Old Scottish Carol

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @michaelgrieve7578
    @michaelgrieve7578 3 роки тому +1

    The air is unmistakably Scottish -lovely Graham

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Many thanks for watching and commenting.

  • @mattleach958
    @mattleach958 3 роки тому +1

    This is beautiful, Graham. Many thanks. I just subscribed to your channel. I always enjoy your wise and educated comments on our various UA-cam organ community channels.
    I'm a 66 year old organ student/assistant church organist/piano on the North Coast of California.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you for watching and commenting. You certainly live in a beautiful part of the world. Several years ago my family were on holiday in California (my sister lives in Texas). We stayed in a beach house between Malibu and Oxnard. I can close my eyes and still see the North Pacific Ocean - magnificent!

  • @apprendrelebalafon9819
    @apprendrelebalafon9819 3 роки тому +2

    Magnifique composition. Phil

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Merci beaucoup d'avoir regardé et commenté - je suis heureux que vous ayez apprécié cette composition !

  • @ChannelRalph
    @ChannelRalph 3 роки тому +1

    Love it, love it!!! ❤

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you very much. I hope you enjoy the score I emailed to you. Happy New Year!

    • @ChannelRalph
      @ChannelRalph 3 роки тому +1

      Thanks! I’ve now listened and followed the score, several times. Not only is it pretty, there’s actually some very clever writing in the inner lines.
      Its well after midnight here in Oz, but I look forward to playing it later this week.
      Cheers!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      @@ChannelRalph You are very welcome. Any 'clever writing' is purely accidental!

    • @ChannelRalph
      @ChannelRalph 3 роки тому

      @@grahamtwist your composing life seems to be full of such "accidents"! Yaaaaaaaaaaay!!!!!

  • @Pianolisapark315
    @Pianolisapark315 3 роки тому +1

    Beautiful share my friend! Fantastic video, nice holiday song!
    Like #36!
    Happy new year to you! 🙏🌹

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you very much for watching and commenting. A very happy New Year to you, too!

  • @SecretsofOrganPlaying
    @SecretsofOrganPlaying 3 роки тому +1

    It’s very interesting to compare the two pieces featuring the same carol side by side. At the end I forgot it was Guilmant’s piece. Really lovely. Thanks Graham!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you for listening and leaving a comment.

  • @musicarrangestudio9134
    @musicarrangestudio9134 3 роки тому +2

    It's very lyrical music! It feels like walking on the night road and admiring the stars in the night sky.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you very much for watching and commenting: I really appreciate it!

  • @digitalpipes
    @digitalpipes 3 роки тому +3

    If you wanted to put Guilmant to shame, well, you managed! Your arrangement is original, full of nice and interesting harmonic solutions, musically engaging and extremely pleasant to listen to. I am tempted to say that this is one of the best pieces you wrote, if not the best. Guilmant’s piece, played after yours, sounds like an utterly boring waffle. Bravo Graham, very very very well done! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Gosh, Paolo! I'm blushing! I think the Guilmant composition is in no way indicative of that great organist's abilities or output. He was clearly fascinated with the bagpipes (!) and his 'Noël Ecossais' was probably just a bit of fun, with his French tongue firmly in his cheek! I can imagine what Guilmant might have said about my attempts at composition! He would not have been as generous as you, for certain! "Sacrébleu ! Quel tas de vieux déchets. La musique de Monsieur Twist doit être classée immédiatement. . . à la poubelle !"

    • @digitalpipes
      @digitalpipes 3 роки тому +2

      @@grahamtwist Pfff! Guilmant n'est certainement pas une grande étoile au firmament des compositeurs romantiques français... and in this case I think he drank a bagpipe full of boredom!!! 😂😂😂

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      @@digitalpipes Haha! Boy - you don't hold back! I'll have to guard against inciting your ire! But you're right: it is a rather dull piece . . . on par with most of my creations!

    • @digitalpipes
      @digitalpipes 3 роки тому +1

      @@grahamtwist on par with most of Guilmant’s creations!!! 😂😂😂

  • @lluisrafalessole-classical5068
    @lluisrafalessole-classical5068 3 роки тому +1

    Wow Beautiful music 🎹👏 Bravo
    Well played friend

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Gràcies per mirar i comentar, ho agraeixo molt. Molt Feliç Any Nou per a tu!

  • @johnhiggins7140
    @johnhiggins7140 3 роки тому +1

    Dear Graham, what a delightful composition, with such an incredible and meaningful story behind it! I really appreciate and value how you are so informative, including telling a good story!
    Your composition is delightful, you have a real gift and talent, which I'm sure is underpinned by a lot of hard work, so well done for persisting to complete it!
    I apologise I'm so late commenting on this, I missed the initial posting.
    Thank you again, and all the very best! Take care John

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      It is always very kind of you, John, to take the time and trouble to comment - I know you are a busy man (and I owe you an email!). Thank you!

    • @johnhiggins7140
      @johnhiggins7140 3 роки тому

      @@grahamtwist Hi Graham, it's an absolute delight to hear your music and stories! Take care John
      Ps I really like the Hereford Cathedral HW sound, how do you find it?

  • @MarkusDrejaOrganist
    @MarkusDrejaOrganist 3 роки тому +1

    Even after Christmas a all time music piece! Thans for your great rendition Graham

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      You are very kind, Markus. I really value your support! Ich habe deinen Kanal abonniert und freue mich darauf, einige deiner Aufnahmen zu sehen und zu kommentieren.

  • @AltoonaYourPiano
    @AltoonaYourPiano 3 роки тому +1

    This sounded so beautiful. I love the sound of this arrangement and the organ you played on. Truly gorgeous results!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you very much for watching and commenting - I really appreciate it! I have now browsed your channel and there is much there for me to discover! Creating music is so very rewarding, so thanks for dipping your toes into my pond!

  • @cablenelsonbabygrandpiano842

    Very good 👍

  • @mitpfeiffenundsayten
    @mitpfeiffenundsayten 3 роки тому +1

    Merry Christmas, dear Graham! I'm glad to have you as friend here on UA-cam. Best wishes and many greetings from Germany, Ralf.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Vielen Dank, Ralf! Ich übermittle Ihnen und Ihrer Familie die besten Weihnachtsgrüße und wünsche Ihnen und Ihrer Familie alles Gute für das Jahr 2022. Ich bin dankbar für die Unterstützung, die Sie beim Ansehen und Kommentieren meines Kanals bieten - es wird sehr geschätzt!

    • @mitpfeiffenundsayten
      @mitpfeiffenundsayten 3 роки тому +1

      @@grahamtwist wir wünschen Ihnen ebenfalls eine frohe und gesegnete Weihnachtszeit und alles Gute für das neue Jahr. Ich freue mich schon jetzt auf unseren Austausch im kommenden Jahr! Viele liebe Grüße von der Mosel, Ralf.

  • @gminor680
    @gminor680 3 роки тому +1

    A beautiful and reflective piece Graham. With apologies to our friends across "la Manche", I definitely preferred your treatment.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      That is so very generous of you, Tim. Should I ever succeed in ascending to your genius as a composer, then I will have arrived at a point where we can both wave with confidence to our friends across "la Manche"! Maybe Alexandre was not quite so enamoured with the bagpipes after all!

    • @gminor680
      @gminor680 3 роки тому +1

      @@grahamtwist Graham, if you ever end up at my level, it will certainly not be by "ascending"! ;)

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      @@gminor680 Well, Tim, when you are at the bottom of the pile, there is only one possible direction of travel (other than the exit door!) . . . and in my eyes, you are at the top of the pile!

    • @gminor680
      @gminor680 3 роки тому

      @@grahamtwist Let's just leave it with me modestly admitting that some of my compositions work a bit better than average! :)

  • @Daves_PianoAndPipes
    @Daves_PianoAndPipes 3 роки тому +1

    Great melody! 🎹 I get lovely Christmas vibes from listening to this

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you for watching and commenting - I really appreciate it!

    • @Daves_PianoAndPipes
      @Daves_PianoAndPipes 3 роки тому

      @@grahamtwist Anytime! Have a wonderful Holiday season 🎹

  • @RienSchalkwijk
    @RienSchalkwijk 3 роки тому +1

    I’m astonished! A beautiful composition, made and played with passion. You can hear the proud Scottish meander trough the musical landscape. Beautiful. And as a encore my beloved Guilmant. Wow. Is this a great way to end the day with a smile. Thanks Graham.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you, Rien! Your profusion of fabulous recordings give me so much joy . . . so I felt I must at least try and get one upload for your every hundred. I'm glad you enjoyed my effort - the Guilmant is the Christmas bonus (some real music by a real composer!). . . or should that be consolation? You can decide!

  • @nsk5282
    @nsk5282 3 роки тому +1

    Beautifully done, Graham! I don't know anything about organ samples, but I love what I hear and how it's played. Thank you for your continuing dedication to composition and performance of beautiful music!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      You are much too kind - but thank you! I love to try and write music for the people who enrich my life . . . so I think I'll have to create a piano composition for you. I sense you are a romantic, so I'll have to see what I can do!!

    • @nsk5282
      @nsk5282 3 роки тому

      @@grahamtwist Dear Graham, I don't know what I did or say to deserve such honor, even a possibility to be a dedicatee ... You certainly have great friends and colleagues musicians that are much more deserving of this high privilege. But you are the boss, and it would be my pleasure to play the music you compose! Happy New Year and may it bring more beautiful compositions from you!

  • @stefanberger1427
    @stefanberger1427 3 роки тому +1

    Beautiful, thank you so much! Merry Christmas and greetings from Germany

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Vielen Dank fürs Zuschauen und Kommentieren - das freut mich sehr!

  • @TheEves
    @TheEves 3 роки тому +2

    This is wonderful, so well performed! Massive thumbs up from two Scottish girls!! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Gosh! Thank you so much for listening and commenting. Looking at your channel, you are quite a distance from me musically (not a church organ in sight with you!) so I can't imagine what pointed you towards my version of this delightful Scottish melody. But I appreciate you watching. Merry Christmas and Happy Hogmanay!

  • @volkmarbusse
    @volkmarbusse 3 роки тому +1

    Such a beautiful piece with these wonderful fade-ins of pictures from the Christmas story of the Bible. I'll email you so you can send me the sheet music. I will try it on my piano. Merry chrismas Graham.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you so much for watching and commenting. Vastly inferior to Fraser's improvisations, I know! But I'm glad you enjoyed this composition!

  • @colinjenkins8124
    @colinjenkins8124 3 роки тому +2

    I enjoyed your treatment and development of the carol Graham. What inspiration you have. Quite a pleasant contrast to the Guilmant which I've been playing for years but decided not to include in any service this year. [Too much music from which to select!] I not heard the fascinating tale about Guilmant, so thanks for your research.

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you so much for watching and commenting, Colin. I'm glad you know and play the Guilmant version, so I hope you don't object too much to my attempt with the same melody. As you remark, there's plenty of good music out there to select from and play . . . and by established composers, too!

  • @RalphLooij
    @RalphLooij 3 роки тому +1

    Always nice to get to know a 'new' (for me) carol, and what better introduction than by a composition on this carol by Mr Twist himself?
    I really like how you combined the Scottish elements of this melody with the French romantic style. Bravo, Graham!
    I'm planning to look more into French romantic composers, I think Guilmant would be a great start, since Guilmant often uses elements of the French classical style, of which I'm more familiar with. But first things first: I have to buy a swell pedal ;)

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thanks, Ralph. I look forward to hearing you reinterpret Baroque music featuring your new swell pedal!

  • @RoDi01
    @RoDi01 3 роки тому +2

    You played this so beautiful lovely. Your melodies have their own power of their own (I hope the translator was right here... ?! sorry if not!). The origin: Sie haben das wunderschön gespielt. Ihre Melodien haben eine ganz eigene Kraft in sich.
    Thanks, and greetings from Munich!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Vielen Dank für Ihren Kommentar zu meiner Komposition und Leistung. Ich habe mir deinen Kanal angeschaut und wir haben viele Gemeinsamkeiten (!): eine lange Pause vom Instrument von mehreren Jahrzehnten und wir werden nie das Niveau professioneller Kirchenmusiker erreichen! Und natürlich verbindet uns unsere Bewunderung für die Talente und den Spaß von Fraser Gartshore!

  • @alexgraziani5923
    @alexgraziani5923 3 роки тому +1

    Hi Graham. Thank you again for this recording. It was a pleasure to discover this Scottish Christmas song. I love both your and Guillmant's compositions. The Hereford's Cathedral sample set is a wondreful choice for these pieces as well! As always, great to hear you playing :)

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you so much, Alex. I started this composition over a year ago, so it was rather a long time getting finished! And, of course, I owe you some music too that needs to be finished. It will be completed some time in the New Year. Merry Christmas to you and Adel!

  • @remi-chapalain
    @remi-chapalain 3 роки тому +2

    This is very beautiful Graham ! I didn't know this tune before, I'm glad you recorded Guilmant's version too. Congratulations for this brillant and colorful composition ! I try to keep on composing too, but I miss inspiration...
    I wish you the best Graham !

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Merci beaucoup d'avoir regardé et commenté, Rémi. Je suis sûr que l'inspiration viendra et vous écrirez une autre composition fabuleuse. Vous pouvez voir à quel point je suis lent dans mes efforts ! Cela ne me dérange pas tellement d'improviser. . . c'est l'affaire fastidieuse d'avoir à marquer (score, in English!) mes tentatives que je trouve difficile !

  • @christopherglenn3240
    @christopherglenn3240 3 роки тому +2

    What a lovely melody and so warmly expressed with your arrangement. And, that crescendo was ah-mazing! Goose bumps. I'm glad to hear your selection of solo reeds over the idea of bagpipes! Great work, Graham. Oh, and that sweater. 'Tis the season. :)

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you for watching and commenting, Christopher! Of course, this music is very far removed from your recent fabulous uploads of Franck and Mendelssohn! I thought if I wore my Christmas jumper, it might distract viewers from listening too carefully and spotting the many little slips that give the recording a particular 'Twist' feel! As ever, you are too kind . . . it must be the season of goodwill and joy to all men!

  • @Me.Myself.and.I.
    @Me.Myself.and.I. 3 роки тому +1

    Wow! I never heard of this Carol before until now....and am intrigued to hear other recordings...beautiful work as usual Graham!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Thank you very much! As ever, I am really grateful for your enthusiastic support for my efforts - it really motivates me to keep trying to compose!

  • @OrganGuyPhil
    @OrganGuyPhil 3 роки тому +1

    You are a master, Graham! I love your arrangement of this Scottish tune very, very much! I feel like I’ve experienced that tune in past years, maybe in some band piece? Your take on it is truly magical!!!! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🎶🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thanks for listening and commenting, Phil. Praise from you means such a lot as your musical magic is beyond compare. A very Merry Christmas to you and a very Happy New Year. When next you make it over to these shores, I'd love to meet you and shake you by the hand. Who knows? Some of your magic may brush off onto me!

  • @jerrymartin79
    @jerrymartin79 3 роки тому +1

    Beautiful Graham! This is a new carol for me too, even though I grew up but a stones throw from Scotland (literally! - Giants' causeway ;) ) - such a lovely tune and wrapped up in your delicious harmony as always!

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you, Jerry. I really value your encouragement and support in my efforts at composition and I am grateful that you are very lenient when commenting on my organ performances. If only I had your brilliance! Merry Christmas to you, and a very Happy New Year!

  • @paulswindenmusic
    @paulswindenmusic 3 роки тому +1

    This is such a beautiful and appealing arrangement, Graham! That solo stop on Hereford gives a really heart-rending plaintiveness to the melody and you play it so brilliantly; I love the crescendo particularly! My very best wishes to you and your family for Christmas. Paul

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thank you, Paul! I really appreciate your very kind comments. I hesitate to upload because when I listen to your brilliant performances, I see how inadequate my own playing (and composing!) really is. I'm sure a piece will be coming your way next year . . . a belated Christmas present! Hope the New Year brings you much joy and many blessings.

  • @organforheartevarosemarier9773
    @organforheartevarosemarier9773 3 роки тому +1

    Very beautiful Carol💟💟💟

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому +1

      Vielen Dank fürs Zuschauen und Kommentieren, Eva. Ich schätze Ihre Unterstützung sehr (obwohl ich wahrscheinlich Kompositionsunterricht von unserem Freund Paul brauche!). Frohe Weihnachten und einen guten Rutsch ins neue Jahr!

    • @organforheartevarosemarier9773
      @organforheartevarosemarier9773 3 роки тому

      @@grahamtwist ich schätze Sie und auch Paul sehr. Ihr habt großes Talent. Fröhliche Weihnachten und viel Freude wünscht Evi 💟💟💟🎄🎄🎄❣❣❣🍀🍀🍀💕💕💕💝💝💝🙏🙏🙏

  • @peternaryd_operasinger
    @peternaryd_operasinger 3 роки тому +1

    Wonderful Graham!😁👍👏👏👏👏 How are you doing?

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      I am just about fully recovered from my recent bad luck with health, thank you, Peter. I really appreciate you watching my compositions and always commenting so generously. God jul och gott nytt år på er. Här hoppas du att alla dina drömmar kommer att uppfyllas under det kommande året!

    • @peternaryd_operasinger
      @peternaryd_operasinger 3 роки тому

      I'm so glad to hear that you are about fully recovered now!👍👍👍
      You're so welcome! Thank you so much! I wish the same to you!☃️🎅🎄❤

  • @james.flores
    @james.flores 3 роки тому +1

    It’s a beautiful setting (yours)! What solo did you use? And how did you determine which solo was suitable for your performance?

    • @grahamtwist
      @grahamtwist  3 роки тому

      Thanks so much for commenting, James - I really appreciate it! You are so incredibly supportive of my attempts at composition and I cannot thank you enough for the encouragement you continue to give me. You are a real star in my firmament!
      I love the Hereford flue stops (certainly plenty to choose from!). The two reed solos are from the Solo Organ - Clarinet (volume up a bit!) and the Orchestral Oboe. The Swell has great possibilities with 16' and 8' reeds other than the fiery trumpet chorus at 16', 8' and 4' which were too much for this piece (I know, never too much for you!). At the end, it is the Cor Anglais - rather a weak stop heading a bit towards a Vox Humana. Thanks for asking! If I had been inspired by your registering techniques, I should have deployed the Tuba for the solo spots (my favourite stop on this organ sample set!).