I consider these to be mostly brown in color. But in fact the Briar Oil Slick gives that subtle hint of red which only adds to their versatility! If these aren’t the perfect boot, they’re near the top of the list!
I am one of them discovered 3340 Through your video and got a pair off eBay in good condition, good price. Over 40 people watching and couldn't waste a second to purchase it. So happy that I got one of rare models from RW. Thank you so much CJ.
I finally hands on 3340 as you recommended in the video. I have to say...3340 is the dopest..super doper comfortable boots I've ever owned. I do own several redwing boots 8111,8086,8084,Beckman black, Nicks boots, Whites boots...Wolverine 1000 miles,,,but this is super simple everyday boots ever! I had to watch your video so many time to buy 3340..but It's really worth of money..Thanks CJ for recommendation!!!
It's the discontinued 952 with a different sole. I'm on my 4th pair of 952's over the past 20 years. When I found out it was discontinued, I went on ebay and found 3 pairs for future use. The 952 listed for $149. Change the sole, switch a few threads to white, add a leather strip to the back and double the price.
I agree, I have the same boots. I’ve worn mine for 10 months daily on concrete floors and they hold up great. I do prefer a little black polish on the toe, it really elevates the overall look in my opinion.
I've been wearing Black Doc Martin's since the age of 22 (I'm 49 now - holy shit, where did the time go) and I just bought my first pair of Red Wings a few hours ago. The 3340's in Briar and I surfed on to your review. Love the music and can't wait to break these in.
Have to say I really enjoy the deep cuts you review. Happy to see some variety of reviews that move beyond the iron rangers and moctoes. Particularly happy about the pairing section of the video. Nice to see how the potential boots match up with different pairs of pants.
I was worried at first when it came to matching it with different pants and shirts. Surprisingly they do well with a lot of different chinos and denim. I will say, although less formal looking, the 3343 is a bit more versatile. The reddish hues that come out of the 3340’s can make them look a little out of place with some shirts and pants. The 3343’s can match with just about any color.
Gotta agree with you,Blacksmiths by far the most comfiest and easiest to breakin.I got the 3342 in Bourbon Yuma about 2 years back.That colorway and leatherisnt that common these days and the leather has developed into a mix between the briar oil slick and the Copper rough& tough.Hope you can do an episode featuring the RW Girard boot which i think is an Asia exclusive style.More power to the channel.
Hi CJ! I had picked up mine , long dreamt about 3340 today from TriBeCa store. I am in New York right now. Bryan, from store, proper gentlemen, had waited for me to collect it despite store being closed due to corona virus outbreak.Stay safe everyone and be a boot!;)
I can't say that they are the best red wings but they're awesome pretty comfortable, stilish, just a great pair of boots, definitely they worth every penny!!!
My compass points north for my 3343s like yours does for your 3340s. I do dig your boots but the CRT is my favorite. To each his own, right? You're CJ Cooke. I'm CM Goode. We all gotta be us😂🤪
Those are some damn fine boots! I love the work Chukka #595. They look great and it's as close to a sneaker feel to an all leather wook boot. Soft leather lining is awesome. I wore them for work in a warehouse and shipping yard. They feel awesome on your feet even after 12 hours. I'll be getting some of these blacksmiths soon as well as a pair of black Iron Rangers to round out my boot collection.
I recently purchased a pair of Ice Cutter 2930 off eBay. Super comfortable with a nice wool lining for some extra warmth. Perfect for winter wear in NYC.
I have these and the rough neck, I wish the iron rangers were in briar oil slick. It's the colour. I have some cigar beckmans that had oil spilt on the toe and left black lines on the toe. So I dyed them. They are the darkest brown I have seen. And everyone asks were I purchased them! But wish I could get iron rangers in this colour, they would look wicked!
I received my Blacksmith on a Thursday. The following day, Friday, I wore it for 11 hours straight with no problem at all. This is the most comfortable RW I have, out of the box, among my 6 RW boots.
This is a true story; The names have not been changed! My father found a pair of authentic Red Wing chukka boots in a second hand store in Hollywood. They lived in my father's improvised "mud room" long after he passed. With regret they got tossed out when we finally moved from there. When I go my boots are going with me because I just couldn't pass on without them.
Came across this video last week, bought this exact pair 4 days ago, paid $30 extra for overnight shipping and am so glad that I did all of that. Before now, best thing I owned were Chippewa (still good)...but Redwing is in a different class
I personally love the Iron Ranger look more than any other boot, regardless of brand. These boots you reviewed are definitely nice. Probably my 2nd favorite.
I’m with you on that . The Iron Rangers are my favorite also but the Blacksmiths are sweet . I also love the 8 in Moc toes . The 10877 from the work line which are made in America and the 877 from the heritage line are also great boots. Really I will take any of the Heritage line.
Just ordered a pair, can't wait to get them. They seem to be harder and harder to find these days. I'm glad I was able to find a pair my size. They look amazing!
I put mink oil on mine and they turned a deep rich red color, also don't show the scuffs, some people like the scuffs call it "patina" but I did the same with my rough and tough, they went deep black like harness, call me a rebel but scuffed up shoes don't appeal to me.
I just found out last night that Red Wing made these boots for Brooks Brothers as the 4522. They have the nitrile cork sole and leather lining in the vamp. No speedhooks, all eyelets. The combination of all of those things make me think they would be your grail boot! Although the eyelets are dark brown, not this antique brass look. Black instead of brown piping up top as well. Annnnd, I see a pair on eBay in size 9D. But they're going for $415 with the Make Offer feature available. My size as well, but I don't think I'm willing to pay that for them.
I finally got a pair of 3340s! I'd been looking for ANY pair of Red Wings in Briar Oil Slick for a while as I have no Briar Red Wings in my collection. Last week I decided to check Sierra Trading Post to see which (if any) Red Wings they had in stock. I was excited to see that they had ONE pair of 3340s left. BINGO! My size! (what are the chances?). Just found them on my door step! Thanks for the inspiration CJ!
Great choice! I have the 3340s and have always treated them with the RW boot oil and it has darkened them to an oxblood color. I love the patina on em!
Debated so hard between these and the iron ranger last year. I’m now saving up for the iron ranger to switching and comparing. Red Wing make beautiful and durable boots. Thanks for the review
CJ Cook, I got the charcoal rough n rough just to be different:). I’m still breaking in the copper rough n tough moc toe. I love RW heritage boots. Thanks for the reviews once again
I have the Blacksmith 3341s as well. I LOVE them! I even skateboard in them. I will do a review of the Blacksmith 3341s soon. The 1907s are a classic - - two very good choices!
Red Wing boots look really nice, but I think the sole often looks boring and a little too low. I prefer the sole edges on the Wolverine 1000 Mile for example, with the leather sole look. These would've looked even better with sole edges closer to 1000 Mile than just plain cork in my opinion.
CJ, thanks for these videos. I am planning to buy my first pair of Red Wing boots on Saturday and am having a hard time deciding between the 3340 and 9011 (Beckman). I want a boot that can handle mud/snow/rain well, but can also dress up well for nicer restaurants and venues. Can the 9011 handle all of that weather, or is it going to be too much fuss? On the flip side, I wonder how well the 3340 will "dress up" after it's been scuffed and worn in. Thanks in advance for any advice you can offer.
IR cost 25% more on average. So there is something on the quality of these last boots that makes the difference. Look at the heel, no 3 line stitches... that is build quality...
I Like my 9215 chuka foreman better, because of the toeway , blacksmith toe is wide IMO, but the leather is superb, they look good on you, good boot , I love the review.
These are hands down my favorite boot I own. I have three pairs of Iron Rangers in Hawthorne, oxeblood, and Amber harness, one Beckmann bought factory seconds in black feather stone, one cooper in Amber, and these in briar oil slick. The contrast between the dark reddish leather, the raw edges, and the brass eyelets are gorgeous plus they patina sooo damn well. After two years they still look new since I baby them but have even considered buying a second pair with fears that they may discontinue at one point or another even thought it’s unlikely
Nice video and beautiful boot!! I own an IR rough & tough and a Blacksmith in rough out Hawthorne. I find the Blacksmith more comfortable the more I wear them. Tried Beckman's, but they just don't work for me as they cut into my tendon too much. I definitely want to get another smooth leather Blacksmith though. And you gave me a nice recommendation. Thanks!
HI CJ, I am pulling the trigger on a pair of the blacksmiths in black spitfire and was just wondering if the sizing on these is the same as the iron rangers. I tried a pair of Iron Rangers on at a local Red Wing store but they didn't have the Blacksmiths in stock. Thanks!
Thanks Just found the channel Enjoying the approach Do you own Iron Rangers? I own two pair. I use leather, or composite / felt or wool inserts ... depends Many make the error of shoving in cheap, counter-top inserts... Maybe some Gene Ammons? Jug.
I've got the IR's , blacksmiths (roughout in black). Rovers , 875's , Beckman chukka's, Pecos, and engineer's , forgot the number . By far the easiest to break in and look at are the Blacksmiths.
CJ, a bit of assistance, if you don’t mind. I had my heart set on a pair of Beckman 9011 in the black cherry Featherstone until watching this review. I’m looking for a “dressier” pair of boots to wear this winter. I would appreciate your advice.
Hey! If you are looking to go dressier the Beckman is the way to go. The Black Cherry Featherstone leather is absolutely lovely. Although, the break-in period on the Beckmans will take longer than the Blacksmiths. Also, the Beckmans are being discontinued...which is so sad. You may want to snag them whilst you can! If you live somewhere with heavy snow and ice the Beckmans are not the greatest but you will look GREAT!
Where'd you buy the 2 dark pairs of denim jeans you wore around the 5-6 min mark? Looks good. Perhaps a video on denim to complement the boots would be good for future! Thanks man
I had a pair of supersoles for about 7-8 months. They literally fell apart, chunks of the sole were just falling off, stitching coming undone. Was told since I didn't still have my original receipt that they wouldn't honor the warranty.
CJ, I bought the 3340 and wore them for six mos. Took them to Redwing Store and had the Postman 9196 sole put on. Now I have a Briar Oil 3340 Rover. Extremely comfortable.
Does the Blacksmith 3340 run true to size? If person usually buys a 10.5, should they order a size 10. Obviously it's best to try on a boot first...but if one is ordering online it's more of a challenge. Just wondering...Thanks!
Hello David, The Blacksmith is made on the same last as the Iron Ranger which run big. If you usually buy a 10.5 in sneakers or a Cole Haan boot for example a 9.5 Blacksmith would be ideal.
that? This boots looks like an iron range, but is slightly different from an iron range? What number will be the style number? I also liked this boots very much. I definitely want to get it.
I decided to subscribe and heed your advice, and deciding on which boot to get. I live in Miami. I decided to get the blacksmith in this video (this boot and color seem so versatile), then I get the Beckman, and the Iron Ranger. Any thoughts or recommendations
Hi! I took a trip to Miami last April. My first time down there and I brought the 3340s. The only boot/shoe I packed. They worked perfectly for the day and transitioning to the night. The Blacksmith is a great choice!
Just ordered a pair of these in charcoal to compliment my Iron Rangers. My one and only complaint with the IR is that I would have liked some sort of impact absorption and the leather insole is a little hard. Im an 11 in most shoes but a 9.5 wide in my IR. Is sizing for these just as crazy and what size did you order different from your usual size to be able to fit an insole?
I have the 3341s as well. They were the first pair of Blacksmiths I purchased. You will love them! The Iron Ranger and the Blacksmith are both made on the 8 last which means the sizing will be the same. I do not use a full insole insert for comfort. I use a Dr. Scholl's half insole insert so my toes have room. So, I did not size up...there is enough room. If you find any discomfort you could wear a thinner sock which I have done as well.
@@CJCook ok that's good to know. My IRs are a wide but I ordered these in D in 2 sizes and will keep the one that fits. As for the half sole, that's exactly what I was thinking. Thanks man.
@@CJCook if you had only 1 other leather of this boot to choose what would it be, and why? on a scale of 1-10 where would you place that leather in comparison to this leather.
I’m not loving Red Wing’s current selection. The slate muleskinner Iron Ranger look cool, but the rest are a little too safe. I wish they had more cool Blacksmiths like this!
Hi CJ, I intent to order the 3340 but not sure about the saiz of this RW. My feet are 10 ½ inch long on manual measurement with medium width. Does RW has a guide measurement on sizes?
3345s...Congrats! I think the Black Prairie Leather is beautiful. I have not tried them on but I have been eyeing the 3345s each time I go to Red Wing. The leather is going to take of some lovely characteristics as it ages. The 9075s next year will be made with the Black Prairie Leather.
@@_glenn_ Thank you Glenn. The Black Harness leather is a true black leather. The Black Chrome leather has a grey base. The Black Prairie leather has a brown base similar to the Black Klondike leather. So as you wear the Black Prairie brown will start to reveal.
Great video good sir!... I am torn as to whether I should get some of these or some 8196's... As someone who has both, which ones do you like better? (Not considering the fact that the 8196's are discontinued)
Well, if you can find the 8196 buy the 8196 because they are difficult to come by (unless you live in Europe or Asia). NOW, with that being stated the 3340s are extremely versatile. From a style perspective, they transition from day to night with complete ease.
HAHA!... thanks for the insight... yeah it looks like I could either get some on ebay or the same place you got them (8196's) for roughly the same price.... I don't know though... I am still torn...I have 7 pairs of Red Wings already, do I really need any of these?...hmmm... I am loving your videos by the way... they give me a new outlook on our favorite boot brand!
Thanks!... I will probably get the 3340's before the year is over... let's be honest!... hahaha!...so far I have a pair of 1907's (With roughneck Vibram sole), 1 pair of 875's...1 pair of 8111's with beckman Roccia soles, 1 pair of 8114's, 1 pair of Rover 2950's (Copper rough and tough), 1 pair of 4552's (Brooks Brothers Iron Rangers with the Roughneck style Vibram lug soles), 1 pair of 9014's in the mail, and now these 8196's will be in the mail soon!... I will drop hints to my GF about the 3340's and maybe I can score them for Christmas.. I think I might have a problem...
I consider these to be mostly brown in color. But in fact the Briar Oil Slick gives that subtle hint of red which only adds to their versatility! If these aren’t the perfect boot, they’re near the top of the list!
Indeed!
I am one of them discovered 3340 Through your video and got a pair off eBay in good condition, good price. Over 40 people watching and couldn't waste a second to purchase it. So happy that I got one of rare models from RW. Thank you so much CJ.
You are welcome Wayne!
I finally hands on 3340 as you recommended in the video.
I have to say...3340 is the dopest..super doper comfortable boots I've ever owned. I do own several redwing boots 8111,8086,8084,Beckman black, Nicks boots, Whites boots...Wolverine 1000 miles,,,but this is super simple everyday boots ever! I had to watch your video so many time to buy 3340..but It's really worth of money..Thanks CJ for recommendation!!!
Mr. Moon!! You are so welcome!
By the way...you have a really nice collection going.
It's the discontinued 952 with a different sole. I'm on my 4th pair of 952's over the past 20 years. When I found out it was discontinued, I went on ebay and found 3 pairs for future use. The 952 listed for $149. Change the sole, switch a few threads to white, add a leather strip to the back and double the price.
These were my first pair of Red Wings. Bought them on a Black Friday sale in 2015, been loving them ever since!
I agree, I have the same boots. I’ve worn mine for 10 months daily on concrete floors and they hold up great. I do prefer a little black polish on the toe, it really elevates the overall look in my opinion.
And yes, my son and I share an account 🤣.
YES! Thank you! Ooo, black polish interesting...I may try that.
I kind of agree. The blacksmiths paired with some jeans like Iron Hearts or Pure Blue Japan jeans and your all set.
I've been wearing Black Doc Martin's since the age of 22 (I'm 49 now - holy shit, where did the time go) and I just bought my first pair of Red Wings a few hours ago. The 3340's in Briar and I surfed on to your review. Love the music and can't wait to break these in.
Congrats Ron! The 3340's are the perfect firsts!
If you're ever looking for work boots you have to check out their supersole 2.0 line. They are the most comfortable boot you will ever wear 👍
Have to say I really enjoy the deep cuts you review. Happy to see some variety of reviews that move beyond the iron rangers and moctoes. Particularly happy about the pairing section of the video. Nice to see how the potential boots match up with different pairs of pants.
Thank you for the compliment...many more reviews to come!
I was worried at first when it came to matching it with different pants and shirts. Surprisingly they do well with a lot of different chinos and denim. I will say, although less formal looking, the 3343 is a bit more versatile. The reddish hues that come out of the 3340’s can make them look a little out of place with some shirts and pants. The 3343’s can match with just about any color.
I love the Copper blacksmiths. The natural look of the leather is the best IMO. Looks particularly beautiful in the sun.
It is a beautiful Leather
I love my copper rough tough blacksmith, it likes blackhole, suck me in ....
Gotta agree with you,Blacksmiths by far the most comfiest and easiest to breakin.I got the 3342 in Bourbon Yuma about 2 years back.That colorway and leatherisnt that common these days and the leather has developed into a mix between the briar oil slick and the Copper rough& tough.Hope you can do an episode featuring the RW Girard boot which i think is an Asia exclusive style.More power to the channel.
Thank you Gabriel! I know the 3342s...They do age beautifully 👍🏽
Hi CJ! I had picked up mine , long dreamt about 3340 today from TriBeCa store. I am in New York right now. Bryan, from store, proper gentlemen, had waited for me to collect it despite store being closed due to corona virus outbreak.Stay safe everyone and be a boot!;)
Glad Bryan was able to help you. The 3340s are top!
Be A BOOT!
I can't say that they are the best red wings but they're awesome pretty comfortable, stilish, just a great pair of boots, definitely they worth every penny!!!
My compass points north for my 3343s like yours does for your 3340s. I do dig your boots but the CRT is my favorite. To each his own, right? You're CJ Cooke. I'm CM Goode. We all gotta be us😂🤪
@@TheGoodeLife1975 Yes ! The copper rough and tough is a beautiful leather 💪🏾 CM!
Those are some damn fine boots! I love the work Chukka #595. They look great and it's as close to a sneaker feel to an all leather wook boot. Soft leather lining is awesome. I wore them for work in a warehouse and shipping yard. They feel awesome on your feet even after 12 hours. I'll be getting some of these blacksmiths soon as well as a pair of black Iron Rangers to round out my boot collection.
I recently purchased a pair of Ice Cutter 2930 off eBay. Super comfortable with a nice wool lining for some extra warmth. Perfect for winter wear in NYC.
Yup, this will be my next pair.
These are the best looking boots from redwing for sure, I'll add the cooper ones in a tie on place 1, they all are durable.
I have these and the rough neck, I wish the iron rangers were in briar oil slick. It's the colour. I have some cigar beckmans that had oil spilt on the toe and left black lines on the toe. So I dyed them. They are the darkest brown I have seen. And everyone asks were I purchased them! But wish I could get iron rangers in this colour, they would look wicked!
I just ordered one yesterday. This will be my fifth Redwing.
Oh YEAH!!
I received my Blacksmith on a Thursday. The following day, Friday, I wore it for 11 hours straight with no problem at all. This is the most comfortable RW I have, out of the box, among my 6 RW boots.
@@jalcanites2939 I agree 100%
How much your last pair last? Or how much does redwing shoes usually lasts?
@@tanveersaeed1576 depends on how much you wear the boots and most importantly treating the leather. The boots should last at least 10 years.
Handsome boots and the denim rocks.
This is a true story; The names have not been changed! My father found a pair of authentic Red Wing chukka boots in a second hand store in Hollywood. They lived in my father's improvised "mud room" long after he passed. With regret they got tossed out when we finally moved from there. When I go my boots are going with me because I just couldn't pass on without them.
Came across this video last week, bought this exact pair 4 days ago, paid $30 extra for overnight shipping and am so glad that I did all of that. Before now, best thing I owned were Chippewa (still good)...but Redwing is in a different class
Awesome! Congrats on the purchase. You will really enjoy the 3340s. I am excited for you!
I was warned about a possible brutal break in on the Blacksmiths, however, I'm not getting that. They are absolutely fantastic
No, the Blacksmiths are the easiest! The Beckmans and Moc Toes are rascals!
I personally love the Iron Ranger look more than any other boot, regardless of brand. These boots you reviewed are definitely nice. Probably my 2nd favorite.
Yeah Iron Rangers are lovely just not super versatile.
I’m with you on that . The Iron Rangers are my favorite also but the Blacksmiths are sweet . I also love the 8 in Moc toes . The 10877 from the work line which are made in America and the 877 from the heritage line are also great boots. Really I will take any of the Heritage line.
Yes, indeed. 💯 💯 💯 💯 💯
such a hard choice for a first boot, the 8111 or the 3340!
3340 is more versatile
I disagree. The best men's boots 8111!
Just ordered a pair, can't wait to get them. They seem to be harder and harder to find these days. I'm glad I was able to find a pair my size. They look amazing!
Awesome!! You will LOVE them!
I put mink oil on mine and they turned a deep rich red color, also don't show the scuffs, some people like the scuffs call it "patina" but I did the same with my rough and tough, they went deep black like harness, call me a rebel but scuffed up shoes don't appeal to me.
Great choice of boots and tuneage
I have to agree. They continue to look nice as the break in. The women dig a man with nice shoes and at the same time masculinity. Great review.
All true statements! Thank you
I just found out last night that Red Wing made these boots for Brooks Brothers as the 4522. They have the nitrile cork sole and leather lining in the vamp. No speedhooks, all eyelets. The combination of all of those things make me think they would be your grail boot! Although the eyelets are dark brown, not this antique brass look. Black instead of brown piping up top as well. Annnnd, I see a pair on eBay in size 9D. But they're going for $415 with the Make Offer feature available. My size as well, but I don't think I'm willing to pay that for them.
415$? Damn! That is crazy high! Probably my fault.
@@CJCook Haha, likely contributed!
I finally got a pair of 3340s! I'd been looking for ANY pair of Red Wings in Briar Oil Slick for a while as I have no Briar Red Wings in my collection. Last week I decided to check Sierra Trading Post to see which (if any) Red Wings they had in stock. I was excited to see that they had ONE pair of 3340s left. BINGO! My size! (what are the chances?). Just found them on my door step! Thanks for the inspiration CJ!
Awesome!
You are welcome Daniel 👍🏽
I’m buying a pair for myself for Xmas. They look fantastic, specially with the chinos. Thanks buddy 🙏
The perfect Xmas gift!
I always wear my 3340s with chinos.
The 3340s are perfect because they can be dressed up or down.
ya I might agree. hmm. im starting to have a boot problem.
Agreed!
I stumbled onto the Blacksmith 2961s at a Nordstrom Rack last week. Another AWESOME option to think about...
holy crap. I need a nordstrom rack like that.
Excellent Review!! I just made a purchase of some American Made Red Wing blacksmiths boots . Thank you for your insight!!
Marco Nice! Congrats, you will not regret it. They are comfortable and stylish.
I've got the 3343's and they are awesome in every way but one. I swear they get scuffed when I just look at them. Any good tips about that?
Yeah, that is the Copper Rough and Tough leather. It takes on characteristics very easily.
Nice boots. However, I really wish they would do a 360 Goodyear welt instead of 3/4.
That would be nice!
Great choice! I have the 3340s and have always treated them with the RW boot oil and it has darkened them to an oxblood color. I love the patina on em!
Oooo...Love that color! Thank you -- I have not treated my boots yet but I will definitely keep the RW Boot Oil in mind.
I'm thinking of adding the Merchant or the Sheldon to my RW collection.
Good move! I own the 8061 and the 8062 both are stylish. Great for wearing to an office or on a date.
Could you make a video that shows more variety of outfits that can go with the 3340? Just love the shoes.
Thx for another good review. Bought some 3341s based on another review you did. It was a good call.
Awesome! Thank you Enrique. I really have enjoyed the 3341s
Debated so hard between these and the iron ranger last year. I’m now saving up for the iron ranger to switching and comparing. Red Wing make beautiful and durable boots. Thanks for the review
Cool! Which Iron Rangers are you interested in purchasing?
Iron ranger is essentially the same boot with a toe cap and different leather
CJ Cook, I got the charcoal rough n rough just to be different:). I’m still breaking in the copper rough n tough moc toe. I love RW heritage boots. Thanks for the reviews once again
I have the Blacksmith 3341s as well. I LOVE them! I even skateboard in them. I will do a review of the Blacksmith 3341s soon. The 1907s are a classic - - two very good choices!
Red Wing boots look really nice, but I think the sole often looks boring and a little too low. I prefer the sole edges on the Wolverine 1000 Mile for example, with the leather sole look. These would've looked even better with sole edges closer to 1000 Mile than just plain cork in my opinion.
Just ordered a pair of 3343's :) Well, Christmas is coming.
Copper Rough & Tough is a really nice leather - - Congrats Stephen!
CJ, thanks for these videos. I am planning to buy my first pair of Red Wing boots on Saturday and am having a hard time deciding between the 3340 and 9011 (Beckman). I want a boot that can handle mud/snow/rain well, but can also dress up well for nicer restaurants and venues. Can the 9011 handle all of that weather, or is it going to be too much fuss? On the flip side, I wonder how well the 3340 will "dress up" after it's been scuffed and worn in. Thanks in advance for any advice you can offer.
Go with the 9011s. One could never go wrong with the Beckman. The Featherstone leather is a great leather for dress up (i.e. restaurants and venues).
IR cost 25% more on average. So there is something on the quality of these last boots that makes the difference. Look at the heel, no 3 line stitches... that is build quality...
I Like my 9215 chuka foreman better, because of the toeway , blacksmith toe is wide IMO, but the leather is superb, they look good on you, good boot , I love the review.
These are hands down my favorite boot I own. I have three pairs of Iron Rangers in Hawthorne, oxeblood, and Amber harness, one Beckmann bought factory seconds in black feather stone, one cooper in Amber, and these in briar oil slick. The contrast between the dark reddish leather, the raw edges, and the brass eyelets are gorgeous plus they patina sooo damn well. After two years they still look new since I baby them but have even considered buying a second pair with fears that they may discontinue at one point or another even thought it’s unlikely
You have a nice collection. Yeah, I have thought about purchasing a second pair
as well because one never knows when Red Wing will pull a boot.
Getting them for my birthday, they look smart.
That is the perfect birthday gift!
I just got the 10877 man I love them
Nice!! Did you have to special order them?
Looks like an Alden 405
Very nice!cool colour!
Nice video and beautiful boot!!
I own an IR rough & tough and a Blacksmith in rough out Hawthorne. I find the Blacksmith more comfortable the more I wear them. Tried Beckman's, but they just don't work for me as they cut into my tendon too much.
I definitely want to get another smooth leather Blacksmith though. And you gave me a nice recommendation. Thanks!
You are welcome! I really like the Red Wing 3344s as well. I am thinking of buying ANOTHER pair of 3340s just in case.
HI CJ, I am pulling the trigger on a pair of the blacksmiths in black spitfire and was just wondering if the sizing on these is the same as the iron rangers. I tried a pair of Iron Rangers on at a local Red Wing store but they didn't have the Blacksmiths in stock. Thanks!
Hey Paul, yes the Iron Rangers and the Blacksmiths are made on the same last...so go ahead and pull the trigger!!
On my 3rd pair because I beat them up working the way I do but love them worth every penny!!
That is FANTASTIC!
I am sure they look amazing nice a beat up.
Have the work chukka in this leather and they are gorgeous. To bad the merchant doesn’t come in this.
Thanks
Just found the channel
Enjoying the approach
Do you own Iron Rangers?
I own two pair.
I use leather, or composite / felt or wool inserts ... depends
Many make the error of shoving in cheap, counter-top inserts...
Maybe some Gene Ammons? Jug.
Hi, I own the 8111s, 8114s, and the 8113s. I am a huge fan of the Iron Rangers.
I prefer 8061 Merchants.. but blacksmiths are cool
I just got a pair of these today , I haven't put them on yet ,
Congrats Tony!
I've got the IR's , blacksmiths (roughout in black). Rovers , 875's , Beckman chukka's, Pecos, and engineer's , forgot the number . By far the easiest to break in and look at are the Blacksmiths.
You have a really nice collection. The Blacksmith 2955s are dreamy! And yes, the break in period is easier than others. Which Rovers did you purchase?
Your sound went off at the on feet part.
CJ, a bit of assistance, if you don’t mind. I had my heart set on a pair of Beckman 9011 in the black cherry Featherstone until watching this review. I’m looking for a “dressier” pair of boots to wear this winter. I would appreciate your advice.
Hey! If you are looking to go dressier the Beckman is the way to go. The Black Cherry Featherstone leather is absolutely lovely. Although, the break-in period on the Beckmans will take longer than the Blacksmiths. Also, the Beckmans are being discontinued...which is so sad. You may want to snag them whilst you can! If you live somewhere with heavy snow and ice the Beckmans are not the greatest but you will look GREAT!
Where'd you buy the 2 dark pairs of denim jeans you wore around the 5-6 min mark? Looks good. Perhaps a video on denim to complement the boots would be good for future! Thanks man
The blue pair are Japanese Selvedge from GAP and the Black pair is from Railcar
Just ordered the 3340. Wish I could have had them by Christmas. Have a feeling I'm gonna love them. You have me hooked CJ! This is pair number 5!!
Congrats!
You will love them! The Briar leather is luxurious!
Which other Red Wings do you have?
@@CJCook I have a pair of 8119 in ox blood, the 8114 (so far my favorite) the 9075 in black harness and the 8166.
@@kennethboley1606 How do you find the difference between the Vibram sole on the 8119s vs the Nitrile sole on the 8114s?
CJ Cook The Vibram sole is more practical here in Michigan. I like the nitrile for comfort and looks. Would consider a Vibram when a resole is needed.
My 3340’s should be here tomorrow. Can’t wait!
Nice looking boot. I think I like them better than the Iron Ranger I don’t like the cap toe on the Iron Ranger.
I had a pair of supersoles for about 7-8 months. They literally fell apart, chunks of the sole were just falling off, stitching coming undone. Was told since I didn't still have my original receipt that they wouldn't honor the warranty.
Damn 😔
CJ, I bought the 3340 and wore them for six mos. Took them to Redwing Store and had the Postman 9196 sole put on. Now I have a Briar Oil 3340 Rover. Extremely comfortable.
Please send me a photo: triplestitch3340@gmail.com
5:00 main reason why i love this channel .
What is more rare the 4522 with the nitrile cork or the 3340 with the vibram mini lug?
Definitely the 4522
Great Channel Mate.
Thank you so much!
Does the Blacksmith 3340 run true to size? If person usually buys a 10.5, should they order a size 10. Obviously it's best to try on a boot first...but if one is ordering online it's more of a challenge. Just wondering...Thanks!
Hello David, The Blacksmith is made on the same last as the Iron Ranger which run big. If you usually buy a 10.5 in sneakers or a Cole Haan boot for example a 9.5 Blacksmith would be ideal.
Nice boots but roughout black is for the long haul
Boots! A channel dedicated to Heritage Boots! Subscribed! Done!
Mahalo!
Thank you Jon!
that? This boots looks like an iron range, but is slightly different from an iron range? What number will be the style number? I also liked this boots very much. I definitely want to get it.
These are the Blacksmith 3340s. They are made on the same last as the Iron Ranger. The Blacksmith is like the Iron Ranger minus the toe cap.
There is a style number of 3340. It was helpful. Thank you very much.
I subscribed to the channel.
@@choutdoorandxtrail8157 Yes, Blacksmith in Briar Oil Slick Leather.
You are welcome.
Thank you for subscribing!
Great job, your Awesome.
I decided to subscribe and heed your advice, and deciding on which boot to get. I live in Miami. I decided to get the blacksmith in this video (this boot and color seem so versatile), then I get the Beckman, and the Iron Ranger. Any thoughts or recommendations
Hi!
I took a trip to Miami last April. My first time down there and I brought the 3340s. The only boot/shoe I packed. They worked perfectly for the day and transitioning to the night. The Blacksmith is a great choice!
@@CJCookthank much, my Red Wing Guru. super excited, lol.
@@ringram305 you are welcome
What insoles do you use for city walking as mentioned? And do you size up to accommodate them?
ua-cam.com/video/cvmqPOqWCUk/v-deo.html
The iron rangers are nice but i have always felt the bkacksmith has ALWAYS been the better boot for casual and style.
I agree!
Well not bad!!!!! It look like comfortable ?????
Just bought these online, you convinced me man. Dude, you are terrible for my wallet, my wife wants to have a few words with you!
Oh no! Well...Put the 3340s on and take your wife out on a date!
@@CJCook I'm sure she will like them when the arrive.
@@mattn1936 Yeah, I believe so. The texture of the Briar will woo her.
@@CJCook haha, I'm sure she won't be able to resist. These still your favorites?
@@mattn1936 yep, still my favorites. I am debating whether or not to buy a second pair. I may buy a second pair of 8114s as well.
The Wolverine 1000 Mile?
Can't wear them in the snow with leather soles 😔
It’s obvious you don’t own a pair of Beckman 9030 or the Alden Indy boots
Just ordered a pair of these in charcoal to compliment my Iron Rangers. My one and only complaint with the IR is that I would have liked some sort of impact absorption and the leather insole is a little hard. Im an 11 in most shoes but a 9.5 wide in my IR. Is sizing for these just as crazy and what size did you order different from your usual size to be able to fit an insole?
I have the 3341s as well. They were the first pair of Blacksmiths I purchased. You will love them! The Iron Ranger and the Blacksmith are both made on the 8 last which means the sizing will be the same. I do not use a full insole insert for comfort. I use a Dr. Scholl's half insole insert so my toes have room. So, I did not size up...there is enough room. If you find any discomfort you could wear a thinner sock which I have done as well.
@@CJCook ok that's good to know. My IRs are a wide but I ordered these in D in 2 sizes and will keep the one that fits. As for the half sole, that's exactly what I was thinking. Thanks man.
You are welcome. Congrats on your new boots!
U sure thats the oil slick? Looks like the cooper
Briar 100%
It would looks awesome with the white sole
YES! I have put it out there to Red Wing to make the Rover in Briar Oil Slick Leather.
1:04 wtf?
🤣🤣
Lol
He dropped the other boot on his nuts.
After 2 years, do you still feel this way?
yes, I certainly do.
@@CJCook if you had only 1 other leather of this boot to choose what would it be, and why? on a scale of 1-10 where would you place that leather in comparison to this leather.
@@ThomasSteed Oro for sure. I love how it ages over time.
Bought a pair Saturday!
NICE!
I’m not loving Red Wing’s current selection. The slate muleskinner Iron Ranger look cool, but the rest are a little too safe. I wish they had more cool Blacksmiths like this!
I agree, they just do the same thing.
@@CJCook I guess Japan had a bunch of exclusive plain toe models with the wedge sole, but not my thing.
They look good
Thank you!
Does the leather collar at the top of the boot cause any discomfort?
Martyn A little at first but nothing painful or blistering in my experience. The moc toe 875’s collars were worse for me.
Ya no están en el catálogo de RW?
Ahorita no en este color.
Hi CJ, I intent to order the 3340 but not sure about the saiz of this RW. My feet are 10 ½ inch long on manual measurement with medium width. Does RW has a guide measurement on sizes?
They don't. I would recommend getting sized at Red Wing. If not possible try a 9.5 in the 3340.
@@CJCook US or UK 9.5?
@@boyethelbert299 US
@@CJCook thanks..
Recently picked up the 3345. What do you think about the Black Prairie leather?
3345s...Congrats! I think the Black Prairie Leather is beautiful. I have not tried them on but I have been eyeing the 3345s each time I go to Red Wing. The leather is going to take of some lovely characteristics as it ages. The 9075s next year will be made with the Black Prairie Leather.
CJ Cook what is the major difference between the black harness and prairie leathers?
Love the channel and your passion for the brand!
@@_glenn_ Thank you Glenn. The Black Harness leather is a true black leather. The Black Chrome leather has a grey base. The Black Prairie leather has a brown base similar to the Black Klondike leather. So as you wear the Black Prairie brown will start to reveal.
Great video good sir!... I am torn as to whether I should get some of these or some 8196's... As someone who has both, which ones do you like better? (Not considering the fact that the 8196's are discontinued)
Well, if you can find the 8196 buy the 8196 because they are difficult to come by (unless you live in Europe or Asia). NOW, with that being stated the 3340s are extremely versatile. From a style perspective, they transition from day to night with complete ease.
HAHA!... thanks for the insight... yeah it looks like I could either get some on ebay or the same place you got them (8196's) for roughly the same price.... I don't know though... I am still torn...I have 7 pairs of Red Wings already, do I really need any of these?...hmmm... I am loving your videos by the way... they give me a new outlook on our favorite boot brand!
You can never have too many Red Wing boots! NEVER! Hahaha! Thank you for the love.
Buy the 8196.
Thanks!... I will probably get the 3340's before the year is over... let's be honest!... hahaha!...so far I have a pair of 1907's (With roughneck Vibram sole), 1 pair of 875's...1 pair of 8111's with beckman Roccia soles, 1 pair of 8114's, 1 pair of Rover 2950's (Copper rough and tough), 1 pair of 4552's (Brooks Brothers Iron Rangers with the Roughneck style Vibram lug soles), 1 pair of 9014's in the mail, and now these 8196's will be in the mail soon!... I will drop hints to my GF about the 3340's and maybe I can score them for Christmas.. I think I might have a problem...
Wow! You have a really nice collection. Also, you have made some really smart customization choices.
Are they good in snow and mud or are they just a show boot
Yes, they are good for the snow and mud just wipe them down after the madness.