Should Goa focus on rebuilding temples, statues and forts and focus on human development?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 вер 2024
- Should #Goa focus on rebuilding temples, statues and forts and focus on human development? Watch 'Point-Counterpoint' only on Herald TV tonight, June 11, at 9.30 pm and repeats thereafter and on #UA-cam
Government can build many new temples in goa.even were the temples are not in good condition it can rebuild.but not to interfere in church proporties . please DNT damage our peace 🙏.we hindu . muslim nd christian all are united.
@@Nakamura7338 Yours is a valid point they Govt is not a religious institution.
This was a good discussion by our intellectuals ,wish ruling party takes the advice of best intellectuals of Goa ..to bring growth & development ...👍🏻
Whenever it's come to Hindu concern all talks about development and secularism education but do you know some intellectuals how much money spent in the name of minority? Just give one picture of Old Gos that's it...!
@@sandeshkuttikar2447 hindu or no all ancient monuments are protected for centuries ,present govt is not even a decade ...its not about religions its about humanity , Hindus or religions are made by men not God ...there were no religions dear ...so lets keep out religions from politics ..
Laws framed by Portuguese are better and retained by Goa Govt after liberation. Communicate was codified. Goa has unique Architecture.
Church has fabricas to maintain Churches Temples have Mazans to look after temples why Govt has to involve. Religion is personal and Govt should look after the welfare of state.
Can the govt use public money to built Temple only, tomorrow if a Mosque or Church needs a build up will the govt provide funds is there a budgetary provision made too
You are right sir, instead of focusing on history they should focus on the current issues of education etc
Best joke is that BJP wants to help the poor people 🤣😂
Forget peanut schemes... explain fule price, elect bill hike, water bill hike, cylinder price, vegetable oil and other grocery price hike. Everything is gone up but salary is Goa are the same.
Goans and non Goans are living in Goa in harmony. The students in Diocesan Schools Colleges are admitted without discrimination. Even Hospitals for example Hospicio Hospital erected by a Priest and run by Sacred Heart Sisters served all persons on humanitarian basis.
All the panels spoke well. I feel bad for the BJP spokesperson. He literally had to bear the brunt. But yet not satisfactory. But I disagree to the fact that BJP kept silent to Velingkar to the remark of Goencho Saib. If it is so than why did the CM react so bad to Ram Krishna on Parshuram? You should have seen how bad did he react. So that seemed a biased response.
Well, anyways, congratulations to Herald TV for literally bringing this topic out. Well handled. This is a good literate culture. Brilliant talks. We hope to hear more issues coming out. We surely finally need the BJP government to give their statement in the end.
Very good Fr. profesor you are very right but no use in Goa bjp jumlla they are all want to finish Goans and Goa
Modi is concern to help poor people Ambani , Adani, &Zindal
Good debate Govt should take cue and act.
The title of the debate itself - should government focus on rebuilding temples itself is concerning - is the government for and of Hindus or all other religions...??were hindus really the only victims of oppression in the past or catholics and muslims as well..should we put our full focus in these topics or could we keep them aside and focus on more imp issues for now..???
First focus on the human aspect, people have suffered immensely because of the pandemic, help them get back on a firmer ground, building of religious places is not the priority...
Goa should focus on its Portuguese connection - which is what made it unique and outstanding in India - and must also focus on creating people who love Goa the right way - so as not to sell their land to strangers who are turning it into a demons paradise
Goa also has Hindu heritage don't forget that
@@jiti5034 there's the rest of india for that
@@flashblast So are you saying that Goa has no Hindu connection? are you joking
@@jiti5034 there are chtistians and Marathi people who existed here.Who are you? You're a migrant
Silence of bjp and cm is makes goans confuse
Spend all money for hospitality nd we need good educational colleges nd Universities.so no one can travel to other states
"No intention of hurting other religions" - Velingkars take adv of this plan and spk of church demolition and rebuilding of temple where it stands..also questioning existence of pond in front of a mosque...
“Goa Governor PS Sreedharan Pillai praised Goa’s communal harmony and suggested an in-depth study of the same since communities live in harmony and communal riots are non-existent” But BJP and RSS are slowly working to disrupt this harmony of the Goan because they are not able to achieve this elsewhere as well as divide and rule. Governor also said once that the other Stetes should follow the example of Goan cultural harmony
Cost of living is beyond Goans. Goans cannot afford a piece of land or a shelter since Rich people out of Goa are purchasing second and fourth homes at high premium. Govt has no policy to help original Goans.
If BJP spokesperson says they remain silent on statements made by individuals not to give importance to them then why the hell importance was given to Late Father Concescao statement and made to apologize?
BJP spokesman said the BJP is doing everything for the poor. Why are Ambani and Adani becoming billionaires overnight. All the deals are being given to these including the Coal business in Goa. Goa does not need Coal but Adanis are routing coal through Goa and BJP is facilitating them by providing double tracking Rail and destroying ecology of Goa.
1. Has any Historian compiled the number of Temples in Nova Conquista?
2. Why there are more Temples in Ilhas Bardez and Salcete?
3. Why there are less Churches in Velha Conquista than the Destiyed Temples?
Govt Should REBUILD the Present ECONOMY which is in shambles due its wrong policies. Instead of improving Present worse Situation, trying to divert attention from their Failures. Creating Communal Disharmony. Why want past ?it it going to Feed our Stomach?or improve our financial situation?
Goa losing identity and culture because of unrolled Internal tourists and purchasing property in Goa including orchads and agricultural lands.
The person who sopen about St. Francis Durga Temple and Safa Masjid must be arrested and file FIR for spreading religious harmony
Why Subhash Velingkar not arrested or FIR is not filled for disturbing religious harmony.
Illegal old goa
Schemes have not reached the poor
But ministers got their shares
Very true.
Great debate dont build anymore churches or Temples
Goa is know for its beaches put dustbins, build good infrastructure around them hire people to keep them clean build good quality roads hospitals and hire goans
Stop lingering in the past
Besides y side with only 1 community y not speak of building more churches or more Mosques as well
In a democracy the government is saperated from the religion just like the USA and European union
DSS senior citizens are not getting timely help it is delayed the train engine is moving and the coaches are left behind.
What schemes is he talking about n helping the poor?is that enough when prices are going up n not getting that alms even on time?bjp is of capitalists n not poor.
20 crores is peanuts for restoring temples. 20 crores one can by 20 double bedroom flats.
Election 2024 at centre is the missile targeted. Goa is following other states to prove we too are not behind.
Let's focus on growth and development, but hope the govt destroy the environment in the name of development. Let there be natural forests and not concrete forest.
Goa has beautiful Churches around, pls think about it too.
Salaries in Industrial Estates are not commensurate with cost of living and Goans cannot accept employment and outsiders are employed for low wages and causes unemployment among Goans.
Farmers ?????
Ghantties (votes banks) gave victory for BJP.
All miners have benefitted from Portuguese and who were friends of Portuguese. CATHOLICS are called Rice bags but friends of Portuguese are glorified.
Nothing going to happen Mlas start feeling pocket till this govt there
Ilhas Bardez and Salcete are better off from Portuguese times called Velha Conquista. This was seen by Nova conquista and realized 200 years late and requested Portuguese to extend beyond Velha Conquista to Nova Conquista.
A good healthy debate. Congratulations on a good audio herald, you'll have improved a lot
what about the debt, unemployment and several scams
Govt silence is nothing but support.
15 lakhs BJP government??????
in the pandemicmedical scams where ventilator purchasehappened etc.
Flats which are not occupied for 3 months must be acquired by Govt and create a bank of flats.
The discussion is the minds of Goan people ......
old people did not get their monthly money for pass 3 months. what are you talking man
Viva Dotor
it's important to think about Present and future. Forget abouts Past is gone never will come Back again.
Goa is a peace loving state with NO Communal Disharmony. Govt need to maintain the same existing communal harmony and Goa can become a role model for the rest of India.
Stop the sale of land to the Non Goans and work hard to maintain Goa's greenery at any cost. Overall a good debate and govt can take a cue from the Herald Debate.
Why have than the government changed the name of our Vasco city into Sambhajinagar?
Change all other places also...
Utorda, Majorda, Velsao, Cansaulim, Fatorda, Raia, Rachol.
Change the street names too also... Why keep that too? Make Dabolim Airport Chatrapati Shivaji...
Do all such nonsense work....
DEVELOPMENT=Abamni_Adani.
Goan people were Christāo Konknne Musalman. Hindu word was alien to Goa.
Bamon Dessai MHar Chamar Mahar Gaude Kunbi Velip etc.
20 is not a MAJORITY?
A very interesting & an elucidating debate 🤭
We are heading towards a statue state don't put taxpayers money for buildings statues temples churches and other religious buildings put your personal money in such things
To ...BJP spokesman Rupesh ... u were invited to discuss BJPs achievement and footfall in Goa apart from Mandir. Not to project UP Yogi s achievement or report card of Modi. We all know the jungle Raj and bulldozer politics. What ia CM sawants report card is more important. Stop deflecting and brag about Central government schemes which is highly disputed by millions of Indians. Case in point gss cylinder...did these poor people get a FREE refill ...NO. Stop this Mandir, Masjid, Church politics...Indians in India esp Goans who respect all religions snd lived in love peace and tolerance past many years see through this divisive politics by the BJP.
Stop this Hate ... the western countries have spoken up and now 20 friendly Islamic countries have shamed India on the Global stage. Are you aware UAE ruling family has donated free land for the first official temple to be built? When, we all know what has happened in UP?
apart UAE as an Islamic country and where 200 nationalities live and work permits freedom of religion and coexistence/tolerance with 36 Christian churches, a Gurudwara etc. Shortly in Abu Dhabi in Sadiyar island a Mosque, Church and the very first Jewish Synagogue built side by side entire funding by the UAE Rulers will be completed...says a lot. Can the current BJP dispensation not take a clue? UAE Govt had to remind India the need for coexistence and tolerance in this country which, is a shame !!!
Add to this how many Goans visit UP ... ZERO !!! OR Gujarat Zero !!! And to compare GOA with UP is ridiculous by this spokesperson. Goans are happy with Indian tourists and honeymooners who come spend, enjoy Goan hospitality and good food NOT the riff raff n cheap VIP Babus n chamchas with a tagline " Aap ne jante mera baap kaun hain " Who the hell Cares!!! ...U are in GOA not on ur netas or babus watch for VIP treatment. " When in GOA... RESPECT the locals. Especially places of worship Churches Mosques n Temple. And Dress Respectfully !!! DRINK RESPONSIBLY AND BEHAVE RESPONSIBLY WITH THE LOCALS Not the DRUNKENESS of your state culture when " riding or driving "...GOA WELCOMES !!! .. Goans on their travels or holidays to any Indian states respect the culture of the state as in any country
U middle aged people should be ashamed to discuss these sort of topic ,these CM cannot afford to pay DSS, to the poor remmember from which state he come from.
THE CM. is the one who triggered this bringing the venum from out side
The BJP guy should focus on the peoples point of view and not the party.
Why are you guys giving this topic attention at all?
Pahle industrial estates thik kare,
no security for women
Mr. Gupta, the minority in Goa always lived in dignity they even had a powerful media presence trough Herald that helped their social relevance, until you took over Herald and the RSS/BJP blackmailed your Boss and sent him into a cave. Please educate yourself on Goas pre Portuguese History, there is enough material IN Dutch Museum on Arab and Dutch traders in Goa, there are also Documents in Lisbon Archives, of all or any local "action" that took place in Goa. Also You will be shocked to know that Goa had black stone temples everywhere with just a Shivlinga or a Demi- God like Betala.and Parshu.. The travelling Aryans brought their own female deities and built their own temples in Goa. Dont rely on these ungrateful idiots who are now showing their true color.Ask them to give up Portuguese pants and go back to KHAXTI if they are so upset with Portuguese.
We are hindus, muslims, christians, not happy on BJP because of going on religions, this will stay in history, this can be problem for good hindus in future, no problem for donkey minded hindus, any government in world cannot go on religions, only our India government do this, this is not development going on religions, this is destroying development, richest people and government are are not following rules, this is problem only for poor people.
Build temples for vote banks among ignorants who need schools to educate their children.
unemployment
CM from goa take advantage of modi because of bjp party now their eyes 👀 open now n Swant who is make mess in goa and this is bjp party very very bad mess n CM don’t had any good knowledge humanity
U people should be ashamed to
Konkani uloi