Shamshad Ahmad, former Foreign Secretary offers controversial view of Army's role in Pakistan! Why?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 бер 2023
  • In this very interesting conversation with Pakistan's former Foreign Secretary, Shamshad Ahmad Khan, he surprisingly and quite unexpectedly offered a very controversial view about the Army's role in the politics of Pakistan. Quite frankly It took me by surprise, given what he has been publicly saying in the past, which to my understanding offered a contrarian viewpoint. Somehow I felt he was carrying a message from certain quarters to be delivered through my platform. Do watch!
    Please support our fight for a FREE DEMOCRATIC PAKISTAN by clicking this link
    patreon.com/user?u=70323056
    Thank you
    براہ کرم اس لنک پر کلک کرکے آزاد جمہوری پاکستان کے لیے ہماری جدوجہد کی حمایت کریں patreon.com/user?u=70323056 شکریہ
    پاکستان کے سابق سیکرٹری خارجہ شمشاد احمد خان کے ساتھ اس انتہائی دلچسپ گفتگو میں انہوں نے حیرت انگیز طور پر اور بالکل غیر متوقع طور پر پاکستان کی سیاست میں فوج کے کردار کے بارے میں ایک بہت ہی متنازعہ نقطہ نظر پیش کیا۔
    اس نے مجھے حیرت میں ڈال دیا، اس بات کو دیکھتے ہوئے کہ وہ ماضی میں کھلے عام کیا کہتے رہے ہیں، جو میری سمجھ کے مطابق ایک متضاد نقطہ نظر پیش کرتا ہے۔
    کسی طرح میں نے محسوس کیا کہ وہ ایک مخصوص ادارے کی طرف سے انہیں دیا گیا پیغام پہنچا رہے ہیں جو میرے پلیٹ فارم کے ذریعے پہنچایا جانا تھا۔ براہ کرم دیکھیں!

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @rocketman007
    @rocketman007 Рік тому +54

    You are a true hero. Haider saab, your name will be written in history for the awakening during this purging era in PAKISTAN ❤

    • @arslansajjad6058
      @arslansajjad6058 Рік тому

      Î

    • @arslansajjad6058
      @arslansajjad6058 Рік тому

      Î

    • @user-fw1ze3ow8i
      @user-fw1ze3ow8i Рік тому

      @Student of Klaus Schwab You may think that way, except that you fail to consider the fact that Ayub Khan knowingly sold Pakistan's future when he agreed to completely give Pakistan's interests in one direction instead of keeping it balanced between America and the rest of the world (read Russia and China). You should only do a quick internet search to see how Ayub Khan was greeted at the Airport by JF Kennedy, and by the Queen herself- you would be flabbergasted. That kind of grandest welcome ever to any international leader has never ever been given to anyone except Ayub Khan. That was because he knowingly signed the Seato-Cento. The rest is history. Now in 2023, the Generals have established a humongous EMPIRE that is above the constitution (they cannot be tried in Pakistani courts- they have their own Kangaroo courts headed by their own folks who give any kind of decision they want, without any fear). Nothing in the country can say or do anything if it clashes with their views. They MANAGE the elections, like they are doing right now, despite any and every legal, constitutional requirement against them. They ensure the governments that are formed are weak, coalition governments, which they then manage through the creation of their own political entitities (they created PMLN, PMLQ, MQM, BAP, TLP, and a host of others during various time in history, remember IJI). They have the largest Industrialized organization in the form of Fauji Foundation and its 51 sub organizations, all of which are headed by Ex-Army Generals. They have created the PLAAT culture that is out of control, and silenced every honest Army person from Major on up. They have brought extensive corruption into the Army itself through that property dealership.Agreed that wasn't there in ayub's times, but it started with Zia, and they have never looked back. No wonder they will not allow anybody who stands up to challenge them. Even today, people like you would give all credit to them, and blame the corrupt politicians for all wrong. But you do not realize that these very same politicians are always brought back (by cleaning them up through NRO's) and continue the plunder , as long as they do not question the stranglehold of the only INVISIBLE power that actually runs the country. Start thinking critically, and you will be able to reach the root cause of the problem, my friend.

    • @Lusiana110
      @Lusiana110 3 місяці тому

      Muhammad Qasim’s dreams : Saudi Arabia is collapsing, Jews will control Al Madinah Al Muqaddasah (Saudi Arabia). The truthfulness in #MuhammadQasimDreams is making people think he is the awaited Imam Al-Mahdi.
      #MuhammadQasimImamMahdi

  • @mohammadyahya4294
    @mohammadyahya4294 Рік тому +19

    ❤ "RESTORE JUDICIARY" ❤ BEAUTIFUL. WELL DONE, SIR. MANY CONGRATULATIONS.

  • @abbasal-kashmiri5291
    @abbasal-kashmiri5291 Рік тому +39

    *PDM + Neutrals + Judges should remember that they would surely be judged on the Day of Judgment* ... *So, everyone should fear of the Divine Justice of ALLAH* ... *May ALLAH have Mercy on all of us* ... *Aameen* !!!

    • @user-hm9wn2fx3g
      @user-hm9wn2fx3g Рік тому +6

      We Need Ruthless Accountability Process in pakistan 🇵🇰👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

    • @MrRizvi512
      @MrRizvi512 Рік тому +2

      I still remember the words of Netan Yahu, he said to his daughter while leaving his home for an official task on their religious occasion. She reminded him that it was an important prayer day and he had to be there. If prayers would be the only way to get things done, Jews would have been vanished from the face if earth, as every year millions of Muslim pilgrimagers gather in Mecca and ask Allah to destroy Jews, he said. I will finish my work and join you in prayers in evening.

    • @AmjadKhan-gt8qf
      @AmjadKhan-gt8qf Рік тому

      ABAS SB
      DO THEY BELIEVE IN
      THE DAY OF JUDGMENT ?
      I MEAN
      1. P D M.
      2. GENERALS
      3 JUDGES
      4. LIFAFA SAHAFIES
      5. MOLVIES LIKE DEIZAL
      6. BEARUCRATE
      SPECIALLY
      1. NAWAZ 2 MARYAM
      3. SHABAZ. 4 .HAMZA
      5.ZARDARI 6. BILAWAL
      7. FARYAL. 8 SARJEEL ETC.
      9. FAZLO DEIZAL 10 ASAD 11 HAMDULLA
      12 BAJWA DG ISI. D.G IS BR ALL CORE
      COMMANDERS

    • @AmjadKhan-gt8qf
      @AmjadKhan-gt8qf Рік тому +2

      DO THESE CULTS BELIEVE THE DAY OF
      JUDGEMENT ?

    • @mirhashmat
      @mirhashmat Рік тому +1

      ​@@AmjadKhan-gt8qf that's the problem. THEY DON'T.

  • @abidmajeed5866
    @abidmajeed5866 Рік тому

    ماشاءاللہ بہت زبردست پروگرام رھا. بہت کچھ سیکھنے اور سمجھنے کو ملا. اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو اور شمشاد صاحب کو اپنی حفظ و امان میں رکھے. You both are true intellectual. ھمیں ایسی ھی سوچ کی ضرورت ھے.

  • @saqlainabbas4358
    @saqlainabbas4358 Рік тому +8

    حیدر مہدی صاحب مولا حسین آپ کو سلامت رکھے 🙏🥰🇵🇰

  • @gentleman-ct8gk
    @gentleman-ct8gk Рік тому +16

    Allah....! Pakistan or Imran Khan ki Efazat Farma Ha... Ameen🤲🤲🤲

  • @mumtazahmed8099
    @mumtazahmed8099 Рік тому +9

    Thank you for the excellent Vlog. We did hear conflicting views but it leaves lot of food for thoughts. Shamshad Sahib question stands' do we have a strong and sincere civilian to lead."
    Army has also to think that they live if the country exists. And during the last 75 years both the Civilians and Armed Forces have contributed towards destruction. Civilians include Judiciary and Bureaucracy. It's commonly considered opinion that Imran Khan can lead towards reconstruction of Pakistan and Army must cooperate and prove loyalty to the soil. Allah Protect Pakistan 🇵🇰 🙏 ♥

  • @muneebsiddiqui5739
    @muneebsiddiqui5739 Рік тому +14

    Shamshad Ahmed saying that establishment is going to take Pakistan out of this mess?Hes clearly defending them what a joke! Only Imran khan is going to take Pakistan out of this mess and noone...

    • @publicpm8809
      @publicpm8809 Рік тому +1

      Exactly

    • @EXCELwithAB
      @EXCELwithAB Рік тому +3

      I am amazed at the audacity he has displayed. Shamshad sb yeh btain fouj itni powerful aur smjhdar h to civilian system ko thek q nhe kr leti. Ulta marshal law impose kr dety hn. 1 bar mulk q tukry tukry krwaya????? Come one lets talk semse its 2023 and We all know how duffer and greedy these generals are.

    • @Maximus-vq4oz
      @Maximus-vq4oz Рік тому +1

      He does not have balls to say anyting against foj.

    • @muneebsiddiqui5739
      @muneebsiddiqui5739 Рік тому

      @@Maximus-vq4oz surely he doesn't, there is no place in this world for cowards

  • @alizafar3542
    @alizafar3542 Рік тому +11

    اگر ہم کوشش کریں گے تو انشااللہ اس ذلت سے نکل جائیں گے 💯🇵🇰✌🏼

  • @rahilahabib2052
    @rahilahabib2052 Рік тому +6

    Fantastic & informative discussion.. thank you dear brothers… lots of blessings…

  • @aichamuhammad5904
    @aichamuhammad5904 Рік тому +10

    The joy!
    The idiocracy!!
    What expressions by Haider Mehdi! What a performance 👏 🙌 👏
    Lol...these intellectuals are such an asset! I didn't know that this generation who served 40 yrs were so smart!! Wallahi
    Our success is behind these intellectuals 🤲🤲🤲
    Allah khair

    • @S.Mir786
      @S.Mir786 Рік тому

      These guys are the root of problems! Getting US aid and making Islamic blocs 😂😂😂 What a joke they made us!

  • @ambreenbukhari1471
    @ambreenbukhari1471 Рік тому +5

    اے میرے اللہ اپنے پیارے نبی مُحمد مصطفے صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہہ والسلم کے صدقے عمران خان کی اس مشکل گھڑی میں فتح اور کامرانی عطا فرما 🙏 آمین

  • @mperacha4286
    @mperacha4286 Рік тому +5

    Some very interesting observations by Shamshad Ahmed saheb - lot of food for thought for all of us.

  • @syedfaisalali8949
    @syedfaisalali8949 Рік тому +4

    Assalam o Alekum, Dear Sir, What a beautiful, real and factful analysis you have provided us today. Thanks a lot, please have Sir Shamshad Ahmad Khan again for having internal facts about govt. people. Love you , May Allah bless and protect as all. Aameen

    • @rebasingh258
      @rebasingh258 Рік тому

      Best Religion : Sikh religion.
      Best Prophet: Guru Nanak Dev ji.
      Best Leader: Guru Govind Singh.
      Please convert to Sikh religion.
      Our rich Sikh brothers in Canada will repay your loan to China and convert Pakistan into Khalistan.

  • @42MSC
    @42MSC Рік тому +6

    Salute to Shamshad Ali Khan for declaring in your closing talk to join the next movement for the good of Pakistanis and our country as per the slogan on his shirt ,” Save democracy “ which he wore while joining walk of lawyers for independence of judiciary. His depiction of people of Pakistan as the strongest and most loyal loin to protect Pakistan highly commendable

  • @anwaarlone7245
    @anwaarlone7245 Рік тому +18

    Allah shaheedon ki qurbani qabool farmay ameen

  • @bluemoon1521
    @bluemoon1521 Рік тому

    شکریہ سر مہدی، اللہ پاک آپکو صحت دے اور آپکے ایمان میں برکت بھی، اور آپکی نیک محنت کو کامیاب کرے جو آپ پاکستانیوں کو جگانے، سمجھانے اور انہیں کارآمد بنانے کیلئے کر رہے ہیں ۔۔ آمین ❤

  • @abdulwahabkhan1836
    @abdulwahabkhan1836 Рік тому +3

    Dear H. Mehdi SAB, All your questions. The answers are great, I agree with what you said.

  • @raomuneeb8943
    @raomuneeb8943 Рік тому

    اللہ آپ دونوں کو صحت دے اور لمبی زندگی عطا کرے۔۔

  • @ashfaqhussain9536
    @ashfaqhussain9536 Рік тому

    ماشاءاللہ انتہائی اہم تحقیقی و معلوماتی تجزیہ و تبصرہ پیش کیا ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ جناب شمشاد صاحب آپ دونوں پر اپنی بےانتہا رحمتیں اور برکتیں نازل فرمائے آمین ثم آمین یارب العالمین!

  • @kashmiri78
    @kashmiri78 Рік тому +6

    Assalamualaikum Both of you
    True Sons of motherland Pakistan ❤❤❤

  • @mirzairshad6700
    @mirzairshad6700 Рік тому +13

    Thanks Sir for such a honourable diplomate on your show

  • @MM_Shakir
    @MM_Shakir Рік тому

    اللہ شمشاد صاحب کو کامل صحت کے ساتھ لمبی عمر عطا فرماۓ۔یہ اثاثہ ہیں پاکستان کا۔

  • @kingkong4162
    @kingkong4162 Рік тому

    ویل ویل ڈن, شمشاداحمد سر ! یو آر دی گریٹ, اللہ پاک آ پ کو مزید سچ بولنے کی ہمت اور حوصلہ عطا فرمأئیں. اور اللہ پاک حیدر مہدی صاحب آپ کو بھی مزید ھیرے تلاش کرنے کی توفیق عطافرمائیں آمیین یا رب لعاللین.

  • @AzadKhan-mj1rt
    @AzadKhan-mj1rt Рік тому +75

    ماشاء اللّٰہ ببر شیر 🦁 چاچو حیدر مہدی اللّٰہ تعالیٰ مرشد عمران احمد خان نیازی کو لمبی صحت والی زندگی اور ہر محاذ پر کامیابی عطا فرمائے آمین ثم آمین

    • @ghazanfarhussain5032
      @ghazanfarhussain5032 Рік тому +1

      Don't place 😭 all hope on mortals
      We come from the
      Lord of the worlds
      And have to return to the
      Lord of the worlds

    • @saminabutt7927
      @saminabutt7927 Рік тому +2

      Ameen summa Ameen

    • @mominaali2700
      @mominaali2700 Рік тому

      Haider mehdi hi hamaray imam mehdi hain

    • @Nouman-ir2ip
      @Nouman-ir2ip Рік тому

      @@saminabutt7927 😊 38:50

    • @Nouman-ir2ip
      @Nouman-ir2ip Рік тому

      @@ghazanfarhussain5032 😊

  • @JavedIqbal-ln9fh
    @JavedIqbal-ln9fh Рік тому +8

    Mashallah Mashallah JazakAllah my brother 🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲 Pakistan zindabad Imran Khan zindabad 🤲🤲🤲🤲🇵🇰

  • @muhammadmuqeem857
    @muhammadmuqeem857 Рік тому

    شمشاد صاحب اور حیدر مھدی صاحب زندا باد جنھون نے پاکستان کے لءے اچھی باتین کی اللہ پاگ قبول فرمءے آمین

  • @sagheerwarsi7331
    @sagheerwarsi7331 Рік тому

    حیدر مہدی سر یہ پروگرام بہت اچھا معلوماتی اور سمجھنے کیلئے ایک بہترین پروگرام ہے کاش کے پاکستان کے اداروں کے سربراہان بھی سمجھیں کے اب وقت سر پر ہے ملک و قوم کو سنبھال لیں ۔
    سب سے پہلے پاکستان
    پاکستان ذندہ باد پائندہ باد
    افواج پاکستان ذندہ باد پائندہ باد

  • @ambreenbukhari1471
    @ambreenbukhari1471 Рік тому +26

    Who is the Fan of MOHAMMAD MUSTAFA SALE ALLAH ALLEH WA ALHI WASALAM 🌹

    • @k.k5885
      @k.k5885 Рік тому

      Sallalahu Alaihewasallam 🕋

    • @baercoltd8561
      @baercoltd8561 Рік тому +1

      Why do you need to know?

    • @baba747baba2
      @baba747baba2 Рік тому +1

      Ye plate form eskam ke Lea nehe hai....Tum Jo topic hai usper BAAT karo...ye mazhabi channel nehe hai

  • @zubairiqbal2784
    @zubairiqbal2784 Рік тому +6

    Lots of love and respect for you sir from DIKhan ❤️

  • @imranjatt7348
    @imranjatt7348 Рік тому

    وعلیکم السلام حیدر مہدی صاحب اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کی اور خاموش مجاہد کی حفاظت کرے آمین 🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹💚🌹👍👍

  • @AbdulSamad-gf7fc
    @AbdulSamad-gf7fc Рік тому

    ماشااللہ
    زبردست ۔حیدر۔مہدی۔صاحب۔بہت۔خوب۔صورت۔مہثالیں۔پیش۔کیا۔شمشاد۔صاحب۔نے۔بلکل۔دورست

  • @mkhattakfocused1
    @mkhattakfocused1 Рік тому +5

    Very insightful discussion by both of you. Stay blessed!

  • @nast697
    @nast697 Рік тому +19

    Great guest. He and others of Shamshad’s calibre must speak out

  • @azharhussain8881
    @azharhussain8881 Рік тому +1

    Sir you are great.pls.carry on your struggles against thieves of Pakistan.

  • @shuaibzaf
    @shuaibzaf Рік тому

    بہت شکریہ حیدر مہدی صاحب۔
    آپ نے ان صاحب کو ایکسپوز کیا۔

  • @shahallahkhan511
    @shahallahkhan511 Рік тому +4

    Despite disagreement between both respected & patriotic personalities on many points, they agree on reforms in army & its roles. It has the capacity to put things on the right track & opt for real democracy, avoid confrontation with public & division within itself. We need as a nation to follow the golden principles of " unity, faith & discipline " in all walks of life. May Allah guide us!

  • @Vladmir-Putin
    @Vladmir-Putin Рік тому +36

    Dear Viewers,
    That's how two mature people negotiate their conflicting views and conduct themselves with civility, grace and tolerance. Thank you Mehdi sb.!

    • @HK-ts3jd
      @HK-ts3jd Рік тому +2

      Well Mr putin,where are you hiding right now 😂😂😂😂

    • @Vladmir-Putin
      @Vladmir-Putin Рік тому +2

      @@HK-ts3jd Putin never hides 😉

    • @anisfatima1559
      @anisfatima1559 Рік тому

      ​@@HK-ts3jd 🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍👍🤭

    • @afzaalsaeed8419
      @afzaalsaeed8419 5 місяців тому

      Two intellects meet at one forum

    • @afzaalsaeed8419
      @afzaalsaeed8419 5 місяців тому

      Sir haider ,I live in Islamabad,send my request to sir shashad to spare a few moments ,it will b honour for me,Warmest Regards

  • @ghulammusa2456
    @ghulammusa2456 Рік тому

    آفرین شمشاد صاحب خدا آب کو لمبی زندگ دے حیدر محدی صاحب بیحد شکریا آپنے ایسے عذیم آدمی کو سامنے پیش کیا زندا باد

  • @ShahbazKhan-ni3ol
    @ShahbazKhan-ni3ol Рік тому +4

    Bring more guests like him who can reveal hidden details

  • @neelofarkhan6100
    @neelofarkhan6100 Рік тому +4

    He is so patriotic and a brave man.

  • @nasrullahshahid4357
    @nasrullahshahid4357 Рік тому +2

    Stay blessed & safe young man " Shamshad sahib ".

  • @mohammadifrahimbutt8296
    @mohammadifrahimbutt8296 Рік тому +2

    Thank you both of you. May Allah bless us all. Ameen

  • @muhammadasifatta5691
    @muhammadasifatta5691 Рік тому +3

    Excellent Mehdi SB, Today the way you conducted the show is an example to other hosts i.e. especially for ARIFA from EAWAZ.

    • @skywalker2176
      @skywalker2176 Рік тому

      Hahaha very true but they are so numb to understand

  • @c-i2698
    @c-i2698 Рік тому +3

    Well done, Haider Mehdi , Sir ❤❤❤

  • @wajidpirzada9969
    @wajidpirzada9969 Рік тому +2

    Excellent❤ Vlog, Congrats for such Meaningful Discussions...🎉

  • @muhammadzia-urrahman1677
    @muhammadzia-urrahman1677 Рік тому +7

    Mehdi sahib. This conversation had been left unfinished. Please arrange another sitting with him as soon as you can. It is always beneficial and productive when different and sometimes opposite options are placed on the table.
    It seems good and easy when you sit with people having unanimity of views.
    The real benefit in discussions is achieved when diverse views are discussed and conclusions arrived at.
    Thoroughly enjoyed your program.

  • @ranaasdullahpanwar1151
    @ranaasdullahpanwar1151 Рік тому +5

    ❤w salam Sir Allah bless you and your family ameen Allah Pak Pakistan ko apni hafzat me rakhe ameen insha'Allah prime minister Pakistan Imran khan Allah Pak Imran khan ko apni hafzat me rakhe or kamyabi de ameen ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @jshahid4534
    @jshahid4534 Рік тому +2

    MashaAllah Excellent Programme and a very fruitful talk and very True analysis Allah SWT Bless you Haider Bahi and Shamshad Sb Love you both Stay Blessed Aameen ✌️✌️🇵🇰🇵🇰👍👍🇵🇰🇵🇰♥️♥️🇵🇰🇵🇰🌹🌹🇵🇰🇵🇰😍😍🇵🇰🇵🇰🥰🥰

  • @khansher5411
    @khansher5411 Рік тому

    We NEED PEOPLE LIKE SHAMSHAD SIR..
    PAKISTAN ZINDA BAAD 🇵🇰🇵🇰❤❤

  • @hussainkazmi5257
    @hussainkazmi5257 Рік тому +5

    Great man❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @KhalidKhan-wx9vg
    @KhalidKhan-wx9vg Рік тому +3

    Salute to you Haider Mehdi sir ❤️❤️❤️

  • @AbdulSamad-gf7fc
    @AbdulSamad-gf7fc Рік тому +1

    پاکستان۔زندہ۔باد
    پاک۔ارمی۔پاہندہ۔۔باد
    عمران۔خان۔زندہ۔باد

  • @manzoorillahi5514
    @manzoorillahi5514 Рік тому

    جزاک اللہ خیرا کثیرا کثیرا

  • @ambreenbukhari1471
    @ambreenbukhari1471 Рік тому +52

    The beauty of QURAN Is that you cann’t change its message but it’s message can change you 😍😍😍😘

    • @iffatshaukat
      @iffatshaukat Рік тому +1

      Very true and we need this message to follow.

    • @user-hm9wn2fx3g
      @user-hm9wn2fx3g Рік тому +3

      We Need Rule of Law in Pakistan 🇵🇰

    • @k.k5885
      @k.k5885 Рік тому +1

      No doubt about it.

    • @KhotaKahani
      @KhotaKahani Рік тому

      Beauty of Quran means nothing today. Quran can not tell what is Islam and who the hell was Mohammad &abu-bakra who sold baby Aisha to Zaani Mohamad who f’ed Aisha at 9😝.

    • @Kevin-ui5yn
      @Kevin-ui5yn Рік тому +1

      Did not change Hafiz Shaitan general and mulla diesel.

  • @farihashoaib2091
    @farihashoaib2091 Рік тому +3

    It makes me cry when Shamshad Sb said he never imagined in his life that Pakistan would come to this point. That’s how every loyal Pakistani thinks today. And blame goes to the handful of culprit generals.

    • @user-fw1ze3ow8i
      @user-fw1ze3ow8i Рік тому +1

      Sorry to say that I lost a lot of my respect for Shamshad Sahib today because he is knowingly covering up the role of Military Establishment over the years. He is very selective in terms of supporting some Military rulers and blaming others that he does not like. He is still talking in the theoretical terms "Yaka-Yak Khuda ki Terf se Sub kuch Theek ho Jaega, aur Panchwan Sher Ander se Hifazat Karey Ga". Come on, Shamshad Sahib. At this late stage of your life, you should have the honesty to stand up and accept that the 4 SHERS (lions) whom you call the FAUJ are in cahoots with that 5th Lion, and they are, as well as have always been the ones who tell the politicians what will happen with Pakistan. You are trying to say that it is the other way around. Please understand that FAUJ will never get the country out of this crisis- they are the ones who are forcing the crisis by their limited vision and due to their corrupt version of "total control". Your statements have continued to show that you support the concept of keeping the Army above the Constitution. Very sorry to hear you. I guess among the so many people who have been exposed in terms of their thinking, you are the next one. In my mind at least, you destroyed whatever respect you had achieved through all these years of your service for the country. Yes, there are a few points where you have said the right things, some even against the FAUJ size, but by and large you have been, and are still standing with and supporting the wrong people, and are unwilling to accept what is the "root cause of the problem". These politicians do not have the ability to do "anything" if they are not supported by the establishment. And your statement that "Koi Long March Shuru Karey Ga tau Mein usey Join Karun Ga". Why would you do that? to show yourself as a patriot. I expected a higher level of honesty from you and cannnot believe that you do not know what you are saying. Very Sad to hear you today.

    • @EXCELwithAB
      @EXCELwithAB Рік тому

      I found shamshad sb highly delusional.

    • @Meow09090
      @Meow09090 Рік тому

      ​@@user-fw1ze3ow8i How can he say that politicians are the root cause of the problem, and than give examples of Bhutto and Nawaz, Bhutto was the spiritual child of General Ayub and started his political career in Ayub's Lap and Nawaz was the spiritual child of Zia ul Haq; the politicians he is blaming were brought into politics by Generals of Pakistan, it is clear as day that the Generals are the problem, they are powerhungry, greedy and Firauns and would sooner burn Pakistan down than return to their constitutional parameters.

  • @riffatjabeen2532
    @riffatjabeen2532 Рік тому

    وعلیکم السلام ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ ۔ بہت اچھا تجزیہ پیش کیا

  • @rajaarif8360
    @rajaarif8360 Рік тому

    One of the Supper discuss between two original Pakistani . Pak Foujj Zinda Bad Pakistan Painda Bad

  • @naabid1983
    @naabid1983 Рік тому +4

    We need shamshad like personalities who speaks bluntly without least reservation n favour-fervour or antagonism , both side targetted on the merits , this is justice that both side be targetted on merits But Mehdi is Mehdi , he also played his role above board n praise worthy n appreciable, vlog was very interesting , this type of vlog is needed to be continued to make the public aware of the track record of our political scenario (performance of the political arena as well as of the army forces arena) worthy shamshad the foreign ministry personnel told us that track record of our political scenario n armed forces arena which was secret n top closed 🔒, He also commented on our judiciary particularly worthy justice Munir , he concluded that there is dire need of reformation n revolution like that of china n Russia , India has put it's country on the right path n track but we has been wondering hither n thither deliberately purposelessly having no thinking n consideration for the country n nation n Economy n constitution in the larger interest of public n country n nation n Economy n constitution in the land of Islamia jamhooria of Pakistan, this is our very drawback n we are inspired vested interest purely having no affinity for the country n nation n Economy n constitution, right is might is our JAN n law lawyer fraternity n jurist n law experts are earnestly requested to come forward to cool down this morning and this unprecedented scenario of the political arena n scenario of the country n nation n Economy n constitution, save the country n constitution extending their affinity n loyalty with the country n nations n constitution,

  • @tariqshah609.
    @tariqshah609. Рік тому +3

    Well said Haider Bhai ❤❤❤

  • @alleyraza9220
    @alleyraza9220 Рік тому

    Janab Haider Mahadi shaib ap ka aur janab shamshad Ahmed shaib ka bohat bohat shukria kya zabardast shamshad shaib na batay ki han haqikat m asa hi ha Khuda ap logon ko salamat rakhay Ellahi Aameen ya Rabbul Alameen

  • @AsifAliRao
    @AsifAliRao Рік тому +1

    AoA Haider GodBless you always 🌹

  • @mohammadmahmood5881
    @mohammadmahmood5881 Рік тому +5

    Bring him on your show more frequently thanks

    • @ihameed73
      @ihameed73 Рік тому

      The man has no clarity of thought.

  • @muhammadtufail8677
    @muhammadtufail8677 Рік тому +7

    Thanks a lot for inviting ex foreign secretary Shamshad Ahmad Khan, the gem of our foreign office, who wisely believe that only IK with the support of Pakistani Ppl can fix the issues presently confronted by the nation

  • @lisathegreat1000
    @lisathegreat1000 Рік тому

    شمشاد صاحب بہت صحیح غصہ کر رہے ہیں ہم نے ، ان کا زمانہ دیکھا ہوا ہے ، ہمیں بھی ایسے ہی غصہ آرہا ہے آجکل کے حالات پر ، آپ کا پروگرام بھی ایک ایسی حقیقت ہے کہ چُھپاۓ بھی نہی چھُپ سکتی ۔ تہہ دل سے آپکا شُکریہ کہ آپ نے آج شمشاد صاحب کو مدعو کیا تھا اپنے اس پروگرام میں 👍❤️👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @ikhan4938
    @ikhan4938 Рік тому

    Your patience of listening was commendable 👏🏻👏🏻
    Mr Shamshad is kind of caught into his on experiences!

  • @afridi477
    @afridi477 Рік тому +5

    Its really great to see him in your show

  • @ihameed73
    @ihameed73 Рік тому +3

    This gentleman moved paper around his entire career and then retired. Good ideas and intentions do not translate to satisfactory results unfortunately. Pakistan has a lot of these type of civil servants.

    • @UmarWazir
      @UmarWazir Рік тому

      Unfortunately true.
      Also, people like him regard the poor and the working as the problem. The poor is not nearly as heinous as our educated.

  • @basitilyas9612
    @basitilyas9612 Рік тому

    Mehdi sahb MashAllah khushi hoti ha apka balance, maturity or intelligence sy situation, issues or logon ko handle krta dekh kr. Kash sb pakistani aisy ho jyen. Khan sahb ki trhan sb haqeeqi azadi k liye kavishen krny waly mujahidon ki trhan apki trhan ye drive force Allah sb pakistanion ma dal de khas kr un me jinky hath ma pakistan k faislon ka ikhteyar ha. Aameen

  • @arshadbutt9343
    @arshadbutt9343 Рік тому +1

    Haider Mehdi we fully endorsed your views and Salute to you 🎉🎉😂😂for your golden views. Maashalah. Allah Taalah bless you. Pakistan Zindabad.❤❤

    • @aichamuhammad5904
      @aichamuhammad5904 Рік тому

      We trust you 🙏 lol because Shamshad is not an option lol 😆

  • @rahilahabib2052
    @rahilahabib2052 Рік тому +1

    Fantastic introduction of politicians By Sir Shamshad…

  • @ZS0719
    @ZS0719 Рік тому +2

    Thank you Mr Shamshad for atleast realizing that IK is the best option

  • @ilyaskhalidzein2322
    @ilyaskhalidzein2322 Рік тому

    100%درست کہا حقیقت اور سچ

  • @ImranJami
    @ImranJami Рік тому

    Heart felt Thanks to Shamshad Sb and Haider Mahdi Sb for giving us such a lovely talk show....❤

  • @catsmadera5196
    @catsmadera5196 Рік тому

    Shahjee: I admire your big heart and tolerance. You performed like a true unbiased journalist. This was another good one along with Orya Maqbool Jan's.

  • @arabianseagull
    @arabianseagull Рік тому

    Whatever my reservations are, "handsup" to our former Foreign Secretary Mr. Shamshad Ahmad Khan for his sincere honesty and courage

  • @asemmustafa7112
    @asemmustafa7112 Рік тому

    Beautiful it was a real pleasure listening to two intellectuals so true and so precise. Thank you sir shamshad and sir haider 👍👍

  • @bashirahmadqamar9672
    @bashirahmadqamar9672 Рік тому

    Thanks for Mr. Shsmshsd's eye opening talk about politiciiens.

  • @aaliazee
    @aaliazee Рік тому

    👏🏻 👏🏻 👏🏻 for Haider Mehdi Sahib

  • @sawan78
    @sawan78 Рік тому

    well done. excellent program.

  • @akib2542
    @akib2542 Рік тому

    Shamshad sir ko is quom ki khidmat ke liye salaam hai.

  • @iftikhar6093
    @iftikhar6093 Рік тому

    Very candid assessment by honourable Mr Shamshad. Masses especially the middle class is the key and the solution!

  • @sweetpets-07
    @sweetpets-07 Рік тому

    Eye opener interview. Verry informative

  • @hajiakber3129
    @hajiakber3129 6 місяців тому

    Header mehdi sb thanks good information
    Allha Pakistan ur palastin kh ghebe madad kerh ameen keamari...karachi
    Good shamshad sb thank thanks allha ap ko ajar de ameen ameen ❤

  • @shahidsadiq1091
    @shahidsadiq1091 9 місяців тому

    Ap salamat rahaen.

  • @shafqatfarooqui4119
    @shafqatfarooqui4119 Рік тому +1

    دونوں نے ہی اچھی طرح سے بڑے پوائنٹس اٹھائے ہیں اور دونوں ھی کافی حد تک درست فرما رہے ہیں۔

  • @lashari3944
    @lashari3944 Рік тому

    Harder bahi today v log is excellent he is great personalty

  • @zulfiqarahmad8757
    @zulfiqarahmad8757 Рік тому

    واہ کیا بات ہے۔ شمشاد صاحب کی سپریم کورٹ کے بارے میں الہامی پیشین گوئی جو اب تک سچ ثابت بھی ہو چکی ہے، کمال ہے۔ میں اس بزرگ اور مدبر دانشور کے تجربہ اور فہم وفراست سے بے حد متاثر ہوا ہوں۔ آج یقین ہو گیا کہ ابھی اس پاک سر زمین میں قحط الرجال نہیں ہوا۔ کچھ امید باقی ہے۔
    Haider Mehdi, thank u for inviting this seasoned gem of a statesman to Ur show. His views are reassuring and a source of morale boosting panacea.

  • @muhammadhaseeb7809
    @muhammadhaseeb7809 Рік тому

    Excellent sir Haider sb and sir shams shad sb In-sha-Allah it is No far away that the state will stand

  • @riazulhaq5068
    @riazulhaq5068 Рік тому

    Welcome sir 🙏🙏🙏💐💚🥀 jumma munarkk

  • @shahbaba8152
    @shahbaba8152 Рік тому +2

    Very good analysis both of you great Gys ✅

  • @AlamKhan-gm8zp
    @AlamKhan-gm8zp Рік тому

    حیدر مہدی صاحب زندہ باد🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

  • @irumiqbal8921
    @irumiqbal8921 Рік тому

    Excellent analysis keep it up

  • @waheedaslam1109
    @waheedaslam1109 Рік тому

    Tanks for ap deat Bai Jan ❤❤❤

  • @rehmankhalil3360
    @rehmankhalil3360 Рік тому +11

    Both of you are great,well matured and loyal to the nation.

  • @user-dt3ko8pm4m
    @user-dt3ko8pm4m 6 місяців тому

    ھم پر عمران خان کا بہت بڑا احسان ہے ۔

  • @nafeesaeed
    @nafeesaeed Рік тому

    Mehdi sahib in k sath every week aik vlog kia krain he is very gentle man n bohat hi nice talk n informative talk krtey hain.

  • @jamalkhan1798
    @jamalkhan1798 Рік тому +1

    Well said Shamshad Sahib . İt was a pleasure to hear you. Even a bicycle pedlars respected the law.

  • @waqarwaseem903
    @waqarwaseem903 Рік тому

    Nation stand with CJP Lawyer or CJP zindabad Clean Election krawo Pakistan bhajho Allah Pak Pakistan or Pakistanion or Imran Khan ki hifazat or madad or kamiyabi ata kry Aameen SumaAameen

  • @omarmalik2913
    @omarmalik2913 Рік тому +1

    Great analysis thank you Sir Mahndi for letting Sir shamshad speak his heart out.

    • @skywalker2176
      @skywalker2176 Рік тому

      One of the many best things about Haider sahab that he lets ppl speak 👌🏿