She was actually the most iconic out of the group even though Cheryl was popular Sarah had that edge that a girl group needs if anything Sarah made the group that bit more powerful.
Prayers go to Sarah Harding let's pray she is victorious against cancer. Edit: R.I.P Sarah Harding she has lost the battle with cancer, let's give our thoughts and prayers to her loved ones.
This is a classic song and Sarah really rips your heart out with that line "Here i am...walking primrose." Such an underrated group. Not surprised it was voted song of the year.
My favourite part of the song. When I heard about the reunion tour, my mind immediately went to this line. Who could sing it besides Sarah? I wonder if they’ll somehow feature her in the show with old footage as a tribute to her.
@3bottlesfor10 I would definitely like to see Sarah represented in some way that compliments their onstage performance. I always have bitter-sweet feelings about GA. They never received their full dues as a group. Sarah and Cheryl especially were treated horribly by the press over nothing-stories. Made me so angry. As time passes, more and more people will be asking ' How come I never heard of GA?' I kinda envy their discovery of one of the best groups of all time.Countless future generations are in for a treat.
Just heard the awful news about Sarah Harding. Rest in peace beautiful lady. You fought hard. Even though you lived a short life, you always shone the whole way through it. Rest in peace Sarah. xx 💔💓
How do you define short some people have long lives and do nothing her music will be her legacy babies born today will know who she is in another 30 years
@@natureclips5849 I meant short as in her age bless her. 39 is quite young really. But yes, her life was full of so many memories and wonderful music. xx 💓
Sarah, you came into this world and lit it up for a little while shorter than we all hoped. What a vibrant personality you had and you were a stunning girl. Today has been a real 💔 day. But I hope you fly high and sprinkle some stardust baby. Condolences to your family and friends and of course the other 4 girls. Stay strong all. ☹
Fly high Sara Harding. You owned this song and shined the brightest on it. Whenever I listen to it I will think of your talent, beauty and sensitive soul
I'd never heard of Girls Aloud until Sarah's passing, as I live in the US. Rest In Peace to her. I like this song! I would've totally been into it, had I known about it when it first came out. It's funky!
Yes, what a crying shame, but I wonder if Sarah Harding having implants had anything to do with her developing breast cancer? I say she had implants, as Sarah Harding seemed considerably smaller up top in her earlier years with Girls Aloud than in her later years-just a thought.
@@michaelwittmann2644 I can tell you’re really cut up about her death… what an insensitive comment. We’re not here to debate the cause of her death. But while you’re mentioning it, I don’t believe there’s a link between implants and breast cancer. Look it up.
@@LM085 You belong to a group of people who lack fortitude and are habitually offended by anything and everything that doesn't fit the tiny confines of your sensitive little mind. You might not be here to discuss Sarah Harding's cause of expiration, but for your information, this is a public forum, and as such, no subject is off limits. My catechism was legitimate; I remind you, it wasn't long ago that cigarettes were given to patients by doctors to alleviate sore throats. It is an inescapable medical fact that not only do implants increase a woman's chances of developing anaplastic large-cell lymphoma (ALCL), but they also increase other wide-ranging health complications for women: brain fog, memory loss, Squamous Cell Carcinoma (SCC) and various lymphomas, asymmetry, breast pain, joint pain, tissue atrophy, calcium deposits, deflation, extrusion, capsular contraction, and iatrogenic injury. Any thoughts that might warn others concerning health dangers ought to be investigated, even if it saves just one life from life-long health issues or something much worse. If we were all born with your unfortunate, restricted outlook on life, the world would be very bland and ignorant. I now bring to your attention a Maxim of Law-no man has the right not to be offended.
The Promise was, in my opinion, their best track. I also believe Sarah's contribution raised it to the standard it achieved...a group that seemed as much about the looks as the music though Sarah's solo demonstrated that her looks were just the tip of an iceberg. R.I.P. sweet songstress
Always loved this song, reminds me of when I spent the best time of my life with the most beautiful girl I've ever known, how I wish I was 10 years younger 😥,love can be the most amazing feeling in life but also the worst pain ever.
RIP Sarah Harding! It still seems unreal that u aren’t here, i really wanted to see a GA performance or reunion and now i just can’t believe we won’t ever get to see the group as a whole 😭 gone but never forgotten!
Devastated to hear the news about Sarah sending lots of love to her family R.I.P. ❤️💔🙏😢 Ps Walking Primrose will be always my favourite part of this song love you Sarah forever. ❤️
hard to believe the ginger one was often called the ugly one, she is beautiful, definitely the best looking, she doesnt seem to push herself to the front like the others, seems very coy and maybe shy, in a very sexy way
This Promise was definitely Sarah’s era. Singing the first verse and that walking primrose line was sketched on everyone’s minds when they think of this song! 🌻🪽
Been thinking about Sarah a lot the last few days after seeing the rest of the Girls at the O2. Life is so unfair sometimes. Back in 2013 at the last tour I was with my Mum and we talked about Sarah and her enthusiasm and vulnerability. She really stood out to us. Now both Sarah and my Mum are gone. Rest in peace walking primrose 🌸
Can anyone explain why this song - drives me nuts - with sheer abandoned pleasure! I am now 64 years old - but hell! - it makes me feel like the teenager I once was! and no I was never a "fan" as such - but this song the way its sung - sheer pleasure - a brilliantly executed song - hats off to you all, "Girls Aloud!
Whatever decade. Whatever fashion. Whatever style. Brit music is tops. 🇬🇧 Goodnight. God bless you Sarah. For making my youngest daughter happy. All those years ago in 2003.
Sarah was such a *star* - her screen presence was insane here! In the video concept she's the "it girl" with all the aura and star quality and she totally sells it. Giving Twiggy or Edie Sedgwick 60's cool in the posing parts and Dusty Springfield glamour in the popstar segments.
Rest in peace, Sarah. What a powerhouse of a voice. I wish she joined a jazz band or something after Girls Aloud ended. She definitely had the talent for it.
Felt choked up watching Sarah in this. Was never a fan of the group but seeing her in this video looking so young, healthy and beautiful and knowing what we know now. Just so incredibly sad. 😞
I remember watching Popstars The Rivals where Girls Aloud were created. Their first single was completely different to what everyone expected - not just another samey sounding girl band, but an edgy 5 piece outfit with a rock sounding song. Girls Aloud went on to have an amazing career with consistently brilliant songs. The Promise is about as perfect a pure pop song as you will ever get. Their writers and producers never got it wrong.
They were shit not one decent song. Sarah was a slapper from stockport I worked with a guy called nick at the airport he banged her over his BMW when he was a nightclub promoter the sun had a story with her n him in it.
Sarah exudes star quality and charisma here. She was so effortlessly magnetic and it’s a shame that was never really exploited as much as it could have been.
Sarah's 'Here I ammmmmmmm Walking Primrose' will forever be iconic!!!!!
Even more so now 😔💔
She was actually the most iconic out of the group even though Cheryl was popular Sarah had that edge that a girl group needs if anything Sarah made the group that bit more powerful.
Waaaa 😭
@@joeylodez485 true but now……………
What does it mean?
Prayers go to Sarah Harding let's pray she is victorious against cancer.
Edit: R.I.P Sarah Harding she has lost the battle with cancer, let's give our thoughts and prayers to her loved ones.
Definitely! 🙏
Amen to that
😔😔😔😔🤞🏽🤞🏽
Really really sad, she was told there is nothing they can do now
@@andrewwest5344 😪😪😪so young, so sad
Goodbye beautiful “walking primrose”. 🥺
Terrific slice of pop.
RIP to a lovely girl who died far too young, girls aloud were far better than most people gave them credit for.
Totally love this song.
@@janthomson7697😊
Good song
Here after that beautiful Sarah Harding tribute from their latest tour 💕
Me too. At the 02 last night!
Same 😣
Me too. ❤
That pat of the song when the music and all we could hear was her voice, brought me to tears. Rest dear Sarah...
❤❤
On a Girls aloud marathon because Sarah was an underappreciated legend that deserves such a better end, always remembered, angel gone too soon
This 🙌
@@hannahgreen3780 ⭐
So sad she never got her happy ever after of children and a husband. Beauty inside and out. R.I.P Sarah 🙏😇🕊️💐💔😪
The word Legend is thrown around way too much. Takes decades to have a chance of being called a legend.
Well said 🙌
1:06 -1:11 sarah's eyes and hair is giving Twiggy vibes stunning! RIP
This is a classic song and Sarah really rips your heart out with that line "Here i am...walking primrose." Such an underrated group. Not surprised it was voted song of the year.
My favourite part of the song. When I heard about the reunion tour, my mind immediately went to this line. Who could sing it besides Sarah? I wonder if they’ll somehow feature her in the show with old footage as a tribute to her.
Sarah on the big screen from this video I hope. Include her as much as possible
@3bottlesfor10 I would definitely like to see Sarah represented in some way that compliments their onstage performance. I always have bitter-sweet feelings about GA. They never received their full dues as a group. Sarah and Cheryl especially were treated horribly by the press over nothing-stories. Made me so angry. As time passes, more and more people will be asking ' How come I never heard of GA?' I kinda envy their discovery of one of the best groups of all time.Countless future generations are in for a treat.
@@3bottlesfor10 Just confirmed - Sarah WILL feature in the new tour!
can confirm they projected a beautiful video of sarah singing her line at the reunion tour x
R.I.P Sarah. I'm more of a rocker, but I've always had a soft spot for absolutely joyous pop music like this. Thank you ladies.
Well written.
💜
Sarah’s verse showcases just how brilliant a vocalist she was. I’m so sorry she’s gone. 💔
Totally agree, such a shame 😢
Absolutely Miss Ruby Red just awful she's gone. 😭
💜
What an accurate thing to say.
It'd be even better if we knew what she meant when she sang that she's "walking primrose".
Just heard the awful news about Sarah Harding. Rest in peace beautiful lady. You fought hard. Even though you lived a short life, you always shone the whole way through it. Rest in peace Sarah. xx 💔💓
How do you define short some people have long lives and do nothing her music will be her legacy babies born today will know who she is in another 30 years
@@natureclips5849 I meant short as in her age bless her. 39 is quite young really. But yes, her life was full of so many memories and wonderful music. xx 💓
RIP Sarah Harding 😢😢❤❤gone but never forgotten
친구가 추천해봐서 들어봤는데 컨셉이나 노래, 분위기 전반적으로 다 좋네요. 걸스 어라우드의 음색이 제일 잘 어울리는 곡 같아요. 중독성이 강해요. 시험기간때 들으면 안되는 곡입니다.
Sarah, you came into this world and lit it up for a little while shorter than we all hoped. What a vibrant personality you had and you were a stunning girl. Today has been a real 💔 day. But I hope you fly high and sprinkle some stardust baby. Condolences to your family and friends and of course the other 4 girls. Stay strong all. ☹
💙💜🙏😔
Beautiful ✌ star 🌟
I can remember when they performed this on the X Factor when Cheryl was a Judge
@@racerja3173 Yes, they really were great as a group and got better with experience. 💛
RIP SARAH. An absolute superstar. Such a talent.
RIP Sarah Harding, my thoughts go out to her friends and family, this is just so so sad🥺🥺❤❤
'Here I am walking Primrose', most iconic line in pop music from UK. ❤
What does it mean?
@@davidz2562 I would assume walking through “Primrose Hill” in London - Sarah lived there.
Lyrical golden Music 🎶
Lol.
Walking her dog primrose.
RIP Sarah Harding . You were the true star of this group. Enjoyed you as one of the frustrated wives in Run for Your Wife. Love this song.
RIP Sarah, the shining has dimmed but your light will carry on forever. Safe flight home. x
Fly high Sara Harding. You owned this song and shined the brightest on it. Whenever I listen to it I will think of your talent, beauty and sensitive soul
Who's here grieving Sarah's passing 😢😢😢 Rip u beautiful gorgeous talented girl 🙏 🌹💕💖🕊️🕊️ xx
*"Wondering when I'm gonna see you again"* hits different now RIP Sarah 😭💔
Beautiful song
RIP Sarah Harding 💜 absolute talent
I used to be obsessed with girls aloud
Kit Kat same 😊
Used to be? I'm still making mashups with them.
I am still obsessed and I am just a boy.
Think & prey for Sarah....... she'll need it 🙏
@@mrtoptenatten😢rip Sarah 😢
A Great Pop song from 5 gorgeous and talented women. RIP Sarah Harding.
She is in a better place another angel looking down 🙂
csodás és már benne van a szomorúság is.....💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
RIP Sarah Harding. Love how the hair/makeup team styled her a la Twiggy for this video.
Five of the most beautiful women in music what a legacy immortal tune
easily their best song ever
sarah hardings vocals so good
sorry to hear of Sara's passing. She was magnificent and her memory will live on
RIP Sarah Harding 💖 you were a beautiful star loved by millions.
Absolute girl-band pop perfection this song.
Rest well, walking primrose.
I'd never heard of Girls Aloud until Sarah's passing, as I live in the US. Rest In Peace to her. I like this song! I would've totally been into it, had I known about it when it first came out. It's funky!
Gd song an they all looked gd x
Top of the pops nadine coyle was funny she lied about her age
Sarah was so well loved such a beautiful talent 😍
Beautiful Sarah. RIP gone too soon ❤❤
Yes, what a crying shame, but I wonder if Sarah Harding having implants had anything to do with her developing breast cancer? I say she had implants, as Sarah Harding seemed considerably smaller up top in her earlier years with Girls Aloud than in her later years-just a thought.
@@michaelwittmann2644 I can tell you’re really cut up about her death… what an insensitive comment. We’re not here to debate the cause of her death. But while you’re mentioning it, I don’t believe there’s a link between implants and breast cancer. Look it up.
@@LM085 You belong to a group of people who lack fortitude and are habitually offended by anything and everything that doesn't fit the tiny confines of your sensitive little mind. You might not be here to discuss Sarah Harding's cause of expiration, but for your information, this is a public forum, and as such, no subject is off limits. My catechism was legitimate; I remind you, it wasn't long ago that cigarettes were given to patients by doctors to alleviate sore throats. It is an inescapable medical fact that not only do implants increase a woman's chances of developing anaplastic large-cell lymphoma (ALCL), but they also increase other wide-ranging health complications for women: brain fog, memory loss, Squamous Cell Carcinoma (SCC) and various lymphomas, asymmetry, breast pain, joint pain, tissue atrophy, calcium deposits, deflation, extrusion, capsular contraction, and iatrogenic injury. Any thoughts that might warn others concerning health dangers ought to be investigated, even if it saves just one life from life-long health issues or something much worse. If we were all born with your unfortunate, restricted outlook on life, the world would be very bland and ignorant. I now bring to your attention a Maxim of Law-no man has the right not to be offended.
R.I.P Sarah Harding .YOU SHONE BRIGHT IN THIS VIDEO ..SHINE BRIGHT IN HEAVEN ANGEL ...gone far to soon !! x
RIP beautiful Sarah. God bless you and your family. Those left behind will remember you and therefore you will never be gone. Sleep tight.
Had to watch this.. just heard about Sarah Harding loosing her brave battle. Will be playing these tunes in her honor. RIP
The Promise was, in my opinion, their best track. I also believe Sarah's contribution raised it to the standard it achieved...a group that seemed as much about the looks as the music though Sarah's solo demonstrated that her looks were just the tip of an iceberg. R.I.P. sweet songstress
This was the first song that I think really showcased her vocals. Nadine got a lot of the leads glad she had this opportunity.
Always loved this song, reminds me of when I spent the best time of my life with the most beautiful girl I've ever known, how I wish I was 10 years younger 😥,love can be the most amazing feeling in life but also the worst pain ever.
Girls Aloud defined our generation! Rest in peace Sarah you beautiful kick ass angel!
Awesome video. They look fantastic. RIP Sarah.
This is simply timeless. Iconic. Should have been #1 the world over and not just in the UK. I love them.
RIP Sarah, beautiful woman, beautiful spirit, condolences to family and friends, no more pain now my love, sleep, 😢😢😢💕💘💞
I am really sad to hear of sarah's passing. It is really painful to see that girls aloud now is 4 members. My prayers to Sarah. RIP Sarah Harding.
RIP Sarah Harding! It still seems unreal that u aren’t here, i really wanted to see a GA performance or reunion and now i just can’t believe we won’t ever get to see the group as a whole 😭 gone but never forgotten!
RIP Sarah. You were an icon.
Keep the memories, Girls Aloud,
Who’s here still listening,
R I P Sarah
A Talent gone to soon
2022
Devastated to hear the news about Sarah sending lots of love to her family R.I.P. ❤️💔🙏😢 Ps Walking Primrose will be always my favourite part of this song love you Sarah forever. ❤️
,,,ako keby si mi písal z duše....,, úplne najlepší song..😀😀
Rest in peace Sarah! Taken too soon but you sure lived your life to the fullest when you were here! Thanks for the music!
*november 17, 2021*
happy 40th birthday sarah. there’s a light that never goes out❤️
I get emotional when I hear and see Sarah Harding..Rest in Peace and may perpetual light shine on heray she rest in peace ..great song girls
RIP Sarah Harding an absolute beauty and light in the music world
The ginger one is bloody gorgeous and Cheryl is a goddess tbh they're all fucking stunning definitely the most beautiful girl band
hard to believe the ginger one was often called the ugly one, she is beautiful, definitely the best looking, she doesnt seem to push herself to the front like the others, seems very coy and maybe shy, in a very sexy way
Nicola is the most articulate of the band.
Love them
Nicola Maria Roberts is the " Red Hot Red Head " . All the way from 10, Ullswater Ave, Stamford. Beautiful natural young lady, with huge talent.
My favourite is nadine
This Promise was definitely Sarah’s era. Singing the first verse and that walking primrose line was sketched on everyone’s minds when they think of this song! 🌻🪽
It’s The Promise, not Promise This!! Promise This is a 2010 song by one of their members Cheryl Tweedy
@@NicolasPetrosLanningmy bad. I keep mixing them up 😂
Rip Sara Harding. Beautiful lady. Forever you will be remembered.
Sarah Harding Brought me here. Not a GA fan but wow her vocals on this! RIP gone too soon x
RIP 🥀🥀🥀🥀 Sarah Harding 💔💔💔💔. I will listen that song all day today.
Already 12y remembrance 💐
Wishing the best for Sarah. She is strong and a fighter. 💙💙
Like that's gonna make a difference.
Best of luck to her though drug use is not a sign of strength of character.
Just shows a bunch of wee munters can be a financial success! 🙂
This aged like milk 😞
@@HannadayFLO What a horrible thing to say, started like a the mean coward you really apparently are.
So devestated about Sarah's passing may she RIP fly high beautiful angel 🙏❤️
Sarah Harding at her finest in this video. RIP Sarah Harding
Rest In Peace Sarah - Just so sad she was far too young - She seemed like such a bubbly, vibrant person
You never realise what you have .. till it's gone
baby dont you know!::::D
This makes me emotional now :(
😢
This song was all about Sarah for me RIP beautiful lady, no pain or suffering just flying free and resting in paradise ❤️❤️
Been thinking about Sarah a lot the last few days after seeing the rest of the Girls at the O2. Life is so unfair sometimes.
Back in 2013 at the last tour I was with my Mum and we talked about Sarah and her enthusiasm and vulnerability. She really stood out to us.
Now both Sarah and my Mum are gone. Rest in peace walking primrose 🌸
How can such a beautiful young talented women be taken so soon😭
Sarah was my favourite. She was beautiful and cheeky. RIP sweetheart 😢
So sad to hear that Sarah lost her battle with cancer today. R.I.P. Sarah Harding.
Can anyone explain why this song - drives me nuts - with sheer abandoned pleasure! I am now 64 years old - but hell! - it makes me feel like the teenager I once was! and no I was never a "fan" as such - but this song the way its sung - sheer pleasure - a brilliantly executed song - hats off to you all, "Girls Aloud!
Whatever decade.
Whatever fashion.
Whatever style.
Brit music is tops. 🇬🇧
Goodnight.
God bless you Sarah.
For making my youngest daughter happy.
All those years ago in 2003.
How girls should look. Gorgeous, pretty, and emphasise those good points.
Memories of this song, RIP Sarah.
"wondering when I`m goin see you again" Sarah Harding....goodnight beautiful soul......
So sorry for Sarah Harding prayers go to her family. Love girls aloud.
Sarah was such a *star* - her screen presence was insane here! In the video concept she's the "it girl" with all the aura and star quality and she totally sells it. Giving Twiggy or Edie Sedgwick 60's cool in the posing parts and Dusty Springfield glamour in the popstar segments.
I think this was one of her favorite songs maybe her favorite song
@@SiminaKiss it's one of my favs too
The best girls aloud song remembering sarah harding always in our hearts
I promise to look after u wherever u I go like this song
Rest in peace, Sarah. What a powerhouse of a voice. I wish she joined a jazz band or something after Girls Aloud ended. She definitely had the talent for it.
RIP Sarah she was definitely the dive of the band with her voice xxx
RIP lovely Sarah. You will always be my fave. So sad and unfair 😢 but your legacy will live on as being part of one of the greatest British girl bands
Best song from girls aloud RIP Sarah Harding
Rest in Perfection Sarah xx
I wish this was a big hit in the US
This is classic. Great outfit, melody, everything.
Dear Sarah, You did so well, now you can rest in peace.
We will miss you ♥️
These girls are all beautiful.. I really hope Sarah fights her cancer battle poor woman she is so young.
Its 2025 and this song is still a bop
What an awful loss . She seemed such a beautiful person inside and out. RIP Sarah .
Funny how many say Sarah couldnt sing but she was main vocals in nearly every chart topping song
Felt choked up watching Sarah in this. Was never a fan of the group but seeing her in this video looking so young, healthy and beautiful and knowing what we know now. Just so incredibly sad. 😞
Now she died today, rest in peace Sarah ❤
This was actually my favourite of all there tracks and I feel devastated at her passing and she so wanted a family.
R.I.P Sarah. Shine bright in that sky ❤️
RIP angel ♥️ such an amazing talent and beautiful human being
I remember watching Popstars The Rivals where Girls Aloud were created. Their first single was completely different to what everyone expected - not just another samey sounding girl band, but an edgy 5 piece outfit with a rock sounding song. Girls Aloud went on to have an amazing career with consistently brilliant songs. The Promise is about as perfect a pure pop song as you will ever get. Their writers and producers never got it wrong.
Who’s here because they grew up listening to girls aloud and actually like the song lol
Jade nope
Meeee❤
@zondaintheair no me too. Some of us appreciate good music 🎶 don't worry jade you're not alone 😂❤️
Jade soz vez
They were shit not one decent song. Sarah was a slapper from stockport I worked with a guy called nick at the airport he banged her over his BMW when he was a nightclub promoter the sun had a story with her n him in it.
it’s nice to see everyone back in these comments to mourn Sarah
Sarah exudes star quality and charisma here. She was so effortlessly magnetic and it’s a shame that was never really exploited as much as it could have been.
RIP Sarah Harding, this song is the first i think of when i think of you