Breaching of Gamtoos River Mouth - Jeffreys Bay, South Africa

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 482

  • @jimdevlin2138
    @jimdevlin2138 5 років тому +178

    Beaver dam busting , Drain clearing, Flash floods, and now river breaching , I think I need some Professional help

    • @moving.quotes
      @moving.quotes 4 роки тому +12

      No idea why the fuck I want to keep seeing these as well.

    • @ClayLoomis1958
      @ClayLoomis1958 4 роки тому +10

      Now you have laser metal cleaning, river ice jam breakage, and overgrown yard clean-up to add to your list of things that satisfy for reasons we can't quite explain.

    • @prunedfingers
      @prunedfingers 4 роки тому +5

      look up post10

    • @Bramon83
      @Bramon83 3 роки тому

      I think you at this point could call yourself a professional that can help.... In specific scenarios 🤣😂😅

    • @barbeerian
      @barbeerian 3 роки тому +4

      @@prunedfingers I imagine being a fan of post10 is what led me here...

  • @johannolivier377
    @johannolivier377 4 роки тому +31

    Spent many of my childhood days in that lagoon. We used to have a house up on the hill to the left, as you face the sea. Such wonderful memories of that place....

  • @ashwinnmyburgh9364
    @ashwinnmyburgh9364 5 років тому +11

    my home! I live at the Gamtoos River mouth and am so impressed by the work our community has done!

    • @wannabecarguy
      @wannabecarguy 5 років тому

      I did this once by myself with no tools. I just thought it would be fun to see the river run into the ocean. It's not that hard to do.

  • @firemanfred9471
    @firemanfred9471 5 років тому +16

    Excellent cinematography...👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦

  • @ajo3085
    @ajo3085 3 роки тому +12

    Are you sure they were really farmers? They look more like they're on the government payroll. A dozen blokes doing the work, 3 dozen standing around watching. 😊 Great video, thanks.

  • @raremajor
    @raremajor 4 роки тому +74

    There's so much beauty in ordinary things.

    • @kevinv.m.94
      @kevinv.m.94 4 роки тому

      I agree!
      If you have an IG account, you may follow @ordinaryphotographer_.

  • @toomuchinformationforu9919
    @toomuchinformationforu9919 5 років тому +75

    looks like someone got a drone for christmas and cant stop playing with it

  • @llaurita2
    @llaurita2 5 років тому +55

    My 5YO daughter does a 1/10 scale version of that every weekend at the beach.

  • @Trowsiff-uk
    @Trowsiff-uk 5 років тому +6

    Fantastic video and good luck to those farmers who sure need it.

    • @Trowsiff-uk
      @Trowsiff-uk 2 роки тому

      @@redimixofmd Rather be a fool than a tool!!😂 C.U.Next Tuesday.

  • @GusMac6129
    @GusMac6129 5 років тому +145

    I went from a tsunami video to this. Well that was a let down.

    • @nathansimard6916
      @nathansimard6916 5 років тому +3

      Bruh Chinese cyanide explosion to seniors day at the beach

    • @mariosantibanez3518
      @mariosantibanez3518 5 років тому +2

      Dude was it the one where you thought the glacier was the tsunami.lol

    • @truetalk5023
      @truetalk5023 4 роки тому

      waterFALLS. seaLEvEL .
      Still Waters always LEvEL,
      Dr.🌏ip
      👀☔
      exAMEN 🌈 FirmAmenT

    • @jovandyparkins578
      @jovandyparkins578 4 роки тому +3

      Lmaooo me too! I was watching tsunami videos and ended up here lol

    • @Superkuh2
      @Superkuh2 3 роки тому

      Don't let this breach video fool you. Most of them get raging. This was the least exciting coastal river breach I've ever seen.

  • @debraolivier2147
    @debraolivier2147 3 роки тому +7

    This was very important for the farmers.

  • @josephastier7421
    @josephastier7421 4 роки тому +47

    "We moved thirty yards of dirt by manual labor only to discover that it wouldn't flow".

    • @shubh4793
      @shubh4793 3 роки тому +1

      Coz people are dumb.

    • @kenea3226
      @kenea3226 3 роки тому +5

      It will flow and end up with waves big enough to surf. The problem is that this is illegal in many places, for a reason.

    • @veronicasmyth3830
      @veronicasmyth3830 3 роки тому

      Your being so extra careful. So I can't sense Who You Are.

  • @effervescentrelief
    @effervescentrelief 4 роки тому +4

    River in South Africa. Used heavily for agriculture which is probably why it periodically stops short of draining into the ocean. Depending on the year and seasonal rainfall the outlet into the ocean varies over time especially since it drains through a sandy beach.

  • @CrusherFitter
    @CrusherFitter 5 років тому +14

    Anyone see there was a much closer bit to dig at up the beach?

  • @BlackCeII
    @BlackCeII 4 роки тому +2

    Ive dug out a bunch of rivers around the world dozens of times. Heres a HUGE tip that will save a lot of effort. Dig from the river side toward the ocean! I have dug out channels by myself that were this far away from the ocean, as you go, the river water keeps the sand wet and softens it and makes it easy to just scoop out of the way, so that gravity can take over. You only need a little bit of water, and gravity does the rest. This video shows such a waste of effort digging from the ocean to the river.

  • @Tauraco00
    @Tauraco00 6 років тому +2

    This is so needed for the marine life - thank you to everyone that helped with this - good job!

    • @sosweetbaby4
      @sosweetbaby4 5 років тому +4

      Marine life🤔
      So the life that was in the river got dumped to ocean salt water tooooo die 🤔👌✌

    • @michellebyrom6551
      @michellebyrom6551 4 роки тому +1

      @@sosweetbaby4 you do realise fish can swim and instinct directs them to theur best environment? Also other life forms have their own methods of staying put/regenerating cyclically.

  • @brt-jn7kg
    @brt-jn7kg 5 років тому +71

    Well that's three minutes I can't get back to life

    • @redwarf8118
      @redwarf8118 5 років тому +3

      then just go outside

    • @markhwlett
      @markhwlett 4 роки тому +2

      4 by the time you've made your comment...

  • @none6352
    @none6352 4 роки тому +8

    why does this seem so amazing

    • @shannonhondo260
      @shannonhondo260 4 роки тому

      The teamwork part of it makes me happy especially with the way the world is these days

    • @Wetfeline
      @Wetfeline 4 роки тому

      It’s not

  • @anotherjuan
    @anotherjuan 5 років тому +14

    please upload a part 2 🙏🏼

  • @LogicSword3675
    @LogicSword3675 5 років тому +114

    if only there were machines to do that...

    • @colinm2056
      @colinm2056 4 роки тому +2

      @@mucsalto8377 race card.

    • @rRobertSmith
      @rRobertSmith 4 роки тому +6

      By the time you find the equipment and the trailer and get it there they have been done for 2 hours......imagine that.

    • @Filmwithpurpose
      @Filmwithpurpose 4 роки тому

      LogicSword3675 they are called bulldozers

    • @benjaminmairs9302
      @benjaminmairs9302 4 роки тому +3

      Then those people wouldn’t have to get any pesky exercise

    • @darrenkastl8160
      @darrenkastl8160 4 роки тому +2

      Are you the guy that drinks all the alcohol at the party by 8:00 pm, and they just stuff you in the corner with a 5 gallon bucket?

  • @stevenopolis3155
    @stevenopolis3155 4 роки тому +2

    Great video! Good job.

  • @111yashrajsingh9
    @111yashrajsingh9 4 роки тому +3

    why do they breach it?
    i have seen several videos of doing the same act but what's the ultimate goal of doing this???

    • @dunruden9720
      @dunruden9720 4 роки тому +4

      Ask your mother to read you the description of the clip.

    • @georgemueh3273
      @georgemueh3273 4 роки тому

      @@dunruden9720 👍🤪🤣😆😝

  • @marcelinoramos4580
    @marcelinoramos4580 3 роки тому

    Thank you

  • @danrodrigues3531
    @danrodrigues3531 5 років тому +12

    So how long did it take to lower the level of the river?

    • @billrobbins5874
      @billrobbins5874 3 роки тому +1

      That took alot of hard work. It looked beautiful while it was flowing. ♥️🌊🌍♥️

  • @Mark-yb1sp
    @Mark-yb1sp 5 років тому +4

    A beautiful community doing a beautiful thing. 🇺🇸❤️👍🏻

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому +1

      finally a lovely comment :)

  • @davidvanniekerk3813
    @davidvanniekerk3813 4 роки тому +1

    Baie mooi. 'n bomel ("drone") is beslis op my wenslysie!!!

  • @rubencampher2788
    @rubencampher2788 6 років тому +5

    Pls keep updating on the gamtoos rivier mouth🙏

  • @Scott-cw9kj
    @Scott-cw9kj 7 місяців тому

    Reconnecting mother nature. I love it🎉

  • @misanthrope9258
    @misanthrope9258 4 роки тому +2

    WOW!!! A lot of time and energy.
    I bet 80% of these people have a child at home glued to a smartphone.

  • @svengalil
    @svengalil 4 роки тому +1

    Nice flying!

  • @paulstack3015
    @paulstack3015 4 роки тому +13

    I remember digging for fun.

  • @daveschwartz5893
    @daveschwartz5893 5 років тому +8

    I'm guessing machinery wasn't an option?

    • @daveschwartz5893
      @daveschwartz5893 5 років тому

      @@mucsalto8377 I get it man. It's social media and everyone can say whatever unfortunately. But considering the vast majority are white you wanna try again?

  • @cpe1704tks.
    @cpe1704tks. 4 роки тому +1

    How come all these rivers in South Africa cannot find their way naturally to the ocean. What is man doing? I'm confused.

  • @RazvanTSibiu
    @RazvanTSibiu 4 роки тому +1

    If water is on a larger surface then a bigger amount will evaporate and there will be more clouds. More clouds means more rain for a green planet.

  • @BruceSeesall
    @BruceSeesall 5 років тому +3

    It is amazing what we can do together.

    • @Filmwithpurpose
      @Filmwithpurpose 4 роки тому +1

      Bruce Sees all there’s like ONE dude doing it all wtf are you talking about. Half the people in the video were standing around.

  • @senormystery721
    @senormystery721 Рік тому

    Can we see an updated video from the same spot?

  • @ronaldoferreiramuniz1199
    @ronaldoferreiramuniz1199 4 роки тому +3

    Great jobs, comunity, excelent !

  •  5 років тому +5

    100% of human intervention in nature prooved lomg-term distructive.
    This is a tiny trench dug in the sand. It would had happened naturally maybe in a few weeks, but still, the full implications were never thought upon by no one.

    • @michellebyrom6551
      @michellebyrom6551 4 роки тому +1

      In that few weeks crops and homes could be lost to floods. Sandbars shift and grow. Digging a trench to help nature along is goid husbandry, along with dredging to prevent too much silting up at the river mouth. Flood plains provide good soil when correctly mabaged.

  • @NoogahOogah
    @NoogahOogah 4 роки тому +1

    Nature: *doing its thing*
    People: HURRY UP

  • @VestigialHead
    @VestigialHead 5 років тому +1

    This is confusing? What was the purpose? If the river was about to be flooded it would have made a breach anyway.

    • @-Gadget-
      @-Gadget- 3 роки тому

      This was my thought exactly. It was on the verge of creating its own path, but I guess that's what you get when people with more money than brains build their home away from home, too close to the river edge, and they start getting ansy 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому +1

      @@-Gadget- did you read the description?

    • @-Gadget-
      @-Gadget- 3 роки тому

      @@s1e_dm The answer to your question is "Yes", hence my comment. If the Groot River was about to flood more water into the lock, it would have forced the break..... All on its own. So my question stands.
      Did you bother reading the description?

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому +1

      @@-Gadget- then you should know that these people's income and livelihood depends on their land, so then breaching the groot river early stops their land from flooding. Even if the groot river would flood and create it's own breach, by that time it would have flooded the farmers land.

    • @-Gadget-
      @-Gadget- 3 роки тому

      @@s1e_dm So, then this was all due to the poor planing of the farmers that chose land below a known flood plain.
      Why didn't you just say that to begin with, as it would have save all this time and effort 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @jamesfazio6383
    @jamesfazio6383 4 роки тому +2

    What was the accomplishment ahead?

    • @-Gadget-
      @-Gadget- 3 роки тому

      Besides the fact that, given enough time, mother nature would have made her own path.... Without their help 🤷🏻‍♀️

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому

      @@-Gadget- read the description you waste of braincells

  • @stasyaksa1411
    @stasyaksa1411 4 роки тому

    Just two questions.
    1. What for?
    2. There is excavator?

  • @lucasbochat1653
    @lucasbochat1653 5 років тому +14

    Don’t know what mod u have on water only flows 8 blocks so I know u guys are cheating on sum way 😣

    • @richardclay
      @richardclay 4 роки тому +1

      How about learning English grammar and punctuation before making a fool of yourself in public with your complete lack of literacy?

    • @kwando472
      @kwando472 4 роки тому

      @@richardclay Woosh
      And saying he made a fool of himself. Christ if you don't get a joke don't react dumbass.

    • @Wetfeline
      @Wetfeline 4 роки тому

      Richard Clay Get off your high horse Dick Clay

  • @rickkkclunk9799
    @rickkkclunk9799 4 роки тому

    how come South Africa has so many rivers like this?

  • @paytugamer771
    @paytugamer771 4 роки тому +2

    1:24 wowwww what a beautiful scene of nature

  • @marvinmartinsYT
    @marvinmartinsYT 4 роки тому

    By hand. Determination. Kudos.

    • @marvinmartinsYT
      @marvinmartinsYT 4 роки тому

      Oh. A couple quick shots of after two days.

  • @supergoober1021
    @supergoober1021 3 роки тому

    Looks like most construction work. More than half are standing around watching the others do the work!
    (Yes, I know that’s not happening. It just fits into that narrative. I supervised underground construction and I would limit how many supervisors, assistant managers, managers, support crews, parts runners and any other people not immediately needed to be on a job site because the crew doing the work were one crewleader and two laborers. Only one laborer was actually digging and the other keeping the spoils away from the excavation. The crewleader was responsible for the two laborers. It definitely looks bad to the public and adding another couple for traffic control didn’t help the visuals, either.)

  • @stevelamperta865
    @stevelamperta865 5 років тому +3

    Its so sickening that the people need permission for something like this ! The people around here would not have even asked and would not have waited either . Government has become a cancer to all ! I wonder if the people will ever do anything about it ? I doubt it....

  • @jeradweeks
    @jeradweeks 5 років тому +35

    What was the point of this?

    • @motherofone1
      @motherofone1 5 років тому +10

      If you had read the description, the farmland was flooded. So they got permission to open a channel between the river and the ocean to allow the river to drain.

    • @brianmck7363
      @brianmck7363 5 років тому +2

      Point was nunya

    • @jameshiggins3742
      @jameshiggins3742 5 років тому

      His reply 😂😂😂

    • @flashforensics
      @flashforensics 5 років тому +9

      @@motherofone1 you need permission to play on the beach now?

    • @alloneword7427
      @alloneword7427 5 років тому +1

      @@flashforensics looking at the history, the residents did this in 2015, but without permission, and the illegal bit is breaching the river mouth, not going on the beach. The local office of the Department of Environmental Affairs apparently filed a complaint with the police. This time (2018), they got permission.

  • @goldfishdoc1999
    @goldfishdoc1999 3 роки тому

    why is it done actually? is there a reason? or just fun?

  • @eyeofthetiger4214
    @eyeofthetiger4214 3 роки тому

    Video too short. Didn't show how wide the pathway went

  • @allanegleston4931
    @allanegleston4931 3 роки тому +1

    too bad they couldnt put in a pernament structure with removable boards . when time comes , remove the boards . i feel though that would be too expensive .

  • @jonesgang
    @jonesgang 3 роки тому

    Why so much work???? I tiny trench 1 tenth of that size would have done the very same thing without all that work. And I like how they were piling up the sand like they were going to throw it back in later on...
    There was a old man that did the same thing in Australia but just used his walking cane.....

  • @travisk5589
    @travisk5589 5 років тому +15

    Why did these people even waste their time. This breach sucked

  • @geoffallen1331
    @geoffallen1331 5 років тому +10

    Why didn't they bring in a digger?

    • @Hurst6969
      @Hurst6969 5 років тому +4

      They had 100 of them

  • @jeffmclaughlin8564
    @jeffmclaughlin8564 5 років тому +1

    Was the point of this excersize to pollute the ocean?

    • @richardclay
      @richardclay 4 роки тому

      READ the description provided.

  • @danp7463
    @danp7463 2 роки тому

    What's the reason?

  • @robbass1521
    @robbass1521 4 роки тому +8

    My kingdom for a backhoe!

  • @jameshaberkamp5927
    @jameshaberkamp5927 3 роки тому

    Just curious. What's the purpose of doing this?

  • @grande521
    @grande521 5 років тому +5

    I'm guessing not Det cord available....

  • @bradprice7543
    @bradprice7543 7 місяців тому

    Well that was a waste of three minutes,Thanks.

  • @toobored54
    @toobored54 5 років тому +9

    Why??

    • @bluvespa
      @bluvespa 4 роки тому +1

      To show you how humans are stupid!! Always to destroy the beauty of our wonderful planet!

  • @kheavmady8780
    @kheavmady8780 4 роки тому +3

    what for?

  • @johnconner8901
    @johnconner8901 4 роки тому

    How is it there was no one surfing that

  • @stevenfoust3782
    @stevenfoust3782 4 роки тому

    What is the point?? It will fill itself back in probably in one day. They don’t have excavation equipment there? Who digs a trench by hand these days?

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому

      if you can't afford digging equipment and your farming land is flooding up, but you have an arsenal of farm boys at your hand. Then I'd dig it by hand than instead of even not digging it at all.

  • @scotthorton7786
    @scotthorton7786 4 роки тому +2

    When tree and bunny huggers come up with a plan.
    WAAAH WAAW

  • @ded_denis_71
    @ded_denis_71 4 роки тому +2

    только я не понял зачем соединять солёную воду и пресную. там же живность в реке помрёт.

  • @pkgamingofficial4206
    @pkgamingofficial4206 4 роки тому

    So how long it will take down level of the river!thats it..

  • @maxinetexasgal5114
    @maxinetexasgal5114 4 роки тому

    Anybody know why this was done? What was the reason?

    • @kenmurray8476
      @kenmurray8476 4 роки тому

      Flood downstream. Expl in intro

    • @maxinetexasgal5114
      @maxinetexasgal5114 4 роки тому

      @@kenmurray8476 thanks, I didnt hear an intro, only music.

  • @johnmartell807
    @johnmartell807 5 років тому

    VERY good selection of music for this

  • @bryanwhite773
    @bryanwhite773 4 роки тому

    But why? Maybe the water didn’t want to go that way.

  • @liberty5565
    @liberty5565 5 років тому +14

    It will fill back in with sand within a week or two.

    • @travisk5589
      @travisk5589 5 років тому +5

      Within a day.

    • @stephensmith3577
      @stephensmith3577 5 років тому

      Glad to sayit is stillopen acter the breach and bigger and deeper than e er

  • @rickrandom6734
    @rickrandom6734 3 роки тому

    Evil, evil sand would not let rivrr meet its friend ocean. People helped and now river is so happy.

  • @suryadixl9410
    @suryadixl9410 4 роки тому +2

    Why? Dont u need water?

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому

      Read the description.

  • @AdamWebb1982
    @AdamWebb1982 3 роки тому

    All this work then doesn’t show us it in full flow :(

  • @sbmusicvideo9143
    @sbmusicvideo9143 4 роки тому +1

    Excellent!

  • @williamchristian8705
    @williamchristian8705 4 роки тому +2

    I can dig this idea.

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому +1

      Yooo an actually funny comment :D

  • @xxjahelixx2602
    @xxjahelixx2602 4 роки тому +9

    0:17 WW1 flashbacks

  • @user-gh8wt2zi2n
    @user-gh8wt2zi2n 5 років тому

    Do they not have backhoes in South Africa?

  • @SharpusAurelius
    @SharpusAurelius 4 роки тому

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that horrible for the environment?

  • @cjodigo
    @cjodigo 5 років тому +2

    50 people an no one has access to a backhoe?

    • @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki
      @Dwightstjohn-fo8ki 4 роки тому

      @@mucsalto8377 thank you; I was trying to figure out from the guys standing around in cutoffs doing nothing AND the extra long introduction that doesn't show where TF this is going on, and was sure it was in some southern US state shithole.

  • @Zenas521
    @Zenas521 4 роки тому

    To bad you didn't get footage of the following day.

  • @davidfourie5719
    @davidfourie5719 4 роки тому

    Why cant it be done at St Lucia

  • @EricBraun100
    @EricBraun100 4 роки тому +3

    Wow overkill on the trench! They could have just scrapped a small path with one shovel. Half hour job, one man.

  • @rudivandereep310
    @rudivandereep310 3 роки тому

    When a drone captures loootsa onlookers observing the few doing the hard work

    • @brianpreston8483
      @brianpreston8483 3 роки тому

      Must be a state job

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому

      Read the description, and here's some context. The onlookers are mostly the farmers themselves who organised the dig. The ones digging are the farm boys who work for the farmers. So it's isn't as if the onlookers are doing nothing, they are the ones paying the farmers with their own money to dig a trench.

    • @brianpreston8483
      @brianpreston8483 3 роки тому

      @@s1e_dm so

  • @CatchingCharkraLight
    @CatchingCharkraLight 2 роки тому

    I wonder if someone should tell them they just need a small downward gash, they water will do the rest.

  • @SundipanBhowmickk100392
    @SundipanBhowmickk100392 4 роки тому

    Is that rainfed river or backwater?

  • @larrilarri1081
    @larrilarri1081 4 роки тому +3

    У меня только один вопрос...

  • @bobyoung241
    @bobyoung241 4 роки тому

    Can freshwater fish survive in salt water?

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому

      No, And that isn't fresh water

  • @billsabado9393
    @billsabado9393 5 років тому

    Is there a reason no one is playing in the breach? Looks fun to me

    • @winfriedkubitzki7523
      @winfriedkubitzki7523 5 років тому +1

      I did it once on Lanzarote island,Gran Canaria.I survived. It looks like nothing but there where the sweet water gets into the salt water there is such a strange" Trouble" its takes you away upside down and i m a good swimmer ,I really thougt I would die.

  • @brazillady5119
    @brazillady5119 4 роки тому +1

    OK, but why?

  • @caderaojohncyrus1378
    @caderaojohncyrus1378 3 роки тому +1

    Maybe they should've let nature do it's thing. Would've been more beautiful to see that in action.

  • @damian4608
    @damian4608 4 роки тому

    fresh water is so scares - Why would breach the river and empty it in the sea ? lower the river level and lessen the habitat for millions of small and big animals and fishes along the river ? i don't get it ......

    • @s1e_dm
      @s1e_dm 3 роки тому

      that isn't fresh water

  • @thesunsetreptiles
    @thesunsetreptiles 5 років тому +2

    And what was the point of that

    • @richardclay
      @richardclay 4 роки тому

      READ the description provided.

  • @WildlifeObsessed
    @WildlifeObsessed 4 роки тому

    What was the point of that ..... ?

  • @tommypetraglia4688
    @tommypetraglia4688 5 років тому +9

    Unfortunately some of us from other parts of the world have no idea where the Gamtoos is.
    It would have been nice if the title or that wallpaper-length description gave a clue to where the fk this is
    Now I'm off to GoogleBox it myself

    • @CooManTunes
      @CooManTunes 5 років тому

      Yes. Depend on Google, you peasant.

    • @petrol88
      @petrol88 5 років тому +1

      @@mucsalto8377 Cheeeeers bru!

    • @richardclay
      @richardclay 4 роки тому

      READ the description provided.

  • @rudirahman8843
    @rudirahman8843 4 роки тому

    Wooow beautiful scant , like

  • @marierandall2824
    @marierandall2824 3 роки тому

    Why do they do this what is the purpose for it

  • @howardmurphy2841
    @howardmurphy2841 4 роки тому

    So natural thanks humans

  • @charlessprayberry1048
    @charlessprayberry1048 4 роки тому +1

    why would do this? made me feel like it was wrong to do