HO ASCOLTATO DAL VIVO (A ROMA) TATIANA SERJAN E DEBBO DIRE CHE HA UNA VOCE IMPRESSIONANTE,MOLTO ESPRESSIVA E ARRIVAVA NELLE ULTIME FILE DEL LOGGIONE CON UNA POTENZA INAUDITA.UNA GRANDE LADY MACHBETH.
This is a brilliant tour de force of singing... Up to the difficult ending and the high D. Hard to think of anyone who has sung it better, not even Verrett, the last great interpreter of the role. . . I wish she had a subtler, less exaggerated, more zoned-out presence or affect in how she acts the scene...
Amazing voice! Well suited for Lady Macbeth. However, has no subtleties at all, both in her singing and in her acting! Both over-sung and over-acted. But these are both easily corrected. I'd still MUCH RATHER hear HER in this roll than than most of those who try to sing it these days! Her pianissimo singing is AMAZING!!! Truly a great voice!
The voice of the singer is excellent. But her singing needs more subtle nuances. Although as a dramatic singer she is much superior to the notorious Netrebko.
Wow! I just made pretty much the same comment, 4 years later, before I saw yours. (And even the other singers I was referring to, I actually meant Netrebko! Lol!)
HO ASCOLTATO DAL VIVO (A ROMA) TATIANA SERJAN E DEBBO DIRE CHE HA UNA VOCE IMPRESSIONANTE,MOLTO ESPRESSIVA E ARRIVAVA NELLE ULTIME FILE DEL LOGGIONE CON UNA POTENZA INAUDITA.UNA GRANDE LADY MACHBETH.
She lets the music "se fait tomber de l'ame aux tenèbres", and creates extremely beautiful and expressive singing. M A G N I F I Q U E!
+infrantasi
non capisci niente dell'arte lirica,è un fatto.
Невероятный голос, невероятноя энергетика. Magnificent
i study with her in same professor, she was before conductor, student at the conductor faculty in Saint Petersburg conservatory
Brava!!!!
WOW!
I love Price, Caballe, Ludvig(even without the High D), Verrett and now Serjan doing this role.
smeisha
What do you think about Zampieri?
Of those ladies only Verrett sang the role.
Потрясающе!
This is a brilliant tour de force of singing... Up to the difficult ending and the high D. Hard to think of anyone who has sung it better, not even Verrett, the last great interpreter of the role. . . I wish she had a subtler, less exaggerated, more zoned-out presence or affect in how she acts the scene...
Nobody will ever surpass Maria Callas in this role (and all the others). But this singer has a beautiful voice. I like her.
BRAVISSIMA BELISSIMA VOCE BEL CANTO BELLA VOCE SALUTI DALLA POLONIA
una voce meravigliosa .
per il resto preferisco il silenzio .
Amazing voice! Well suited for Lady Macbeth. However, has no subtleties at all, both in her singing and in her acting! Both over-sung and over-acted. But these are both easily corrected. I'd still MUCH RATHER hear HER in this roll than than most of those who try to sing it these days!
Her pianissimo singing is AMAZING!!! Truly a great voice!
The voice of the singer is excellent. But her singing needs more subtle nuances. Although as a dramatic singer she is much superior to the notorious Netrebko.
Wow! I just made pretty much the same comment, 4 years later, before I saw yours. (And even the other singers I was referring to, I actually meant Netrebko! Lol!)
she needs to fix this unpleasant vibrato
I don't hear an unpleasant vibrato at all. Besides, is that all you can think to say after such a tour de force?
@@liedersanger1 3:09 for example
You are aware that Verdi wanted Lady Macbeth to sound like the "voce del diavolo"?
I disagree. She has a beautiful voice and no problem with vibrato.
@@liedersanger1 her Tosca is the same. She can not sustain notes and bleating like a sheep