xiang liu / you don't know the hell i've been through (lost you forever fmv)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 61

  • @elejah4011
    @elejah4011 Рік тому +59

    His life is so sad he was born alone,ends up as a slave to fighting ring, escapes yet hides in the cold north for a century, then to repay a kindness becomes a general in a war that has nothing to do with him, in the end hiding and denying one of the few people he loved😢

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому +12

      just tragedy from the moment he was born with a few moments of joy for hundred of years 😭

    • @kennpanuncial6703
      @kennpanuncial6703 Рік тому +20

      Yes, he was alone. He has no parents, people is shit scared of him, no friends. But the army came to him differently. He can't abandon them. He actually cares for them A LOT. In the book, he told XY this "I've watched my comrades die, soldiers who used to talk and drink with me, we helped each other. And now, I'm still here. I've lost count about how many bodies I've buried" with a bittersweet smile. Yet in the end he still dies alone with so much exhaustion , the bearing responsibility he has, his great love for XY. The fact that he has no one yet he gave everything to XY. XL is just a character that's just so much and more. You can't help but understand his reasons. T.T

    • @Kiki-en9vm
      @Kiki-en9vm Рік тому +3

      This is why it made me mad realising what he is planning to do, why go extreme,why this believe that a soldier must die on the battle field to be worthy.zhang liu never give himself a chance even when the world didn't give him chance, he had the right and power to take the best like everyone from the world , live and survive like everyone,but he chose this crappy soldiers code,and his adopted father's believes that had nothingvto do with him,part of his failure comes from him too,xiao yao tried to talk him out of it but he refused.

    • @Kiki-en9vm
      @Kiki-en9vm Рік тому +3

      No matter his reason, he xhould have given himself a chance, at survival yet he refused it,even if he didn't end up with yao, they should have been great friends,no one had ever accepted him like yao,and from yao,he can come to meet more friends,but he was so consumed with soldiers code that he sees surviving when his brothers in arms didn't survive as a sinnwhich I find so unfair to himsrlf,there is also a saying that one leaves when is tough to be alive to fight another day.i also blame the writer,who made him die just like that,eith no chances of return,and also jing character too,the writer pure all the world sufferings on him,he went through he'll,I can't get it.

    • @elejah4011
      @elejah4011 Рік тому +2

      @Kiki-en9vm that is just his personality and jing's character was weak and dumb im sorry. I think the author wrote exactly what she wanted to write. A sad story😁 nor everything needs happy ending

  • @elejah4011
    @elejah4011 Рік тому +22

    This is crazy good!! The people he spends years of his life helping discriminate against him but he helps them reach their goals, finds a cure for their illnesses and gets them their homeland back!!! All he had to do was be the general but he was more than that!

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому +4

      exactly what i wanted to show! glad it can be seen from the video

    • @kennpanuncial6703
      @kennpanuncial6703 Рік тому +4

      True but he actually has comrades who used to drink with him but they all died and he was the one who buried them. :(

  • @angeladelmar9362
    @angeladelmar9362 Рік тому +3

    That's why the character of Xiang Lu deserves it's own solo drama!!! ❤😂Love from the Philippines

  • @xinhualiao2883
    @xinhualiao2883 Рік тому +16

    Xiang liu is the only reason I keep watching this drama

    • @user_ishi_17
      @user_ishi_17 Рік тому

      Right if this is going to be sad ending for them I am not gonna continue watching the drama

    • @HalimaSadia3969
      @HalimaSadia3969 Рік тому

      Me too

    • @HayleyEvers
      @HayleyEvers 5 місяців тому

      S2 is boring me already. If he is not end game I think alot of viewers will hit the roof .

  • @Marguerite-wu3nw
    @Marguerite-wu3nw Рік тому +19

    Even if I understand why she loves Jing, part of me wants to see Xiao Yao and Xiang Liu together.
    Alas, both are too much alike and not ready to abundant their missions.

  • @sharonali3809
    @sharonali3809 Рік тому +15

    Thanks for showing us Xiang Liu. It breaks us and soothes us all at once

  • @Marguerite-wu3nw
    @Marguerite-wu3nw Рік тому +11

    Meeting Xiao Yao seemed to change slowly Xiang Liu somehow. The cold-blooded snake started to feel something for the first time in his difficult life. He kind of wanted her to be around... but on his terms.
    Unfortunately, they had a bad start, with him being rough too many times !!!
    She had to use her communication skill to stay alive, so when they met again, her being a Princess and him being FFB,
    she could not see his love and longing for her.
    XL had one chance though after saving her from death.
    Unfortunately, he chose not to be around when she opened her eyes for the first time after 37 years.
    I like your edits.
    I am your new subscriber!!

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому

      well said and thank you!

    • @z-n2000
      @z-n2000 Рік тому

      Xiao yao loves xiang liu too

    • @kennpanuncial6703
      @kennpanuncial6703 Рік тому +2

      It's like the cold-blooded one was never the cold-blooded one. But the most sensitive one, XL is not human, he lived in the world long enough that his ruthlessness became his facade. I kind of like how the author played his character as dangerous, and cold but turned out to be the most sensitive logical yet fragile type. He's a character that you'd wish he'd be a little selfish and greedy through and through yet he always chooses the best decisions even if it means he'll walk on it alone. :) The man has such a big heart!

  • @ARLG999
    @ARLG999 Рік тому +5

    Every frame where xl is a piece if art ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ 🤗

  • @bunnyblue3082
    @bunnyblue3082 Рік тому +2

    Heartwrenching! Wonderful edit again. I really petition for episodes of xiang liu and xiao yao interactions! I need more of them together. Even if ultimately they have a sad ending. Some of the most beautiful love stories are sad IMHO.

  • @IzzieSabrina143
    @IzzieSabrina143 5 місяців тому

    I just finished watching season 2 ending,I’m literally in tears!!! Xiang Lu definitely deserved a better ending!!!!!! Watching his final scene was heartbreaking to watch💔💔💔💔

  • @laurelmorris198
    @laurelmorris198 Рік тому +9

    This is such a tragedy..I know what's coming and
    I don't want to see it. But I can't stop watching this drama...hoping, stupidly that someone has had mercy on us and changed the ending.....

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому +2

      same here, i curse the day i started it but i'm happy i did because it's amazing at the same time

    • @sharonali3809
      @sharonali3809 Рік тому +3

      I would like a different ending but I'm not holding out much hope for that. There are pics of him on the battlefield.

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому +1

      @@sharonali3809 maybe we get special eps or we can just write fanfiction 😭

    • @sharonali3809
      @sharonali3809 Рік тому +3

      @@thepenguin1024 a tempting thought and although I am quite creative, I'm a failure at chinese fan fiction. I have to wait on some inspired soul to pen an alternative ending. Although I did see a fanfiction video where XY and XL were a married couple. It was cute.

    • @sa_manda
      @sa_manda Рік тому +4

      If any, i'm quite satisfied that i'm sharing the same feeling with many people. Most of us thinks Xiang Liu is the best guy but the drama just won't make that happen. I'm becoming an idiot for still hoping that they might change the ending😩

  • @hanaharu5447
    @hanaharu5447 Рік тому +1

    great , thanks you and the lyrics of the music are so perfect ❤

  • @sa_manda
    @sa_manda Рік тому +4

    Darn novel, Xiang Liu doesn't deserve all these heartbreaks😭 why does he have to be hurt all the time? Been so long since i got engrossed in a drama but all i'm feeling is heartbreak for Xiang Liu's character😩💔

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому +2

      i haven't liked a cdrama this much since the untamed, word of honor and love between fairy and devil and all i know is pain

    • @sa_manda
      @sa_manda Рік тому

      @@thepenguin1024 aaaa saaaame. Finally found a watch-worthy drama after a long time and it just happened to be a sad one😩😩

    • @sa_manda
      @sa_manda Рік тому

      @@thepenguin1024 aaaa saaaame. Finally found a watch-worthy drama after a long time and it just happened to be a sad one😩😩

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому

      @@sa_manda we can never win, can we

  • @liezeloktober-lm8hw
    @liezeloktober-lm8hw Рік тому

    Thank you for all of your great edits of Xiangliu and Xiaoyao💗❤️💕

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому

      no problem, i have to get them out of my system with editing so why not share ❤️

  • @Samanta-369-x8g
    @Samanta-369-x8g Рік тому +2

    Дуже гарний кліп. А Тань Дзінь Ци красавчик. Дякую.💛💙💖

  • @ARLG999
    @ARLG999 Рік тому +4

    Lost you forever is not a love story it is tragedy it is the tale of xiang liu sad life and his tragic death😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

    • @hanaharu5447
      @hanaharu5447 Рік тому

      Do you know the end ? Not a happy end for Xiang Liu in the book?

  • @brittneysanders4027
    @brittneysanders4027 Рік тому

    Love him Xiang liu

  • @joleeneRnaylor
    @joleeneRnaylor Рік тому +1

    I don't get how anyone could NOT like his character😮

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому

      me too, you've got to have 0 thinking abilities to not see how interesting he is

    • @HayleyEvers
      @HayleyEvers 5 місяців тому

      I love his character!

  • @khanla6944
    @khanla6944 Рік тому +2

    You don't Stupidly have to Treat him soo bad.. U were writer or director.. At least give him a Happy ending After enduring hell lot of Bad things 😢

  • @xiaozhan-go9ix
    @xiaozhan-go9ix Рік тому

    tan jianci love you forever 😍🥰

  • @dhruti6270
    @dhruti6270 Рік тому +1

    It's looks full sad

    • @thepenguin1024
      @thepenguin1024  Рік тому

      he's one of the most tragic characters i've ever seen in my life actually

  • @nancywilliams9873
    @nancywilliams9873 Рік тому

    😮😮😮😢😢

  • @beingyourself7
    @beingyourself7 7 місяців тому

    Is it worth to watch it??

    • @iamtamadtv6018
      @iamtamadtv6018 6 місяців тому

      Yes it is but I feel so heartbroken for XIangliu. I fall inlove with his character but the author of the novel doesn't give him a happy ending maybe this is the reason why the title is "Lost you forever", XIangyao and XIanglui love story is complicated. Why I hate about the story, The author doesn't even let the female lead understand how much she is loved by this pure heart Demon. I stll choose to continue to watch this drama because of Xiangliu even if in the end I will cry.