FGO's New Content Guidelines for Streaming and Videos will Ruin Creators

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 224

  • @thekirtfox
    @thekirtfox Місяць тому +194

    Not just creators, but it's going to slow down uptake and interest in their game. It's content creators that do the work keeping people interested in the game. This doesn't help anyone in anyway. and will just slowly strangle the life out of their game.
    Also, I'm a global player, and I avoid as much JP spoiler as I can and have been pretty much fine with it. Only issue I have is spoilers in thumbnails and titles. If it's JP content, excluding anniversary stuff I don't watch the vid.
    The vids keep my interest up through all the years I've played and also help with some fights where I don't have time to sit and try and figure the mechanics out cause I have a job and other obligations.

    • @dimitris6258
      @dimitris6258 Місяць тому +4

      No it is not. No one gives a f for content creators

    • @progmrz5512
      @progmrz5512 Місяць тому +8

      ⁠​⁠@@dimitris6258
      No one or is it just only you? Lol
      Whether you argree or not, a gacha game which is categorized a live service game needs Content Creators to attract and keep interest on the players. Hell, this is the reason why Genshin became this huge was thanks to Content Creators literally making content about the game and spreading it. And Hoyo capitalized on that making a creator program just for that.
      Essentially Content Creators are literally a free advertisement on the game.
      Also, I like how you are saying you don’t give a f on Content Creators yet you have 100+ comments on Kitasean. I thought you don’t give an f? Then why do you have 100+ comments on Kitasean? Hypocrite much?

    • @alexandrunache9078
      @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому +3

      @@dimitris6258 Without content creators this game would have died even faster. And I don’t mean just UA-camrs; the wiki, discords where people share gameplay and pulls, all of these have content created by the community for the community. Without those what do you have? A single player game with no one to share your passion for?
      That’s the worst nightmare for an intellectual property and dismissing the value content creators bring is super hypocritical. I’m sure you’d lose your interest in many other games way faster if you found no one that shares that interest as well.
      PS: why do you think Undertale, a small indie game released 10 years ago, remained in the back of everyone’s head for years after its hype was over? I’m sure you know who was responsible. The content creators you don’t give a f about

  • @SoraJieSoN
    @SoraJieSoN Місяць тому +67

    fgo killing itself speedrun any%

  • @MetalFreezer3000
    @MetalFreezer3000 Місяць тому +117

    Aniplex decided to pull an Atlus

    • @ZagiNoa
      @ZagiNoa Місяць тому +25

      I mean, they are part of Sony so...

    • @MetalFreezer3000
      @MetalFreezer3000 Місяць тому +17

      @@ZagiNoa if you mean Aniplex, pretty much, yeah

    • @hafirenggayuda
      @hafirenggayuda Місяць тому +6

      Man, Sony grudge about Concord's failure affecting every other games now

  • @someoneelse4939
    @someoneelse4939 Місяць тому +103

    Imagine having content creators that mantain the hype for your game and they do it at no cost to you.
    And you go:"Nah, we don't want that".
    All of this to accomodate a couple of butthurt and very loud JP players that can't stay away from social media 3 hours to avoid spoilers.

    • @silverjuly9339
      @silverjuly9339 Місяць тому +1

      Sounds like Nintendo level of pettiness

  • @Sombody123
    @Sombody123 Місяць тому +32

    Just when I was thinking that the FGO YT content creators were steadily having a slow resurgence. Nope. Curb-stomped.

  • @vlionheart
    @vlionheart Місяць тому +30

    This is idiotic on so many levels. For older stuff like LB5 or LB6 this is the same as complaining that your history teacher is spoiling what happened to the roman empire. For newer stuff it's idiotic because guides showing good farming strategies for events and boss fight mechanics is basically a necessity for many people.
    Doing this after the whole append 4 and 5 debacle when their reputation is damaged is such a stupid move I can't even describe how dumb it is and this can seriously damage the game.

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +2

      From what Radiant-Hope-469 wrote on Reddit, the limit is going to expand monthly and "By December 2024, the banned quests are Interludes, Ordeal Call Main Quests and Olga Marie Quests. And not Fuyuki-locked events."

  • @syl_ster230
    @syl_ster230 Місяць тому +36

    I can slightly understand from a spoiler standpoint because it's basically impossible to avoid spoilers, but that is THEIR fault for keeping the 2 versions 2 whole years appart and now the content creators are paying for that huge flaw? Absolute clown behaviour

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +2

      Global content creators are spoiling JP players too.

    • @syl_ster230
      @syl_ster230 Місяць тому +23

      @@Dorrovian that is more those JP players not reaching said content in time, NA simply does not have the content.

    • @paradoxwraith5275
      @paradoxwraith5275 Місяць тому +7

      ​@@Dorrovianall they gotta do it not look at the content but that's hard I guess

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@syl_ster230 And? The JP players also provide the bulk of the game's income. Let them go through the content without spoilers for at least a month.

    • @cuongquan1633
      @cuongquan1633 Місяць тому +14

      ​@@cameraredeye3115this is the internet spoiler can be avoided. Just search shit that won't spoil the story for you. Gate keeping 5 years old content ( lb6) is stupid.

  • @NexusVFD
    @NexusVFD Місяць тому +40

    Atlus at least does it from the jump we are 7-9 years in, its a lil too late to be pulling these kinds of stunts unless they want to kill the game off which may just be what theyre after

    • @Daustarticmon
      @Daustarticmon Місяць тому +7

      @@NexusVFD it wouldn't surprise me, after all the main story will be ending next year and, if they don't have anything planned to keep the hype, the game may last 2 more years which will be enough for na to catch up so that way they can kill both servers at the same time.

    • @animeturnMMD
      @animeturnMMD Місяць тому

      The situation is that FGO in japan is BIG, Genshin levels of BIG, it is played for a lot of people and it is basically them who keep the game funded, this is why the DEVS obey them, but still....

  • @TheStuffEnjoyer
    @TheStuffEnjoyer Місяць тому +64

    How to kill your game 101...

  • @ShiraFuyu2022
    @ShiraFuyu2022 Місяць тому +25

    Sony really tried to bring the game down like they did with Spidermanless Movies

  • @stephorozco8911
    @stephorozco8911 Місяць тому +13

    If they were concerned about NA being spoiled, maybe, just maybe.. they should've made the games as close to each other as possible. Instead of making NA waiting 2 FRICKING YEARS APART.

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +1

      Servers being apart doesn't have any effect on the fact that content creators spoil content for JP players.

    • @alexandrunache9078
      @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому +3

      @@DorrovianIt 100% does. Look at any other gacha and you will see how well hidden spoilers and future patches are from the community by the community. Most of them are at worst months apart, yet spoilers don’t appear from their games biggest CC.
      In Fgo not only do you have to deal with a lack of content due to no endgame or story (since it takes months to years for main story chapters to come), but you’re also dealing with a game that is so hard to manage that unless you have 2 years of content in advance you will not be prepared to pull who you want. That’s why the wiki is literally an extension to the game.
      PS: The whole JP players being spoiled by NA is stupid since JP players also made content on OC3 and anything in between to LB5. This is obviously elitism and it’s not hard to tell. JP players complained hard when we got something they didn’t a while back, even though they get “QoL” 2 years earlier (another massive problem with the servers being apart “ They just like to play favorites when it suits them

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +1

      @@alexandrunache9078 I have no idea what you are about, all gachas I have played which had time gap between servers had easily available informations about future content. That includes Touhou LW, HI3rd, Arknights, Revue Starlight, Princess Connect and many, many more.
      It's just these games are not that big on story as FGO is.

    • @alexandrunache9078
      @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому

      @@Dorrovian Can you elaborate? Because there is a difference between information being easily accessible and the community and content creators spoiling it. In HSR for example, not only is Information accessible for the next patch due to leaks, but the CCs also have access to it in a program offered by the company. Even so there are measures in place so these things don't go out, yet that wouldn't matter if the community was actually hellbent on making content even faster.
      Meaning, and to add to my previous comment, it's not only the servers apart that are at fault for CCs making content of the game, but also the conditions FGO has (or better said hasn't) provided for their community.
      Also saying other games are not big on story like FGO is purely subjective. FGO had some highs yes, but it also has some really big lows and this inconsistency is not that apparent to other industry standard gachas which actually are consistent. I'm not even going to talk about the difference in story presentation and the time it takes till they release new chapters as that is night and day.

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +1

      @@alexandrunache9078 I think we are talking little around each other, yes, other games I played didn't have content creators as obnoxious with spoilering people with thumbnails and titles as FGO does.
      But that's on person, not on server gap.
      As per story, I didn't mean FGO is the best one (even I think that, with HI3rd, HSR and Another Eden as next best), but that for FGO story is much more important part of overall package than for other games.

  • @KawaiiFive0h
    @KawaiiFive0h Місяць тому +4

    Whelp like you mentioned to me on social medias I guess looking at characters is safe for now but all of these guidelines are just absolutely INSANE to me.
    Guess they just don’t want us streaming their game. I think most other FGO creators will just go, “Fine, there are other games.” And that will be that.

  • @alexandrunache9078
    @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому +6

    For those that don’t know, summer 8 spoils LB6 yet requires only Fuyuki to experience.
    By their own rules it’s ok to spoil major characters and bosses from LB6 but … not spoil major bosses and stuff from LB6.
    Yeah that tracks.

  • @thanglongnguyenvu3815
    @thanglongnguyenvu3815 Місяць тому +8

    I guess they could not wrap their heads around what free advertisement they’ve had until now.

  • @eolyneherlentzlefay7945
    @eolyneherlentzlefay7945 Місяць тому +37

    All I know is if FGO ever gets another Arthurian Legend chapter no way no how they're gonna stop me from yapping about it and posting a vid about it

    • @kaitoyuki
      @kaitoyuki Місяць тому +11

      Ready your rant essay.
      I mean. The game icon is Artoria. One of the main characters is Galahad Mashu.
      We haven't seen King Arthur(male)'s end of journey yet. Playable Agravain? Palamedes? Galahad Alter? I'm almost sure there's gonna be one more arthurian legend chapter. If not, there should be a new chapter where some arthurian legend characters appear.

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому +1

      Enjoy the copyright strike then.

  • @Ant-so4br
    @Ant-so4br Місяць тому +38

    i dont care, ill upload the spoilers if nobody does

  • @swishs6446
    @swishs6446 Місяць тому +61

    What was the point of these guidelines generally? In what way is something like showing a craft essence bond breaking their bank somehow?

    • @kitasean
      @kitasean  Місяць тому +12

      It's basically to prevent spoilers

    • @X99-h6r
      @X99-h6r Місяць тому +37

      @@kitasean they can add a feature to the game to obscure them.. they want global dead.

    • @zeroone2731
      @zeroone2731 Місяць тому +33

      @@kitasean they could honestly do this but in a more reasonable way like a month or 2 weeks of non posting recent story chapters but 2 years yeah they are killing their own game

  • @ZerebusPrime
    @ZerebusPrime Місяць тому +21

    If not for content streamers I literally would have never picked up this game. This is typical SONY nonsense from as long as videogames have been around.

    • @E-Luckmaster
      @E-Luckmaster Місяць тому +1

      I thought Concord's fumble was enough for Sony to learn from their mistake. But it seem i underestimated them

  • @FigureUnboxing
    @FigureUnboxing Місяць тому +2

    This is a nightmare even for me as a figure UNBOXER!!! As I use their soundtrack and some animation to decorate my videos. So they are not allowed now? All my videos revolve on these. Those makes my channel unique! Gosh, this is terrible!!!!

  • @thepureheartofdark
    @thepureheartofdark Місяць тому +6

    As I commented in similar videos. If they start to hit informational content and sites. I'm out.

  • @Shinekage
    @Shinekage Місяць тому +5

    Its a massive overkill. Limiting the movies and such is one thing, but you will just curbstomp interest like this.

  • @vastolorde9228
    @vastolorde9228 Місяць тому +21

    Watch this start to affect their stocks in the game they are going to hit the uno reverse button so hard they're going to pretend this never happened and sweep it under the rug. I know this is wishful thinking, but it's better to think positive for now and to wait and see how this will play out for now.

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому +1

      No, if anything JP welcomes the new changes. It's only the entitled American content creators that are upset.

    • @alexandrunache9078
      @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому +7

      @@cameraredeye3115Silence bot !

    • @thedragonoftheuchiha
      @thedragonoftheuchiha Місяць тому +1

      @@cameraredeye3115 Respectfully, not all of JP welcome these changes. Also, do you have a problem with those guidelines? Cuz I distinctly remember you commenting under a OC3 story chapter.

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому

      @@alexandrunache9078 Nope. Real person here.

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому

      @@thedragonoftheuchiha I'm one of few who doesn't.

  • @KinDGrove
    @KinDGrove Місяць тому +12

    It’s hard enough getting people to be interested in FGO since it’s daunting as a gacha game, now they are doing everything in their power to kill interest in the game. It’s super out of touch with the community.

  • @Wheres_my_Dragonator
    @Wheres_my_Dragonator Місяць тому +9

    Not really surprising considering what japanese fans had to say about nintendo suing pocketpair. Japanese love their original ip and will support them no matter how detrimental it is to everything else, even to themselves.

  • @Zeke1460
    @Zeke1460 Місяць тому +6

    “How to ruin public interest in your own game in 1 easy step!”
    I swear this is the dumbest thing they’ve ever done. And they’ve done a LOT of really stupid shit. Like the new appends without initially giving a way to get more. And this is somehow even stupider than that for their own game.

  • @Insanity_101
    @Insanity_101 Місяць тому +16

    The thing that I'm wondering about is if this move by Lasengle was considered after reading all of the results from surveys? I'm not sure on how things look in the JP side and I can only speak for myself, but whenever I'm asked on where I hear news or watch FGO related content I always answer non-official UA-cam channels. I wonder how this will affect content creators making things for the NA side of FGO? As someone who used youtube to help in more difficult CQ's cause I'm too lazy to read lots of texts, I'm VERY worried that I'm going to have a hard time in the future.

  • @Sidestreetdog
    @Sidestreetdog Місяць тому +8

    Seriously, if it just latest content and ask to not spoil for weeks or month I would understand
    But LB5? That already a year for EN and years for JP
    Streamers couldn't really do any content like that, most of them even do live on day 1

  • @danysiegh9746
    @danysiegh9746 Місяць тому +3

    The Main problem is that Story recaps help new players progress faster without feeling like they are going to miss context for new events, I could see them try to make it one or two months ban, but the fact that it is LB 4 that can be released SUCKS I mean it wouldn't be as engaging if people can't see the visuals but I guess story recaps can be like a podcast....

  • @shaifs5072
    @shaifs5072 Місяць тому

    Reminds me of early PS4 generation when so many games had sharing features disables streamers were getting copyright strikes to hell.
    It’s disappointing but not surprising to see them go back to this.

  • @BlueSpiritFire1
    @BlueSpiritFire1 Місяць тому +4

    This is just baffling. Completely backwards to muzzle everyone for a few people who can't control themselves and curb their social media usage. It's on _us_ as the player to control what we see. I'm still pre-LB6, but guess what? That's on me! Avoiding spoilers for anything beyond where I am is MY responsibility. The most creators need to do imo is just not put blatant spoilers in the thumbnail and title.

  • @bradleyharris774
    @bradleyharris774 Місяць тому +17

    What's even the point of this? To avoid spoilers? Do the Devs not know that Western Players play JP and spoil the latest story chapters all the damn time? This seems like a pointless (and mean-spirited) middle finger to content creators who are literally FREE advertising for the game. Talk about shooting yourself in the foot.

  • @danielford9161
    @danielford9161 Місяць тому +3

    I could understand telling content creators not to show the cutscenes and dialog but to not show gameplay is absurd. Most of it is just running the same nodes over and over again and the event farming nodes especially often have nothing to do with the story of the event anyway.

  • @NeoGram19
    @NeoGram19 Місяць тому +7

    this gonna hurt community that reads plays fgo JP that skips story and im one of them because i skip the story because i cant read japanese

  • @neves783001
    @neves783001 Місяць тому +3

    Lol, OC2 Gudao face. 😅
    Speaking of OC2, with these guidelines in mind, I'll probably not know when (or IF) a certain group of characters are ever coming back in the story.

  • @MaximizingLIVE
    @MaximizingLIVE Місяць тому +21

    My main FGO content I upload is my story playthroughs but until I start seeing Sony actively hitting videos of people’s playthrough’s I’m not too worried since commentary should absolutely be protected by fair use right? I know Sony/Aniplex also had similar guidelines for the Tsukihime Remake and Mahoyo but full length playthroughs of those games still exist on UA-cam. Only thing I’m actually slightly worried about is soundtrack copyright, because UA-cam’s handling of that with gaming is so bad, if there’s even a hint of a copyrighted song in the background of a game you’re playing the entire video will be taken down so hopefully the developers can at least get that across to the higher ups at Sony/Aniplex. If the OST became copyrighted it’d be a complete nightmare for creators 😅

    • @henriqueabreu9706
      @henriqueabreu9706 Місяць тому +6

      In Japan there's no such thing as fair use. Anything can be a copyright infringement basically.

    • @MaximizingLIVE
      @MaximizingLIVE Місяць тому +5

      @@henriqueabreu9706right, but UA-cam is based in America and if I’m not mistaken we get fair use applied because of that don’t we? I’m not super familiar with how the back and forth of international laws would work here so forgive my ignorance.

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@MaximizingLIVE It's not just Japanese copyright laws you have to contend with now. Because of Sony's new FGO content guidelines, not even "fair use" is an applicable defense anymore.

    • @alexandrunache9078
      @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому +3

      Yeah, sadly guidelines beat copyright laws since it’s telling people how to use their property. Meaning people that don’t listen to them have no excuse since they made rules about them.
      Still stupid and low effort from them.

  • @Daustarticmon
    @Daustarticmon Місяць тому +3

    This is just insane, the proper way would be that you are not allowed to show anything of the current event or chapter until 48 to 72 hours have passed.
    As for the weird registration of old chapters I think is more for NA, since right now we are doing the road to seven campaign, after all is no secret and even Albert had been very vocal that they hate that na has that 2 years of insight in for future content.
    Hopefully they don't add new things in the future.

  • @kxem16
    @kxem16 Місяць тому +9

    So they just wanted to one up their F**k up with the servant coins and head straight to screw the people who "technically" do their free advertisement of the game while the said people also spends money and the time to play the game. That's one hell of away to ruin the reputation of the game. If their only concern about is spoilers of the story, sucks to suck but, the "majority" of the reason I watch FGO CCs is because of the Battle Gameplay, How the new Servant works and Strats. and plus I'm a dumbass when it comes to reading the japanese langauage, the FGO CC's help with understanding some of the story and the new mechanics of the game as well.

    • @squarebrain6714
      @squarebrain6714 Місяць тому +1

      At least servant reviews are not affacted, but the best dummy for testing is mobs in x-a Fuyuki, like jp CC do.

  • @ChaosSonic
    @ChaosSonic Місяць тому +9

    Looking at the dates, at least with lb7 in mind, I wonder if this put in place with with english version in mind, as shown in the livestreams when they get annoyed at our clairvoyance on future content, so they are trying to minimise what jp content is getting put out in the wild. not sure how i feel bout that, as the way it is at the moment lets me look forward to what's coming up and plan for the future.

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +5

      No, from other people have said it's because JP players were feed up with global content creators spoiling story hours after release, before they were even able to see it for themselves. So they complained and Sony did correct thing, but made too strict limitations.

    • @MrArrino
      @MrArrino Місяць тому +1

      @@Dorrovian Bro, I am global player thus two years behind and up till now with I managed to avoid most spoilers (the biggest one I didn't avoid was Oberon, but well... his class is one big spoiler so it was something unavoidable, yet I didn't know his full involvment in LB6 story, so no fuss) and those guys cannot avoid spoiler for few hours?

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому

      @@MrArrino So you got spoilered on biggest reveal of LB6 and somehow you are avoiding spoilers? That's big cope, your post is only argument in favour of that ban.

    • @MrArrino
      @MrArrino Місяць тому

      @@Dorrovian the only thing I knew was that he is pretender and doing something behind the scenes, thing that was heavily hinted in whole LB6 story. I didn't know that he was Vortigern, I didn't know that Morgan will be murdered so early in the story, I didn't know about Cennuros, and I didn't know that Oberon will change into big bug. If this is biggest spoiler of the LB then sure, I was spoiled terribly.
      The thing is (unlike JP players) I am 2 years behind. And If I have to wait 2 fricking years for game to catch up I will use clairvoyance to plan my rolls, spoilers or not.
      But here we are talking of few hours gap and guys who for some reason are watching streams and game plays of content available for them instead of playing this content :)

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +1

      @@MrArrino Again, you can get spoilered without searching for content by thumbnails and titles made by many content creators. This is on them, not on someone who went to see if there is something new on anything else on YT.

  • @ren4383
    @ren4383 Місяць тому +8

    This is just annoying, if that the case might aswel play and stream other games than fgo.

  • @octapusxft
    @octapusxft Місяць тому +4

    If they do not want spoilers, they need to basically shut down any story discussion on comments and reddit

  • @j.a.c.m.architecte
    @j.a.c.m.architecte Місяць тому +2

    I suspect this is related to how flustered fgo fans claimed to feel about if it was possible or not to catch up. They do not want to do that and I know some of us gave ideas on how that could be done and theorized about it, but I don’t see that happening in a very long time, unless they make it a thing to work on that. In the meantime we’ll have to do with being two years behind and being in the dark until they « release » stuff for NA as a surprise. Mystic eyes EX or whatever it was called, is done, that era is going to be a bygone thing.

  • @lilyaholmes109
    @lilyaholmes109 Місяць тому +2

    Content creator is one of the top place for the community to talk about the franchise. Creators are also the one place who hype up the community. Take that away, people honestly would slowly but surely leave the game. What are they trying to get with this really

  • @drzero7
    @drzero7 Місяць тому +18

    They DO realise this isnt pre-covid era where FGO was king of gacha right... They DO know that they have been de-throned by Mihoyo for like 4 years right... They are literally killing the Legacy players (which is basically the majority of the players still left)

    • @eiuholder5004
      @eiuholder5004 Місяць тому +4

      The bulk of the playerbase (and of revenue) of the game comes from Japan. Aniplex aren't hurt by Hoyoverse games since they have very different target demographics and is still generating more revenue than the vast majority of mobile gachas. The one you should be worried about specifically is FGO NA.

  • @rubeetora
    @rubeetora Місяць тому +1

    I wonder if they’ll do some kind of contracted influencer streamer program in the future so they can control information…

  • @JadedWarlock
    @JadedWarlock Місяць тому +6

    So this is how Soyny wants to do this... Maybe I should just drop.

  • @maxtech23
    @maxtech23 Місяць тому +1

    This is pretty crazy, i can understand not wanting people to be spoiled if that's one of there reasons for doing this but at the same time it's very easy to avoid spoilers by just not watching gameplay streams and videos of the jp version unless there's spoilers in thumbnails which is pretty annoying, it is your fault anyways if you go out of your way to watch gameplay of the jp version when you know there's a high chance you will get spoiled, such a shame what sony is doing.

  • @win2teabag009
    @win2teabag009 Місяць тому +2

    The Japanese brought upon this civil war

  • @Aniwehwalanpake
    @Aniwehwalanpake Місяць тому +10

    This is literally a bad news for fgo content creators and others advance guides and stuff so it's not just for the hype of the game itself but no theu literally kill the game itself for the content and s***

  • @Dorrovian
    @Dorrovian Місяць тому

    From what Radiant-Hope-469 wrote on Reddit, the limit is going to expand monthly and "By December 2024, the banned quests are Interludes, Ordeal Call Main Quests and Olga Marie Quests. And not Fuyuki-locked events."

  • @sinanoda9212
    @sinanoda9212 Місяць тому +7

    FGO, the game that I love but I can't support.

  • @CrypticBoss
    @CrypticBoss Місяць тому +2

    Just when I thought of trying it out for the first time, love copyright woo!!!

  • @fromeggman
    @fromeggman Місяць тому +8

    They keep this up and it will kill the game with the rate they release stuff typically.

  • @kingsora3087
    @kingsora3087 Місяць тому +16

    Ok so hear me out...... CLOSE THE 2 YEAR CONTENT GAP!!!!! thats the simple solution to this that will hurt no body and actually bring the game back to NA players who left for JP

    • @paradoxwraith5275
      @paradoxwraith5275 Місяць тому +11

      :l it wouldn't bring the players back. It would kill the game faster.

    • @bashamd96
      @bashamd96 Місяць тому +7

      Speedrunning like that causes burnout

    • @aizeroth8858
      @aizeroth8858 Місяць тому +2

      Just accept it, they will never close the gap. Never. They have been very clear about this. If you don't like it (like me) just quit and maybe come back once the story is over.

    • @kingsora3087
      @kingsora3087 Місяць тому +10

      @aizeroth8858 then this decision will most like slowly kill the game, other gacha games r innovating faster then fgo and eventually the story can't save this game. Sooner or later nasu is gonna haft to get to the point, the story is already going down hill atm so......

    • @aizeroth8858
      @aizeroth8858 Місяць тому +6

      @@kingsora3087 FGO is indeed a sinking ship, I don't see any hope of saving it with the mindset the devs/managers at Lasengle/Sony have. That's why im quitting after LB7 despite being a hardcore player for 5 years.

  • @ismrockmoon
    @ismrockmoon Місяць тому +1

    It felt like the whole servant coin fiasco was just bait so we would all protest it, allowing them to slip this policy in without any of us noticing."

  • @paulct91
    @paulct91 Місяць тому +1

    2:10 - That part seems dependent on whether FGO's Lasagna bothered to even update this document as the 'Updated' date is September 1, 2024 and strangely not a much later date in September.
    Reference
    Document Update Date: 9-1-2024 (0:10)
    KitaSean's concerns: 2:10

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому +2

      That's because September 1 unlocked in-game content up to and including LB4 (previously LB3) as far as guideline-legal content goes. October 1, that restriction is relaxed further, up to and including LB5.

  • @666dandark
    @666dandark Місяць тому +1

    This is the dumbest shot in the foot they ever gave themselves.

  • @meikisaragi1445
    @meikisaragi1445 Місяць тому +6

    This is bad for FGO. I mean, let's face it. It's not the best gacha game to stream right now. But I guess, It doesn't matter to them.

  • @Llucmenork
    @Llucmenork Місяць тому

    It seems you can show High Difficulty Quests tho, even Events and blank earth ones.

  • @joshiiman264
    @joshiiman264 Місяць тому

    Everyone saying this is to avoid spoilers are valid for thinking that. But then they put out saying that you can post videos and streams of the corresponding story chapters starting next month.

  • @beestek.94
    @beestek.94 Місяць тому +2

    Looks like Aniplex wants to kill FGO now for FGO2(copium) 😂
    But seriously, this is what happens when the higher ups of a company are old people on a market that contains coomers as the consumers. I swear, Japanese gacha game companies are so behind in times.

  • @erzal3373
    @erzal3373 Місяць тому +4

    This is Crunchyroll all over again bruh.

  • @billdecou242
    @billdecou242 Місяць тому +1

    Well according to what I have heard if you delete a video it can potentially still get a strike. If it's deleted you can not contest it so private is the best option.

  • @Isukiri544
    @Isukiri544 Місяць тому +1

    I get they want to avoid spoilers for later stuff but this is kind of ridiculous imo. I’m guessing the next coming chapters in JP must be so huge that they don’t want any sort of spoilers coming out.

  • @homulity5293
    @homulity5293 Місяць тому +2

    Is this the synchronized intelligence nation?

  • @Zilong17
    @Zilong17 Місяць тому +1

    This is incredibly minus. I'm not even a content creator, but I often record my high difficulty quests and the boss battles to share them with friends and fellow FGO players in my own smaller communities to discuss gameplay, minturns, theme runs etc. Not being able to share the performance of my servants in relevant content is incredibly dismaying.

  • @Hanszo1995
    @Hanszo1995 Місяць тому +2

    To be fair, FGO JP content are not supposed to be put out to global "yet". Of course they can't just out right to demand NA side not allowed to streaming this, it can cause a heavy backlash instead. If you do aware, there incident that forcing qooapp to delete everything related to FGO because the promotion content was supposed for JP not global.

  • @ColorOfSakura
    @ColorOfSakura Місяць тому

    I can understand wanting to put the kibosh on people posting Story related spoilers for content that hasn't come out in NA yet or is still even relatively new for JP.
    However events that have clear requirements other than Fuyuki (So you mean basically everything nowadays?) and stuff like *Bond CEs*? What the hell kind of nonsense is that.

  • @JphantomXIII
    @JphantomXIII Місяць тому +1

    They're either try to kill hype for their game or rank down the international versions clairvoyance. This is insane the only thing this will accomplish is stopping international player from learn how abhorrent they speed of game update be new story chapter or events

  • @XCCCUnknown
    @XCCCUnknown Місяць тому +2

    WAIT... STREAMING TOO????? What in the actual fuck are they thinking??? They keep making more bad business practices since the stoppage of re-run events. They ruined the expectations of the anniversary, the summer event, and the excitement of animation updates, and now they plan to ruin creators from playing their game online?

  • @Rainos62
    @Rainos62 Місяць тому

    I agree i think its bad. I can understand them saying hey until its out on global you cant cover the story on that part because the worst thing is when you see a thumbnail that is a clear spoiler. I also think events are fine because if you havent done an event you cant read it anyways so i dont think its a problem especially for older events which they dont have any plans to bring back.

  • @Gumshoe08
    @Gumshoe08 Місяць тому +4

    They really hate their fanbase i see.

  • @Zidane92332
    @Zidane92332 Місяць тому +2

    I wonder why don't they just limit how content creators make fgo content without giving too much spoilers. I mean, they could just give cc permissions to stream the content after a week or two, and only limit to streaming.
    This is basically append skill fiasco all over again

  • @drakeAbyss
    @drakeAbyss Місяць тому

    The fact that the potential for spoilers can cause some JP players to throw tantrums like children is pathetic, honestly. Even more pathetic is the devs listening to that minority of people who are clearly so attached to the game they would never stop throwing money at it. The only thing this does is hurt content creators and the community at large. If you don't want to be spoiled its really easy unless you're online 24/7 with no life(which I suspect is the case with these people) so screw em. Hopefully content creators figure out something cause I'd hate to see all the effort and passion so many of them put into their channels go down the drain

  • @piratevirus227
    @piratevirus227 Місяць тому

    Bro, that’s rough for FGO JP content creators. At least NA is safe. 😅

  • @user-cYhjMAHpW
    @user-cYhjMAHpW Місяць тому +1

    What's next to KuSony?
    Banning those who played JP server thru VPN?
    If that happens, I'm uninstalling the game for good.
    Especially that I'm slowly into retirement phase of playing games, watching videos, everything.

  • @mr.shadow8812
    @mr.shadow8812 Місяць тому +1

    What am curious is why did jp players specificially report these?

  • @GDYganesitutos
    @GDYganesitutos Місяць тому +5

    Besides the story mode and events, what else is there to do in the game? In other gacha games, this would be bad, but in FGO, it’s even worse. At least in other gacha games, you have different game modes and other features to create content with. FGO doesn’t even have a story replay option, so basically, content creators in the endgame will have to either whale out and spend money to generate gacha content or create multiple secondary accounts to replay old stages. It’s insane!

  • @TukkyHD
    @TukkyHD Місяць тому +2

    Guess they hate money

  • @jean-pierrebenzenique
    @jean-pierrebenzenique Місяць тому

    maybe this restriction is for the NA player who are still far behind?
    but still, interlude is prohibited??? why???

  • @skylordquasar
    @skylordquasar Місяць тому +3

    Ok but why though? It at least makes some sense in the case of persona where they make money by selling the story. What is the point here?

  • @dagobertobobadillajr7670
    @dagobertobobadillajr7670 Місяць тому +1

    The JP mindset is on a whole other level when it comes to boot licking. If this hits the states, someone better sue sony.

  • @gorraiya
    @gorraiya Місяць тому +4

    I kinda support it too, you JP players are too comfy spoiling stuff, Ive been avoiding lb7 spoilers like the plague and I've clicked on one of your vids and had something spoiled before when it wasn't even related to lb7
    I agree this fucks content creation and it does suck and is actually pretty unfair about the events and stuff too BC like who cares about event stories haha but as someone who avoids main story spoilers I can rest easier there I guess

    • @blaneonthemoon2507
      @blaneonthemoon2507 Місяць тому +3

      Stop watching fgo youtubers outside of guide videos if you dont want to be spoiled. Its just that simple.

    • @gorraiya
      @gorraiya Місяць тому +3

      @@blaneonthemoon2507 that kind of attitude would be why this is happening

  • @MrBlackboy21ful
    @MrBlackboy21ful 12 днів тому

    If this game burns ill be ok with that.

  • @HeyImGreenArrow
    @HeyImGreenArrow Місяць тому +5

    Terrible decision

  • @daikiraiheart3895
    @daikiraiheart3895 Місяць тому +3

    Im looking forward 3 months revenue will it drop or not

  • @Dorrovian
    @Dorrovian Місяць тому +19

    Let's all thank xNaya and his main plot points/boss fights spoilers in thumbnail hours after new content release. I'm not surprised JP players had enough.

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому +3

      And you wonder why the JP players hate him so much...

    • @ss16gokou
      @ss16gokou Місяць тому +14

      It's not his fault. If they don't want to get spoiled they shouldn't click his video. Hell I'm a huge hater of spoilers and I do get spoiled on Facebook or Twitter but not on UA-cam because on youtube you control what you want to play.

    • @kamamara2567
      @kamamara2567 Місяць тому +1

      @@ss16gokoualso why are they getting recommended NA content when their in JP?

    • @alexandrunache9078
      @alexandrunache9078 Місяць тому +2

      @@kamamara2567yeah, and why are they not just playing the story rn and be finished with this spoiler dodging. It honestly affects NA more than JP since we get spoiled 2 years in advance. And honestly it would be more fair to us if we got mad that JP CCs spoiled us than if NA “spoiled” them.
      Just close YT for 2 days and finish the story.

    • @kamamara2567
      @kamamara2567 Місяць тому

      @@alexandrunache9078 yeah let’s hope that this gets removed but I doubt it 😞

  • @luckystar788
    @luckystar788 Місяць тому +2

    This stupid especially when EN version already pass Lb6, yet they still limited it to Lb4 doesn't help how road to LB campaign already spoiling most content pass to LB6 this is me or whoever made ruler this are Boomer.

  • @marklopezBleach
    @marklopezBleach Місяць тому +3

    Wheres xnaya in this, absolute cooked? 💀

  • @E-Luckmaster
    @E-Luckmaster Місяць тому

    We understand sony was salty with concord but they don't need to drag fgo in their 2024 fumble list.

  • @banbowyt8945
    @banbowyt8945 Місяць тому +1

    Is this like limited to gameplay? Let say I put an image of Melu and talk about her lore and her role in lb6 without gameplay of bosses is that fair game?

  • @despairgumshoe6206
    @despairgumshoe6206 Місяць тому

    I think its about time UA-cam and Twitch start telling these companies 'We are American companies. The only laws we will abide by are American ones. Thus Japanese patent laws do not apply and Fair use is the standard. If it violates American copyright then feel free to report, otherwise keep Japanese laws to Japanese sites.' We are here because websites began catering to these conglomerate who have no legal standing in America due ro fear of bding sued instead of hey these videos/streams are covered by fair use since you put it in a game🙄🍹

  • @DreMcTM
    @DreMcTM Місяць тому +1

    This sounds similar to the Mahoyo streaming policy where they wouldn't let anyone stream past chapter 5.
    Maybe they are trying to prevent spoilers for the final few chapters of FGO. Not defending them, just a thought.

    • @alsha1243
      @alsha1243 Місяць тому +7

      i can kinda understand that it's new-ish product and they want to entice potential buyers, but gatekeeping 5 years old chapters is such a mesozoid method for keeping an interest.

  • @gummiemonkey2022
    @gummiemonkey2022 Місяць тому

    So we can show summer 8 (fae summer ) but not lb 6 even thou it mentions it in the event ..?

  • @ChaldeaWarmaster
    @ChaldeaWarmaster Місяць тому +1

    I feel like you will be fine on Twitch for the most part when streaming FGO related stuff.

  • @takaya86
    @takaya86 Місяць тому +1

    No one knew that there was an eight beast, and its called Sony.

  • @homulity5293
    @homulity5293 Місяць тому +2

    There are so many content creators that all they post is clear guides for events. And I guess they just have to quit UA-cam?

    • @cameraredeye3115
      @cameraredeye3115 Місяць тому

      No, they just need to stop posting spoilers for new content.

  • @devilhero1062
    @devilhero1062 Місяць тому +1

    stories gone means ost about those chapters will be gone as well
    which is sad and bs cuz it's from your own story why take down the fan uploads and didn't even upload on their main channel even after those take downs like how are we supposed to find those songs and ost

  • @FateTrap-ec9cz
    @FateTrap-ec9cz Місяць тому +5

    This game is killing itself slowly every year. That's crazyyyy

  • @EizenMalak
    @EizenMalak Місяць тому +1

    The concept of not watching the videos with story spoilers alien to jp people?
    If it was something to stop spoilers through thumbnails, I would understand, but timegating content? That's stupid.

  • @KhoaNguyen-tu6cw
    @KhoaNguyen-tu6cw Місяць тому +12

    Is this for JP only, will it gonna affected NA too ?

    • @kitasean
      @kitasean  Місяць тому +5

      As of right now it is JP only.

    • @THEBULLETPROOFKINGDOM
      @THEBULLETPROOFKINGDOM Місяць тому +2

      ​@@kitasean F/GO Content is still F/GO Content.
      Sadly, NA will get affected too.

    • @1907IceFire
      @1907IceFire Місяць тому +2

      @@THEBULLETPROOFKINGDOM nah, it's just to avoid spoilers to global/kr/cn users, like they don't want spoilers but in their official site they showed Hakuno welfare that you're supposed to see only when you clear OC3...so it's not about spoilers is to try to let the global users that probably complained about being spoilered on story chapters to survive being on socials without get that...a thing I don't really understand but probably it mean something for lasagna...

    • @Dorrovian
      @Dorrovian Місяць тому +4

      @@1907IceFire From what I heard it's because JP players were angry with global content creators spoiling story hours after release, before even them had time to play it.

    • @1907IceFire
      @1907IceFire Місяць тому +2

      @@Dorrovian well i understand them, few people want spoilers but others are pissed from that, the 2 years gap created this situation in the end...if you have content in english lot of people Will Just play without caring about spoiler video on socials