This film has the strongest narrative since the original film from 1954, the best since that film, and it might be in competition of being the best Godzilla movie ever. I can’t wait for further rewatches of it.
When she apparently died, it was sad sure but it didn't make me cry, only when Koichi was completely overcome with pain, grief, anger, sadness and frustration and let's out that scream, that's when I broke down
I legitimately got goosebumps when Godzilla attacked Ginza and the original theme started. I finally got to experience what the people experienced back in 1954
Same. When that theme kicked on I got chills and my wife (also a huge Godzilla fan) grabbed my hand and squeezed. I'm a HUGE fan of the 60s Godzilla vs Mothra and it was like the music cues were ripped straight from that movie.
Never saw and avoided the trailers. I just walked in the movie blind. What an experience in the theater. Never thought to see such a heavy emotional story of people trying their best to survive and live. Usually the human characters and story are whatever, but this is one that impacted me forever.
I went the same way. I've watched all the Showa era Godzilla films but nothing afterwards, and I didn't even know this film existed until a friend wanted to see it with someone. I said yes, and went in knowing absolutely nothing. Pleasantly surprised would be an understatement lol
I cried twice during this film, once for the story and it's magnificence. Second, for the fact that something that has been near and dear to my heart since I was probably 5 or 6, was presented so masterfully. The vindication of 30 years of Fandom for me was overwhelming.
Watched this last night in theaters, and it really was an experience. There are multiple sequences you completely forget this is a Godzilla movie. Most characters aren't very fleshed out, mostly one-note likable stereotypes. The eccentric scientist, the rough but gold hearted ship captain, the rookie who wants action. But they all have a mostly unspoken layer of trauma and loss from the war that makes their personalities so much deeper without tons of exposition or flashbacks. We all know how terrible World War 2 was, especially for the Japanese. It such a human film, which is really what Godzilla is all about. It brings the themes back to human strength and resilience against all odds. I also especially liked the direct callouts of the failures of the Japanese government and the absurdity of the Cold War. It is such a fantastic film that says so much with so little (literally, $15 million is nothing). Even if you don't like Godzilla, this movie is absolutely worth the watch.
Honestly, maybe that's what we need right now, a little bit of old school classic story telling, tried and true character models. Anything over the endless deconstruction and insulting of legacy characters.
I liked the parts of the movie where the impact was so strong, you could hear a pin drop in the theater because everyone was so blown away that they were holding their breath.
I think something interesting was how the film came from the Japanese perspective and it was very critical of war itself and also the kamikaze narrative during WWII. How like in reality there was no honor in killing yourself for the Emperor or the Japanese war machine but surviving and rebuilding the nation and its people was worth working towards
If I had to identify one scene as my favorite, it's when an emotionally overcome Noriko offers a deep bow of respect after Sumiko gives up her stash of rice for the benefit of Akiko.
Gotta disagree, THIS is the best looking Godzilla design hands down. I think there were times he moved a little too stiff (like a rock em sock em robot) but when he didn't its as you would expect. The scene of Godzilla chasing the tiny boat in the ocean to me was epic. That entire scene beginning to end was Awesome! Japan took their monster back & its the best one by far.
As much as I love the OG 54 Design, GMK Design (outside the humpback), Godzilla 2000 Look, and Shin's massive radioactive shooting from everywhere abilities......This look is incredible and took the best looks from 70 years (almost) and put them together.
Unfortunately Japan entered some other movie for the best international film and oopsie....HAHA! That deadline is like Sept or something and once entered it can't be changed. Hopefully the Oscars give it something.
The actors were exceptional. The characters are well written and you actually care what happens to them. Godzilla is completely terrifying and is possibly the best looking version of the character. You can tell some corners were cut due to budget but they definitely picked the right corners.
I think Minus One wins for action solely because it grounds all of its action in human persoectives. It isn't nameless tanks and planes shooting at Godzilla while the name characters get reports on the radio, it's characters you care about trying to survive. The way the action is directed in Minus One is thrilling, even if it is quite different from classic Godzilla rampages.
Haha I knew I couldn’t be the only one!! Those Monster madness Godzilla-thon videos are classics. I was just a kid when I watched those. It made me addicted to Godzilla content.
I've been brought to tears in movies, but the little kid in me, as well as the dad that I've grown to be could not contain the wave of feelings before, during, and after. Even everything OTHER than Godzilla sutured me completely into the story, the characters, and the emotion. Not to go full sap, but even the grand spectacle the king of monsters brought are amongst the greatest I've experienced watching movies. A++, period. This movie is meant to see on a large screen.
There's just something deeply terrifying about the way they used Godzilla in Minus One. You can see humans running away as he tramples everything, he's big enough to be a force of destruction, but small enough that he can personally go after the characters the audience cares about, and the way he's shot in the action scenes just makes the devastation he causes so much clearer
This is the biggest endorsement this film could've received. James, a super nerd and lover of everything Godzilla says this is the best in the franchise. Everyone needs to see this in theaters before it's too late.
Out of the many godzilla movies, this was litterally one of those movies where I had some moments of having tears and usually when you have a movie that can make you tear up out from just pure perfection, it's perfection at its finest in my opinion.
I cannot fully explain how absolutely magnificent this movie is. Everything. The design. The effects. The actors. The characters. The music. The carnage. It is just gorgeous and this movie should not go unwatched. Period.
I think this film also has the scariest Godzilla, the words that kept coming to me when it showed up at the beginning of the film was "sheer malice" and those words remained true through the whole film. This godzilla takes things personally and roars like a bear about to rip you to shreds just for looking at him wrong. This resentment for humanity doubles the anti nuclear message, as there's nothing more anti humanity than humanity's creation of the nuclear bomb.
And I think with this latest Godzilla film, they kind of dropped all pretense that Godzilla was a metaphor for the A-bomb. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Gozilla's atomic breath had ever actually created a nuclear explosion in and of itself prior to this film.
There certainly was a genuine sense of horror in this film. Watching 'zilla chase that boat somehow felt terrifying... I was kind of reminded of JAWS in a weird way.
I find this Godzilla kind of terrifying but in a different way that I found Shin to be. While Shin was a mindless force of nature, this Godzilla seems purposefully evil and vindictive.
probably has a lot to do with what he's a personification of Shin was a perfect embodiment of the 2011 disaster(s), whereas -1.0 seems like an embodiment of modern war, in a way, which one could absolutely call 'purposefully evil and vindictive'
Japanese just know how to make those atomic breaths always so cool and fresh. I loved them both in Shin and Minus One, though Minus One made me gasp in the theater.
It's been so long since a jp godzilla movie I completely forgot how impactful that breath use to be because of how often it was used in the west and toned down
As a long Godzilla fan, this movie is a dream come true : An excellent complete movie on all level (actors, story, music, technical, artistic choices) not just a monster flick.
Something about being set during WWII makes this special like the original. It captures why the original was so impactful and serious. Also, the music! Using the original themes was such a surprise for me. Sounded fantastic.
This was just a well written movie. You can replace WWII to another disaster that wrecked the world, and remove Godzilla for another conflict that takes place within that post wrecked world and it will still be great. To me it’s a love story, and about a man that is trying to recover from his action. Because he still had PTSD, he fails to realize people love him, and he didn’t realize that until she was gone. Also, it’s a nice touch/message to not rely on your government/or other world’s government when you need to protect the things your love. Sometimes you have to take matter into your own hands. And the music is so great like you said.
I really love the Heisei-ish design elements - and I'm all in for Heisei-era. This one was a blast, especially on the big screen. Only a limited run unfortunately (already over where I live) and they can't get that Blueray out soon enough. I WANT THAT FILM IN MY HANDS!
I just saw it earlier tonight and it legit made me cry several times and pull back in horror and awe many times and had actual goosebumps for more than half the movie, definitely the best Godzilla I think
The camera views really added to it for me at certain parts. Not just some camera looking up type thing with tiny models around. The scale and way things moved around on the camera with the realistic look was cool.
That film was for me the highlight of if not December but the whole year. I also re-watched the original 1954 film the night before seeing Minus One. I also can agree that the human story is the part that kept me invested fully.
About Godzilla taking a nap in 2nd Act - If I recall correctly they explained that they set up a network of Geiger counter buoys and knew Godzilla's approximate whereabouts, sort of an early warning system
Just got home from seeing in IMAX. I agree it is the best Godzilla movie ever. My son and I have watched them all multiple times, we both walked out and agreed immediately this was just on a whole nother level of storytelling and execution. I want to see it again!
IMO The monster scenes are perfectly impactful in this movie, it starts very scary and personal, and while he's still shot in scale with people later in the movie he also just completely tears everything up in his path and creates a realistic, massive impact. I think my favorite scene has to be with the news crew on top of the building broadcasting right before they lose their lives, it's a classic trope.
I just watched it yesterday. When the destruction happens the audio in the theater makes the experience feel so real. I also cried at the end, best movie of 2023.
I was excited to see this review since I love his past Godzilla reviews, and I loved Godzilla Minus One. I'm glad you enjoyed it as well, and I agree with your review on all accounts. I am glad we got an amazing Toho Godzilla film that was serious and well made on all accounts, and has been well regarded by every moviegoer and critic that has seen it. I also feel like it is a great homage to the original Godzilla film in regards to tone, message, and themes.
Minus One made Godzilla scary again. Even his pre-radiated form is pretty intimidating. The design reminds me of Hesei Godzilla, with some dash of Monsterverse.
I thought Godzilla Minus One was a strong 8 out of 10 in the Godzilla movie scale. My favorite movie of 2023. I suggest watching it in 4DX if it's an option for you. It's a "big" movie that benefits from an audience, the large screen, and the seat motion gimmicks of 4DX. Watching it on streaming is not going to have the same impact.
I think one of the factors that hasn’t been talked about as much as it should’ve is how brilliant the sound design is. The film isn’t afraid to be genuinely loud so when it gets quiet you really feel it. Godzilla’s theme is perfectly placed and all of the sfx for the roars and the atomic breath just feel right.
I loved how instead of the typical Godzilla atomic breathe, we got a moment of peace then a atomic blast like a bomb. Didn’t see that coming. I like how ToHo is mixing it up with the Godzilla abilities.
I saw it last weekend, it was absolutely incredible it felt like classic cinema in the modern age, you’re the expert I bet you loved it as much as I did
IDK, I liked ShinGoji for being an unsettling, tragic horror that evoked unease and pity from me, but I really love how MinusGoji outright terrified me, as it was a rampaging, vengeful beast out to wipe the humans from his ever-expanding stomping grounds.
In the film they actually find Godzilla's location and realize they have so many hours before his landfall. Watch it again and see. It's only then that the crew jovially break bread all resigned to their fate.
Now that I live in Japan, I've had to wait up to a month or so to see U.S. releases in theaters, but this is one of those moments where it's been out in theaters for over a month now, so I'm glad it's still showing in theaters this week too. I actually didn't realize it was so popular until I saw reviews in the U.S, so I wish I'd gone and seen it sooner.
Honestly one of the best movies ive ever seen theaters. It was so beautifully done. And i agree so much that every person needs to go and see it. I cried a few times cause it just touched me.
Perhaps the most important review of all. And James Rolfe endorsing the human element, which is often incredibly weak, in a Monster movie? Very encouraging.
Honestly, this would have been a great movie even without Godzilla. Vets coming home from a war and trying to deal with their own survival and loosing the war
I saw it Friday night and was super impressed with everything it had to offer. I had some teary moments, too, it was hard not to with how serious the movie is. I’m at the theater again right now to see it again with a friend lol
This movie truly is a cinematic masterpiece. The story, the characters, the visual effects, the tone, the musical score. It's worthy of being considered not only the greatest Godzilla movie (even objectively) but also one of the greatest movies ever made PERIOD. Highly recommended for both kaiju fans and general moviegoers.
I wish I could’ve had you as a neighbor back in the early 90s. I had brothers that lived on one side of me and we always watched Godzilla movies. They actually introduced me to them. I loved being apart of the 90s
I think why James prefers the Shin version of the design is the surreal, alien look of Godzilla, a direct result of humanity's hubris. Godzilla from -1 looks like the Monsterverse Goji waking up from a nap and is very cranky, with the amount of close-up shots we get of the beast.
I have been WAITING for this review. I saw Minus One over the weekend and was blown away. Ever since, I have been dying to hear your take on it. Your reviews on Godzilla are really the only ones that matter imo.
I have been watching monster movies for nearly 55 years. I would not only rate this as the best Godzilla, but possibly the best monster movie I have ever seen. A moment that touched deep[y was when he unleashes his breath it leaves an effect similar to an atomic bomb. A woman simply says "Please not again"
You know we couldn't wait for you to drop this video we all have to check in with the unofficial overseer of everything Godzilla monster horror related
Even though the movie explains it, up until 1952, Japan was under US occupation, so the US should’ve been more active regardless of being “busy with the Russians.” As for Shin Godzilla, it was clearly a response/critique to March 11, 2011.
Just caught a screening on Dec 26th in San Diego at 5:30 PM. Our theater was about half full and people really seemed to enjoy it. I thought it was the best new Godzilla since Shin Godzilla
I can totally agree. Minus One is the best in this rich series. I was truly invested in the story of the characters. I felt their greef, their pain and the horror they are suffering. The sound effects, the visuals, everything was spot on. Even without Godzilla this movie shows us the horror of war and the consequences of our actions. A must see for everyone even if you are not a Godzilla fan!
Saw it in 4DX and it was awesome. Brought my 9 year old and 6 year old to see it and my 6 year old applauded at the end. 6 year old is a huge Godzilla fan, my 9 year old liked it too even with the subtitles.
Just got back from seeing it in IMAX. It, Shin and the original 1954 film are definitely the golden standards of the series, and it's hard to rank them compared to one another.
Could not have said it better myself. I was blown away with how GREAT this film was. I went in with medium expectations, and boy those were blown away. Easily a top 3 movie I’ve seen this calendar year.
I was able to catch it in a theater this week and it was an incredible experience. So much fun! Also, I was not a huge fan of the older movies growing up, but I thought Godzillas posture was quite stiff in this movie as a homage to the suit days.
I'm glad you said it's the best movie of the franchise. I feel like so many have been dancing around not giving this movie the credit it deserves as the best Godzilla film.
This film has the strongest narrative since the original film from 1954, the best since that film, and it might be in competition of being the best Godzilla movie ever. I can’t wait for further rewatches of it.
I'm so excited!! Everyone said it's amazing
Better than Shin Gojira even?
I really liked it and parts made me super smile. Loved the OG feel. Beware tho. It’s a super super sloooooooow in big parts.
@@0002pA Much better. This eschews Shin's droning board meetings for a powerful story of redemption.
It is the best one
Hearing Koichi screaming after he thought Godzilla killed Noriko was the realest sounding scream I think I've ever heard in cinema
On par with Barefoot Gen!
For real, that was an actual scream from someone pushed to his psychological limit.
@@shooby9496 😭😭
When she apparently died, it was sad sure but it didn't make me cry, only when Koichi was completely overcome with pain, grief, anger, sadness and frustration and let's out that scream, that's when I broke down
The only scream that I think is better is in Hereditary when the mom finds her beheaded daughter.
I legitimately got goosebumps when Godzilla attacked Ginza and the original theme started. I finally got to experience what the people experienced back in 1954
Yep I was already on an emotional high up to that point and when they started playing the music, and we hit hyperdrive lol
Same. When that theme kicked on I got chills and my wife (also a huge Godzilla fan) grabbed my hand and squeezed. I'm a HUGE fan of the 60s Godzilla vs Mothra and it was like the music cues were ripped straight from that movie.
Ginza
Absolute chills when the theme kicked on as the ships started attacking
Ginza. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is the Godzilla film that critics and even non-Godzilla fans will appreciate.
Like me. I don't care at all about Godzilla or monster movies, but I really did enjoy this one.
Right, after watching the movie I’m starting to become a fan
@@asia1174 Never too late.😉
Never saw and avoided the trailers. I just walked in the movie blind. What an experience in the theater. Never thought to see such a heavy emotional story of people trying their best to survive and live. Usually the human characters and story are whatever, but this is one that impacted me forever.
Same here! I cried like crazy
Not gonna lie, Did pretty much the same thing. Some friends were going, and I asked to tag along.
What a great way to introduce myself!
I went the same way. I've watched all the Showa era Godzilla films but nothing afterwards, and I didn't even know this film existed until a friend wanted to see it with someone. I said yes, and went in knowing absolutely nothing. Pleasantly surprised would be an understatement lol
Same and it made the film so much better
The human plots bogged down the last few Godzilla movies. I’m glad they got it right with this one.
I cried twice during this film, once for the story and it's magnificence. Second, for the fact that something that has been near and dear to my heart since I was probably 5 or 6, was presented so masterfully. The vindication of 30 years of Fandom for me was overwhelming.
Sick 🤢
Watched this last night in theaters, and it really was an experience. There are multiple sequences you completely forget this is a Godzilla movie. Most characters aren't very fleshed out, mostly one-note likable stereotypes. The eccentric scientist, the rough but gold hearted ship captain, the rookie who wants action. But they all have a mostly unspoken layer of trauma and loss from the war that makes their personalities so much deeper without tons of exposition or flashbacks. We all know how terrible World War 2 was, especially for the Japanese.
It such a human film, which is really what Godzilla is all about. It brings the themes back to human strength and resilience against all odds. I also especially liked the direct callouts of the failures of the Japanese government and the absurdity of the Cold War. It is such a fantastic film that says so much with so little (literally, $15 million is nothing). Even if you don't like Godzilla, this movie is absolutely worth the watch.
Honestly, maybe that's what we need right now, a little bit of old school classic story telling, tried and true character models. Anything over the endless deconstruction and insulting of legacy characters.
I liked the parts of the movie where the impact was so strong, you could hear a pin drop in the theater because everyone was so blown away that they were holding their breath.
@@officersquarehead that final scene when he comes around in the Fighter... just wow
I think something interesting was how the film came from the Japanese perspective and it was very critical of war itself and also the kamikaze narrative during WWII. How like in reality there was no honor in killing yourself for the Emperor or the Japanese war machine but surviving and rebuilding the nation and its people was worth working towards
@@BobPantsSpongeSquare97This
If I had to identify one scene as my favorite, it's when an emotionally overcome Noriko offers a deep bow of respect after Sumiko gives up her stash of rice for the benefit of Akiko.
Gotta disagree, THIS is the best looking Godzilla design hands down. I think there were times he moved a little too stiff (like a rock em sock em robot) but when he didn't its as you would expect.
The scene of Godzilla chasing the tiny boat in the ocean to me was epic. That entire scene beginning to end was Awesome! Japan took their monster back & its the best one by far.
This definitely the best design. That boat chase was scary af
@@goodxd701 Got to be honest I was expecting to hear the Jaws theme at any second lol
Agreed, I respect his opinion, but this really felt like the modern version of a Toho classic.
@@glenchapman3899 that would've been so cool😂
As much as I love the OG 54 Design, GMK Design (outside the humpback), Godzilla 2000 Look, and Shin's massive radioactive shooting from everywhere abilities......This look is incredible and took the best looks from 70 years (almost) and put them together.
戦後の人々が、本当に全てが壊された世界で懸命に困難に立ち向かう姿、家族愛、優れた兵器のない状態でのゴジラとの決戦など、見どころの多い映画でした。怪獣映画にも関わらず、人間に焦点が当たっているドラマには、とても感動させられましたね。
俺も本当に賛成だね！この映画を見る前にゴジラの映画を見ることがない、そして何を期待すべき事が分からなかった。でも、この映画の人間ドラマが期待を遠くに越した！映画を見る中に泣かされた事もあったんだ！とっても感動的な映画だったね！
（俺の日本語が上級じゃない、アメリカ人んだねｗｗｗ）
Hope it wins some awards. Great to see a Japanese movie being so popular, it's rare.
Unfortunately Japan entered some other movie for the best international film and oopsie....HAHA! That deadline is like Sept or something and once entered it can't be changed. Hopefully the Oscars give it something.
But did win Yamazaki Best Director in Japan!
This one DESERVES best International Film at the Oscars or Golden Globes
Bruh its definitely winning awards
It’s been nominated for an Oscar!!!!! I think for Best Visual Effects!!!!
The actors were exceptional. The characters are well written and you actually care what happens to them. Godzilla is completely terrifying and is possibly the best looking version of the character. You can tell some corners were cut due to budget but they definitely picked the right corners.
Ahahah when those four tanks rolled up, my mnd recalled the budget
@@shinzilla4847 that's probably pretty accurate though considering they had just lost the war lol
Hard to believe that a 15 million dollar foreign film looks better than the 200 million films from Hollywood.
Not hard to believe at all. Just watch more foreign movies.
They know what they're doing and it's amazing
Because the writer-director headed the VFX too
You took the words right out of my head.
It’s called “no waste”. The money was spent where it needed to be. Hollywood films waste a ton of money.
I think Minus One wins for action solely because it grounds all of its action in human persoectives. It isn't nameless tanks and planes shooting at Godzilla while the name characters get reports on the radio, it's characters you care about trying to survive. The way the action is directed in Minus One is thrilling, even if it is quite different from classic Godzilla rampages.
日本人にとっては、伝説として語られ続けている船、飛行機、戦車など〈名前のある〉兵器ばかりなので…登場するだけでも胸が高まりましたし、重巡洋艦「高雄（TAKAO）」がゴジラにアタックされ、艦が傾きながらも砲撃を命中させる場面場面、日本人の心の琴線を震わせるには十分で、涙が溢れ出て止まりませんでしたよ☆ from🇯🇵
@@隆利-f8hif that is true and the case, that’s incredible. I had no idea
SOME of the tanks and planes shooting at godzilla are nameless
@@nosuchthing8…本作に登場したものには、全てに名前と機番名 そして歴史があります。あの当時に、太平洋戦争で傷ついて他国のドックにいたり、完成間近で試運転中に終戦を迎えた戦闘機（SHINDEN）など‥使えるものをかき集めての戦いだったので…兵士と共に兵器軍機にとっても、戦争に決着をつけるその姿に 日本人は涙が止まらないのです。from🇯🇵
@user-rg2sm8kq1r I'm sorry my friend. I only know English and a little Spanish. Domo arrogato.
You made me love Godzilla even more as a Kid back around 2009 with your Godzilla-thon. Thank You
Same here. I feel I've learned so much from James, and that's something I'll forever be grateful for. Can't wait to watch Minus One.
☝️😎 What DumbMovieRevies said, hands down. I came in here to say the exact same thing but he already did.
FACTS!
15 years....
Haha I knew I couldn’t be the only one!! Those Monster madness Godzilla-thon videos are classics. I was just a kid when I watched those. It made me addicted to Godzilla content.
I've been brought to tears in movies, but the little kid in me, as well as the dad that I've grown to be could not contain the wave of feelings before, during, and after. Even everything OTHER than Godzilla sutured me completely into the story, the characters, and the emotion. Not to go full sap, but even the grand spectacle the king of monsters brought are amongst the greatest I've experienced watching movies. A++, period. This movie is meant to see on a large screen.
I agree, this movie was incredible. For me, absolutely the best Godzilla movie.
It's all in subtitles?
There's just something deeply terrifying about the way they used Godzilla in Minus One. You can see humans running away as he tramples everything, he's big enough to be a force of destruction, but small enough that he can personally go after the characters the audience cares about, and the way he's shot in the action scenes just makes the devastation he causes so much clearer
This is the biggest endorsement this film could've received. James, a super nerd and lover of everything Godzilla says this is the best in the franchise. Everyone needs to see this in theaters before it's too late.
Out of the many godzilla movies, this was litterally one of those movies where I had some moments of having tears and usually when you have a movie that can make you tear up out from just pure perfection, it's perfection at its finest in my opinion.
I cannot fully explain how absolutely magnificent this movie is. Everything. The design. The effects. The actors. The characters. The music. The carnage. It is just gorgeous and this movie should not go unwatched. Period.
It was okay.
So far with shin and this i feel like reiwa era is godzilla mixed with anime. The music in both were perfect
I've never seen so many people get so excited for a Godzilla movie before. I'm excited! Seems like the franchise is doing well these days!
I think this film also has the scariest Godzilla, the words that kept coming to me when it showed up at the beginning of the film was "sheer malice" and those words remained true through the whole film. This godzilla takes things personally and roars like a bear about to rip you to shreds just for looking at him wrong. This resentment for humanity doubles the anti nuclear message, as there's nothing more anti humanity than humanity's creation of the nuclear bomb.
And I think with this latest Godzilla film, they kind of dropped all pretense that Godzilla was a metaphor for the A-bomb. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Gozilla's atomic breath had ever actually created a nuclear explosion in and of itself prior to this film.
I read that godzillas roar is used from the original film but they just made it louder.
There certainly was a genuine sense of horror in this film. Watching 'zilla chase that boat somehow felt terrifying... I was kind of reminded of JAWS in a weird way.
Honestly, I thought shin godzilla was scarier, this godzilla was just cool imo
And he really kills people up close + personal !
I find this Godzilla kind of terrifying but in a different way that I found Shin to be. While Shin was a mindless force of nature, this Godzilla seems purposefully evil and vindictive.
The end battle reminded me of Independance Day.
probably has a lot to do with what he's a personification of
Shin was a perfect embodiment of the 2011 disaster(s), whereas -1.0 seems like an embodiment of modern war, in a way, which one could absolutely call 'purposefully evil and vindictive'
The atomic breath in minus one is absolutely breathtaking
Absolutely! Now we have TWO movies this year with a stunning atomic explosion scene (this & Oppenheimer)
Japanese just know how to make those atomic breaths always so cool and fresh. I loved them both in Shin and Minus One, though Minus One made me gasp in the theater.
It's been so long since a jp godzilla movie I completely forgot how impactful that breath use to be because of how often it was used in the west and toned down
Pun intended?
As a long Godzilla fan, this movie is a dream come true : An excellent complete movie on all level (actors, story, music, technical, artistic choices) not just a monster flick.
I enjoyed Godzilla Minus One! Great acting performance from Ryunosuke Kamiki.
Something about being set during WWII makes this special like the original. It captures why the original was so impactful and serious. Also, the music! Using the original themes was such a surprise for me. Sounded fantastic.
This was just a well written movie. You can replace WWII to another disaster that wrecked the world, and remove Godzilla for another conflict that takes place within that post wrecked world and it will still be great. To me it’s a love story, and about a man that is trying to recover from his action. Because he still had PTSD, he fails to realize people love him, and he didn’t realize that until she was gone. Also, it’s a nice touch/message to not rely on your government/or other world’s government when you need to protect the things your love. Sometimes you have to take matter into your own hands. And the music is so great like you said.
I really love the Heisei-ish design elements - and I'm all in for Heisei-era. This one was a blast, especially on the big screen. Only a limited run unfortunately (already over where I live) and they can't get that Blueray out soon enough. I WANT THAT FILM IN MY HANDS!
たぶん昭和の事だと思う。マイナスワンの時代は昭和（Showa ）と言われる時代です。
I just saw it earlier tonight and it legit made me cry several times and pull back in horror and awe many times and had actual goosebumps for more than half the movie, definitely the best Godzilla I think
The camera views really added to it for me at certain parts. Not just some camera looking up type thing with tiny models around. The scale and way things moved around on the camera with the realistic look was cool.
I've never seen more people in one theater cry at the end of a movie, and it was a Godzilla movie no less!
I literally cried as he was walking into the city and the music started lol I’m not even ashamed
That film was for me the highlight of if not December but the whole year. I also re-watched the original 1954 film the night before seeing Minus One. I also can agree that the human story is the part that kept me invested fully.
About Godzilla taking a nap in 2nd Act - If I recall correctly they explained that they set up a network of Geiger counter buoys and knew Godzilla's approximate whereabouts, sort of an early warning system
Yes that’s true.
After the alarm I think they had 12 hours or so to prepare, and Godzilla’s speed took them by total surprise too.
Just got home from seeing in IMAX. I agree it is the best Godzilla movie ever. My son and I have watched them all multiple times, we both walked out and agreed immediately this was just on a whole nother level of storytelling and execution. I want to see it again!
IMO The monster scenes are perfectly impactful in this movie, it starts very scary and personal, and while he's still shot in scale with people later in the movie he also just completely tears everything up in his path and creates a realistic, massive impact. I think my favorite scene has to be with the news crew on top of the building broadcasting right before they lose their lives, it's a classic trope.
James. It won an Oscar, it’s returning to theaters, and it’s getting a sequel. When is the in-depth video?
It's great to see another authentic Godzilla movie in the theater. And it's great to see James enjoy it.
“I’m sure it’ll be streaming soon.”
I wish that were true. We had to wait so long.
I just watched it yesterday. When the destruction happens the audio in the theater makes the experience feel so real. I also cried at the end, best movie of 2023.
I love the look of Godzilla in this film its a great modern interpretation the classic look
This was probably my favorite movie of the year, if I'm being honest. It genuinely made me tear up at parts and it was simply just wonderful
I was excited to see this review since I love his past Godzilla reviews, and I loved Godzilla Minus One. I'm glad you enjoyed it as well, and I agree with your review on all accounts. I am glad we got an amazing Toho Godzilla film that was serious and well made on all accounts, and has been well regarded by every moviegoer and critic that has seen it. I also feel like it is a great homage to the original Godzilla film in regards to tone, message, and themes.
Minus One made Godzilla scary again. Even his pre-radiated form is pretty intimidating. The design reminds me of Hesei Godzilla, with some dash of Monsterverse.
I thought Godzilla Minus One was a strong 8 out of 10 in the Godzilla movie scale. My favorite movie of 2023. I suggest watching it in 4DX if it's an option for you. It's a "big" movie that benefits from an audience, the large screen, and the seat motion gimmicks of 4DX. Watching it on streaming is not going to have the same impact.
Where do you rate the other films?
Finally watched it dubbed on Netflix and it was excellent. Plan to go back and watch the subtitled version soon. Thanks for the video.
For me Godzilla Minus One is the best modern Godzilla ever! And its the best movie I've seen this year
I think one of the factors that hasn’t been talked about as much as it should’ve is how brilliant the sound design is. The film isn’t afraid to be genuinely loud so when it gets quiet you really feel it. Godzilla’s theme is perfectly placed and all of the sfx for the roars and the atomic breath just feel right.
I feel like this was a complete homage to the 1950s Godzilla. Wasn’t a fan of the newer movies but this was great
I loved how instead of the typical Godzilla atomic breathe, we got a moment of peace then a atomic blast like a bomb. Didn’t see that coming.
I like how ToHo is mixing it up with the Godzilla abilities.
I highly recommend the film for any G fans. It was a great G film in the traditional Toho style. Loved every second of it!
I saw it last weekend, it was absolutely incredible it felt like classic cinema in the modern age, you’re the expert I bet you loved it as much as I did
It's second on my list now. The original Japanese version will always be my favorite. This was amazing
Watched this in IMAX on Sunday. Easily my favorite Godzilla film, what an incredible experience!
IDK, I liked ShinGoji for being an unsettling, tragic horror that evoked unease and pity from me, but I really love how MinusGoji outright terrified me, as it was a rampaging, vengeful beast out to wipe the humans from his ever-expanding stomping grounds.
I like both quite a bit but would much rather rewatch the entirety of Minus One than Shin.
Shin is a Star Trek but this is like Star Wars. Different vibes imo.
In the film they actually find Godzilla's location and realize they have so many hours before his landfall. Watch it again and see. It's only then that the crew jovially break bread all resigned to their fate.
James is a true Godzilla connoisseur, so I really value his opinion. Can't wait to see this!
5:23 I don’t understand what James means here. This Godzilla looks like a grittier, more horrific version of Heisei Godzilla than anything.
I just watched the movie a couple
of hours ago. I agree. It is a GREAT movie. When it was over, I had a tremendous feeling of satisfaction with it.
Now that I live in Japan, I've had to wait up to a month or so to see U.S. releases in theaters, but this is one of those moments where it's been out in theaters for over a month now, so I'm glad it's still showing in theaters this week too. I actually didn't realize it was so popular until I saw reviews in the U.S, so I wish I'd gone and seen it sooner.
Uh oh now godzilla gon get you! 😲
I’m so glad that I took your advice and saw this in a theater. What an amazing movie!
I saw it on Sunday 12/4/23
It was great. I really cared about the human characters, which is rare.
This was a true tribute to the 1954
I loved how even if you could see what was coming…the emotional moments hit so hard. It was truly a beautiful experience to have during a G film.
I'm sure the Japanese sailor looking at Godzilla chasing his boat from behind must have thought..."We're going to need a bigger boat!"
Honestly one of the best movies ive ever seen theaters. It was so beautifully done. And i agree so much that every person needs to go and see it. I cried a few times cause it just touched me.
Perhaps the most important review of all. And James Rolfe endorsing the human element, which is often incredibly weak, in a Monster movie? Very encouraging.
Honestly, this would have been a great movie even without Godzilla. Vets coming home from a war and trying to deal with their own survival and loosing the war
I saw it Friday night and was super impressed with everything it had to offer. I had some teary moments, too, it was hard not to with how serious the movie is. I’m at the theater again right now to see it again with a friend lol
The reason why Godzilla has more up close shots is that you are suppose to see him from the human view up close than far away.
This movie reinvigorated my love for the theatre
I’m so glad this video exists. I saw the movie Sunday and it was shocking to get home and find that mr godzillathon himself hadn’t done a review yet.
I didn't have a Godzilla movie that would make me cry on my bingo card..
This movie truly is a cinematic masterpiece. The story, the characters, the visual effects, the tone, the musical score. It's worthy of being considered not only the greatest Godzilla movie (even objectively) but also one of the greatest movies ever made PERIOD. Highly recommended for both kaiju fans and general moviegoers.
I wish I could’ve had you as a neighbor back in the early 90s. I had brothers that lived on one side of me and we always watched Godzilla movies. They actually introduced me to them.
I loved being apart of the 90s
I think why James prefers the Shin version of the design is the surreal, alien look of Godzilla, a direct result of humanity's hubris. Godzilla from -1 looks like the Monsterverse Goji waking up from a nap and is very cranky, with the amount of close-up shots we get of the beast.
I have been WAITING for this review. I saw Minus One over the weekend and was blown away. Ever since, I have been dying to hear your take on it. Your reviews on Godzilla are really the only ones that matter imo.
I have been watching monster movies for nearly 55 years. I would not only rate this as the best Godzilla, but possibly the best monster movie I have ever seen. A moment that touched deep[y was when he unleashes his breath it leaves an effect similar to an atomic bomb. A woman simply says "Please not again"
You know we couldn't wait for you to drop this video we all have to check in with the unofficial overseer of everything Godzilla monster horror related
Absolutely loved this movie. Going back to the theater again to see it.
Same!
Ditto
These are some of my fav vids from you. Glad we are still getting GREAT Godzilla films
Even though the movie explains it, up until 1952, Japan was under US occupation, so the US should’ve been more active regardless of being “busy with the Russians.” As for Shin Godzilla, it was clearly a response/critique to March 11, 2011.
Just caught a screening on Dec 26th in San Diego at 5:30 PM. Our theater was about half full and people really seemed to enjoy it. I thought it was the best new Godzilla since Shin Godzilla
I can totally agree. Minus One is the best in this rich series. I was truly invested in the story of the characters. I felt their greef, their pain and the horror they are suffering. The sound effects, the visuals, everything was spot on. Even without Godzilla this movie shows us the horror of war and the consequences of our actions.
A must see for everyone even if you are not a Godzilla fan!
Saw it in 4DX and it was awesome. Brought my 9 year old and 6 year old to see it and my 6 year old applauded at the end. 6 year old is a huge Godzilla fan, my 9 year old liked it too even with the subtitles.
Saw it the other night. Was surprisingly impressed
こちら日本！
観に行って頂いてありがとうございます！！
Just got back from seeing it in IMAX. It, Shin and the original 1954 film are definitely the golden standards of the series, and it's hard to rank them compared to one another.
Just got done seeing it a couple of hours ago at my local theater. AMAZING!!!
Could not have said it better myself. I was blown away with how GREAT this film was. I went in with medium expectations, and boy those were blown away. Easily a top 3 movie I’ve seen this calendar year.
I think this just may surpass the original 1954 film.
To me godzilla in this film, looked like the heisei 90’s version
I was able to catch it in a theater this week and it was an incredible experience. So much fun!
Also, I was not a huge fan of the older movies growing up, but I thought Godzillas posture was quite stiff in this movie as a homage to the suit days.
This film has singlehandedly restored my faith in modern cinema.
The US Veteran community loves this movie! The real PTSD and Survivor's Guilt... a very accurate depiction. Dang.
YES!! After Shin Godzilla, I had to see this! Shin Godzilla is FREAKING AWESOME!!!!
James give this movie A+...
This movie won an Oscar ❤
I thought the boat scene was absolutely terrifying!!
For reasons difficult to describe, it felt like watching JAWS - both situations felt like they "needed a bigger boat" for sure!
I'm glad you showed the scene when the battleship gets THROWN into the buildings. That was intense.
Love hearing James talk about movies he loves and is passionate about. This is the James we come to Cinemassacre for. Keep it up!!
I'm glad you said it's the best movie of the franchise. I feel like so many have been dancing around not giving this movie the credit it deserves as the best Godzilla film.