Tbh, Taran is just an editor. He is a machine, he works with writers and actors in the studio. Justine just does every artistic part of her videos, so this should not be a surprise
I'd say it's not even for question that Taran is a better editor. iJustine just is a tech UA-camr, maybe she's a good one but Taran is a professional editor. Also iJustine uses f*cking final cut so you can't take her seriously haha.....
19:30 did everyone catch that transition when justine mentions about how exited she is about the new transition pack, also the fact taran edited this video thats quite funny
Well he also won the original competition by existing. Rematch where he uses his full power of macros. Would love to see full power Taran against this representation of iJustine full power.
reminds me of that guy wit hthe hammers and the bullet proof windows, and he always said "not tough enough" even after going to town with a hammer for like 3 minutes
I actually feel that people can have the most powerful editing software and it wouldn't even matter, it's the decisions the editor makes that makes the videos look good or bad, for all taran' skill he just isn't as creative as justine, she also cared about what people would say if she left what she thought could be offensive in her video, taran just doesn't care about the comments, even though they could influence his job security if people outright turned on him
@@kayleas5328 most people prefered tarans in the comments tho, ijustines felt cringy and sorta lifeless, while tarans felt corprate but not in a bad way
To be fair to Taran, cutting down your footage first rather than rushing to completion is a good editing habit to have when working on a major production. If a director orders a change, you don't want to delete completed work.
Its representative of how LTT works differently than Justine. She's the one taking decisions, so she doesn't have to worry about last minute changes. A lot of what both of them did was representative of how both of the compagnies does thing differently.
That boomer who gave my man a 5 was clearly biased (typical iSheep behaviour, but Justine ofcourse is waaay better than that), they should've given out the scores without knowing the editor
@@MdIrfan11396 I disagree and so does Taren. ijustine made better editing and directing decisions. It was a better product. Macro's help speed, fluency, reduce mistakes. All the judges agreed he had less technical mistakes. Taran's video was just boring, tastes differ and iJustine's is better suited for youtube
It's that damn tone of voice that sets you on the wrong foot. I inherited the same "explaining" tone of voice from my dad and I just can't kill it off.
@Chips Master Well I do the same but I convert all the frames to ascii images and open them all in notepad and just switch to next frame when I need to
Judge: Your video has too many zooms and therefore people would click away. Him not knowing Taran also edited this video and so far no-one has clicked away.
I loved the way Taran expressed his thought on Justine's work. Great thing to acknowledge opponents talents, he has exhibited a great sportmanship......👍❤️
Yes, also depends on the goal. One style is for educational videos and fits more for tech videos the other is for pure entertainment and fits for more general purpose videos.
Conclusion: this had nothing to do with the title. It was just a goofy collaboration and nothing more. As if Mac vs PC would be a realistic question in any case. Got money to burn? Buy a mac.
Raw footage from people like Justine who are comfortable in front of the cameras would be more polished even before editing. Hence why the she got a challenge editing this particular raw footage she was given.
Taran's edit was probably more "the engineer" and Justine's edit was probably more "the entertainer". Depends on the crowd, LTT viewers come for the details and specificity, Taran is here to deliver. Can't really comment on Justine's viewers though, I'm not one of them.
I'm pretty sure Austin's crowd watches for detail and specificity, so I think Taran nailed it. Its an informative video, It should let the viewer know of all the features of the device.
I feel like their editing compliments their character a lot. Justine edits her own videos, so her editing style goes hand in hand with the host's humor. While Taran's editing style is on a higher scale level, working for a company that has several dozen employees. It also has to do with their audience, Justine has a more mainstream-based audience, with Apple products being a more mainstream theme than the "tech taken to the next level" kind of energy that Linus Tech Tips has. So I can definetly see how Justine's video would be easier to watch without getting bored, while Taran's video is slightly more centered on the product that Austin is reviewing. Both videos were great though and kudos to both editors.
I just finished watching a Corridor video before this so it took me a bit to realize that he was out of place lol. I was just like, "Yeah, Niko, of course."
@@dnhn.design He said " a carpenter shouldn't blame their tools" :) meaning it wasn't his softwares fault it was his decision making! They both just over thought ,,,imo
as a music producer and DJ I would LOVE to see a similar video with music production and/or DJ software. everyone gets so defensive about what they use but like it was said in the video, "a bad carpinter blames his tools"
I simply like simplistic style much more than a more "spiced" one. I love Paul's Hardware editing for that, it's just a cut, it's just that and it's perfect for his style.
Ali-Mery you do realize this wasn’t supposed to be a competition between them right it was about their methods on editing and what they used also you must be slow because the guy who you think is worse than the simpleton actually edited this whole video.
as a video editor i totally understood that. let me explain: i can watch one of my edits 10 times over and make it more seamless, getting "technically" better each time but if i'm not inspirred and in the mood, i can make a technically perfect video that seems soulless and boring. on the other hand some days i get footage that i love editing and have that spark of creativity which results in an engaging high quality final video, but i'm so over excited i miss technical problems like uneven horizon or inconsistent audio levels or jerky camera motion etc.
@@KaelDenna eh, i don't really get it. As somone who's been editing videos and studying the art of production for years at this point, i genuinely do not understand how they came to that conclusion.
Because if anyone saw both of the videos uninterrupted side by side again and again they would be thinking the same thing. The point of an editor 99% of the time is to make unobtrusive editing decisions.
Justine edits as if it's her own video where it fits more to show her "personality in the edit", but Austin Evans is completely different. I actually would enjoy watching iJustine but her editing is just unbearable to me, especially the music.
Well, sounds like it ended up being a directorial competition rather than which setup is best for editing. They were judged on creative skills, not the effectiveness of the tool. So I'll give the judges a 2 out of 10 :)
I noticed that as well. But ultimately, it really comes down to communicating the message making the talent look good. I use Sony Vegas for editing. Just comparing what it does with what I see them doing with the software they are using, the basics of what the tools do are pretty much the same. The additional features are different and there may be some shortcuts that make one better than the others, but I think I could use any of the three and come out with pretty much the same video without pulling my hair out.
I really appreciate Taran's humbleness, and at the same time, Justine is praising Taran for his work. It's fair that Justine won, and we didn't get to see but snippets, but Taran did a fantastic job too. Congrats to both of you for you work and your being humble. Great guys/girls!
@@triple7marc yeah, not everybody is a "fair loser", like being able to praise the winner etc. I wrote this a year ago, so that's just what I remember.
The fact justine got up to change the temperature herself, stopped to look at snacks, let her dog out, all while poking at taran, while Still editing, just goes to show how confident she feels w her edits after editing thousands of her videos for years, even though theres a time limit.
He was not taking it very seriously tbh, he did say that he was not using PR pro as a pro tool but master the basics, of course it would be amazing in a normal youtube video, but judges are usually very picky.
@@manwithstds7503 oh forsure, i wasnt trying to talkbad about him, i just was pointing out her confidence in her skills. She could have stayed in her chair but she felt good about it & had fun all around. Both outcomes were great.
Yeah I mean I think this video showcased their styles and workflows pretty well. Taran comes at it from a content-creation and artistic angle, and he's very aware of the technicalities of the video, so he tends to put a ton of polish on things and make sure the bare minimum looks as nice as possible, even if he doesn't put as much on top of it. Justine tends to come at it from a content-consumption angle, making sure the video is as engaging as possible first and polishing the flow last.
I have a huge amount of respect for Taran being as humble as he was. It takes a very strong person to be able to critically self evaluate like he did- especially in-front of the judges and everyone.
Lucas Leite they shoot in like 8k raw at LTT on those red cams so they have the pixels to do the comedic zooming. He’s not going to stop just like that after one hater, how else can they justify those 30k cameras and 1000000TB media servers to Linus
As an ordinary viewer, getting an inside look into the process of making a UA-cam video is my main takeaway from this video. It's really fascinating how much time and effort goes into them, this has left me with a new sense of appreciation for creators.
This was really well done. I love the contrasts in styles where he is so hyper focused and serious because thats his job. Justine on the other hand before the last bit was using editing to relax, and just chill. He had like 5 things and help directly from Austin while she just ate snacks and just used what was on her system. The styles of editing shows well and really visualize each person perfectly. Justine also proved why she does do her own editing while being an OG on this platform. To me this was less about the operating system or suites used and more about that. I do wish they showed more about both programs cuz some ppl never used a mac or a pc. Fun video as always from LTT, almost as fun as this segway, to the other comments. Lol
Watching this was very enjoyable, I am not a video editor but I thoroughly enjoyed this and I I have not watched an iJustine video in a very long time but, I found myself smiling the entire time while your video. Good job to both of you. Great video... I am going to massage my face now. TTFN.
@@quicktoreason2722 How very true. The focus was wrong, and the things it was judged one was wrong. It's not who made the most attractive youtube video, but which was the most effective at dealing with technical solutions.
@@BulletMagnetMan but informative, would you rather learn first aid from a guy who knows what he's doing, or a guy who only sorta does and is slightly funny
@@cocoshort6528 @Coco You smell like someone with a sub par PC hating on MAC users... get over it, stop with teh MAC vs PC wars, i have both, they have their own pros and cons that PC users will never get... There are always creative people doing creative weird ways, and boring teachers...
When Justine said that Taran left in rants as opposed to cutting those down. I think thats the difference in communities. The LTT community loves when Linus goes on a mini rant or goes completely off topic. Edit- the "TMZ Zoom in" is a quirk we love too.
Yeah, and who are these judges, Corridor Digital, yes. Bitwit, yes. Justine's sister and some rando dude, gtfo. Get a variety of judges, we had 1 tech judge, 1 professional level judge, 1 iPhone dude,and 1 sister. Maybe keep the pro dude, the PC dude, and get Austin's editor, and 1 other, majority of the judges had small attention span audience, yes Austin has that, but not as bad as Justine's audience type, and LTT audience likes creativity with information, and GamersNexus likes information. The editing styles were a big swaying thing, look at the dude who says "This music doesn't help hear information" about Justine and proceeds to give a 5 to Taran because "too informative" .. excuse me, wth?
@Conor Literally everyone likes ijustine, including the entire linus team. Who cares that she buys oreos lol linus made a video about the underwear he wears...
Hands down, one of your absolutely best videos. Watching two 'unseen' people do what they do best under pressure (and knowing a bit about editing) was incredible: DEFINITELY more content like this. Thank you Justine and Taran, and judges. I felt the pressure.
@@minartson And they knew their conclusion. "It doesn't matter". To get a true Apples to Apples comparison, you'd need to have someone fluent in both programs, be given the same time, and given the same video to render with the same about style. The face we had the variables of Windows, Asus, MacBook, MacOS, Justine and Taran, the competition was "Justine vs Taran". Because there's no way to validate which is better with such variables.
@@Xyler94 exactly right. if we'd wanted to compare like-for-like, they could've both used premiere, but this wasn't about benchmarking the tech, this was about comparing the styles & approaches of two editors who happen to use these different toolsets. back in the linear edit days, I would get runners & tape-ops asking me to show them how to edit. I'd tell them to hook a 9-way remote cable between two decks & find some footage to play with. "no," they'd say, "show me how to use *that*" & point at the GVG edit controller in one of the suites. I'd tell them "I can show you how to edit, or I can show you how to work the edit controller- which do you want me to do?" editing is part of story telling. the script & the storyboard (if there is one) are where you start. if you don't know what the story is, you're wasting your time, whatever the hardware is.
@@minartson to be fair though, the title & description here do hint heavily at an 'ecosystem' comparison with the added bonus clickbait of 'mac vs PC', & that simply never happened except for a fleeting mention of the different handling of the LUT. so yeah, that got lost somewhere.
I think Justine was exaggerating. While she might not have a script, she probably makes notes on what to talk about. Since she's a one woman band, that's ok! Whereas at LMG, it's really important to have a script, if there is no script, there is no video. 🙂
Locutus I think many people forget that LTT is practically its own media company at this point, with each employee having his own role. The person writing the script isn’t the same person reading off it in front of the camera, which in turn makes a detailed script all the more crucial. Being a one-woman army, iJustine likely has her own notes on what to say in her videos, but she can afford to wing it more compared to LTT.
Skiller S I know but in the commercials they said I’m a Mac I’m a pc and even though a Mac is technically a personal computer, I’ve never heard anybody call a Mac a PC
He really did; imo since the judges found out that the first video was Justine’s they favoured her more for some reason. Before they find out it’s her video, they clearly say the colour grading and correction is horrendous; however while judging they say that it was better which is contradicting themselves
Iceay right exactly; what with all the blurred colour transitions and loud sudden entries into parts of the video, it almost felt like she presumed her audience consists of children and morons
@@stormbringer228_ You are making stuff up, they never mentioned the color grading and correction is horrendous. They said the color shifts because it had a second or two of a color mishap and never mentioned color again.
@@cantorgauss gaming mice aren't just for gaming, they can be used for a variety of purposes. Compared to normal mice they are much better as they have programmable buttons, superior sensors, better DPI and much more. Not to mention the RGB lighting.
This is a really good point, without discussing the purpose of the videos, it's hard to rank them. Which one was more entertaining is what was graded by the judges, I wonder if the question was different. "Which one is a better review?" Interesting comment.
I came to this conclusion myself when they mentioned “This is meant for UA-cam” and I bet a lot of iJustine’s advantage came from points docked over that
They were editing the same videos, so I doubt one of them had a drastic information/education difference than the other. It's not like they were editing out huge chunks of the actual information, just the parts that were repetitive or irrelevant. I doubt either video showcased significantly more of the product than the other, so what it really comes down to is how you can make the same information more interesting.
IMO, several advantages in iJustine corner since before starting. If the data we have is right. She has edited more videos, or so they said ( she has edited a crazy ton, I just don't know how many has he edited, specially before getting into LTT). This is in most graphic content making a solid advantage, you learn a lot with practice, even if the genius vein of Taran or whoever will surely lead him far. Seeing the amount of video edited by justine, the "shark" adjective is not casual. Also, she is both the editor and the content creator, the actor and director of the scenes. Has actual TV acting experience. Also experience on interacting with the community, comments, etc, and tracking that tightly during years. A mountain of experience to know what works better with a very specific audience, how to enhance a take, etc. The experience is also due to age, Taran is younger, and with exceptions, more years in some duties is a lot more tricks and that. Surely if you take Justine at Taran's moment, years ago, she would have lost against him, the guy has good potential. Also, IMO, editing YT videos, anyway, is extremely far from deep FX editing, and all the handling, 3D stuff, etc. Even in pure video editing, these tasks are pretty basic. So, not sure if the test serves to consider stuff at certain deeper level. I... don't feel the "5" qualification was fair, tho... casually, it was from the mac based guy, hehe. :D But in al honesty, his advice did seem very good, although I have not seen the footage and the edited videos. I can understand if mac pro users feel intimidated by today's PC's capabilities in pro fields. Not entrance, it's many years established. I've always seen instances of those pros fearing or complaining of increased competition. But hey, life is so. My only fear is... if aaaall this was scripted. Kindda rigged ? As... the cocky pose of Taran at the beginning... Dunno if he's Canadian or US (and anyway, stereotypes are rubbish) but... kindda sth was off to me, there. It kindda doesn't match the personality I'm guessing in this tall guy. So... it very well could be, not that the entire thing was rigged ( I dunno) or the judges decision (either can't know), but is more possible that the cocky comments were totally scripted, on purpose, to make it interesting, or pursuit an agenda Mac/Pc (in order to favor Mac), or just to give it some extra bait (to "heat" the match). In any case, VERY interesting video. For us more techy people in the side of graphic content creation (my main work tho I like hardware in general). And one way or the other, hats off to Justine. She's very talented. It'd be completely expected to win, if all we know is true, and this was all, well, real. Nah, doesn't seem like a fake. I still don't buy the Taran's cocky attitude. I believe that's what I'm almost sure it's scripted, to give it a bit of emotion.
Justine's editing feels like editing for a 14 year old to watch. Taran's editing looks like something an 18-year old would watch. It's a product of their style. Justine edits more variety content while Taran edits tech content. Of course variety content is going to be more geared toward a younger and more diverse audience while tech content will be geared toward a primarily male and older audience.
@@andrewb378 Let me guess, you're 18? That's also a hilarious gap - as if someone is 18 years old then they're so much more mature than they were 4 years ago.
@@MrKamillordo it's not a matter of maturity it's a matter of focus. If you're 18 watching a tech video you're going to be paying attention whether there's fancy graphics or not. If you're 14 watching a lifestyle video, you probably won't be paying as much attention so the video needs to be flashier with more/faster cuts, graphics, more up tempo music, jokes, etc. The age gap itself isn't that big because people building their first PC where they'd be watching tech videos probably aren't going to be older than about 25. People watching Justine's videos probably won't be more than 15 or 16. People who watch UA-cam consistently probably aren't much older than 30 and I think even that's a stretch.
Can you guys do competition videos like this more often? As an editor, this was pretty entertaining to watch. I feel like professional chefs feel the same when they watch cooking competitions on TV.
Too bad you can't buy Final Cut at the
LTT STORE
lmao
ah that is a big oof right there
Austin Evans 😂😂 so true
Bruh
Lol
Thoroughly enjoyed this
Yo, it's actually him
I know Marques would have voted for Taran. More mature + crisper editing.
nice to see ya in the comment section
nice.
Right. Most of the recent longer form factor and obviously sponsored videos from LTT have been genuinely enjoyable.
poor guy, had to spend 4 hours editing and then edit the video of him spending 4 hours editing.
And he had to edit how he lost and relive it over and over again.
😂😂😂
Poor guy had to spend four hours with a simpleton like Justine. That's the saddest part in my opinion
@@dooley9621 poor guy got paid
Doktor Whatson Hiiii
They are technically so good that it is basically a personality thing
Tbh, Taran is just an editor. He is a machine, he works with writers and actors in the studio. Justine just does every artistic part of her videos, so this should not be a surprise
@@ttiization yeah you can see it sometimes, when he is left loose like in the editing of this video he is great.
I'd say it's not even for question that Taran is a better editor. iJustine just is a tech UA-camr, maybe she's a good one but Taran is a professional editor.
Also iJustine uses f*cking final cut so you can't take her seriously haha.....
@@byp4ss514 to be honest final cut is as god as première. preferences :)
@@byp4ss514 People like you make Premere users look stupid, coming from a premere user. no one gives a shet if you dont like mac or final cut.
Linus is acting like those Discovery channel guys who explain what animals are doing
That is offensive yet Hilarious
Yeh well you would have to do it when you have iFAKE... sorry sorry I mean ichar.. what's her name again?
The word you're looking for is David Attenborough.
@@wembley636 lmao who hurt you
Tru tru
"Try unplugging it and plugging it back in" - ultimate tech tip from Linus.
what solves 99% of issues with your computer? re-start... or simple unplug and plug again...
@@zoki.to974 yup, I tell clients "I had to initiate a technical cycle" aka, turn it off and back on again.
and it works
You know what works even better?Smashing the thing just like i do with my remote
He probably forgot to disable the USB Hibernation feature in all honesty.
"He left in a lot of long rants"
of course he did, he edits for linus. Half the channel is rants lmao
Trueeeee 😂
The rants are my favorite part, so that is a legit way of doing things.
@@kpeteho6ot yeah I love the rants too, one of my favorites is the first red camera video which in itself is just a rant
@@gormygorm too bad some people don't. honestly if no one rants enough then companies cannot improve their products entirely.
Cut all the rants and you've just cut the whole channel away
19:30 did everyone catch that transition when justine mentions about how exited she is about the new transition pack, also the fact taran edited this video thats quite funny
きざ라ぎ 레ン
Just noticed it. Hahaha
Good catch.
@@ADeeSHUPA what?
And then 30 seconds later, "the zooming was a little bit too much for me," punching in so much that you can see the loss of video quality, lol.
Judge: Overall good video
Taran: Thanks
Judge: *gives Taran a 5/10*
You mean the guy whose channel is basically a big IPhone advertisement liked the Final Cut video more? Shocking.
@@BigCat315 not even close. Have you seen his edits? I highly recommend you to check out his channel.
@@BigCat315 His channel is not like that, it's just the name of the channel.
I didn't like the judge too
It's a German judge, they're notoriously hard to please.
Taran redeemed himself by editing this incredible challenge video 😂 so much footage was shot this day... it turned out awesome 👏🏻
"I've edited more than a billion views on my channel"
Yeah, not the right answer. LOL
Well u know what they say. Mac is much easier to use for not very professional users. But you showed it's not
Well he also won the original competition by existing. Rematch where he uses his full power of macros. Would love to see full power Taran against this representation of iJustine full power.
Hello
Great job, this looked like a lot of fun.
This was actually a fun and interesting video to watch that was edited by TARAN.
hell yes
Ashik Chowdhury no time limit this time
hell yes my dude, edited by our GOD TARAN
GOD TARAN
lol i knew that he edited it, he threw in justines own transitions when cutting on the judges
"I edited over a billion views" was a confusing thing to hear
*The guy who edited the Gangnam Style video once*
“Yeah, me too”
@GOKUL V she has edited all of her videos which have accumulated over 1 billion views.
Editor of despacito : Peasants
@@TheAlpha6echo 😆
she edited some videos, that all videos views combines that crosses billion. 😎
21:42 "overall it was a really great video"
*gives it a 5*
exactly
b i a s
Cos he had to end his feedback on a good note.
reminds me of that guy wit hthe hammers and the bullet proof windows, and he always said "not tough enough" even after going to town with a hammer for like 3 minutes
this is called the $ H I T sandwich
This feels like an editor showdown instead of a software showdown
Yeah i totally forgt thevideo was about that
nah, feels more like a how used to the setups were using showdown
Wait, it was about that topic...
I actually feel that people can have the most powerful editing software and it wouldn't even matter, it's the decisions the editor makes that makes the videos look good or bad, for all taran' skill he just isn't as creative as justine, she also cared about what people would say if she left what she thought could be offensive in her video, taran just doesn't care about the comments, even though they could influence his job security if people outright turned on him
@@kayleas5328 most people prefered tarans in the comments tho, ijustines felt cringy and sorta lifeless, while tarans felt corprate but not in a bad way
To be fair to Taran, cutting down your footage first rather than rushing to completion is a good editing habit to have when working on a major production. If a director orders a change, you don't want to delete completed work.
Its representative of how LTT works differently than Justine. She's the one taking decisions, so she doesn't have to worry about last minute changes. A lot of what both of them did was representative of how both of the compagnies does thing differently.
That boomer who gave my man a 5 was clearly biased (typical iSheep behaviour, but Justine ofcourse is waaay better than that), they should've given out the scores without knowing the editor
Devansh Jangid he was biased how?
@@abpdev He's a pro-mac power user.
@@randommm1516 That's exactly what I thought
Taran: Uses macro keys with his 3 keyboards and a mixer DAC box
iJustine: I’m just using my trackpad.
in a way that made it so that justine was in her comfort zone more than he was probably. Only difference for her was the headphones.
@Saprioof Not on a Mac.
@@catfan5618 this times 10. I used the HP spectre and my MacBook Pro from 2012 was still a better experience
@@Pepp_ered stop the cap
@@ayanokoji5594 MacBook's trackpads are just different, there's no any windows laptops with this kind of trackpad..
For how smugly proper Taran sounds, he’s seemingly nice, honest, precise, and gracious.
Maybe the only reason he lost was that he was editing in a different setup than he is used to
@Mikołaj Wysocki And hopefully he will reduce the usage of "zoom" in LTT videos.
@@MdIrfan11396 I disagree and so does Taren. ijustine made better editing and directing decisions. It was a better product. Macro's help speed, fluency, reduce mistakes. All the judges agreed he had less technical mistakes. Taran's video was just boring, tastes differ and iJustine's is better suited for youtube
@@WickedFalsehood I told this because I could see him try to reach out for his macros during the video....
It's that damn tone of voice that sets you on the wrong foot. I inherited the same "explaining" tone of voice from my dad and I just can't kill it off.
24:57 "Nobody should hate on someone else for using one tool or the other.
That's why this video was sponsored by Windows Movie Maker!"
it is objectively better
The best video editor for experts, and amateurs!
did anyone else notice that when the judges complained about zooming, he zoomed on purpose in this video. That cracked me up
wait where is this?
@@lavacreeperbossb9376 20:20
Yeah I saw that XD
Same with the "having fun with transitions" part
@@pierholtrop5432 no it's 21:35
How does she edit on a trackpad lol
It’s actually not hard
Just shortcut cheatcodes! I often do the same!
How do u not edit with a trackpad
using a mouse is horrible
it's actually good when you're doing that on a Mac, i edit with trackpad when i'm on my bed or something because the huge trackpad tho
i'm editing with trackpad, it's not that hard.
Such inferior software, compared to the one that I use, windows moviemaker.
Ms paint on win xp
@Chips Master Well I do the same but I convert all the frames to ascii images and open them all in notepad and just switch to next frame when I need to
Bwahahahaha!!!!!!
I edit my videos with Davinci Resolve for s a m s u n g s m a r t f r i d g e®©™
Bitch please i use adobe suite pirated
"a poor carpenter blames his tools"
- Legendary
I was about to comment on this, but I knew somebody else would have noticed.
samuel rodriguez Too good to pass!
That’s because a poor carpenter can’t afford good tools
Its like a poor dancer blames the floor 😂*indian version*
@@yougants8927 there's a Russian variant that reads as: "poor dancer blames his balls"
Judge: Your video has too many zooms and therefore people would click away.
Him not knowing Taran also edited this video and so far no-one has clicked away.
Bro, they edited that in 4hrs, didn't have the time to watch it.....
@@stevejobs7989 what. Is this actually Steve Jobs. Omg I'm a fan*ahhhh*
@@aadisahni um what
@@peteblue8828 he is steve jobs. Hes back
@@aadisahni I don't think it's him.
I loved the way Taran expressed his thought on Justine's work. Great thing to acknowledge opponents talents, he has exhibited a great sportmanship......👍❤️
Conclusion: It depends on the editor and not the software?
You have achieved nirvana
Yes, also depends on the goal. One style is for educational videos and fits more for tech videos the other is for pure entertainment and fits for more general purpose videos.
and from PC power because some programs causes little troubles with lags
Or...
Just use Blender on Linux.
_Linux Master Race._ Lol.
Conclusion: this had nothing to do with the title. It was just a goofy collaboration and nothing more.
As if Mac vs PC would be a realistic question in any case. Got money to burn? Buy a mac.
omg i did NOT realize how tall Taran is until they pointed it out so....forcefully
Hes like, 12/13ths of a Grant tall
@@a_guy_in_orange7230 how tall is grant?
@@DelightfulWalrus 6'3
@@DelightfulWalrus Assuming you are talking about Grant Ward.
His last name is Dutch
This is just a contest between two editing styles more than the platform
Thats one point of this video i think. Linus says some words at the end to this topic.
Raw footage from people like Justine who are comfortable in front of the cameras would be more polished even before editing. Hence why the she got a challenge editing this particular raw footage she was given.
Justine: brings a bunch of comfort items(I think that’s what they would classify as)
Taran: brings computer stuff
And a cardboard box. For comfort!
@@verficationaccount why didn’t he just bring a computer stand though?
@@private-lurkingcluelessnes1740 He loves boxes
@@private-lurkingcluelessnes1740 maybe he brought all the stuff in the box and then used the box as well?
So...basically they both brought a bunch of comfort items!
Taran's edit was probably more "the engineer" and Justine's edit was probably more "the entertainer". Depends on the crowd, LTT viewers come for the details and specificity, Taran is here to deliver. Can't really comment on Justine's viewers though, I'm not one of them.
that's cute if you really think that
LLT is not the other side of the road, it's just one foot off justines curbside
Personally. I liked tarans the best because his video wasn't corny.
I'm pretty sure Austin's crowd watches for detail and specificity, so I think Taran nailed it.
Its an informative video, It should let the viewer know of all the features of the device.
@@dragone521 Accurate, I loathe the effects that justine used in her video.
@Simple Tech At least they don't put flashling lights as their transations lol
Taran is a giant amongst dwarves
Damn, he's tall AF
It's all in the genes baby.
@@jedigrandmaster1773 He's normal sized. Linus Sebastian is only as tall as a washing machine.
he is 6'3" which is tall.
@@xali2008 >>LAUGHS IN DUTCH
This video is very well edited either way.
Taran did.
It was Dennis
cus he had more time
@@pedrotski No, it says in the outro that it was Taran 😂
@@z._hid It's a typo.
I feel like their editing compliments their character a lot. Justine edits her own videos, so her editing style goes hand in hand with the host's humor. While Taran's editing style is on a higher scale level, working for a company that has several dozen employees. It also has to do with their audience, Justine has a more mainstream-based audience, with Apple products being a more mainstream theme than the "tech taken to the next level" kind of energy that Linus Tech Tips has. So I can definetly see how Justine's video would be easier to watch without getting bored, while Taran's video is slightly more centered on the product that Austin is reviewing.
Both videos were great though and kudos to both editors.
perfect summary.
This video immediately went up a notch when I noticed Niko from Corridor Digital.
I know perfect judge !!
big ups for corridor
Ikr? The video kept my attention partially because I just wanted to hear what Niko had to say.
I just finished watching a Corridor video before this so it took me a bit to realize that he was out of place lol. I was just like, "Yeah, Niko, of course."
Nice miata
taran: uses premiere
justine: uses final cut
me: Laughs with windows movie maker
Me laughing in kinemaster free version
Cizor because it’s true I have movie maker on my pc and what windows doesn’t even support it anymore
Windows Movie Maker is still better than some free editors
@@10meisterballe ikr i actually downloaded it on windows 10 so i can edit a clip quickly and speed it up to send through whatsapp lol
I loved movie maker
The excessive transition effects when Justine was talking about getting her new transitions had me dying.
They had me dying when watching the final video too. Really bright and eye piercing.
I love how in the beginning, Taran is so much taller than both Linus and Ijustine that his hair is out of the frame.
Linus: "Nobody should hate someone else for the tools they use"
Commenters: "I'm going to pretend I didn't hear that"
Lol
@@dnhn.design He said " a carpenter shouldn't blame their tools" :) meaning it wasn't his softwares fault it was his decision making! They both just over thought ,,,imo
Linus is actually right.
Taran: I thought my music was worse.
Judge: I thought it was better!
Justine: I liked mine!
Yeah bro, he is super humble I see!
Typical women
UmbriellSattori huh?
The real winner is Austin here got two editors for him 😂😂
Haha..so true
FOR FREE
FOR C H E A P
*S T O N K S*
You know Ken is still gonna edit it
as a music producer and DJ I would LOVE to see a similar video with music production and/or DJ software. everyone gets so defensive about what they use but like it was said in the video, "a bad carpinter blames his tools"
Tarans style is just the way i like it: informative but memeable
I simply like simplistic style much more than a more "spiced" one. I love Paul's Hardware editing for that, it's just a cut, it's just that and it's perfect for his style.
It was more of a test of the synergy between the editor and the youtuber, than of the editor's skills by themselves.
Who asked nigga
@@1sainttropez Stop... Get some help.
Yeah yeah, right right.
This is like a cooking show but for editing
lol ikr
Was thinking that
I wanna like this comment but it's on 666 and I don't wanna mess that up
I agree. I wish there was more videos like this. They should do this again but DaVinci Resolve and Premiere Pro
Haha so true 😄
Taran's back is straighter because of the massive back muscles he got from building his treehouse.
Zdawg Dawgdawg Taran, not Tarzan! 😂JK.
Coming back after he announced he’s quitting… 💚 Taran will always be iconic and I hope we can see what he does in the future!
The truth has been revealed where Teran is going.
So little do people talk about how humble Taran is.
no, he just ate a lot of humble pie when he lost. you're just ignoring the trash talk that he came out with at the start
@@alpeshr82 shush iJustine fan
@@alpeshr82 shush
@@alpeshr82 Not scripted, part of the show ?
I think he still wants to get a job with iJustine. It's part of the interview lol.
when you realize you enjoyed the video where the guy who edit the video is the same guy who lost the challenge in the video you just watched
mind blowing
yep i think he would have won if the simpleton's sister wasn't a judge
rott 1 well Justine is just better then the other guy
Ali-Mery you do realize this wasn’t supposed to be a competition between them right it was about their methods on editing and what they used also you must be slow because the guy who you think is worse than the simpleton actually edited this whole video.
@@alimery07 yeah you're just delusional. stop talking man
I want to see how it looks when Linus edits a LTT video himself
Yea not that good lol
the oldest videos and some NCIX videos should be edited by himself
Power Point and Excel.They need to do that.
@@justinyhc3057 Yea, he stopped doing it way before he elevated the production value to what we see today though.
LTT is where it is today because LInus does not edit the videos.
"Your video was better on a technical level."
"Your video didn't have the production quality of Justine's."
Me: Huh?
I mean its 2 different things
as a video editor i totally understood that. let me explain:
i can watch one of my edits 10 times over and make it more seamless, getting "technically" better each time
but if i'm not inspirred and in the mood, i can make a technically perfect video that seems soulless and boring.
on the other hand some days i get footage that i love editing and have that spark of creativity which results in an engaging high quality final video, but i'm so over excited i miss technical problems like uneven horizon or inconsistent audio levels or jerky camera motion etc.
@@KaelDenna eh, i don't really get it. As somone who's been editing videos and studying the art of production for years at this point, i genuinely do not understand how they came to that conclusion.
@@KaelDenna well then her loving the video shes editing has nothing to do with having production quality does it
I think they may have been referring to the aesthetic value
Why does Taran look like he has an inside joke with himself and is gonna burst out laughing at any second but he tries really hard to contain it?
Because if anyone saw both of the videos uninterrupted side by side again and again they would be thinking the same thing. The point of an editor 99% of the time is to make unobtrusive editing decisions.
Justine edits as if it's her own video where it fits more to show her "personality in the edit", but Austin Evans is completely different.
I actually would enjoy watching iJustine but her editing is just unbearable to me, especially the music.
you should try it yourself - take a puff before meeting with clients. You will know that you could not laugh, but some barriers would have gone.
That’s true
taran: uses premiere
justine: uses final cut
me: *Laughs in Davinci Resolve*
Me: **Cries with Filmora 9 running on a Celeron.**
Windows Movie Maker
@@xavier1964 wym ms movie maker is the better editing software
Me: _Sighs with laptop unable to run even Windows Movie Maker without chugging hard._
Plebs, I'm using PowerPoint 2003
Well, sounds like it ended up being a directorial competition rather than which setup is best for editing. They were judged on creative skills, not the effectiveness of the tool.
So I'll give the judges a 2 out of 10 :)
I noticed that as well. But ultimately, it really comes down to communicating the message making the talent look good. I use Sony Vegas for editing. Just comparing what it does with what I see them doing with the software they are using, the basics of what the tools do are pretty much the same. The additional features are different and there may be some shortcuts that make one better than the others, but I think I could use any of the three and come out with pretty much the same video without pulling my hair out.
I give the judges a 0.3457 becuase i think that doing it right is more important than doing it wrong in a better way. Right?
justine did seem to finish a lot earlier... despite snacking, letting the dog out, etc...
the sec they said it's UA-cam video so it must be entertainer
I knew they were bad
That's funny. Didn't realize that. So true.
I really appreciate Taran's humbleness, and at the same time, Justine is praising Taran for his work. It's fair that Justine won, and we didn't get to see but snippets, but Taran did a fantastic job too. Congrats to both of you for you work and your being humble. Great guys/girls!
Humbleness? Where? After he lost you mean?
@@triple7marc yeah, not everybody is a "fair loser", like being able to praise the winner etc.
I wrote this a year ago, so that's just what I remember.
Taran: You made me use 2% of my power
mere imac mortals
I like the way when Justine said she doesn’t like gaps in videos, Taran made like 3 cuts in her sentence. Clever detail
And even used the same transition packs when Justine was talking about it haha
17:35
Linus: Talks quietly about Taran to avoid interfering or to annoy him
Taran with 1 earcup off: Bro I hear you
no its so ijustine doesnt know whats going down.
20:03 "The zooming was a little bit too much for me." I see what Taran did there.
The fact justine got up to change the temperature herself, stopped to look at snacks, let her dog out, all while poking at taran, while Still editing, just goes to show how confident she feels w her edits after editing thousands of her videos for years, even though theres a time limit.
So true
Yeah I’m a PC user but she’s cool.
She was NOT sweating those 4 hours lmao
He was not taking it very seriously tbh, he did say that he was not using PR pro as a pro tool but master the basics, of course it would be amazing in a normal youtube video, but judges are usually very picky.
@@manwithstds7503 oh forsure, i wasnt trying to talkbad about him, i just was pointing out her confidence in her skills. She could have stayed in her chair but she felt good about it & had fun all around. Both outcomes were great.
The real punishment is having to edit an Austin Evan's video
I agree
@@austinevans lol
@@austinevans the highest level of humor, when you can laugh over yourself. Good job
Evans Austin Agree I
I used the Austin Evans to destroy Austin Evans
Tarans editing style is a lot better because for me it's just not as distracting as Justines with all the effects.
Yeah I mean I think this video showcased their styles and workflows pretty well.
Taran comes at it from a content-creation and artistic angle, and he's very aware of the technicalities of the video, so he tends to put a ton of polish on things and make sure the bare minimum looks as nice as possible, even if he doesn't put as much on top of it.
Justine tends to come at it from a content-consumption angle, making sure the video is as engaging as possible first and polishing the flow last.
Justines edit looks like something made for kids, the effects, the transitions
@@catutz1317 well it was made for Mac people.
Payperheirplain yep
Payperheirplain good point
"I often shoot and edit a video in under 5 hours" that is the mark of a true professional, jeez
Are you the one who’s been on UA-cam for over 15 years ? No. Don’t be mad she won
@@Kubulek17 bro I'm not. I was impressed how quickly she could do that
It’s a 100 years old debunked Marxist theory that something is worthy more because it took longer to be done.
Justine: Final Cut
Taran: Premiere
Me: I use iMovie on my iPhone 7
next : imovie vs windows movie maker
Me: uses Kinemaster
Me last month: What’s iMovie? Must be an Apple product! LOL
you will never get a job in hollywood if use Imovie lol
@@nick-vo9tx it’s a phone app. No shit
I love that they edited down taran’s height.
EDIT: I did notice that Taran was the one who edited the video.
Me 2
also me
I love how taran edited down taran's height.
@@bas_de_beer yea it's very funny.
he literally just bent his knees lmao
"he sounds like a diva!"
*brings 2 chapsticks, a blanket, and her dog*
Honestly that just sounds like everyone that works from home
haha caden that is many funny i many chuckle
Wasn’t this recorded at her house tho ?
Caden Guizar this was recorded at her house lol
He has his own freaking room in a workspace where most people sit next to each other
I have a huge amount of respect for Taran being as humble as he was. It takes a very strong person to be able to critically self evaluate like he did- especially in-front of the judges and everyone.
At 17:45 Taran cuts out Justine's pauses as she talks about cutting out other people's pauses lol
Jimmy Wen he also zoomed in on the 4th judge when he complained about the comedic zooming
@@lucasleite694 21:36
Subtle. Niceee
well played
Lucas Leite they shoot in like 8k raw at LTT on those red cams so they have the pixels to do the comedic zooming. He’s not going to stop just like that after one hater, how else can they justify those 30k cameras and 1000000TB media servers to Linus
21:35 "TMZ style zoom in and out is too much"
Taran (editing this video at the exact point):
How do you like me now?
As an ordinary viewer, getting an inside look into the process of making a UA-cam video is my main takeaway from this video. It's really fascinating how much time and effort goes into them, this has left me with a new sense of appreciation for creators.
moshe gelt ok
Only thing is these guys don't do their own editing anymore...
Yea you're right
@@macintush I think Justine just proved you wrong on that one
Jeffrey Librebowski ijustine?
This was really well done. I love the contrasts in styles where he is so hyper focused and serious because thats his job. Justine on the other hand before the last bit was using editing to relax, and just chill. He had like 5 things and help directly from Austin while she just ate snacks and just used what was on her system.
The styles of editing shows well and really visualize each person perfectly. Justine also proved why she does do her own editing while being an OG on this platform. To me this was less about the operating system or suites used and more about that. I do wish they showed more about both programs cuz some ppl never used a mac or a pc. Fun video as always from LTT, almost as fun as this segway, to the other comments. Lol
Taran's first browser tab: "Nyan Cat - 10 hours"
Ah, a peak behind the LTT curtain reveals a man of culture.
😂
So he was listening to that for 4 hours to speed himself up?🤣🤣🤣🤣
4:04 - 4:10
He Is a man Of Culture i see... I always feel so happy whenever i spot these type of people (no sarcasm)
it's like white noise, but 100% more annoying
Normal People: Hells Kitchen
Nerds: LTT Editing Showdown.
Im both lmao
Lmao I literally thought of this
Enjoyed this way more
"Normal" is wrong word.
Oh shit I just watched hells kitchen before this video
Twist ending: This video was edited on a PC
By Taran
@@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος lol
@@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος so I guess which one do you like better between the vid that you are seeing and ijustine's Austin Even's vid.
@@NeedingSleep Both were great, but I believe Taran's was more professional.
@@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος yea ijustine is more on the funny and entertaining side of editing while Taran is a very professional editor.
Watching this was very enjoyable, I am not a video editor but I thoroughly enjoyed this and I I have not watched an iJustine video in a very long time but, I found myself smiling the entire time while your video. Good job to both of you. Great video...
I am going to massage my face now. TTFN.
The video is clearly editor vs editor rather than Mac vs PC.
No not really, Taran admits iJustine's video was more dynamic. I was under the assumption that Taran would win but hey it was fair game.
@@raiduh899 again, like he said, it's editor vs editor because they were judge on editing style. It has nothing to do with the software
@@quentin4031 Thanks for making my point more clear!
Exactly! The title should be "Editor A x Editor B, Who's The Best" or something like that, this video has nothing to do with the tool used.
Taran: Is Justine ahead of me?
Justine: “i wonder if Austin knows how funny he is?! His outtakes are hilarious! *hehehehehe* ”
Removes jokes anyway
Lol
I liked your video a lot, 5/10 IGN.
5/7 best editing
It was the best video from LTT, ever, but too much water bottles, 4/10
I mean, technically the editing was perfect, but like he said, it was boring. Technical prowess isn't all that makes a video good :p
Absolute GOTY 3.5/10 GN
The edit had a little something for everyone, 9/10
Man this is such a great challenge, especially post covid I'm so glad this happened, great character dynamics in this one
IJustine: Quirky youtube edit
Taran: Information youtube edit
@@quicktoreason2722 How very true. The focus was wrong, and the things it was judged one was wrong. It's not who made the most attractive youtube video, but which was the most effective at dealing with technical solutions.
basically
Gamers Nexus: Boooooring UA-cam edit.
@@BulletMagnetMan but informative, would you rather learn first aid from a guy who knows what he's doing, or a guy who only sorta does and is slightly funny
@@cocoshort6528 @Coco You smell like someone with a sub par PC hating on MAC users... get over it, stop with teh MAC vs PC wars, i have both, they have their own pros and cons that PC users will never get... There are always creative people doing creative weird ways, and boring teachers...
When Justine said that Taran left in rants as opposed to cutting those down. I think thats the difference in communities. The LTT community loves when Linus goes on a mini rant or goes completely off topic.
Edit- the "TMZ Zoom in" is a quirk we love too.
And if it's in the script, i would think you would keep it?
Conor maybe keep your hate to yourself?
Conor Calm down dude. I was just saying there's a difference in audiences and what they like.
Yeah, and who are these judges, Corridor Digital, yes. Bitwit, yes. Justine's sister and some rando dude, gtfo.
Get a variety of judges, we had 1 tech judge, 1 professional level judge, 1 iPhone dude,and 1 sister.
Maybe keep the pro dude, the PC dude, and get Austin's editor, and 1 other, majority of the judges had small attention span audience, yes Austin has that, but not as bad as Justine's audience type, and LTT audience likes creativity with information, and GamersNexus likes information.
The editing styles were a big swaying thing, look at the dude who says "This music doesn't help hear information" about Justine and proceeds to give a 5 to Taran because "too informative" .. excuse me, wth?
@Conor Literally everyone likes ijustine, including the entire linus team. Who cares that she buys oreos lol linus made a video about the underwear he wears...
14:50 "I got tired of paying double for the hardware"
I felt that
The Earth felt that. 😂
Hands down, one of your absolutely best videos. Watching two 'unseen' people do what they do best under pressure (and knowing a bit about editing) was incredible: DEFINITELY more content like this. Thank you Justine and Taran, and judges. I felt the pressure.
Its unfair testing since its more "editor vs editor" rather than "Mac vs PC" and it's just judged from Creativity
I think that was the point of the video. People are so caught up in "Mac vs PC" they forget that editing is more than just the hardware you use...
@@Xyler94 The whole point is Mac vs PC though, not iJustice vs Taran.
@@minartson And they knew their conclusion. "It doesn't matter". To get a true Apples to Apples comparison, you'd need to have someone fluent in both programs, be given the same time, and given the same video to render with the same about style.
The face we had the variables of Windows, Asus, MacBook, MacOS, Justine and Taran, the competition was "Justine vs Taran". Because there's no way to validate which is better with such variables.
@@Xyler94 exactly right. if we'd wanted to compare like-for-like, they could've both used premiere, but this wasn't about benchmarking the tech, this was about comparing the styles & approaches of two editors who happen to use these different toolsets.
back in the linear edit days, I would get runners & tape-ops asking me to show them how to edit. I'd tell them to hook a 9-way remote cable between two decks & find some footage to play with.
"no," they'd say, "show me how to use *that*" & point at the GVG edit controller in one of the suites.
I'd tell them "I can show you how to edit, or I can show you how to work the edit controller- which do you want me to do?"
editing is part of story telling. the script & the storyboard (if there is one) are where you start.
if you don't know what the story is, you're wasting your time, whatever the hardware is.
@@minartson to be fair though, the title & description here do hint heavily at an 'ecosystem' comparison with the added bonus clickbait of 'mac vs PC', & that simply never happened except for a fleeting mention of the different handling of the LUT. so yeah, that got lost somewhere.
0:28 Taran’s jokes about his height are gold.
cracked up so hard. IT WAS ALL PART OF HIS PLANS!!!
Justine: who uses scripts ewww
Linus: *sweats nervously*
UKYusei This is on LTT so Justine was probably reading that line off the script
I think Justine was exaggerating. While she might not have a script, she probably makes notes on what to talk about. Since she's a one woman band, that's ok!
Whereas at LMG, it's really important to have a script, if there is no script, there is no video. 🙂
Locutus I think many people forget that LTT is practically its own media company at this point, with each employee having his own role. The person writing the script isn’t the same person reading off it in front of the camera, which in turn makes a detailed script all the more crucial. Being a one-woman army, iJustine likely has her own notes on what to say in her videos, but she can afford to wing it more compared to LTT.
so they gave her a lollipop so she can lick it on screen? Was that their plan? Ugh. Men. Am i right?
@@curt8806 lol that's sarcasm right?
15:16 final cut Pro is for quick edits
Justine: edits continuously for 4 hours
That's a quick edit
"I used to be a Mac guy, but I got tired of paying double for... hardware!"
F A C T S .
You know it's true when Nicko himself says it.
Fact - Macs are 2x more likely to be infected by Malware than Windows machines.
@@Olie956 source: drug abuse.
Aaron Garza totally
@@Olie956 sources?
kyle says "it wins just from that"
Also kyle: "let me give him less"
No matter what, taran is still the macro king.
Yeah man👍
You mean Terran? Stuck in the Kuprulo Sector?
AyidIsMe I preferred his tbh. Hers was just all over the place
And macros do win often
@@schnicetv8253 be prepared for the UED to come back
Thoroughly enjoyed this video, and I love the takeaway at the end. Couple of solid individuals. 👌🏼
This should be turned into a weekly series like hell kitchen
yessssssss we need that!
That's RAW!!!!
сэммич
OMG YES!!!
This is just like a modern “I’m a Mac” “I’m a pc” commercial
i miss those.
windows please dont say pc personal computer both of them are pc-s
Skiller S I know but in the commercials they said I’m a Mac I’m a pc and even though a Mac is technically a personal computer, I’ve never heard anybody call a Mac a PC
@@joeyscerbo7776 xd idk about that
And im a chromebook.
The judges: Taran looses
The comments: TARAN DESERVES MOREEE!!!
Loses*
He really did; imo since the judges found out that the first video was Justine’s they favoured her more for some reason. Before they find out it’s her video, they clearly say the colour grading and correction is horrendous; however while judging they say that it was better which is contradicting themselves
Iceay right exactly; what with all the blurred colour transitions and loud sudden entries into parts of the video, it almost felt like she presumed her audience consists of children and morons
@@stormbringer228_ You are making stuff up, they never mentioned the color grading and correction is horrendous. They said the color shifts because it had a second or two of a color mishap and never mentioned color again.
*"yay" sound effects intensifies*
I can't believe how much I've enjoyed watching this video!!!!! 23 minutes smiling ear to ear, and the other 2 laughing out loud!!! LOVED IT!!!
Are we gonna ignore the fact that Justine used a freakin' Touchpad to edit the video.
Apple touchpads are amazing hahah
@@brokenlegend23 they are but they can't beat the gaming mice, especially the high end ones.
@@abbas23hussain why the hell would you need a gaming mice to edit a video ?!?
@@cantorgauss gaming mice aren't just for gaming, they can be used for a variety of purposes. Compared to normal mice they are much better as they have programmable buttons, superior sensors, better DPI and much more. Not to mention the RGB lighting.
@@abbas23hussain Especially the RGB lighting is ESSENTIAL for video editing. Somebody referred RGB to as cancer (was it Linus?) and I agree.
Taran is an educationally oriented editor while iJustine leans towards entertainment.
And editors and camera people are the only ones that are actually good in LTT as well.
This is a really good point, without discussing the purpose of the videos, it's hard to rank them. Which one was more entertaining is what was graded by the judges, I wonder if the question was different. "Which one is a better review?" Interesting comment.
I came to this conclusion myself when they mentioned “This is meant for UA-cam” and I bet a lot of iJustine’s advantage came from points docked over that
They were editing the same videos, so I doubt one of them had a drastic information/education difference than the other. It's not like they were editing out huge chunks of the actual information, just the parts that were repetitive or irrelevant. I doubt either video showcased significantly more of the product than the other, so what it really comes down to is how you can make the same information more interesting.
IMO, several advantages in iJustine corner since before starting. If the data we have is right. She has edited more videos, or so they said ( she has edited a crazy ton, I just don't know how many has he edited, specially before getting into LTT). This is in most graphic content making a solid advantage, you learn a lot with practice, even if the genius vein of Taran or whoever will surely lead him far. Seeing the amount of video edited by justine, the "shark" adjective is not casual. Also, she is both the editor and the content creator, the actor and director of the scenes. Has actual TV acting experience. Also experience on interacting with the community, comments, etc, and tracking that tightly during years. A mountain of experience to know what works better with a very specific audience, how to enhance a take, etc. The experience is also due to age, Taran is younger, and with exceptions, more years in some duties is a lot more tricks and that. Surely if you take Justine at Taran's moment, years ago, she would have lost against him, the guy has good potential. Also, IMO, editing YT videos, anyway, is extremely far from deep FX editing, and all the handling, 3D stuff, etc. Even in pure video editing, these tasks are pretty basic. So, not sure if the test serves to consider stuff at certain deeper level.
I... don't feel the "5" qualification was fair, tho... casually, it was from the mac based guy, hehe. :D But in al honesty, his advice did seem very good, although I have not seen the footage and the edited videos. I can understand if mac pro users feel intimidated by today's PC's capabilities in pro fields. Not entrance, it's many years established. I've always seen instances of those pros fearing or complaining of increased competition. But hey, life is so.
My only fear is... if aaaall this was scripted. Kindda rigged ? As... the cocky pose of Taran at the beginning... Dunno if he's Canadian or US (and anyway, stereotypes are rubbish) but... kindda sth was off to me, there. It kindda doesn't match the personality I'm guessing in this tall guy. So... it very well could be, not that the entire thing was rigged ( I dunno) or the judges decision (either can't know), but is more possible that the cocky comments were totally scripted, on purpose, to make it interesting, or pursuit an agenda Mac/Pc (in order to favor Mac), or just to give it some extra bait (to "heat" the match).
In any case, VERY interesting video. For us more techy people in the side of graphic content creation (my main work tho I like hardware in general). And one way or the other, hats off to Justine. She's very talented. It'd be completely expected to win, if all we know is true, and this was all, well, real.
Nah, doesn't seem like a fake. I still don't buy the Taran's cocky attitude. I believe that's what I'm almost sure it's scripted, to give it a bit of emotion.
For me Tarren is better .. Justine's editing was more like a "vlog" editing not for tech/any reviews so 🤷🏽♂️
I must agree with you
Justine's editing feels like editing for a 14 year old to watch. Taran's editing looks like something an 18-year old would watch. It's a product of their style. Justine edits more variety content while Taran edits tech content. Of course variety content is going to be more geared toward a younger and more diverse audience while tech content will be geared toward a primarily male and older audience.
@@andrewb378 Let me guess, you're 18? That's also a hilarious gap - as if someone is 18 years old then they're so much more mature than they were 4 years ago.
@@MrKamillordo it's not a matter of maturity it's a matter of focus. If you're 18 watching a tech video you're going to be paying attention whether there's fancy graphics or not. If you're 14 watching a lifestyle video, you probably won't be paying as much attention so the video needs to be flashier with more/faster cuts, graphics, more up tempo music, jokes, etc.
The age gap itself isn't that big because people building their first PC where they'd be watching tech videos probably aren't going to be older than about 25. People watching Justine's videos probably won't be more than 15 or 16. People who watch UA-cam consistently probably aren't much older than 30 and I think even that's a stretch.
@@MrKamillordo Trust me, an 18 year old is way more mature than a 14 year old. Source: I'm 18 and used to be 14 and know people who used to be 14.
They need to give us raw footage and let the subscribers edit it and see everyone’s edit styles
A nice 2 year long video.
Can you guys do competition videos like this more often? As an editor, this was pretty entertaining to watch. I feel like professional chefs feel the same when they watch cooking competitions on TV.
Should have added a final shot of Taran looking at the sky and walking away like he's leaving Linus Media group
He's not really leaving LMG is he ?
*(Android Version)*
*Taran : uses Premiere*
*iJustine : uses Final Cut*
*Me : laughs with* _KINEMASTER_
Credit: @Ainz
Me too XD
Same lol
hold my DaVinci Resolve
yes
@@ebux9885 that's the best answer
Amazing colab, one of the best and heartwarming I've need in awhile!