Beethoven - Symphony No.9; Jarvi, DKB

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @erikfaringer9593
    @erikfaringer9593 2 роки тому +26

    Jarvi is that one conductor that literally reminds you who's masterpiece you are listening to

    • @neillbarrett5392
      @neillbarrett5392 7 місяців тому

      I would add John Eliot Gardiner to that list, too👍

  • @andrewb9974
    @andrewb9974 3 роки тому +29

    Bar none. Every ounce of energy from every single musician...single best performance of the 9th I've EVER heard.

    • @aladora3352
      @aladora3352 3 роки тому +2

      +1

    • @GermanGreetings
      @GermanGreetings 2 роки тому +1

      @@aladora3352 Let me guess: Böhm with Jessye Norman und Barenboim in der `Night of the Proms ?` I love them all !
      But which is your treasure ?

  • @lvbdevinelove2329
    @lvbdevinelove2329 2 роки тому +8

    I could watch Maestro Jarvi all day. Greetings from Hawaii 😊

  • @davidlis8756
    @davidlis8756 11 років тому +20

    The faces that the basso voce makes when he starts singing in the final movement are absolutely priceless. The way his eyes bug out and twists his face up. He looks like a cartoon character. Gotta love it!

    • @Thereal67P
      @Thereal67P 4 місяці тому

      It looks like he can't contain his excitement, and who could blame him?

  • @Music4Evert
    @Music4Evert 12 років тому +15

    The ferocity of the piccolo flute at the end of the symphony always amazes me. Such a small instrument with such a serious part. :)

  • @beethovennine
    @beethovennine 6 років тому +29

    Definitely one of the best renditions I've ever heard...SO many incredible details, but the way the choir sings "Bruder!" at 1:02:17 is absolutely stunning. What an understanding of Beethoven! Cheers!!!!

  • @davidlis8756
    @davidlis8756 11 років тому +36

    I absolutely love Maestro Jarvi. He's so charismatic, the way he smiles and gestures to the orchestra. He really has a passion for his work and the orchestra responds with just as much passion as well.

    • @Schlipperschlopper
      @Schlipperschlopper 7 років тому +8

      Greatest conductor alive today!

    • @Neldidellavittoria
      @Neldidellavittoria 6 років тому +1

      Such JOY on his face while conducting the ode to JOY!

    • @andymilsten9096
      @andymilsten9096 4 роки тому +2

      David Lis I got to meet him at NYP last January, it was the most awesome experience ever!

  • @johnroberts8413
    @johnroberts8413 5 місяців тому +1

    What I love about Maestro Jarvi is how obviously he feels the music. He is engaged at not only a musical level, but also emotionally. This flows into the orchestra and enables them to express the emotions written deep into the music!

  • @Danielz10001
    @Danielz10001 11 років тому +56

    It is the angriest Beethoven I've ever heard!
    Oh, the timpani...! Oh the lower strings..! I love this performance!!

    • @jmpriess
      @jmpriess 10 років тому +6

      I agree, Daniel, this is angry Beethoven, and I love this performance, but I advise you to seek out Furtwangler's 1942 performance with the Berlin Philharmonic - you might have to revise your judgement ...

    • @Danielz10001
      @Danielz10001 10 років тому +1

      Jonathan Priess Thank you. I'll listen.

    • @FJAC78
      @FJAC78 8 років тому +7

      Es bestial.El 20:08 por ejemplo. Todas las sinfonías de Järvi para mi, son brillanes, jóvenes, energéticas, ágiles, pasionales, enorme Järvi y la orquesta suena cristalina. Es para estudiarla en los conservatorios

    • @Neldidellavittoria
      @Neldidellavittoria 7 років тому +3

      FJAC78 - Totalmente de acuerdo. Esta versión es poderosa.
      Casualmente, estaba justo en ese pasaje cuando leí su comentario. :)

    • @javierhernandezmederos8177
      @javierhernandezmederos8177 7 років тому +2

      Daniel Machado Hoy por hoy junto a Myung Whung Chung es el mejor director Beethoveniano que existe. Enérgico, decidido, sublime.

  • @georgebyrne4334
    @georgebyrne4334 9 років тому +15

    I don't care how he spells his name. A wonderful, energetic performance. Maestro appears at one with the singers and musicians.

  • @douglascarter5943
    @douglascarter5943 10 років тому +25

    These Symphonies have now become my favorites and what I now call definitive.
    Bravo maestro Jarvi

  • @abundance6692
    @abundance6692 7 років тому +25

    A bit of trivia: Some may not know that all the great solo horn writing in the 3rd movement is scored for the 4th horn. In the orchestra for the original performance, the 4th horn was the only hornist who had a valve horn, which was in the earliest days of its existence back then. So Beethoven wrote the demanding horn solos in the slow movement for the 4th horn.

  • @1guillermarle
    @1guillermarle 10 років тому +14

    A stonian who was educated in California under Leonard Bernstein .A kammerphilarmonie which was founded by students in Frankfurt,Germany!What a combination. Listening to them is like watching clockwork in itself .Who was made for whom? And at the very center super Beethoven. The vibs of heaven.

  • @edrooney7836
    @edrooney7836 9 років тому +28

    An absolutely vibrant performance of this work - and Paavo seems to be enjoying it more than everyone else!

    • @mydogskips2
      @mydogskips2 7 років тому +4

      He always seems to be enjoying it more than everyone else.

    • @krysm1985
      @krysm1985 3 роки тому

      Nothing more exhilarating than performing something as magnificent as this piece.

  • @samye8571
    @samye8571 4 роки тому +5

    Why Beethoven can live forever. So many great musicians make it happen through their great love and great works. Generations after generations. Forever.

  • @jetblackstripes
    @jetblackstripes 4 роки тому +7

    Just another walk in the park ~ to The Sublime! This is truly amazing. I'm no expert, but the brisk nimble quality here, the patience, trust and feeling with which it is applied, the sense of discovery and wonder. I'm moved to tears. Music for the BEGINNING of The World. Joy!

  •  10 років тому +10

    HOLY SH***********T! the climax at 7:49 is from out of this world!!!!

  • @berniemiller2391
    @berniemiller2391 12 років тому +8

    great video. thanks for posting this series.
    at the end the maestro said bravo or danka to his orchestra and tears welled up
    as they so moved his soul, as was mine.
    Thank The Lord for Beethoven, an oasis is a cesspool of modern drek.

  •  10 років тому +8

    i really cant describe how unique this interpretation is....just....wow

  • @MaestroEspressivo
    @MaestroEspressivo Рік тому +3

    Simply superlative. The truly Beethovenesque tempi, the intensity, the brilliant direction from Järvi, and the ready-to-rumble attitude and capabilities of the orchestra are all stunning. There is so much to learn from Paavo about the craft and art of conducting, including providing the opportunity for the the players to step up and out, individually and collectively, in a performance that requires much of each and all. Absolutely love this.

  • @lj291261
    @lj291261 8 років тому +8

    Die Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen unter der Leitung von Paavo Järvi. Was für eine Präsentation! Wunderbar! Explosiv! Gigantisch! - Extraordinary. Beethoven would be happy. The best performance of Beethoven's masterpiece. The best symphony ever written.

  • @snidleywhiplash4791
    @snidleywhiplash4791 Рік тому +5

    who is that incredible first cellist? her passionate playing anchored the whole performance. Bravo!

  • @KatieTheAcademic
    @KatieTheAcademic 5 років тому +5

    Their movement 4 is just magnitficent! My ears are so satisfied.

  • @manikalani8226
    @manikalani8226 8 місяців тому +1

    Unique. Forever. Great Conductor, Fantastic Musicians, and Orchestra in the foremost climax that is imaginable. Jarvi completely understands and catches the core untouchable depth of Symphony No.9. He recalled Beethoven and flourished his music in our hearth. It is beyond
    of imagination. Thank you all.

  • @michaelvierling8484
    @michaelvierling8484 12 років тому +3

    Deutsche Welle, the German TV channel that broadcasts worldwide has been reporting about and promoting this orchestra and his conductor for years as excellent Beethoven interpreters. They indeed are. Thanks for uploading, and I see there is more.

  • @SteveMetcalf
    @SteveMetcalf 12 років тому +4

    I believe that this is the most well-informed and most interesting orchestra currently playing today.

  • @notaire2
    @notaire2 6 років тому +3

    Sehr spannende Aufführung dieses großartigen Meisterwerks mit perfekter Synchronisierung aller Instrumente und im ziemlich schnellen Tempo. Der Chor und die Solisten sind auch ausgezeichnet. Der geniale Dirigent leitet alles echt energisch!

  • @jazzporridge1506
    @jazzporridge1506 4 роки тому +4

    I absolutely adore this conductor.I mean come on to fuuch

  • @keitomusicstudio9395
    @keitomusicstudio9395 8 років тому +6

    素晴らしい演奏だ!ありがとうございます。サイコウダ

  • @saavedra4661
    @saavedra4661 6 років тому +5

    Great symphony and a great performance, bravo maestro Jarvi

  • @davidsiglin4860
    @davidsiglin4860 2 роки тому +3

    Exceptional. Amongst the best I have heard, possibly the best. Fabulous drive and energy.

  • @caitruane
    @caitruane 12 років тому +10

    Beethoven, his 9th symphony, and Paavo Jarvi--that what I call a Holy Trinity!

  • @idkh20
    @idkh20 11 років тому +2

    This is by far my favorite piece of music to listen to on the headphones while doing stuff. Riding my streetbike, working, jogging, riding the bus, playing video games, but most of all just walking in a crowded public area. It's so much fun listening to this.

  • @АлександрЧёрный-и9щ
    @АлександрЧёрный-и9щ 6 років тому +2

    МНЕ ТРУДНО ПРЕДСТАВИТЬ СЕБЕ, ЧТО МОЖЕТ БЫТЬ ИНОЕ ИСПОЛНЕНИЕ, ПРЕВОСХОДЯЩЕЕ ЭТО ! А ВЕДЬ ИСПОЛНЯЕМОЕ ПРОИЗВЕДЕНИЕ----ЭТО ВЕДЬ ДАЛЕКО НЕ ЧТО-НИБУДЬ........ СПАСИБО ВАМ, МАЭСТРО ЯРВИ , И ВАМ - ИСПОЛНИТЕЛЯМ-ОРКЕСТРАНТАМ !!! ДА БЛАГОСЛОВИТ ВАС БОГ НА СЧАСТЛИВУЮ ЖИЗНЬ ----СООТВЕТСТВЕННО УРОВНЮ ВАШЕГО ИСКУССТВА !

  • @javihernandezmederos8664
    @javihernandezmederos8664 8 років тому +9

    Gracias Järvi por elevar a Beethoven a un nuevo nivel. Un nivel donde el alma se alza por encima de las estrellas haciéndonos más insignificantes pero mas humanos

  • @Neldidellavittoria
    @Neldidellavittoria 7 років тому +17

    So powerful! Jarvi is to Beethoven's symphonies what Callas was to opera. Thanks for the upload.

    • @stevenhaynes7633
      @stevenhaynes7633 7 років тому

      Very nice, but let's not leave out Roger Norrington though

  • @fredsharp7419
    @fredsharp7419 3 роки тому +2

    I stand in awe of this work and this performance! Put this and the Sistine Chapel ceiling (and perhaps the Bach Mass in B minor) in a space capsule, and any extraterrestrials that found such a capsule would surely bow their heads in awe. Such originality -human voices with a symphonic orchestra, soloists and choir, singing at the very edge of human capability, wiring for horns and woodwind, especially bassoon, way ahead of its time - and all composed by a deaf man? Ridiculous! And the overall message of the work? The world needs it now more than ever.

  • @TheMahlerfan
    @TheMahlerfan 11 років тому +4

    But gangnam never comes back and is forgotten while Beethovens 9th will survive forever - just count all the views of all the different performances together, and remember all the performances since the year 1827 all over the world!

  • @hansputz7111
    @hansputz7111 2 роки тому +1

    Für mich, ein Laie zwar, aber die beste Interpretation...DANKE

  • @Sibethoven
    @Sibethoven 6 років тому +6

    Järvi and the DKBs beethoven is the best of all!

  • @bernardcorteziii585
    @bernardcorteziii585 8 років тому +6

    Magnificent Maestro & The Sinfonia !

  • @RayReegs
    @RayReegs 12 років тому +4

    The Ninth Symphony. Probably the greatest creation to to come from the mind of man.

  • @Amon2202
    @Amon2202 12 років тому +3

    Fantastic - beautifull filming as well.breath taking finale

  • @valentinvargas8219
    @valentinvargas8219 2 роки тому +1

    Most sublime has wrote as classical music of all times,a real máster work of a human mind ever!!!

  • @JonatasAdoM
    @JonatasAdoM 3 роки тому +3

    I thought I was in for another 9th symphony and I was surprised from the beginning.

  • @drjjpdc
    @drjjpdc 2 місяці тому

    When you listen to Paavo's 5th, you'll note he was one of the early conductors where you can hear the piccolos in the last movement the way LVB intended them to be heard.

  • @pierre-gabrieljobin9450
    @pierre-gabrieljobin9450 Рік тому

    Yes, the interpretation and rendition are outstanding, but note the beautiful photography, the mouvement of cameras, the close-ups, etc. Bravo au réalisateur et au chef Jarvi.

  • @andrewb9974
    @andrewb9974 3 роки тому +3

    Third mov...so difficult to express the lines at that tempo, but it's just.. done. Exceptional musicianship to accomplish that.

    • @GermanGreetings
      @GermanGreetings 2 роки тому +1

      The Bremer kept themselves small and focussed on this project... So even in fast parts, they listen to eachother - and Järvi puts his 70 steps from `silence and Maestoso`...
      Wow.
      I `saw` so many Chamber-Orchestras getting too fast `automatically`...
      In Beethovens case this is a totally different matter: Because no one gets so close to Ludwigs original Metrum, as Järvi... still being transparent !
      Without any haste, echoed in fine, Saqqara-like steps, to get all the dynamic out of these Symphonies... I would like to go on in German... but then this comment would become half a book :)

  • @saavedra4661
    @saavedra4661 8 років тому +10

    Food for your soul, magnific interpretation

  • @lolo-gw6gn
    @lolo-gw6gn 6 років тому +2

    Un Beethoven tempétueux et révolutionnaire comme il se doit ! Je pense que Paavo Järvi nous a donné une des plus belles intégrales de ces dernières années, voire l'intégrale des années 2000. La 9e est enfin menée comme elle doit l'être et le FInale est parfaitement tenu et réussi, pas comme nombre de versions qui s'essoufflent au dernier moment, même si elles sont dirigées par des grands noms de la musique. Ecoutez ce que Järvi nous donne à écouter dans l'Héroïque et vous comprendrez. A noter que le propre frère de Paavo Järvi, Kristjan, a enregistré la 9e aussi mais dans la réorchestration de Gustav Mahler. Intéressant mais pas autant que celle-ci. Génial, mais à écouter en SACD prioritairement si l'on peut...

  • @p--p3029
    @p--p3029 8 років тому +3

    Świetne, przystępne i żywiołowe wykonanie. Wręcz analityczne - czemu dodatkowo sprzyjała akustyka sali w Bremen. Bez zbędnego nadęcia jak np. u Karajana. Sporo ciekawych pomysłów artykulacyjnych. Dziewczę grające na kontrafagocie - bezcenne :)

    • @pulsatilla1214
      @pulsatilla1214 Рік тому

      Amrei Liebold;)
      ua-cam.com/video/Drn6bP9lFgg/v-deo.html

  • @javihernandezmederos8664
    @javihernandezmederos8664 8 років тому +3

    Järvi a dia de hoy junto a Whung Chung son los mejores intérpretes de Beethoven. Un Beethoven furioso y enérgico con tintes dulces y amables compaginados con un desorden en el finale, ese finale vibrante y unico en el mundo sinfónico. Ese caos que hablaba Fürtwangler, nos permite deleitarnos con una de las versiones referentes y emocionalmente más maduras, de la 9a Sinfonía del maestro de maestros Beethoven.

  • @kanchan109
    @kanchan109 7 років тому +6

    I wonder common orchestra cannot catch up with this speed,
    however. I like this original speed Beethoven wrote.

  • @matteopagliari
    @matteopagliari 5 років тому +2

    Great! Great! Great!!! Incredibile Paavo Järvi! 🌹

  • @fjames208
    @fjames208 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the uploaded...great performance..maravilloso 👏 👏 👏👍😁❤🙏

  • @mentariorudy
    @mentariorudy 10 років тому +1

    No he oido aun la version de Paavo Järvi, pero me restan solo dos minutos de ansiedad. Este hombre, ha escuchado desde niño y por mediacion de su padre y profesor, toda la musica del mundo. Es sin duda alguna, el gran director del futuro, pero todavia falta la resolucion del grandisimo Carlos Kleiber, espectacular, muy preciso en las entradas y cortes. No lo dudeis. ¡Va de camino!

  • @gerardovaldez7634
    @gerardovaldez7634 11 років тому +4

    oh my God this is.... too beautifullll

  • @gratiaDei777
    @gratiaDei777 11 років тому +2

    One of the best versions.

  • @halneufmille
    @halneufmille 2 роки тому +1

    Love the attention to detail everywhere, like 46:34

  • @Leon-Hardt
    @Leon-Hardt 8 років тому +4

    The best scherzzo: is the complete version, the timpanies's timbre (17:27) and timpaniest performance.

  • @jaimehketlachine
    @jaimehketlachine 6 років тому +2

    Merci mille fois pour le Upload.

  • @leonardolucchesifilmmusic
    @leonardolucchesifilmmusic 11 років тому +2

    Che Capolavoro!! Immenso!!

  • @wolframg1
    @wolframg1 7 років тому +1

    IT'S MAJESTIC MASTER JARVI!

  • @stringedandsaxy
    @stringedandsaxy 12 років тому +4

    the woman playing the bassoon is amazing haha @ 50:50

  • @lunionbladel
    @lunionbladel 10 років тому +8

    SUPER Jarvi

  • @SimarutLapisatepun
    @SimarutLapisatepun 8 років тому +7

    1:03:18 -
    *The Final Prestissimo in JÄRVI's Version... Even though it's not same as Furtwaengler's, but it was really fast like Bernstein and Karajan did in 1970s!!!*

    • @GermanGreetings
      @GermanGreetings 5 років тому

      comparisons no more necessary, Sir....
      `Seid umschlungen`...simply, dear しまたむ
      Järvi is different as his epic-small Orchestra, to `magic` this out.
      The marvel here is about Mathematics, but only about `how many` there are determined, to create this nearly unbearable `dynamic silence`.
      Because from this reference point somewhere in Universe `there` Bremens `Chamber-Angels` start to worry, performing by heart, focussing on `him`...
      to do it... and Järvi smiles them... directly to heaven, as Beethoven dreams it in advance.

  • @elemusic19
    @elemusic19 9 місяців тому

    I still believe that the last 2 minutes have yet to be surpassed.

  • @canardeur8390
    @canardeur8390 Рік тому

    Vladimir Poutine is conducting Beethoven's 9th Symphony.
    Suddenly, short after beating the first bars of the 1st movement, he gets the news from his loyal people at the Kremlin, that the NATO forces have entered Ukraine.
    He then suddenly becomes angry, speeds up the tempo and thinking during all the concert "Wait for me! Wait for me, and you will see what you will get!".

  • @dillonmcgee3688
    @dillonmcgee3688 3 роки тому +1

    Beautiful -

  • @vic9343
    @vic9343 6 років тому +2

    A maior herança que uma pessoa poderia ter deixado para a humanidade em termos artísticos!

  • @edgar2589
    @edgar2589 12 років тому +1

    Incredible, thanks for bringing me here.

  • @GermanGreetings
    @GermanGreetings 5 років тому +2

    Sir Järvi... and
    Hansestadt Bremen? I am so proud of of this `keeping small itself - St. Martin in the fields`..., therefore most toxic orchestra on stage ever !
    A dangerous mix - Beethoven would have...
    Ach... Do not mention my ungainly poetry in what shadow ever of this devine as naughty scale... life is wonderful, Ludwig.

  • @Thereal67P
    @Thereal67P Місяць тому

    The last 2 minutes are incredible to me

  • @chaikagome9725
    @chaikagome9725 7 місяців тому

    Bravo!

  • @maxbuskirk5302
    @maxbuskirk5302 11 років тому +3

    1:01:58 to 1:03:33 best finale ever!!!

  • @theodoresladovichjr.8923
    @theodoresladovichjr.8923 4 роки тому +3

    Have just celebrated the New Year by having a Beethoven Symphony Marathon by listening to all 9. I enjoy the newer approach to the works, even some liberties in phrasing and interpretation, but I think it works. Noticed some horn parts in the 9th are different, which makes me wonder if Jävi used the Del Mar urtext editions. Does anyone know?

  • @eusebioorru7383
    @eusebioorru7383 11 місяців тому

    Maestro Jarvi é stato un piacere immenso ascoltare la sua interpretazione di questo capolavoro musicale. Praticamente perfetto.

  • @leonardkalom4476
    @leonardkalom4476 6 років тому +1

    I have enjoyed all of these 9 symphonies. So many nuances and superb tempos. Unfortunately, the solo tenor was terrible in the 9th. I speak here as a degreed musicologist, and Beethoven lover for 65 of my 70 years . If any of you can find it, may I refer you to Solti's 9th with the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Chorus. Original 1972 Decca release and re-released by Decca in 1999. My CD is a "Penguin Classics". Soloists are Lorengar, Minton, Burrows, and Talvela. Solti also knew tempos were to be much faster. Everyone should have listened to Toscanini . He knew tempos, and knew they were all faster.

  • @Tensai180
    @Tensai180 12 років тому +1

    OMG...This is so beautiful

  • @stevenhaynes7633
    @stevenhaynes7633 7 років тому +2

    I love the way the cellos roll like thunder.

  • @epuacnos
    @epuacnos 7 років тому +1

    Nice job Nice Job Bravooo!!!

  • @FernieCanto
    @FernieCanto 12 років тому +1

    What kind of bitter person is only able to praise Beethoven by putting down videos so full of joy and fun such as Gangnam Style? It's sad that people forget that happiness comes in many forms.

  • @10GOLDENWOOD20
    @10GOLDENWOOD20 11 років тому +1

    Makes my night!

  • @matthewfeczko7533
    @matthewfeczko7533 2 роки тому +2

    There’s a circle of hell for advertisers who interrupt Beethoven.

    • @halneufmille
      @halneufmille Рік тому

      Use add block, add block plus and add block for UA-cam. Problem solved.

  • @psalmtone2008
    @psalmtone2008 6 років тому +1

    Those are some serious virtuosi!

  • @StevenAnderson-f2n
    @StevenAnderson-f2n 3 місяці тому

    Wie ein Held zum Siegen !

  • @tracer740
    @tracer740 11 років тому +1

    Bravo!!!

  • @cengizeren366
    @cengizeren366 2 місяці тому

    that chord before the double fugue…he heard that as a deaf man

  • @pablogv2817
    @pablogv2817 12 років тому +1

    excelente!!!

  • @handsomechuck1
    @handsomechuck1 11 років тому +1

    Yes, but they will soon be forgotten. This will get hits as long as human beings exist and listen to music.

  • @helenaconstantine
    @helenaconstantine 2 роки тому +1

    I've heard this hundreds of times in dozens of performances. How can he find anything new in it?

  • @anthonyhk
    @anthonyhk 6 років тому

    Best Beethoven 9

  • @bonapona2251
    @bonapona2251 7 років тому +1

    Bravi !!!

  • @laszloboromisza
    @laszloboromisza 4 роки тому +2

    Nagyon jó zene, különlegesen jó előadásmódban!

  • @pochosamuel7644
    @pochosamuel7644 Рік тому

    Musicos DKB: Benditos seais todos que habèis traido tan inmenso goce a mi alma

  • @10vutrandung69
    @10vutrandung69 8 років тому +2

    I like this one , because at the end it is so fast and powerful. just x1,25 speed , it will fast just like furtwangler 's ochestral playing it at the end very fast .

  • @veloteuton63
    @veloteuton63 6 років тому +5

    where was this recorded?
    The passion with which this performance is given is electrifying. An amazing rendition of one of the greatest pieces of music ever written!
    Jarvi is my favourite conductor.

    • @Quotenwagnerianer
      @Quotenwagnerianer 6 років тому

      Beethovenhalle Bonn. Concert series with all 9 Symphonies as a part of the annual Beethoven festival.

  • @Suvikuja4A
    @Suvikuja4A 11 років тому +1

    What a wonderful and philosophic poem! Have you, titomun123 written it yourself? If you are quoting somebody, tell me whom!

  • @Queeen7q
    @Queeen7q 4 роки тому +4

    Christiane Oelze - soprano,
    Petra Lang - alto,
    Klaus Florian Vogt - tenor,
    Matthias Goerne - baritone

    • @leporello7
      @leporello7 4 роки тому +1

      Well, you got at least 1 out of 4 ;-) - Christiane Oelze, Annely Peebo, Simon O'Neill, Dietrich Henschel are singing here.

  • @bluemoon7313
    @bluemoon7313 7 років тому +2

    Cool performance. I still think Ben Zander had it right the first time, and so did Norrington: the trio of the scherzo should be half the speed of the scherzo itself, for various perfectly good technical and musical reasons. Not to mention it sounds really, really right done that way. I wish more conductors would rethink this. Do it as the music seems to say there and it's WAY too rushed. Listen to Norrington's 80s performance of the scherzo, whatever else you might say about it, the trio sounds exactly right. The entire metronome marking thing there is a red-herring, and I think Norrington's explanation of what's supposed to happen at that point is compelling.

    • @charlesandrews3795
      @charlesandrews3795 6 місяців тому

      The accelerando that leads to the trio is a perfect Beethoven red herring. Everyone forgets the man loved a practical joke. I agree entirely, the trio is correct in the Norrington performance and no other I know of.