This Video Is Grossly Offensive

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 жов 2018
  • Argument: A UA-cam video in which a pug is trained to answer to the phrase "Gas the Jews" is anti-Semitic in nature and grossly offensive.
    Counter-Argument: The video in question is comedic in nature and offense is subjective.
    Arguer's Fault: Neglect of intent/context and a general lack of humor.
    M8 Yer Dugs A Nazi: • Video
    The Nature Of This Video Has Been Debated
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    Jonathan Pie: • It's a JOKE!
    Philip DeFranco: • We Need To Talk About ...
    Joe Rogan: • Joe Rogan on UA-camr ...
    Count Dankula Interview: • EXCLUSIVE: Count Danku...
    BBC Articles
    Count Dankula Arrested: www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-...
    Count Dankula Guilty: www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-...
    Count Dankula Fined: www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-...
    Independent Article
    Count Dankula Found Guilty: www.independent.co.uk/news/uk...
    Tweet: / counterarguing
    Post: / counterarguments
    Buy: teespring.com/stores/countera...
    Donate: www.paypal.me/counterarguments
    Email: countertheargument@gmail.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,3 тис.

  • @CounterArguments
    @CounterArguments  5 років тому +1835

    Re-uploaded?
    Yes.
    Why?
    Answer: ua-cam.com/video/xz-g9Aeu4Vg/v-deo.html

    • @abdullahimran6012
      @abdullahimran6012 5 років тому +50

      Counter Arguments hotel?
      Trivago

    • @untitled6087
      @untitled6087 5 років тому

      Good call!

    • @FirstLast-cf4mi
      @FirstLast-cf4mi 5 років тому

      You are tenacious.
      Have you read this btw? - www.amazon.co.uk/Trigger-Warning-Offensive-Killing-Speech/dp/0008125457
      The Guardian don't like it - www.theguardian.com/books/2017/feb/27/revolting-how-establishment-underlining-democracy-what-afraid-of-mick-hume-review-communist

    • @FlameEliwood
      @FlameEliwood 5 років тому +1

      I'm sorry that despite telling people to watch the video in your comment for a clear answer that anyone scrolling down could see, people still aren't actually talking about the topic at hand. Instead they are asking about why it's reuploaded, still talking about UA-cam premier, or just stating how they are going to watch it again without adding to the discussion.
      Hopefully your next video will do better

    • @TheBioshocksnake
      @TheBioshocksnake 5 років тому

      This is off topic, but is there a possibility to do a video on the Sargon v Richard debate at Mythcon? There are a *LOT* of really bad arguments from Sargons side, and it would be interesting to hear your view on the behaviour and arguments from Sargons side (also I need closure from the trauma of hearing the worst arguments from a source I previously respected).
      You're awesome :D

  • @rushopolis
    @rushopolis 5 років тому +3584

    Counter counter argument: The dog is a legit racist.

    • @MarschelArts
      @MarschelArts 5 років тому +211

      I mean, it's a pug... they always looked suspicious.

    • @thecaptain5026
      @thecaptain5026 5 років тому +38

      Counter^6 argument= everything is racist

    • @edvardasb.4989
      @edvardasb.4989 5 років тому +1

      CHECKMATE BITCH

    • @joostvanrens
      @joostvanrens 5 років тому +35

      @@thecaptain5026 counter^7 dogs are an oppressed class and therefore can't be racist

    • @zyaicob
      @zyaicob 5 років тому +17

      @@thecaptain5026 *_EVERYTHING IS RACIST, EVERYTHING IS SEXIST, EVERYTHING IS HOMOPHOBIC, AND YOU HAVE TO POINT IT ALL OUT_*

  • @Korajiyo
    @Korajiyo 5 років тому +3385

    It's funny because the Nazis attempted to prosecute a man who did the same thing during the Nazi regime.

    • @alexo.1388
      @alexo.1388 5 років тому +36

      Who?

    • @LT-xc9cs
      @LT-xc9cs 5 років тому +176

      The Other Point Of View I think you meant that Nazi’s give people more freedom of speech than UK

    • @mobeenkhan824
      @mobeenkhan824 5 років тому +47

      The Other Point Of View
      How is the modern UK worse then the nazis.

    • @lsswappedcessna
      @lsswappedcessna 5 років тому +10

      Oh, history repeats itself!

    • @MrLhxD
      @MrLhxD 5 років тому +27

      @@mobeenkhan824 UK's history is full of Wars and Colonialism! How are they better than Nazis and Commies?

  • @geoffstockton
    @geoffstockton 5 років тому +2448

    You can actually see the racism in the dog's eye. The owner's boyfriend may be a stand-up guy. Be that as it may, that dog is clearly a racist.

    • @Im_Just_A_Dreamer
      @Im_Just_A_Dreamer 5 років тому +77

      It's a pretty big racism too. I'm surprised the dog could still see with that big racism in his eye!

    • @tobology6781
      @tobology6781 5 років тому +32

      Keep your hate pugs out of my canpus

    • @aciooica4469
      @aciooica4469 5 років тому +13

      The dog didn’t get the joke... XD

    • @caitthecat
      @caitthecat 5 років тому +1

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @lazergurka-smerlin6561
      @lazergurka-smerlin6561 5 років тому +3

      @@Im_Just_A_Dreamer Maybe the dog will go blind and not see colour anymore! Oh shit

  • @larsbruinenberg767
    @larsbruinenberg767 3 роки тому +852

    “If you’re offended it doesn’t mean you’re right” - Ricky Gervais

  • @Nakia11798
    @Nakia11798 5 років тому +468

    I can’t believe that happened over two years ago. Poor guy, all he did was make a joke with a dog.

    • @lukelblitz3627
      @lukelblitz3627 3 роки тому +24

      Hey,aparently he is taking this to international court now

    • @mistofisto9108
      @mistofisto9108 3 роки тому +3

      @@lukelblitz3627 wat

    • @Aetherian1
      @Aetherian1 3 роки тому +3

      @@mistofisto9108 Yep, check out his channel, he made an update video on it about a month ago I think

    • @emperorsascharoni9577
      @emperorsascharoni9577 3 роки тому +1

      If he had this guy as a lawyer the judge would get the fine.

    • @Aetherian1
      @Aetherian1 3 роки тому +9

      @@emperorsascharoni9577 Lol nope, the appeal got rejected multiple times and when he took it to the high courts to prove that the law was flawed one of the judges was the guy that wrote it. The UK is a precarious society that avoids anarchy not because of the legal systems - lately despite them - but because anarchy is impolite.

  • @jaewok5G
    @jaewok5G 5 років тому +1554

    the cherry on top is that the dog's name is Buddha!!!! no one ever mentions that!

    • @ghl3186
      @ghl3186 5 років тому +74

      silly clown, didn't you know that buddha is the god of fascism?

    • @bonogiamboni4830
      @bonogiamboni4830 5 років тому +72

      After all, the swastika was originally an indo-buddhist symbol.

    • @dx.feelgood5825
      @dx.feelgood5825 4 роки тому +8

      That's hilarious, oml

    • @GORTROG
      @GORTROG 3 роки тому +4

      It all makes sense now

    • @My_wife_left_me
      @My_wife_left_me 3 роки тому +6

      His name is buddha because when he was a puppy he was super fat

  • @demonderpz7937
    @demonderpz7937 5 років тому +1074

    I personally do not understand how people can be arrested for their sense of humor and fear the direction the world is going towards.

    • @trulymrword
      @trulymrword 5 років тому +17

      DemonDerpz Screw Nuke War, the Information war will be the death of us.

    • @mekullag9787
      @mekullag9787 4 роки тому +17

      what are you talking about, why did so many people upvote you? This is literally the exact opposite of “where the world is going“, it‘s where we‘re *coming* from. Who ever came up with the idea that being overly sensitive was a millenial thing? A generation ago people literally thought jazz music was the devils work.
      What happened to the guy was a combination of out of date laws, judge and prosecution. Three things that take notoriously a little longer than society to adopt new values (which is also a good thing, because society is volatile).

    • @brabhamF1
      @brabhamF1 4 роки тому +38

      @@mekullag9787 The problem aren't directly these laws. The problem is how they are being used today. The 90's and early 2000's were a lot more open about all kinds of humor. If I look back at the kind of jokes I could make when I was younger and noone got offended (jokes about Poles, Italians, Spaniards, Brits and Germans while I had friends of all the nationalities) and people jsut laughed and said it was a joke.
      Now I make a mildly offensive joke (I wouldn't call it that but that is basically what those are) and people who have fuck all to do with it come along and literally screech at me about how racist/sexist/homophobic I am. I was told that jokes about the "Deutsche Bahn" (notorious for delays for literally fuck all reasons) are racist because they have gay/iranian/turkish train conductors. THIS IS WERE WE ARE HEADED.
      Just because we had older generations tell us that our new generational music/dresscode was the devils work/turning us into criminals doesn't compare to an entire generation of even sometimes formerly normal people having a cultural outrage behaviour. The press coverage would make Goebbels very proud.
      “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly - it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
      ― Joseph Goebbels

    • @mekullag9787
      @mekullag9787 4 роки тому +6

      @@brabhamF1 And yet have a look at pop culture, the trend is very obvious. The Simpsons used to be considered edgy! You´ll be hard pressed to find a single episode of theirs that would not be seen as "family friendly" today, outside of maybe the Halloween episodes.
      Today we have shows like Family guy and American Dad competing for who can make the most offensive joke and no one bats an eye.
      Have a look at music. Hip Hop is the most popular genre and it´s full of violence, sex and drugs, music videos that may have been classified as porn 60 years ago run on TV all day long.
      Sexuality becomes less and less of a tabu. People think it´s PC culture that made the metoo movement? These women would not have dared to speak out in the last century, because they would have been murdered in public opinion for daring to make such a thing public.
      I can´t deny that a subculture has emerged which demonizes any- and everything that may offend or trigger anyone, but realize that the internet makes it seem like much more of a problem than it is. On one hand the group themselves have a medium with which to fight what they dislike in a very public way and on the other hand people use the group to make money by stirring up hate and ridicule around them, so basically two factions who both have the goal of making the first seem like a big "thing".
      I´m sorry about your personal experience, but I fail to see this taking place on a larger scale.
      Also I have to add that not every new sensitivity that comes up is a bad thing (neither is openness necessarily good), as for example mistreating people for being different may have been widely accepted in the past, the world is a better place for that not being the case anymore.

    • @unclesam8862
      @unclesam8862 4 роки тому +4

      @@mekullag9787 hip hop is NOT the most popular genre

  • @elcomentario5430
    @elcomentario5430 5 років тому +436

    I'm not sure if this was true but either the judge or someone involved in the prosecution said something along the lines of, "the context does not matter". To that I say, isn't that the whole point of proving guilt and administering punishment. The difference between manslaughter and the degrees of murder is intent. Context is everything in this situation.

    • @louisvictor3473
      @louisvictor3473 5 років тому +35

      I guess it is fair them to shoot that guy in the face in what would otherwise be cold blooded murder, and then claim "no, it was a murder in self defense because I felt threatened - you can't say it wasn't, context doesn't matter."

    • @professionalmemeenthusiast2117
      @professionalmemeenthusiast2117 5 років тому +38

      If context doesn't matter then everyone who quoted Dankula has also committed a crime

    • @buzzline1544
      @buzzline1544 5 років тому +45

      ​@@professionalmemeenthusiast2117 Dankula even said to the media outside the court something like "if context doesn't matter, why can't you be prosecuted for reporting on me"

    • @professionalmemeenthusiast2117
      @professionalmemeenthusiast2117 5 років тому +18

      @@buzzline1544
      Exactly. Without context, words cannot ever be judged at all.

    • @kommentator666
      @kommentator666 5 років тому +4

      "At Airdrie Sheriff Court today, 23 April 2018, Sheriff Derek O'Carroll fined Mark Meechan £800 for breaching the Communications Act 2003, by posting a grossly offensive video on the internet. On sentencing Sheriff O'Carroll made the following statement in court:
      [...]
      "
      www.scotland-judiciary.org.uk/8/1962/PF-v-Mark-Meechan
      It took me 5 minutes to retrieve this information. Please just google stuff before you spread false claims.

  • @kormagogthedestroyer
    @kormagogthedestroyer 3 роки тому +44

    As a Jew, I am confused how people thought the video was anti-Semitic. He literally said IN THE VIDEO ITSELF that it was a joke and he didn’t believe the things he said.
    I actually find the video funny. The fact that he was CONVICTED over telling a joke just says something about the justice system.

  • @numismaticmaster8612
    @numismaticmaster8612 5 років тому +238

    But having Nazis makes the joke that much more powerful. If you were to use the Croatian Fascists, very few people would get it. The Nazis are just universal.

    • @Izanagioomikami
      @Izanagioomikami 5 років тому +14

      What Dolphins? Dolphins are evil. Way more than nazis.

    • @ruttsuco.804
      @ruttsuco.804 5 років тому +18

      Sol Badguy what about Nazi Dolphins?

    • @ghl3186
      @ghl3186 5 років тому +22

      @@ruttsuco.804 what about nazi zombies, feminazis, or grammar nazis? edit: or ashke *nazi* jews?

    • @dutchdykefinger
      @dutchdykefinger 5 років тому +2

      fucka you whale and fucka you dolphin! ;)

    • @magicno2
      @magicno2 4 роки тому +4

      What would actually be more powerful is racism against black people. Image having the dog respond to the N-word by running away.

  • @Lordlaneus
    @Lordlaneus 5 років тому +442

    Ooh, a re-upload, perfect excuse to rewatch

  • @SoniaSephia
    @SoniaSephia 5 років тому +387

    This really goes to show that Scotland's hate speech law needs to be reformed.

    • @HerrMisterTheo
      @HerrMisterTheo 5 років тому +4

      GalaxyEspeon
      Count Dankula is Scottish though

    • @SoniaSephia
      @SoniaSephia 5 років тому +3

      Fixed it lol oops.

    • @Axyo0
      @Axyo0 5 років тому +20

      you mean removed

    • @silverspeak4813
      @silverspeak4813 5 років тому +2

      It’s actually ‘less strict in Scotland than the uk’

    • @lmao.3661
      @lmao.3661 4 роки тому

      extra thicc and spicy memez
      The fuck are you on about mate

  • @hiukas.
    @hiukas. 5 років тому +286

    I bet you that if ww2 soldiers watched the video they would laugh hard

    • @jacobshirley3457
      @jacobshirley3457 4 роки тому +2

      During WW2 or after?

    • @thegodhoward8037
      @thegodhoward8037 4 роки тому +34

      Either since it would make out their enemies as annoying little ankle bitters

    • @user-ft3jq5vi2l
      @user-ft3jq5vi2l 3 роки тому +34

      And if you showed it to actual nazis THEY would be angry.

    • @captaingreyeye7461
      @captaingreyeye7461 3 роки тому +16

      Yah I bet the video wouldn’t be out of place. The we’re making joke art about hitler in a wedding dress marrying Stalin.

    • @jay-tbl
      @jay-tbl 3 роки тому +7

      @@user-ft3jq5vi2l The only reason this video is offensive is either you weren't paying attention, or you ARE a nazi

  • @ChilledfishStick
    @ChilledfishStick 5 років тому +1134

    The thought police can stick it. Even being Jewish with quite a large number of murdered relatives, I still find real bigots less offensive than those who wish to protect my fragile sensibilities.

    • @typhoidss
      @typhoidss 5 років тому +76

      Same, Im jewish, so everyone is trying to shelter my "precious feelings"

    • @danieltsiprun8080
      @danieltsiprun8080 5 років тому +4

      אני יודע נכון שזה מעצבן שהם כביכול מנסים להגן על הרגשות שלך.

    • @acezero5705
      @acezero5705 4 роки тому +8

      Bbbbut I know I need to protect your feels

    • @adonisadmirer2752
      @adonisadmirer2752 4 роки тому +30

      @@typhoidss +Chilledfish It's okay mateys, we're going to get this devil dog away from you, you don't need to ask, we're doing this to protect you.

    • @shnpio
      @shnpio 4 роки тому +7

      That’s one of the biggest problem of political correct culture is that it was invented by white people who want to hide and excuse their previous mistakes, even if their intentions are good. One example is a lot of native Americans will say they prefer to be called Indians as it is an outline of the white mans stupidity thinking they were Indian and that they find Native American quite patronising same with African American it’s suggests that there is something wrong with calling someone black meaning with this logic it must be wrong or lesser to be black so why do the white people get to decide what the black people get to be called? Because it makes them feel better

  • @masonaut0
    @masonaut0 5 років тому +539

    Why do you put a thumbtack on your sticky notes?

    • @ghl3186
      @ghl3186 5 років тому +52

      it's a cover for his freemansonry

    • @nochannelmusician769
      @nochannelmusician769 5 років тому +113

      Because they’re the crappy ones. They don’t stick.

    • @AEther0238
      @AEther0238 5 років тому +59

      Now we're asking the real questions.

    • @Paranuui
      @Paranuui 5 років тому +6

      To... keep them up?

    • @lsswappedcessna
      @lsswappedcessna 5 років тому +11

      He doesn't trust horse hoof 3M glue.

  • @don-jx2xn
    @don-jx2xn 5 років тому +248

    This whole court case makes me ashamed to be Scottish

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 5 років тому +13

      Vote for political parties that value free speech.

    • @allenkennedy99
      @allenkennedy99 5 років тому +9

      @@Chronically_ChiII So, UKIP, and that's basically it?

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 5 років тому +6

      Sadly, do to the incompatibility of other British parties, yes.

    • @stlchucko
      @stlchucko 5 років тому +6

      No need to be ashamed mate.
      Welcome to how it feels to be American.

    • @anthonysutherland4108
      @anthonysutherland4108 4 роки тому +1

      Don't be disheartened my Scottish friend. This Australian loves nothing better than a non pc rant from an outraged Scot.👍😀🇦🇺

  • @pigeonoverlord9433
    @pigeonoverlord9433 4 роки тому +48

    Want my theory? That pug was a reincarnated Hitler

    • @swine13
      @swine13 3 роки тому +1

      Mein Furrer!!

  • @lalilulelo6138
    @lalilulelo6138 5 років тому +46

    dude, you forgot the whole part where the judge specifically said "context is irrelevant".
    you did a bang up job of explaining the context btw, just that the law apparently doesn't give a shit.

    • @kapjoteh
      @kapjoteh 3 роки тому +4

      L̸a̵ ̴L̸i̵ ̶L̴u̶ ̷L̸e ̷L̴o̶ by that logic, the reporter that quoted him should have also been arrested

  • @Rentedreaper25
    @Rentedreaper25 3 роки тому +55

    I need to know who was that guy who screamed "it was a joke you cu-"

  • @smilingipad3044
    @smilingipad3044 5 років тому +160

    YES A RE-UPLOAD. POPULAR OPINION WINS.

  • @brainiacguy16
    @brainiacguy16 3 роки тому +35

    The scary thing about this is the precedent it sets. Since “grossly offensive” is entirely subjective, literally anything could be prosecuted under this ruling
    All it would take is The government deciding that anything it doesn’t like counts as “grossly offensive” And boom: you have dystopian censorship without a single legal change

    • @ISuperI
      @ISuperI 2 роки тому

      Just replace grossly offensive with terrorism and voilà, you have Nicaragua, an actual dictatorial regime

  • @TheMemesofDestruction
    @TheMemesofDestruction 5 років тому +96

    The actual offense Meechan was charged with took place after Police officials edited out the preamble. This editing may have transformed the video into new intellectual property owned by the police department.

    • @imveryangryitsnotbutter
      @imveryangryitsnotbutter 5 років тому +45

      So the police are guilty of tampering with evidence? That's... chilling.

    • @TheMemesofDestruction
      @TheMemesofDestruction 5 років тому +24

      I'm Very Angry It's Not Butter!! If this was of a transformative nature and falls under fair use then the police department may own the intellectual rights to the “offending” video..

    • @A-Duck
      @A-Duck 5 років тому +26

      @@TheMemesofDestruction Therefore by producing and disseminating said video, guilty of a hate crime themselves. Charming.

    • @TheMemesofDestruction
      @TheMemesofDestruction 5 років тому +9

      @@A-Duck Law is a fickle thing

    • @eggy6745
      @eggy6745 3 роки тому +7

      @@imveryangryitsnotbutter it wouldn't be the first time the scottish police has done that

  • @georgeheld1901
    @georgeheld1901 3 роки тому +69

    10:18 “it simply would not make sense to walk into a museum, see a Nazi flag, and be offended”
    It’s happened before...

    • @byronobrien3121
      @byronobrien3121 3 роки тому +2

      Really?

    • @georgeheld1901
      @georgeheld1901 3 роки тому +5

      ᛒᚣᚱᚩᚾ ᚩᛒᚱᛇᛖᚾ yeah, I know the Met has removed some stuff, and I know that many air-and-space museums have removed the swastica from the Hindenburg in their airship sections

    • @byronobrien3121
      @byronobrien3121 3 роки тому +4

      @@georgeheld1901 unbelievable.

    • @sirlionson2207
      @sirlionson2207 3 роки тому +5

      @@byronobrien3121 in South Africa there was a museum that had a bar in it and in the bar was a captured nazi flag. The museum was forced to take it down

  • @marioc.7198
    @marioc.7198 5 років тому +18

    This reminds me of a news article I read a few years ago about an auction of a 2500 years old thracian coin with a swastika on it taking place on german eBay. Since the german constitution forbids the exhibition of nazi symbols of any sort and being the swastika the most notorious of those symbols, the auction had to be taken down by court order. This is obvious nonsense because, although the letter of the law could be interpreted in a literal sense, the context of the situation had to be taken into consideration. A 2500 years old swastika was obviously a religious symbol with absolutely no connotations with 20th century national socialism.

  • @advangel9763
    @advangel9763 5 років тому +148

    The fact that you re-posted this video is grossly offensive.

    • @GypsieAsh
      @GypsieAsh 5 років тому +1

      Advangel 😆👍

    • @tayo5532
      @tayo5532 5 років тому +2

      Tactical decision

    • @aeryn9361
      @aeryn9361 5 років тому +1

      Must be an anti Semite

    • @belaschmidt1770
      @belaschmidt1770 Рік тому

      Bring him to court, maybe you can get some money 😂😂😂

  • @BumLuck
    @BumLuck 5 років тому +36

    I really like this new feature where a video is uploaded and then people can just watch it as soon as they see it.

  • @dwightk.schrute6743
    @dwightk.schrute6743 5 років тому +44

    I'm getting tired of seeing this damn pug in my recommendations.

    • @daraghokane4236
      @daraghokane4236 5 років тому +10

      Well if the police didn't arest dankula he wouldn't be famous. We need to get rid of hate speech laws for no other reason than to stop making edgy morons famous. In a perfect world dankula would have made his video it would become a big vine for a week then everyone would forget about it.

    • @zer0nen0ne78
      @zer0nen0ne78 5 років тому

      Dwight K. Schrute Don’t you have some beets to tend to?

    • @AnakinSkyobiliviator
      @AnakinSkyobiliviator 5 років тому +6

      Were you.... _grossly offended by it?_

    • @jerrygregor
      @jerrygregor 5 років тому +8

      There are three vertical dots under the right hand side of the video. Click on them and then click, "Not interested". That'll save you the bother of having to watch a video you don't want to see and then feel the need to tell the rest of us about it.

    • @doso4782
      @doso4782 4 роки тому +1

      Question:
      What are you doing here?

  • @m.a.t.a.s
    @m.a.t.a.s 4 роки тому +36

    "Jokes are like food, not everyone gets it!"

    • @dangerxcom
      @dangerxcom 3 роки тому +1

      Jokes are like love, not everyone gets it!

  • @jackbartlett4402
    @jackbartlett4402 3 роки тому +9

    “I say what I think happened, then you say what you think happened, then I decide who’s right. That’s why it’s called Justice, cause it’s just us.”

  • @carpo719
    @carpo719 3 роки тому +5

    Honestly, when one thinks about it, it is absolutely absurd that we even have to TALK about this as if language needs to be 'curated' just because others don't get it.

  • @chargles6238
    @chargles6238 2 роки тому +2

    I want to make every essay I write for school from now on sound like this guy’s videos.

  • @thecaptain5026
    @thecaptain5026 5 років тому +5

    Seen it before, I just wanted to say I love your use of logic in your videos. I think many people could learn a lot from your work. It's entertaining, logical, reasonable and accessible.
    Keep it up!

  • @johnnybgoodeish
    @johnnybgoodeish 5 років тому +23

    I found it even funnier when I learnt that the dog's real name is Buddha! :)

    • @swine13
      @swine13 3 роки тому +1

      He said that because "Karl Wooff" had seemed a little on the nose at the time

  • @haberak3310
    @haberak3310 5 років тому +56

    5:55 Very easy jojo part 2 Rudolf Von Stroheim
    Also as a jew the original video was hilarious

    • @Izanagioomikami
      @Izanagioomikami 5 років тому +1

      You're not a jew. You're a comment under a youtube video. Get your facts straight m8

    • @ghl3186
      @ghl3186 5 років тому +14

      @@Izanagioomikami so by your logic, i'm not canadian because i'm a reply?

    • @kentuckyfriedchildren5385
      @kentuckyfriedchildren5385 4 роки тому +3

      @@ghl3186 *yes*

    • @blueberrimuffin6682
      @blueberrimuffin6682 3 роки тому

      BBBBBBRAKA

    • @pyrosnappy7641
      @pyrosnappy7641 3 роки тому

      @@Izanagioomikami i am no longer eskimo, i am just a commenter, holy fuck the realization hit me like a train

  • @rayflyers
    @rayflyers 5 років тому

    Happy to rewatch it ...and bingewatch your whole catalog while I'm at it.

  • @martinclarke9490
    @martinclarke9490 5 років тому +31

    It should be made clear to confused audience members that in Scotland judges are called "sheriffs". So for anyone in the comments saying that there was a screw up at 3:41, there wasn't.

    • @Soitisisit
      @Soitisisit 3 роки тому +2

      That's interesting, I didn't know that.

    • @swine13
      @swine13 3 роки тому

      That escalates matters in the eyes of the state! Haha
      🎵"I shot the sheriff..."🎶
      ...and by 5pm it was a national emergency and I had 2 choppers and about 45 armed officers outside begging me to let the hostages go while snipers set up on rooftops with enough of a vantage to take me out."

  • @LazyActor
    @LazyActor 4 роки тому +12

    "guilt must be proven." LMAO wrong country mate.

  • @Tommowo
    @Tommowo 5 років тому +56

    The people questioning why this was re-uploaded didn't watch the last vid :c

  • @georgemorley1029
    @georgemorley1029 3 роки тому

    I’ve been searching for this - the irony inherent in the loss of irony by the inversion of the Producers situation. Thank you! Perfect.

  • @IrrelevantPride
    @IrrelevantPride 5 років тому

    I just wanted to say that I love your channel and I'm glad I stumbled upon it. Thank you for putting out thoughtful and interesting content on youtube!

  • @ajhintleman215
    @ajhintleman215 2 роки тому +2

    Humor can't exist without offending someone/something. As we approach times where people get offended by any and everything, laughter will fade as people will simply shut down all jokes with, "this offends me" or, "this is offensive". Sad indeed.
    I know I'm 2 years late but uhhh good video!

  • @jackmclane1826
    @jackmclane1826 2 роки тому +3

    Fun fact: During the third Reich several people were punished for training their dogs like this. Because it was offensive! ;)

  • @Abel_lived
    @Abel_lived 5 років тому

    So glad you re-uploaded this. Well done mate

  • @GypsieAsh
    @GypsieAsh 5 років тому

    Thank you for re posting! This is probably one of my favorite of your videos! 👏🤓

  • @oluwafikayomiolanbiwoninu9453
    @oluwafikayomiolanbiwoninu9453 5 років тому +31

    You should have been his lawyer mate

    • @danieltsiprun8080
      @danieltsiprun8080 5 років тому +11

      The judge ruled the context didn't matter so counter argument points wont be valid by the judge rule. Which is fucking retarded if the prosecution quoted what dank said by the same logic the judge used that context doenst matter then the prosecution cant be sued too.

    • @lmao.3661
      @lmao.3661 4 роки тому +2

      Context didn’t matter unless they were saying it themselves.

  • @biggiecheesejr6285
    @biggiecheesejr6285 5 років тому

    I just watched the original version of this video and then the video after and yet I still find myself watching the re-upload like 10 minutes later.

  • @sevenguardians7517
    @sevenguardians7517 3 роки тому +8

    I personally didn’t find it all that funny but I also wasn’t offended by it
    He did not deserve to be convicted over a UA-cam video

  • @alpacawithouthat987
    @alpacawithouthat987 3 роки тому +3

    I find government taxes grossly offensive. Does this mean we should arrest every government official now?

  • @TheJimmyp427
    @TheJimmyp427 3 роки тому +6

    3:45 "in a court of law, where a defendant's guilt *must* be proven, the notion of a defendant's guilt being evident *without* proof would seem to undermine the purpose of a trial."
    So fucking elegant. I hope whatever this guy went on to do, he's really good at it cuz man he was great doing this channel.

  • @biffnotsotannen1462
    @biffnotsotannen1462 5 років тому

    Already watched it but I love this channel so much that this video needs to get as much out of the UA-cams as it can.

  • @ThePharphis
    @ThePharphis 5 років тому

    I just watched the original earlier!
    Comments were broken, though.
    Anyway glad to see it re-uploaded so more people see it

  • @pingpong607
    @pingpong607 5 років тому +22

    Hopefully the vid does better this time around without all that UA-cam Premiere stuff.

  • @DaRat100
    @DaRat100 3 роки тому +6

    I honestly hate that people take things so over the top like there's way more important things to worry about instead of a guy making Nazi jokes.

  • @emperorsascharoni9577
    @emperorsascharoni9577 3 роки тому +1

    The dude needed you as his lawyer.

  • @dos.factotum
    @dos.factotum 3 роки тому

    this just showed up in my recommended again, miss you lots pal. Hope you're having a fulfilling life.

  • @Fester90
    @Fester90 3 роки тому +7

    Black humor is like legs. Not everyone has them

  • @Korajiyo
    @Korajiyo 5 років тому +6

    Class action lawsuit against that sheriff for his grossly offensive decision? Let's go UA-cam comments section.

  • @Charlotte4Short
    @Charlotte4Short 5 років тому

    I know I watched this before. But I highly support your work so I'm going to watch it fully three times more.

  • @Brite__
    @Brite__ 5 років тому

    Such a shame that just by the nature of this being a re-upload, it still won't get as many views. It's a very good argument.

  • @QueenOfPugs
    @QueenOfPugs 3 роки тому +17

    See, I’m Jewish, and I find this hilarious

    • @kapjoteh
      @kapjoteh 3 роки тому +5

      Pug Lover you’re also a pug lover

    • @QueenOfPugs
      @QueenOfPugs 3 роки тому +3

      Allen Rubin that is true

  • @catfood1788
    @catfood1788 3 роки тому +3

    This is disgusting that poor man went to court for 2 years because of that horrible racist dog

  • @beardedshuckle5220
    @beardedshuckle5220 2 роки тому

    Oh man, out of everything I’ve seen from Counterpoint lately this is the reason I sub. Dank and some big band jazz XD

  • @cardiobroker
    @cardiobroker 3 роки тому +1

    I had heard about the video for years but hadn’t actually seen it. It’s so much funnier than I imagined. lol.

  • @blaster1567
    @blaster1567 5 років тому +3

    this guy should be a lawyer

  • @luka_8
    @luka_8 5 років тому +8

    So, I'm German. And I laughed my ass off at the video of the dog. Yes, it was offensive. But damn, since when can't we make jokes about offensive stuff?
    What happened is now mor than 50 years ago and, yes, while nazis exist today still, is it this bad?
    Jeez people need to take the sticks outta their asses

  • @WhompingWalrus
    @WhompingWalrus 4 роки тому +1

    Oh okay, so the justice system deliberates on subjective matters, unless someone says that a subjective matter is objective in their opinion, then _they_ get to be both judge and jury.

  • @zer0nen0ne78
    @zer0nen0ne78 5 років тому

    Watched the original, watched again to support Counter Arguments. Always enjoy your work, keep it up!

  • @Brian-hg3gt
    @Brian-hg3gt 4 роки тому +7

    7:20 lol arrested a Jewish director for making a antiSemitic film 😂

    • @JacobRy
      @JacobRy 3 роки тому

      Jews can be antisemitic technically

    • @pyrosnappy7641
      @pyrosnappy7641 3 роки тому

      @@JacobRy well literally anyone can, no one is automatically safe from being antisemitic

    • @maxwellflocker3050
      @maxwellflocker3050 3 роки тому

      @@pyrosnappy7641 yes i would choose to be jewish just to hate jews

    • @pyrosnappy7641
      @pyrosnappy7641 3 роки тому

      @@maxwellflocker3050 well it's the same concept as white girls hating the white race for muh white privilege

  • @orande9916
    @orande9916 5 років тому +19

    I will rewatch and like this video that I’ve already seen just to support you. I feel special I deserve a cookie.
    🍪 ahh that’s better

  • @mangcrow5738
    @mangcrow5738 5 років тому +2

    You would be a good lawyer if you aren't already.

  • @bdog-it4701
    @bdog-it4701 5 років тому +2

    What about the fact that the police went out of their way to find someone offended by it; ie: they took it to the local synagogue and asked them if they were offended...

  • @johnnybgoodeish
    @johnnybgoodeish 5 років тому +8

    My feelings are hurt!
    Answer: so what's your point?

    • @byronobrien3121
      @byronobrien3121 3 роки тому

      Civilised society: my feelings are hurt. Excuse me but my intention was only to jest.

  • @dragonslayer101
    @dragonslayer101 3 роки тому +4

    Honestly i thought this video was going to be about the precautions of over selective-breeding in pugs....
    But this is good too.

  • @distorted_heavy
    @distorted_heavy 3 роки тому +2

    Going out in style was the only proper way to end the video

  • @nunitoism
    @nunitoism 5 років тому

    Dude this content is really good. Good job. Subscribed.

  • @jackmurphy7104
    @jackmurphy7104 3 роки тому +5

    When i clicked on this video i was expecting a whole bunch of racist jokes lol

  • @hellpwnage6665
    @hellpwnage6665 5 років тому +13

    It would be funny if furries dressed up in a pug fursuit and imitated the video.

  • @theprogrammer32
    @theprogrammer32 5 років тому

    For those wondering about the re-upload: he took the original down because it was a "premier" not a normal video, he explained in his last video (about premiers)

  • @PockASqueeno
    @PockASqueeno 4 роки тому +1

    Where do you find all the amazing music you use for your videos? I’ve never heard a single video with boring or annoying background music.

  • @nathanmaxon4692
    @nathanmaxon4692 5 років тому +6

    AH. You missed the final comment. Context does not matter. Obviously.

  • @dontforgettolike7127
    @dontforgettolike7127 3 роки тому +3

    This is offensive. Anne frankly, he should be in jail.

    • @smellsnice9735
      @smellsnice9735 3 роки тому

      Do you understand satire you troglodyte.

    • @dontforgettolike7127
      @dontforgettolike7127 3 роки тому +2

      SmellsNice do you know who Anne frank is you smug asshole?

  • @orange7810
    @orange7810 2 роки тому +1

    That guy's lawyer is probably nonexistant.

  • @REDandBLUEandORANGE
    @REDandBLUEandORANGE 5 років тому +2

    Man I hope that judge has trouble sleeping at night

  • @evaahh9584
    @evaahh9584 5 років тому +5

    I should have a death sentence from me and my schoolmates lol.
    Chemistry practical where we use a solution and some acid to see until a cross disappears? My suggestion: for our final solution we should replace the x with a Star of David
    That’s just the tip of the iceberg

  • @parallel4
    @parallel4 5 років тому +3

    You're preaching to the choir fam. I haven't met anyone (including people who are very much leftists) who believes Mr Dankula should've been arrested; some think his video was bad or untasteful, but nobody thinks he should be arrested other than the people convicting him (who are just a very small group of people, who are not members of the general public).
    Also, just because something is comedic in nature, doesn't mean it's not bigoted. I don't believe the author of the video holds anti-Semitic views nor did he create the video with anti-Semitic intentions, but just as a general statement: comedy can be bigoted and spread bigoted ideas. If Jewish people are the butt of your joke and the punchline boils down to "Jews bad", then that would be a bigoted joke, despite it being with comedic intentions. This does not apply to Dankula's video, but "it has comedic intentions" is not a valid argument against "this video is offensive/harmful/bigoted"; they are not mutually exclusive.

    • @note4note804
      @note4note804 5 років тому

      The argument wasn't that bigotry and comedy are mutually exclusive, is was that offense and comedy are equally subjective and that something that has comedic intent cannot be "self evident bigotry". The rest of the video shows the intent is not bigoted, not because it is funny, but because it explains that the joke's subject is not that the holocaust was funny.

  • @Blekk101
    @Blekk101 5 років тому +1

    If I ever get into a legal battle, I want you to be my lawyer.

  • @mayolicious69
    @mayolicious69 4 роки тому +2

    I really want to know who his lawyer was, so I can avoid him like the plague

  • @EWKification
    @EWKification 5 років тому +3

    2 things come to mind:
    1) It's sad that you even have to explain this, as it's so obvious it was a joke.
    2) While losing 800 pounds, perhaps Count Dankula is now famous."
    Uh, also I may not be able to look at those pugs the same after this.

    • @theadamsharland
      @theadamsharland 5 років тому +1

      Fame isn't a good thing when it makes you unemployable

    • @dutchdykefinger
      @dutchdykefinger 5 років тому

      i would go for "notorious" :)

  • @noahbodycares3005
    @noahbodycares3005 5 років тому +14

    I hate this premier feature. I can’t even watch the video for another day even though it’s finished?
    (Let’s make all the comments about the premier feature again to troll Counter Points)

    • @zyaicob
      @zyaicob 5 років тому

      @@jatsko3113 i second this motion

  • @ToastGreeting
    @ToastGreeting 3 роки тому +1

    Imagine being a judge and you see some guy come in and he's known as "Count Dankula ", that would be epic

  • @glenniesewell8054
    @glenniesewell8054 5 років тому

    Well done. I already agreed that this was a punch at humor. I am just glad you put it to logical thought. Thank you, kindly.

  • @khdayskh1314
    @khdayskh1314 5 років тому +8

    Congrats on the reupload \o/ may your message spread wide and far with showers of woke.
    Ok I'll stop being cringe

  • @Lis-ard
    @Lis-ard 5 років тому +6

    im not a nazi, but
    that video is hilarious and I love it

  • @yuniq9gaming930
    @yuniq9gaming930 3 роки тому

    Good work, sir...
    Way to nerd it out.

  • @austinbyrd4164
    @austinbyrd4164 3 роки тому +2

    "A mere attempt at humor"
    and a damn successful one at that 😂

  • @user-cu6ii3gv1x
    @user-cu6ii3gv1x 5 років тому +19

    I mean Dankula did join UKIP following all this. That was pretty disappointing. But that doesn't make his pug video anti semitic

    • @dylancope
      @dylancope 5 років тому +6

      Yikes, I didn't know he did that. It's a shame but it certainly doesn't change anything.

    • @ochentaycincoalbricias
      @ochentaycincoalbricias 5 років тому +18

      Freedom of speech applies to everyone, so...

    • @canaryimpulse989
      @canaryimpulse989 5 років тому +37

      He's extremely pro free speech. If you watch his content on his channel you'll see he's very consistent on that. He thinks that UKIP for all their faults are the only UK party that's pro free speech, and to be honest, I kind of agree.

    • @SinnersBFree
      @SinnersBFree 5 років тому +17

      UKIP is the least anti semantic party in the UK. Also it’s probably fair to say he joined UKIP BECAUSE of all this.

    • @user-cu6ii3gv1x
      @user-cu6ii3gv1x 5 років тому +5

      @@canaryimpulse989 he's also a fan of Donald Trump. Maybe he's just playing devil's advocate when he supports him but when I think Trump I don't think free speech. We have free speech despite Trump's best efforts to paint the press as an enemy of the state.

  • @Outplayedqt
    @Outplayedqt 5 років тому +4

    Why upload this again?

    • @MrPatters
      @MrPatters 5 років тому +9

      He explains here: ua-cam.com/video/xz-g9Aeu4Vg/v-deo.html

    • @khdayskh1314
      @khdayskh1314 5 років тому

      Watch his previous video

    • @Jesse0Lucas
      @Jesse0Lucas 5 років тому

      UA-cam premier fucked it up, check the vid before this one for more info

  • @les8865
    @les8865 5 років тому +1

    Awesome as usual. Keep it up!

  • @javiarcamaro7178
    @javiarcamaro7178 4 роки тому +1

    At the end, even the security gaurds were cheering our big beard mesiah. You do you, you magnificent creature u.