great live.
I just love her voice, everything about her is just AMAZING. Can't get enough of her.
this is very very good. she feels the song she sings and that's the most important thing for being awesome :))
without words... just stuning
Beautiful! Love this song and its a great acoustic!
The funny part to me is that noone seems to realize aside from lyrics, the guitar riffs, and melodies where at least in part, if not completely written by the band, which in turn means if ben moody wrote every note you hear on a guitar in an evanescence song, he OWNS that!!! If I write a instrumental song and my vocalist in my band writes lyrics for it, he owns the lyrics, I own the riffs. if I leave my band and start another one I can use anything I wrote with the first band with the new one.
Never thought I'd say it because I am one of the biggest EV fans out there..but I REALLY like this band. This girl an sing and sign well and she deserves respect for that. She has mine.
Her voice is awesome
Awesome! I love singers that can actually sing live, its a rare and special talent!
I just Love her... her voice is amazing O.o
I've heard both versions and I like them both, with and without the high notes. Belting in the rafters all the time does not always mean a better singer. This is still very well sung, in my opinion.
Beautiful version of the song. I wish the band much success and hope for more than 1 album
I adore the way Carly sounds live. I adore the way she sounds on cd. Basically I love her voice whether it's live or not. I love the fact that the rest of the band members all play guitar. It makes Rocky that much cooler. I love the acoustic versions of WATF songs and yes, I have to say I love acoustics of Ev as well considering they have been my favorite band for a very long time. Carly looks so gorgeous in this video. People need to stop harassing her and trashing her.
Wow
Wonderful version of a great song.
🌎🌊🌲🔥🌪 ❤️
beautiful voice and great band
I can't even I, I just randomly found this, this has been one of my favorite songs for a long time. Oh so good.
I kind of want to hear Amy sing this.... For science. lol
totallyyyy
I d like to hear Carly sing a lot of amys songs,, Just saying for Science,, then we can compare the theory into actual fact :)
As a scientist in training I must say I fully agree. Now we only need a bit of government funding to carry out the trials.
Johnnie C She must try The end of a dream 😁
DeAndre Pittman, the phrasing of „for science“ is HILARIOUS! But given what you mean I actually can‘t think of a better alternative. 😂
Such a sweet sweet voice!
I am a huge EvFan but Carly have amazing voice especially in live perfomances admit it!
Agreed!
one thing I truly love about her is that she sings with soul
she doesnt sing just to sing
Ugh. I love this performance!!! I like Carly's slightly raspy voice more than I like Amy's and this performance is impeccable! Goose bumps every time!
Voz poderosa !
Comparação estúpida entre a Amy e a Carly. Ambas são maravilhosas. Mas eu estou completamente apaixonada na voz dessa mulher. 😍 ❤
in the begening of the song it sort of reminds me of Heaven's a Lie by Lacuna Coil, specially this acoustic version.
I love this band, too bad i got into them a night right after they came to play to my city, i can't beleive i missed it because in less than two days they turned out to be one of my favorite bands.
amazing!!! I love her voice
my favorite band,,Go Carly Go,,keep up the good music
They were so good, still waiting for a second album/tour 😔
she sounds so amazing here *-*
Love them so much 😍😍😍
holy crap what she can do with her voice ♥.♥
*Standing Ovation* This was EXCELLENT!!! :) She is seriously like Amy Lee's sister. It's RIDICULOUS!!!
Tell me you're joking
Alexa Charbonneau Sounds like you're a little mad the band members Amy Lee shunned went and found someone as talented and beautiful to form a band with, if not more so.
Arch Nemesis who said Amy abandoned her fans?
Amy Lee is such a nice person, I talked to her on Facebook and Twitter both, she said she wants to make a concert in Kurdistan so she can meet her fans in there!
Arch Nemesis It's true that the success of The Open Door didn't quite match the success of fallen but I *personally* think that, The Open Door rocks.
That's why it spend weeks on #1 on the billboard.
But the only thing I'm not sure about is the third album *Evanescence*
Anyways, Amy Lee wants to do artistic things, different from her other music.
I know that for example Call Me When You're Sober from The Open Door was nothing comparing it to Bring Me To Life and Going Under from Fallen.
But things have to move on.
Amy don't want to do the same shit all over again.
I will be a true fan forever - who knows what's in the future of Evanescence? :)
P.S. Terry Balsamo left the band and was replaced by Jen Majura.
Arch Nemesis maybe they'll be reunited someday :)
I hope so, it's so much fun with Ben Moody in the band :D
she sing so beautiful
great performance..
awesome... her voicee is awesome
Ben Moody & Carly Simonson Magic!
Q buena voz tiene !!! Ojalá venga para argentina seguro q la rompe , gran compositor ben moody
I love this song! I hope it will be give a next album!
Ótima! Além de linda tem uma voz perfeita! ♥
Man this is good.
Wow , great preformance !
love it... please come back with new project...
2,100th liker. I love We Are The Fallen, AND Evanescence equally. But now that I heard more of WATF'S songs, I like them a bit more. This acoustic version of this song is the best! They should do more of their songs like this.
Definately.
Harringtonize Check out John LeCompt and Rocky Gray's new project on Facebook called Even Devils Die, they have two songs out on iTunes. It's awesome! There's even an interview with him, in it he says that WATF isn't dead.
wow really good voice
Please back, We Are The Fallen
SUPERB! Just to brilliant! Just gotta love this version :D
i love, that she sings with closed eyes!
beautiful voice!
this acoustic version sounds different from the album version, but both sound amazing!!
Damn there are a lot of haters! If any of you saw Carly on American Idol you would know that this IS her style and the great thing about music and fashion is that it doesn't belong to just one person its for everyone! Good job We Are Fallen!!!!
woaw she really feels the song :)
her eyes are closed through the hole song. i really like this song!
Carly has a really nice and rich voice!
the drummer doing the riff, awesome!
She's such a powerful singer :)
No se trata de q Amy sea mejor. Simplemente es famosa y distinta. Carly como a mucha gente le cuesta emprender el verdadero género cuando no hay apertura... Mucha gente tiene oportunidad de mostrar su oscuro e impresionante talento, q también les ha costado educar. La suerte es diferente para todos... Además gracias a Amy y su voz se crean nuevos sueños y voces; y esto afortunadamente nunca termina...
Hermosa y fuerte voz de ella... excelente actitud para este género!
:) this performance is more than great
BEAUTIFUL.
Carly Smithson,beautiful voice...I wait for new projects.
+Carla Nascimento same here, been watching those old video and still love how she's performing
+Rado Andriamanantena r0
i like the acoustic more than i do the studio
How can you guys compare Carly and Amy? Two different, good singers. The band doesnt matter.
Bravo!
this song is amazing and this version is rare!^^
Hate for all the haters!!
I love here voice!!
And i love this song!! Thumbs UP!!
I came to them because of some curiosity but stayed for her beautiful voice.
I love both bands too!
Carly's so great here!
I like this, great song , great voice :-)
At first I honestly thought that this song was about Amy. Since that 3 of the men in this band were Amy's. I was defensive for Amy, I know pathetic but what can you do? Now that I learned the truth, it seriously opened the doors to another band that I am OBSESSED with! The song is exactly the things that I wanted to tell my best friend (since we were 9) since she up and left me behind for an abusive boyfriend and drugs. I think Carly is going to go far. I'm glad to be a WATF fan! (cheesy I know)
Carly sang so Lovely !!
If you came here for a talent show, you've come to the wrong place. If you've come here to listen to a beautiful new take on an already incredibly beautiful song, look no further.
Perfect❤
this band is really good... it's album is awesome... since evanescence doesn't decide when to realease its new album, this band's album is really cool to entertain as it happens!!!! can wait anymore for EVANESCENCE'S NEW ALBUM...
the opening was sooo folk tunes banjo meet inspirational 🥰
This is perfect
i can't believe this is seven years ago where does the time go 😢😳
Are you sure this is live? Because this is just....WOW. I came across this by accident. I'm so glad I did now.
Epic!! I love the acoustic stuff!!
so perfect
love those guitars
To the people saying she can't sing the high notes. You need to stop being so ignorant and realize not all acoustic versions are like the original. It sounds just fine the way she's singing it. She could hit the high notes but she changed it up for the acoustic version.
we are the fallen are very very good
NAILED IT!
WOW carly sings great live, she is a real singer.
and I like to see rocky playing a guitar, this band has a great future, not like other bands xD
This aged well huh
just fucking AMAZING!! such a voice so clean!
waw this acoustic is really cool
When will we hear new music?
unfortunately ı guess never
This is beautiful.
beautiful
AMAZINGAMAZINGAMAZING!
lovely
girl can sing
The woman can sing, that's all the matters to me.
we no puedo para de escuchar esta banda muy wena
Love it
Why is this so good?!
good video..good song..good band..