"Even though your gone you gave me the best years of my life filled with laughter and joy. I wouldn't trade those memories for anything. It's hard without you...but i know i'll see you all again someday. But until then i keep you in my heart and live the lessons you taught me" -Your Friend Eternally Twilight Sparkle
Memories coming back... losing my dad over 8 years ago... and the friends and people I've known and loved who all went before there time... it's so tough having to deal with losing loved ones... I still struggle to deal with it at times, but we've all gotta keep going and get on with life... for them. Thanks you for writing such a beautiful and powerful song.
Only one thing to say... I started crying when i heard the song. It reminded me of my friend that passed away 2 years ago... This song Will always be in my heart. Love you Joaftheloaf with all my heart ;)
What the eff man... I haven't been hit that hard in the feels since Lion King. If you haven't taken sniper training, you should consider it... one song, one kill. That aside, the song itself is beautiful. Well done.
I always find myself coming back to your old songs. Take great in knowing your songs carried me through a great ordeal. I've become a great EMT. My depression was bad before i found your music, along with a few others. I found so much motivation listening to these everyday, and i find it a bit tougher listening to them since i lost my father a few months back. /) love your work J.
Listening to that song after the show is over knowing that the last movie is coming out thinking about all my friends who are made over the years with the fandom wondering where they are this song is so hitting home. It’s not liquid pride it was tears
"Here I stand at the end of what we call life, and in time I'll find my way to have my turn among the stars, and come home To live in a world where the earth is still, kept in peace and live with harmony." Thank you Joaf for these very inspirational words I spoke these lyrics at a funeral for a dear brony friend of mine who loved your work I hope to find my way to the stars and see them again so we can play games and go to the movies some of the best memory's I have thank you so much for this song.
I have to support Classic, here. The advantages of longevity severely outweigh the disadvantages. But those details aside, there is no such thing as a truly unique phenomenon. Anything that can happen probably has, and all but definitely will again. So to think that you will be the only immortal is simply astronomically unlikely. Put simply, tell me you would not enjoy living eternally with perhaps a choice few companions who will stay, and an untold myriad that will fade in all but your memory.
bob thebuilder Even Though there are more pros than cons, you still have to witness every death, every person you become close to, every family you make, will die and you will have to bear that pain forever. You may even live to see your own home planet die, and that's something no one wants. But if you do want to be immortal just remember, not every one you have will always be there.
This is really a touching damn song. It really is, I'm not just saying that just because everyone else is. This song made me tear up thinking that everyone in my life including me will one day say goodbye for the last time. And just you voice is just damn amazing witch made it so much more sad. Please keep this up and don't let anyone say otherwise
Feather when I see you, and your personality, and then hear your work, im thrown for a loop. I cant believe its you. You and Joaf are just plain awesome.
When Twilight Sparkle became and alicorn one of my first thoughts was "won't she outlive all her friends by like 1000 years?". Glad to see that someone else had the same thought and explored it a little.
I showed this song to my now boyfriend eight years ago. I know it's so silly, but this song has really always been so impactful to me. I Miss your music, i wish you still made it online where i could see it. We're engaged now. Thank you for giving me something to share with him.
Every time he hit those higher notes i couldn't help but cry even more than i already was.... thank you for this song, i feel crying helps me relieve stress with all the things that have been happening in my life lately. Again, thank you.
this song is full of fond memories. its funny, i just graduated highschool and this song got me through the roughest summer of my life, and i come back to it, at 3am as a freshman in college and its all thats keeping me going and awake to finish what i started. Thanks joaf, for inspiring me through tough times.
Joaf, you surely are my favorite brony artist... You are such a wonderful musician and you inspire me so... Thank you for letting me cover one of your songs... And congrats to you and Leah, its about time. x3
ok so i don't normally cry at ANYTHING but i found myself bawling over this, i just wanna say thank you for the music and i just wish someday i can make something half as good as this
This once again shows why you (Joaftheloaf) are my favorite brony artist. Your songs often times show such emotion. (Could be just your voice and singing style) Regardless, I love singing along with your songs and feeling the emotion of my own Scootaloo feelings.
Hey I just wanted to say thank you for uploading this. I was listening to it while putting the finish on a story I was writing and...the words really helped inspire me, as the story was about friends. Thank you. I may not be a brony, but you guys put out fantastic music.
This is so inspiring and sad, in a good way. I'm pretty sure that Twilight isn't immortal, but, to hear the fact that she has to "say goodbye" to something she never even realized she would love so much in this song, makes me want to cry as well. And it makes me think, is realizing and finding your destiny all you would ever hope for, or is it just a living hell you have to experience? Are Twilight's wings a sign of good and hope or of the heart-shaddering things to come? We can only wait...
WHY DO YOU MAKE ME CRY!? WHY!?!? but seriously, this is absolutely beautiful, a lot of heart and feeling went into this song. you and Megaphoric have done an amazing job, you should feel proud! Brohoof from the UK /) Keep on smilin'!
I feel like a tank for being able to hold back my tears after listening to this song so many times And I've listened to it about twice every day since I first saw it, that is an accomplishment!
Those people and a few other musicians in the fandom was inspired me as well, I am learning to play the piano right now to play these types and learn more and I have those people to thank as well.
I was just on UA-cam and one of the suggested videos was the animated version of Swing Tavi Swing. I remembered seeing it so I wanted to come to your channel to see if you had anything else as amazing as that. I was not prepared for the feels trip that i accidentally hitched a ride on. I couldn't remember the last I cried. I found myself bawling like a baby after two/three songs. You sir are probably the most underrated artist of all time. Never stop what you are doing. Easiest Subscribe Ever.
Damn, Joaf. Just damn. Dem feels, mayne. This is why you + Megaphoric is the best collab since Mando + EileMonty. I'm seriously looking forward to this album.
Indeed. I actually cried the first time I heard it. Mind you, that was on one of the few serious _Scrubs_ episodes and I had lost my grandmother like a month beforehand, so there were external forces at work...
after i cried listening to this song i look back to the pictures of me and my friends i still remember me and my friends are having fun i'd even look at my old class pictures then bit by bit i feel happy cause i can finally see their faces again and i feel sad cause i don't see some of my friends anymore
Doggone you. This liquid pride won't stop rolling down my cheeks. You, sir, are amazing and adding Megaphoric's voice to the mix just... wow. That's all I can say.
omgomgomgomgomgomg, I'm dying.. this is just absolutely positively perfectly amazing I love your music, and your voice you are just absolutely perfect, agh. So many feels.. I'm crying. c':
Liquid is rolling down my face... oh wait those are Joaf made tears, I shed them quite a lot, especially since I've played your stuff like... oh well Banshee is telling me I've got about 600 hits on everything I brought from you.
Shit! I just started crying from my grandpa passing away cause of this song... That was 3 years ago and this song finally made me brake down... Joaf, your an ass for making me cry, but I love you for it man... I needed it...
don't worry about it dude! i love the way you sing it (i actually thought you sang "and love in harmony" but it's still awesome!) -hugs you- keep it up! You're one of my favorite acoustic brony musicians :D
No matter how many times I listen to this, 3:10 gets me every time. Your voice is gorgeous and gives me chills, especially on those high notes. Well done, Joaf :')
Oh god. The feels. I've been working on a FimFiction based on this very idea of immortality vs. mortality... the feels man. I'll play this whenever I need inspiration... ;w;
So beautiful!!! It's so wonderful to hear your voice again ;3; You and I really need to do a collab whenever you and Mega finish with the album! (If you're not too tired from making it, that isXD)) But excellent work as always...I'm very glad that they've said that she won't outlive the others D:
i lost my brother to autism on his 3rd birthday, i lost my cousin to a vehicle accident, last year i lost two friends at once from them having to move across the country. its amazing how supportive family and the brony fandom is. remember your never alone. all bronies can be a shoulder to cry on. its ok to cry im a 17 year old brony and i cry at music and stuff. i can lend out a hoof for you even if it means only a few words. ''Hugs" i am sorry for your loss. Orthanderis
'Princess what're these?"
"Gravestones."
"Oh, where they good ponies."
"The best..."
this hits different in 2020 now that it's actually over......
"Even though your gone you gave me the best years of my life filled with laughter and joy. I wouldn't trade those memories for anything. It's hard without you...but i know i'll see you all again someday. But until then i keep you in my heart and live the lessons you taught me"
-Your Friend Eternally
Twilight Sparkle
Krazy Stargazer you made me cry- why- damnit
Imorhai The Night Fury
thats how the song made me feel
Ugly sobbing.
Imorhai The Night Fury
Its okay smile because it happened and is still happening
+Krazy Stargazer Why.... ;-;
This was part of my childhood it would probably be one of the best.
Memories coming back... losing my dad over 8 years ago... and the friends and people I've known and loved who all went before there time... it's so tough having to deal with losing loved ones... I still struggle to deal with it at times, but we've all gotta keep going and get on with life... for them.
Thanks you for writing such a beautiful and powerful song.
*A Toast*
To the Fandom. This story isn't over yet.
*Raises glass*
Allison Carlberg *clinks*
Allison Carlberg (raises glass) till the end fellow brony and beyond
*Raises glass* to bronyhood, from the start till the end, may there be many seasons of love and tolorance...
*raises glass* to these many years we have all been conjoined by one simple show!
WHO SAID YOU COULD PLAY WITH MY FEELS, DAMMIT?! T.T
UA-cam did.
Well, this just made the idea of a series finale a little depressing.
Unless they are brought to life to join an army of undead, only to be revived through "The Magic of Friendship" giving them more life.
true now i want to cry
Sorry friends, but the time has come.
Only one thing to say... I started crying when i heard the song. It reminded me of my friend that passed away 2 years ago... This song Will always be in my heart. Love you Joaftheloaf with all my heart ;)
What the eff man... I haven't been hit that hard in the feels since Lion King. If you haven't taken sniper training, you should consider it... one song, one kill.
That aside, the song itself is beautiful. Well done.
I literally started crying. Not even joking, I really did start crying. Just look at fucking fluttershy and pinkie pie!!
I always find myself coming back to your old songs. Take great in knowing your songs carried me through a great ordeal. I've become a great EMT. My depression was bad before i found your music, along with a few others. I found so much motivation listening to these everyday, and i find it a bit tougher listening to them since i lost my father a few months back. /) love your work J.
I can't stop crying
*Salutes mermorial and walks away.*
Listening to that song after the show is over knowing that the last movie is coming out thinking about all my friends who are made over the years with the fandom wondering where they are this song is so hitting home. It’s not liquid pride it was tears
"Here I stand at the end of what we call life, and in time I'll find my way to have my turn among the stars, and come home To live in a world where the earth is still, kept in peace and live with harmony." Thank you Joaf for these very inspirational words I spoke these lyrics at a funeral for a dear brony friend of mine who loved your work I hope to find my way to the stars and see them again so we can play games and go to the movies some of the best memory's I have thank you so much for this song.
Now that the final episode just aired it’s hard to say goodbye to the show
Liquid pride... its different than tears right? This is liquid pride coming from my eyes.
Being immortal fucking sucks.
it would be the best don't lie.
Outlive ALL the friends and family and the planet and be forced to choke in space forever not being able to die.
meet new friends make a new family eventually make way to another planet
I have to support Classic, here. The advantages of longevity severely outweigh the disadvantages. But those details aside, there is no such thing as a truly unique phenomenon. Anything that can happen probably has, and all but definitely will again. So to think that you will be the only immortal is simply astronomically unlikely.
Put simply, tell me you would not enjoy living eternally with perhaps a choice few companions who will stay, and an untold myriad that will fade in all but your memory.
bob thebuilder
Even Though there are more pros than cons, you still have to witness every death, every person you become close to, every family you make, will die and you will have to bear that pain forever. You may even live to see your own home planet die, and that's something no one wants. But if you do want to be immortal just remember, not every one you have will always be there.
Well, this is more relevant since the finale....
Also, still very fond of this piece. =)
This song is so emotional and I almost cried... Thank you so much joaf the loaf your music is so beautiful
seriously I have never had tears when listening to a song, and there was somthing in my eye
I love this man, keep being fantastic
This is really a touching damn song. It really is, I'm not just saying that just because everyone else is. This song made me tear up thinking that everyone in my life including me will one day say goodbye for the last time. And just you voice is just damn amazing witch made it so much more sad. Please keep this up and don't let anyone say otherwise
Feather when I see you, and your personality, and then hear your work, im thrown for a loop. I cant believe its you. You and Joaf are just plain awesome.
When Twilight Sparkle became and alicorn one of my first thoughts was "won't she outlive all her friends by like 1000 years?". Glad to see that someone else had the same thought and explored it a little.
***** *****
I agree, it's a bit stupid to just make shit up in response to a serious comment.
Actually, Luna may be right. 4.bp.blogspot.com/-RmYt62Kb2NI/UWsPEjxnomI/AAAAAAABYS8/vA-Ozmk7LTU/s1600/Capture.JPG
***** Actually I have a fimfiction story of my theory of what will happen here:
www.fimfiction.net/story/211856/friends-forever
It's a possibility.
There is a theory that alicorns aren't immortal. Search for celestial not being immortal
I showed this song to my now boyfriend eight years ago. I know it's so silly, but this song has really always been so impactful to me. I Miss your music, i wish you still made it online where i could see it. We're engaged now. Thank you for giving me something to share with him.
Every time he hit those higher notes i couldn't help but cry even more than i already was.... thank you for this song, i feel crying helps me relieve stress with all the things that have been happening in my life lately. Again, thank you.
I saw the title and panicked, because I thought this was your farewell song for some reason. Glad to see it wasnt, and great work as always.
this song is full of fond memories. its funny, i just graduated highschool and this song got me through the roughest summer of my life, and i come back to it, at 3am as a freshman in college and its all thats keeping me going and awake to finish what i started. Thanks joaf, for inspiring me through tough times.
I genuinely adore this song. And it brought tears to my eyes - which is no easy feat! I solemnly applaud you, Joaf.
Great song, I really like it =D
Is there any way you could release some kind of sheet music for it? I would love to learn it on the piano.
Joaf, you surely are my favorite brony artist... You are such a wonderful musician and you inspire me so... Thank you for letting me cover one of your songs... And congrats to you and Leah, its about time. x3
I wish, if someone make a cover of this with Twilight's voice :'c
there are no words i can even think of in regards to this song it is amazing and sad at the same time and is a perfect remembrance song
Gah, I swear Joaf is the only artist that can get me crying over songs. This is crazy good.
so many tears. so many tears. thank you
Bloody hell...I don't generally feel much of anything -- bit of a sociopath -- but this made me tear up. Well done.
You put a lot of your heart into everyone of your songs and you can always hear it stupendous job.
ok so i don't normally cry at ANYTHING but i found myself bawling over this, i just wanna say thank you for the music and i just wish someday i can make something half as good as this
this picture and song puts tears to my eyes. how could this be such a touching thing..
I can't count how many times I've heard this song, and it still makes me tear up. Brilliantly done.
This once again shows why you (Joaftheloaf) are my favorite brony artist. Your songs often times show such emotion. (Could be just your voice and singing style) Regardless, I love singing along with your songs and feeling the emotion of my own Scootaloo feelings.
Hey I just wanted to say thank you for uploading this. I was listening to it while putting the finish on a story I was writing and...the words really helped inspire me, as the story was about friends. Thank you. I may not be a brony, but you guys put out fantastic music.
Beautiful yet Depressing at the same time, brings me to tears when I listen to it. Great Job and keep up the good work.
Never heard a song that made me cry so much. Beautiful song. Good job.
thats the downside of an alicorn
That's a great way to end my night, feeling all sad.
This is so inspiring and sad, in a good way. I'm pretty sure that Twilight isn't immortal, but, to hear the fact that she has to "say goodbye" to something she never even realized she would love so much in this song, makes me want to cry as well. And it makes me think, is realizing and finding your destiny all you would ever hope for, or is it just a living hell you have to experience? Are Twilight's wings a sign of good and hope or of the heart-shaddering things to come? We can only wait...
Ain't have tears running down my face. Thanks. This is so beautiful but how did you not cry through the entire thing while singing?!?
WHY DO YOU MAKE ME CRY!? WHY!?!?
but seriously, this is absolutely beautiful, a lot of heart and feeling went into this song.
you and Megaphoric have done an amazing job, you should feel proud!
Brohoof from the UK /)
Keep on smilin'!
Ah, nostalgia.
Never felt so many emotions. this song really is something.
This made me cry because at some point in life we must all say goodbye nut that moment..is worth waiting for
I stumbled upon this years ago, and I still love listening to it.
I feel like a tank for being able to hold back my tears after listening to this song so many times And I've listened to it about twice every day since I first saw it, that is an accomplishment!
Those people and a few other musicians in the fandom was inspired me as well, I am learning to play the piano right now to play these types and learn more and I have those people to thank as well.
As always, a great piece! Soft, gentle, and plenty moving, just the way it should be.
*Applause* one of my favorite songs. You did fantastic!
I was just on UA-cam and one of the suggested videos was the animated version of Swing Tavi Swing. I remembered seeing it so I wanted to come to your channel to see if you had anything else as amazing as that. I was not prepared for the feels trip that i accidentally hitched a ride on. I couldn't remember the last I cried. I found myself bawling like a baby after two/three songs. You sir are probably the most underrated artist of all time. Never stop what you are doing. Easiest Subscribe Ever.
Damn, Joaf. Just damn. Dem feels, mayne. This is why you + Megaphoric is the best collab since Mando + EileMonty. I'm seriously looking forward to this album.
This is so beautiful. I almost cried watching this. The feels in this are amazing.
Wow, it sounds so much better when not played through a livestream!
So many feels man. I can't take it.... I love this song.
I cried when i kept listening it on repeat when the 11th Doctor rengenerated..... Honestly i can say that your did a awesome work....
This is so very sad and mellow. It reminds me of _I Will Follow You Into the Dark_ by _Death Cab For Cutie_. Quite touching.
I take a LOT of influence from that song. I love the strumming pattern in that song :D
Indeed. I actually cried the first time I heard it. Mind you, that was on one of the few serious _Scrubs_ episodes and I had lost my grandmother like a month beforehand, so there were external forces at work...
The song that won’t be forgotten.
You never fail to make me cry, Joaf.
after i cried listening to this song i look back to the pictures of me and my friends i still remember me and my friends are having fun i'd even look at my old class pictures then bit by bit i feel happy cause i can finally see their faces again and i feel sad cause i don't see some of my friends anymore
same fam.
Ohgod, the feels. I can't handle so much sad in one day!
I started crying and now I can't stop watching this video
Arrr... I can't take the sadness, it's like someone's punching at my heart.
this is making me cry a lot and its bringing back a upsetting memory of my uncle T-T
This is (IMO) the best song you've made. Keep up the great work, Joaf. =D
This fandom never ceases to amaze me I'm proud to be part of it
THE FEELS! -cries in corner-
*Hugs
I know what you two feel. *hugs them*
i am thinking that twilight is thinking "its a long long way to equstiera"
You Madame, have earned all the upvotes in the Equestria. Maybe that will help Twilight get back faster.
Plenty of tears has been shed that day :') Beautiful song.
Doggone you. This liquid pride won't stop rolling down my cheeks.
You, sir, are amazing and adding Megaphoric's voice to the mix just... wow. That's all I can say.
That soon really made me cry😢😢😢
Wow... No words can properly describe the sheer beauty of this piece. ;u; Fantastic job!
omgomgomgomgomgomg, I'm dying.. this is just absolutely positively perfectly amazing I love your music, and your voice you are just absolutely perfect, agh. So many feels.. I'm crying. c':
This and stay from 4everfreebrony are great tribute songs to my grandma who passed yesterday
I’m gonna miss her a lot
This is quite depressing to see twilight immortal
This was uploaded 2013 did this predict the future of mlp
New favorite song of all time. Love it.
Liquid is rolling down my face... oh wait those are Joaf made tears, I shed them quite a lot, especially since I've played your stuff like... oh well Banshee is telling me I've got about 600 hits on everything I brought from you.
Shit! I just started crying from my grandpa passing away cause of this song... That was 3 years ago and this song finally made me brake down... Joaf, your an ass for making me cry, but I love you for it man... I needed it...
don't worry about it dude! i love the way you sing it (i actually thought you sang "and love in harmony" but it's still awesome!)
-hugs you- keep it up! You're one of my favorite acoustic brony musicians :D
Joaf, you still make my favorite sad songs. I would hate it if I didn't love it so so much.
i cryd from it and i bought the album thanks
Eyes tearing up .Seriously. And music and such never makes me cry, so for a song to do that... This is a feels megabomb T_T
this was hauntingly beautiful
Who gave you the order to play whit my feelings and my pride?! DAMMYOU
No matter how many times I listen to this, 3:10 gets me every time. Your voice is gorgeous and gives me chills, especially on those high notes. Well done, Joaf :')
Anyone else here after the finale?
THIS IS BEAUTIFUL I AM CRYING
Oh god. The feels. I've been working on a FimFiction based on this very idea of immortality vs. mortality... the feels man. I'll play this whenever I need inspiration... ;w;
This..i love this song so much. Right in the feels but i love it.
one of the saddest things ive ever heard...... well done sir....well done
So beautiful!!! It's so wonderful to hear your voice again ;3; You and I really need to do a collab whenever you and Mega finish with the album! (If you're not too tired from making it, that isXD)) But excellent work as always...I'm very glad that they've said that she won't outlive the others D:
Right in the feels
i lost my brother to autism on his 3rd birthday, i lost my cousin to a vehicle accident, last year i lost two friends at once from them having to move across the country. its amazing how supportive family and the brony fandom is. remember your never alone. all bronies can be a shoulder to cry on. its ok to cry im a 17 year old brony and i cry at music and stuff. i can lend out a hoof for you even if it means only a few words. ''Hugs" i am sorry for your loss. Orthanderis
this made me cry :( WHYYYYYYY!!!