@toycat Funny enough, I've been tempted by the addon not because of the smithing but because string is now a droppable item from grass & I've always had trouble getting string quickly enough 😂.
@@toycati personally think this is best add-on so far and has the most potential as more things are opened up to these creators And I think it has a 4.4 rating because some people got it and were confused with everything, and just gave up and gave a bad rating, not understanding how truly amazing it is
Seems like a bit bias of a review tbh... The first couple pages of the tinkers book pretty much explain everything just like any other add-on, the other pages are mostly in-depth details you don't need to know until later when you're interested, like if you want to know what all the keywords on the tools mean, you can just look them up when designing a perfect tool for you. And you can't really experience it for 20 mins in creative, when it's designed to be played over hours/days in survival, then expect to have a good idea what it's like, also some of the tools can mine in a 3x3 area, do insane damage like 20+ and can have unlimited durability, not to mention the 20+ custom effects like being able to cut down an entire tree in one hit (which essentials completely failed at), or giving a really high chance to get wither skeleton skulls, so saying it's got no high end is a bit of a joke lol. It also has a bunch more to do with smelting, crafting, and combat, should really give it more of a chance. Not sure if it's a balance choice or a bug, but tools from tinkers on Java don't disappear when they break, they become unusable, and then you need to repair them.
I agree it feel like he wanted to make a easy video since addons are new but also did a pretty piss poor job trying to review these. Ecko soldiers does much better reviews of these addons
I couldn’t watch this, was actually making me mad lol.. From the moment he mentioned Tinkers he just started acting really annoyed and whinny like he’s being forced to make this video before he can have his ice cream.
The video isn't a guide or in-depth analysis, not sure why you and others think every mod deserves to be treated like it's a mod review from back then. It's simply trying 3 higher rated mods and going into it with 0 experience as a noob who's trying it for the first time. This Tinkerer's is implemented worse in almost every way compared to Java. He did run through these quick, but this is realistic for like 90% of people who try out the mods. Most players trying aren't going "let me sit down for an hour or two" to begin understanding the mod. It's a mod creators job to make sure the introduction and learning process is as easy and understandable as possible, even helping guide you in the start. TC just throws like 6 books as you and says "read" like this isn't the fastest way to make most people feel overwhelmed, like it's not worth it, and quit within 10-20 mins even if they genuinely are interested in the concept or would be willing to learn... But don't want to deal with a crappy learning system. (Sounds like school, right? Students actually look forward to classes with good and fun teachers regardless of the subject). I've been playing with Applied Energistics, or Tech Reborn, and a few others, and this is a problem techy mods also commit, but these have MUCH MORE content than TC and their presentation is still easier to understand in Java because it's 1 book or well made wiki it directs you where everything is in one place, images have color, there's diagrams, examples, and even challenges they give players (without holding their hand), and it's ALL in one place rather than this mess spread across several books (subtabs would be better), these mods, to make even easier, are recommend being paired with questbooks with short descriptions/instructions to help guide the player down some path of progression. I saw this TC bedrock version and... Yeah, it needs work. I'm not surprised no one would want to dedicated more than 20 mins unless they're just THAT bored with MC and looking to squeeze anything out of Bedrock at that point. And no, I'm not going to give it benefit of the doubt or go even slightly easy on it. This is a PAID mod. PAID. And the alternative is better, free, has more compatibility with other mods, it feels less janky (you have to use both to understand), and there's several more reasons why it just is better (from more features/capabilities and potential, and more). This TC for bedrock being popular is just a testament to how bad mods on bedrock are that mediocre ones rise to the top.
@@RemedieX Totally agree with your last paragraph, was horribly implemented and would never pay for such poor content, would personally only pay for large varied content like an expansion, otherwise they are just going to nickel and dime you. But my main point was he was trying it in creative mode, which just does not work with tinkers because of how the parts system works. It would be a lot nicer of an experience for him if played naturally in a play through, but I know not everyone has time for that, unless that's what they are looking for like you said.
The different tool handles give different bonuses, as well as the different tool head types. Matching both gives a Pure tool, but reading and picking what you ultimately want are a big part of how you make stuffs (at least in the Maps that I have bought that have this in them, I do not have the add on yet).
When you were detecting for ore with that ore scanner You said this was recommended by eckosoldier The ore scanner is supposed to work on the same level as ores You were testing it above GROUND And not in a cave or ravine
Essentials has basically Timber Mod, fake blocks to use as secret entrances, chunk borders, vein miners, an ore finder, perma night vision, AND vertical half slabs! SOLD!
13:57 Mask means only the blocks that are part of the mask get replaced. Since your mask is Stone Brick, Glass Block, and Block of Emerald, none of the selected blocks changed because they are grass blocks
I'm in LOVE with tinker's construct but for some reason a lot of items and blocks in the add-on that are essential for you to progress through the mod are completely invisible for me. I hate it so much and no matter what i do, I can't make it work properly for my worlds. I've deleted the add-on and re-downloaded it and it's solved nothing. Also what is it with UA-camrs and absolutely hating on this mod? I swear I hear nothing but hate from UA-camrs over this mod, even before it came to bedrock, UA-camrs were hating on it because "it's too complicated 😢". Like duh, that's the point of the mod, why are you surprised that it's complicated?
The bedrock version deserves all the hate it gets, that was an absolutely horrible cash grab. But the java edition is absolutely fantastic, people just don't have the common sense to READ THE INSTRUCTIONS GIVEN TO THEM.
@@ryan___ryan2711listen mate, heard those stories practically everyday from my mother (that works in hospital), a lot of people can't read huge text in the middle of doors, do you really think they're gonna read instructions?
@@furrymczplayer18 No problem! I joined the FTB discord the other day and I've seen a lot of people having this same problem. If you bump into any more bugs, feel free to swing by!
I play on a world with tinkers constructs, the grave stone addon, and the essentials one. They are nice, but they definitely need more refining to be top tier in my eyes
Just take the books in tinkers one step at a time. Spend some time making all the things in materials and you, then spend some time on puny smelting, then spend sometime on mighty smelting. Don't try to do everything at once
100% agree, but don't think it's going to happen sadly, by how negative he sounded towards it. It's meant to be a slow progression mod, not something you can showcase in 20 mins in creative. Terrible way to experience it for the first time, for sure.
to give you an idea of how big Tinkers construct is I did an in-depth review of it and it took almost 4 hours to get threw it all and I did experience some bugs that seem to be specific to my world because I am un able to reproduce them
Yeah, Tinkers is relatively deep, all things considered. Also, Bedrock tinkers is a lot jankier tham the Java mod, because addons cant really do custom UI menus.
@@Ralzoneit might eventually get to that point, again addons were kinda just thrown onto us out of nowhere and they’re still testing out a lot of things for the capabilities of addons as a whole at the moment for the game and just doing small updates and bug fixes before they do anything big like that for them that could potentially break them without further testing
@@Ralzone I doubt add-ons will ever be at level of mods, they're not gonna give players that kind of freedom. The same reason why there's not official support for mods, selling mods like add-ons would be breaking EULA (you cannot profit from selling modified version of the game), but it's going on for so long (first mods were already in alpha) and is so big they just leave us alone. At least they gave you tools for add-ons, we created everything from scratch.
The portable crafting table should just give you access to the 9x9 recipe interface as long as it's in your inventory. You shouldn't have to place it down at all. This should also be a late-game addition to vanilla since it would help massively with mining (turning ore to blocks without placing a table down every time).
Reason why I don't like marketplace addons: - may be no exploration based addons - all of addons have a guid book Reason why I like marketplace addons: - they are extremely explained - easy to use - we can download naturalist addon for free from developer's youtube channel
I mean, unless you play on console, yeah. I think that’s why people making reviews for marketplace content is so important to me. I need to know when my money is going to be well spent.
Only switch to bedrock if you can use ray tracing on bedrock. Or if you can't use mods on java. Bedrock makes installing mods easier (there's free ones on mcpedl) and is more optimized without the need for sodium
I love Tinker's Construct from Java, but it's a mod I don't really use any more as I find myself ignoring allot of gear from other mods because Tinker's stuff is just better. Fantastic mod but I wanted to explore what other mods had to offer
All three of these are add ons that I'm interested in so it's good to see a review. Marketplace ratings aren't much to go on, though a very low rated one often indicates that there are seriously broken elements in it. Reviews like this gives me an idea of what the add on does and how it works, so even if the reviewer doesn't like it, I still get an informed opinion about it. Toycat mentioned Ecko's reviews so I think it's helpful to watch both if you're interested in an add on to get two different perspectives. Ecko has reviews for all three of these, but I haven't gotten around to watching the Tinker review yet.
Do keep in mind (except for console edition), you don't HAVE to play for mods. You can still download them from the Internet and put them into your game. The only difference is that no one ever made those because why do it for bedrock when you can do it on Java. All the marketplace stuff was make an incentive for creators to make mods for bedrock because they can actually get paid. Of course, that comes with it's own downsides of its own. And you know, you have to pay money. But that's why they contained it into a small marketplace section o nthe main menu that you never have to interact with if you don't want to. It's monetized, but not in a way that's actually intrusive, which makes it a neutral feature, unlike 90% of other monetized games these days. In my eyes, the marketplace is perfectly fine. If it's something you want, then good for you. Otherwise, it lets other players be, and that's okay too. Then again, that's my opinion. So if you disagree, feel free to explain yours as well.
So Microsoft basically steals 70% of income from marketplace, so you pay a lot, but creators get barely anything and in case of Tinker's Construct there is literally better ports of original mod on the internet than this garbage from the marketplace. Also there is so little useful addons on the marketplace and quality is so low that it isn't really worth the money. God I would pay for something like Create on Java, but not for a ton of cheap furniture addons that can't even make this furniture usable or just A BLOCK. I pay for furniture addon and get clock-entity!? This must be a joke. And accessibility of marketplace for creators is just not existent, you can't just go and post your work you have to complete some stupid verification process and tons of moderation and it doesn't even moderate anything properly because there is still stolen IP on the marketplaces. Idea is great, implementation is awful
The marketplace is actually in a horrible state, from copyright to actually getting original ideas from the paid content. With the new mods, it’s gotten better but it’s nothing good. You also didn’t mention the fact that in order to download mods from another site, you have to have a PC or Pocket Edition and PAY for realms to play on anything but PC and PE. That’s still making people pay for mods and it’s scummy as hell when considering 2 of the platforms can’t even get stuff for free. A good idea but Mojang really hasn’t managed it well. Idm paying for things either, I got BDcraft as it’s my favorite texture pack but that’s the only thing I’ve bought because everything else is either too expensive or just straight up a scam.
Slightly annoying that this review was done impulsively instead of being practiced to thoroughly inform potentially-interested people. Hopefully he takes a slightly less-impulsive approach to showcasing mods like these. Though I'm glad he did take the time to explore them later on, albeit at a slower and less-prepared pace.
What do you mean? Spending 5 minutes on tinkers constructs and not having any understanding of material properties or even touching smelting was a PERFECTLY valid review of Tinkers /s
he is just using the mask feature wrong with world builder the mask sets blocks that can be changed so you can replace a specific block in a selection rather than all of them in reality this addon is almost as versatile as the world edit mod for java
the essentials addon's ore scanner only work when your near the ores that are listed on the scanner and it will tell you how many ores are in the vein before you mine it
Tinker's Construct is great for mining with a mace, digging a 3 wide section of blocks at a time. That and the weapons really make sense with higher level metals like manyulyn. He didn't even get into the forge where you smelt metals.
i wouldnt say "let me review these things and see if its worth your money" and then be biased about the add on just because YOU dont like it and cause people who watch your ideos to not even pay attention to it even if they might like it themselves. You could make a bone farm out of a regular mob grinder with the undead effect, free bones and arrows, you think too narrowly about these kinds of things, man
Essentials is the Jack of all trades master of none the vein miner treecapitator and grave stone where done better in other add ons already available the grave stone one being free and most of everything else was too expensive for what it did didn't work properly with just the portable end chest and crafting table being genuinely good IMO
The point of tinkers is unlimited tool customization. Each ingredient has a different trait you may or may not want on your type of tool. They act as enchants. There is a lot more to this MOD than ibx could hope to show no offense it's just that big
Love that the last one had chunk borders. It's the only reason I'm considering buying it. I already have a much better tree chopper add on but chunk borders is huge for us on console. Now if only they would do an add on similar to lightmatica. 😫 Or something for connected textures
The fake blocks are so you can make a secret entrance to a secret base. Make a wall and then switch out a couple blocks for fake blocks and you can enter and exit the room without an obvious door*. I think it mentions that in the Add-on description.
I am almomst surprised that this many add ons are getting added so quickly. Also, I wonder what the best add ons made outside the marketplace are (keep in mind: add on makers can use a lot more features when not restricted to making an add on for the marketplace).
Tinkers gets really confusing at times you really do have to read the books for how to craft stuff and what certain things do like the alloys and stuff it really is easier to just start a new worl with it and figure it out
I like the pricing. The main thing woth add-ons is they are cross play whivh regular mods are. Also only one person actually needs to own the add-on for everyone in the server to be able to play it. So while some might not like paying for it. It is by far the best method to play mods cross play
tinkers construct isn't bad u just have to learn it.. it takes a bit but after a while u will understand and it will be fun/good. it is VERY important to read the books.
Can you make a video with players request for add-on suggestions the community wants. I for one love bedrock edition but so desperately need a replay mod add-on for creating cinematic cutscene for my let’s play series. Would this be a video you can create since you have the ears and eyes of the people?
Hey I'm trying to find an old Minecraft UA-camr I used to watch. I can't remember if it is ibxtoycat, but it rings a bell. However I can't find the old world lets plays. His voice sounds familiar. It's not Stampy, but very similar!
Just a question, why do chunk borders matter? Like I hear a lot about building in chunk borders & doing certain things in chunks? Just hear about it a lot & was wondering why they are useful?
@@White_Wookey I think addons in most cases doesn't disable achievements on existing worlds, but experimental settings that are required for some of them do, however I think that there is no addon on the marketplace that requires these. But paying for addon for it to disable achievements in a new world is still looks like cash grab. I don't know why is there even a difference between enabling it on creation or after, Bedrock is so broken
Hey I am just here to say that there's a free tinker construct addon downloadable in mcpedl I didn't check if it's from the same developer just so you know that you can play it if you're not ready to pay the price
Bro did not just offend Tinkers' construct What the heck toy cat? I know that it is an opinion but if you played on java you would know the true Tinkers Construct
That's just how add-ons are, they're hugely limited to tools already present in game, that makes it hard to copy Java mods that change the code of the game.
@@Dread_2137 nope, there is much better ports of that mod on the internet and one of them even older and currently outdated, it has custom UIs and everything. Marketplace is just truly a cashgrab
Mister cat, I accidently bought that editor add on the other day after given the free 500 coins, didn't mean to, which is what this is all about anyways...I accidentally selected the coin purchase option when trying to hit the search one or whatever but because of how janky the browsing is on console sometimes, and the marketplace getting an update of something bc that box in middle of screen popped up did a loading animation then proceeded to process the coin purchase of the editor. Tl;Dr I accidentally got the editor add on bc there is no "are you sure you want to purchase this" safety check when buying anything off marketplace (with coins.). Am I only one that thinks that should change/that this ish has happened to?
Not to me also the same thing happened to me I was looking at something and I accidentally gave it to buy and when I realized it discounted the coins and I didn't want to buy anything, and it was then that I thought I shouldn't this have a purchase verification to avoid these mistakes Accidentally.
@@darcus200man Fr I'm sorry for that having happened to you too but I gotta be real with ya...made me feel a whole lot better lol just don't feel as dumb as I did if I'm honest. Thanks for letting me know bro
Hey would you mine doing a video on my tool I’ve created which merges Minecraft bedrock edition addon’s I will give it too you for free just for doing the video on it!
I hate everything about add ons..... how am I supposed to pay for 400-500 of them when they all switch over or could you play mod packs as like a bundle deal...
wait until he finds out there are 4 other books in that tinker's construct mod.
I understand some people love that sort of depth, but it's not for me!
@toycat Funny enough, I've been tempted by the addon not because of the smithing but because string is now a droppable item from grass & I've always had trouble getting string quickly enough 😂.
@@toycati personally think this is best add-on so far and has the most potential as more things are opened up to these creators
And I think it has a 4.4 rating because some people got it and were confused with everything, and just gave up and gave a bad rating, not understanding how truly amazing it is
@@toycat it's not for *anybody* who plays Minecraft Survival (properly... yes, yes - i know, don't let anybody tell you how to play it)
@@curmudgeonylibrarian kill village cats !! >:-D
Seems like a bit bias of a review tbh... The first couple pages of the tinkers book pretty much explain everything just like any other add-on, the other pages are mostly in-depth details you don't need to know until later when you're interested, like if you want to know what all the keywords on the tools mean, you can just look them up when designing a perfect tool for you.
And you can't really experience it for 20 mins in creative, when it's designed to be played over hours/days in survival, then expect to have a good idea what it's like, also some of the tools can mine in a 3x3 area, do insane damage like 20+ and can have unlimited durability, not to mention the 20+ custom effects like being able to cut down an entire tree in one hit (which essentials completely failed at), or giving a really high chance to get wither skeleton skulls, so saying it's got no high end is a bit of a joke lol.
It also has a bunch more to do with smelting, crafting, and combat, should really give it more of a chance.
Not sure if it's a balance choice or a bug, but tools from tinkers on Java don't disappear when they break, they become unusable, and then you need to repair them.
I agree it feel like he wanted to make a easy video since addons are new but also did a pretty piss poor job trying to review these. Ecko soldiers does much better reviews of these addons
I couldn’t watch this, was actually making me mad lol.. From the moment he mentioned Tinkers he just started acting really annoyed and whinny like he’s being forced to make this video before he can have his ice cream.
The video isn't a guide or in-depth analysis, not sure why you and others think every mod deserves to be treated like it's a mod review from back then. It's simply trying 3 higher rated mods and going into it with 0 experience as a noob who's trying it for the first time. This Tinkerer's is implemented worse in almost every way compared to Java. He did run through these quick, but this is realistic for like 90% of people who try out the mods. Most players trying aren't going "let me sit down for an hour or two" to begin understanding the mod. It's a mod creators job to make sure the introduction and learning process is as easy and understandable as possible, even helping guide you in the start. TC just throws like 6 books as you and says "read" like this isn't the fastest way to make most people feel overwhelmed, like it's not worth it, and quit within 10-20 mins even if they genuinely are interested in the concept or would be willing to learn... But don't want to deal with a crappy learning system. (Sounds like school, right? Students actually look forward to classes with good and fun teachers regardless of the subject).
I've been playing with Applied Energistics, or Tech Reborn, and a few others, and this is a problem techy mods also commit, but these have MUCH MORE content than TC and their presentation is still easier to understand in Java because it's 1 book or well made wiki it directs you where everything is in one place, images have color, there's diagrams, examples, and even challenges they give players (without holding their hand), and it's ALL in one place rather than this mess spread across several books (subtabs would be better), these mods, to make even easier, are recommend being paired with questbooks with short descriptions/instructions to help guide the player down some path of progression.
I saw this TC bedrock version and... Yeah, it needs work. I'm not surprised no one would want to dedicated more than 20 mins unless they're just THAT bored with MC and looking to squeeze anything out of Bedrock at that point. And no, I'm not going to give it benefit of the doubt or go even slightly easy on it. This is a PAID mod. PAID. And the alternative is better, free, has more compatibility with other mods, it feels less janky (you have to use both to understand), and there's several more reasons why it just is better (from more features/capabilities and potential, and more). This TC for bedrock being popular is just a testament to how bad mods on bedrock are that mediocre ones rise to the top.
@@RemedieX Totally agree with your last paragraph, was horribly implemented and would never pay for such poor content, would personally only pay for large varied content like an expansion, otherwise they are just going to nickel and dime you.
But my main point was he was trying it in creative mode, which just does not work with tinkers because of how the parts system works.
It would be a lot nicer of an experience for him if played naturally in a play through, but I know not everyone has time for that, unless that's what they are looking for like you said.
Editing error: in the intro the 4.2* review map was TRIMS, not tinker construct!
The different tool handles give different bonuses, as well as the different tool head types. Matching both gives a Pure tool, but reading and picking what you ultimately want are a big part of how you make stuffs (at least in the Maps that I have bought that have this in them, I do not have the add on yet).
2:12, the start of your laughter sounded like a creeper or breaking a grass block 😂
I thought that was on purpose as a jab on tinkers lol
When you were detecting for ore with that ore scanner
You said this was recommended by eckosoldier
The ore scanner is supposed to work on the same level as ores You were testing it above GROUND
And not in a cave or ravine
Essentials has basically Timber Mod, fake blocks to use as secret entrances, chunk borders, vein miners, an ore finder, perma night vision, AND vertical half slabs! SOLD!
FOR 99 CENTS
Perma night vision? What?
Perma night vision?/effect @s night_vision 10000 255
It's 2$ now
13:57 Mask means only the blocks that are part of the mask get replaced. Since your mask is Stone Brick, Glass Block, and Block of Emerald, none of the selected blocks changed because they are grass blocks
With the World Builder, you MUST take your time and read the instructions. It is a fantastic add-on when you get the hang of it
world edit bedrock edition for free *AHEM*
Worldbuilder has saved me so much time in my world. And fixing mistakes is incredibly easy. Worth the price imo.
The terrible UI doesn't help for Tinker's Construct. In the Java mod, there's a special UI which shows what parts you need for which tools
I'm in LOVE with tinker's construct but for some reason a lot of items and blocks in the add-on that are essential for you to progress through the mod are completely invisible for me. I hate it so much and no matter what i do, I can't make it work properly for my worlds. I've deleted the add-on and re-downloaded it and it's solved nothing. Also what is it with UA-camrs and absolutely hating on this mod? I swear I hear nothing but hate from UA-camrs over this mod, even before it came to bedrock, UA-camrs were hating on it because "it's too complicated 😢". Like duh, that's the point of the mod, why are you surprised that it's complicated?
The bedrock version deserves all the hate it gets, that was an absolutely horrible cash grab. But the java edition is absolutely fantastic, people just don't have the common sense to READ THE INSTRUCTIONS GIVEN TO THEM.
@@ryan___ryan2711listen mate, heard those stories practically everyday from my mother (that works in hospital), a lot of people can't read huge text in the middle of doors, do you really think they're gonna read instructions?
That's a bug caused by having the holiday creator experimental feature on, they're working on fixing it but haven't figured it out just yet
@@burstbusterz8630 OHHHHHHH thank you for letting me know, I've been going crazy trying to figure out if my Minecraft was broken or not 😭
@@furrymczplayer18 No problem! I joined the FTB discord the other day and I've seen a lot of people having this same problem. If you bump into any more bugs, feel free to swing by!
ToyCat: This ore finder is broken.
Also ToyCat: **doesn't use it underground**
Toycat: Mind blown by the beginning of tinkers
Also Toycat: Looks at smeltery book and you can hear the dread in his voice.
I play on a world with tinkers constructs, the grave stone addon, and the essentials one. They are nice, but they definitely need more refining to be top tier in my eyes
You have to start tinkers construct in a new world to truly love it, the smelting aspect is top tier, the extra tools are definitely awesome too.
Just take the books in tinkers one step at a time. Spend some time making all the things in materials and you, then spend some time on puny smelting, then spend sometime on mighty smelting. Don't try to do everything at once
100% agree, but don't think it's going to happen sadly, by how negative he sounded towards it.
It's meant to be a slow progression mod, not something you can showcase in 20 mins in creative.
Terrible way to experience it for the first time, for sure.
to give you an idea of how big Tinkers construct is I did an in-depth review of it and it took almost 4 hours to get threw it all and I did experience some bugs that seem to be specific to my world because I am un able to reproduce them
Yeah, Tinkers is relatively deep, all things considered. Also, Bedrock tinkers is a lot jankier tham the Java mod, because addons cant really do custom UI menus.
@@venomousfrog5546yeah, that's advantage of mods, mods can modify the code of the game, add-ons can only use tools already present in the game.
@@Dread_2137 Yeah, mojang should give more freedom and tools to creators for addons even start to compare to mods
@@Ralzoneit might eventually get to that point, again addons were kinda just thrown onto us out of nowhere and they’re still testing out a lot of things for the capabilities of addons as a whole at the moment for the game and just doing small updates and bug fixes before they do anything big like that for them that could potentially break them without further testing
@@Ralzone I doubt add-ons will ever be at level of mods, they're not gonna give players that kind of freedom.
The same reason why there's not official support for mods, selling mods like add-ons would be breaking EULA (you cannot profit from selling modified version of the game), but it's going on for so long (first mods were already in alpha) and is so big they just leave us alone.
At least they gave you tools for add-ons, we created everything from scratch.
The portable crafting table should just give you access to the 9x9 recipe interface as long as it's in your inventory. You shouldn't have to place it down at all. This should also be a late-game addition to vanilla since it would help massively with mining (turning ore to blocks without placing a table down every time).
Reason why I don't like marketplace addons:
- may be no exploration based addons
- all of addons have a guid book
Reason why I like marketplace addons:
- they are extremely explained
- easy to use
- we can download naturalist addon for free from developer's youtube channel
i bought it 😭😭
Now, we no longer can download Naturalist 2 from Developer's UA-cam channel i.e. it get replaced by Minecraft marketplace from mediafire
i would never switch from java for this, i CANNOT imagine paying for mods when they are free all over the internet.
I mean, unless you play on console, yeah. I think that’s why people making reviews for marketplace content is so important to me. I need to know when my money is going to be well spent.
you can still download mods from the internet
Edit: not anymore
Only switch to bedrock if you can use ray tracing on bedrock. Or if you can't use mods on java. Bedrock makes installing mods easier (there's free ones on mcpedl) and is more optimized without the need for sodium
@@absolutezero9507 ray tracing does not make up for how terrible Bedrock generally is
Yea it does. Theres nothing wrong with bedrock edition its just different and you dont like it 😂 @osryr
0:07 oh my god seeing myself actually jumpscared me 😭
I love Tinker's Construct from Java, but it's a mod I don't really use any more as I find myself ignoring allot of gear from other mods because Tinker's stuff is just better. Fantastic mod but I wanted to explore what other mods had to offer
All three of these are add ons that I'm interested in so it's good to see a review. Marketplace ratings aren't much to go on, though a very low rated one often indicates that there are seriously broken elements in it. Reviews like this gives me an idea of what the add on does and how it works, so even if the reviewer doesn't like it, I still get an informed opinion about it.
Toycat mentioned Ecko's reviews so I think it's helpful to watch both if you're interested in an add on to get two different perspectives. Ecko has reviews for all three of these, but I haven't gotten around to watching the Tinker review yet.
Do keep in mind (except for console edition), you don't HAVE to play for mods. You can still download them from the Internet and put them into your game. The only difference is that no one ever made those because why do it for bedrock when you can do it on Java. All the marketplace stuff was make an incentive for creators to make mods for bedrock because they can actually get paid. Of course, that comes with it's own downsides of its own. And you know, you have to pay money. But that's why they contained it into a small marketplace section o nthe main menu that you never have to interact with if you don't want to. It's monetized, but not in a way that's actually intrusive, which makes it a neutral feature, unlike 90% of other monetized games these days. In my eyes, the marketplace is perfectly fine. If it's something you want, then good for you. Otherwise, it lets other players be, and that's okay too.
Then again, that's my opinion. So if you disagree, feel free to explain yours as well.
So Microsoft basically steals 70% of income from marketplace, so you pay a lot, but creators get barely anything and in case of Tinker's Construct there is literally better ports of original mod on the internet than this garbage from the marketplace.
Also there is so little useful addons on the marketplace and quality is so low that it isn't really worth the money. God I would pay for something like Create on Java, but not for a ton of cheap furniture addons that can't even make this furniture usable or just A BLOCK. I pay for furniture addon and get clock-entity!? This must be a joke.
And accessibility of marketplace for creators is just not existent, you can't just go and post your work you have to complete some stupid verification process and tons of moderation and it doesn't even moderate anything properly because there is still stolen IP on the marketplaces.
Idea is great, implementation is awful
The marketplace is actually in a horrible state, from copyright to actually getting original ideas from the paid content.
With the new mods, it’s gotten better but it’s nothing good. You also didn’t mention the fact that in order to download mods from another site, you have to have a PC or Pocket Edition and PAY for realms to play on anything but PC and PE. That’s still making people pay for mods and it’s scummy as hell when considering 2 of the platforms can’t even get stuff for free.
A good idea but Mojang really hasn’t managed it well. Idm paying for things either, I got BDcraft as it’s my favorite texture pack but that’s the only thing I’ve bought because everything else is either too expensive or just straight up a scam.
One thing I have no idea what you're talking about with the realms thing you can get mods on phone and pc without paying for anything
@@kirishplayz7664yeah that’s only on phone and pc. If you play on any other platform you need realms.
@@Damgladorit tinker construct is bad remember that feed the beast themselves made it, so go complain to them.
"Tinkers is highly technical"
I mean, yeah, it's technical mod, we on java love technical mods.
Wait until he hears about the create mod
Slightly annoying that this review was done impulsively instead of being practiced to thoroughly inform potentially-interested people. Hopefully he takes a slightly less-impulsive approach to showcasing mods like these. Though I'm glad he did take the time to explore them later on, albeit at a slower and less-prepared pace.
What do you mean? Spending 5 minutes on tinkers constructs and not having any understanding of material properties or even touching smelting was a PERFECTLY valid review of Tinkers /s
he is just using the mask feature wrong with world builder the mask sets blocks that can be changed so you can replace a specific block in a selection rather than all of them in reality this addon is almost as versatile as the world edit mod for java
the essentials addon's ore scanner only work when your near the ores that are listed on the scanner and it will tell you how many ores are in the vein before you mine it
Tinker's Construct is great for mining with a mace, digging a 3 wide section of blocks at a time. That and the weapons really make sense with higher level metals like manyulyn. He didn't even get into the forge where you smelt metals.
I’ve been waiting for you to review the world builder 🤩🙏🏻
Honestly tinkers construct is cool but its kinda weird they still let you craft tools the normal way
Because add ons aren't allowed to change or remove base game mechanics.
Plus its pretty time consuming to get a weapon lol
@@AngelDelight69not really? All you need is like 3 tables to create your first wooden weapon
personally i love tinkers construct and it pairs nice with Essentials i dont mind reading a guide book personally love it
i wouldnt say "let me review these things and see if its worth your money" and then be biased about the add on just because YOU dont like it and cause people who watch your ideos to not even pay attention to it even if they might like it themselves. You could make a bone farm out of a regular mob grinder with the undead effect, free bones and arrows, you think too narrowly about these kinds of things, man
I appreciate you reviewing these, you just never know when it comes to the marketplace
Essentials is the Jack of all trades master of none the vein miner treecapitator and grave stone where done better in other add ons already available the grave stone one being free and most of everything else was too expensive for what it did didn't work properly with just the portable end chest and crafting table being genuinely good IMO
it's so funny how much effort truly goes into learning crafting recipes in tinker's construct to craft weapons no stronger than a stone sword
The point of tinkers is unlimited tool customization. Each ingredient has a different trait you may or may not want on your type of tool. They act as enchants. There is a lot more to this MOD than ibx could hope to show no offense it's just that big
2:12 This is the first time I have seen his creative world, and as an Undertale fan, I was turned on when I saw Flowey being there.
Bridge forever with a portable furnace / crafter, you have to crouch to place the block but it's a bridge to infinity.
Love that the last one had chunk borders. It's the only reason I'm considering buying it. I already have a much better tree chopper add on but chunk borders is huge for us on console. Now if only they would do an add on similar to lightmatica. 😫 Or something for connected textures
All I want is borderless glass on PS5
Mutants is a pretty good add-on it makes the game more challenging and fun
The fake blocks are so you can make a secret entrance to a secret base. Make a wall and then switch out a couple blocks for fake blocks and you can enter and exit the room without an obvious door*. I think it mentions that in the Add-on description.
I am almomst surprised that this many add ons are getting added so quickly. Also, I wonder what the best add ons made outside the marketplace are (keep in mind: add on makers can use a lot more features when not restricted to making an add on for the marketplace).
Absolutely thrilled to see more exposure for Bedrock content!
10:08 puzzle block(if I remember right)based I believe. The lines remind me of those
Tinkers gets really confusing at times you really do have to read the books for how to craft stuff and what certain things do like the alloys and stuff it really is easier to just start a new worl with it and figure it out
Crazy to me that Microsoft cant see the free mods are why java is so big. If they just add mod support for bedrock it would be so much better.
Esaestuals had an update where you can now chop down entire huge trees in one go
I do dislike the pricing on the marketplace for the addons but addon like the essentials is cheaper like why can’t other cost close to that
I like the pricing. The main thing woth add-ons is they are cross play whivh regular mods are.
Also only one person actually needs to own the add-on for everyone in the server to be able to play it.
So while some might not like paying for it. It is by far the best method to play mods cross play
tinkers construct isn't bad u just have to learn it.. it takes a bit but after a while u will understand and it will be fun/good.
it is VERY important to read the books.
Nice flowey and majoras mask statues
good day when u upload
0:30 TINKERS CONSTRUCT IS ACCUALLY THE BIGGEST, MOST FUN AND THE BEST ADD ON IN THE GAME
The world builder add on needs a performance update other than that its pretty good
Omg echo I forgot about him I used to watch his survival island streams. All the time
Does the ore scanner scan for ancient debris? If ir does thats super bennificial
25:05 I think it could be useful when strip mining
Bro these outros are amazing lmao
Mojang before:Minecrafters are not allowed to make their mods cost money
Mojang now:This mod cost 10$
Because now they're making money off it. So greedy
Tinkers' Construct, i am very familiar to that add-on
Can you make a video with players request for add-on suggestions the community wants. I for one love bedrock edition but so desperately need a replay mod add-on for creating cinematic cutscene for my let’s play series. Would this be a video you can create since you have the ears and eyes of the people?
If they redid the aether mod I would for sure cop that for bedrock ngl
Hey I'm trying to find an old Minecraft UA-camr I used to watch. I can't remember if it is ibxtoycat, but it rings a bell. However I can't find the old world lets plays. His voice sounds familiar. It's not Stampy, but very similar!
Just a question, why do chunk borders matter? Like I hear a lot about building in chunk borders & doing certain things in chunks? Just hear about it a lot & was wondering why they are useful?
You know, you could spend either $1 or $600, neither value actually says its amazing. True for everything.
Fake blocks are useful to hide entrances to your home.
it seems to me they made tinkers more complicated then what its like on java
28:04 I'm no longer a miner, I'm a farmer!
Pls compare world utilities with essential add-on
If you buy the premium edition of Minecraft on console rn you could get all three add ons for free technically, and it’s half off right now
15:33 I think it's cause you moved too far away from the chunks, making them unload? I flying in the middle would work better
Bro, forgot to show the smeltery in tinkers construct
Do they disable achievements?
If you enable them when you create a world - yes, after creating a world - shouldn't
@@Damglador kinda a let down Ngl would be a better feature if they didn’t disable them on existing worlds, considering they are paid for.
@@White_Wookey I think addons in most cases doesn't disable achievements on existing worlds, but experimental settings that are required for some of them do, however I think that there is no addon on the marketplace that requires these.
But paying for addon for it to disable achievements in a new world is still looks like cash grab. I don't know why is there even a difference between enabling it on creation or after, Bedrock is so broken
@@DamgladorAll types of addons disable achievements.
@@mobamba4282 no, Im playing with gravestones and getting achievements
shamefully i bought the tinkers construction, it was very fun for a while but low key they could have done way better on it
What add on gives the villager selling heads? Pls tell me I need to know. 😭
Hey I am just here to say that there's a free tinker construct addon downloadable in mcpedl I didn't check if it's from the same developer just so you know that you can play it if you're not ready to pay the price
What if they add a legacy add-on?
Chunk borders is all you needed to say
Bro did not just offend Tinkers' construct
What the heck toy cat? I know that it is an opinion but if you played on java you would know the true Tinkers Construct
When you usethe furnace it becomes permenamt and you can summoj a new one.. easiest dupicator ever
Who cares about duping a furnace tho. It takes 2 secs to get 8 stone
Big number of items = monkey brain go oooh
I knew they would make us pay for mods eventually. .I guess my time here is almost through because I will not have it.
Marketplace version of Tinker's Construct is a hot garbage
That's just how add-ons are, they're hugely limited to tools already present in game, that makes it hard to copy Java mods that change the code of the game.
Additionallly, Mojang limits what they can do and while it seems they are loosing them a bit, this also plays a factor into these Addons
@@Dread_2137 nope, there is much better ports of that mod on the internet and one of them even older and currently outdated, it has custom UIs and everything. Marketplace is just truly a cashgrab
Bro the mask is what you are able to replace
Mister cat, I accidently bought that editor add on the other day after given the free 500 coins, didn't mean to, which is what this is all about anyways...I accidentally selected the coin purchase option when trying to hit the search one or whatever but because of how janky the browsing is on console sometimes, and the marketplace getting an update of something bc that box in middle of screen popped up did a loading animation then proceeded to process the coin purchase of the editor.
Tl;Dr I accidentally got the editor add on bc there is no "are you sure you want to purchase this" safety check when buying anything off marketplace (with coins.). Am I only one that thinks that should change/that this ish has happened to?
Not to me also the same thing happened to me I was looking at something and I accidentally gave it to buy and when I realized it discounted the coins and I didn't want to buy anything, and it was then that I thought I shouldn't this have a purchase verification to avoid these mistakes Accidentally.
@@darcus200man Fr I'm sorry for that having happened to you too but I gotta be real with ya...made me feel a whole lot better lol just don't feel as dumb as I did if I'm honest. Thanks for letting me know bro
Hi love the vids
Do addons remove achievements?
Yes
Yall have to understand that the addons are more from console than anything.
It did update and I love it so far
World builder is so good
Tinkers is in Bedrock now? I might try bedrock now.
as far as the Bedrock Marketplace Ratings Children don't understand how to rate things.
I have played the original of this add-on and this is childs play compared to the original
I’m not spawning in with the handbook. The addon is active in my world
Tinkers Construct on java: **bone tools are good, not great, but definitely don't do THAT** **Free**
Tinkers Construct on Bedrock: Hah, goteem.
The funniest thing is that there is better ports of Tinker's Construct on the internet
Omg I really hope this isn’t to laggy for my tablet bro.I NEED TO MAKE SOME SECRET BASES NOW. Essentials is the only good one
Bone dagger = bone meal farm
Are you going to review the java mod legacy4j?
If i didn't have to spend 7 Canadian dollars for any of these, which i would probably only use once, rhen i would be interested lol.
i always assume the rating in the store is fake
Hey would you mine doing a video on my tool I’ve created which merges Minecraft bedrock edition addon’s I will give it too you for free just for doing the video on it!
you should not put multiple of the same block in the a gradient or it will not work properly.
I hate everything about add ons..... how am I supposed to pay for 400-500 of them when they all switch over or could you play mod packs as like a bundle deal...