The Best Diet According To [18] Studies
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 гру 2024
- The best diet for longevity isn’t keto, or vegan, or carnivore, or Mediterranean.
For weekly health research summaries and extra sights, sign up here 👉 drstanfield.co...
💊 Supplements I Take: drstanfield.co...
💊 MicroVitamin (multivitamin & mineral that I take): drstanfield.co...
📜 Roadmap - how to look young & feel strong: drstanfield.co...
✔️ Twitter: / bradstanfieldmd
✔️ Patreon: / bradstanfieldmd
Here are the links to the research papers referenced in the video:
www.niddk.nih....
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
www.bmj.com/co...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.sciencedir...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.cochrane.o...
www.thelancet....
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
www.uptodate.c...
www.cochrane.o...
The links above are affiliate links, so I receive a small commission every time you use them to purchase a product. The content contained in this video, and its accompanying description, is not intended to replace viewers’ relationships with their own medical practitioner. Always speak with your doctor regarding the content of this channel, and especially before using any products, services, or devices discussed on this channel.
Hope you're having a great week!
💊MicroVitamin (multivitamin & mineral that I take): drstanfield.com/products/microvitamin
📜Roadmap - how to look young & feel strong: drstanfield.com/pages/roadmap
Doc, you do an amazing job of giving lots of useful information in a succinct way! Keep it up and thank you!
I was until I started reading the comments. Now I've got a migraine weekend judging by the current prodrome 😂😂😂
Olive oil and avocado a rich in monounsaturated fats. It is not a good idea to generalice unsaturated fats as good fats, imo.
Foods that promote longevity would be a good video as the title suggests.
I think all the research just keeps pointing to one simple conclusion: Whole foods r good and overly processed foods r bad. Lol, obviously more nuanced than that but I think it hits the overarching idea. No need for any food religion or tribalism. Just eat more whole foods and find the ones you love to cook and eat with your family.
That sounds sustainable. Me like it
Yup, and avoid eating a lot of high oxalate “whole” foods. Watch Sally Norton on the topic if you have’t yet.
What are Whole Foods? I know probably dumb question but I hear this a lot and don’t fully get it because even the Whole Foods seem like they can be unhealthy as well
@@HammyGirl999is spinach one?
@@HammyGirl999and there you go getting right into the tribalism.
I'm glad the point was made that while many diets can help a person lose weight, most aren't good for long-term health. Not just weight loss but overall health.
The problem with doing a " diet " is that it infers an end goal to stop at. That is why I like Keto with fasting, it is a lifestyle, not a temporary state. It is easy to do, and has massive, objective and very importantly , subjective results.
@@mgib1325 A diet is a way of eating. That simple. You can call it a lifestyle if it tickles your fancy. And your objective results for long-term health may not be ideal. But everyone has the freedom to eat how they like.
@aaronwright7266 very true. Let's face it, if you can cut out all the processes foods that the industry has people hooked on, then you are already making a massive impact on your help. From the food industry, to Dr.s , to health insurance to pharma, the entire US medical system is just one big money making scam. Add in things like FDA approving low fat , high sugar ( carb) diet, then it is tough for people to know what is best.
what you are doing is really valuable man
changes other people lives
thank you so much
Please consider making a vid exploring studies on taurine impact on prolactin and GH. Thanks
Isn't brushing your teeth directly after a meal bad for enamel ? I thought research showed that
Not really, but avoid brushing for 30 min after you’ve had very acidic food. Like vinegar, citrus juices,...
@@werundwarum that's what I was thinking about
Practicing dentist here. This would only apply for a VERY acidic meal. Also smart to avoid brushing immediately after vomiting. Waiting half an hour allows your saliva to buffer the pH changes back to normal. In all other circumstances, brushing after a meal should generally be fine.
@@mmwosu good to know, thanks !
chew xylito gum first
I have one kidney(one was removed due to birth defect at age 22) and take 40mg listinopril for blood pressure. My potassium is always high and my blood pressure runs 135/80. I have a right bundle branch block and partial left bundle branch block with thousands of ectopic beats a day already. I really wish I could eat lots of veggies and fruits a day but have to keep most of them at lower consumption so as to keep my potassium intake moderate to low. I am 69yo. I think everyone should understand that eating too much potassium is NOT always a good thing. Some of us could have dangerous consequences from a high potassium diet.
Potassium is not a problem for people without hyperkalemia. This is why people should get their blood tested annually or every couple of years. The standard metabolic panel includes blood potassium. I eat 8 to 10 grams of potassium each day, while my sodium is below 1.5 g/day. My last blood test showed my K level at 4.5 mmol/L, Na at 139 mmol/L, and Cl at 100 mmol/L. All in mid-range healthy levels.
Go carnivore.
You are a brave man to take on the diet zealots. Best of luck
Thanks!
Thanks Keith!
Research, facts, evidence, science. And this is why we love Dr. Brad.
Nutritional science isnt facts or science its Pseudo science .
There's so many studies though. Others can cite studies showing otherwise. I trust Longo more on protein, he's qualified in carrying out studies, and does it full time, all his life, not just a practising GP. All Brad states here to support more protein is an associative study. Which is easily subject to reverse causation. Bigger muscles are very often the result of people who exercise a lot, are already healthy, can move. Every animal tested lived longer with reduced protein (but not too low). All the blue zones ate a low protein diet. Best to read Longo's book, not trust a random video.
@@andrewnorris5415 Yeah but maybe blue zones people less buying food from store, they grow own veggies, fruits, animals. Look what they doing most time people they working and moving a lot, not sitting in office or in cars all time. It is a big difference in life and they get a less stress .
@@yummymealsss of course. to be in a blue zone you have to by necessity, max everything out. There is only a few of them. Plenty of other placed in the world lived low stress, moved a lot (it was very common back then, the norm around the world), ate more protein - and they were not a blue zone...
@@andrewnorris5415 and blue zone itself not a fact, its probably a hoax. Fake birth certs, bad data, unscientfic measurements
Probably the most confusing thing is saturated fat. We have half of the doctors on youtube saying saturated fat is good then half of them saying saturated fat is bad. It is REALLY difficult to decide who is right.
Good point! Same with meat!
Saturated animal fat is very bad long term, in any amount. Certain saturated plant fats like stearic acid in cocoa are healthy. The doctors saying saturated animal fats are good are confused by studies that are extremely flawed. These studies pit saturated animal fats vs margarine or mineral oil but describe them as seed oils. A blatant lie. Margarine is completely a processed food over 90 percent trans fats.
There isn't one study out there that doesn't show saturated animal fats to be significantly worse for the heart than polyunsaturated fats which are from plants and actually healthy. I've read them all.
This is why you have to be careful about who you get your information from. If you dont want to get your hands dirty and directly read the literature, then you need to develop a strong sense of someone's credibility, aswell as an idea of what the "totality" of current evidence tends to. People who speak in absolutes are people you should ignore. All in all, relatively low amounts of saturated fat in your diet will likely be fine, higher amounts will likely lead to worse health outcomes. This varies from person to person too.
@@Fearzero you indicate stearic acid is healthy 'plant' fat, but it's also one of the most abundant fatty acid in red meat as well.
Yes, it's sad what some doctors will do to get more youtube clicks. Maybe you should look elsewhere to educate yourself.
Another helpful video. Thanks Dr. Brad!
I struggled to try and lose weight for 8 solid years of actively trying to lose weight even with being very physically active. 10 mile walks, 20 mile bike rides, working all day on my feet I was still 250 pounds. I ended up to 320 lbs at 25 years old. I started fasting, got rid of sugar, cut carbs, got better sleep, and transitioned to getting rid of processed foods. I'm now 29 years old, and under 220 lbs, still reaping benefits. When I want to lose a few pounds, I go a few days without eating. Fasting and going low carb definitely helped me jump start my health transformation. I'm not afraid of carbs though. I did up my protein intake over this last year given the conversations with protein.
Before watching my guess is that it is the diet that helps you stay lean while also keeping your lipids in check and you feel good on, regardless of which diet that is.
I'm doing carnivore and getting great success with it. I think one of the biggest reasons why it's so good is that clean, healthy, non-engineered fruits and vegetables that have no forever chemicals sprayed on them practically doesn't exist.
Basically I would be ketovore instead of carnivore, but red meat is practically the only thing I can get that I know for sure hasn't been ruined by psycho-food-science.
Do you know your meat is not vaxxxed?
What are these forever chemicals that have been sprayed on your veggies? And how come they don't get into your red meat?
So animals don't eat vegetables?
all that saturated fat and lack of fibre in your diet will give you long-term chronic inflammation - the root cause of all age related chronic diseases
The the United States, 80% of all antibiotics are used in factory farming and the dairy industries. Also, the pollution from these literal slaughter houses are in the top 4 dirty industries. Finally, the horrific suffering on an industrial scale is grotesque.
been doing keto for 8 years, very hard to gain weight; always full and no longer obsessed about food
I must say that this is one of your best videos ever! Thank you - much appreciated…
Excellent information. Just curious are you familiar with the work of the NZ based neurologist Dr. Matt Phillips who has been running trials on many neurological disorders
such as Parkinsons, Dementia and Brain Cancer. He is focused on the mitochondria and encourages Omad and a Carnivore diet. His trials have been showing a decrease in
symptoms. Based on his work I think the focus should be on metabolic health and fasting as the primary way to achieve long lasting health.
One point I am interested in that I have not heard before is the clinical significance of an early dinner. I took a look at the abstracts of the linked articles but could not find a related one, perhaps I missed it?
Hi Dr. Brad. If I am not mistaken your are conducting a study on rapamycin, so that means that you hope that lowering mTor helps for longevity. Now you say that we should keep leucine high. I am kind of confused.
Transient spikes of mTor is not to be avoided and actually needed to build muscle.
Exercise actually lowers mTor, while you're exercising. Then eating protein with some carbs spikes mTor to build muscle. mTor is best thought of as a spring that is activated & deactivated. Folks should think of 'cycling' mTor, not permanently activating or deactivating it.
I do fully appreciate that you take newest data into your videos yearly instead of sticking to one ideal. Just the guy I was looking for as the other docs seem to stick to their money maker. Thank you for not selling more than one supplement as well. Immersing your stuff more than others
Which of the two of you is correct in understanding the effects of cholesterol and its individual expressions in creating Cardiovascular problems, you or DR. Rob Lusting? The analysis made by Dr. Rod Lusting differs from your approach.
I would greatly appreciate it if you could give me an informed answer
I think Robert Lustig adheres to the insulin hypothesis.
high fiber and high protein has been my diet-it’s pretty hard to overeat if you try to hit both as foods high in one or the other are very satiating
7:58 The graph suggests that ideally you should consume no salt at all, but if you do then you will certainly die because salt is an essential nutrient. Longevity is affected by many things, not just blood pressure. We need to see how salt intake correlates with mortality, which is the subject of the video - that would give us a U-shaped curve, but I have no idea where the minimum would be.
Protein and fibre are linked to greater satiety so they should definitely be considered when creating your diet
The main problem with weight loss is that is that the body fat is a survival mechanism.
It stores energy for periods of food insecurity.
Weight loss is basically a massive long term caloric deficit, which basically means subjecting organism to food insecurity stress.
So natural thing for the organism is to try to gain more fat stores as a buffer for such events. Hence it will do things like slowing down metabolism or using survival-level hunger signals to get one to eat above maintenance. Stuff like eating more protein and refeeds just delay it, not prevent it.
Also, it's not just a question of weight regain. A big problem is hitting the wall with weight loss long before getting out of obesity.
Like yeah there are always these people in the comments who show up and talk about losing all excess weight and maintaining after changing their diet, usually to keto or low carb in general, but the problem is that they aren't the norm.
Like there are people with ED who can literally starve themselves to death but most of people with ED are overweight, not underweight.
Completely disagree, eat foods that improve metabolic processes and make the mitochondria more effective.
@drbradstanfield Would you consider making a video on the steps you're taking to reduce your LDL? You've mentioned pushing for a very low LDL, but I don't think you have a video on that specifically. For readers who are dying from high cholesterol, knowing what works to get it as low as you would really help.
Thank you!
The average LDL cholesterol level of a centenarian is about 110 mg/dL. Some anorexics have very high cholesterol levels as the body is trying hard to protect itself. Notice how the body raises cholesterol levels to protect itself from disease, not lowers it.
Is the low sodium intake really universally valid now, or is there still a debate on whether it’s just for sodium sensitive individuals?
i've been low-carb for 2 years. starting having left calf cramps. went away after i started taking 1 tbsp of iodized sea salt in water every morning. i think i was low on salt.
Low sodium has never been universally valid, its an on-going thing that is simple not supported by the evidence.
The problem with many of these studies is focusing primarely on weight loss, it is only one factor but not the best criteria of measuring metabolic health. It would be much relevent to track fasting insulin, TG/HDL ratio or waist circumference. I agree the adherence problem is very important, that"s why we should not do "diets" but rather understand the causes of bad health and change our life style accordingly.
Excellent video again Dr Brad. Thankyou😊
Hello Dr Brad I have seen many times that inhibiting mTOR is supposed to be a way to boost longevity. However, a high protein diet preserved your muscle mass and probably only does so by activating mTOR to stop catabolism. This suggests that a high protein may not be good for lifespan as it doesn't inhibit mTOR. What do we do? Am I missing something?
Don't focus on individual mechanisms. They will lead you astray.
No lifestyle factor is good for all mechanisms.
Salt is a problem if you have hypertension, Sodium retension is caused by hyper insulinemia. Removing the salt is just treating a symptom, maybe we should focus on the cause.
Is it true that sodium has only in 1 out of 5 persons a big effect on blood pressure? Why should the other 80% cut out salt? Also, salt is a electrolyte and we need it. I crave it sometimes.
I really enjoy these videos and the way the information is presented with scientific rigor.
Well, a couple of things are misstated. The graph for salt shows a U shape, so 'low salt' should be 'proper salt.' The other item involves confounding among unsaturated fats. MUFA and omega-3 fats, sure, but there is growing evidence that omega-6 fats need to be limited. As for saturated fats, their vilification is gradually coming unwound, so it is too early to commit. Other than these points, the presentation is more objective and spot-on than the norm, by far.
You (and Brad) missed the bit about water - diet fizzy drinks are shown to help weight-loss more than just water.
What about activation of mTor associated with proliferation of ERC, causing epigenetic noise in high-protein diets?
It's Carnivegopaleomadashatkinterianism. You're welcome
I thought it's photosynthesis, or whatever the yogis who claim to live off of sun do.
😂😂😂
@@LVArturs, breatharianism
@@Joe_C. That was a scam and most of the followers died prematurely.
Where is the pesci, where are you getting your omega 3 bro?
I did low sodium diet I started having headaches but after I added half a tablespoon of salt of sea salt. Then my headaches vanished with the half of a tablespoon of sea salt. Why did this happen to me? I did the low sodium and headaches started but add salt back into my diet and the headaches disappeared.🤔
A breath of truth. TU. I've been following longevity experts. The one thing they all have in common is a direct relationship to a company selling their products.
G’day Brad, thanks for another informative video.
I have a silly point, to point out. At about 9:40 you have a list of fundamentals. One of them is high protein (1.6g per kg).
I know this refers to lean body weight, but perhaps there are people who don’t, so they end up possibly even doubling what they should have. So perhaps place in the bracket “based of lean body weight”
A question, what is your opinion about the health value, regularity of consumption etc. for vital wheat protein ?
It’s now an hour after I left the comment. I’m watching your other diet video called “be healthier than 99.7% of people”…. You stated the protein requirement is based from lean body weight. Golly you are quick
This is basically my diet - as for not starchy tubers, sweet potatoes and pumpkins are a net positive I believe. I try to keep carbs low anyway, as something has to give to keep calories low and eat lots of the good stuff. Nuts . avocado and Olive oil do take up quite a bit of daily calories. Bulk out on not starchy veggies
Do people know of a quick healthy breakfast? I was doing oatmeal and eggs for a while but it made me feel sluggish. I love toast and gives me energy but i know its not good for me. Should i just eat fruit? I noticed if i skip breakfast i dont have the energy to exercise later in the day.
Just oatmeal without the eggs? Make it with water, add some fruit to it?
Or something like Huel?
Steak and eggs
@@MichaelGGarry I ate it as porridge and added things like fruit and honey but it gets old and takes time to make.
Great info as always, thank you!
Such a blessing discovering your channel, Thank you Dr. Brad!
No blessing . Only chance
This is good summary. In medical fielt protein supplements are recommended for elderly whereas some Japanese retrospective studies show that Japanese who consume meat, milk products, alcohol and sugary stuff in moderate way live longer. Also other studies suggest that in humans protein intake of 0,75-1 g/weight in kiloes could be superior to high protein intake what comes to longevity. Theory is that protein cause aging in DNA and cell level.
I'd love to see the research that you're basing yourself on for your recommendations.
While I won’t claim it’s necessary for long term health, going keto and doing IF corrected many of my health issues and helped me lose weight where all else failed.
I think protein balance and salt balance is the key. Your output in terms of exercise will decide how much of these you need. If you're not resistance training/exercising then excess protein will lead to gluconeogenesis and be used for energy. If you're doing a lot of cardio/sweating, you need sufficient salt. I wouldnt recommend blanketly reducing salt intake. Have some salt, exercise and sweat as much as possible, and monitor your blood pressure. Im popping salt tablets on my longer runs for example.
Micro vitamin as a powder please? With hydrolysed collagen and creatine monohydrate?
Salt intake has never been proven to cause high bloodpressure
Yes and water has never been proven to be wet.
People are such ass holes! Just listen to the way you talk to each other. WOW..
THe real correllation is between junk and high BP, so the idiots conclude it was the salt - not the seed oils and refined carbs.
Eat meat - lots of it, preferably fatty
Thank you for your talk. I’m using the WW program for the past 26 days and on it I consume much of their ”Zero Points” foods which are those you mentioned (fruits, non-starchy vegetables, beans/legumes). I also consume lean meats. It has been helping and yes, my desire for salt is decreasing. It’s easy to fail however I’m sticking to it because I’m tired of bouncing around from diet to diet. I also picked up a low dose multi, like you said and I notice that my fingernails are growing in now without ridges, so I was missing some kind of nutrients and this low-dose multi solved that, and probably helping other body processes within that were stressed as well. I think we also have to keep an eye on total caloric intake per day because in my experience if I go over 1,200 calories per day, I will not lose any weight. But that’s me, and we each have to adjust accordingly. I’ve lost 5 pounds this month.
Excellent info
Whats wrong with starchy veg? Potato and kumara is bad?
The only way to make starch palatable is to eat it with butter.
Better to stick to fatty meat
Better not to eat carcinogens and saturated fat...
Many people like the Weston A Price diet with Whole Foods from clean farms
What is low fat diet? 20% or 10-12% ?
Big difference.
Hey Brad, can you do a video on C60? I have had a few people bring it up and it seems like total nonsense from what I can tell. Thanks for the content. Hope the family is doing well!
Where does sprouted whole grain bread fall in this?
Sooooo, high protean and fresh fruit and veg... sounds like the Keto diet to me? The inclusion of wholegrains might be considered OK on keto as the fiber in them counters the carbohydrates.
When a study was done on centenarians (people who lived 100+ years) they had nothing in common as far as food intake was concerned, they all consumed varied good wholesome food including meat, fish, dairy and eggs. The native Americans sometimes consumed a diet almost 90% bison meat and and had some of the longest longevity rates in the world, it has nothing to do with meat. the centenarians only had one thing in common LOW BLOOD SUGAR! So long as your diet consists of good wholesome food including meat (esp. red meat), fish, dairy and eggs (no processed rubbish esp. sugar) and you avoid carbs (esp. refined carbs) and seed oils you will have NO issues!
That does make a great deal of sense - esp when you consider that for 90% of human evolution that's what we ate.
Frequent eating and high carbs combine to produce insulin resistance, which is behind so many diseases - diabetes, dementia, heart disease, stroke, arthritis, erectile disfunction, cancer, cataracts, and others. If you have a varied diet, eat no more than three times a day and reduce your carbs while concentrating on fat and protein then you will have little to worry about.
Brilliantly covered
low carb mediteranean diet is excellent, however new findings about olive oil including high amounts of micro plastics is disturbing
😳❗️Oh NO ...
What "new findings" about Olive Oil?
I go through gallons of it.
Can you explain or provide a link?
Thank you.
@@TheDulciferolive oil is the safest oil, however its something we should be aware of as consumers and pressure companies to find ways of reducing that contamination . heres what i found
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24016262/
The more microplastics in my oil the better. I am a very stubborn person and will not settle for anything but the maximum levels of microplastics.
Dentists recommend waiting at least 30 minutes after a meal before brushing your teeth due to high acidity levels in the mouth that make the enamel sensitive(which may lead to translucent teeth). A better approach may be to rinse with water, wait 30 min at least and then brush
Is it true that new study suggests that saturated in diary products isnt associated with increase in heart disease
It seems to be a complicated topic. I found two older studies that suggested the saturated fat in milk is less dangerous. But also three studies from 2017-2019 that still find correlations. Could not find a new one.
The confusion comes from not controlling for the food replacement. I favour observational studies with substitution analysis, and trials!
Hi Brad, did you sell your Tesla shares at the peak of the market? I hope so. You got them when they were below 100.
My question is, does this weight-based protein intake ratio apply to all body type? I mean, slender, average and overweight people? It does not make much sense to me that two people weighing the same, however one being short and overweight and the other one being tall and slender, should require the same amount of protein. It would make more sense if that calculation were done on the person's ideal weight for their body stature. How does the amount of accumulated fat relates to protein consumption? Again, excellent video! Too bad Microvitamins are a😂vailable here in Brazil!
More sensible is protein g per lean mass kg. Quality also matters, less quality protein is needed.
1.6 grams/kg might give you a smidge more muscle than 1.2 but the difference is very small.
Sir , how about super green mix supplement with all important vegetables and fruits , is it worth to buy , because some country peoples couldn’t have chance to consume all vegetables
Just a thought, but is there a health-promoting effect in seriously adopting any systematic dietary plan? Perhaps the sense of having some conscious control over one's own health is, in itself, health-promoting. Obviously, some diets are probably healthier than others, but the simple act of choosing (however difficult to maintain) might be the essential, unnoticed factor.
If you have a healthy weight, what kind of diet give you extra longevity then?
Success is not built on success. It's built on failure, it's built on frustration, it's built on fear that you have to overcome. I pray that everyone who reads this remains successful in life.
He just glossed over fizzy drinks. Is that just sodas? Or is it any mineral water, soda water, bubly flavored water type drinks?
Rest easy, it's just soda.
Could you please covert Androgen Receptor Upregulator like L-Carnitine for muscle growth?
Sodium sneaks up on you, it's a challenge to avoid it but staying away from restaurant and processed food works.
"What's the best longevity diet?" Proceeds to tell me the best weight-loss diet. Mmk.
Yeah, I had the same thought. There's a lot of overlap between staying thin and living longer but they're not the same thing.
That meta analysis is checkmate to the people claiming no association between saturated fat intake and cardiovascular disease. I'm going to use it well. People need to be informed on the risks and benefits of their diets to make an informed decision.
.My mother 80 has to make sure to salt her food enough and has to drink salt water every day to live, if she doesn't she ends up in the hospital getting transfusions to get it back up. So telling everyone to cut their sodium intake is not safe.
I think it's important to point out that saturated fat research is not so qualitative starting with the FFQ, if you include as saturated fat hot dogs, burgers with fries of course it will be bad. But high quality meat of animal sources? Not so sure. Keeping apoB in check while consuming saturated fat is likely safe for CVD. Anyway, I would say more research is needed here and personally I will eat red meat from time to time, taking into account the cooking
Let’s see how apoB compares when consuming grass fed beef vs beans.
1) Foods high in refined sugar spike insulin which increases body fat, activates Mtor, and increases inflammation.
2)Increased protein intake as you suggested is the name of the game BUT NOT from animal sources. Why? because the animal fat (which is saturated fats) increases bodily inflammation which then damages cells, increases oxidation and accelerates the aging process.
So eat plant based protein to get the protein intake you need (which has the healthy unsaturated fats) and without the inflammation that comes from animal fat. There!!
By the way, I love red meat, but I feel amazing when I eat it at most once per week.
Very good information but considering that avoiding meat at all you could lost some important nutrients found it only in meat as B-12 and other high rate of aminoacids as Leucine, Isoleucine, Valine or Glutamine where ground been have a higher rate. Also creatine...so the most important thing it's a balance and red meat part and how was raise the animal
People are so sick who would ask something like that. Gross
@@awakethemaster if you take a multivitamin or eat cereal you will get your vitamin b.
With regard to salt, a lot of people don't realize that a little salt goes a long way because salt is strong. Reduce your salt usage to 25-35% of what you use now, and try it. It will taste almost the same.
9:46 "we want to avoid processed foods"
I could never pursue a diet that forbids me from washing and cleaning, cutting, cooking, or fermenting my foods.
low sodium - so how much a day
You don't need 1.6 g/kg/day to build muscle for longevity. This is to maximize muscle, as in young bodybuilders (see research by Brad Schoenfeld). For longevity we want to gain or maintain muscle over LONG periods of time, not short periods ASAP. Just like the evidence is weak that this much protein is detrimental, the evidence is also weak that this much protein is beneficial. Personally, I error on the side of caution where I can still easily build muscle. That's 1.2 g/kg of protein or even less. I can squat 275 lbs at age 60 while being tall and lean (6' 2", 185 lbs). Consistent resistance training is the key. Period. No shortcuts.
I think here the benefit suggested is low term weight loss, ie protein helps with satiety. As for RT I agree 100% , as 59 year old started going to gym this year, when from less than 1 pullups to nearly 9 ( if well rested for a few days , probably more if neutral grip as much easier ) . As for squats don't know as will never do deadlifts or squats as too technical for me ( ie not worth the paid off. Just watching a few videos is BS to me ) So use hack machine , one leg press ( apparently safer than using 2 ) , farmer carries , RDL with kettlebell, lunges and bulgarian squats . Glute Drive and some leg curl machines. On the Hack machine if I want to do say 10 plus reps then add 50Kg to it. If I want some extra up it to say 80Kg . I do full un-assisted squats. Could probably do more, but not going there for quite awhile. i want compete injury free training. Just want to build a huge strength reservoir for when 70 , 80 or 90. Don't really want to bulk up - So after say 6-months will maybe move to callenthistics strength , flexibility and movement more
thank You.
I'm rather smaller guy at 71kg and 168cm, if I eat less than 2g / kg lean bodyw, I feel no power and muscle mass goes down. I think we should find our own body type and what is best. Not all are the same
@@mikecar52 Are you claiming that you will lose muscle (or at least not be able to gain muscle) if you consume under 1.6 g/kg of protein while resistant training? I don't care what people say. That's an appeal to authority. I care what the research shows. Please provide studies, not YT videos. I already know the opinion of Brad Schoenfeld and it's consistent with what I wrote. That's why I referenced him.
You're also creating a strawman. Did you even read what I wrote? In your Layne Norton refererence, Layne explicitly states _"individuals trying to maximize the skeletal muscle adaptations to training."_ It's *MAXIMIZE.* Also. Layne Norton is not concerned with *LONGEVITY.* Layne states exactly what I said, young bodybuilders need at least 1.6 g/kg to maximize muscle.
I'm concerned with *LONGEVITY* in people over 50, not young people trying to maximize muscle in their 20s. Not too many 20 year olds care about longevity and not too many elderly people care about winning bodybuilding competitions. Know your audience. The Rhonda Patrick videos you provided were not about longevity. This Brad Stanfield video is about longevity.
What is the *OPTIMAL" amount of protein for someone over 50 to live the longest in the best health (i.e. healthspan)? My opinion is that it's 1.2 g/kg while trying to maintain muscle (typical). And it's okay to bump it up to 1.6 g/kg if someone loses muscle after an illness (atypical).
Did you watch the Brad Schoenfeld video? Rhonda Patrick said she's having a hard time getting her Dad up to 1.2 g/kg and a more difficult time getting him to resistant train. This a recipe for disaster to recommend to the elderly general population to eat these extreme amounts of protein when it's unlikely that they will consistently resistant train. How do you think they'll try to get the protein? Red meat and protein powders?
You must have good knees 😂😂
Everyone has a different metabolism. My rule is eat to your lab results. Try a diet, see if it gives you low LDL, low HBA1C, good body weight, good results for other tests - and it should leave you satiated when you eat. For me, that turned out to be a primarily pescatarian diet.
Just watched a doctor/researcher say Mediterranean was the healthiest in an epidemiological viewpoint. I think genetic/individual factors are a component that needs more attention , tailoring for each person.
Any thoughts on Himalayan salt?
Salt is salt…
@@scwheeler24 salt with trace elements of other minerals in it. Overwhelmingly sodium chloride
Carbohydrate last food order reduces bood sugar spikes and insulin secretion. Good for health.
Is salt alright if my blood pressure fine?
yep. books on salt: David Brownstein and James DiNicolantanio. also YT interviews.
There is apparently something called Mediterranean-green, supposedly little better vs regular version.
What types of fish?
That Cochrane study, the next sentence says: had little effect on the risk of dying.
Are we sure seed oils aren’t a much worse problem.
People have been eating saturated fat forever. Our bodies evolved to manage it. We’ve been eating vegetable oil (seed oil) for like a century and keep increasing the amounts, it’s in like all processed foods.
@d_e_a_n Events were 21% lower in trials exchanging SFAs for PUFAs. As for mortality, there were 75% less deaths than events so they had far less statistical power. Note in analysis 1.23 there was a small reduction, but ns.
And some evolutionary counterpoints... We have also eaten sugar forever (via fruits and honey). Farmed animals are much larger and richer in fat than wild. CVD develops slowly and strikes after reproduction. Ancient populations have atherosclerosis. The Tsimane have among the lowest rates of heart disease (CAC) and eat ~15% kcals fat, 4% saturated.
There is so much conflicting data on protein intake in general, and Leucine specifically. I don't know what to trust.
Hey Lucine! You got some ‘slpannin’ to do.
Note to self: he said no biscuits…but he said nothing about cookies.
Emphasize fiber, unsaturated fats, and protein, be moderate in calories, saturated fats, and sodium, minimize trans fats and refined carbohydrates.
imho?...No particular diet, beyond a well rounded one based on healthy Organic Whole Naturally made foods, can be good for Long term.
Many of them can be useful for helping even healing particular issues..but should not be adhered to exclusively beyond that point.
Whole foods plant based diet is the healthiest.
Hm, sounds solid.
But if we were looking for "the best" diet for longevity (really trying to optimise everything) shouldn't we get as much protein as possible from plants instead of meat if we considered all so far published science?
I mean the World Health Organisation classified meat as a carcinogen lately ...
I am an omnivore myself but I also just read about those "Gerontotoxines" mostly found in meat (also lean meat) - like the "Advanced Glycation End Products"?
While irrelevant in the shorts term they seem to add up over a 70+ year lifetime and slowly increase the all course mortality risk.
Just to ground my concerns a bit more in science I googled the role of "advanced glycation end product intake" in aging and disease risk and browsed through the studies.
The AGEs in meat, particularly those processed at high temperatures, have been linked with chronic diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and cancer. (Huang, Huang, & Dong, 2021); (Lin, Wu, & Yen, 2018).
Another study found that the consumption of red meat, rich in AGE, was associated with an increased risk of pancreatic cancer in men, suggesting that dietary AGEs may play a role in cancer development (Jiao et al., 2015).
Dietary AGEs also affect the gut microbiota and may lead to increased intestinal permeability, which can negatively impact overall health (Qu et al., 2017); (Phuong-Nguyen et al., 2023).
Also correlates with insulin resistance and inflammation (Luévano-Contreras & Chapman-Novakofski, 2010).
And so on and so on ...
So is this a relevant factor for longevity (in case all other parts of live where already optimised)? Or are there studies with other conclusions as well?
I would love to hear more about this topic.
Thanks & Greetings from Germany
Not sure what you mean by "as much protein as possible from plants." I get all my protein from plants and I find it somewhat difficult to keep my protein under 1.6 g/kg/day. I don't want to get as much as possible.
Diet drinks are shown to be better for weight loss than just drinking water.