Barstool Pizza Review - Nicky's Coal Fired (Nashville, TN)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
  • Dave stops by Nicky's Coal Fired, which is one of his favorite styles, but can't place what other chain it reminds him of.
    Download The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: onebite.app/do...
    Follow on Instagram: / stoolpresidente
    Follow on Twitter: / stoolpresidente
    Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolspo...
    Follow Barstool Sports here:
    Facebook: / barstoolsports
    Twitter: / barstoolsports
    Instagram: / barstoolsports
  • Комедії

КОМЕНТАРІ • 726

  • @anthonyhunt8284
    @anthonyhunt8284 Рік тому +780

    We really need a “REVISIT THE 9’s TOUR” it’s been years since you’ve done the most famous ones let’s see the consistency and if anyone stepped up their game!

    • @paskowitz
      @paskowitz Рік тому +21

      The Michelin Star of pizza reviews. Let's see who the Le Bernardin of pizza is.

    • @wantapgt
      @wantapgt Рік тому +7

      Great idea actually

    • @MrStradia
      @MrStradia Рік тому +10

      Kind of like a recalibration of sorts.

    • @thomasbigoski9501
      @thomasbigoski9501 Рік тому +8

      Completely agree!! Also he should solicit votes for a second taste tour. Places like Santillos that he gave just an 8.2 to I believe.

    • @surfboard396
      @surfboard396 Рік тому +1

      Look at his old vids. It’s there.

  • @scottmcwave9479
    @scottmcwave9479 Рік тому +544

    Everybody knows Dave purchased a new jacket at the women’s store!

    • @Stankyratx
      @Stankyratx Рік тому +6

      That jacket is dope

    • @Jjdjjdhg
      @Jjdjjdhg Рік тому +23

      Ladies medium. Everybody knows the rules

    • @Mr_Zel
      @Mr_Zel Рік тому +8

      Unisex one size fits all

    • @jamesconnell7005
      @jamesconnell7005 Рік тому +2

      Everybody knows the rules.

    • @leonhughes9014
      @leonhughes9014 Рік тому

      his skinny jeans absent.. put on a couple of pounds

  • @Redscape_
    @Redscape_ Рік тому +155

    One bite, everyone knows Dave got himself a "power suit" at Able

  • @steveg5591
    @steveg5591 Рік тому +201

    Dave, if you say you can eat this pizza all day give it an 8.2!

    • @ARTofTY-TV
      @ARTofTY-TV Рік тому +18

      I'm guessing it was lacking in the flavor department.

    • @imlost19
      @imlost19 Рік тому +25

      hes been really harsh with his scores lately. im all disco bobulated

    • @Morrie-queens
      @Morrie-queens Рік тому +26

      @@imlost19 cocaine seems to curb ones appetite.

    • @n8archy121
      @n8archy121 Рік тому +8

      Sounded too dry

    • @fleshypuppet
      @fleshypuppet Рік тому +6

      I agree! With all the raving he did about that pizza, I guessed that he was going to score it an 8.1.

  • @user-in2dy1xv7m
    @user-in2dy1xv7m Рік тому +517

    One women’s clothing store, everybody knows it’s perfect for Dave.

    • @jerryc8978
      @jerryc8978 Рік тому +7

      Dave thinks he's a twenty something UA-cam influencer.

    • @AnonYmous-pn7ig
      @AnonYmous-pn7ig Рік тому +6

      I'm not sure he can even zip it up. And what's with all the 7.2 - 7.8 scores lately. Has Dave's taste buds just flattened to basically the same scores for everyone?

    • @RyanMcAndrews
      @RyanMcAndrews Рік тому

      He was trying to buy something to cover that grease stain from the midnight oil pizza.

    • @Brandon-youtube
      @Brandon-youtube Рік тому

      thats where he got his coat last year

    • @sbs3003ses
      @sbs3003ses Рік тому +2

      "That's my jAAm"

  • @guerro327
    @guerro327 Рік тому +219

    Only Dave can get Enrico wrong and call it Enrique. Everybody knows the rules.

    • @Keykers1
      @Keykers1 Рік тому +8

      You're telling me

    • @tommymas1
      @tommymas1 Рік тому +1

      @@Keykers1 😜🤪😂🤣

    • @valhallaoutcast
      @valhallaoutcast Рік тому +1

      has to be the dumbest millionaire in the history of mankind

    • @kennymccormick8295
      @kennymccormick8295 Рік тому +2

      ​@@tommymas1 Add more emojis to show us your intellect.

    • @tommymas1
      @tommymas1 Рік тому +5

      @@kennymccormick8295 Ah, you're one of those. J stands for Jacka**, right?

  • @johnweenus3939
    @johnweenus3939 Рік тому +8

    “The ovens called Enrique! I love that” *Cuts to the shot of the oven clearly named Enrico*

  • @virgilfuerst4576
    @virgilfuerst4576 Рік тому +19

    My brother owns crust 54 ( on south Washington) in holland Michigan and is a HUGE fan of your videos and reviews and really wants a review of his own!

    • @shrimp_p4rm
      @shrimp_p4rm Рік тому

      Bougie ass name for a pizza shop. 4.1 on name alone.

  • @masonfikkert
    @masonfikkert Рік тому +23

    "By far my favorite from Nashville" gives it a lower score than Joey's, everybody knows Dave's scores are arbitrary

    • @SIXPACFISH
      @SIXPACFISH Рік тому

      They should have took his order over the phone if they wanted a good score.

  • @mrfeather2732
    @mrfeather2732 Рік тому +8

    why most of the time I always guess your score... its starting to creep me out that if its a coding thing or those ratings are actually ratings.

  • @anyaneez8628
    @anyaneez8628 Рік тому +33

    Dave, this restaurant brings back haunting memories for me lad. One day, my wife and I went here for a slice and she locked eyes with a man she could not resist. She made him her boyfriend and they are still dating to this day. Pizza was a bit oily as well. What a nightmare. Cheers mate

    • @wyminn2594
      @wyminn2594 Рік тому +3

      sorry mate she came onto me first

    • @fernandowong371
      @fernandowong371 Рік тому +1

      Sorry to hear that, bruh

    • @MrChumpus
      @MrChumpus Рік тому +2

      You got the pizza with sausage and your wife got the other guy's sausage. It happens

    • @JakeM25
      @JakeM25 Рік тому +2

      Brutal if true

    • @axel2x748
      @axel2x748 Рік тому +2

      Lol he trolling look at his past comments 💀💀.

  • @ATCguy83
    @ATCguy83 Рік тому +31

    One bite everybody knows Enrique is a top notch Italian name.

  • @eazy1174
    @eazy1174 Рік тому +22

    Wasnt expecting that score. Dude was hyping it up the whole time

    • @aMoodyCanadian
      @aMoodyCanadian Рік тому

      yeah look at the sloppiness of the cheese though and overall grease, they got too much cheese on it i think for his taste

  • @jimc.goodfellas
    @jimc.goodfellas Рік тому +45

    Everybody knows that coal fired is Dave's jam

  • @ShaferScott
    @ShaferScott Рік тому +27

    Dave 100% bought some ladies clothes for himself in that store.

    • @WarrenAAndrews
      @WarrenAAndrews Рік тому

      That's the next scandal

    • @clappingpig
      @clappingpig Рік тому +1

      Yeah he for sure got himself some new jeans.

    • @mattfoster5934
      @mattfoster5934 Рік тому

      @@clappingpig He definitely got a Pair of skinny jeans🤣

    • @HoesLoveCoCo
      @HoesLoveCoCo Рік тому

      Imagine stealing one of the top comments and thinking youre gonna get more likes just cause youre verified 😂🤡

  • @jimmybuckets5863
    @jimmybuckets5863 Рік тому +10

    I remember back when Dave gave scores between 0 and 10, now everything is between 6 and like 8.2. This looks miles better than that last floppy mess but only 1.2 points higher?

  • @mondoenterprises6710
    @mondoenterprises6710 Рік тому +12

    I have to admit Dave. I've never gone into women's boutiques and cruised the "clothes" (yeah, right), but thanks for the pro tip!

  • @koalatea2367
    @koalatea2367 Рік тому +44

    I'm as faithful to these videos as Dave is to the pizza game.

    • @clappingpig
      @clappingpig Рік тому +3

      Let me guess, you also wear women's jeans...

    • @cain2548
      @cain2548 Рік тому

      @@clappingpig only your moms cuz I wear a 44 waist.

    • @DWojo
      @DWojo Рік тому

      Me too! 😊

    • @specimen-
      @specimen- Рік тому

      @@clappingpig why do people hate him so much lol

  • @MattDahlberg
    @MattDahlberg Рік тому +9

    You know you watch too many of these when you are within .2 every time... Totally called a 7.6 this time around. 😂

    • @joeheid2776
      @joeheid2776 Рік тому +1

      Me too. I said 7.7.

    • @MattDahlberg
      @MattDahlberg Рік тому +1

      @@joeheid2776 When he turned his head before giving the score I almost bumped it up and I think he did too. 🤣

  • @larrychamel
    @larrychamel Рік тому +19

    Happy you got a good Pizza today, Dave! Much better than the Flop & Slop you had in the last video.

  • @Sebas-lj1gt
    @Sebas-lj1gt Рік тому +18

    One bite, everybody knows Armandos and Arturos is no where close to Anthony’s.

    • @Mrbink01
      @Mrbink01 Рік тому

      Pretty damn close for Dave....starts with an A

  • @MattyStavvy
    @MattyStavvy Рік тому +81

    If that pizza looked like a bar pie or football pizza it would be an easy 8.2 due to the crisp, thin style, and coal fire oven. Dave is bumping off points due to the aesthetics everybody knows the rules

    • @jesselynch1844
      @jesselynch1844 Рік тому +3

      Agreed. Looks like his normal 8.1 score to me kinda pizza

    • @colindsouza979
      @colindsouza979 Рік тому

      @@jesselynch1844 i literally had the same score in mind bruv

    • @rwinstanley8668
      @rwinstanley8668 Рік тому

      Agreed. I was 7.9-8.1 with 7.9 final answer. Get with it Dave. Flop, crisp, taste?

  • @SoaP_xcvi
    @SoaP_xcvi Рік тому +1

    3:00 Billy Strings playing in the background. Fuck yes!

  • @mondoenterprises6710
    @mondoenterprises6710 Рік тому +2

    It's hard to maintain consistency when you have 27" pies. There's a certain size that is the sweet spot based on the size and performance of the oven. I like the 18" size coal fired for $20 works for me. And you can't skimp but you don't want to overload the ingredients.

  • @bootheguru
    @bootheguru Рік тому +6

    This video is about Pizza

  • @AnonYmous-ry2jn
    @AnonYmous-ry2jn Рік тому +1

    The more I watch these, the more I understand the criteria/methodology: Most important: “light” & “no flop” BECAUSE IF YOU’RE A PIZZA REVIEWER DOING SEVERAL A DAY STANDING UP: A) You’ll blow up like a balloon if it’s not “light”; and B) Must be easy to eat **neatly** standing up with no utensils.
    No doubt these reviews are very (or at least somewhat 😉😉😉) valid within Dave’s parameters, but these reviews are MOST reliable *if you are a UA-cam stand-up pizza reviewer* ! Everybody knows the rules!!!

  • @alexanderjohnson6114
    @alexanderjohnson6114 Рік тому +4

    I've watched you well enough where I guessed 7.6 on your impression and I screamed got it!. Absolutely comical scared the shit out of my dog but that's here nor there. So stoked I got it

  • @hankfanelli719
    @hankfanelli719 Рік тому +1

    My only encounter with a NY style coal fired pizza was in So, Fla. from that chain and it was the worst pizza I ever spit out, it reeked of kerosene and was a burned edge crust disaster.

  • @yuckfoo218
    @yuckfoo218 Рік тому +2

    Awesome shout out to Anthony’s. Best chain pizza ever + Marino connection.

    • @lilmandee4315
      @lilmandee4315 Рік тому +1

      I also love Anthony's but best pizza chain untill jets comes in the building 💯

  • @steve4hockey
    @steve4hockey Рік тому +5

    Need a Top 10 revisit for sure One Bite team. Make it happen!

  • @Fine_art_aerial
    @Fine_art_aerial Рік тому +2

    I know not your style but love Anthonys coal fire spicy pizza in Plantation!! Normally dont like stuff like that but really really good!!

  • @hinney827
    @hinney827 Рік тому +2

    Was definitely expecting a 7.9 or 8.1 with the wavering right before the score. Had good crisp, was light and thin. Must have been missing that tang in the sauce, everybody knows Dave's system.

  • @jasonbradley6695
    @jasonbradley6695 Рік тому +8

    One woman’s clothing store, everybody knows Dave was looking for a new pair of pants 👖

  • @coldcrush9
    @coldcrush9 Рік тому +4

    One bite, everybody knows Dave headed back to Able's for a credit card

  • @kylerivoire3826
    @kylerivoire3826 Рік тому +16

    I couldn't possibly eat this much pizza. Dave truly does the Lord's work.

  • @FeathersFurandFins
    @FeathersFurandFins Рік тому

    Perfect ending. "........ya." HAHA

  • @TheTurdballs420
    @TheTurdballs420 Рік тому +2

    Prez gives out a ton of 7.6’s

  • @berrey7
    @berrey7 Рік тому

    I like the Light Pastel striped sleeves and the Palm tree decor on the jacket you got from the Women's Store.

  • @mondoenterprises6710
    @mondoenterprises6710 Рік тому +2

    Btw, that was a very nice looking oven! The real deal.

  • @starkparker16
    @starkparker16 Рік тому +20

    If Steve saw the name he'd know the name, everybody knows the rules.

  • @ududebun
    @ududebun Рік тому +1

    Just as accurate at remembering ovens names as he is at guessing dogs names.

  • @BarqB
    @BarqB Рік тому +1

    That looked and crunched like at least an 8. Especially next to that second hand store looking old ladys jacket

  • @LL3Jay
    @LL3Jay Рік тому +2

    00:24 that could not have been more sus

  • @jtasgl88
    @jtasgl88 Рік тому

    Used to live down the street from this place. So freaking good.

  • @deker0
    @deker0 Рік тому +1

    Called the exact score. Once he started talking about how that pie could be recreated by a chain, I knew it would never get to 7.7 or higher.

  • @cegentry
    @cegentry 7 місяців тому

    Funny I live right outside Nashville. I have started making pizza at home because I can’t find a pizza worth a crap anywhere. Then again I’m not a hipster that runs around all the bum areas of town that are being rebranded as the place to be. I guess I need to find a few of these places but I am really happy with what I’m making at home. Making pizza is trickier than one might imagine.

  • @KareemKayy
    @KareemKayy Рік тому

    i kinda saw that coming, i get the the thin, crunchy crust and coal fire aspect where there, but in the end it was too small and bar pie size to be dave's style of pizza, if it was slightly bigger easily would've been a 8.4+

  • @samuelspencer7092
    @samuelspencer7092 Рік тому

    I wonder if the difference you notice with the "chain coal fires" is age? Similar to cast iron skillets where the more used the better kind of thing.

  • @derricdueker64
    @derricdueker64 Рік тому

    My fav pizza joint in Carbondale Illinois just happens to have 3 (three) womens clothing stores right next door. Fabulous! One is named Enrique's.

  • @mikester695
    @mikester695 Рік тому

    Try Phillies CBP Pass and Stow wood fired pizza. I had a 7 but it was busy and a reheat. The fresh made looked 9 ish. They had several on deck to be reheated. I should have ordered and odd one they make from dough ready to stretch.

    • @mikester695
      @mikester695 Рік тому

      BTW they're only open for Phillies games.

  • @modoc1888
    @modoc1888 Рік тому

    Eagles playing in the background. Love it 9.1

  • @DaveDuncanMusic
    @DaveDuncanMusic Рік тому

    His inner Christopher Walken came out at the very end when he said "I could eat it all day....yeah."

  • @vernonlove7242
    @vernonlove7242 Рік тому +1

    Listening to you eat it, hell, it sounds delicious. Alot of crunch..

  • @hudsontoo1212
    @hudsontoo1212 Рік тому

    You gotta give it to the man- how is it possible to reliably eat a pizza every day??? I couldn’t do it. It shows legit dedication to a craft. I’m not sure what that craft is… but it is dedication for sure.

  • @Oldgames1000
    @Oldgames1000 Рік тому +1

    Looked really good. Maybe a 7.9 or 8.1.

  • @Gserra78
    @Gserra78 Рік тому

    I live in Nashville and I'm originally from Brooklyn Bensonhurst am such a A picky pizza person especially being from Brooklyn and to me the best pizzeria in Nashville is Angelo's in Antioch Tennessee they've been there for over 20 years and they are the best Whenever you're back in Nashville you need to try this place

  • @errk25
    @errk25 Рік тому +1

    Was thinking he was on the 7.9-8.1 line. 7.6 is like WTF? They must have been out of his size at the women's store. He's so emotional.

  • @lukekuykendall6366
    @lukekuykendall6366 Рік тому

    He should visit Prince Street Pizza in Gallatin, TN. I travel all over the Midwest for work and their pizza is outstanding!

  • @PsychicMonkey44
    @PsychicMonkey44 Рік тому +3

    First time I've predicted the score correctly 🤝

    • @wizcorn9958
      @wizcorn9958 Рік тому +1

      My wife is a medium and she says you might actually have a gift, she said she felt something when she scrolled past your comment.

  • @jillianmerluse2418
    @jillianmerluse2418 Рік тому

    My cats ears hates your intro song. I dig it. And your reviews. Cheers!

  • @Cinziaking
    @Cinziaking Рік тому

    Added bonus, BMFS playing in the background!

  • @craigrowe8084
    @craigrowe8084 Рік тому +1

    Dave legitimately doesn't get enough respect for remembering all these pizza places and comparing them to similar joints.

  • @zennedupyt
    @zennedupyt Рік тому +3

    This pizza looked delicious!

  • @joelrocha6449
    @joelrocha6449 Рік тому +1

    That pizza should be an 8.1 stone cold lead pipe lock! Come on Prez

  • @NippleSauce
    @NippleSauce Рік тому +1

    I don't blame Dave for not remembering the name of the pizza chain in Florida. It's a common, modern American name and pizza places usually go with something that sounds more Italian

  • @monkeygraborange
    @monkeygraborange Рік тому +1

    *EXCELLENT* NEON!!

  • @kevskikane
    @kevskikane Рік тому

    That crunch.... Damn.

  • @patrickburke7929
    @patrickburke7929 Рік тому +1

    To my Pizza Eating Comrade's in South West Florida looking for a Hidden Gem off the Beaten Path. I Highly Suggest to Try ANY (Anthony's New York) 🍕 in Bonita Springs off Coconut Rd that I've been trying to get One Bite to give a Try & the Owner Anthony who originally is from Brooklyn & Brought his Pizza making Skills on down to the Sunshine State. I as a Tradesman always go to this Spot wen I'm working in the area...

  • @bg4t1
    @bg4t1 Рік тому

    Love you man love your posts and your journey keep ‘‘em coming fam!!

  • @herbmiller3123
    @herbmiller3123 Рік тому

    You gotta review Delizia pizza right in New Britain PA, it's one of those hole in the wall places but their pizzas got good crust, the sauce is fresh on the sweeter side and the cheese is like a warm hug, you won't be disappointed

  • @actuallynotsteve
    @actuallynotsteve Рік тому +1

    I've been off with my guess by .1 for the last 3 days, very frustrating

  • @jasontoscani3009
    @jasontoscani3009 Рік тому

    What were the dipping sauces on the side ? Ranch maybe

  • @jmanned
    @jmanned Рік тому +5

    I feel like Dave is the kind of guy that would smell like a pizza.

  • @hunterwade560
    @hunterwade560 Рік тому

    You should try Solorzano's in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee.

  • @ericrothdeutsch3842
    @ericrothdeutsch3842 Рік тому

    You've got to try the pizza at Smith & Lentz brewery in Nashville.

  • @jf8643
    @jf8643 Рік тому +3

    This man just likes toast with cheese

  • @Canadian2K
    @Canadian2K Рік тому +1

    i had johns of bleaker and while it was good i dont understand how its a 9.... i wonder if dave got special treatment or if there just so busy now they cant keep the quality the same

    • @mondoenterprises6710
      @mondoenterprises6710 Рік тому +1

      You have to go back 30 years for John's. Now they get hammered. Nobody could keep up.

  • @TheEasylovin
    @TheEasylovin Рік тому

    The Sicilian place over off of broadway is one of the best places around.

  • @HeffewiezenDudeGuy
    @HeffewiezenDudeGuy Рік тому +1

    Coal style fire, everybody knows the rules

  • @juckimal
    @juckimal Рік тому

    I love the reviews after a couple of pops!

  • @MysteriousMM
    @MysteriousMM Рік тому +1

    One Bite Everybody Knows that was an 8.1 but Dave knew it was a chain so scored it lower

  • @davidwilliams5749
    @davidwilliams5749 Рік тому

    "You say Enrico, I say Enrique. Everybody knows the rules when I'm sporting a jacket like this."

  • @mondoenterprises6710
    @mondoenterprises6710 Рік тому +1

    "Well, I'm actually looking for clothes for my lady friend."

  • @rolling4life-media-house.90

    sounded a lil christopher walken on the " eat it allday " 3;14

  • @danfosmire4343
    @danfosmire4343 Рік тому

    I called it perfect... 7.6! I always try to score them before you just by you look and I called this one

  • @davidc4764
    @davidc4764 Рік тому

    Love your pizza reviews, Dave.

  • @henryhavill9555
    @henryhavill9555 Рік тому

    You the only I know that can eat pizza and talk at the same time , much love

  • @Imac7065
    @Imac7065 Рік тому

    Anthony's Cold Fire Pizza is great (I'm in FL)

  • @ac_wiss
    @ac_wiss Рік тому

    Gotta try Two Boots in Midtown! Coolest spot to eat pizza

  • @vinylvishrecords
    @vinylvishrecords Рік тому

    That Pizza is my Jawn, upcoming road trip to that place.

  • @samthesuspect
    @samthesuspect Рік тому +3

    As a Floridian, Anthony's is about as good as it gets down south.

    • @DabsDad
      @DabsDad Рік тому

      If you ever get a chance try Jewell Bistro in Lake Worth. I don't think they make pies on weekends, but they are the best in SFL I've tried. It's quirky because they don't always make pies so it's tough to predict when you can get one. The owner used to run Pizza Oceano in Lantana. Four Brothers in Palm Springs is good too. Also Hot Pie in West Palm and Royal Palm Beach is alright. We like Mario the Baker in Royal Palm. They are originally from Connecticut via North Miami. Consistently very good.

  • @twiggehtwi
    @twiggehtwi Рік тому

    Ur eating new pizzas every fucking day. Man I wish I could live your life lol. I love your channel

  • @matthewcarter3664
    @matthewcarter3664 Рік тому

    Anxiety when Dave doesn’t immediately let the pizza breath.

  • @brendanobrien4657
    @brendanobrien4657 Рік тому

    This man ate so much pizza he’s turning into one

  • @davidorozco1998
    @davidorozco1998 Рік тому +1

    Looked like he wanted to change the score at the end. That looked more like a 7.8

  • @MrEvannelson
    @MrEvannelson Рік тому

    Next time you’re in Los Angeles you have to go to “Tomato Pie Pizza Joint”, in South Pasadena.

  • @gregyan1012
    @gregyan1012 Рік тому

    You gotta try smith and lentz pizza in Nashville!

  • @firiesport8
    @firiesport8 Рік тому +1

    7.6? That looked and sounded way higher

  • @wrenlinwhitelight3007
    @wrenlinwhitelight3007 Рік тому +2

    I live in Nashville near Nicky's and I've been there a lot. Finally I won the Dave Portnoy lottery of pizza place reviews

  • @OneWingedDemonSlayer
    @OneWingedDemonSlayer Рік тому

    Signature powder sniff at 0:25