Can Bhutan's New Megacity Help Reduce High Youth Unemployment & Brain Drain? | CNA Correspondent
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 сер 2024
- Bhutan, a kingdom hidden away in the Himalayas, told the world once Gross National Happiness counts as much as GDP. Now, it has a new vision to take the country into the future. It will redefine capitalism and yet remain loyal to its famous focus on its people’s well-being. CNA Correspondent travels to Bhutan to find out if it has indeed found that winning formula to strike that delicate balance everyone is seeking between material wealth and happiness?
00:00 Introduction
01:25 Bhutan's high youth unemployment rate and brain drain
03:48 Bhutan's grand plan to build a high-tech 'mindfulness city'
07:49 A peek into Gelephu, Bhutan's new mega-city
15:58 How do the citizens feel about Bhutan's future?
18:48 Balancing its past and future
=================
About CNA Correspondent: Highlights of news stories and features by CNA's network of Correspondents based in major cities across the region.
=================
#CNAInsider #CNACorrespondent #Bhutan #Asia #Culture
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider
As someone from India, we are very happy to be a part of this impressive project, we could learn a lot from the values of the Bhutanese culture 🇮🇳🪷🇧🇹
is the bhutan government finished with the genocide of its hindu minorities, or its still going on?
8:25 what did they do
They cut it out ..
Intentionally here
is the bhutan government finished with the genocide of hindu minorities, or its still going on?
i visited bhutan more than 5 years ago, part of its charm is the isolation and focusing on living itself. By changing direction to being economy driven will be like 180 degree shift for them. And its too ambitious to be thinking of building metropolitan city without foreign aid like China. When i was there, not even half the country has proper tar road, half of my journey was bouncing around in the car on dirt road.
I'm from Bhutan and happy to see this spreading like wild fire 🔥🔥🔥. Need support from other countries to help develop our little country and our mindful city.
India will support our brother Bhutan always. Already our PM pledged 10000Cr investment in Gelephu
Extremely wellness sounds came from Bhutan 🇧🇹 bright future come from bright n delight souls, pray from my side all goals come to success through government , Respect from Nepal 🇳🇵🌺🌺🇧🇹🙏🏻.
Bhutan is still happy and strong. ❤❤❤
I love Bhutan 🇧🇹
the bhutan government has stifled private sector for decades and now the people are fed up with the rich getting richer and the poor gettign poorer. Tens of thosuands of Bhutanese have left and many are on the way out to find a better life abroad! good luck to you all and hope your dreams come true outside of bhutan
They/he/she is one of them Anti nationals. We have them honestly. 😊 But i hope u will forgive and realistically forgive others
@@user-cr9bh4ni7x how am i an anti national you clown? you ex slave need to watch your mouth
go for it 🌞Bhutan 🌙love from sikkim ❤ you learnt a lot from us: what not to do. we need to learn a lot from you: what to do.
0ccupied Sikkim?
@@awaiskhan9329 Paki troll bot detected...immediately reported.
@@awaiskhan9329sikkim isnt occupied .it joint willingly unlike balochistan which was annexed with military😂
@@prodigalfraudaddy
Indian history taught you that or you were present at the voting?
Sikkim and Uttarakhand, Kalapani were parts of Nepal before Br!tish annexed them. See historical map of Nepal.
Were you present when those maps were drawn or you learnt this from Pakistan's history.
At some point of time, a piece of land has been occupied by one larger kingdom or other. The point is they joined India of their own voilition. Historically, Sikkim has been a part of India and will remain so.
What kinda history are they teaching at Pakstan(Terror*stan) that says Uttarakhand, a state created in 2000 was a part of another country.
Before getting to any of this, first say when are you going to accept that you annexed Balochistan and destroyed their culture?@@awaiskhan9329
Beautiful documentary! Nicely presented.
His Majesty, You are the father of inspiration to all Bhutanese and beyond. You are a result of hard work and passionate dedication to any assignment. You came and cemented a strong bond between people and still building a tower to be emulated by generations hence you are known as people's king. Personally, I love your zeal and resilience. I always get emotional when you start to deliver a speech...You are a living god for us Bhutanese....I am pretty confident Gelephu mindfulness city will be a great project...I am more excited because i am from gelephu....Love live His Majesty...love live Bhutan
Palden Drukpa Gyalo🇧🇹🇧🇹🇧🇹🇧🇹🙏💙
Whoa a Living God 😂 calm down dude LMFAO
@@downundabrotha you won't understand this bro....
Best wishes Bhutan 🇧🇹
is the bhutan government finished with the genocide of hindu minorities, or it is still going on?
One of the fascinating countries I ever visited. I went there 2 years ago and the guide also told me about his sister who used to work as a hotel manager and moved to Australia and now works there as a cleaning lady but got higher salary. From what they told me, Bhutanese people have a good relationship with Australia because when Covid hit they didn’t fly away to escape but chose to stay and work (which helped the society function).
Haha. I am in aus and almost all of the immigrants here started their career with cleaning and still doing. Even cleaning job are dignified. Y I feel like ur post smells like jealousy.
#yothiga....I didn't know there were still flights available during COVID ... even so where can they run away and fly to? Please share
@@malgudidays3311 I don’t know the details that just what local told me and I never thought about it until I watched this video.
I love the philosophy of the Bhutanese Government!
behind that facade of tranquility things are not exactly as they seem.
Meanwhile, China is taking advantage of them by stealing their territory in an attempt to get at India.
It's just marketing strategy lol
It’s a Propaganda to whitewash the ethnic cleansing of Bhutan
My hat to Bhutan for having this ambitious goal in mind. I must point out that even the some of most environmental friendly countries in the world such as Germany or Norway have not being able to make it work to the same degree. In addition, it will be very expensive. Sri Lanka had tried to be an all organic food nation and that policy really back fired on it.
Bhutan has a population of only 1 million. So they can afford to be all organic.
One of the amazing countries that I have visited. People are very generous and very kind. They are highly educated and super talented. The tourism and organic agriculture industries should be restrategized for economic growth.
Leave all debate aside,people are happy with free health,education,free agricultural assitance,cheap energy and lists goes on. Therefore,this project is for future generation
Young Bhutanese seem to be rejecting GNH en masse and embracing GDP per capita, down under 🇦🇺
That's why this megha city is being built
Bhutanese going to Australia is rejecting GNH?
Then you must be rejecting your own country by speaking English
@@user-oo8wf9gq6r GNH sounds good on paper but does not work.. I rejected my country long ago by moving to Australia.
Nice report, thank you.
Bhutan should balance nature and development as it has done till now.
"It's a start of journey."
Proud to be Bhutanese..
Nah..Bhutan govt prefers to employ foreign workers instead of own people. Recently they decide to employ thousands of foreign nurses which will be paid much higher (even comparable to Bhutanese Dr) than Bhutanese nurses but the problem here is Bhutan got sufficient nursing colleges and there are plenty of Bhutanese nurses but yet they won't employ all of them. Funny how the govt cry about brain drain but wont employ them.🤡 And fyi Bhutan ain't Last Shangri-La anymore, rape and murder cases are seen every once in a while, case of mother abandoning infants are also not rare anymore. Bhutan government should address this asap if not more ppl will be leaving this country.
~(concerned Bhutanese youth)
I wish to visit Bhutan once in my lifetime. I love its natural wonders and beautifully simple lifestyle. Lots of love from 🇵🇰
The Bhutan Megacity project will be difficult to pull off. It will become a white elephant. Plane tickets for the Royal Bhutan Airline is expensive. Accommodation is also not cheap. So only the rich can afford it. But why should they go there for their retreat? Can they get enlightenment faster?? The only thing enjoyable in Bhutan is climbing up to the Tiger Nest Temple. Thailand is already quite well established for Buddhist retreats and will definitely be cheaper.
Typical Indian mentality
Please give me more info about ir🙂
To compete effectively as a mindfulness centre, cost for tourists have to come down. And you need to work with India and/or China for better overland connections. Having to fly in among the cliffs is crazy and number of flights coming in will be restricted.
But you definitely need to restrict tourist movement from the Mindfulness Megacity. The transport infrastructure in the country cannot support mass tourism. Accidents are bound to happen on the narrow mountain cliff roads; with disastrous consequences.
I agree with your points buddy
Best wishes Bhutan ❤
Yes! Tourism and Development goes All Together.
To start with Tourism Sector needs to be Promoted.
Infrastructure needs to be created for Tourism.
Promotion of Tourism need to be done for International Attention.
Airport Infrastructure need to be Improved.
Good decomentry ❤❤
To the leaders and my fellow citizens never give up on the possibilities of greater future ahead of our new generation, as it’s all depends on how we react and think about our future. Only if we follow one plan, it will work. Please stay positive and react positively
Bhutan doesn’t need massive project, focus on infrastructure development and ease tourism your small country and population will benefit from it not propaganda of happiness alone.
Bhutan have ppp per capita even similar to south africa, still better than many asian countries while preserving its culture and environment.
No overwork, perfect work life balance, less stress
A human should think about himself too sometimes than rather thinking as whole nation to progress fast like korea where your future generation could either barely sustian or die.
They speak very food English! Hope Bhutan can develop into a country which can balance GDP and happiness. It will take years and years. The people must be trained to accept some capitalism too.
Capitalism is like drug....not needed
Wow it is so pretty over there
Bhutan is now feeling the bite of not embracing capitalism.
In today's time Every country is capatalist except for North Korea
It was ridiculous from the beginning allowing Internet but not getting higher wages, many Bhutanese watching others getting big houses cars and all for the same work they do, is easy for them to blame covid when the problem was showing way before covid hit, at least they are looking very western making excuses. Is imposible to mix spiritualism with capitalism and they know but they have no choice this time.
GNH is not anti capitalist. It's the balance of the people's wellbeing and monetary wealth
Nature ha given its own glimpse .. they are May be
Chinese/ American s ..
Giving Capitalishits Colouring
Visualising glimpse ..
Under their s .. .. .. .. ..
@@user-oo8wf9gq6r GNH is only a theory, an ideology, like socialist ideology could be, but in practice many young Bhutanese migrate to find both, 'wellbeing and monetary wealth'. Something is not working.
I want to visit Bhutan as a pilgrim but 200 USD per day is very expensive for me.
Where are you from actually??
Cause you have same name as Bhutanese woman ..
why on Earth would you want to go to a country and regime that committed genocide and ethnic cleansing of its minorities?
When Singapore 50 times smaller than Bhutan could achieve everything, why not Bhutan? I am just waiting to complete my studies to return Bhutan. Now, it’s our time, we have suffered a lot in the name of preserving nature, fighting global warming. It’s not only our responsibility, every country should act and why should we shoulder the responsibility of doing everything by ourselves?
Maybe because it's a landlocked country
Loll......Singapore is at the tip of straits of Malacca, the busiest straits in the world.....how to compare a land locked country like Bhutan? Even Kazakhstan need many times of effort just to attract foreign investment though
Yep you're right but they can find their ways to utilise their assets in an economical way, and btw Singapore had a strong minded leader Lee Kuan yew, so they need a leader who can do proper business and can tackle problems, they don't have major lifestyle problems such as Singapore had before economic rise like poverty, lack of food and resources, etc.@@chinthengfong1598
@@chinthengfong1598 , you laugh at my comment. Read your comment after 5 years and reply me again.
@@themultiverse405 I didn't laugh, I'm spitting fact, can Bhutan compete with Singapore both economically and financially? And, if you want progress, Bhutan should lift up the recognition for both PRC and ROC then we talk
Diverse economy : some scale manufacturing, arts and crafts, tourism, organic agricultural products and service sectors in spiritual and wellness….
Alot of experts in the comments.
I wish the Doc makers would give some facts like how much would a project like this will cost ? How long will it take to build it if they got 100% funding.
Giving citizenship to exiled Bhutanese may be an option. I live in US and wanted to return where I was born.
There are already plenty of established retreats in Thailand. It will not be easy for this project to succeed. I don't see anything special it has to offer.
What’s special is its belief and we believe and will succeed
Every country is special in its own way. It depends how you present it . Thailand being popular retreat hasn't Stopped Bali , Nepal , Maldives , Switzerland being parallel retreat destination
While large-scale projects like the Gelephu Mindfulness City (GMC) naturally raise questions about feasibility, it's important to recognize that doubts can hinder the transformative vision His Majesty holds for Bhutan and the region. Everyone has a role to play in the success of this special city, and we hope conscious investors will contribute their resources to its development. The GMC envisions a harmonious blend of nature, culture, and modern living, creating a sustainable haven that fosters well-being, innovation, and economic growth while preserving Bhutan's unique heritage and environment.
Bhutan should develop its tourism industry first by making it more affordable. Bhutan can be the Switzerland of Asia. ❤ from Assam.
Unfortunately for the Bhutanese, mindfulness and economy don't come hand-in-hand. Should have focus on tourism.
You are right, I am always anxious about this, hopes are fading for me in Bhutan.
You are no expert.let Bhutan strive
Who is to say they can't come to hand-to-hand? Let them do their thing. Success or not, at least they tried.
@@dreamadventure8220 They don't have to expert, anybody can give opinion
@@theMiaow Economy is about money and competitiveness, I think we can agree that mindfulness is not about that. Anyway, both you and I are keyboard warriors, we can type anything we want :)
We can not afford peace of mind if we were to focus on startups and entrepreneurship.
Bridges used to have shops and apartments, bring back the living cities.
I feel this documentary would have been more efficient and effective to cover they travelled few corners appreciate that but connecting with people was minimal. As leaving next to this country Indian and at a distance of 45 minutes of my hometown from Gelengphu …
look at the history of planned cities. There are many examples of disasters and waste. Is there even one success story?
That’s a lame excuse
this is an absolute pipe dream
wakanda forever !
It's not your concern. It is Bhutans own right to pursue or to squander this pursuit
The most beautiful of Bhutan, for me, are the children. They are pure, like a diamond. Their eyes shine and have the bright of pure beings. they are carried on the backs of their happy mothers with pride and naturally. Many young bhutanese people migrate for a simple opportuity of to live like 'west' people. The goverment, as in many (all) others countries in the world, is the same: they live in his own world of rules, tax, and socialist ideology, without working for the people
They are proud of their kings, and wallpaper the walls with their pictures. They are handsome indeed, and they believe in them.
Simple strategy. Make it a tax haven. And residency for high networth individuals. Switzerland of the east.
Oh my god!?!!?!!!!!!!!!!!!
Seems like Bhutan is trying to strike a balance between GDH ( gross domestic happiness) and GDP ( Gross domestic product).
Its Gross National Happiness not GDH
@@tyt684😂slat
How many trees are being planned to be cut to make the 21st century Shangri La? Honest question.
Bhutan is Bhutan let them Alone.
I don’t think this PM is honest , Bhutan could have easily developed with tourism but their obky source of income was stopped after Covid as they raised the tariffs on tourists and locked themselves for more than a year during Covid … on if the dumbest decisions any country could make were made … I don’t get why the citizens don’t complain too much submissiveness
Nah…. You are just thinking about it monetarily. So many things to consider.
Bhutanese sounds like Korean but also Indian... that's interesting..
I don't want to sound like a nerd but there is no language called indian.
Because they are probably educated abroad like India, Korea etc.
Our language has no relation to Indian and Korean
You are right.
@@tyt684 Any relation to the Tibetan language?
12-7-2021 Tibet’s first bullet train line enters service.
megacity project if depending on foreign investors alone will not be enticing noting transportation out of bhutan is a nightmare.
besdies tourism or agriculture industries. I cant see what kind of investment Bhutan can entice into the country let alone investment in a mega city. I fear this would open the door and push Bhutan into the hands of China.
Bhutan committed g no cide against its ethnic minority
really? 😲what ethnic minority?
@@braunarsch the hindu minority in the south. they systematically killed and drove out the hindus in the south in the 80s and 90s
You worry about yourself and we Bhutanese will worry about ourselves. If you’re not holding Bhutanese Passport that’s because you’re not Bhutanese. We love our king, country and all Bhutanese! དཔལ་ལྡན་འབྲུག་པ་རྒྱལ་ལོ
Lol we are regretting that few are still living here.
The real Edward Snowden would be disappointed to see fakes using his name to spread misinformation.
support india and make it a superpower. dis will help bhutan
I'd feel really sorry for this stunning country with its original people and culture...if the "great political powers" convince them to "Westernise".... Really sorry! Beautiful film, thanks for sharing ;)
All parts of the Himalayan region has some issues. However, among the players, the Bhutanese monarchy is the worst, surpassing even the Indians and the Chinese in their acts of cruelty.
Just another sad Nepali commenting again 😂
@@tyt684 I happen to be Tibetan, actually.
@@nepalirecaps First, try to be independent. Then only you can come and give comments about Bhutan.
Whats up with this attitude like bruhhh you don't deserve to have that attitude 😂😂 you guys are literally indian puppet state with a dictator king some people even say north korea of the south @@tyt684
@@ayoogorkhali9262 Seriously, Nepali people have such audacity? Look at your filthy TIA airport every day, how many jobless Nepali are leaving for the Middle East to be slaves of the Arabs, look at your poor infrastructure; did you see how poor horses were stuck on that bridge for a day because you could not even afford to build a good bridge? and not to forget filthy Kathmandu streets and Kidney selling villages because people are filthy poor, even your passport and currency is weaker than us.
Bangladesh should also implement this as a new heaven for the entrepreneurs
For a long time there has been so much corruption surrounding the Royal Family. I'm glad people are waking up and Leaving Bhutan. The double standards of Government/Royal Family has caused many to leave.
Tf Ur talking? Nobody's leaving permanently if u watch properly. We good with how the country's working.
I saw thousands of bhutanes refugee in USA
They are not Bhutanese. They are illegal immigrants who despite living in Bhutan, went against Bhutan.
🤡@@jigmetobdengyeltshen6372
They were illegal immigrants kicked out of country
@@tyt684 They'll return eventually
Many tried hard to show how special Bhutan was but in the end the experiment was a failure and they themselves are recognizing that rven if they can't spell the word capitalism because that would be a complete embarrassing after all those years of propaganda that ended like this, note that people started leaving Bhutan before covid because many didn't want to just live as tourist guide's specially agter watching other Bhutanese that work outside having way more money for the same work while a average Bhutanese have to work hard to get the latest Iphone
Hope Bhutan doesn't give away all the construction contracts for Gilephu to the Chinese.
Later dnt cry environment issues
Two world can't exist
Funding coming from where? Rich crypto bros hub for the Balaji nation state crowd is where this sounds like it's headding. Promisory wishfulness with no plan
So you never heard of foreign investment ??
And how do you know that Bhutan has not done any research? Did the king and prime minister sit with you to discuss the plan?
Don't act like a frigging know all. What level of education do you have? We have more qualified people than you in Bhutan. No one likes a fricken know all.
Balaji nation? You mean India? And how is your country, Myanmar doing? Look at your own sad situation before talking ill of others.
Happy country cannot keep bright people.
And that particular project is one of the many solution government is coming up with.
@@jigmetobdengyeltshen6372 it'll be completed after 50 years and probably be a ghost city
@@aa6eheia156 says the expert here lol
Unhappiness Index🤔
I think rhetorical speeches, artist impressions and vision cannot build the city. The power lies in the execution and the money (investment) behind it. From the look of it, it seems like money has not reached the ground yet with empty and abandoned buildings.
Yes, planner need to look in to this issue and work hard
mega city in Bhutan???? their whole population is under a million. Los Angeles Metropolitan area is 10 million. New York city itself alone is 10 million. tokyo last I check is over 30 million. I went to double check. 37 million in the metropolitan area.
Your city populations numbers are WRONG lol. City of Los Angeles only have over 3 million people. New York City has just over 8 million, and Chicago has 2.6 million people….those are US cities. How do I know? I’m American, can read, know how to Google US city population to gain facts lol. Fyi Tokyo only have 13 million people not “30 million” 🙄.
India 🇮🇳 should help its neighbor to succeed as it is near Indian border
Bring down cost for tourists other wise tourists are not gonna come to Bhutan. Have more road connectivity with india or china. All dont want to fly down to bhutan which is a small country ... tie up tourism packages with india ir or china
Now Bhutan time is on 🔥
Shame on Nepal government
Bahasa yang di gunakan seperti campuran bahasa Japan dan Korea. Ciri khas nada mengarahkan kesana.
completely wrong information
It's a Tibeto-Burman language. It's way different to Japanese and Korean.
It's similar to Tibetan, Burmese, Meitei and Kuki-Chin
This is the same guy who chase 100k nepalese orgin bhutnese people and now he expect his other bhutenese to come back to bhutan. I think he is afraid that if bhutan has lesser and less population then it will be engulf by india so far its already a vessal state of india, defence and foreign relationship is be looked after by india. Sadley population is less then 1 million.
Wai maka… I’m half southern Bhutanese(meaning lhotsham in our term or in simple term Nepali but we don’t claim we are from Nepal)and half eastern Bhutanese
If I come to Nepal and encourage your people to follow my rules and regulations and encourage them to not follow Nepal’s tradition and its culture and go against its own people.. will you think Nepal government will be happy and proud?? There’s a saying in our country "we can’t clap with our one hand rather we need two hands" meaning ..Don’t judge just simply because you heard from one side story?? Have you heard the story from us..
Our majesty did what’s best for the people and the country..his majesty is our lifelong hero of the nation 💕and Im proud to be Bhutanese..
@@ngawang1582 Nepali people never forced Bhutanese people to stop following their own culture and tradition. They just wanted freedom to follow their own Nepali cultures and traditions which the Bhutanese absolute monarchy hated.
@@aa6eheia156I belong to lhotsampa community of Bhutan and a proud Bhutanese and I have never heard or known the government of Bhutan stopping us from following our culture and traditions. U may talk about the 90s which I remember very well, the tensions brewed all bcos of some politically motivated individuals who wanted to topple the monarchy like in Sikkim. Its the nepali majority who voted out the Chogyal of Sikkim. Bhutan would be next Sikkim if those troublemakers were not chased out of the country. So, I would appreciate if you do your homework before you say something.
Gross national happiness
Gross National Stupidity
Thank of a marriage. You would have to give some of yourself away, and to adopt some part of the other party as your own. It goes for both parties of course. You cannot have what modern lifestyle can offer without giving away some of your ideals. Where the balance is? It would be a "suck it and see", or "trial and error" approach.
Because Bhutan has been able to shield itself from outside influence, it really doesn't have a role model to follow. In other words, it doesn't have the foundation for what is to be done. I think Bhutan does suffer from the same dilemmas many Pacific Islands are facing...the economy of scale and isolation.
It doesn't have large enough population to sustain a strong economy. Sadly, a sustainable economy would invariably have some form of industry. Bhutan doesn't have a technology based industry except tourism. That is over-dependence on a single industry as proven by the recent pandemic crisis.
Another dilemma Bhutan is facing is accessibly. While its isolation is a plus in many ways, it is also a curse and a burden on the country obviously. This is the same with the Pacific Islands. Boat transportation is almost the ONLY viable means to travel. Imagine the impacts of a serious cyclones.
Maybe America can come to the aid of Bhutan ? 😀
Haha you mean America helping Bhutan like they helped Afganistan, Yemen and Iraq?
@@nimawangchuk2078 It is meant to be ironic.
@WalkOverHotCoal Sorry bruh.Duely noted
@@nimawangchuk2078 No problem, Bro.
More than 10 thousand bhutani have settles in usa,bring those refugees back and ask them to help them invest,bhutan is clean the people likes to keep their country clean,promote toursim,bhutan can be the next switzerland and 1 thing tighten the border with india,else all those begger rackets from rajastan bihar will enter a new country to beg,else indian tourist are very wealthy
They are nepalis not bhutanese
@@Hey_puppets How can you say that they are nepali's. If they were Nepali then why they are said as Bhutanese Refugees..
@kiranthapa6392 do yout know about the biggest scam in Nepal where your ministers were involved? It was about these illegal terrorists who were being sent to USA and some of your ministers lief and sent citizen of Nepal also along with these terrorists kicked out from Bhutan 😂
First to comment! Yay
In short we want capitalism without over consumerism
Indian has been giving free money not debt to Bhutan year somewhere like 600 crore.. Bhutan is our good neighbor we have never encroach any land of Bhutan, always helped military also,always supported them..
Bhutan should not become close with China otherwise it would become next Tibet.
Please don't relate us to Tibet; there is nothing similar about Bhutan and Tibet.
@@tyt684 I think Bhutan and Pakistan are similar.. Pakistan and Bhutan are good at ethnic cleansing hindu religion
Bhutan is country with poorer and whatever kind of development is there in Bhutan is all because of free money from india.. I don't think Bhutan has anything to export to world for free trade other than saying we are carbon negative..
Indian has helped in everything to make Bhutan what it is today..
India is angel for Bhutan..
@RajRaj-lc8qw lol, do you know there are more beggars and homeless in India than entire Bhutanese population, do ypu know there are more toilets per capita in Bhutan than India? Do you 99% of construction workers in Bhutan come from India? Do you know 84% of all maids and domestic helpers in Bhutan come from India? Bhutan gives jobs to millions of indians. Yes we don't export much, but we do export worlds cheapest electricity to India, we do export raw materials as as minerals at dirt cheap price to India and Bangladesh, also do you know India's loan to Bhutan to construct hydro projects have some of the highest interest rate in the world?
When Indian governments gives out aid to Bhutan, it's not for free la, it's for safeguarding your entire Northeastern states, which if we befriend China tomorrow, your entire Northeast will be liberated by PLA, and they will happy that to be no more treated with racism by Indians.
@@tyt684 Chinese bot..i Indian never annexed sikkim, Nagaland or arunachal pradesh(northeast) Those state agreed to join in india.. India is giving free money aid so u can develop..bhutan is like small state to us...just appreciate india for caring for u people.. If there was China you would have been already part of China like Tibet..if anyone attack Bhutan we will help Bhutan.. Bhutan is like little sister to us.. Bhutan defense system is also aid by india..
@@RajRaj-lc8qw why do you think I am Chinese? just for saying china wants to take over the northeast? funny Indian Paj**t. I never mentioned about Indian annexation of Sikkim and all, you bought it yourself hahaha...... We dont have to appreciate you all because we pay for the services, nothing is free kaluuuu. Again I am telling you Bhutan and Tibet is different, no one will attack us if India quitely stay out of Bhutan, we are not your brother or sister.... just a neighbor with very different mindsets.
It's all thanks to the Bhutanese living abroad, if they'd stayed they would've hindered this proyect.
This is what happened when Bhutan copied India 🤣🤣
Indian near Tibet:
Tibet has 20 times bigger gdp per capita than my inddia 0ccupied tibet.
150,000 Bhutanese living refugee else where in the planet kicked out in 1990. Take them back you will have almost 1 Million. World has forgotten them. Some 15,000 still living in hot tropical plains of Nepal under auspicious of UNHCR. Dr. Bhumpa Rai, then Royal eye surgeon until he fled the kingdom recently died in refugee camp. He never had his wish to live in west but remained in hot plains as refugee in hope of returning his mother land Bhutan. Rest In Peace Dr. Rai. You are truly Bhutanese patriot.
Those are Neplese immigrants who tried to overthrow King by Going against the law. Bhutan have right to protect its country. Traitors will be dealt same way in any country .
Nepali migration is the biggest threat to the world. Australia, Finland, Germany all developed countries are now full of illegal nepali migrants. Bhutan King did a great job to get out illegal migrants from Nepal to save the locals.
@@dreamadventure8220 Who were the wrongdoers? Did the Bhutanese govt find the finger prints of uncle Sam?
Did you forget what Nepali populace did to Sikkim in 1975? Welcoming them will be like the ticking timebomb
@@johntwohy8337the wrongdoers were the ones in the the camp who were kicked out 😂..
Bhutanese are confused between religion and development ...they need to get that sorted out first...
They know about it that’s why everything is well balanced.
人均产值如此之低，吃不饱穿不暖用什么幸福？看不见王城角落哪些可怜人😢尽管在中国和印度之间，实际上由于喜马拉雅山脉隔断，不丹只能和印度发展贸易，但印度作为一个与所有邻国都有领土争端的国家，与其相邻可不是什么好事。曾经的锡金就是例子。
Beause bhutan work in indian policy this is reason why bhutan facing this situation.
这样，中国就可以将非法占领的领土归还给不丹。你知道印度毫不犹豫地向不丹提供了多少援助吗？
@@trendshort_ ？中国和不丹有任何领土纠纷？
Bhutan: A mythical paradise with ethnic cleansing history and making many people refugee in 1990s.
Serves you people right. Shitting on the plate you all were eating from.
You people tried to overthrow the king..just like you did in Sikkim.
Can't trust you all, and that is why you all are out of Bhutan.
If you want to blame anyone, then blame your parents and grandparents for what they tried to do to the country.
Bhutan for Bhutanese
Nepalis want Bhutanese to be minority in their own country.
Nepalis go to nepal or india .
@@pikachuthunderbolt3919 bhutan as a country will never thrive it will fade in the hand of india sooner or later cry more
@@SajanLimbu-so8gx it’s your mind set, we are moving forward with prosperity and abundance. We Bhutanese have been independent and we Bhutanese are independent and we Bhutanese will be independent forever.
Good bye! Rotten eggs!
Get well soon!!!
@@paldrupdorji7136 independent??? Really??? ... economy so good youths dont wana stay in bhutan. If india closes the border you have nothing
Don't worry too much, look at your neighbor India. There are millions of young Indians still jobless and can't find work for years - yet they are all still happy with their government.
Saying is easy but implementing isnt
Bhutan has brains?
What brain drain? Bhutan only got happiness going on for its self
Only China can help Bhutan move ahead and create more jobs.
the only happy people in Bhutan are the tourists and the King. The locals commoners....not so much.
🤪Because China talking to Kingdom of Bhutan , worry U$A and India.
China's Border Talks With Bhutan recently.
More than one Lakh nepalis were kicked out of Bhutan in 1990's and now their PM is concern about 15000 people's 😂😂😂 there is no biggest hypocrite than Bhutanese rulers
You said it yourself 100000 Nepalese lol. How can we accept someone who is not Bhutanese? I bet you that even thousand years we will never ever accept illegal immigrants and terrorist as our citizen.
I m 100% it will fail. Let's wait . 5 yrs' 10 yrs' 100 yrs' ?
Why do you think so?
Another Chinese bot
Like your father failed in life by making you? You sad excuse of a person
@@tyt684 because there is a rich history of such plans being disasters. The pattern is always the same. Somebody with too much power thinks they are playing a game of sim city, and it never makes economic sense for anyone to move in.
@@chasejones8212 such as?
Indian puppet state 😂😂
Says a Nipali 😂
Stateless immigrant 😅
Totally under indian diplomacy
World consider Bhutan as a de facto state..foreign policy of Bhutan is under our India policy.. Bhutan is protectorate of India..
Bhutan is our little sister.. Don't call Bhutan puppet even though they are Indian puppet ... Nepal is not much different..
@@RajRaj-lc8qw You can think like that if you want, but reality is different
2nd comment! Boo