Ail/Seijūrō Ginga/Alan Granger Voice Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
  • Voices:
    Japanese:
    Hikaru Midorikawa (first anime)
    English:
    Vince Corazza [credited as "Vincent Corazza"] (DiC)
    Brian Beacock (Viz)

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @billylilly1251
    @billylilly1251 8 років тому +40

    I Love Vince Corazza's voice

    • @nangbaby
      @nangbaby 8 років тому +8

      billy lilly Agreed. He gives Alan a mature vibe, while the other actor makes Ail seem like a generic young man. Consequently, there it's hard to buy any romantic tension between any of the characters his character is involved with.

  • @Futurestarra
    @Futurestarra 9 років тому +46

    Damn, Hikaru Midorikawa has been in the voice acting game for a LONG time.
    I genuinely love all his voice actors. Though I do agree with another commenter, Vince is best heard as Darien (Mamoru). Still has a nice voice to listen to in both languages.

    • @xgray2012
      @xgray2012 6 років тому +7

      Futurestarra I liked Vincent a lot better as Tuxedo Mask in the old English dub of Sailor Moon than as the voice of Ail in the old English dub.

    • @RecoveringChristian
      @RecoveringChristian 4 роки тому

      How??? He was so stilted and dry and unnatural as tuxedo mask. You could tell he was just regurgitating lines half heartedly off the terribly translated script. In DIC as Allan he was soo natural and fluid, brooding and silly and had conviction. But yall like the awkward uninspired line deilvery more? Is the sky green, is grass purple???

    • @crusaderbowserjr3071
      @crusaderbowserjr3071 3 роки тому

      Hiraku Midorikawa was the voice of Android 16 in Dragon Ball Z, Fiore in Sailor Moon R Movie and Hero Hunter in One Punch Man.

    • @adamfleming2186
      @adamfleming2186 2 роки тому

      And as Carlos Oliveira in the original Resident Evil 3

    • @drixg555
      @drixg555 2 роки тому

      The voice of Gridman.

  • @quangduy9x
    @quangduy9x 8 років тому +27

    lol the 2 english voice actors for Alan/Ali are both good-looking 😆😆😆

  • @jonathanwashington6083
    @jonathanwashington6083 6 років тому +13

    Ok. I'LL say it...
    Vince Corazza is a total hunkasaurus!

    • @nekusakura6748
      @nekusakura6748 2 роки тому

      I'm sure his wife would agree with you.
      Lucky Woman...

  • @SnowWolfAlpha
    @SnowWolfAlpha 9 років тому +36

    I think Brian's won this one. I can only imagine Vince as Darien.

  • @liquidcatt8247
    @liquidcatt8247 6 років тому +22

    Brian can voice anyone from a black and white robot bear to a handsome green skinned alien

    • @diaquallo
      @diaquallo 6 місяців тому

      Upupupupupupu~

  • @KyloRen4238
    @KyloRen4238 2 роки тому +4

    Happy Birthday Brian Beacook. UR awesome dude. I Love Boruto Naruto Next Generations, Naruto Shippuden, Sailor Moon Eternal, Sword Art Online 3 Alicization, Bleach and Toradora! Awesome, u were. I respect and support u man!!! I love u, dude! Your a legend. May the Peace be with u Chojouro, Helios, Koji Haruta and Yumichika Ayasegawa. From Harlingen Texas. March 29, 1966
    March 29, 2022 through March 29, 3022

  • @saintfighteraqua
    @saintfighteraqua 3 роки тому +8

    They are all so good, especially Hikaru. In English, I think Vince just sounds more iconic.

  • @nekusakura6748
    @nekusakura6748 4 роки тому +13

    I'd really like to see Brian Beacock voice more Bishounen characters like Ail. He really surprised me in the role.

    • @TroublesomeSlateTruck
      @TroublesomeSlateTruck 2 роки тому

      4:30-4:31 Ohhhh, Annnnn! No!
      4:36-4:37 Ann! Don’t Leave Me!
      7:08-7:09 (Gasps In Horror) An!!!!!!! An? An!
      7:16-7:17 An, I Don’t Wanna Lose You! AN!!!!!!!!

    • @nekusakura6748
      @nekusakura6748 2 роки тому

      @Troublesome Slate Truck 1516 Brian really nailed those Emotional Cries at Ann's temporary Death.

  • @xXDOREMIVSSONICXx
    @xXDOREMIVSSONICXx 8 років тому +19

    Brian Beacock is Takato from Digimon Tamers.

  • @xgray2012
    @xgray2012 6 років тому +5

    Good ol' Midorikawa Hikaru-san!! You really need to make a comeback to the voice acting game.

  • @eymed2023
    @eymed2023 3 роки тому +6

    Not gonna lie, those WERE the best episodes of Sailor Moon in my opinion. (Of seasons 1 and 2 at least).
    Seasons 1 and 2 were VERY messed.
    But the cardians arc was consistently good from beggining to end.
    Not to mention, the villains had secret identities too, and they got to bounce off the scouts' personalities. That made them MUCH more fun than any other villain in those seasons.

    • @L33TRedNinja
      @L33TRedNinja 2 роки тому +3

      Mmm, those ARE good points… 🤔

    • @donnaquixote7538
      @donnaquixote7538 Рік тому +2

      At first I didn't know that the whole Ail and An subplot was just a filler plot and was really disappointed when the characters just forgot about them...

  • @Vfox-xn5zx
    @Vfox-xn5zx 4 роки тому +2

    Ail is one of my anime husbands and the voice I fell in love with was Brian Beacock thank you I have the actors name now

  • @蟹えびね
    @蟹えびね 6 років тому +8

    Ail's voice of Brian Beacock is really nice.

  • @sugarcxne1910
    @sugarcxne1910 7 років тому +8

    I like Brian's best, damn he plays the flute well.

  • @vampireunicorn2271
    @vampireunicorn2271 6 років тому +13

    While I do think Vince Corazza is best out of the DiC/Cloverway Tuxedo Masks, I'm not really buying him as Ail - he sounds like he needs a glass of water badly, he sounds too rough. Hikaru and Brian were far better.

    • @RecoveringChristian
      @RecoveringChristian 4 роки тому

      I've noticed, if you don't have a generic, conventionally bland accent neutral nebraskan 2010's voice, any deviation from this, purists label you as smoking 64 packs a day, old grandma voice, or needing a glass of water. You have VERY little tolerance for anything outside that narrow construct.
      How is he better as tux, if he has the SAME supposedly dry parched voice?

  • @CarloNassar
    @CarloNassar 7 років тому +10

    FUN FACT:
    Brian also did Takato in Digimon.

  • @KyloRen4238
    @KyloRen4238 2 роки тому +3

    Brian Beacook
    Shows & Movie & Games
    1. Chojuro, Sakon and Ukon, Yashamaru, Hoichi, Shibuki, Shu, Santa Yamanaka, Mizura, Zetsu, Hotarubi - Boruto Naruto Next Generations, Naruto Shippuden, 8 Boruto Naruto The Movie, Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations, Revolution, 3, 4 2005 - 2008 - 2010 - 2012 - 2013 - 2014 - 2016 - 2018 - 2019 - 2025
    2. Ail/Seijuro Ginga, Pegasus/Helios - Sailor Moon R, Super S, Eternal 2015 - 2019 - 2021
    3. Takeru Higa - Sword Art Online 3 Alicization War Of Underworld 2019 - 2020 - 2021
    4. Yumichika Ayasegawa - Bleach 2006 - 2014
    5. Koji Haruta - Toradora! 2014
    6. Takato Matsuda - Digimon Tamers 2001 - 2002

  • @kanrara11
    @kanrara11 4 роки тому +3

    Hikaru so handsome

  • @donnaquixote7538
    @donnaquixote7538 Рік тому +1

    Although this is besides the point, I wonder why they are always having hot chocolate in the Dic/Cloverway dub and never coffee or tea. 🤔

  • @直子藤本-e8f
    @直子藤本-e8f 8 місяців тому +1

    個人緑川光かっこい大好き❤

  • @BailcuryG27
    @BailcuryG27 6 років тому +5

    My Top 2 Ali’s English Voice Actors
    1. Brian Beacock
    2. Vince Corazza

  • @mikeAustinstonecold
    @mikeAustinstonecold 8 років тому +7

    Fei fong wong male japanese voice (xenogears)

  • @chilvari
    @chilvari 9 років тому +9

    Japanese voice actors sound the same to me (for all Anime). Maybe because Japanese isn't my native language so I can't tell the difference. But I do find that the villains seem to stand out better than all the other characters. I feel like their persona & demeanor is better emphasized even though all the characters sound the same. I dunno how else to explain it. Somehow, the monotonous voice acting seems to work for the villains.

  • @StevenLeeSan
    @StevenLeeSan 4 роки тому

    Who would've thought that before he voiced for Marth, he roled as such handsome devil.

  • @nateadams9517
    @nateadams9517 6 років тому +1

    Brian Beacock. I actually thought he was voiced by Dee Bradley Baker at first

  • @redgehugo7162
    @redgehugo7162 6 років тому +2

    Vince Corozza is Carlos in re3

  • @L33TRedNinja
    @L33TRedNinja 7 років тому +1

    That moment when you realize Hikaru-san also played Akihiko... 🤣

  • @藤本菜々美-u7v
    @藤本菜々美-u7v Рік тому

    このシーン個人かっこいい素敵❤

  • @johnnyb9591
    @johnnyb9591 9 років тому +24

    Brian wins this one. Vinces voice just does not go well with

    • @johnnyb9591
      @johnnyb9591 8 років тому +8

      I thought Vince as Tuexdo Mask was one of Dics better casting Descions,but Robbie Daymond is doing a good job

    • @RecoveringChristian
      @RecoveringChristian 6 років тому +3

      Vince as tuxedo mask was a down grade, he was soo self aware, not always immersed (not DIC) Vince as Alan was great, he brought out that characters humanity (DIC). VIZ is blah, he sounds like a dweeb, but it was decent, actually pretty good.

    • @icekokoro2708
      @icekokoro2708 5 років тому

      RecoveringChristian what is it with you saying that the last 17 episodes of R were not by DiC? Why? Because they weren’t part of the initial run? Because some of the voices were different?

    • @RecoveringChristian
      @RecoveringChristian 4 роки тому

      @@icekokoro2708 yes. First 65 episodes. After that scene on the bridge with the Wyrd Sisters, there was a long hiatus. When it finally came back, everything was off, the magic was gone, Tracy and Roland(melvin) were no longer the voice directors. Paved the way for cloverway.
      I understand from the perspective of younger purists who weren't there, it's all the same to them. To them, they are all watching this at once now and time and context doesn't matter. I also understand, to them, if the entire VIZ cast and voice directors and script writers were fired, came back years later, it was still be considered viz to them, no matter how bad and far removed it was from how viz used to be. Vis a vis writers strike of 2008 that killed off dozens of tv shows. For the sake of purists bashing dic, they like to lump it all together, which includes the cloverway dub, done by a different team in a different decade.

  • @golby260
    @golby260 6 років тому

    Isn’t Midorikawa Heero from Gundam Wing? Surprised no one’s noted this :)

  • @Terestrasz
    @Terestrasz 7 місяців тому

    awwww you didn't include OH NO NOT THE DUCKS"? :(

  • @maddielovelee
    @maddielovelee 6 років тому +3

    Vince all the way. When I heard the viz dub of him i so badly wanted to watch the other just bc of this voice change. His voice reminds me of zuko kinda and that's like the best voice ever lol

  • @yumikumi2
    @yumikumi2 8 років тому +9

    I'm sorry but I can't take surfer voice seriously.

  • @zinzolin14
    @zinzolin14 4 роки тому

    Hmmm, his voice reminds me of Brother One from Drakengard 3. I love that sweet whispy tone of his voice 😁

  • @yumikumi2
    @yumikumi2 8 років тому +13

    viz wins this one.

  • @ricofresh22
    @ricofresh22 3 роки тому +1

    I thought he sounded too much like darien lol

    • @official_nerd4917
      @official_nerd4917 3 роки тому +4

      Which is funny cause he actually went on to voicing him later on

    • @nekusakura6748
      @nekusakura6748 2 роки тому +1

      @@official_nerd4917 And would be a much better fit in that role.

  • @gibbs615
    @gibbs615 8 місяців тому +2

    2:24 Vince was the best english dub voice of Alan.

  • @azazelc8079
    @azazelc8079 4 роки тому +1

    Out of the english ones, this is one I don't really have a preference for. I really don't care for The Doom Tree arc at all actually.

    • @magicalcat-girl5272
      @magicalcat-girl5272 Рік тому +1

      Yeah, I also really didn't like the doom tree arc of sailor moon r at all to be honest. It's my least favorite arc of season two and it was just annoying too.

  • @bbbbbb6999
    @bbbbbb6999 4 роки тому

    Whaligoe tell me

  • @magicalcat-girl5272
    @magicalcat-girl5272 Рік тому

    All of the voices for ail/alan were good, but my favorite voice actor for ail/alan is vince from the dic dub version of sailor moon. Brain was okay as ail/alan in the viz dub of sailor moon. I really didn't like the doom tree arc of sailor moon r at all to be honest.

  • @lilacfairy.
    @lilacfairy. 5 років тому +5

    Sorry I prefer DiC voices better than Viz. Viz's voices doesn't click well enough like DiC's.

    • @Blossom44100
      @Blossom44100 4 роки тому +6

      Agreed! Sure they censored some of the storyline, but their adaption made it feel like magic exists! Their Sailor Moon was so magical!

    • @lilacfairy.
      @lilacfairy. 4 роки тому +3

      @@Blossom44100 And the their music brings out the feelings and magical moments 💗🌙.

    • @Blossom44100
      @Blossom44100 4 роки тому +2

      @@lilacfairy. Agreed :') Their dub amplifies the fun in believing in magic :')

  • @peachygoogles6359
    @peachygoogles6359 4 роки тому +1

    The agave plant 🌱 in seasonal form. Many textures, many smells, many moons. Many uses. Powerful properties it possesses. Yerbah Mala Nunca Muere. (Mala means Buenísima!) when used to attack another critter, not used well. Not a good word to use may be a mistake or heard tel by another.

  • @bbbbbb6999
    @bbbbbb6999 4 роки тому

    FAnd then Nana