Yep, I don't understand why you'd listen to such a minor problem regarding spoilers when any sensible player knows how to avoid them. Plus there must be players like me who usually skip most of the story or event quests on release since I don't have time everyday to read the story bits and you have limited time rewards tied but later go through vods to see someone else's playthrough rather than using the in game replay feature.
What do you expect from a company that keeps a strict 2 year game update gap between global and JP when most modern live service games try to either eliminate completely with a global release schedule or keep the gap as small as possible.
@@Chaosloki Normally I'd agree but with FGO the 2-year gap is impossible to close and make into a global server for NA and JP. There are way too many events and banners that they'd have to jam together for the average casual player to try and play. There'd be way too much chaos for people to try and keep up even if they released everything back-to-back immediately. As of right now there are over 100+ campaigns/events/banners total within that 2-year gap. Plus, it really is useful at the least that NA players can actually plan ahead whereas JP gets shafted with unpredictability lol. - But regarding the guideline stuff for spoilers, that stuff is stupid.
Wow FGO is lagging behind newer gachas you'd think they want the overall fandom to be as active as possible and keep talking about FGO but they decide to gatekeep NA out and kill engagement among players and content creators about newer contents. Bold strategy Cotton let's see how this plays out for them.
@@ForYouTheOneListeningThey'll never realized that. The Japanese are famous for never learning anything from history or from the examples set by others.
I've actually been hit with a copyright warning when it comes parts of the story and some music related to the collabs but never a strike. This is pretty crazy.
Yeah its strikes, I waited a week to release this after confirming everything privately with some other CCs that focus on posting new story bossfights. Unless the Sony Music Entertainment is an imposter its unfortunately a direct strike
@@PlushieMistress Not for me. I don't make content, but I do watch content. It is how I stuck with the game. I also spend money on NA. But now I just don't feel like spending as much money on the game if this is how they are gong to act. If this affects you guys, I will take it as affecting me as well. Which means the wallet gets closed each time they do something.
I knew Sony would show his ugly side at some point. After the Concord debacle they are panicking and over correcting. 400 million loss has wide consequences.
@@juanbriones5989 Oh yeah that little jewel of a console, I made a PC for 600 when the PS5 came because I thought the price was too high, I play now in 2k 100-120 fps, why would any sensible person buy a PS5 Pro?
And yet even so, there were legit Japanese comments on Plushie, xNaya, and NeoBenedict’s videos complaining that they spoiled BB Dubai’s 3rd ascension, and the final boss of OC3. So it’s definitely a thing that they were reported.
JP gacha dev: "Let's region lock our games! All of UA-camrs who make videos about our games, copystrike 'em all! Also keep our game as low budget as possible, and as cash-grab as possible!" Also JP gacha dev: "Why do Chinese and Korean gacha games more successful?"
Banning the story is fine and understandable but banning the gameplay and boss fight is dumb. That is like 90% of the content that can be made with out actually spoiled much of the content while creating hype for the game.
Bruh no banning the story is complete nonsense the fgo replay feature is dreadful if i want to reread the story i'm going on youtube lol. Not to mention youtube has been a place where entire playthrough of 60 buck games are uploaded, like come on if that was actually bad business you can bet youtube would have been censored since the 2010's And the wors part is that their reasonong is the stop spoilers.... Wtf... SPOILERS?????? this is what you're worried about??????? That's none of their business like wtf seriously? Spoilers has to be one of the biggest nonsense debate of the decade like who the hell actually cares enough about spoiler regulation to start gunning in all directions, if your stories is "ruined" by spoilers then it wasn't a good story bruh This no spoiler policy is just as stupid as everything else, this is game workshop level of shooting yourself in the foot, remember when the astartes short film was removed from youtube to be put in a terrible warhammer plateform? Yeah that's the sort of genius decision making we're dealing with
@@pougetguillaume4632well for game workshops. Their solution is simple. They just release a new chapter of Space Marine (which they have done hundred times) and Warhammer fans will forget everything that has happened instantly and praise Game Workshop as the second coming of Emperor or something.
@@pougetguillaume4632 banning the story is understandable if it's just maybe a week(?) or so, still a dick move but you can kind of make sense of it. until you realize that lb4 was 5 years ago and it's (as of September) the furthest that we can post
I'm sorry, but they're not gonna feel anything from this. This will do next to nothing to their bottom line. We really shouldn't pretend that this is gonna have half the impact people are acting like it will.
@@orga7777 even if the topic is JP players, i feels like JP likely to play Blue Archive rather than FGO unless they're typemoon fans, especially for gen Z and gen alpha they would likely to try Blue Archive if they want to try gacha games
I've always thought FGO is too half-hearted and inconsistent about guarding about spoilers, often doing basically noting or being too restrictive, but this is a step further into unreasonble. Gatekeeping 4+ year-old content? Whoever made this call is so out of touch with reality. It seems clear to me they're just imposing an arbitrary ban to get the fans complaining to shut up and stop making a fuss.
Knowing this community, all Lasagna has to do is give some free SQ and everything will be forgiven. But seriously, after the fiasco that was the Ivan Raid, it became quite obvious that they DON'T GIVE A SH*T about the NA Server and this is just more proof of that since with FGO barely being advertised outside Japan the global version DEPENDS on content creators to stay relevant.
Even if JP players didn't support this, why would FGO give SQ for this? It's not something Lasengle did, and it would basically be acknowledging that their boss Sony did something wrong.
It is fine being safe for now, Plushie, but if in a month if xNaya or someone similar (who was mentioned by the raging JP base) are not hit then I think you should be fine. If your friend who got hit is trying to appeal to the JP base, that is probably why he got hit. Since these guidelines are NOT posted in English anywhere on the Global Server, you should definitely not worry about it until they are.
LMAO, Sony just can't stop taking Ls. - Concord blows up on their face. - Their "Spiderman Villains" movies are atrocious (which by the way, is only to keep the MCU from adapting said villains). - Their AI attempts in Subtitling anime got exposed (downsizing my a**) - And now, the biggest potential pull for FGO Global is in shambles all because "spoilers". Funny how the Japanese defend these. The stories have been sh*t for some time. And now these buffoons decide to gatekeep almost 5-year old stories as spoilers? Who in their right mind considers a 5 year old story as spoilers? This won't attract sht in the future. No wonder 30M DL has hit a wall. JP does generate the most revenue because (1) Global can't attract new players because of your shenanigans, and (2) most of the spenders in Global still invest more on JP. Global is two years behind and they're practically killing potential draws with this stupid decision all because of spoilers. Japanese players think it's honorable to secure the story, in reality, Sony has their hand so far up their a-. Enjoy the accelerating pitfall of this game.
Another big reason for which JP is more profitable, other than being the OG server, is that it's in the Japanese culture to spend some money monthly on collectibles and gacha. It generates an income comparable to a subscription model with spikes of sudden micro-transactions when the new shiny thing drops.
To be fair, this game should've died a long time ago. Aside from the story (for those who enjoy), nothing it presents brings anything decent to the table.
@@abrahammesrajecorrea2349 I think others only defend them because they are angry Western content creators have Fair Use to fall back on unlike them. It is jealousy.
This person does not represent the opinions of Japanese people at all, so do not misunderstand. You foreigners are not players or fans, but criminals who infringe on the copyrights of others for selfish reasons.
I really never minded the story spoilers since they're just scenes out of context. Even with major spoilers like Oberon and Cernnunos, it only works when you have the full context. This guidelines simply doesn't make sense.
Oberon is a spoiler, though. But I think that is the only one, because even without context it ruins the reveal if you saw that before playing it. The rest I would not consider spoilers at all.
@@orga7777I’d say I was very thoroughly spoiled about Oberon and a few lb6 story beats and I still enjoyed how things played out. I think I ended up liking Oberon even more than if I had gone in without knowledge. I think, ironically, partially knowing the story made me enjoy characters like Barghest and Morgan less. And I was absolutely smitten with Barghest’s art (giant woman, giant muscles, giant tits, hell yeah). Morgan I’m mostly just uninterested in her other than her QP gifts.
@@orga7777 And then you'll get shit like good smile releasing figures of "Oberon Votigern" LMAO but I guess it's fine as long as they're making the money and not CCs
@@orga7777 I can see why people like the fairy knights and Morgan but some of them I don’t like for design reasons and some for story reasons. *MASSIVE SPOILERS, BEWARE* Like: Melu wtf is that 3rd/4th ascension? I don’t want to see it but have to because of gameplay reasons. I thought her story with Aurora and Percival were fantastic but genuinely “ugh” at those ascensions. She’s just wayy too overdesigned. Even ignoring the Albion mud on her pretty much naked body (she looks too young for me), her face paint is wholly unappealing and her weapons and wings make her sprite (and 3rd art) cluttered without harmony. Barghest, you burnt alive innocent fairies and enslaved the “humans” as your “dogs” then we just pretend that you’re an innocent and just knight?? Huh?? I know that she was cursed with a ceaseless hunger and I don’t blame her for falling to temptation and losing what remained of her sanity when she remembered her greatest sin but like? We go to her house and act all cuddly and domestic after we recently watched her burn down the Autumn Forest and its inhabitants. What happened with the story there? And Morgan has Firefly (Honkai Star Rail) Syndrome in that she become’s our wife (while not knowing what it actually means iirc) and you don’t really have a say in it. She lacks the charm of the Tamamos and (even though I dislike her) Kiyohime so it feels forced. Adding to my gripes with Morgan, I understand her hatred of the Lostbelt’s fae. An abnormally large population of the fae (of the ones we meet) are either beyond redemption or are lacking in impulse control. She encourages Baobahn Sith(BBS) to emulate the behavior she hates because it’ll keep BBS alive longer… supposedly. Morgan doesn’t teach her daughter how to survive past “be mean, do some magic tricks” and is surprised when it backfires. I actually think she wasted BBS’s potential as both an heir as well as accidentally sabotaged her. edit: Pretty sure it’s intentional to some extent. Morgan’s main thing seems to be that, despite her overwhelming strength, she fails at her most important moments. At least during LB6, otherwise she just wins after she enters Chaldea. I also largely disagree with Morgan’s sentiment that a country only amounts to the land within it’s borders. What’s the point of running/ruling a country if nobody (or at least nobody you want living) is there for you to govern? Baobahn Sith? I actually really like her. She’s a really good mirror and rival for Caster. I actually kinda wish we had interpersonal character dialogues in the My Room alongside the “About (Character Name)” voice lines because I’d be interested to see Caster and BBS’s rivalry/friendship. I love her casual catty bitch behavior. She’s peak girl failure and I love her. (I’m not crazy about BBS’s summer version though. Cute design but, huh? It doesn’t make sense to me…)
I do feel for the situation you are left to delicately walk around. It's a tough spot. To a degree I get why they'd do something like this. Some people are absurdly fast to drop spoilers of the latest stuff and it's easy for that stuff to end up in front of you (be it youtube or social media). And goodness knows I remember being annoyed as heck about LB6 spoilers being thrown around right before LB6 (and specific parts) unlocked. But this is a pretty extreme stance. And it makes things really tough for those making videos. Sadly I agree that there isn't likely to be any effective backlash or pushback on this. If the JP side is cool with it then...that's all that will matter to the people at the top.
the one who probably signed off on this is the current ceo of lasengle, yoshinori ono. he left street fighter 5 in such a bad state and his team really disliked him, after he left they made the new sf6 a success. i told you before this guy was trouble when he suddenly became ceo of lasengle a while back
Right!? Like plushie should be getting some in-game rewards at least for being one of the biggest fgotubers in the na community. Pretty much all modern gacha games promotes content creation
Gachas don't generally do this. But bigger console games, especially Japanese ones, do it all the time. Embargos are pretty normal. The issue here is more how strict it is.
@@devo1246 ofc because most console games are not live service and if their story and content gets spoiled then nobody would want to play the game since they already know how it goes.
A disappointing result from typical asian corporations. Unfortunately while extremely disappointing, it's not surprising either. They just don't like fandom freedom without permission and while the spoilers are smth I do have an issue with, this is too much in the other direction. I'm really sorry this happened to you Plushie.
I have never had problems with spoilers, I just don't watch FGO content at all unless it's a CQ being done or a guide for a story boss I can't beat, people really are stupid.
Why does FGO keep going about it's problems in the most ridiculous ways possible?! just put a "Don't stream new content for one month." rule and that's it!
@@devo1246 Sadly you are right, only NA is dying at least in enthusiasm, and for some reason the players still spend money in this game. JP for some reason gets all the favoritism and in turn protect their master like the brainwashed gacha addicts they are, you rarely see JP players complain even when they are facing the same issues as us... and they had for a longer time (+2 years).
@@alexandrunache9078 Japan (and asians in general) love thier waifus so much, they are willing to be robbed out of their money for them, it's sad but true, all of those QOL's all of those nice changes the game could have if JP side were more critical about the game but nah... gotta stand together to... attack content creators on Global instead, and the worst part is that the company listens to them like spoiled children.
The problem is that they thought setting a guideline, the viewers who only watch creator contents were going to play the game by themselves which increase the active players. That may roll the gacha and bring them money. Or maybe they are planning to let some famous Vtuber to do somemore FGO Story Stream like the one Pekora did in Part 1. In addition, Kinoko said in the interview(I forget which year with Famitsu), he wants the players enjoy the experience by themselves. However, I don't think this guideline thing is going to bring them any merits. This thing came out on the 9th anniversary along with the append skill 4,5. A lot of JP FGO streamer talked about how bad it is and unfortunate that not able to upload any latest contents.(Even farming latest free quest is forbidden) They even sent mail to ask if it is necessary to delete the past video that contain content pass LB3(That's the restriction when it come out). They replied it is okay to keep the old video and that's all. The JP FGO streamers accepted the guideline for a while, therefore some of them are so angry about the overseas creator can do whatever they want. Spoilers are always a problem, but JP players ought to say it is your fault of looking up UA-cam or Twitter(X) before the guideline came out. The self-responsibility stuff Japanese people always talk about. But now they have the justified reason to smack the one who unpleased them. I just want to talk about the JP player are also displeased at the first place, but the anger move from Anipex to you guys which is unforune. Rule is absolute to them. Apology for my rusty English, haven't written English since I left university. Really love your FGO contents. My best wishes to you.
Ultimately what this is at the end of the day is a cultural difference in what are called "moral rights" over, particularly, *how* information disseminates about a work, which in Japan you typically have a lot more legal control over. Basically, there's a lot of legal protection over how an IP/trademark holder in Japan gets to have their work/service perceived and/or presented. Of course, living in a country which has that as the law of the land naturally influences a lot of people living there into seeing these Americans disrespecting those moral rights and finding it incomprehensible that we do so. In America, the freedom of information itself (and how we protect that freedom) generally trumps those moral rights from existing, and so the average American aware of this whole debacle is going to think these guidelines are ridiculous. It's just a matter of what you grew up with. "How can you not respect the wishes of the creator of the work??? They're the ones who made it!" VS. "Why should a company have ANY right to tell me what to do? Once the work is published, it's out there for all to see!" Frankly, the argument we should be making is "If Lesengle wants to publish its game in America, it should respect how Americans treat information." That might not help for the Ordeal Call stuff, but maybe for the stuff that's out in NA it will.
Well tbf, the guidelines so far are only for the JP version which isn't officially out for folks outside of JP. We will have to see how the NA side handles stuffs
Alright here's my fucking question then. Why the FUCK are JP players going over to NA UA-camR CHANNELS IN THE FIRST PLACE? We're 2 years behind them as is, and they've gotten a chance to see the content we have yet to see "technically". They have literally no reason to even be around the NA scene unless they're looking through older content which the JP fanbase/ youtube scene hasn't provided???? FGO is literally bigger in the JP scene than it will EVER be in NA and they have more people doing channels for it, HELL THEY HAVE PEKORA WHO'S A VTUBER DOING IT. SHE EVEN HAS AN OFFICIAL FIGURE OF HER IN MASH'S GALAHAD OUTFIT. What can the NA scene even PROVIDE to JP that hasn't already been given? Witch Hunts aside, which you'd think that considering the lesson Salem is supposed to teach them about of "witch hunting is bad, don't do it" what legitimate motivations do they have to be watching english speaking channels who don't even provide active translations for them to understand what is even BEING SAID? Its so hard for me to wrap my head around. Its one thing for the Western Audience to be watching the major V-Tubers from JP. But NA doesn't even have something like that since, and lets be absolutely honest. Lasengle/ Aniplex could lose NA and not give 2 shits about us aside from the revenue loss which JP can make up for 10 fold. Can someone please explain it to me? This isn't me trying to be a monger of any kind. I'm literally just fucking confused. Last I checked the JP audience would rather forget about NA as an existence and let it rot to the wayside. ESPECIALLY from the Corpo side. They already do the bare fucking minimum, attempting to throwing Kanou Yoshiki (2- San) under the bus (who by the way fought 2 years straight to let us get a 5 star ticket) with the Coin System, they barely put out strengthen quests for servants who desperately need them the most, don't do any meaningful changes, don't give us animation updates aside from the 2 Jeanne's and Kiara which we got recently. Kiara didn't EVEN NEED IT in comparison to other servants who are still shooting god damn caster balls to this day. Geronimo and Jekyll Hyde (as much as I hate to say it) are still objectively the worst servants in the game next to Phantom. If I was a JP player, I'd be trying to start a god damn revolution against all of this bull shittery and forcing Sony/ Aniplex who have grown to complacent with their money printer to make major improvement. I legitimately think that FGO started going down hill since the 7th anniversary. At least when it comes to meaningful updates main story chapters aside. But apparently, and please correct me if I'm wrong on this, as I could be very incorrect. Its ok to respect corporations more and considering that if you say anything negative about them, it can end up having you be stuck in a defamatory lawsuit which they'll more than likely win as it is culturally acceptable to consider "guilty until proven innocent" and that "whoever is suing you, they're more than likely in the right" to do so anyway. I've even heard of horror stories of people saying awful things about the companies on the internet over in JP and them getting sued for it as a result. TLDR Fuck Sony, Fuck Aniplex, and FUCK THE SUITS who can't seem to be even remotely fair with these kind of guidelines. Like come on, not being able to show Bond CE's? They fucking suck for the most part. Lore and pretty art aside (which we can just google anyway), they all do the same garbage stuff which BY THE WAY WE WERE PROMISED A REWORK ON 2 YEARS AGO. WHERE'S THAT AT LASENGLE? CARE TO EXPLAIN? I apologize, if any of this was offensive. But it just angers me so much that FGO, a game I hold in such high regards is being treated like this because its ok to not care about their audiences apparently. Do they not even realize how messed up a lot of this is for the basic viewers like me who get excited to see whats 2 years down the road? Its what keeps me motivated to keep playing FGO despite games like Nikke who have just as compelling story telling and if not better gameplay/ gatcha to keep sticking around. The complacency and stagnation makes it feel like FGO is going to be pruned on its own like a Lostbelt at some point because of how its being treated. The only thing keeping it up is the high level of story telling and the IP name. Thats it. This game would have died off like other gatcha games at this point if it weren't for that. Its a game I've grown with since the first anniversary on the NA side. Its helped me through so much mental depression, and has legitimately saved my life as sappy as it sounds. The story of the lostbelts... the story of humanity, how despite all its short comings and flaws can still find ways to make up for it. And improve, to press forward. I hate it so much. So. So. Much. I can't describe it very easily. I apologize for using your comment section as a venting/ ranting thing Plushie. Its not ok, and isn't something that should be seen. I just hate how this game is going into what I think is the shitter because it can't adapt to more modern standards and isn't capable of even trying to slowly role out updates that would be meaningful. I STILL FEAR I may lose my account because it isn't linked to my Google Account. For whatever awful reason it maybe. This isn't fair, and the JP audience needs to do something for fuck sake. I just don't know what would be the catalyst for it. It would have to be such a monumental fuck up that even Sony wouldn't be able to ignore it lest they lose even more faith with even their most loyal of fans. Nasu would literally have to step in and take the wheel for things to even look hopeful. And that poor man's already overworked as is. They literally tried to publicly throw Kanou Yoshiki under the bus during the 9th anniversary. I BET by the 10th they'll try to find an excuse to fire him for someone who's money grubbing and "perfect" in Sony's eyes. I don't even get why that, NOT EVEN THAT didn't get the JP crowd to move aside from the Coin Changes. They had the door open, they could have taken A GOD DAMN MILE.
Sometimes I get videos from JP from your everyday UA-camr to the official JP FGO channel . I don't think they are the kind that actively looked for creators like Plushie, xNaya or maybe Myst. I would guess that these videos just somewhat popped into their feed and are outraged by it.
@ChaldeaWarmaster I never genuinely care for VTuber stuff tbh. It just isn't my thing, not knocking others for enjoying it. But I genuinely don't get the appeal. I prefer older style of youtube commentary like they were from the early 2010's. SSoHPKC is one of the only few youtubers I've ever went back to aside from Myst and Plushie that I ACTIVELY watch. He's from an old youtube group called "The Creatures".
NA is literally the privileged server. Always second to get Qol improvements, unique banners, best compensation if they screw up. And you are complaining about Pekora? She doesn't affect your gameplay at all! It's not like she skins Mash's face and wears it in game to fuck with you or anything, it's just a merch release. And I almost forgot, NA did sponsor HoloEN to do some fgo content, you just missed it.
I'm NA exclusive, but... I'm also a really small and newer channel who compares FGO characters to their originals. If this starts to come after me? It could ruin my entire channel. I have been preparing to branch out a bit to try some new things, but... perhaps I should speed that up just in case these rules come to NA as well. I completely don't understand why they would create these overly restrictive and asinine rules. x_x
Entities that own IP can always do what they want with it, even if people using it have gotten comfortable and may be blindsided when that entity actually enforces its ownership. That's all to say I agree that you should definitely diversify what you do. It's the same with an office job, one should be able to take on different types of work in case there main one is no longer needed.
I've enjoyed your videos too. Maybe Lasengle will implement a similar approach to being a sponsored creator for them similar to what Capcom did awhile back. That may be an odd coincidence anyway, considering Yoshinori Oro came from Capcom and now works at Lasengle.
Indeed. While I love your content, these guidelines seem to be made to practically crucify anyone who dares to make content about their game due to their CEO who was infamous for ruining Street Fighter 5. Diversifying your content will be a good way to still generate revenue and widen the scope of what you create.
So this is kind of an "end of an era", with how some of the Japanese are accepting and endorsing this guideline; as well as barely being able to see stuff in FGO? Because it truly feels like it
Why shouldn't they endorse it? People are right to be mad at xNaya spoilering everyone with thumbnails. The problem are content creators like him who made Sony made a move, not Sony for listening to user base.
@@Dorrovian ... because the content is not aimed at them? It's like I went to X to mass report Japanese users for showing screenshots of OC3 because they're also spoiling everyone. Thing is, their stuff wouldn't normally show up on my feed if I didn't look directly for them. UA-cam is something similar but not quite. The UA-cam algorithm is bad enough that English content ends up in their feed. However, if they really don't want to be spoiled, they can easily unsubscribe to their JP FGO tubers and watch something else entirely so the algorithm will think you no longer want to watch it. It's rather simple and it baffles me in nearly a decade old game... they seem to lack the mental capacity to do that if they're so desperate, yet never said a peep years ago in such way and only do so now because of some guidelines. If they wanna go out of their way to ruin it to everyone, well, guess they can keep the xenophobia as well too.
@@Dorrovian because those guidelines are way to restrictive, it would be understantable if it was like " you can only upload new content 2 weeks after the release" but this one limits to something released in 2019 and it blocks events,interludes and boss fights without an end date It would make sense if fgo was a paid game
@@Dorrovian the problem is players being unable to ignore spoilers im already like 5 years into FGO or more, and i still have never been spoiled on story in FGO, because i do something as simple as ignoring anything i dont wanna see, including thumbnails, and that includes xnaya's, i just see some weird mob on them and im "im not clicking that nor reading that title even", and continue with my life
As a member of a nore niche side of the community, being the Roleplay and Fanfic Community, having story translations restricted actually hits hard and prevents us from keeping up to date on the lore to know whats happening, to know what can happen, whats been re-explained or retconned for all our own stories and characters and balancing, etc. etc. Especially since not all of us can just read japanese nor do us Type-Moon fans even have wikis and websites that stay up to date, dont shove in headcanon, and just leave portions describing what a character has done in specific stories despite full official or reliable fan translation existing.
I'm worried because the JP FGOtubers I'm following are my sources of the story (even if I don't understand what they're saying) and demos of new characters.
Well, you can blame the JP players raising a stink about it. The hilariously ironic part is they're also guilty of not playing the game but want the content without actually interacting with it, hence this guideline.
@@reishiki8682 and not caring about this and still spoiling the content. I just wanted to check some FGO fanart in X by inputting FGO in the search bar and I got spoiled there instead of UA-cam or Reddit because of their screenshots on OC3. And I can't even report them for that. How on earth is that fair?
@@abrahammesrajecorrea2349 And that's why the internet is both a convenience and a hindrance at the same time. Not helped by how majority of "self-proclaimed players/fans" will act all high and mighty about jt.
My favourite part is that early this year lasengle themselves put spoilers for lostbelt 5,7 and ordeal call prologue in the story of the fate samurai remnant Collab that is fuyuki lock
No one should respect this. This is while Mihoyo has a content creator prerelease server to shill their new things, while FGO wouldnt piss on most of their fans if they were on fire.
I mean, Lack of QOL and incredibly shitty gacha + servant coins + this, it is not surprising to me at all that they are behind the times, those gacha mechanics and rates only worked over 4 years ago because the genre was just starting, and it was already outdated by then, and then again FGO is outdated not just in that but in many other areas as well.
@@xLuis89xHaving to update to "so-proclaimed modern standards" means they're desperate for money... when they're not. Because at the end of the day FGO is just a collect your favorite type of game. You go in, you spend in-game currency and gamble with the rates, simple and straightforward. Nothing else to entice you to spend beyond the characters and/or their gameplay, no passes, paywalls or paid cosmetics. Meanwhile other games will plaster you with so many ads that usually entails "buy X to improve your gameplay experience", which is more blatantly scummy because FGO's rates "are bad" but they're not sugarcoating it in the first place. Hell, it's one of the very few games that bother making lower rarity characters useful or have a niche that lets them play their intended style, most gachas have units that age so quickly that their relevancy usually only lasts two to three weeks of their debut before they're powercrept and rendered irrelevant.
@@xLuis89x You missed the point with Gacha games and mechanics, because the only "modern" mechanic was to have a separate server. Pity does exist, gacha rates are still hell, even Azur Lane despite being beyond the cream of the crop still does not have the good gacha rates for your desired Shipgirl. Hell AL's market changed from WWII geeks to "L2D cashcows" and that worked wonders for them. Its more of the fact that they do not understand what their market focus should be: is it the skins, the new characters they can produce, the plot?, or find something pointless to spend on? Because they are trying to tap on a market that another gacha game already perfected or pioneered and do not understand how they did it. Like E7's equipment and QOL improvements that was a part of the puzzle of why they succeeded and FGO still fumbled there. BA also has another benefit of using a mechanic similar to Servant coins to unlock specific Character only upgrades but BA made it a lot more accessible for F2P grindable characters like Yuuka and Hoshino and FGO's servant coin doesn't even fully understand that in the slightest.
yeah lasagna sure, just let all TA runs ded from not being able to use few of hundreds useless free CEs, that's actually better at supporting a team in a single player team oriented game than the 5* gacha CEs you're supposed to pay for sry guys, Arash and F2P TAs are deadge now
This type of behavior is insane and very common sadly from music corporation and corporations in general base in JP, the fact that Sony owns Lasangle is even more scary since they are know to go scorch earth when they use the copyright system. Sometimes they will just issue a warning but they could very well use the strikes even multiple at the same time, also I don't trust the way they say it will not apply to older videos, if they changed their minds once they can change it many times in the future.
FGO has a strict restriction about story spoiling. However, Sony Music Entertainment or LSG didn't check your videos manually. If they didn't see your videos, they didn't do a copyright strike (not a copyright claim, remember this). Actually, they saw and they knew your videos but they didn't care. It is the fact that someone reported your videos to Sony Music. JP streamers can not make videos story after Lostbelt 4. It is not fair, right? So, just maybe, they reported
You are indeed correct, There were claims here n there back in the day like with Kita's stream ages ago but they never actually struck a channel before it's after JP players and JP content creators started to report to Aniplex and Sony they had to react since as sad as it is JP players are the most profitable.
JP gacha dev: "Let's region lock our games! All of UA-camrs who make videos about our games, copystrike 'em all! Also keep our game as low budget as possible, and as cash-grab as possible!" Also JP gacha dev: "Why do Chinese and Korean gacha games more successful?"
This has been consistently the theme with JP games company. Like just look at Blue Protocol, the fabled MMORPG that in all honestly looked really good. It was hyped to near death and now it's on its way to EoS. And one of the big reasons why is because it's region locked. Meanwhile Genshin and Wuthering are thriving because they don't put stupid region lock on their games.
@@ahmadyulinuBecause making a global release is in of itself a huge risk, as it's far costlier than a region-specific one. It could even render a company go in the red (Disgaea RPG nearly got NIS to declare bankruptcy because of how bad the launch was and how there's barely any income on its global version, which forced its shutdown while the JP one is still ongoing).
I really hope the situation can get better or at least turn back to where we were before this rule was even made, playing JP alone and not seeing any videos made about everything new and exciting to see, is just not right for me. And yeah, I can protect myself from spoilers, and even if I get spoiled something in FGO, I don't think I would be so upset about it, and definitely not to the point that I have to make UA-camrs who enjoy the game stop showing their enjoyment I like FGo because of Fate, but I've been playing for this long in both NA and JP definitely was because of you guys Yeah I don't want this to go through at all... I really hope they understand this feeling to do something to change this
It's becoming a hot topic of how horrible the decision made by FGO devs. Stresses it's global. A lot of money is being pull back. Congratz Lasagna, you are digging your own grave.
This is a business cutting off their nose to spite their face because they have no creative talent left. It's clear the leadership has no concept of the massive value they are accruing from free advertising being produced by content creators.
These stupid Japanese corporates i swear. On the plus side, I don't need to get worried about getting accidentally spoiled on the NA side. It's 2024 and NA still has a fricking 2 year gap with JP, just who in Sony thought that timegating 2 years of content as a good business decision 😂😂😂
I'm not sure the 2 year gap was a Sony decision. It's just what happened. If staying 2 years behind was a Sony choice...then it's the rare Sony choice I'm fine with. Catching up would have been an absolute nightmare.
my god this rules is so awfully stupid. i was like, fine with bond ce and ost's but not allowing lb5 onwards? any limited event which not required clear fuyuki (high-end cont)? and even olga marie quest?? might be waste but your action to remove some vids are correct for now though. for every global fgo youtubers out there, pls do take care of yourself. i hope you guys stay strong through this new guidelines, the community always got your back
They keep pressuring players to finish story, but stuck and/or struggling on boss fights. How the fvckin hell did they think we got through it when most of us are busy irl?! Those incoming super difficult Olga-babe nodes, future advancement quests and event CQ's, pod quests.. We need their videos to give us some ideas to come up with our own based on our roster servants. TO HELL WITH THESE GUIDELINES!!
If its down to the JP players complaining then I will be pissed. they got pissy when NA had the chaldea breakroom stuff and they didn't, meaning DW (at the time) had to start making that too. Then because the JP players have bitched so much the devs have started making NA exclusive stuff, like banners and such. The JP players are the most petulant players I have seen, throwing tantrums constantly because they don't get their own ways.
@@therojoking7039 I actually think it’s the complete opposite: they aren’t complaining enough. The servant coins drama? The game gave us a couple of SQ and they finally shut up. The JP player base just eats whatever slop they’re given, and it’s sad to see since they’re the only ones who are capable of changing their game for the better.
@@elontusk9167 that's the thing, the collectvie community have been so indoctrinated into consuming and enjoing this and that to the point they feel lile they belong to a cult
@@elontusk9167 Simple are real. They are the most submissive gamers out there. I'd rather take the insane Genshin community that complains over anything, at least there, changes are made.
@@alexandrunache9078Changes that ultimately don't matter in the bottom line anyway as what they deliver is still the same stuff, hence them being labeled "professional victims". Whereas in this case it's mainly story... which majority are guilty of skipping getting through the actual gameplay part of it and just want to get to the story segments without effort. Hence certain players getting annoyed because they're taking their time and they get spoiled because of a search suggestion.
I think it would be better to post both the Min turn and the F2P run of the Olga Marie quests in one video and just timestamp it, just in case of any mishaps, I think that could be a "Safer" way to break the rules
Looking at the loosening, i know we are getting recollections for Atlantis/Olympus soon-ish I’m worried for the wikis to be honest. It’s only social media for now but the wikis are easy to access
We FGOtubers can *at least* make videos on our Gacha Rolls, Servant Skills & Animations, and Event Boss Fights. At least that last one for events that require Fuyuki Completion.
You're in luck, summer 8 spoils the entire LB6 cast and it's Fuyuki locked so I guess their laziness in making the guidelines doesn't stop fgotubers from still spoiling story post LB5.
@@THEBULLETPROOFKINGDOM not even that, they folded faster than you can imagine considering in Summer 2 Schez had her True Name. So I really don’t want to hear people complaining about spoilers when they have shown in the past to not care. Either that or they are incompetent, or both.
Japan’s draconian Fair Use rules strike again. Obviously check with lawyers before doing anything, but if you’re in the US Sony can’t enforce these rules without suing you, which they won’t do cause it risks setting a precedent they don’t want on their hands. Granted, that means possibly giving Sony your dox in a DMCA counter-claim, but you can keep your videos up if you’re willing to do that. European countries and Canada should have similar rules, check your local laws to be sure. Now whether you actually WANT your play chicken with your channel like that? Different story entirely. Good luck, gang!
the problem is UA-cam, you get 3 copywright strikes your channel is gone. it is the 3 strike system. and offcourse you can appeal. but that takes a long time. Sony doesn't even go to court, cause you have to fight google first. that is why it is such a hassle. and bad actors and companies exploit that system a lot.
They just got out of a controversy (the shit anniversary), and now they do this? Don't they think? Lasgna/Sony have no brains and want the game to die?
Lol, this is clearly decision of crusty old upper management, they still think fan made stuff should not make any money from their IP, and doujins are copyight infringement. But they forgot these kind of things are pretty much free advertising.
Feels like another shot in the foot by them… So much of the enjoyment of the game is in seeing what other people do… min turn… etc… People need to make noise about this, maybe they will yield again. Lasengle is getting unreasonable.
It also says about SOUND PLAYER? What does it mean? So we can't use the soundtrack and servant dialogue too? What about NP animation? This is nightmare as I do FGO unboxing figures and I use those as resources to decorate my videos.
This is one of the stupidest things FGO/aniplex/lasengle have ever done. This is going to ruin their own reach in overseas markets. Because youtubers like Plushie are how FGO gets traction. It’s such bullshit.
Temporary Spoiler Locks on just the latest Story Parts aside, This is one of the weirdest spoiler locks and ToS Decisions I've seen in a LONG while and it's only hurting the game in the long run.
Probably best to expand your content to other things, like other games, just in case Sony goes full on Dumbnium on strikes. At the very least you can still keep things running if things go sideways on the FGO content. Honestly they're just shooting their own foot at this point, shooting down your own exposure on platforms such as this is a surefire way to drain the interest of this game.
Remember when everyone thought FGO couldn't get any lower after the 9th anniversary fiasco? At this point I just want the story to end already and close the game for good
@@alexng7298 I don't know the exact stances, so take this with a grain of salt, but I remember I read a comment somewhere saying how JP players would probably willingly report content because of Japanese etiquette and norms. Don't remember the exact word, but they're also probably a lot more tolerant with whatever happens, even if it is bad
So how that JP bois think we can beat the new upcoming bosses? try and retry every time a "unexpected" action from the boss take place, like remove buffs, got solemn pierce, instakill thing, etc.? Is thanks to the videos i can safely prepare and beat the boss, even with the blue stones that works like command spells, is so anoying going to try and retry the boss only coz JP bois don´t want spoilers.
@@Luca-yb4sh Said communities use the same source, the wiki. The core issue is that the game itself doesn't tell you ...well, the game. You don't know how much your skill leveled up unless you check the wiki, you don't know the chance of IP to proc, you don't even know what a new servant does unless you or someone else pulls them. The wiki and the guides people make are a necessity, they are the core of experiencing the game because the game itself doesn't do it and you wouldn't want to be more miserable than you already are.
@@alexandrunache9078My guy, this isn't a rocket science test, everything is RNG. What majority players check online are the boss mechanics, its gimmicks and suggestions on how to tackle them. That you're obsessed with numbers probability means you're one of those players that want to min-turn it with unga bunga huehue gigamaxes so you don't get hassled by its gimmicks.
@@reishiki8682 I'm sorry, but knowing where my time and effort goes is not an obsession with numbers. Knowing that 1 skill that charges np gives 50 unlike another that gives 30 is a big deal. Not because of your horrible assumption (which I don't understand the aggressiveness behind it) about me, but because like you said people care about boss mechanics and easier ways to defeat them. Wouldn't that knowledge, that you farmed for a specific character to lv 10 their skill and that choice helps you deal with a boss better than if you chose another skill, be exactly why people look for these numbers? We are not asking for much, just standard practice... because the alternative is to tab out and search the wiki every single time you need to know if that 72 proof of hero material is actually going to help that skill or not. Redundant stuff shouldn't be in a multibillion dollar game and you shouldn't defend them like this. So my guy, don't take it personally but, have some standards. This says more about what you allow others to do to you than it says about me.
@@reishiki8682 are you this clueless? knowing how much of a battery do you get from one skill or how much crit stars you get from a skill is absolutely viable, don't even try to think otherwise, that type of data is very useful, PERIOD.
I tell ya fgo gameplay is boring The only thing that is interesting is the servant animation n their story Other than that, i doubt it could garner many players interest You should switch it by now I mean, gacha game keep evolving during these years
If all else fails, you can always be a Shrek Superslam UA-camr In all seriousness, sucks this is happening, but I'll stay tuned for anything you pump out
it will most likely will be short lived, seein as how everything happens in FGO and they still praise it to heaven and beyond, like the ''pity'' system''
@@neilisawesome2333 the JP playerbase doesn't give a shit if the global players leave, it doesn't affect them at all, that's why they are pushing this, lmfao
This is no content restriction, this is simply dictatorship, too many stupid rules, looks like Lasengle is saying "hey guys we don't need more money than Japanese players spending with us already, so we restricted you so you can invest your time and money playing other gachas instead, you are welcome", looks like the extra append skills from the 9th anni were kind of hint about Lasengle getting even greedier and ridiculous than ever
it's kind of funny how only when the append patch happened people were really concerned about the state of the game... it's long overdue by like 4 years, lmfao
the funniest part of this is the bond CE restriction. I can understand why someone would want to be surprised but at the same time, you could also get spoiled by literally playing the game and seeing someone with the bond CE equipped in your supports. And how would you even enforce that? What, you need to blur your CEs every time you go to the CE screen?
Lasengle being few decades behind in marketing their game just keeps on making stupid decision,instead of endorsing content creators,encouraging them to promote their game,they just shafted them,for a game which relies on word of mouth it just doesnt make sense,even with all its flaws i still really love FGO and the direction which Lasengle is going in scares me for the games future
Can't stream story cuz spoilers, can stream events with said main story spoilers. Are they playing 5D chess or ... nah they just don't care about the people free promoting their game.
@@Skolladrum I think you missed the point. Fgo has had events in the past that only required the prologue to do, yet contained characters from LB5 onward with no care to their true identities. By their rules, you can make content on summer 2023 since it’s not LB6 locked, yet spoil everything pertaining to the characters. What’s the point? Either make all events locked up till the LB they are from or don’t have dumb guidelines
Hey plushie, I checked out the guidelines, and there's a section on "where to post and stream" with a link to more details. When you click it, it lists what i think are platforms where content is allowed, and UA-cam is on there too. you might want to check because im also confused by this
I'm sorry but this is ironic because fgo appmedia has everything you're showcasing on video but in text and photos, on his channel and website. Why is that not considered spoilers? Why can they talk about fights, strategies and all but foreigners cannot? Super weird hiperfixation on certain creators.
Because appmedia is not going to be put into your YT feed randomly and spoil you story with thumbnail. xNaya does, he did to me personally until blocked him.
@@Dorrovian then that's skill issue on your own and it took you long enough to solve the problem. You don't see me whinning and wanting to mass report Japanese people for spoiling OC3 bits to me in X when all I wanted was just to see FGO fanart by inputting FGO tag in the searcher. You and the others complaining take accountability and stop ruining the fun of others and defending this.
@@Dorrovian ok, so can you please tell me HOW I can report Japapese users on X who spoiled OC3 bits to me and I bet others when all I wanted was to see fanarts? Genuine question because there's no choice to report someone for "spoiling content" on X and I'm a "victim" as you claim. I want my justice too. Tell me how can I get it, please
From what Radiant-Hope-469 wrote on Reddit, the limit is going to expand monthly and "By December 2024, the banned quests are Interludes, Ordeal Call Main Quests and Olga Marie Quests. And not Fuyuki-locked events."
all of this happening a week after i downloaded FGO NA(i had already been spoiled on everything up to LB6, i only joined for the experience).. seems like i hopped on the train at the best(worst) possible time LMAO
This is just insane, the proper way would be that you are not allowed to show anything of the current event or chapter until 48 to 72 hours have passed. As for the weird registration of old chapters I think is more for NA, since right now we are doing the road to seven campaign, after all is no secret and even Albert had been very vocal that they hate that na has that 2 years of insight in for future content. Hopefully they don't add new things in the future.
![[FGO] 『30 Million Download Campaign』EVERYTHING you need to know !](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f2bKFA9l-1w/mqdefault.jpg)
![[FGO] 『30 Million Download Campaign』EVERYTHING you need to know !](/img/tr.png)
![[FGO] Werewolf Advancement Quest Tutorial (Spoken)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UuEornJ7_g4/mqdefault.jpg)
What a stupid and senseless set of policies. Lostbelt 4 came out in 2019. Restricting content back as far as five years is ridiculous.
Yep, I don't understand why you'd listen to such a minor problem regarding spoilers when any sensible player knows how to avoid them. Plus there must be players like me who usually skip most of the story or event quests on release since I don't have time everyday to read the story bits and you have limited time rewards tied but later go through vods to see someone else's playthrough rather than using the in game replay feature.
What do you expect from a company that keeps a strict 2 year game update gap between global and JP when most modern live service games try to either eliminate completely with a global release schedule or keep the gap as small as possible.
@@Chaosloki Normally I'd agree but with FGO the 2-year gap is impossible to close and make into a global server for NA and JP. There are way too many events and banners that they'd have to jam together for the average casual player to try and play. There'd be way too much chaos for people to try and keep up even if they released everything back-to-back immediately. As of right now there are over 100+ campaigns/events/banners total within that 2-year gap. Plus, it really is useful at the least that NA players can actually plan ahead whereas JP gets shafted with unpredictability lol.
-
But regarding the guideline stuff for spoilers, that stuff is stupid.
@@d4nkdesu the problem is the strikes, not the nonsense guideline
@@BboyEasySteps two years ago jp was so full of dead weeks that if na wanted they could easily cut out around one year of the gap lol
This is worse than Atlus with the Persona series.
FGO grows by word-of-mouth on Global and limiting what content creators release is insane.
What did atlus do with persona?
Wow FGO is lagging behind newer gachas you'd think they want the overall fandom to be as active as possible and keep talking about FGO but they decide to gatekeep NA out and kill engagement among players and content creators about newer contents. Bold strategy Cotton let's see how this plays out for them.
@@INCOGNITO-iq4qy They'll probably reverse the changes once the realise that
@@ForYouTheOneListeningThey'll never realized that. The Japanese are famous for never learning anything from history or from the examples set by others.
@@ForYouTheOneListening Persona 5 Royal was restricted to be streamed for a certain time.
I've actually been hit with a copyright warning when it comes parts of the story and some music related to the collabs but never a strike. This is pretty crazy.
Yeah its strikes, I waited a week to release this after confirming everything privately with some other CCs that focus on posting new story bossfights. Unless the Sony Music Entertainment is an imposter its unfortunately a direct strike
Music is always a danger. Especially on YT.
Fuck
For constructive criticism, I've actually had to watch your videos on mute because sometimes you'll randomly mention a story spoiler without warning.
I hope at least the music will be save, I really want to listen to OC IV OST, if or when it comes out 😅
Fgo just recovering from servant coin situation then this happen 😢
Think about it on the bright side, if you are just a player this affects you minimally
@@PlushieMistress It still sucks to see content creators get hit by this
@@PlushieMistress Not for me. I don't make content, but I do watch content. It is how I stuck with the game. I also spend money on NA. But now I just don't feel like spending as much money on the game if this is how they are gong to act. If this affects you guys, I will take it as affecting me as well. Which means the wallet gets closed each time they do something.
I think the difference is that unlike servant coins, the JP fanbase isn't as against it compared to those outside of Japan.
@@PlushieMistress Won't be for long if they keep this up. End of story.
Wtf FGO. They really are punishing the very people who support the game.
they have done since the game came out thanks to that horrendous gacha, lmfao, now they are doing it even worse with this.
Such a stupid move
Every other games: please promote my game to your audience
FGO: heh
I knew Sony would show his ugly side at some point. After the Concord debacle they are panicking and over correcting. 400 million loss has wide consequences.
And the 700 ps5 pro with no disk or vertical stand.
Sony really wants all people to hate them, it seems. At this point, no one worth their salt should ever forgive them
@@juanbriones5989 Oh yeah that little jewel of a console, I made a PC for 600 when the PS5 came because I thought the price was too high, I play now in 2k 100-120 fps, why would any sensible person buy a PS5 Pro?
there's a limit how much they want to dry our money
the next kodak
The fact that this is over Japanese fans worried about spoilers is nuts, Japan is notorious about spoiling their shit in the trailers and previews 😂
And yet even so, there were legit Japanese comments on Plushie, xNaya, and NeoBenedict’s videos complaining that they spoiled BB Dubai’s 3rd ascension, and the final boss of OC3. So it’s definitely a thing that they were reported.
japanese don't want spoilers and then go and watch english speaking people to be stupidly spoiled, lmfao what is this?
@@xLuis89x YT feed showing you thumbnails and titles that will spoiler you. Even if you block CC afterwards you have been already spoilered.
None of them care about the overseas content creators. From their perspectives you're all just foreigners showing story spoilers 😢
I could get if it was a big spoiler like Oberon third asc, but BB third asc. is just flashy costume without any meaning
Other games: Pay CC to promote their games
Meanwhile FGO:
This.
JP gacha dev: "Let's region lock our games! All of UA-camrs who make videos about our games, copystrike 'em all! Also keep our game as low budget as possible, and as cash-grab as possible!"
Also JP gacha dev: "Why do Chinese and Korean gacha games more successful?"
Banning the story is fine and understandable but banning the gameplay and boss fight is dumb. That is like 90% of the content that can be made with out actually spoiled much of the content while creating hype for the game.
Honestly Japanese companies need to grow up, they’ve been doing this for over a decade.
Bruh no banning the story is complete nonsense
the fgo replay feature is dreadful if i want to reread the story i'm going on youtube lol. Not to mention youtube has been a place where entire playthrough of 60 buck games are uploaded, like come on if that was actually bad business you can bet youtube would have been censored since the 2010's
And the wors part is that their reasonong is the stop spoilers.... Wtf... SPOILERS?????? this is what you're worried about??????? That's none of their business like wtf seriously? Spoilers has to be one of the biggest nonsense debate of the decade like who the hell actually cares enough about spoiler regulation to start gunning in all directions, if your stories is "ruined" by spoilers then it wasn't a good story bruh
This no spoiler policy is just as stupid as everything else, this is game workshop level of shooting yourself in the foot, remember when the astartes short film was removed from youtube to be put in a terrible warhammer plateform? Yeah that's the sort of genius decision making we're dealing with
@@fatcat2015Sony is no longer Japanese studio though... It's mostly western in California.
@@pougetguillaume4632well for game workshops. Their solution is simple. They just release a new chapter of Space Marine (which they have done hundred times) and Warhammer fans will forget everything that has happened instantly and praise Game Workshop as the second coming of Emperor or something.
@@pougetguillaume4632 banning the story is understandable if it's just maybe a week(?) or so, still a dick move but you can kind of make sense of it. until you realize that lb4 was 5 years ago and it's (as of September) the furthest that we can post
Forget catching up with chinese gacha games, f/go is digging its own grave.
At least globally. Seems like the JP players want to gatekeep the game from fans from elsewhere.
@@orga7777who'd have thought that japanese people are racist
I'm sorry, but they're not gonna feel anything from this. This will do next to nothing to their bottom line.
We really shouldn't pretend that this is gonna have half the impact people are acting like it will.
@@orga7777 even if the topic is JP players, i feels like JP likely to play Blue Archive rather than FGO unless they're typemoon fans, especially for gen Z and gen alpha they would likely to try Blue Archive if they want to try gacha games
More like Sony is digging the grave.
All this to avoid spoilers. This is such a dumb call
An ordeal call
Trully ordeal call moment
@@PlushieMistress a Lostbelt, if you will. Remember we're back to only covering the Lostbelts now
@@Hollyrking268Ordeal MID*
I've always thought FGO is too half-hearted and inconsistent about guarding about spoilers, often doing basically noting or being too restrictive, but this is a step further into unreasonble. Gatekeeping 4+ year-old content? Whoever made this call is so out of touch with reality. It seems clear to me they're just imposing an arbitrary ban to get the fans complaining to shut up and stop making a fuss.
Knowing this community, all Lasagna has to do is give some free SQ and everything will be forgiven.
But seriously, after the fiasco that was the Ivan Raid, it became quite obvious that they DON'T GIVE A SH*T about the NA Server and this is just more proof of that since with FGO barely being advertised outside Japan the global version DEPENDS on content creators to stay relevant.
They dont have to do that, big jp fgotubers are supporting this decision unlike the coins
@@PlushieMistressR.I.P to the NA Players i guess then...😮💨
Even if JP players didn't support this, why would FGO give SQ for this? It's not something Lasengle did, and it would basically be acknowledging that their boss Sony did something wrong.
Not even sq can make this make sense to me. Don't be sellouts fellas
They would need free SQ and rollback the decision or it's not worth it
Bond CEs? Are they going to send cease and desists to the wikis?
imagine lol, now nobody knows how to play the game lol
@@lickilicky5288maybe now the devs had to actually work and put all of that data in the Game.😂
@@chaosblazko5863 Hahahah one can wish... one can wish...
A horrible business decision ever.
It is fine being safe for now, Plushie, but if in a month if xNaya or someone similar (who was mentioned by the raging JP base) are not hit then I think you should be fine. If your friend who got hit is trying to appeal to the JP base, that is probably why he got hit. Since these guidelines are NOT posted in English anywhere on the Global Server, you should definitely not worry about it until they are.
LMAO, Sony just can't stop taking Ls.
- Concord blows up on their face.
- Their "Spiderman Villains" movies are atrocious (which by the way, is only to keep the MCU from adapting said villains).
- Their AI attempts in Subtitling anime got exposed (downsizing my a**)
- And now, the biggest potential pull for FGO Global is in shambles all because "spoilers".
Funny how the Japanese defend these. The stories have been sh*t for some time. And now these buffoons decide to gatekeep almost 5-year old stories as spoilers?
Who in their right mind considers a 5 year old story as spoilers? This won't attract sht in the future. No wonder 30M DL has hit a wall.
JP does generate the most revenue because (1) Global can't attract new players because of your shenanigans, and (2) most of the spenders in Global still invest more on JP.
Global is two years behind and they're practically killing potential draws with this stupid decision all because of spoilers.
Japanese players think it's honorable to secure the story, in reality, Sony has their hand so far up their a-.
Enjoy the accelerating pitfall of this game.
Another big reason for which JP is more profitable, other than being the OG server, is that it's in the Japanese culture to spend some money monthly on collectibles and gacha. It generates an income comparable to a subscription model with spikes of sudden micro-transactions when the new shiny thing drops.
This is so disappointing. I was always hoping FGO could evolve like Star Rail, but now they're evolving backwards.
@@kotominekirei7330 That really should have been its goal, it could have grown so much even with just Arcade and stuff. But nay.
@@k.e.v.2011 this truly reiterates my point that FGO is the potential man of gacha games
To be fair, this game should've died a long time ago. Aside from the story (for those who enjoy), nothing it presents brings anything decent to the table.
To you and your fellow c.c, thank you for your effort. The most valuable thing of FGO is the community you built along the way.
日本人としてもFGОの今回のガイドラインはおかしいと思ってる
やり過ぎだと思うし、だったら新規ストーリーを1週間配信しないようにすればいいのに
それを全面禁止にするとか頭大丈夫なのかって思う
@@ドリルバスター2021 thank you. Thank you for seeing these guidelines are wrong unlike others defending them.
@@abrahammesrajecorrea2349 I think others only defend them because they are angry Western content creators have Fair Use to fall back on unlike them. It is jealousy.
This person does not represent the opinions of Japanese people at all, so do not misunderstand.
You foreigners are not players or fans, but criminals who infringe on the copyrights of others for selfish reasons.
I really never minded the story spoilers since they're just scenes out of context. Even with major spoilers like Oberon and Cernnunos, it only works when you have the full context. This guidelines simply doesn't make sense.
Oberon is a spoiler, though. But I think that is the only one, because even without context it ruins the reveal if you saw that before playing it. The rest I would not consider spoilers at all.
@@orga7777I’d say I was very thoroughly spoiled about Oberon and a few lb6 story beats and I still enjoyed how things played out. I think I ended up liking Oberon even more than if I had gone in without knowledge. I think, ironically, partially knowing the story made me enjoy characters like Barghest and Morgan less. And I was absolutely smitten with Barghest’s art (giant woman, giant muscles, giant tits, hell yeah). Morgan I’m mostly just uninterested in her other than her QP gifts.
@@orga7777 And then you'll get shit like good smile releasing figures of "Oberon Votigern" LMAO but I guess it's fine as long as they're making the money and not CCs
@@annie.V. The story made me love all of the Fairy Knights. And Morgan is probably my favorite character so far. I love her story in LB6.
@@orga7777 I can see why people like the fairy knights and Morgan but some of them I don’t like for design reasons and some for story reasons. *MASSIVE SPOILERS, BEWARE* Like:
Melu wtf is that 3rd/4th ascension? I don’t want to see it but have to because of gameplay reasons. I thought her story with Aurora and Percival were fantastic but genuinely “ugh” at those ascensions. She’s just wayy too overdesigned. Even ignoring the Albion mud on her pretty much naked body (she looks too young for me), her face paint is wholly unappealing and her weapons and wings make her sprite (and 3rd art) cluttered without harmony.
Barghest, you burnt alive innocent fairies and enslaved the “humans” as your “dogs” then we just pretend that you’re an innocent and just knight?? Huh?? I know that she was cursed with a ceaseless hunger and I don’t blame her for falling to temptation and losing what remained of her sanity when she remembered her greatest sin but like? We go to her house and act all cuddly and domestic after we recently watched her burn down the Autumn Forest and its inhabitants. What happened with the story there?
And Morgan has Firefly (Honkai Star Rail) Syndrome in that she become’s our wife (while not knowing what it actually means iirc) and you don’t really have a say in it. She lacks the charm of the Tamamos and (even though I dislike her) Kiyohime so it feels forced.
Adding to my gripes with Morgan, I understand her hatred of the Lostbelt’s fae. An abnormally large population of the fae (of the ones we meet) are either beyond redemption or are lacking in impulse control. She encourages Baobahn Sith(BBS) to emulate the behavior she hates because it’ll keep BBS alive longer… supposedly. Morgan doesn’t teach her daughter how to survive past “be mean, do some magic tricks” and is surprised when it backfires. I actually think she wasted BBS’s potential as both an heir as well as accidentally sabotaged her. edit: Pretty sure it’s intentional to some extent. Morgan’s main thing seems to be that, despite her overwhelming strength, she fails at her most important moments. At least during LB6, otherwise she just wins after she enters Chaldea.
I also largely disagree with Morgan’s sentiment that a country only amounts to the land within it’s borders. What’s the point of running/ruling a country if nobody (or at least nobody you want living) is there for you to govern?
Baobahn Sith? I actually really like her. She’s a really good mirror and rival for Caster. I actually kinda wish we had interpersonal character dialogues in the My Room alongside the “About (Character Name)” voice lines because I’d be interested to see Caster and BBS’s rivalry/friendship. I love her casual catty bitch behavior. She’s peak girl failure and I love her. (I’m not crazy about BBS’s summer version though. Cute design but, huh? It doesn’t make sense to me…)
I do feel for the situation you are left to delicately walk around.
It's a tough spot. To a degree I get why they'd do something like this. Some people are absurdly fast to drop spoilers of the latest stuff and it's easy for that stuff to end up in front of you (be it youtube or social media). And goodness knows I remember being annoyed as heck about LB6 spoilers being thrown around right before LB6 (and specific parts) unlocked. But this is a pretty extreme stance. And it makes things really tough for those making videos.
Sadly I agree that there isn't likely to be any effective backlash or pushback on this. If the JP side is cool with it then...that's all that will matter to the people at the top.
the one who probably signed off on this is the current ceo of lasengle, yoshinori ono. he left street fighter 5 in such a bad state and his team really disliked him, after he left they made the new sf6 a success. i told you before this guy was trouble when he suddenly became ceo of lasengle a while back
So they basically don't want free advertisement anymore is what this saying.
Has any other gatcha game ever censored content creators from covering gameplay? This is incredibly ridiculous.
Right!? Like plushie should be getting some in-game rewards at least for being one of the biggest fgotubers in the na community. Pretty much all modern gacha games promotes content creation
Gacha games literally paying sponsorships to get streamers to showcase their latest update meanwhile Sony copying Nintendo Yakuza's style.
Nintendo is the only other one that comes to mind, and even they went back a bit on that.
Gachas don't generally do this.
But bigger console games, especially Japanese ones, do it all the time. Embargos are pretty normal.
The issue here is more how strict it is.
@@devo1246 ofc because most console games are not live service and if their story and content gets spoiled then nobody would want to play the game since they already know how it goes.
GBF, Atelier Resleriana and others: go whatever you want and keep winning.
FGO: those are forbidden and keep losing.
A disappointing result from typical asian corporations. Unfortunately while extremely disappointing, it's not surprising either. They just don't like fandom freedom without permission and while the spoilers are smth I do have an issue with, this is too much in the other direction. I'm really sorry this happened to you Plushie.
I have never had problems with spoilers, I just don't watch FGO content at all unless it's a CQ being done or a guide for a story boss I can't beat, people really are stupid.
that's just Japanese Game publishers, Tencent, and Nexon.
Why does FGO keep going about it's problems in the most ridiculous ways possible?! just put a "Don't stream new content for one month." rule and that's it!
if fgo has to die for sony to finally go down i will be very sad
FGO isn't dying lol
Not even close.
@@devo1246 Sadly you are right, only NA is dying at least in enthusiasm, and for some reason the players still spend money in this game. JP for some reason gets all the favoritism and in turn protect their master like the brainwashed gacha addicts they are, you rarely see JP players complain even when they are facing the same issues as us... and they had for a longer time (+2 years).
@@alexandrunache9078 Japan (and asians in general) love thier waifus so much, they are willing to be robbed out of their money for them, it's sad but true, all of those QOL's all of those nice changes the game could have if JP side were more critical about the game but nah... gotta stand together to... attack content creators on Global instead, and the worst part is that the company listens to them like spoiled children.
The problem is that they thought setting a guideline, the viewers who only watch creator contents were going to play the game by themselves which increase the active players. That may roll the gacha and bring them money. Or maybe they are planning to let some famous Vtuber to do somemore FGO Story Stream like the one Pekora did in Part 1.
In addition, Kinoko said in the interview(I forget which year with Famitsu), he wants the players enjoy the experience by themselves.
However, I don't think this guideline thing is going to bring them any merits. This thing came out on the 9th anniversary along with the append skill 4,5. A lot of JP FGO streamer talked about how bad it is and unfortunate that not able to upload any latest contents.(Even farming latest free quest is forbidden) They even sent mail to ask if it is necessary to delete the past video that contain content pass LB3(That's the restriction when it come out). They replied it is okay to keep the old video and that's all.
The JP FGO streamers accepted the guideline for a while, therefore some of them are so angry about the overseas creator can do whatever they want. Spoilers are always a problem, but JP players ought to say it is your fault of looking up UA-cam or Twitter(X) before the guideline came out. The self-responsibility stuff Japanese people always talk about. But now they have the justified reason to smack the one who unpleased them.
I just want to talk about the JP player are also displeased at the first place, but the anger move from Anipex to you guys which is unforune. Rule is absolute to them.
Apology for my rusty English, haven't written English since I left university. Really love your FGO contents. My best wishes to you.
Ultimately what this is at the end of the day is a cultural difference in what are called "moral rights" over, particularly, *how* information disseminates about a work, which in Japan you typically have a lot more legal control over. Basically, there's a lot of legal protection over how an IP/trademark holder in Japan gets to have their work/service perceived and/or presented. Of course, living in a country which has that as the law of the land naturally influences a lot of people living there into seeing these Americans disrespecting those moral rights and finding it incomprehensible that we do so. In America, the freedom of information itself (and how we protect that freedom) generally trumps those moral rights from existing, and so the average American aware of this whole debacle is going to think these guidelines are ridiculous. It's just a matter of what you grew up with.
"How can you not respect the wishes of the creator of the work??? They're the ones who made it!" VS. "Why should a company have ANY right to tell me what to do? Once the work is published, it's out there for all to see!"
Frankly, the argument we should be making is "If Lesengle wants to publish its game in America, it should respect how Americans treat information." That might not help for the Ordeal Call stuff, but maybe for the stuff that's out in NA it will.
Well tbf, the guidelines so far are only for the JP version which isn't officially out for folks outside of JP.
We will have to see how the NA side handles stuffs
So I also kinda get the JP's sentiment of why these foreigners trespassing and not obeying our rules
@@kiyoslovermangxakieungao8955 The guidelines say Lostbelt 5 and 6 content are a no-go, but those are already out in NA.
@@thepersonwhocomentz well to be honest with how JP is handled, I would suspect that NA will be affected in some way.
FGO JP is getting hint rough, I pray NA stays safe 🙏
Alright here's my fucking question then.
Why the FUCK are JP players going over to NA UA-camR CHANNELS IN THE FIRST PLACE? We're 2 years behind them as is, and they've gotten a chance to see the content we have yet to see "technically". They have literally no reason to even be around the NA scene unless they're looking through older content which the JP fanbase/ youtube scene hasn't provided????
FGO is literally bigger in the JP scene than it will EVER be in NA and they have more people doing channels for it, HELL THEY HAVE PEKORA WHO'S A VTUBER DOING IT. SHE EVEN HAS AN OFFICIAL FIGURE OF HER IN MASH'S GALAHAD OUTFIT. What can the NA scene even PROVIDE to JP that hasn't already been given?
Witch Hunts aside, which you'd think that considering the lesson Salem is supposed to teach them about of "witch hunting is bad, don't do it" what legitimate motivations do they have to be watching english speaking channels who don't even provide active translations for them to understand what is even BEING SAID?
Its so hard for me to wrap my head around. Its one thing for the Western Audience to be watching the major V-Tubers from JP. But NA doesn't even have something like that since, and lets be absolutely honest. Lasengle/ Aniplex could lose NA and not give 2 shits about us aside from the revenue loss which JP can make up for 10 fold.
Can someone please explain it to me? This isn't me trying to be a monger of any kind. I'm literally just fucking confused. Last I checked the JP audience would rather forget about NA as an existence and let it rot to the wayside. ESPECIALLY from the Corpo side.
They already do the bare fucking minimum, attempting to throwing Kanou Yoshiki (2- San) under the bus (who by the way fought 2 years straight to let us get a 5 star ticket) with the Coin System, they barely put out strengthen quests for servants who desperately need them the most, don't do any meaningful changes, don't give us animation updates aside from the 2 Jeanne's and Kiara which we got recently. Kiara didn't EVEN NEED IT in comparison to other servants who are still shooting god damn caster balls to this day. Geronimo and Jekyll Hyde (as much as I hate to say it) are still objectively the worst servants in the game next to Phantom.
If I was a JP player, I'd be trying to start a god damn revolution against all of this bull shittery and forcing Sony/ Aniplex who have grown to complacent with their money printer to make major improvement. I legitimately think that FGO started going down hill since the 7th anniversary. At least when it comes to meaningful updates main story chapters aside.
But apparently, and please correct me if I'm wrong on this, as I could be very incorrect. Its ok to respect corporations more and considering that if you say anything negative about them, it can end up having you be stuck in a defamatory lawsuit which they'll more than likely win as it is culturally acceptable to consider "guilty until proven innocent" and that "whoever is suing you, they're more than likely in the right" to do so anyway. I've even heard of horror stories of people saying awful things about the companies on the internet over in JP and them getting sued for it as a result.
TLDR Fuck Sony, Fuck Aniplex, and FUCK THE SUITS who can't seem to be even remotely fair with these kind of guidelines. Like come on, not being able to show Bond CE's? They fucking suck for the most part. Lore and pretty art aside (which we can just google anyway), they all do the same garbage stuff which BY THE WAY WE WERE PROMISED A REWORK ON 2 YEARS AGO. WHERE'S THAT AT LASENGLE? CARE TO EXPLAIN?
I apologize, if any of this was offensive. But it just angers me so much that FGO, a game I hold in such high regards is being treated like this because its ok to not care about their audiences apparently. Do they not even realize how messed up a lot of this is for the basic viewers like me who get excited to see whats 2 years down the road? Its what keeps me motivated to keep playing FGO despite games like Nikke who have just as compelling story telling and if not better gameplay/ gatcha to keep sticking around.
The complacency and stagnation makes it feel like FGO is going to be pruned on its own like a Lostbelt at some point because of how its being treated. The only thing keeping it up is the high level of story telling and the IP name. Thats it. This game would have died off like other gatcha games at this point if it weren't for that. Its a game I've grown with since the first anniversary on the NA side. Its helped me through so much mental depression, and has legitimately saved my life as sappy as it sounds. The story of the lostbelts... the story of humanity, how despite all its short comings and flaws can still find ways to make up for it. And improve, to press forward.
I hate it so much. So. So. Much. I can't describe it very easily. I apologize for using your comment section as a venting/ ranting thing Plushie. Its not ok, and isn't something that should be seen. I just hate how this game is going into what I think is the shitter because it can't adapt to more modern standards and isn't capable of even trying to slowly role out updates that would be meaningful. I STILL FEAR I may lose my account because it isn't linked to my Google Account. For whatever awful reason it maybe.
This isn't fair, and the JP audience needs to do something for fuck sake. I just don't know what would be the catalyst for it. It would have to be such a monumental fuck up that even Sony wouldn't be able to ignore it lest they lose even more faith with even their most loyal of fans. Nasu would literally have to step in and take the wheel for things to even look hopeful. And that poor man's already overworked as is.
They literally tried to publicly throw Kanou Yoshiki under the bus during the 9th anniversary. I BET by the 10th they'll try to find an excuse to fire him for someone who's money grubbing and "perfect" in Sony's eyes. I don't even get why that, NOT EVEN THAT didn't get the JP crowd to move aside from the Coin Changes. They had the door open, they could have taken A GOD DAMN MILE.
Sometimes I get videos from JP from your everyday UA-camr to the official JP FGO channel . I don't think they are the kind that actively looked for creators like Plushie, xNaya or maybe Myst. I would guess that these videos just somewhat popped into their feed and are outraged by it.
@@ChaldeaWarmaster I'VE NEVER gotten recommended JP content from non JP youtubers. That is actually wack.
@@RoyalEmber Not even say...Hololive?
@ChaldeaWarmaster I never genuinely care for VTuber stuff tbh. It just isn't my thing, not knocking others for enjoying it.
But I genuinely don't get the appeal. I prefer older style of youtube commentary like they were from the early 2010's.
SSoHPKC is one of the only few youtubers I've ever went back to aside from Myst and Plushie that I ACTIVELY watch. He's from an old youtube group called "The Creatures".
NA is literally the privileged server. Always second to get Qol improvements, unique banners, best compensation if they screw up. And you are complaining about Pekora? She doesn't affect your gameplay at all! It's not like she skins Mash's face and wears it in game to fuck with you or anything, it's just a merch release.
And I almost forgot, NA did sponsor HoloEN to do some fgo content, you just missed it.
This helps me... Now i have an escuse to not buy the lucky bag summons
I'm NA exclusive, but... I'm also a really small and newer channel who compares FGO characters to their originals. If this starts to come after me? It could ruin my entire channel. I have been preparing to branch out a bit to try some new things, but... perhaps I should speed that up just in case these rules come to NA as well. I completely don't understand why they would create these overly restrictive and asinine rules. x_x
Entities that own IP can always do what they want with it, even if people using it have gotten comfortable and may be blindsided when that entity actually enforces its ownership.
That's all to say I agree that you should definitely diversify what you do. It's the same with an office job, one should be able to take on different types of work in case there main one is no longer needed.
I've enjoyed your videos too. Maybe Lasengle will implement a similar approach to being a sponsored creator for them similar to what Capcom did awhile back.
That may be an odd coincidence anyway, considering Yoshinori Oro came from Capcom and now works at Lasengle.
Indeed. While I love your content, these guidelines seem to be made to practically crucify anyone who dares to make content about their game due to their CEO who was infamous for ruining Street Fighter 5. Diversifying your content will be a good way to still generate revenue and widen the scope of what you create.
So this is kind of an "end of an era", with how some of the Japanese are accepting and endorsing this guideline; as well as barely being able to see stuff in FGO?
Because it truly feels like it
Why shouldn't they endorse it? People are right to be mad at xNaya spoilering everyone with thumbnails. The problem are content creators like him who made Sony made a move, not Sony for listening to user base.
@@Dorrovian ... because the content is not aimed at them? It's like I went to X to mass report Japanese users for showing screenshots of OC3 because they're also spoiling everyone. Thing is, their stuff wouldn't normally show up on my feed if I didn't look directly for them. UA-cam is something similar but not quite.
The UA-cam algorithm is bad enough that English content ends up in their feed. However, if they really don't want to be spoiled, they can easily unsubscribe to their JP FGO tubers and watch something else entirely so the algorithm will think you no longer want to watch it. It's rather simple and it baffles me in nearly a decade old game... they seem to lack the mental capacity to do that if they're so desperate, yet never said a peep years ago in such way and only do so now because of some guidelines.
If they wanna go out of their way to ruin it to everyone, well, guess they can keep the xenophobia as well too.
@@Dorrovian because those guidelines are way to restrictive, it would be understantable if it was like " you can only upload new content 2 weeks after the release" but this one limits to something released in 2019 and it blocks events,interludes and boss fights without an end date
It would make sense if fgo was a paid game
@@Dorrovian the problem is players being unable to ignore spoilers
im already like 5 years into FGO or more, and i still have never been spoiled on story in FGO, because i do something as simple as ignoring anything i dont wanna see, including thumbnails, and that includes xnaya's, i just see some weird mob on them and im "im not clicking that nor reading that title even", and continue with my life
@@Hiken_Bakuzan Thumbnails from xNaya can spoil you just by visuals.
As a member of a nore niche side of the community, being the Roleplay and Fanfic Community, having story translations restricted actually hits hard and prevents us from keeping up to date on the lore to know whats happening, to know what can happen, whats been re-explained or retconned for all our own stories and characters and balancing, etc. etc.
Especially since not all of us can just read japanese nor do us Type-Moon fans even have wikis and websites that stay up to date, dont shove in headcanon, and just leave portions describing what a character has done in specific stories despite full official or reliable fan translation existing.
I'm worried because the JP FGOtubers I'm following are my sources of the story (even if I don't understand what they're saying) and demos of new characters.
Demos of new characters are fine, its mostly story
Because they take their time with the story, they don't just speedrun it for content creation like most non-JP streamers do.
....watching translation of interlude and main story is literally the main reason why i still playing this game....wtf???
Well, you can blame the JP players raising a stink about it. The hilariously ironic part is they're also guilty of not playing the game but want the content without actually interacting with it, hence this guideline.
@@reishiki8682 and not caring about this and still spoiling the content. I just wanted to check some FGO fanart in X by inputting FGO in the search bar and I got spoiled there instead of UA-cam or Reddit because of their screenshots on OC3. And I can't even report them for that.
How on earth is that fair?
@@abrahammesrajecorrea2349 And that's why the internet is both a convenience and a hindrance at the same time. Not helped by how majority of "self-proclaimed players/fans" will act all high and mighty about jt.
Why blame people spoilered by thumbnails and titles of videos instead of CC who did these spoilers?
They really want the community to die with the game after the Ordeal Call.....
My favourite part is that early this year lasengle themselves put spoilers for lostbelt 5,7 and ordeal call prologue in the story of the fate samurai remnant Collab that is fuyuki lock
Sony should be thrown in a concept incenerator... wait wrong fandom. Sony should be pruned before it becomes a cause for a singularity.
Project Moon alluded to!
@@Rais-Codex THE FAULT LIES WITH YOU, SONY ANIPLEX!!!
This is depressing. It was UA-camrs and their spoilers that convinced me to reinstall the game lmao
Lasangle keeps farming Ls. Everything has gone downhill since the reestructuration.
No one should respect this.
This is while Mihoyo has a content creator prerelease server to shill their new things, while FGO wouldnt piss on most of their fans if they were on fire.
I mean, Lack of QOL and incredibly shitty gacha + servant coins + this, it is not surprising to me at all that they are behind the times, those gacha mechanics and rates only worked over 4 years ago because the genre was just starting, and it was already outdated by then, and then again FGO is outdated not just in that but in many other areas as well.
@@xLuis89xHaving to update to "so-proclaimed modern standards" means they're desperate for money... when they're not. Because at the end of the day FGO is just a collect your favorite type of game. You go in, you spend in-game currency and gamble with the rates, simple and straightforward. Nothing else to entice you to spend beyond the characters and/or their gameplay, no passes, paywalls or paid cosmetics. Meanwhile other games will plaster you with so many ads that usually entails "buy X to improve your gameplay experience", which is more blatantly scummy because FGO's rates "are bad" but they're not sugarcoating it in the first place. Hell, it's one of the very few games that bother making lower rarity characters useful or have a niche that lets them play their intended style, most gachas have units that age so quickly that their relevancy usually only lasts two to three weeks of their debut before they're powercrept and rendered irrelevant.
@@xLuis89x
You missed the point with Gacha games and mechanics, because the only "modern" mechanic was to have a separate server. Pity does exist, gacha rates are still hell, even Azur Lane despite being beyond the cream of the crop still does not have the good gacha rates for your desired Shipgirl. Hell AL's market changed from WWII geeks to "L2D cashcows" and that worked wonders for them. Its more of the fact that they do not understand what their market focus should be: is it the skins, the new characters they can produce, the plot?, or find something pointless to spend on? Because they are trying to tap on a market that another gacha game already perfected or pioneered and do not understand how they did it. Like E7's equipment and QOL improvements that was a part of the puzzle of why they succeeded and FGO still fumbled there.
BA also has another benefit of using a mechanic similar to Servant coins to unlock specific Character only upgrades but BA made it a lot more accessible for F2P grindable characters like Yuuka and Hoshino and FGO's servant coin doesn't even fully understand that in the slightest.
yeah lasagna sure, just let all TA runs ded from not being able to use few of hundreds useless free CEs, that's actually better at supporting a team in a single player team oriented game than the 5* gacha CEs you're supposed to pay for
sry guys, Arash and F2P TAs are deadge now
This type of behavior is insane and very common sadly from music corporation and corporations in general base in JP, the fact that Sony owns Lasangle is even more scary since they are know to go scorch earth when they use the copyright system. Sometimes they will just issue a warning but they could very well use the strikes even multiple at the same time, also I don't trust the way they say it will not apply to older videos, if they changed their minds once they can change it many times in the future.
FGO has a strict restriction about story spoiling. However, Sony Music Entertainment or LSG didn't check your videos manually. If they didn't see your videos, they didn't do a copyright strike (not a copyright claim, remember this). Actually, they saw and they knew your videos but they didn't care. It is the fact that someone reported your videos to Sony Music. JP streamers can not make videos story after Lostbelt 4. It is not fair, right? So, just maybe, they reported
You are indeed correct, There were claims here n there back in the day like with Kita's stream ages ago but they never actually struck a channel before it's after JP players and JP content creators started to report to Aniplex and Sony they had to react since as sad as it is JP players are the most profitable.
@@RedLotus02 Jp are the most stupid idiots ever, well I guess that's why they spend so much on gacha games all the time.
I don't understand why bond CEs are being censored....
JP gacha dev: "Let's region lock our games! All of UA-camrs who make videos about our games, copystrike 'em all! Also keep our game as low budget as possible, and as cash-grab as possible!"
Also JP gacha dev: "Why do Chinese and Korean gacha games more successful?"
This has been consistently the theme with JP games company. Like just look at Blue Protocol, the fabled MMORPG that in all honestly looked really good. It was hyped to near death and now it's on its way to EoS. And one of the big reasons why is because it's region locked.
Meanwhile Genshin and Wuthering are thriving because they don't put stupid region lock on their games.
@@ahmadyulinu region locked and censored at that, fk that crap
@@ahmadyulinuBecause making a global release is in of itself a huge risk, as it's far costlier than a region-specific one. It could even render a company go in the red (Disgaea RPG nearly got NIS to declare bankruptcy because of how bad the launch was and how there's barely any income on its global version, which forced its shutdown while the JP one is still ongoing).
They are acting as if they have always took care of their game 😂
they are clearly only doing it to appease the JP side and their shitty complaints , nothing else
I really hope the situation can get better or at least turn back to where we were before this rule was even made, playing JP alone and not seeing any videos made about everything new and exciting to see, is just not right for me. And yeah, I can protect myself from spoilers, and even if I get spoiled something in FGO, I don't think I would be so upset about it, and definitely not to the point that I have to make UA-camrs who enjoy the game stop showing their enjoyment
I like FGo because of Fate, but I've been playing for this long in both NA and JP definitely was because of you guys
Yeah I don't want this to go through at all... I really hope they understand this feeling to do something to change this
It's becoming a hot topic of how horrible the decision made by FGO devs.
Stresses it's global.
A lot of money is being pull back.
Congratz Lasagna, you are digging your own grave.
It's Sony making the bullshit decisions not the devs
This is a business cutting off their nose to spite their face because they have no creative talent left.
It's clear the leadership has no concept of the massive value they are accruing from free advertising being produced by content creators.
These stupid Japanese corporates i swear. On the plus side, I don't need to get worried about getting accidentally spoiled on the NA side.
It's 2024 and NA still has a fricking 2 year gap with JP, just who in Sony thought that timegating 2 years of content as a good business decision 😂😂😂
I'm not sure the 2 year gap was a Sony decision. It's just what happened. If staying 2 years behind was a Sony choice...then it's the rare Sony choice I'm fine with. Catching up would have been an absolute nightmare.
it's more thanks to the stupid JP players though, Lasagna is only doing what the jp players demanded that's all.
How is NA supposed to catch up to JP? Speed up events? Skip them entirely?
my god this rules is so awfully stupid. i was like, fine with bond ce and ost's but not allowing lb5 onwards? any limited event which not required clear fuyuki (high-end cont)? and even olga marie quest?? might be waste but your action to remove some vids are correct for now though.
for every global fgo youtubers out there, pls do take care of yourself. i hope you guys stay strong through this new guidelines, the community always got your back
They keep pressuring players to finish story, but stuck and/or struggling on boss fights. How the fvckin hell did they think we got through it when most of us are busy irl?!
Those incoming super difficult Olga-babe nodes, future advancement quests and event CQ's, pod quests.. We need their videos to give us some ideas to come up with our own based on our roster servants.
TO HELL WITH THESE GUIDELINES!!
If its down to the JP players complaining then I will be pissed. they got pissy when NA had the chaldea breakroom stuff and they didn't, meaning DW (at the time) had to start making that too. Then because the JP players have bitched so much the devs have started making NA exclusive stuff, like banners and such. The JP players are the most petulant players I have seen, throwing tantrums constantly because they don't get their own ways.
I swear JP players would get pissy if NA got an exclusive CE
@@therojoking7039 I actually think it’s the complete opposite: they aren’t complaining enough. The servant coins drama? The game gave us a couple of SQ and they finally shut up. The JP player base just eats whatever slop they’re given, and it’s sad to see since they’re the only ones who are capable of changing their game for the better.
@@elontusk9167 that's the thing, the collectvie community have been so indoctrinated into consuming and enjoing this and that to the point they feel lile they belong to a cult
@@elontusk9167 Simple are real. They are the most submissive gamers out there. I'd rather take the insane Genshin community that complains over anything, at least there, changes are made.
@@alexandrunache9078Changes that ultimately don't matter in the bottom line anyway as what they deliver is still the same stuff, hence them being labeled "professional victims". Whereas in this case it's mainly story... which majority are guilty of skipping getting through the actual gameplay part of it and just want to get to the story segments without effort. Hence certain players getting annoyed because they're taking their time and they get spoiled because of a search suggestion.
This company feels like a parody of itself at this point
We might be digging on our grave but at least we'll take you with us lol - Aniplex.
I think it would be better to post both the Min turn and the F2P run of the Olga Marie quests in one video and just timestamp it, just in case of any mishaps, I think that could be a "Safer" way to break the rules
Looking at the loosening, i know we are getting recollections for Atlantis/Olympus soon-ish
I’m worried for the wikis to be honest. It’s only social media for now but the wikis are easy to access
We FGOtubers can *at least* make videos on our Gacha Rolls, Servant Skills & Animations, and Event Boss Fights.
At least that last one for events that require Fuyuki Completion.
You're in luck, summer 8 spoils the entire LB6 cast and it's Fuyuki locked so I guess their laziness in making the guidelines doesn't stop fgotubers from still spoiling story post LB5.
@@alexandrunache9078 That and the True Names of a few Epic of Remnant Servants getting Summer Versions.
@@THEBULLETPROOFKINGDOM not even that, they folded faster than you can imagine considering in Summer 2 Schez had her True Name. So I really don’t want to hear people complaining about spoilers when they have shown in the past to not care. Either that or they are incompetent, or both.
Fuck, so they're pulling an Atlus on us
Fellas, I suggest you’ll try out reverse 1999
Japan’s draconian Fair Use rules strike again. Obviously check with lawyers before doing anything, but if you’re in the US Sony can’t enforce these rules without suing you, which they won’t do cause it risks setting a precedent they don’t want on their hands. Granted, that means possibly giving Sony your dox in a DMCA counter-claim, but you can keep your videos up if you’re willing to do that. European countries and Canada should have similar rules, check your local laws to be sure.
Now whether you actually WANT your play chicken with your channel like that? Different story entirely. Good luck, gang!
the problem is UA-cam, you get 3 copywright strikes your channel is gone. it is the 3 strike system. and offcourse you can appeal. but that takes a long time.
Sony doesn't even go to court, cause you have to fight google first. that is why it is such a hassle. and bad actors and companies exploit that system a lot.
You had every right to be angry/worried originally. This was 100% going to happen. It always happens with JP companies and creator guidelines.
They just got out of a controversy (the shit anniversary), and now they do this? Don't they think? Lasgna/Sony have no brains and want the game to die?
So this will heavily affect any playthroughs of the game. That's a bummer since I mostly consume the story via YT.
Lol, this is clearly decision of crusty old upper management, they still think fan made stuff should not make any money from their IP, and doujins are copyight infringement.
But they forgot these kind of things are pretty much free advertising.
Feels like another shot in the foot by them… So much of the enjoyment of the game is in seeing what other people do… min turn… etc… People need to make noise about this, maybe they will yield again. Lasengle is getting unreasonable.
It also says about SOUND PLAYER? What does it mean? So we can't use the soundtrack and servant dialogue too? What about NP animation?
This is nightmare as I do FGO unboxing figures and I use those as resources to decorate my videos.
This is one of the stupidest things FGO/aniplex/lasengle have ever done.
This is going to ruin their own reach in overseas markets. Because youtubers like Plushie are how FGO gets traction. It’s such bullshit.
Temporary Spoiler Locks on just the latest Story Parts aside, This is one of the weirdest spoiler locks and ToS Decisions I've seen in a LONG while and it's only hurting the game in the long run.
Probably best to expand your content to other things, like other games, just in case Sony goes full on Dumbnium on strikes.
At the very least you can still keep things running if things go sideways on the FGO content.
Honestly they're just shooting their own foot at this point, shooting down your own exposure on platforms such as this is a surefire way to drain the interest of this game.
this!
100% , the only reason I came back to the game was because I saw some FGO cc's on my feed talking about stuff.
I mean the simple solution for this is........ bring JP and NA to the same time frame and not have a 2 year gap
“Alr fellas here is 12 sq if you let this slide 😉”
the community: ''THANK YOU SO MUCH , YOU ARE SO GENEROUS!''
And you got 4 mapo tofu without any servants in the process 🥴
Small indie Company Problem
Remember when everyone thought FGO couldn't get any lower after the 9th anniversary fiasco?
At this point I just want the story to end already and close the game for good
Are you and the other FGO content creators are going to gather and petition to Lansgle and/or Aniplex?
Its not gonna work, especially with a lot of big JP fgotubers openly supporting it.
Games like this won't work because majority of their playerbase are Japanese. They'd just be talking to a wall.
@@PlushieMistress Are JP fgotubers really in support of 4 year old content and latest Ordeal Call content?
*and not
@@alexng7298 I don't know the exact stances, so take this with a grain of salt, but I remember I read a comment somewhere saying how JP players would probably willingly report content because of Japanese etiquette and norms. Don't remember the exact word, but they're also probably a lot more tolerant with whatever happens, even if it is bad
These rules are the most ridiculous and short sighted restrictions I’ve ever seen a company put on their game. Pointless and frankly stupid.
So how that JP bois think we can beat the new upcoming bosses? try and retry every time a "unexpected" action from the boss take place, like remove buffs, got solemn pierce, instakill thing, etc.?
Is thanks to the videos i can safely prepare and beat the boss, even with the blue stones that works like command spells, is so anoying going to try and retry the boss only coz JP bois don´t want spoilers.
If that's what you're worried about, plenty of communities where you can ask for advice.
@@Luca-yb4sh Said communities use the same source, the wiki. The core issue is that the game itself doesn't tell you ...well, the game. You don't know how much your skill leveled up unless you check the wiki, you don't know the chance of IP to proc, you don't even know what a new servant does unless you or someone else pulls them. The wiki and the guides people make are a necessity, they are the core of experiencing the game because the game itself doesn't do it and you wouldn't want to be more miserable than you already are.
@@alexandrunache9078My guy, this isn't a rocket science test, everything is RNG. What majority players check online are the boss mechanics, its gimmicks and suggestions on how to tackle them. That you're obsessed with numbers probability means you're one of those players that want to min-turn it with unga bunga huehue gigamaxes so you don't get hassled by its gimmicks.
@@reishiki8682 I'm sorry, but knowing where my time and effort goes is not an obsession with numbers. Knowing that 1 skill that charges np gives 50 unlike another that gives 30 is a big deal. Not because of your horrible assumption (which I don't understand the aggressiveness behind it) about me, but because like you said people care about boss mechanics and easier ways to defeat them.
Wouldn't that knowledge, that you farmed for a specific character to lv 10 their skill and that choice helps you deal with a boss better than if you chose another skill, be exactly why people look for these numbers? We are not asking for much, just standard practice... because the alternative is to tab out and search the wiki every single time you need to know if that 72 proof of hero material is actually going to help that skill or not. Redundant stuff shouldn't be in a multibillion dollar game and you shouldn't defend them like this.
So my guy, don't take it personally but, have some standards. This says more about what you allow others to do to you than it says about me.
@@reishiki8682 are you this clueless? knowing how much of a battery do you get from one skill or how much crit stars you get from a skill is absolutely viable, don't even try to think otherwise, that type of data is very useful, PERIOD.
I guess it’s time to switch to Limbus Company!!! /s
do it, but you need to adapt from changing to a diverse cast of character designs to business suit city.
I tell ya fgo gameplay is boring
The only thing that is interesting is the servant animation n their story
Other than that, i doubt it could garner many players interest
You should switch it by now
I mean, gacha game keep evolving during these years
If all else fails, you can always be a Shrek Superslam UA-camr
In all seriousness, sucks this is happening, but I'll stay tuned for anything you pump out
Idk man, maybe this policy is what finally breaks my UA-cam addiction
As if they already do enough advertising for their own game
Censoring like this only makes the playerbase hate the company more...
it will most likely will be short lived, seein as how everything happens in FGO and they still praise it to heaven and beyond, like the ''pity'' system''
It's like they are begging to loose players. Time to rise up and start complaining so they remove these fucked up restrictions
@@neilisawesome2333 the JP playerbase doesn't give a shit if the global players leave, it doesn't affect them at all, that's why they are pushing this, lmfao
This is no content restriction, this is simply dictatorship, too many stupid rules, looks like Lasengle is saying "hey guys we don't need more money than Japanese players spending with us already, so we restricted you so you can invest your time and money playing other gachas instead, you are welcome", looks like the extra append skills from the 9th anni were kind of hint about Lasengle getting even greedier and ridiculous than ever
it's kind of funny how only when the append patch happened people were really concerned about the state of the game... it's long overdue by like 4 years, lmfao
They're limiting content creators. Stop framing it like they're banning non-JP players
the funniest part of this is the bond CE restriction. I can understand why someone would want to be surprised but at the same time, you could also get spoiled by literally playing the game and seeing someone with the bond CE equipped in your supports. And how would you even enforce that? What, you need to blur your CEs every time you go to the CE screen?
My take? Sony being a jerk
don't think it has anything to do with sony this time though.
Lasengle being few decades behind in marketing their game just keeps on making stupid decision,instead of endorsing content creators,encouraging them to promote their game,they just shafted them,for a game which relies on word of mouth it just doesnt make sense,even with all its flaws i still really love FGO and the direction which Lasengle is going in scares me for the games future
Can't stream story cuz spoilers, can stream events with said main story spoilers. Are they playing 5D chess or ... nah they just don't care about the people free promoting their game.
Event with requirements of First singularity not all event. Event that needs clearance pass that is not allowed (unless it's rerun)
@@Skolladrum I think you missed the point. Fgo has had events in the past that only required the prologue to do, yet contained characters from LB5 onward with no care to their true identities.
By their rules, you can make content on summer 2023 since it’s not LB6 locked, yet spoil everything pertaining to the characters. What’s the point? Either make all events locked up till the LB they are from or don’t have dumb guidelines
heavens, how is a giant glowing blob a ordeal call spoiler?
As expected from KuSony. 🙄
Hey plushie, I checked out the guidelines, and there's a section on "where to post and stream" with a link to more details. When you click it, it lists what i think are platforms where content is allowed, and UA-cam is on there too. you might want to check because im also confused by this
I'm sorry but this is ironic because fgo appmedia has everything you're showcasing on video but in text and photos, on his channel and website. Why is that not considered spoilers? Why can they talk about fights, strategies and all but foreigners cannot? Super weird hiperfixation on certain creators.
Because appmedia is not going to be put into your YT feed randomly and spoil you story with thumbnail. xNaya does, he did to me personally until blocked him.
This is false. Appmedia is also not exception. He talked about that in the recent video in Japanese.
@@Dorrovian then that's skill issue on your own and it took you long enough to solve the problem. You don't see me whinning and wanting to mass report Japanese people for spoiling OC3 bits to me in X when all I wanted was just to see FGO fanart by inputting FGO tag in the searcher.
You and the others complaining take accountability and stop ruining the fun of others and defending this.
@@abrahammesrajecorrea2349 Well, I think CC who did spoil things and lead to that ban should take accountability, not their victims.
@@Dorrovian ok, so can you please tell me HOW I can report Japapese users on X who spoiled OC3 bits to me and I bet others when all I wanted was to see fanarts?
Genuine question because there's no choice to report someone for "spoiling content" on X and I'm a "victim" as you claim. I want my justice too. Tell me how can I get it, please
From what Radiant-Hope-469 wrote on Reddit, the limit is going to expand monthly and "By December 2024, the banned quests are Interludes, Ordeal Call Main Quests and Olga Marie Quests. And not Fuyuki-locked events."
Yeah i covered that in the video
@@PlushieMistress A lot of people missed that.
all of this happening a week after i downloaded FGO NA(i had already been spoiled on everything up to LB6, i only joined for the experience).. seems like i hopped on the train at the best(worst) possible time LMAO
This is just insane, the proper way would be that you are not allowed to show anything of the current event or chapter until 48 to 72 hours have passed.
As for the weird registration of old chapters I think is more for NA, since right now we are doing the road to seven campaign, after all is no secret and even Albert had been very vocal that they hate that na has that 2 years of insight in for future content.
Hopefully they don't add new things in the future.