Victorinox Venture or Mora Garberg?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 149

  • @marksaint2936
    @marksaint2936 Місяць тому +75

    A guy from Alabama drinking his morning coffee watching a guy from Australia talk about European knives, it’s a good world.

  • @maxlvledc
    @maxlvledc Місяць тому +20

    "It tickles me a certain way"
    - Pete 2024 (take that to the bank!)

  • @nandayane
    @nandayane Місяць тому +16

    A cedric and ada video is exactly the pick-me-up I need after a long week!

  • @johnbuck283
    @johnbuck283 Місяць тому +5

    The most underrated feature of the Venture that puts it above all other fixed blades at the moment IMHO is the curved belly that spans across the whole edge. I have long been waiting for a knife like Fällkniven H1 or PHK that would have a thinner blade. The belly and the significantly dropped point of the blade is exactly what I have been longing for and I was considering a custom knife, because such a knife was not available AFAIK. Most of the knives these days (especially scandi gound) seem to have a long flat part and then steeply curving part near the tip. I don't find that useful at all. The narrowish blade, long belly and drop point are exactly what I want from a knife that I use for skinning large game, processing small game and fish and chopping veggies.
    Benchmade makes blades with long belly, but they all have either an unnecessary broad blade that makes them clumsy or a sharp tip (extreme case: Meatcrafter). Victorinox hit the nail on the head with this one.

  • @armedoptics3523
    @armedoptics3523 Місяць тому +15

    As a longtime subscriber...you still Rock.

  • @destro6971
    @destro6971 Місяць тому +17

    I definitely need more street cred in the Bush.
    Giggity

  • @sloanNYC
    @sloanNYC Місяць тому +7

    Picked up that Garberg a couple months ago and have loved it. Really sharp out of the box, really useful for a variety of yard duties, and a nice small and thin sheath. Just ordered that extra kit with sharpener, had no idea that existed! Glad to see the Venture is so great too.

  • @Generic_Username_0331
    @Generic_Username_0331 Місяць тому +12

    The Venture Pro comes with a pen, tweezers and fire steel inside the fancier sheath.

  • @-Craptastic-
    @-Craptastic- Місяць тому +7

    I hope you feel better soon Pete.
    Take Care!

  • @andrewblakesley4202
    @andrewblakesley4202 Місяць тому +8

    Mora Robust for me. It's everything I need and cheap.

  • @adamsheppard3480
    @adamsheppard3480 Місяць тому +4

    "Streets of the bush" is just perfect

  • @billbailey1517
    @billbailey1517 Місяць тому +4

    I purchased the Venture basic after your review as my new camping knife and i am very happy with its performance got it for a bargain 115$. Great video Thank you

  • @poncho151
    @poncho151 Місяць тому +4

    That “apples to oranges” guy even explained “apples to oranges”! Next level!

  • @TheStoyanbahchevanov
    @TheStoyanbahchevanov Місяць тому +5

    In my opinion, Venture is more comparable with Cansbol. Put them together in the next video. Cheaper though. Cheers

  • @markcollier9279
    @markcollier9279 Місяць тому +8

    How can you compare these 2. One is red and one is black. Completely different. Apples and oranges

  • @alexandergutfeldt1144
    @alexandergutfeldt1144 Місяць тому +3

    I own both and don't really like either 😳!
    The Garberg just doesn't feel comfortable or well balanced, so I don't use it. That is very subjective!
    The venture (pro with kit) works great for all camp (kitchen) tasks, but I don't like to use it for heavier wood processing tasks. The toolkit is need for building stuff, but I honestly don't do enough of that to justify schlepping it around.
    I prefer bringing a short (7-9cm) blade and a little hatchet. Fits my needs better!

  • @namelesske
    @namelesske Місяць тому +1

    I love your Tool outro. And also like, finally someone found the direct competitor for the Garberg.

  • @Omniseed
    @Omniseed Місяць тому +2

    We always knew Pete loved the streetbush

  • @profesorEDC
    @profesorEDC Місяць тому +2

    Get well Pete, thanks for the effort of the video I enjoyed it.

  • @jeetts59
    @jeetts59 Місяць тому +1

    I have a F1, since you reviewed it many years ago and still find it the best bush knife I’ve ever owned.

  • @BrentonCarr
    @BrentonCarr Місяць тому +19

    You should review an actual apple vs an orange

    • @jez76
      @jez76 Місяць тому +2

      But you can’t! That would be like comparing app……..

    • @rymic72
      @rymic72 Місяць тому +1

      That could end up going as viral as his cat review. He’s just the man for doing the comparison vid as well

    • @SanderExtremeW
      @SanderExtremeW Місяць тому

      Yes, and always refer to it so that’s handled forever 😉

  • @devildogwhisper
    @devildogwhisper Місяць тому +1

    The comparison of comparing apples to oranges to comparing dissimilar knives is akin to bananas-to-plantains comparisons.

  • @marcusott5054
    @marcusott5054 Місяць тому +2

    Have you heard of UG (Utsch & Gierse) Tools knives? Especially the "TiNy" Model? It's a bout the same blade length as the Garberg and Venture,but has a 3D-printed titanium handle and weighs only 80g (~2.8 ounces). Magnacut blade too.

  • @Low-effort-individual
    @Low-effort-individual Місяць тому +1

    As the self appointed apples to oranges guy this is more a pumpkin to squash type of comparison

  • @Treckopc
    @Treckopc Місяць тому +6

    Kansbol - and you have both of them into one

    • @CSGraves
      @CSGraves Місяць тому +1

      Looks like I got here two days too late!

  • @KMV007
    @KMV007 Місяць тому +1

    I have the Garbeeeerg and always felt the handle is the other way around. The pommel has a bigger finger guard than the front.

  • @tomturbuckle0076
    @tomturbuckle0076 Місяць тому

    For those that care about knives I would not say these are competators. These two would be complimentary to each other. The Victorinox kept in a pack for camp tasks and the garberg on your hip for quick access.

  • @wretchedmess
    @wretchedmess Місяць тому +1

    Sorry you're under the weather. I've got the Garberg that I quite like, and if the Victorinox price eventually drops to something not crazy, I'll get one to check out...

  • @danielsorenson8769
    @danielsorenson8769 Місяць тому +1

    Great review and I agree with your conclusions.
    Please review apples and oranges. The masses need to see that comparison.

  • @SanderExtremeW
    @SanderExtremeW Місяць тому +2

    I thought the pro came with a firesteel and even a pen, tweezers? Also toothpick? Don’t know, i should have checked 😉 applesoranges. Love your vids 😇

  • @RobPfitzner-d9o
    @RobPfitzner-d9o Місяць тому +1

    I’m not one to comment, but just have to say after watching for some years now - Love your vids mate! Keep up the great work!
    Hope you feel better soon Lord Palpatine! 😂🍻

  • @cal1776
    @cal1776 Місяць тому +1

    Bow drill convention was this weekend? Missed it again

  • @lampshade8969
    @lampshade8969 Місяць тому +1

    Those sure are knives that will cut.
    Check the Peltonen m07 out. Don'nt have a venture yet, but I like ithe Peltonen more than my Garberg (which I like more than I thought I would)
    The Garberg is a bad allrounder though. Not the case with the peltonen which will do food prep and buchcrafting equally well imo.
    yes more knives pete

  • @Mjodvitner
    @Mjodvitner Місяць тому +1

    "do it" 😂

  • @martijndaems6503
    @martijndaems6503 Місяць тому

    Good question.
    I was wondering it myself as well
    But i own a Mora garberg

  • @crux85
    @crux85 Місяць тому

    I will watch this clip, but have paused it at the beginning and commenting (unsolicited) that the garberg is gonna woop vics behind! 😅😂😂😂

  • @cjt1982
    @cjt1982 Місяць тому +1

    like comparing apples to onions... quite similar but used in different ways

  • @bokusimondesu
    @bokusimondesu Місяць тому

    Feel better soon Pete! For Pete's sake 😬
    That was quite a comparison and Knife Grinds for Dummies.
    Doing such good work, even when ill, that's... cutting edge. 😅

  • @stevesleshfishingliving3082
    @stevesleshfishingliving3082 Місяць тому

    Garberg + Cedric & Ada = $. Love this channel. Love my garberg. Click bait never tasted so good

  • @cashdingo6386
    @cashdingo6386 Місяць тому

    I knew I recognized the Victorinox, it looks like a shrink down Cold Steel Slockmaster.

  • @eriktaylor5704
    @eriktaylor5704 Місяць тому +1

    I love apples and oranges, especially in fruit salad. Great video, keep up being the worst 😂.

  • @jaysgood10
    @jaysgood10 Місяць тому +1

    Got both. But I’m not a fan of grapefruit.

  • @swamp.stomper
    @swamp.stomper Місяць тому

    Good show! Looking fit as well!

  • @zoiders
    @zoiders Місяць тому

    I love my Victorinox collection of SAKs and Swiss Tool but the fixed blade offerings leave my cold. The first model was a somewhat over priced Muela. This new model looks for all the world as if its come from the same OEM manufacturer who makes catering and game processing knives for Spyderco. Not a bad thing perhaps but I am still going to choose the Mora.

  • @jamierichards27
    @jamierichards27 Місяць тому +7

    Yay Knives!

  • @Dcale
    @Dcale Місяць тому

    And that’s why the Sabre grind is the best

  • @blamedexter
    @blamedexter Місяць тому

    Hope you are still doing freehand sharpening. Really enjoyed those videos and hope you do more

  • @michaelfuxeklint4909
    @michaelfuxeklint4909 Місяць тому

    The Victorinox more food prep and the Mora more bush craft ??, personally i prefer Victorinox 👍👍

  • @pbrb123
    @pbrb123 Місяць тому +1

    Not meaning to go too apples & oranges on you, but I wonder about comparing the Venture to the Mora Kansbol?

  • @37hud
    @37hud 23 дні тому

    I choose the mora kansbol.

  • @davidjacobs828
    @davidjacobs828 Місяць тому

    Although we all know felix immler is THE GOD OF BUSHCRAFT and also the sak ..
    I've got to go with my garberg carbon multi mount.
    Also, if you don't feel up side down in Australia, THERE'S A BIG REASON .

  • @ras9182
    @ras9182 Місяць тому +1

    Calgary here

  • @miketranfaglia3986
    @miketranfaglia3986 Місяць тому +25

    They're both wildly overpriced, if you ask me (and I know you didn't!) I've been particularly disappointed in the edge-holding ability of the Victorinox knives. I love the lower priced Mora knives, but can't see why the full tang costs so much more.

    • @DinoNucci
      @DinoNucci Місяць тому +6

      Correct

    • @sabelfechter7136
      @sabelfechter7136 Місяць тому +2

      Butter steel.

    • @Dan12345
      @Dan12345 Місяць тому +2

      This specific Victorinox is in 14C28N, as opposed to the usual 4116, but I do agree there are cheaper options. I’d be a lot more upset if the Venture was 4116, because I think for the cost of a SAK 4116 is fine.

    • @miketranfaglia3986
      @miketranfaglia3986 Місяць тому +1

      @@Dan12345 Sure, it's an upgrade over the (very) basic 4116, but certainly no super steel at that hefty price point. I guess both of these are produced in high-cost countries, so you're not necessarily expecting to get any bargains out of Switzerland, but that's one thing that's always been such a pleasant surprise about the basic Mora knives. They're cheap, even though they come from Sweden, and they're quite good. Even the Chinese can't make a Mora-style, similar quality knife for less. I guess I should reserve judgement until I've tried these knives myself, but I just doubt I'll ever pay those prices for either.

    • @Dan12345
      @Dan12345 Місяць тому +2

      @@miketranfaglia3986 true it’s no super steel. Can you find a better steel in a knife that size for the same price, outside of China? I haven’t been able to. Personally I’m happy with 14C28N and 4116 (in Swiss Army knives). I think if you want edge retention you might be looking at the wrong company. Try Spyderco or Benchmade or even the Buck Pro or Heritage series.
      I’ve got my Spyderco Enuff 2 in K390, which I’ve used for batoning when backpacking and holds an edge well.

  • @Surago
    @Surago Місяць тому +2

    10:00 to be fair Pete, we're here watching a video comparing knives, we are already dorks. I'm a fedora and a poor man's katana away from relegating myself to whatever the Florida version of my mom's basement.

  • @eriktaylor5704
    @eriktaylor5704 Місяць тому

    Which ever circles exist where that giant sheath does not look ridiculous are circles that should be avoided.

  • @starkparker16
    @starkparker16 Місяць тому +1

    I don't understand the apples to oranges saying. Any dingus can compare apples to oranges. Like taking candy from a baby, it's super easy.

  • @Navapex
    @Navapex Місяць тому +1

    If you want to split wood, the garberg is ok. Personally if I could part with my $180+ I would go for Victorinox, which is more versatile but it is overpriced am afraid.

    • @superdave6415
      @superdave6415 Місяць тому +1

      Where is the garberg that expensive Canadian and Australian dollar is about the same and the garberg is $106 here

    • @Navapex
      @Navapex Місяць тому +1

      @@superdave6415 Garberg ~$AU150 and Venture ~$AU180 here in Australia

    • @superdave6415
      @superdave6415 Місяць тому

      @@Navapex wow what a rip off

    • @Navapex
      @Navapex Місяць тому +1

      @@superdave6415 Here in Australia we are getting ripped of in every way especially nowdays.😞
      Thats why I make my own knives using car leaf springs.

    • @Vedraan
      @Vedraan Місяць тому +1

      90-100e here in EU. where they are produced, doesn't make sense.

  • @DrRWH
    @DrRWH Місяць тому

    I think it’s more like lemons and limes. What are you doing man? No one in the history of the world would do that. Really important.

  • @lyndonmarquis414
    @lyndonmarquis414 Місяць тому

    It’s like comparing apples to pears!

  • @jayr526
    @jayr526 Місяць тому +1

    Why does no one ever say you can't compare tangerines to pomegranates?. inquiring minds want to know

  • @plibani4248
    @plibani4248 Місяць тому +3

    I only see one thing really wrong with the Venture : Why is it full tang?
    Full tang = strong knife. However a full flat grind that makes the edge very thin = week knife.
    So if you buy the Venture, you'll be paying for a full tang knife, that IS NOT a full tang knife in practical use.

  • @Tbarrr91
    @Tbarrr91 Місяць тому

    What are chest levers?

    • @antchung2370
      @antchung2370 Місяць тому

      Reverse cutting technique..

    • @MrKumbancha
      @MrKumbancha Місяць тому

      its a cutting technique, surprisingly strong cuts and you dont get tired
      you place the thing you want to cut and the knife on your chest edge away, and cut not with your hands, but pulling your elbows back.
      Search on youtube, its kind of hard to explain.

  • @fancyhitchpin8675
    @fancyhitchpin8675 Місяць тому +3

    Yo Pete, you may want to throttle back a little on the pseudoephedrine my man.

  • @Circa1664
    @Circa1664 Місяць тому

    You can Garbergs in the states for $70-$80

  • @just9911
    @just9911 Місяць тому +1

    COMPARE ALL THE FRUITS!!!!

  • @brandensutton2324
    @brandensutton2324 Місяць тому

    🤙

  • @josephanthony1277
    @josephanthony1277 Місяць тому

    Tifas to Aeriths, bro

  • @heididragonfly
    @heididragonfly Місяць тому

    🔥🐈‍⬛🔥
    Because OfMy Hard Red Nasty Australian Wood 🎵🎶🎵

  • @scipio7837
    @scipio7837 Місяць тому

    It's like comparing Robertson to Phillips. Robertson is waaay better. Can handle far more torque.

  • @Steve_G88
    @Steve_G88 Місяць тому

    do it

  • @carlstanland5333
    @carlstanland5333 Місяць тому

    Do it.

  • @JustineWiniker
    @JustineWiniker Місяць тому

    Everyone is sick right now. Covid is going around here, in America.

  • @thefishinglor6931
    @thefishinglor6931 Місяць тому

    venture forme too lol

  • @michaelstjohn6086
    @michaelstjohn6086 Місяць тому +1

    Chest leaver or trying to fly away?

  • @fede1233
    @fede1233 Місяць тому +2

    Tengo ambos y sin duda elijo el Victorinox Venture. Mucho más versátil que el Mora Garberg

  • @ZarlanTheGreen
    @ZarlanTheGreen Місяць тому +2

    There is no such thing, as a Scandi with a microbevel. A Scandi grind only has one single bevel, by definition. If it has a secondary bevel, then it isn't a Scandi grind. It's a sabre grind.

  • @airiksknifereviews9548
    @airiksknifereviews9548 Місяць тому +1

    The Garberg has actually went down in price. It's about $69 To $80 on Amazon in the US. I prefer the Carbon and avoid the leather sheath , it doesn't hold up.
    Sorry my Aussie knife buds 🫤

  • @MikeyNewman1974
    @MikeyNewman1974 Місяць тому

    Decently designed knives, ridiculous prices for at best, basic steels...........

  • @LoreTunderin
    @LoreTunderin Місяць тому +10

    Even if it is apples to oranges... Why can't you compare fruits of similar shape and size? 😂 It's not like you're comparing apples to atomic weapons or anything.

    • @chriskp
      @chriskp Місяць тому +2

      He spent 15 minutes comparing them

    • @harpothekidrs3282
      @harpothekidrs3282 Місяць тому +2

      You're truly today's Aristotle

  • @DrNukeP
    @DrNukeP Місяць тому

    🍎 🤼‍♂️🍊

  • @joex
    @joex Місяць тому +1

    Garberg1000%

  • @michaelschweimler7292
    @michaelschweimler7292 Місяць тому +1

    None If both, instead a mora companion or heavy duty companion.
    Or two/ three of them for the price one Venture or Garberg is...
    The Venture is imho a better kitchen knife, i sold mine after a short time and the Garberg does not fit my hand.

  • @UnCoolDad
    @UnCoolDad Місяць тому

    Both overpriced. I'm unsure how they justify the price difference between the Mora Companion and the Garberg

  • @frankrice1253
    @frankrice1253 Місяць тому

    Who are you, & what have you done with Pete ? Lets see that toe. 🦶

  • @eyeofthetiger4184
    @eyeofthetiger4184 Місяць тому

    G'day Pete, its more like comparing granny smith to red delicious or washington navel to valencia ; )
    Anyway, neither, Terava Puukko 140 and a BK-18 Cant remember the exact prices but I think in the ball park in AUD. Cheers Duke.

  • @greekveteran2715
    @greekveteran2715 Місяць тому +2

    Different knives for different uses. I'd take the Victorinox for camping and the Garberg as a "survival" knife. If one is after a Bushcraft knife, the Bushcraft Black is way better than both of these. If he's after general use/utility/food prep/camping hiking etc, then the Victorinox is the way to go.

    • @General_ONeill
      @General_ONeill Місяць тому +2

      Not different uses necessarily bud. You probably just need to learn and use a scandi and flat grind for all tasks.

    • @HughMessenger
      @HughMessenger Місяць тому

      You mean ... comparing oranges to bushcraft knives.

  • @ogarzabello
    @ogarzabello Місяць тому +1

    The Venture is a GREAT kitchen knife 🤣
    Sorry Felix! 😁

  • @randomescu
    @randomescu Місяць тому

    For me its very hard to keep that angle at Mora for a such large surface. Victorinox lose sharpness pretty fast but they are incredible easy to resharpen. Id choose Victorinox knife and Victorinox ceramic and diamond files!
    Sadly for both, after i bought a 4MaxScout i never needed to buy another knife.

  • @Youtube-Censorship-Police
    @Youtube-Censorship-Police Місяць тому

    both are a scam for what you pay, the venture even has the unlabeled steel they use for their $20 vics, the mora at least has 14c28n, which is a quality budget steel.

    • @MrKumbancha
      @MrKumbancha Місяць тому

      They literally use the same steel.
      edit: there is a carbon steel garberg that uses a different one,but the stainless is the same as the venture

    • @Youtube-Censorship-Police
      @Youtube-Censorship-Police Місяць тому

      @@MrKumbancha where did you find the infos? i couldn't find one single website (including the official victorinox one) that labeled the steel.

    • @MrKumbancha
      @MrKumbancha Місяць тому +1

      @@UA-cam-Censorship-Police survival supplies australia has it labeled as that at least
      swiss knife shop too

    • @Youtube-Censorship-Police
      @Youtube-Censorship-Police Місяць тому +1

      @@MrKumbancha okay, thanks for the clarification.
      usually they use 440c for their more expensive knives and since victorinox doesn't label the steel on their own website, i was a bit hesitant to believe that it's anything else than inox.
      anyway, if it's 14c28n it is good news, i hope they start to use it on a regular basis and in their folders too.
      cheers

    • @MrKumbancha
      @MrKumbancha Місяць тому +1

      @@UA-cam-Censorship-Police yeah, hope so too

  • @muskett4108
    @muskett4108 Місяць тому +1

    I'd have a Terava 120 for the bush, and just get a Victorinox Kitchen/Chef's knife for the camp kitchen. And with the change buy a beer. My choice for a survival knife is the Skrama.
    The Venture is over priced. Moras do nothing for me.

  • @adadadad8251
    @adadadad8251 Місяць тому

    sweden > switzerland

  • @John..18
    @John..18 Місяць тому

    This is like comparing apples to oranges,,
    I don't know how to tell the difference between a orange and a apple, so this video is very helpful, thank you very much,,!!

  • @ronp4529
    @ronp4529 Місяць тому

    I picked up a Garberg from Amazon recently for $55. I'm not sure it's even worth that much. I like it though.
    Btw I did in fact bend it permanently, albeit only slightly, batoning a twisted piece of hardwood.

    • @Dhari1
      @Dhari1 Місяць тому

      May I assume (please, correct me) your Garberg is in the stainless version?

    • @richardhenry1969
      @richardhenry1969 Місяць тому

      I'm very curious what we're you batoning? An how big was it?

    • @TheDavewatts
      @TheDavewatts Місяць тому +2

      I've never had a problem with either Mora Garbergs, stainless or carbon, I'm not calling you a liar by the way just shocked at yours bending, must have been a slab of hard wood to do that.
      Anything bigger than wrist thick I use an axe, right tool right job.👍🏻

    • @ronp4529
      @ronp4529 Місяць тому +1

      @@Dhari1 - yes it's stainless

    • @ronp4529
      @ronp4529 Місяць тому

      @@richardhenry1969 - I think it was cherry, and probably 3.5 inches across.

  • @cocovasquez1
    @cocovasquez1 Місяць тому +3

    That’s easy.. Mora Garberg all day and twice on Sunday. Joe X easily destroyed the Victorionox. Voctorionox is just a kitchen steak knife

    • @Uploaderization
      @Uploaderization Місяць тому +4

      Joe X is entertainment, not knifetesting.

    • @cocovasquez1
      @cocovasquez1 Місяць тому +1

      @@Uploaderization Nah probably for you but not for me. I rather a knife that’s been tested hard and the Garberg lasted way longer than that piece of junk

    • @Uploaderization
      @Uploaderization Місяць тому

      @@cocovasquez1 It's not testing, it's entertainment. I suppose if somebody test a car by driving it into a wall and the car breaks, then you consider that a bad car?

    • @2Snakes
      @2Snakes 3 дні тому

      @@cocovasquez1 Mora Robust survived better than the Garberg did with Joe X, and its not full tang, and its a lot cheaper, and it has a proper finger guard.

  • @MusicalWeasel
    @MusicalWeasel Місяць тому

    As of the writing of this comment, the usd is equal to 1.47 aud.

  • @2Snakes
    @2Snakes Місяць тому

    Neither.

  • @DinoNucci
    @DinoNucci Місяць тому +1

    Venture didnt need to exist.

  • @allfather885
    @allfather885 Місяць тому

    Over $100 for 14C28N seems like robbery. Especially for plastic scales / handles. If it was titanium scales or a better steel I could see the price, but for 14C28N? No way.

  • @kingfathand
    @kingfathand Місяць тому

    Duh?
    Garberg is proven. Victorinox is a knife for non knife people.

  • @dennisleighton2812
    @dennisleighton2812 Місяць тому +2

    10:44 I just can't help thinking what the point is of having a Scandi grind if you put a micro (secondary) bevel on it? Surely that changes the very nature of the Scandi grind which is always described as having a zero edge. I don't get it. It then becomes a sort of abominated sabre grind? It smacks of Mora becoming disenchanted by the constant flow of complaints about Scandi blades being very difficult to sharpen properly in the field, and offering a simple "fix". But, have they betrayed the fundamental value of Scandi grinds?
    11:55 Slicing demo - that was one of the best demos I've ever seen and puts the whole slicing thing into perspective! Most people don't actually understand this, and the demo will help them to do this. Great stuff mate!
    Agree totally with your conclusion.