Medieval ages have always fascinated me. Though my fantasization had stemmed from reading childrens books back when I was a wee child, playing wooden swords and shields against your friends and cousins somewhere in the woods, building "castle forts" with your friends and movies that inspire medieval ages. When you actually start to learn the medieval ages and the history of it all as an adult, it paints a different picture in your mind that not only medieval folks (regardless of which time period of that age) were actually down right smart and sophisticated. Its politics, however, have not changed. I am talking about how politics now inherits how politicians were back then vs now. It was always about business and the people who mattered were the ones with money and influence.
That metallic shwing sound associated with drawing a sword is actually a Hollywood construct. A scabbard that made that sound would constantly dull your very expensive blade.
@@andypandy7769 Yeah labor was cheap, (actually it was free slave labor) but my point is is that it took a lot hard manual labor without the use of machines. Many people died building those castles and churches back then. I worked in construction building big structures and I know very well the value of machines. All of our parts were mass produced in mechanized factories.
How the castle was built was very important but also those who defended mattered a lot, their leader, supplies, what army they're facing, what weapons etc.
It must be a blast to live somewhere where you can get a job re-enacting the people from the distant past for these kinds of documentary-style programs lol I swear, I see the same group of people in multiple ones sometimes. 👍
Enact the slaughter of the people you are stealing land and hope from. Doesn't sound like fun or healthy amusement. Freakish. Have these victims ever received an apology or restitution? .
@@eijonassonhe's not joking and he's not wrong he's just a cynic. His world view is clouded by negativity this not allowing him to see the grandeur and majesty of the skilled work and artistry that went into these places. Yes it's true, for example, even today there are Welsh people that will not step inside any of the ring of iron castles and spit on the ground at their gates but mostly today Welsh people cherish the castles as a memory of times past. So don't let the negative people get you down man.
I genuinely enjoy the duality that is engineers, people who design and construct things(creators) are the very people you enlist to destroy things. I imagine men who were in charge of running trebuchets were actually well respected men. I feel like at my own job I was picked out of the bunch because my employer after a few weeks knew I was intelligent so he gave me a raise and a position that only someone with wit and general intelligence could actually do with nay success. I imagine that's exactly how you would have decided to put a guy on a trebuchet crew "Hey take this guy with you and show him the ropes" its not just a matter of constructing and deconstructing the device but also maintaining it and learning mathematics of matching your counterweight to the projectile weight and distances. Just things that you wouldnt put a common "grunt" doing which at the time was likely a peasent farmer who has no clue what hes doing or even who hes fighting or why.
6:58 What a public playground those lucky kids enjoyed! Puts my city park in Chicago to shame lol. I would very much like to know what specific castle that is if anyone knows
as a frequent player of long-range support classes in war games, I can tell you, when it comes to fighting fortifications, they were attacked with cunning and skill, and defended with guts and balls. I've been on both sides of the wall, and there's no wall that can help you when the attacker has mortars. .....or, rocket launchers.... whichever you fancy.
@@synvolatris8679 Combat Arms, TF2, World Of Tanks, AOE2, World In Conflict... World In Conflict was where I developed my support playstyle. Nobody had anticipated the use of support helicopters as a front line weapon!
Sieging or storming a fortified castle, you are always going to incur massive losses on your side as attackers. Castles are a extremely effective deterrent.
The stone castle, it sounds like a perfect jail where the prisoners got to first build the jail, then willingly wall themselves in. It seems like the outsiders had all the advantages.
To an extent, you are correct, but, don't forget defender or attacker, a siege was a costly affair on both sides... and most of the losses, that were not caused by disease or desertion, on the attackers side were usually caused by a defenders' sallying out to try to break the siege, or create set backs for the attacker.
It is not accurate saying canons made castles obsolete because the stone walls cannot stand the impacts.The more accurate picture is only the attackers have canons a very one sided fight. Not until the Vauban forts (Starting 1660?) did they start putting canons inside forts for defense. If you make the situation equal, by having canons inside castles, with lots of ammo, that would take some moderate design changes , better still a few 82 mm mortars, I don't care how many canons or trebuchets you have, you will not be able to get near them, the castle will not fall.
Compared to castles in east asia, Japan had some formidable castles like Odawara, Himeji and Osaka. They use stone as a main base and soil to fill the tiers of the castle layered defenses. Since Japan sits near the earthquake fault line, the structures had to be in wood with movable parts. The design of the Tenshu differs from european castles but still dangerous, many good stories come from the Japanese castles. Free doco could do some content on Japanese Castles.
Simon de Montfort spent his time acquiring lands to build a dynasty in Southern France, not chasing Cathar heretics. He left that up to the Dominicans. He was fighting Catholics for land. The siege of Toulouse where Simon was killed was manned by Catholics, not heretics! The most perfect part of his death was that it was from a rock hurled by a Mangonel operated by women. 😄
You say "The word siege means seat" and you explain that's when the army waits. Then a few minutes later you go on to say the siege was the bloodiest in history. How do the two correlate?
@@watermelon2223 I'm guessing my point was if siege is the sitting and waiting part of a battle then how can "the siege" have been the bloodiest in history? I think he meant the battle that ensued after the siege part was the bloodiest but I could be wrong.
Living in a castle was probably one of the worst experiences ever. Could you imagine the smell of fresh feces putrefying the very air you breath? No wonder the rich had homes in the country side.
Humans were so violent in those days. Nothing's changed, they still are. The human race doesn't impress when it comes to constant wars caused by overpopulation and the need for power and dominance. Humans are territorial, they will always fight.
*Amature battle re-creation scenes detract from this documentary series. Shots of grimacing models dressed up as kings and Lords also look amaturish, and serve no real purpose.*
Why make it shorter? If anything the could be longer. No ones fault but yours that you can't concentrate long enough to watch one that only goes for 48 minutes 🙄 Click over to the cartoon channel, might suit you better 😏
So I had to check and see if this was the same episode I watched before because MOST of this show is identical to episode one of the same series. This documentary sucks and I am not going to waste the time to watch any more of this or any other episodes. I wish I could block this uploader.
It feels like I am watching a masterpiece documentary. Most appreciated!
Medieval ages have always fascinated me. Though my fantasization had stemmed from reading childrens books back when I was a wee child, playing wooden swords and shields against your friends and cousins somewhere in the woods, building "castle forts" with your friends and movies that inspire medieval ages. When you actually start to learn the medieval ages and the history of it all as an adult, it paints a different picture in your mind that not only medieval folks (regardless of which time period of that age) were actually down right smart and sophisticated. Its politics, however, have not changed. I am talking about how politics now inherits how politicians were back then vs now. It was always about business and the people who mattered were the ones with money and influence.
Yep. That is a constant throughout all of history. So greed and corruption; two things we can always rely on.
Oh and I totally agree: smart and sophisticated. History is awesome.
Is it cold in there
That metallic shwing sound associated with drawing a sword is actually a Hollywood construct. A scabbard that made that sound would constantly dull your very expensive blade.
Good observations, I've never thought about that, if thats the case, what would a real scabbard mode out of?
@@liawweileong6036 Scabbards were made from wood. Sheathes were made from leather or some other fabric.
Unless the metal used to make the noise was designed to sharpen it, like a butcher’s knife and the rod he uses to maintain the edge
Metallica
Duh
People today: Look at those tall towers! How romantic!
Footmen 1000 years ago: *looking at the towers while praying to survive the siege*
xD
+1 for the pictures and history. -1 for the social commentary.
Je suis heureuse de vivre dans cette époque je ne voudrais pour rien au monde vivre dans le passé.
The roofs floors and any other wood pieces are always gone and it is a true sinking you feel in your heart for the magnificent buildings they were👊👊👊
Great video. Boggles my mind the amount of manual labor that it took to manufacture the parts and build these castles.
@@andypandy7769 Yeah labor was cheap, (actually it was free slave labor) but my point is is that it took a lot hard manual labor without the use of machines. Many people died building those castles and churches back then.
I worked in construction building big structures and I know very well the value of machines. All of our parts were mass produced in mechanized factories.
And the labor to bring engines of war to bring these mighty places down
Thank you very much for uploading...❤️ From India
Excellent video.
Great documentary 👏👏
Very entertaining and enjoyable, thankyou.
You're very welcome! :)
Excellent Documentary!
How the castle was built was very important but also those who defended mattered a lot, their leader, supplies, what army they're facing, what weapons etc.
🤗🤗
It must be a blast to live somewhere where you can get a job re-enacting the people from the distant past for these kinds of documentary-style programs lol I swear, I see the same group of people in multiple ones sometimes. 👍
ÀaàA
Enact the slaughter of the people you are stealing land and hope from.
Doesn't sound like fun or healthy amusement.
Freakish.
Have these victims ever received an apology or restitution? .
@@eijonassonYou are joking, right?
@@eijonassonhe's not joking and he's not wrong he's just a cynic. His world view is clouded by negativity this not allowing him to see the grandeur and majesty of the skilled work and artistry that went into these places. Yes it's true, for example, even today there are Welsh people that will not step inside any of the ring of iron castles and spit on the ground at their gates but mostly today Welsh people cherish the castles as a memory of times past. So don't let the negative people get you down man.
Well worth the watch hello from Australia
Very good work
Nice, How about a documentary on tower houses?
I genuinely enjoy the duality that is engineers, people who design and construct things(creators) are the very people you enlist to destroy things. I imagine men who were in charge of running trebuchets were actually well respected men. I feel like at my own job I was picked out of the bunch because my employer after a few weeks knew I was intelligent so he gave me a raise and a position that only someone with wit and general intelligence could actually do with nay success. I imagine that's exactly how you would have decided to put a guy on a trebuchet crew "Hey take this guy with you and show him the ropes" its not just a matter of constructing and deconstructing the device but also maintaining it and learning mathematics of matching your counterweight to the projectile weight and distances. Just things that you wouldnt put a common "grunt" doing which at the time was likely a peasent farmer who has no clue what hes doing or even who hes fighting or why.
I love histroy!
Best show ever!!!
This is going to be useful info after WW3
14:40 that music is from the "Saving Private Ryan" soundtrack lol that's an interesting choice.
I agree with you it's a weird placement in the documentary too. I've heard songs from stronghold crusader and C&C Generals also in some of these too
Good documentary tbh
its a very good channel
6:58
What a public playground those lucky kids enjoyed! Puts my city park in Chicago to shame lol. I would very much like to know what specific castle that is if anyone knows
I believe that is Cité de Carcassonne
@@TheJusnic82yanno what I see roman and medieval in it and the touch of restoration work. I think you must be right.
as a frequent player of long-range support classes in war games, I can tell you, when it comes to fighting fortifications, they were attacked with cunning and skill, and defended with guts and balls.
I've been on both sides of the wall, and there's no wall that can help you when the attacker has mortars.
.....or, rocket launchers.... whichever you fancy.
What games?
@@synvolatris8679 Combat Arms, TF2, World Of Tanks, AOE2, World In Conflict...
World In Conflict was where I developed my support playstyle. Nobody had anticipated the use of support helicopters as a front line weapon!
I always cheat and use nukes.
@@bcn1gh7h4wkI like to play Foxhole. If you haven’t seen it, I would totally check it out!
Freeze at 23:16:
The leaning tower of Pisa is now a proven military tactic
Sieging or storming a fortified castle, you are always going to incur massive losses on your side as attackers. Castles are a extremely effective deterrent.
Groovy...
Does anyone know what song is played via the violin? example: timestamp starting 4:23 - 5:00 violin and piano.
The keep a/k/a panic room.
In the engineering contest between kinetics and stationary fortifications, kinetics always wins.
King in the castle, king in the castle...Wawaweewaa
King of my castle ;)
The stone castle, it sounds like a perfect jail where the prisoners got to first build the jail, then willingly wall themselves in. It seems like the outsiders had all the advantages.
To an extent, you are correct, but, don't forget defender or attacker, a siege was a costly affair on both sides... and most of the losses, that were not caused by disease or desertion, on the attackers side were usually caused by a defenders' sallying out to try to break the siege, or create set backs for the attacker.
Really enjoyed this and thank you for showing us footage instead of cartoons like its some sort of glorified bloody video game.
Anyone know the name of the Music???
It is not accurate saying canons made castles obsolete because the stone walls cannot stand the impacts.The more accurate picture is only the attackers have canons a very one sided fight. Not until the Vauban forts (Starting 1660?) did they start putting canons inside forts for defense. If you make the situation equal, by having canons inside castles, with lots of ammo, that would take some moderate design changes , better still a few 82 mm mortars, I don't care how many canons or trebuchets you have, you will not be able to get near them, the castle will not fall.
19:28 Ladies & Lords, behold Minas Morgul
Compared to castles in east asia, Japan had some formidable castles like Odawara, Himeji and Osaka. They use stone as a main base and soil to fill the tiers of the castle layered defenses. Since Japan sits near the earthquake fault line, the structures had to be in wood with movable parts. The design of the Tenshu differs from european castles but still dangerous, many good stories come from the Japanese castles. Free doco could do some content on Japanese Castles.
Why does that one musical piece feel like the imperial march?????
Great documentary, but have I been spelling defense wrong my whole life? Or is defence a different word or meaning??
Wonderful, no wonder the peasants are revolting.
Yes, the peasants were very revolting.
My god the music at 24:40 is epic, anyone know the name? I tried with sound recognition apps but no luck.
It's all just generic epic music, there are lots of these on UA-cam, you can listen to them until your ears fall off
isn't it awkward for the current Cold Stream Guards? the whole Cromwell bit?
"History" is spelled wrong in the title of this video
That's the English spelling.
Say this phonetically - "Wot? Ye dun like ya histroy?" - and see how English you sound.
They had better skills to build than we could muster today with what we have 😂💪
Untrue. Modern concrete and steel structures are far superior. Ridiculous romanticism is what you’re doing
Good content but the cinematography is nauseating (e.g. constant use of panning overly tight shots) and makes this series literally unwatchable.
Why was the Norman prince bishop black? Was that accurate.
I want one CASTLE IN ENGLAND AND IM GUNNA CRUSH THE OPPOSTION WITH A MASSIVE DEF POS TO UPGRADE THIS TO SHOWCASE THIS POWER
Simon de Montfort spent his time acquiring lands to build a dynasty in Southern France, not chasing Cathar heretics. He left that up to the Dominicans. He was fighting Catholics for land.
The siege of Toulouse where Simon was killed was manned by Catholics, not heretics! The most perfect part of his death was that it was from a rock hurled by a Mangonel operated by women. 😄
The castles and the video both
A lot of "Darth Vader music" going on in this segment lol
You say "The word siege means seat" and you explain that's when the army waits. Then a few minutes later you go on to say the siege was the bloodiest in history. How do the two correlate?
It was only the bloodiest because of the conclusion, the majority of the siege was uneventful but the end was very bloody
@@watermelon2223 I'm guessing my point was if siege is the sitting and waiting part of a battle then how can "the siege" have been the bloodiest in history?
I think he meant the battle that ensued after the siege part was the bloodiest but I could be wrong.
@@Mister_Holdsworth idk lol I guess the killing of enemy troops was like the conclusion of a siege
Living in a castle was probably one of the worst experiences ever. Could you imagine the smell of fresh feces putrefying the very air you breath? No wonder the rich had homes in the country side.
Far too many ads. Ads are harassment.
Etamebut spelled backwards. 😉
Humans were so violent in those days. Nothing's changed, they still are. The human race doesn't impress when it comes to constant wars caused by overpopulation and the need for power and dominance. Humans are territorial, they will always fight.
*Amature battle re-creation scenes detract from this documentary series. Shots of grimacing models dressed up as kings and Lords also look amaturish, and serve no real purpose.*
Thanks for the wonderful documentary, but you could make it shorter 👌,
Thanks.
Why make it shorter? If anything the could be longer. No ones fault but yours that you can't concentrate long enough to watch one that only goes for 48 minutes 🙄 Click over to the cartoon channel, might suit you better 😏
@@wendyc1658 hehehe thanks for your long comment 😉, Yes will watch cartoons with you together 😋.
Thanks.
@@Samady95 hahaha great comeback
Get rid of all the damn ads!!!!!!!!
If we got rid of "all the damn ads!!!!!!!" this channel wouldn't exist.
Jesus rose from dead
Like reincarnation
So he didn’t actually sacrifice anything did he?
@rekaputri.official @aqiss and family
So I had to check and see if this was the same episode I watched before because MOST of this show is identical to episode one of the same series. This documentary sucks and I am not going to waste the time to watch any more of this or any other episodes. I wish I could block this uploader.
I'm sure they can gladly block you
G
Thieving is far from being a good topic for education or entertainment. Despicable !
;
albno zgnij