I love that we’re getting away from the narrow dress boot look (still love all of mine but..). The work boot / hiking boot look with formal attire is such a good look and has made formal at work and our long commutes in much more comfortable. I like being able to present in the boardroom, hike 15 flights of stairs to the next meeting and navigate the tough terrains of the inner city in my way to the train tracks for my ride home; all within weather that goes from 70s and sunny to 40s and snow within hours.
Same. Mine were in copper rough and tough. Then I picked up rangers in black harness and amber harness. And now I’m trying to find these in briar but they’re nowhere to be found
Just ordered these in store a week ago after finding my size. They look more brown than I thought but in bright lighting I can really see the red undertones. Nice review, thanks for reassuring my purchase.
idk why more people aren't raving about the black black smiths or copper rough and tough. But great review. once i bought my first pair, i stopped wearing sneakers completely.
3340s were my first pair of boots about eight years ago and they are still going strong. They are definitely not dress boots and the bulbous toes are important to note, but if you are looking for a heritage boot with a burlier and more casual workwear look then I think these are a great choice.
I love my Blacksmith 3345s! The Prairie Leather is awesome! I'm currently comparing them to the Chippewa Service Boot and the Blacksmith is blowing it out of the water... I also found the break in with these much better than the IRs. I used to have a pair of 1000 Mile and they simply do not match the quality of the Blacksmiths in my opinion. Great video as always Nick!
I have had these for a few months and highly recommend. I used saphir neutral oiled leather cream which is neatsfoot oil based and I think it looks good. I actually still get a pretty decent amount of luster with a good brushing and have only treated them with the saphir once and a small touch up. The leather seems to "heal" the light nicks and scratches from everyday wear after a firm brushing and relaxing overnight. The leather resembles that of a good football (american) in color and feel, and there is a nice pebbling on the upper and hind sections, smoother tighter grain leather on the toe which I feel is a nice subtle detail. For me there was not that bad of a break in, mostly felt rough around the collars. I did not size down, got the same as my sneaker/dress shoe size but I prefer to wear with merino wool socks and don't mind the extra roomy toe box. Even for the summer I try to find some thicker cotton socks if I choose to wear this style of boot, it really helps with the fit and comfort.
I love my red wing blacksmith boots. They fit great, look better as they get more used, are tough as nails, and feel like butter inside. Can be worn all day with ease.
I have a pair of handmade hiking boots made by a company called Prospector (I believe no longer in business). They are almost 30 years old. Anyway, I have used mink oil on them and have cleaned them with saddle soap once per year since I bought them. I have never had a problem and they look fantastic. I will be replacing the commando sole for only the second time (the first sole I had on their was the best sole I ever had on a shoe/boot of any kind and lasted almost 20 years lol). I think one problem is people apply too much mink oil. I use a conservative amount but really work it into the leather. The process takes me a while and your hands get sore but I believe it is worth it. I only have three pair of boots, these a timberland and a cheaper wolverine. My Timberlands are the newest and they are 11years old. They were nubuck but I couldn't stand them so I saddlesoap cleaned them then mink oiled them up about ten years ago and now they look like oil tanned leather. Look great in my opinion. Anyway, I think mink oil is the best product to use most leather boots of a casual or working nature. I would definitely avoid using it on dress type boots or anything that is chromed leather.
Thanks for the review, appreciated. Just a pointer on Chrome tanned leather versus Veg. In the crust state there's not a great deal of difference at all in the gloss level and if anything veg leather can have a little more shine on it. At the end of the day it's how it's finished that dictates the gloss level. A lot of chrome tanned leathers are finished using pigments, resins and lacquers which in general increase the gloss level. Both retannages when finished with oils or hot waxes with have a fairly matt natural look, especially if you're working on a buffed grain.
Always love your review! I also had nightmare with breaking my iron ranger and about to break in resently purchased moc toe. I thought briar oil slick black smith is so charming but unfortunately it is not available in Korea. Waiting them to be released in Korea, too. BTW beckman is still available in Korea, so if you can, I would love to get your review on old beckman pair! before I get them!
Am I the only who hasn’t been able to break in the The Blacksmith in the Briar Oil ⁉️ OUCH❗️ My Iron Ranger in Black felt great out the box so I know I have the right size. But I this guy said the break in depends on the batch you get I am thinking of having the width and instep widen. I love the leather and how thick it is so don’t want to give them up. Maybe I should see if I get another pair and see how they fit.
I love your videos very good comparisons I’ve watched this videos 4-5 times I’m gonna be getting these as a Christmas present to myself I like the variety of boots on this channel
Just bought a pair of these in the 3345 Black Prairie leather as my first "real boots". Gambled a bit by going with my true size but they were on sale at Mr. Porter for $210 and I just couldn't resist. So far I'm absolutely in love with them... they definitely hurt after wearing them for a little while since I'm still breaking them in but they're mostly very comfortable and I think they look FANTASTIC
I will try these. I am looking for more info on Georgia small batch. I love my Georgia giants for work and dress up nice in an engineering environment.
@@Stridewise Don't worry too much about it, UA-cam is normally like it. We all come here for the quality reviewing anyway but yeah, I can understand the frustration :)
Love these. I would also consider the Red Wing Merchant 8062 in Olive Mohave rough out. It has a little bit more cushion in the sole and a more tapered toe box, as well as another unique color that works with everything.
I actually bought a pair of the 3343s and a pair of the 3340s. I use the 3343s for work and the Briars for going out on the weekends. Love this boot. Shock absorption wasn't great so I bought them true to size and added a leather insert coupled with a cork insert. I broke them in first without any inserts. But they got a bit loose. Nothing crazy but I like a snug boot. And that toe box is extra roomy for sure. Once broken in to my foot print though, I put the leather and cork inserts in. They fit like a glove now and the shock absorption is way better too. Before the inserts the soles (although really durable and sleek looking) weren't really great for walking on gravel all day. Now they still aren't a lug sole but they are a lot better. Plus the weight factor really helps when walking around all day too. Love lug and crape soles. But man they can get heavy after a 12hr shift outdoors all day. The uppers are handling the beat down I put on em extremely well though. Plus they clean up and look great. Love these boots.
@@charlesbronson240 i have a local dealer who has a used pair that fits my size, its a used pair though but the shoes did not fit the original customer and he has worn it just a couple of times and they are as good as new. Unfortunately this leather is not available anymore.
The last similar pair I had were Sears, I think in the late 1980s. They had two hooks and I believe were shorter at the ankle. They also had cork/rubber type soles, for lack of a better description. My father who was born in 1912 called what I purchased "plow shoes." The boots in this video review look good but are above my budget. I wonder how farmers and blacksmiths could have afforded them in olden days, even with the price adjusted for the time.
Hey Nick great vid and big fan of the channel. Any chance you could do a review on the Red Wing Merchant boot? Seems similar to the Blacksmith but I like the look of the slimmer profile / less bulbous toebox. Thanks for the vids man keep up the hard work.
Do you know what happened to the RW Harvester? I was really liking the look of those, but don’t see them anymore. They were only out for like a year or two from what I saw. Another great review!
Just got the Beckmans from Sierra Trading Post, $200 for factory seconds in the cigar featherstone color. I'd definitely prefer the blacksmiths but they dont have it as factory seconds and I can't see myself paying that much (paid $400 for my shell cordovans, and that was kinda a lot for me). It just sucks that maybe I would've skipped the Beckmans and just got the Blacksmiths if they made it in a size 6 ugh
I have these exact boots (briar slick as in the video). I’m wearing these to the grave with me, so yeah, I like them. Also own Briar Slick Moc Toe. Owned several Chippewas and one Thorogood (Janesville moc toe), but in hindsight I wish I only spent money on redwings.
I plan on getting these in the Copper Rough & Tough (not really a big fan of the Briar), but I'm just waiting to get a good deal on them. I'm counting on Nordstrom to put them on sale in a few weeks.
I find the old Nitrile Soles to be more comfortable to walk in. Looks thicker for shock absorption. IMO. I do prefer the look of the Blacksmith vs my Iron Ranger. I own 2 Blacksmiths CR&T and Spitfire that required no breakin and 1 IR 8111.
Hi Nick love ur channel im from the UK and a real boot nut, own several Redwing boots,Whites, Alden Indys, etc . you really need to check out the new Loake AW20 industrial collection,out as of November 2020.absolutely gorgeous beautifully made boots i pulled the trigger on the Loake Hebdens in brown CXL,and cant wait to give them a beating, it was a toss up between the Thursdays and the Loake but glad i went for these for the time being.
@@Stridewise I'd like to wear my boots in the winter. But I just seem to forget about them in the spring/summer. So my beckmans and classic rounds stay in the closet and my classic chukkas and caverly chukkas (cigar Esquires) get most of my wear. I'm thinking merchants with the flatbox might work in the warmer months. So they might be my next purchase. Edit: just got to the part of the video about mink oil darkening the leather. Definitely will. I was worried about my black cherry beckmans getting dark. Someone on Reddit recommended bick 4. Doesn't darken and 1+ year in, I'm happy with bick. I've treated them 4x and hasn't darkened the leather.
bill s hi bill, u have FB? Do u mind to drop a pic of ur black cherries in Redwing boots social club? I’m considering buying or BM Black Cherry or IR Oxblood Mesa.. I want some red leather boots in my collection ( I own already 1x BM, 2x IR, 1x Chukka , 1x Engineers. Tx in adv. What u recommend?
bill s hi bill, u have FB? Do u mind to drop a pic of ur black cherries in Redwing boots social club? I’m considering buying or BM Black Cherry or IR Oxblood Mesa.. I want some red leather boots in my collection ( I own already 1x BM, 2x IR, 1x Chukka , 1x Engineers. Tx in adv. What u recommend?
bill s hi bill, u have FB? Do u mind to drop a pic of ur black cherries in Redwing boots social club? I’m considering buying or BM Black Cherry or IR Oxblood Mesa.. I want some red leather boots in my collection ( I own already 1x BM, 2x IR, 1x Chukka , 1x Engineers. Tx in adv. What u recommend?
These remind me of my red wing 213s which are discontinued. They are 7 years old and look great. I resoled them w vibram soles last year. They also have a 360 degree Goodyear welt. Any feedback on what is still available that is closest to the 213s?
I visited a Redwing Store yesterday in Portland, OR. No Blacksmiths. I visited one of their retailers today, and he said that the Blacksmith was discontinued. Bummer! Say that it isn't true?!
I think the break in process also depends what socks you wear. Never wear cotton socks because your foot will get wet then blister. Wear wool blend socks and it will keep your feet dry with some extra cushion.
so im considering ordering my first pair of "nice" boots and am obsessed with red wings (lil bit about me im a landscape and outdoor brand photographer) so I'm outside in rugged conditions a lot and im struggling with which boots to buy for my first pair, i know ill probably get multiple styles once i get into it but the blacksmiths have my heart style wise, it is the style i wear, albeit in much cheaper but im thinking for what i do the moc toes might be better if im standing a lot and moving about the wilderness quite a bit, so my question is, trust my gut and get the moc toes even though they are my second fave ( i also ride a motorcycle and feel they would probably look dope with one) or get the blacksmiths first so i can wear in the city more. the struggle is real
That is tough. Boots are big financial decisions! I'm an overthinker myself (hence the very long videos). I think go with the Blacksmiths, they will look perfectly fine and be perfectly functional for your uses until you get the moc toes.
@@Stridewise One of the things i appreciate about you is the fact that you always go in depth on everything, so thank you for the longer videos, and responding to comments on old videos. you do a hell of a job and i think youre right the blacksmiths have my heart, gonna try and go this weekend or as soon as its okay enough to go into shops and get a pair. Thank you for all you do!!
@@ThirdMonarch This made my day, Matt! Really appreciate that you took the time to write that out, it made a difference. Let me know how the Blacksmiths go!
Stridewise well you give so much to us or at least me. I feel confident in like 20 different things I never knew about buying nice boots, so it’s the least I can do. Keep crushing it my friend
I was looking at Blacksmith boots today....timely review! They look great wuth jeans! In your opinion, do you think they could pull off a casual office look with chinos?
@@Stridewise agree completely..although I will say Thursday captains in brown are being worn solidly!! Trip to Spain is in the works so I'll definitely be putting some steps in them.
Wore mine today- (Day after a DC snow storm- Did great) The Blacksmith in Spitfire tho may be my favorite out of my Boot Collection (up to nearly 50 pairs now) Good Review tho-thx
Mink oil tends to sort of build up on the leather of redwings and I find they pick up lint too much. I go with huberts boot oil, after a cleaning with saddle soap.
I love my redwing Moc toes but I've be turned to Chippewa. I have a pair of black 6" Service and I wish I'd bought them before I'd spent my cash on my Redwings.
You should do a review on the 875 mlc toes. I know you already reviewed one of the moc toes but the 875s are unique in their history and their leather color.
✪ Check out the 10 Best Boots On the Market! ua-cam.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/v-deo.html
I own these and they make my Thursday captains feel like something I picked up at the clearance rack at Spencers
😂
This is true after feeling Thursday boots it was night and day
I've had my Blacksmith 3343s for three years now and couldn't be happier with them. Tough as nails and very versatile style-wise.
I love that we’re getting away from the narrow dress boot look (still love all of mine but..). The work boot / hiking boot look with formal attire is such a good look and has made formal at work and our long commutes in much more comfortable. I like being able to present in the boardroom, hike 15 flights of stairs to the next meeting and navigate the tough terrains of the inner city in my way to the train tracks for my ride home; all within weather that goes from 70s and sunny to 40s and snow within hours.
These were my first redwing heritage boots and first “nice” boots. I love them and they started my boot collecting addiction.
Same here!
Same. Mine were in copper rough and tough. Then I picked up rangers in black harness and amber harness. And now I’m trying to find these in briar but they’re nowhere to be found
@@citizentuck whatre heriotage boots?
@@stevethea5250 a style of boots
My first Red Wings. Absolutely love them. Started my addiction
They're a classic!
pal after 1. redwing not long for 2. .ive got 6 pair now
Just ordered these in store a week ago after finding my size. They look more brown than I thought but in bright lighting I can really see the red undertones. Nice review, thanks for reassuring my purchase.
Definitely needs to be made available in wide sizes!
idk why more people aren't raving about the black black smiths or copper rough and tough. But great review. once i bought my first pair, i stopped wearing sneakers completely.
Thanks Shalik! I'm reviewing some copper rough and tough RW Chelseas soon!
3340s were my first pair of boots about eight years ago and they are still going strong. They are definitely not dress boots and the bulbous toes are important to note, but if you are looking for a heritage boot with a burlier and more casual workwear look then I think these are a great choice.
I love my Blacksmith 3345s! The Prairie Leather is awesome! I'm currently comparing them to the Chippewa Service Boot and the Blacksmith is blowing it out of the water... I also found the break in with these much better than the IRs. I used to have a pair of 1000 Mile and they simply do not match the quality of the Blacksmiths in my opinion. Great video as always Nick!
I have had these for a few months and highly recommend. I used saphir neutral oiled leather cream which is neatsfoot oil based and I think it looks good. I actually still get a pretty decent amount of luster with a good brushing and have only treated them with the saphir once and a small touch up. The leather seems to "heal" the light nicks and scratches from everyday wear after a firm brushing and relaxing overnight. The leather resembles that of a good football (american) in color and feel, and there is a nice pebbling on the upper and hind sections, smoother tighter grain leather on the toe which I feel is a nice subtle detail. For me there was not that bad of a break in, mostly felt rough around the collars. I did not size down, got the same as my sneaker/dress shoe size but I prefer to wear with merino wool socks and don't mind the extra roomy toe box. Even for the summer I try to find some thicker cotton socks if I choose to wear this style of boot, it really helps with the fit and comfort.
These boots are my Grail boots, if that can be a thing. Just sweet. Thanks for the review.
You're welcome, glad you liked it.
I love how you said Vibram and then corrected yourself, but immediately went back to your original pronunciation... Great video, I learned a lot.
hahah "i said what i said!!!" so glad you liked it
I own these boots and think t his is the best review on youtube of the pros and cons... nice job.
wow, I always think the videos from my first year of this channel are terrible, it's really nice you gave this your vote of confidence dmitry!
I love my red wing blacksmith boots. They fit great, look better as they get more used, are tough as nails, and feel like butter inside. Can be worn all day with ease.
Your review helped me pull the trigger and get these boots. They fit your foot like a glove. Thank you for your help dude!
Hey so glad to be helpful!
I have a pair of handmade hiking boots made by a company called Prospector (I believe no longer in business). They are almost 30 years old. Anyway, I have used mink oil on them and have cleaned them with saddle soap once per year since I bought them. I have never had a problem and they look fantastic. I will be replacing the commando sole for only the second time (the first sole I had on their was the best sole I ever had on a shoe/boot of any kind and lasted almost 20 years lol). I think one problem is people apply too much mink oil. I use a conservative amount but really work it into the leather. The process takes me a while and your hands get sore but I believe it is worth it. I only have three pair of boots, these a timberland and a cheaper wolverine. My Timberlands are the newest and they are 11years old. They were nubuck but I couldn't stand them so I saddlesoap cleaned them then mink oiled them up about ten years ago and now they look like oil tanned leather. Look great in my opinion. Anyway, I think mink oil is the best product to use most leather boots of a casual or working nature. I would definitely avoid using it on dress type boots or anything that is chromed leather.
Thanks for the review, appreciated. Just a pointer on Chrome tanned leather versus Veg. In the crust state there's not a great deal of difference at all in the gloss level and if anything veg leather can have a little more shine on it.
At the end of the day it's how it's finished that dictates the gloss level. A lot of chrome tanned leathers are finished using pigments, resins and lacquers which in general increase the gloss level.
Both retannages when finished with oils or hot waxes with have a fairly matt natural look, especially if you're working on a buffed grain.
By far the best real world experience reviews of boots out there. Thanks for your channel!
Always love your review! I also had nightmare with breaking my iron ranger and about to break in resently purchased moc toe. I thought briar oil slick black smith is so charming but unfortunately it is not available in Korea. Waiting them to be released in Korea, too. BTW beckman is still available in Korea, so if you can, I would love to get your review on old beckman pair! before I get them!
My 3343's were my first boot purchase and they have been wonderful.
Am I the only who hasn’t been able to break in the The Blacksmith in the Briar Oil ⁉️ OUCH❗️ My Iron Ranger in Black felt great out the box so I know I have the right size. But I this guy said the break in depends on the batch you get I am thinking of having the width and instep widen. I love the leather and how thick it is so don’t want to give them up. Maybe I should see if I get another pair and see how they fit.
I love your videos very good comparisons I’ve watched this videos 4-5 times I’m gonna be getting these as a Christmas present to myself I like the variety of boots on this channel
That's great Brendan! High quality clothes are the best gifts for oneself :) Hope you have a happy Christmas
Just bought a pair of these in the 3345 Black Prairie leather as my first "real boots". Gambled a bit by going with my true size but they were on sale at Mr. Porter for $210 and I just couldn't resist. So far I'm absolutely in love with them... they definitely hurt after wearing them for a little while since I'm still breaking them in but they're mostly very comfortable and I think they look FANTASTIC
Yay! Having boots you love is the best feeling. Glad they worked out so well for you Danny (and that you got such a good deal)
I will try these. I am looking for more info on Georgia small batch. I love my Georgia giants for work and dress up nice in an engineering environment.
Arriving at that 320p quality, need to use some Saphir conditioner on it
I'm freaking out trying to decide if I should reupload it :( :(
It's fixed!!!!
@@Stridewise Don't worry too much about it, UA-cam is normally like it. We all come here for the quality reviewing anyway but yeah, I can understand the frustration :)
Love these. I would also consider the Red Wing Merchant 8062 in Olive Mohave rough out. It has a little bit more cushion in the sole and a more tapered toe box, as well as another unique color that works with everything.
Thanks for the nice review. Especially mentioning the mink oil colour change probability.
Glad it was helpful!
I just had my Blacksmith in Briar oil slick delivered yesterday. This is my 5th RedWing and second in Briar Oil slick leather.
Good choice, Jun!
Great review I always enjoy your videos thank you for all your hard work that you put into it really appreciate it man
I own two Beckman, three iron rangers, a Moc toe, and the blacksmiths in briar oil.......and the blacksmiths are hands down my favorite
Why do you say that I mean what's your reasoning just interested thanks
I actually bought a pair of the 3343s and a pair of the 3340s. I use the 3343s for work and the Briars for going out on the weekends. Love this boot. Shock absorption wasn't great so I bought them true to size and added a leather insert coupled with a cork insert. I broke them in first without any inserts. But they got a bit loose. Nothing crazy but I like a snug boot. And that toe box is extra roomy for sure. Once broken in to my foot print though, I put the leather and cork inserts in. They fit like a glove now and the shock absorption is way better too. Before the inserts the soles (although really durable and sleek looking) weren't really great for walking on gravel all day. Now they still aren't a lug sole but they are a lot better. Plus the weight factor really helps when walking around all day too. Love lug and crape soles. But man they can get heavy after a 12hr shift outdoors all day. The uppers are handling the beat down I put on em extremely well though. Plus they clean up and look great. Love these boots.
Love my Blacksmith 3345s! Comparing them to the Chippewa Service Boots... So far, no contest Blacksmith owns!
Red Wing's Irish Setter Sport Boot was the Ultimate Plain Toe Boot 40 years ago. Built like an Iron Ranger with no toe cap.
I love these boots and after owing this one i have ordered the spitfire black and is on the way. I cant describe how much i love these.
Where did you end up finding the spitfires? If you don’t mind my asking.
@@charlesbronson240 i have a local dealer who has a used pair that fits my size, its a used pair though but the shoes did not fit the original customer and he has worn it just a couple of times and they are as good as new. Unfortunately this leather is not available anymore.
Lovely review on a GREAT boot!
BRIAR Oil Slick all day!
I know that's your fave CJ haha
Resole on your IRs Nick. Send em to Brian the Boot Bootmaker. Or cord half sole from Dr.Sole in cream.
The last similar pair I had were Sears, I think in the late 1980s. They had two hooks and I believe were shorter at the ankle. They also had cork/rubber type soles, for lack of a better description. My father who was born in 1912 called what I purchased "plow shoes." The boots in this video review look good but are above my budget. I wonder how farmers and blacksmiths could have afforded them in olden days, even with the price adjusted for the time.
Hey, they're investments!
Nice review Nick. I notice you're wearing selvedge denim, nice cuffs btw. Which jeans are you wearing?
Everyone I know says Vibram like you first said it. Ever since I can remember, and I'm old.
Great Video. I just ordered a Pair in Copper Rough and Tough.
Another great review 👌🏼. Would love to see a Williston and/or Sheldon review if you haven’t already made one.
Your reviews are awesome, thanks for another great one!
So happy you like them, Jake!
Hey Nick great vid and big fan of the channel. Any chance you could do a review on the
Red Wing Merchant boot? Seems similar to the Blacksmith but I like the look of the slimmer profile / less bulbous toebox. Thanks for the vids man keep up the hard work.
Yeah I'm planning to do more Red Wing reviews!
I just noticed, 10k+ subscribers and 1.48m views! Keep up the good work.
I had a little celebration here in Brooklyn! Thanks for noticing and for the encouragement, I appreciate it.
Do you know what happened to the RW Harvester? I was really liking the look of those, but don’t see them anymore. They were only out for like a year or two from what I saw.
Another great review!
Think they might still be found in Europe!
I like the wiggle room in the toe box. Do you also get that wiggle room in the Thursday Boot or is it snug around the toes?
Love this colour too, should have watched this review before I darkened mine😂
Suggestion: Maybe do a video on good boot socks.
Just got the Beckmans from Sierra Trading Post, $200 for factory seconds in the cigar featherstone color. I'd definitely prefer the blacksmiths but they dont have it as factory seconds and I can't see myself paying that much (paid $400 for my shell cordovans, and that was kinda a lot for me). It just sucks that maybe I would've skipped the Beckmans and just got the Blacksmiths if they made it in a size 6 ugh
We need a Crockett & Jones Islay review stat! Great review BTW!
Thanks Jonathan! Crockett & Jones are pretty pricy but I've been getting a lot of requests!
Gonna loan him the $800 to buy them?!
I have these exact boots (briar slick as in the video). I’m wearing these to the grave with me, so yeah, I like them. Also own Briar Slick Moc Toe. Owned several Chippewas and one Thorogood (Janesville moc toe), but in hindsight I wish I only spent money on redwings.
haha glad you enjoy 'em so much my man.
Great video!! Quick question these or the RM Williams!? Thanks
it's apples and oranges! But RMs.
I plan on getting these in the Copper Rough & Tough (not really a big fan of the Briar), but I'm just waiting to get a good deal on them. I'm counting on Nordstrom to put them on sale in a few weeks.
I find the old Nitrile Soles to be more comfortable to walk in. Looks thicker for shock absorption. IMO. I do prefer the look of the Blacksmith vs my Iron Ranger. I own 2 Blacksmiths CR&T and Spitfire that required no breakin and 1 IR 8111.
The Beckman's were discontinued. But they are back. There's some interesting new stuff coming too.
OK I called them and they are discontinuing it, they're just selling off their old stock.
I love mine, I used mink oil on them and they color well
Cool! Good choice
Hi Nick love ur channel im from the UK and a real boot nut, own several Redwing boots,Whites, Alden Indys, etc . you really need to check out the new Loake AW20 industrial collection,out as of November 2020.absolutely gorgeous beautifully made boots i pulled the trigger on the Loake Hebdens in brown CXL,and cant wait to give them a beating, it was a toss up between the Thursdays and the Loake but glad i went for these for the time being.
Great review 👍👍 I enjoyed it
How is the shock absorption ? And comparer to the red wing ranger?
Got these bad boys in copper rough and tough, briar oil slick are next in line
Good review, Nick. Congratulations on 10k subs too!
Btw, do you wear boots during the summer as well?
When I can! I'm experimenting with lightweight denim so I can get away with more boots in summer :)
@@Stridewise I'd like to wear my boots in the winter. But I just seem to forget about them in the spring/summer. So my beckmans and classic rounds stay in the closet and my classic chukkas and caverly chukkas (cigar Esquires) get most of my wear. I'm thinking merchants with the flatbox might work in the warmer months. So they might be my next purchase.
Edit: just got to the part of the video about mink oil darkening the leather. Definitely will. I was worried about my black cherry beckmans getting dark. Someone on Reddit recommended bick 4. Doesn't darken and 1+ year in, I'm happy with bick. I've treated them 4x and hasn't darkened the leather.
bill s hi bill, u have FB? Do u mind to drop a pic of ur black cherries in Redwing boots social club? I’m considering buying or BM Black Cherry or IR Oxblood Mesa.. I want some red leather boots in my collection ( I own already 1x BM, 2x IR, 1x Chukka , 1x Engineers. Tx in adv. What u recommend?
bill s hi bill, u have FB? Do u mind to drop a pic of ur black cherries in Redwing boots social club? I’m considering buying or BM Black Cherry or IR Oxblood Mesa.. I want some red leather boots in my collection ( I own already 1x BM, 2x IR, 1x Chukka , 1x Engineers. Tx in adv. What u recommend?
bill s hi bill, u have FB? Do u mind to drop a pic of ur black cherries in Redwing boots social club? I’m considering buying or BM Black Cherry or IR Oxblood Mesa.. I want some red leather boots in my collection ( I own already 1x BM, 2x IR, 1x Chukka , 1x Engineers. Tx in adv. What u recommend?
Well Nick, very nice review! Thanks a ton for fuelling my addiction... ;-)
Glad you enjoyed it!
These remind me of my red wing 213s which are discontinued. They are 7 years old and look great. I resoled them w vibram soles last year. They also have a 360 degree Goodyear welt. Any feedback on what is still available that is closest to the 213s?
Alden Indy ;) Or the Thursday Diplomat
I watch this video too many time, at the end i ended up ordering one pair of blacksmith 3343 myself. Thanks mate.
Glad it was helpful Jaynern!
how do they compare to the 1000 mile weight wise? my experience with red wing is that they can be quite heavy!
Which boot do you recommend for arch support. Looking for a pair for my husband.
Great review 👍
Thanks dude!
Mine are in the mail. Red Wing are A LOT easier to find in the UK than the Wolverine 1000 Mile.
If you're getting blacksmith boots for work; get the version with spitfire leather. It's way tougher and long lasting with less maintenance.
Plus it has the coolest name of any leather
Nick, which boot do you like better the blacksmith or the Beckman?
What do you think about the Wilcox version of this boot?
Nick, which do you like better, Thursdays Captain or these Blacksmith boots?
I replaced the outsole with ROLE CLUB, it has a better shock absorption.
Nice! How much did it cost you to replace the sole, Jimnel?
I visited a Redwing Store yesterday in Portland, OR. No Blacksmiths. I visited one of their retailers today, and he said that the Blacksmith was discontinued. Bummer! Say that it isn't true?!
I don't think they're discontinued, it's more Red Wing is having a lot of trouble keeping up with demand
@@Stridewise I suppose a good problem for Red Wing to have. I'll stay on the hunt! Thanks and keep up the great videos!
Another great review. Any chance you would ever review the Dalton boot from Allen Edmonds?
I just filmed Sullivan Street, Max! Hope to do more Allen Edmonds this year.
@@Stridewise Awesome, thanks for the response.
I think the break in process also depends what socks you wear. Never wear cotton socks because your foot will get wet then blister. Wear wool blend socks and it will keep your feet dry with some extra cushion.
Bingo. Wearing a newer pair of Beckmans now with wool socks- the break-in has been far less painful than what folks have said.
Im currently going through the break in pase. Rough 🤨
Hang in there, Julian!
Its been now 2 month and i shocked. Now they are the best boots/shoes i have ever worn, period !
so im considering ordering my first pair of "nice" boots and am obsessed with red wings (lil bit about me im a landscape and outdoor brand photographer) so I'm outside in rugged conditions a lot and im struggling with which boots to buy for my first pair, i know ill probably get multiple styles once i get into it but the blacksmiths have my heart style wise, it is the style i wear, albeit in much cheaper but im thinking for what i do the moc toes might be better if im standing a lot and moving about the wilderness quite a bit, so my question is, trust my gut and get the moc toes even though they are my second fave ( i also ride a motorcycle and feel they would probably look dope with one) or get the blacksmiths first so i can wear in the city more. the struggle is real
That is tough. Boots are big financial decisions! I'm an overthinker myself (hence the very long videos). I think go with the Blacksmiths, they will look perfectly fine and be perfectly functional for your uses until you get the moc toes.
@@Stridewise One of the things i appreciate about you is the fact that you always go in depth on everything, so thank you for the longer videos, and responding to comments on old videos. you do a hell of a job and i think youre right the blacksmiths have my heart, gonna try and go this weekend or as soon as its okay enough to go into shops and get a pair. Thank you for all you do!!
@@ThirdMonarch This made my day, Matt! Really appreciate that you took the time to write that out, it made a difference. Let me know how the Blacksmiths go!
Stridewise well you give so much to us or at least me. I feel confident in like 20 different things I never knew about buying nice boots, so it’s the least I can do. Keep crushing it my friend
@@ThirdMonarch you're my favorite commenter!!
I just got A pair of these love them
excellent review man. Its between these and the Thorogood 1892 Tomahawks for me.....Thanks
Glad you liked it, Brett!!
I have a pair and completely agree on everything joust said,
Cool! Glad I hold up to scrutiny, Francesco :)
I was looking at Blacksmith boots today....timely review!
They look great wuth jeans! In your opinion, do you think they could pull off a casual office look with chinos?
david macy - no
Have you looked at the redwing merchants? They are the same last but don't have the full to box. Still rugged but a bit more elegant.
Yeah not yet! I mentioned them in the video but plan to, maybe when they're a bit more popular
@@Stridewise Sorry. Missed you mentioning them. Would love to see them in action, have been thinking about picking up a pair as my second gyw boot.
My addiction started w a solid pair of wolverine kilometer. Recently aquired Iron ranger mesa oxblood..now I want the blacksmiths
Yeah I like them way more than the Wolverines! - Nick
@@Stridewise agree completely..although I will say Thursday captains in brown are being worn solidly!! Trip to Spain is in the works so I'll definitely be putting some steps in them.
gread review also do you have any reviews on black stone boots
Have you tried Courteney boots?Interesting brand!!
This is the perfect all around boot in my mind
You've got a strong case
Beckmans back on UK website as of Nov 2020
Wore mine today- (Day after a DC snow storm- Did great) The Blacksmith in Spitfire tho may be my favorite out of my Boot Collection (up to nearly 50 pairs now) Good Review tho-thx
Thanks for your great reviews! To ask what jeans are those in your opening intro?
These ones! stridewise.com/studio-dartisan-denim-review-g003/
Mink oil tends to sort of build up on the leather of redwings and I find they pick up lint too much. I go with huberts boot oil, after a cleaning with saddle soap.
My favorite over Iron Ranger
What you would you prefer of you only could Buy One? Blacksmith or Iron Ranger? Wearing all day i mean?
I want a pair of these so bad but Red Wing isn’t making these right now,
I wanna go out and buy it now.
i'm afraid this is not for the instant gratification shopper haha you gotta be real patient
Which One you prefer? Red Wing blacksmith , iron Ranger or thursday boot Captain if you have to Chose only One pair? Please Short precise Answer.
The best boots from RW
I like them better than my iron rangers and you were right about there being no break in period,
Yeah Cliff they're more versatile, less of that flashy nickel.
I love my redwing Moc toes but I've be turned to Chippewa. I have a pair of black 6" Service and I wish I'd bought them before I'd spent my cash on my Redwings.
You should do a review on the 875 mlc toes. I know you already reviewed one of the moc toes but the 875s are unique in their history and their leather color.