How Should Christians View the Gap Theory? | Dr. Robert Carter

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 27

  • @Terrylb285
    @Terrylb285 Місяць тому +2

    Scientists corrected the early church and dominant worldview for almost 1500 years that the sun revolved around the earth . It took the church almost 100 years to admit their interpretation of scripture supporting geocentricity was skewed.

  • @Terrylb285
    @Terrylb285 Місяць тому +1

    YEC, OEC , Gap theorists. They all have a time gap, the debate is ,how long was it to the first mentioned evening.

  • @JohnMark1313
    @JohnMark1313 Місяць тому

    It's not that old and existed beyond your parents. It was in the notes of the Scofield Bible that was a required text in the Bible college I attended in the mid 70s and was taught as a legitimate option.

  • @fredwoods-o3g
    @fredwoods-o3g Місяць тому +2

    What's more plausible: we continue to discover new things that God faked about the universe, or the origin stories in the Bible were made by people that didn't know what they were talking about?

  • @scottatutube1
    @scottatutube1 Місяць тому +3

    Death is the punishment for sin for humans, not animals

    • @livingflame3845
      @livingflame3845 Місяць тому

      Correct. Jesus was not sent to redeem the animals for the sin of man.

    • @stankulp1008
      @stankulp1008 Місяць тому

      but animals didn't die until God covered Adam and Eve with animal skins on their way out of the Garden

    • @Terrylb285
      @Terrylb285 Місяць тому

      On day 7 God rests from creating even to this day .Correct there is no verse that says animals didn’t die before the fall of man. But we do have a verse that animals did die during Gods creation event. Psalm 104:29-30

    • @stankulp1008
      @stankulp1008 Місяць тому

      @@Terrylb285 your reference is about God feeding the animals, not about anything happening during creation

    • @Terrylb285
      @Terrylb285 Місяць тому

      @@stankulp1008 psalm 104:29-30. When you ignore them, they panic, when you take away their life’s breath, they die and return to the dust. When you send your life-giving breath, they are Created, and you replenish the surface of the ground. Read the broader context 104:5-30

  • @scottatutube1
    @scottatutube1 Місяць тому +3

    Hugh Ross has very cogent arguments for an old earth creation.

    • @Terrylb285
      @Terrylb285 Місяць тому

      Hugh Ross has the best scientific model that lines up with scripture.

  • @ecuador9911
    @ecuador9911 Місяць тому +1

    I think “gap” is a bad description of the difference between 1:1 and what follows. I’ve always looked at Genesis 1:1 as a “summary” statement (“In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.”) That summarizes all of physical creation. Everything that follows (Gen 1:2ff) concentrates on the creation of Earth. There is no “gap” but an understandable concentration on the portion of the creation story that impacts us the most.
    And yes the UNIVERSE is billions of years old, based on (1) TIME (as we understand it) and (2) observable information left by God’s general revelation. We are now using TIME (as we know it and measure it) that ITSELF was ALSO in the process of being created (along with space, matter and energy) during those six Yom.
    PLEASE stop using the Bible to determine the “age of the earth.” That’s why God gave us General Revelation.

    • @Terrylb285
      @Terrylb285 Місяць тому

      How long are the days (Yom) in genesis Is an interpretation debate. How old the is the universe is a science debate. You are correct, God Creates the Universe ( all physical matter). Then when the earth reaches it stage as a ball of water genesis 1:2 starts.

    • @larrybedouin2921
      @larrybedouin2921 Місяць тому

      Then why are we given genealogies?

    • @ecuador9911
      @ecuador9911 Місяць тому

      @@larrybedouin2921 I’m not sure what genealogies have to do with determining the age of the earth or the age of the universe. God created mankind AFTER He created everything else.
      Put another way, the time it takes to furnish a house doesn’t tell us how long it took to build the house.
      Genealogies certainly helped verify that Jesus was the Jewish Messiah.

    • @larrybedouin2921
      @larrybedouin2921 Місяць тому

      @@ecuador9911
      God created man on the sixth day of creation.

  • @ineffablewhune
    @ineffablewhune Місяць тому

    It's like this:
    {The notion that there's a gap between Genesis 1:1 & 1:2}
    is ONE thing.
    {The notion of what happened therein that hypothetical gap}*...
    is superficial to the first thing
    and with potentially infinite variations.
    Thus: every single narrative in regards to the latter could be erroneous; yet the primary premise of a gap in general... could still be accurate.
    The conflation of those two things being presented as scientific thought... is frankly laughable to me.
    It's like discounting the idea wheels are round...
    because someone thought the wheels were donuts; which wouldn't work.
    *hence "there's a bunch of different theories"
    Yes. There is. So be rational and ACTUALLY think like a scientist: Stop conflating them as one thing.

  • @davidrandell2224
    @davidrandell2224 Місяць тому

    THM in Gen.1:2 refers to the Tihamah regions- Hijaz, Asir and Yemen- in western Arabia,not the ‘deep.’ Start at start. “The Bible Came from Arabia “, Kamal Salibi,1985, plus his 3 other bible study books and blog for facts not fantasies. The Bible contains myth, legend, history and science. Separating them is not easy: Kamal Salibi does that quite well. Junaynah at Dn- garden of Eden- located at 20/20 by 42/55 in Asir region western Arabia with the 4 rivers and gold etc. Still Adam and Eve mythical and the trees and cherubim etc.

  • @scottatutube1
    @scottatutube1 Місяць тому

    Adam and eve were told to subdue the earth before the fall. Subdue is strong language. You don't subdue bunnies and daisies. You subdue things that are in chaos and unruly.

    • @stankulp1008
      @stankulp1008 Місяць тому

      incomplete thought, they were told to multiply and subdue

  • @larrybedouin2921
    @larrybedouin2921 Місяць тому

    Gap? Nay!
    It's called Hebrew parallelism.
    Reapeat and expand. It's a pattern found throughout the cannon of scriptures.