@Barry Baz BS, it's hard as hell to get a visa even if you are a citizen of a bordering country. And even if you do have a visa, they have a habit for arbitrary border closures for no apparent reason every so often.
Marko Zlotov $200 a day isn’t too bad. It’s a once in a lifetime experience. And $1500 for a trippy week in some obscure dictatorship plus plane tickets is alright. My last trip in the US, I spent more a day on hotel, Uber rides and drinks and tickets to things to see.
@@sloppynyuszi I don't know how you are travelling but you have to know that if you change money on the black market rate in Turkmenistan you get 16 TMT for 1 USD instead of the official 4 TMT which makes everything hilariously cheap. For 4 days there I've spend ~100 USD including hotel, a trip to the Gate to Hell in Darvaza by Bus and Jeep and a train ride to the Uzbek border while dining in restaurants every evening. The flight was 40 USD Berlin - Moscow (Aeroflot) and 120 USD Moscow - Istanbul - Ashgabat (Turkish Airlines). I returned by land (train where possible) back to Germany throw UZ, TJ, KG, KZ and RU. Also, I've spent ~1500 USD for a 4 weeks trip throw USA and Canada in 2018 including flights from Germany so it also depends on the travel style I guess.
@@zlot555 it used to be even cheaper for locals as they had government subsided shops where they had limited choice of goods, yet everything was outlandishly cheap. Like a kilo of flour would cost something less than 10cents. Now these shops have constant shortages and market prices are out of reach for many people.
This must be from 2006. The football shirt he is wearing is the Reading shirt from 2006-07 campaign, and Niyazov died in december 2006, which means it has to be from fall 2006.
Not sure if y'all heard that part about free water, almost free utility bill and super cheap gas.. They may not make much money or get to play loud music in their car or getto go to ballet.. But I'd sacrifice that as long as my basic necessities are met and live in a community of relative equality... USA has a huge income disparity gap and sadly the majority of the super wealthy realize money doesn't buy happiness... Only content to a certain extent
I went to Turkmenistan for a vacation back in 2018, & none of the Niazov-era restrictions mentioned in this video still existed. It's undoubtedly still an authoritarian state, but there are no real restrictions on tourists.
Of course the Niyazov era restrictions didn't exist since his sucessor Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow erase the restrictions (although it's still authoritarian) , this happened after 2006, the year when Niyazov died and I think this was recorded 2006 or before that.
FRIENDLY JAPANESE BUSINESSMAN a joke about North Korea. The kid wants an item they have at home (North Korea) but the mom says they already have it at home. At home they have a different but usually worse version of the product, in this case (Turkmenistan.) That being said and despite the monarchy in place the people of this country seem very happy and healthy. Unlike DPRK or North Korea the people actually seem well fed and the normal citizens actually seem content.*
every time I read "DPRK" without fail, I *always read it as "koreurrrrr" in the voice of the North Korean that's giving commentary over state propaganda from Shane's guide to North Korea documentary!* no idea why that's what has stuck with me the most from that documentary, but it is, and I'll forever hear "koreurrrrr" in my head each and every. single. time.. lmfao
I really wish the filmmaker had blurred out the faces of some of the people showing him around. I'm sure it didn't go well for them when this came out.
Did you know , the government give free houses to the people of Turkmenistan ?? Do you know there is no homeless in Turkmenistan but you can see lots of homeless on the streets of western countries !!!! Do you know a pint of beer coats 2 pence in Turkmenistan but you have to pay £6:50 !!! and also you heard Gaz, water, electricity are free in Turkmenistan but in your countries , in the winter the people sleep under 5 duvets because they can't afford to pay their utility bills.
yeah I guess so, but they're quite keen on keeping as good of a global standing as possible, so I'm assuming part of the reasoning behind everyone speaking fairly good English is because 'they' think that if they're able to speak to the worlds biggest geopolitical players in English, that'll help ease any sanctions/bad feelings directed towards them due to how poorly they're treating their populous. again, it's just a hunch & not really based on any hard facts. as hard facts about this country are much like the case with the DPRK; nigh impossible to actually obtain any facts about what they're like and, at the very best, you're going to get incredibly shaky and unreliable intel about the ongoings in-country. (at least at the time it's gotten slightly better information wise with the death of Niyazov but really, not all that much better if at all really. still not liked by the rest of the world and they're still stupidly insanely secretive! perfectly unbalanced: as all modern era dictatorships should be!!!
@@unfortunately_fortunate2000 free housing, free education, free electricity, free water, gasoline at 2 cents a liter and you think they are treating their population poorly?
i actually find turkmenistan to be a pretty nice country, they have some strange rules, but the people there genuinely seem happy. this compared to north korea is a dream land.
Did you see the rural areas? They look boned out. I think the country had a budget crisis and food shortages as well. I don’t know why the narrator tried to soften the country’s image at the end, but it is a horrible place to live. Probably only seeing a small percentage of well off urbanites. North Korea isn’t exactly setting the bar very high either
@@jonathansoko5368 no man I am from there, happiness comes from Turkmen culture, while government comes from Soviet Union, still ex KGB mentality, people always find a way to laugh and crack a joke
That female guide at the museum/ art gallery was really pretty. And for all the criticisms levelled against Turkmenbashi we must also credit him for keeping out radical Islam and keeping alive Turkmen culture.
@@sbm1994 No... because the more repressive you are, the more counter-reaction you will get. For example, Ataturk did good, but he failed to provide an alternative interpretation of Islam... thus he was viewed as unIslamic. Instead of repressing, Muslim governments should provide an alternative interpretation to radical Islam. As to your second question, I am sorry I cannot answer as I am not a Tajik.
This is proving to be one of the most refreshing pieces of journalism that I've watched in a while (all the best programs and docs are either disturbing or enraging. Ideally both 😐). What a bonkers country - I'd read a bit, but clearly I'd missed out on the best parts 🍻
It's a beautiful country. Was proudly the Turkmen SSR within the USSR. Those who love laid back places and good, unspoilt nature may consider going to Turkmenistan 🇹🇲
That was a glowing report. I imagine the president watching this with his translator and I think he would be pleased. Especially considering you took the time to read his book and show the country in a positive way.
If I had known Waldemar Januszczak was the host of this episode, I would have clicked on it instantly. Please don't hide him, as he is what makes any program, with him in it, the BEST!
Kim Jong Un: makes executions, treats himself as a god , places his pictures in mostly everywhere in the north korea, makes his evil rules. Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow: * takes notes *
I don’t know, this place seems like one of the more benign dictatorships I’ve heard of. If you live in the more developed parts of Turkmenistan it seems like you could live pretty happily as long as you don’t disagree with the government publicly or take part in any protests. Living out in the middle of nowhere however, that sounds like it would be very boring. Plus I’d also wager that the standards of living are a lot poorer there, but that’s part of life for nomadic folk. I’d be interested to know about the standards of health care in Turkmenistan.
How the heck does one just switch rooms in a Turkmen hotel without the staff knowing? And, if they *_DO_* know, doesn’t that kind of defeat the whole purpose of fooling the government officials? Plus, wouldn’t the staff get kind of suspicious as to why they are switching rooms so often? 🤔
He probably went into each of his friends’ rooms to record each night as he’s assuming that each bugged room has a different person listening on the other end. The thinking is that he’s tricking each one in to thinking he’s having a one off general conversation or even talking to himself so that they don’t think he’s a journalist. If he recorded every night in the same bugged room by talking about how ludicrous the dictator is, they’d figure out pretty quickly he’s a journalist.
@@markham5800 this was years before clinton destroyed the country and the entire fallout that came afterwards. before that most people (in usa atleast) were completely oblivious to his rule.
@florian eimer realy ? where did you hear about this ? From the american propaganda ? It is that enough for you? Go to ask African people , they will tell you the truth .
The documentary fails to mention, President Saparmurat Niyazov passed away in 2006, having lived only 66 years. Then arrived President Gurbanguly who ruled till 2022 and now his son, Serdar Berdimuhamedow is President, the 3rd leader of this nation since 1991. It could be that TRACKS purchased this documentary from someone else. No one was uploading such videos on UA-cam in 2006 as far as I know.
This was wonderful! As stated in the majority of the comments, everything's relative. The people in this honest film,don't give me the impression they're unhappy. Especially the absence of rubbish plays a huge role and respect seems to have real value here. Furthermore it occurred to me that quite a few people speak English over there, which i find rather odd for such a distant place. Definitely not the image they try to portray. A bit wacky? Sure, but isn't Vegas or New York or Paris, London etc not wacky either? I mean, come on, who are we westerners to decide what's weird? Thanks for posting this eye-opening documentary 😉
I have just watched some U tubers filming quite openly there . They didnt go into the history of the country . They did visit Merv ( probably the wrong spelling ) ,as well as a very empty capital . Few cars and people eventually meeting and joining in with a wedding party . The children they met spoke a little English as the were taught it at school . Its interesting to see both videos as they had great fun there
Looks like he invested heavily into the countries infrastructure with a very artistic style.... blend of old world with new world. Architecture like this is rarely replicated in the west. It's what's possible when corporations don't invade a country and steal their resources.
At least the dictator is spending money on people.I did not see homeless people on roadside, drunk lying outside the pubs,or intravnous drug users as we see in America.The roads were more cleaner than we see in New York city.
I’m from Turkmenistan. I agree the country’s pretty bad compared to most of Europe, but it’s nothing like North Korea. Statistics say that no one their owns a phone, but my Grandma, Aunt, Aunt’s husband, Uncle, and Uncle’s wife all own a telephone. The building there are much prettier then the ones in Europe. What is more beautiful a giant stick (Ifel tower) or a cathedral made of marble. Freedom is limited though. The people are really nice, they don;t shoot up schools every month like American’s.
Yeah i totally agree, its not a paradise and its not like Europe in some things, but it has much better things and much nicer people than the west. But Turkmenistan's image has been ruinned by western media and propaganda
18:09 the black caviar in the video is 'imitation' made of fish-meat. The description is in Russian. So 25 pounds for those jars is not cheap - they sold you 'phoney' caviar, not comparable to the offering at Selfridges.
This country's ideals make me smile. They're unorthodox sure, but they're doing something right. Live and let live. This country is harmless and beautiful.
when does this documentary take place? There are others that are very recent showing the capital looking very different. Trying to get some bearing on when this documentary was filmed.
It looks beautiful to me. The host was condescending in my opinion. The leader and his self-obsession is not a reflection of the history, rich culture or the people of a nation. (Turkmenbashi looked like Wayne Newton on that bottle🤣)
yes thank you!! I really dislike this western (specifically native english speaker) 'ohh look at my extremely risky trip into the land of these primitive people' style of reporting
Why would you travel all the way to another country just to make fun of it? I have been to Turkmenistan and it was a great experience. The people are very hospitable, welcoming and very kind. Of course freedom is limited in Turkmenistan, but their culture is ancient and very interesting and they have a lot to offer a tourist. Once you get use to the way things work in Turkmenistan, there are a lot of fun things to do in that country. I really like the marble buildings, they are more beautiful than any building I have seen in the UK and even all of Europe. This video is totally one sided and not fair to the people of Turkmenistan.
Free Turkmenistan! Who cares? Politicians all over the world are totally nuts and much worse!! The answer to a lot of questions lies in the heart of the people you met traveling. Once I leave here, I would like to go to lots of countries ending with ...stan. Take care..
Saparmurat Niyasov died in 2006. The current president & "Turkmenbashi" is Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow. I have a feeling, in this video the two of them get mixed up. Or was this video made before 2006?
@@everettduncan7543 it was made in early 2006 have a look at the Reading football shirt with Little on the back start by checking when he played for Reading.............. Reading shirt is at 26minutes 50 seconds
The guy driving claims there are eight different types of desert in Turkmenistan. But it all looks the same to me. It´s a very long drive, which give me plenty of time to attack the Ruhnama. Beautiful lines.
I came here because I was tootling around Turkmenistan on Google maps, which doesn't have street view but has a some photos. I was surprised at how modern a lot of it was. I "landed" in front of a cafe and the signage was in English. Probably because of English-speaking businesspeople. The inside was very welcoming. I think that was in Mary. All the restos I saw were impressive, and the carpets are crazy! But I was surprised this didn't mention what I saw most commented on: you hardly see anyone on the street. One reason given was actually a result of the free fuel: people keep their ovens on all the time to conserve matches needed to light the ovens. So when fuel is free, matches become scarce?! I guess every home had to have someone there to tend to it. Really strange! BTW I also read that some of the free stuff had been discontinued with the new president.
As a Muslim even I think it still feels wrong to call Turkmenistan an Islamic country, but I can see that the leader takes some fundementals from the Quran and the prophet's sayings, later puts them in his own book, albeit in a very absurd way. As Bill Wurtz would say: "We could make a religion out of this!"
Not a bad video. Not a fan of the (typically) condescending British commentary though. Thank God everyone thinks I'm from somewhere else when I'm abroad 🤣
I’ve actually wanted to visit this place for awhile. I ride horses and they are known for their Akhal Teke horses, so I’ve wanted to do a horse trekking trip through here.
@@ajack1312 not entirely true. There are a few companies that have government approval for horse trekking tours! A friend of mine went a few years ago and had a blast.
@@ajack1312 In most cases, that would probably be true. However, there are always exceptions; like, how a group of motorists from New Zealand managed to make a motorcycle-tour across the Korean Peninsula, from Mount Paektu to Jeollanam-do, at the tip of South Korea, across from the Jeju Island.
Very good doc. It’s important to understand that people can be happy in other forms of regimes apart from democracy. We may disagree with his ways, but it truly seems that he is not punishing his people even halfway as what the US (long-term imprisonment for the smallest of reasons) or China, nor spending huge budgets on Iraq intervention such as UK. Ideal rule is what we imagine. Also, don’t expect much from the dictator, he is a politician afterall. P.S. Maybe if he had walked those stairs as well, he wouldn’t have died from heart attack
Okay this country is half the size of Los Angeles county. It's a bit easier to manage than a free country of 340,000,000 people, that the world's economy depends on. It all looks great until you refuse to read the book, to get a drivers license. In a huge country like America... you have all religions, all races, all sexualities, etc.... it's a completely different thing, altogether.
Ehhh still, I feel like in the Western world we take rights such as Freedom of Speech for granted. They don’t have that over there because they’re not aloud to talk about their leader disparagingly. I find it hard to believe the same people who say “oh no don’t judge another person’s lifestyle” would be ok with not being able to critique Trump or Clinton or whoever you put as the U.S. or any other countries’ president.
I met an actual Turkmen guy who got himself into Europe. He says the place is pretty much like North Korea, and it hasn't improved with the new president.
I guess to appreciate the beauty of living in such a place one has to spend some time there with no right to leave, just reading Ruhnama, cheering and glorifying the leader and generally speaking just doing as told..... than.... you will no longer think this place is jolly and charming
This is the kind of nonsense I was told from childhood about Soviet Russia - in truth many dissidents were asked to leave and did so. A number of people I met waited years to get permission to go to the US, (worried about a political risk by doing so), and a number I met returned as they preferred life in the Soviet Union, what with excellent education, safe society, proud stoicism and a deep humour. I'm not supporting that regime, but let's put it into perspective... and when people rant about the poverty of Russians it was often true, but then consider what had happened to their country in WW2 - it was crushed, wrecked, from end to end, then wracked by sanctions, so that whatever system had come about post war would not have been a bed of roses.
@@Oberkommando even so, I'm having a hard time to find any optimism of living in such a place. Evolution seem to have had much fun in creating this region of no opportunity
@@washubrain well, would you rather live in a country where a dozen groups of armed and ruthless men try to get into power and hold it for longer than a year, meanwhile the Chinese and US exploit all your resources and get richer than anyone while you are left in a war torn dump struggling to afford food? Turkmenistan is not a good place, sure, but the post-soviet dictators at least keep the never ending civil wars out. Heck Iraq was not a great place if you were against the gov under Saddam, Lybia wasn't heaven either if you spoke up against Ghadaffi - but both Iraqis and Lybians now mourn their once hated dictators as they now have to walk to school among mine fields.
We should all be aware that it is definitely my actions and yours that contribute to the economic growth and economic excellence of Turkmenistan....So develop and prosper your country
29:30 the elephant story was told by Mowlana, Iranian poet, about 800 years ago. I know the poetry in Farsi (Persian) by heart. Mowlana says, as humans, our perception of the truth is like touching different parts of an elephant. Apparently even his book is fake.
Westerners always criticise other country’s cause it’s foreign to them the people there seem more happier and more humble then any western country I think there leader has done well and it looks like a beautiful country
In the UK one can get plenty of souvenirs with a picture of HM The Queen, there are loads of homeless people, police with no numbers on their uniforms who smash in doors illegally (and nothing happens to them), the UK armed forces use torture chambers in other EU countries to work on unconvicted, untried people, social services circumvent the court system to adopt children away from parents with no trial, nor proof of abuse, yet the children are never returned (they tried this on some families with dual nationalities, the children were soon returned when their embassies kicked up a fuss, but British people have no such protection!) - yet nothing happens even after corruption and power abuse is published even on the front of national newspapers - and ALL our electronic comms are spied on by GCHQ. Are you *seriously* trying to put down Turkmenistan by comparison when a hotel is bugged in the most rudimentary fashion, 80s Soviet style? Wake up mate...!
The current president is similar to the one in this video. For a new country it will be difficult to stay peaceful unless you have a dictator as a leader. He is working for his people for example building TAPI which is a gas pipeline that will take Turkmen gas an export it to Afghanistan, Pakistan and India. A new rail line connects it to the Afghan province of Faryab which can then be connected to South Asia. He wont be in power forever, but at least he is working on big projects that will generate billions for his country.
34:00 The earthquake some of his family died in was a 7.3 on the Richter Scale, not a 10. The highest recorded was a 9.5. There is not a fault known on the planet long enough to cause a 10 magnitude quake on the Richter Scale.
I'm from the UK,4yrs ago I worked in Ashgabat for 3 months, no need to go into much detail I will keep it simple,it's just like North Korea but in central Asia, the place is absolutely bonkers.
Ironic that he's pointing out the president is on the banknotes and on everything, when he is British... does he not realize Q Elizabeth is on everything in his country too?
My dad traveled to Ashgabat as a guest of the leader & his hotel room was bugged, camera’s memory card removed by secret service, and calls listened to.
Im American, but Akhal-Teke horses are the love of my life and I'd put up with just about anything to live in the royal stable. If anyone knows the president, let him know! Lol
Hopefully then you now know that this country never had democracy, it went from being part of the USSR to being ruled by Turkmenbashi and then when he died the new guy is just as bad
Very Nice and well done I'm a big fan of Turkmanbashy 😂 gonna look for his book I have a good idea what the content will be Qadafi has a similar book 😂
Besides some odd infrastructure and a city in the middle of no where, the people seemed happy. And for an impromptu non state visit that would be pretty hard to fake so it can’t be that bad
Isolated and cut off countries have a habit of building hotels for literally no one.
Barry Baz
No.
@Barry Baz BS, it's hard as hell to get a visa even if you are a citizen of a bordering country. And even if you do have a visa, they have a habit for arbitrary border closures for no apparent reason every so often.
Marko Zlotov $200 a day isn’t too bad. It’s a once in a lifetime experience. And $1500 for a trippy week in some obscure dictatorship plus plane tickets is alright. My last trip in the US, I spent more a day on hotel, Uber rides and drinks and tickets to things to see.
@@sloppynyuszi I don't know how you are travelling but you have to know that if you change money on the black market rate in Turkmenistan you get 16 TMT for 1 USD instead of the official 4 TMT which makes everything hilariously cheap. For 4 days there I've spend ~100 USD including hotel, a trip to the Gate to Hell in Darvaza by Bus and Jeep and a train ride to the Uzbek border while dining in restaurants every evening. The flight was 40 USD Berlin - Moscow (Aeroflot) and 120 USD Moscow - Istanbul - Ashgabat (Turkish Airlines). I returned by land (train where possible) back to Germany throw UZ, TJ, KG, KZ and RU. Also, I've spent ~1500 USD for a 4 weeks trip throw USA and Canada in 2018 including flights from Germany so it also depends on the travel style I guess.
@@zlot555 it used to be even cheaper for locals as they had government subsided shops where they had limited choice of goods, yet everything was outlandishly cheap. Like a kilo of flour would cost something less than 10cents. Now these shops have constant shortages and market prices are out of reach for many people.
im surprised he didnt change the flag to his face...
Lmao
:DDD
A narcissist I supposed. Only a dictator would understand his mindset.
I lived there for 2 years for work in Balkanabat from 2009 to 2011. Interesting country. Nice people, troubled government.
Jack de Gier I bet the rooms are nice there
The women are quite attractive
Got the opportunity of flirting with women?
metfan099 I knew a girl in school who was Turkmen. She was very pretty.
@@daniellopez9622 i talked to one online, they are both beautiful amd great women
He was replaced by his dentist , because he thought his son is not good enough.
I thought that was good thinking on his part.
Barry Baz
I’ve got some real bad teeth ,
Mycel
No ! I was generous with the nicotine rather.
He did not even get nepotism right...
@@itmkoeln
Well ,apparently his relatives were all idiots, so no need of any of that
the dentist believed to be his son too
This must be from 2006. The football shirt he is wearing is the Reading shirt from 2006-07 campaign, and Niyazov died in december 2006, which means it has to be from fall 2006.
Indeed, today the nation has a new Great Leader, a former dentist now playing dictator.
Revolutionary Socialist Media
Yeah, that just another oblivious zionist puppet.
of course it is because he doesn't mention the president's death, which was in 2006
@@awesome220the last few seconds of the program mention that he died a few months after filming
@@NG-cf7zh and it took a while after that for the English speaking world to confirm whether or not it was a hoax right when this first came out.
They look happier and healthier than the people in North Korea.
I have to say the Turkman women are beautiful.
They probably are healthier, but they are just as oppressed
Not sure if y'all heard that part about free water, almost free utility bill and super cheap gas..
They may not make much money or get to play loud music in their car or getto go to ballet..
But I'd sacrifice that as long as my basic necessities are met and live in a community of relative equality...
USA has a huge income disparity gap and sadly the majority of the super wealthy realize money doesn't buy happiness... Only content to a certain extent
they look happier and healthier than the people in America
North Korea doesn't set the bar very high.
I went to Turkmenistan for a vacation back in 2018, & none of the Niazov-era restrictions mentioned in this video still existed. It's undoubtedly still an authoritarian state, but there are no real restrictions on tourists.
Of course the Niyazov era restrictions didn't exist since his sucessor Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow erase the restrictions (although it's still authoritarian) , this happened after 2006, the year when Niyazov died and I think this was recorded 2006 or before that.
Can u permanently live there if ur a US citizen
bs go say somethings againts berdimuhhamdow you will end up in jail for ever
@@bijikurdistan6962 nope they will send you to turkey
I smell a filthy rat
He's got every reason to smile - he owns the country.🤔
And before he became a dictator he was a dentist, so he has to show off those pearly whites.😆
@@AviationNut No. This is Turkmenbashi. Not the current president.
He died in 2006…
Lukashenko: 🤭🤭
@@tomaszzalewski4541 Lukashenko: Why can't I do this in my country?
5:33 I feel kind of bad for the soldier, who almost dropped his weapon, was filmed doing so, and even unknowingly showed his face to the camera 😨.
Who knows its a part of intentional comedy! ;)
@Nick 111 Could be 😆.
Rest in F, the SKS, dropped by some guard who just tripped lol
@@bmhater1283 The Guard: 💀
me: "mom, I want DPRK!"
mom: "we have DPRK at home"
dprk at home:
FRIENDLY JAPANESE BUSINESSMAN a joke about North Korea. The kid wants an item they have at home (North Korea) but the mom says they already have it at home. At home they have a different but usually worse version of the product, in this case (Turkmenistan.) That being said and despite the monarchy in place the people of this country seem very happy and healthy. Unlike DPRK or North Korea the people actually seem well fed and the normal citizens actually seem content.*
every time I read "DPRK" without fail, I *always read it as "koreurrrrr" in the voice of the North Korean that's giving commentary over state propaganda from Shane's guide to North Korea documentary!*
no idea why that's what has stuck with me the most from that documentary, but it is, and I'll forever hear "koreurrrrr" in my head each and every. single. time..
lmfao
@Alex Hendel Same here 😆.
Should be the other way around lol.
I really wish the filmmaker had blurred out the faces of some of the people showing him around. I'm sure it didn't go well for them when this came out.
Agreed.👍
My thoughts exactly
@ETOPS Proof?
@ETOPS You probably should research the meaning of the word "definitely". It does not mean what you think it means.
yea
North Korea's stoner brother.
Were you aware marijuana is legal in North Korea?
*Gay brother
@@topixfromthetropix1674 how progressive, medical marijuana for north Koreans. By the way meth is legal there too
Did you know , the government give free houses to the people of Turkmenistan ??
Do you know there is no homeless in Turkmenistan but you can see lots of homeless on the streets of western countries !!!!
Do you know a pint of beer coats 2 pence in Turkmenistan but you have to pay £6:50 !!! and also you heard Gaz, water, electricity are free in Turkmenistan but in your countries , in the winter the people sleep under 5 duvets because they can't afford to pay their utility bills.
Alec cayebi turkmenistan is honestly a good county, besides a few strange things.
Fascinating. I found it odd that so many people speak English.
Benefits of a free education system
yeah I guess so, but they're quite keen on keeping as good of a global standing as possible, so I'm assuming part of the reasoning behind everyone speaking fairly good English is because 'they' think that if they're able to speak to the worlds biggest geopolitical players in English, that'll help ease any sanctions/bad feelings directed towards them due to how poorly they're treating their populous.
again, it's just a hunch & not really based on any hard facts. as hard facts about this country are much like the case with the DPRK; nigh impossible to actually obtain any facts about what they're like and, at the very best, you're going to get incredibly shaky and unreliable intel about the ongoings in-country.
(at least at the time it's gotten slightly better information wise with the death of Niyazov but really, not all that much better if at all really. still not liked by the rest of the world and they're still stupidly insanely secretive! perfectly unbalanced: as all modern era dictatorships should be!!!
@@unfortunately_fortunate2000 free housing, free education, free electricity, free water, gasoline at 2 cents a liter and you think they are treating their population poorly?
One in millions
Only in a capitol. No Russian or English in rural area.
i actually find turkmenistan to be a pretty nice country, they have some strange rules, but the people there genuinely seem happy. this compared to north korea is a dream land.
You are only looking at the capitol. Can you imagine the rural aread
Did you see the rural areas? They look boned out. I think the country had a budget crisis and food shortages as well. I don’t know why the narrator tried to soften the country’s image at the end, but it is a horrible place to live. Probably only seeing a small percentage of well off urbanites. North Korea isn’t exactly setting the bar very high either
They seem happy because these are literally actors on place. Notice there's zero citizens anywhere they are at????
@@jonathansoko5368 no man I am from there, happiness comes from Turkmen culture, while government comes from Soviet Union, still ex KGB mentality, people always find a way to laugh and crack a joke
I felt the same. Im happy to see there’s no genocide. Jus strict.
Since 2006, Turkmenistan is ruled by The Dentist.
Revolutionary Socialist Media what do you mean?
@@Oikofugix IT IS LITERALLY RULED BY FORMER DENTIST
John Oliver did a programme (Last Week Tonight) on this ex-Dentist a few years back. What do you think of Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow?
Free electricity, water, petrol 2 cents, now that's what a dictator should be like.
Viktor Yep!
This is very fascinating. This is a country that you don’t often hear about, and it’s nice to learn about it.
That female guide at the museum/ art gallery was really pretty. And for all the criticisms levelled against Turkmenbashi we must also credit him for keeping out radical Islam and keeping alive Turkmen culture.
None of the central Asian countries other than Tajikistan have radical islam
@@sbm1994 No... because the more repressive you are, the more counter-reaction you will get. For example, Ataturk did good, but he failed to provide an alternative interpretation of Islam... thus he was viewed as unIslamic. Instead of repressing, Muslim governments should provide an alternative interpretation to radical Islam. As to your second question, I am sorry I cannot answer as I am not a Tajik.
Drinking game: Take a shot everytime he says Turkmenbashi
I am now dead
Liver failure
"The one thing he doesnt like is foreign journalist that record his country without telling, thats exactly what we are going to do."
*T H U G L I F E* 🚬😎
This is proving to be one of the most refreshing pieces of journalism that I've watched in a while (all the best programs and docs are either disturbing or enraging. Ideally both 😐).
What a bonkers country - I'd read a bit, but clearly I'd missed out on the best parts 🍻
Stag Weekend in Turkmenistan?
Man, I like him. I don’t know why but I do. I want to go to TURKMENISTAN 🇹🇲
I can feel the embarrassment of the soldier who dropped the riffle
My thoughts, exactly.
Drew Binsky visited recently and it is still same
the guy loves him self
Both.
Isnt that what everyone says to do now adays? Love yourself? Lol
llewellyn williams so what? As if you don't love yourself?
MOST dictators tend to be narcissists! 🤣
@@mrconfusion87 which dictator wouldn't be a narcissist?
It's a beautiful country. Was proudly the Turkmen SSR within the USSR. Those who love laid back places and good, unspoilt nature may consider going to Turkmenistan 🇹🇲
what was the song that was playing in this documentary??
@@mdisteakjami7159 at what time stamp exactly, please?
That was a glowing report. I imagine the president watching this with his translator and I think he would be pleased. Especially considering you took the time to read his book and show the country in a positive way.
If I had known Waldemar Januszczak was the host of this episode, I would have clicked on it instantly. Please don't hide him, as he is what makes any program, with him in it, the BEST!
So well said.Same thing happened to me
It would be helpful to put in the description the date of this documentary. 2006, btw.
Turkmenistan seems like a decent country but I can say surely they have even better people
oh well according to 8:41 Brazil has been denied the chance to read the great words of Ruhnama
denmark too :D
Lucky lucky...
34ey5 drift im from denmark
Bizarrice...mas a cidade de ashgabat eh demais
Chile too
Kim Jong Un: makes executions, treats himself as a god , places his pictures in mostly everywhere in the north korea, makes his evil rules.
Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow: * takes notes *
@@rft9776 He will eventually! 🤣
I would love to get the English edition of Turkmenbashi's book for my personal political library.
It's on Amazon I'm pretty sure
I don’t know, this place seems like one of the more benign dictatorships I’ve heard of. If you live in the more developed parts of Turkmenistan it seems like you could live pretty happily as long as you don’t disagree with the government publicly or take part in any protests. Living out in the middle of nowhere however, that sounds like it would be very boring. Plus I’d also wager that the standards of living are a lot poorer there, but that’s part of life for nomadic folk. I’d be interested to know about the standards of health care in Turkmenistan.
Well, still not the level of Belarus
How the heck does one just switch rooms in a Turkmen hotel without the staff knowing? And, if they *_DO_* know, doesn’t that kind of defeat the whole purpose of fooling the government officials? Plus, wouldn’t the staff get kind of suspicious as to why they are switching rooms so often? 🤔
Simo Heinonen Exactly what I wondered too, and if every room is bugged then what difference does it make...
@@fromspace7 they probably did nothing, they said it to make a bigger suspension
@Adrijus Rimavicius That would honestly make more sense.
He probably went into each of his friends’ rooms to record each night as he’s assuming that each bugged room has a different person listening on the other end. The thinking is that he’s tricking each one in to thinking he’s having a one off general conversation or even talking to himself so that they don’t think he’s a journalist. If he recorded every night in the same bugged room by talking about how ludicrous the dictator is, they’d figure out pretty quickly he’s a journalist.
@@MultiLiam24 Yeah, probably 🤔.
Try to learn more about Muammar Gaddafi , he was not a dictator at all
I agree. Kind of odd for the host of this show to completely discredit himself with an odd comment like that at the beginning of the documentary.
@@markham5800 this was years before clinton destroyed the country and the entire fallout that came afterwards. before that most people (in usa atleast) were completely oblivious to his rule.
@florian eimer realy ? where did you hear about this ? From the american propaganda ? It is that enough for you?
Go to ask African people , they will tell you the truth .
Advice to travelers: Do not go around the world with preconceived notions. Be open-minded and learn to appreciate other cultures.
If I were to go to North Korea per se, I'd have the preconceived notion that at any time I might somehow end up in a concentration camp there.
The documentary fails to mention, President Saparmurat Niyazov passed away in 2006, having lived only 66 years. Then arrived President Gurbanguly who ruled till 2022 and now his son, Serdar Berdimuhamedow is President, the 3rd leader of this nation since 1991. It could be that TRACKS purchased this documentary from someone else. No one was uploading such videos on UA-cam in 2006 as far as I know.
This was wonderful! As stated in the majority of the comments, everything's relative. The people in this honest film,don't give me the impression they're unhappy. Especially the absence of rubbish plays a huge role and respect seems to have real value here. Furthermore it occurred to me that quite a few people speak English over there, which i find rather odd for such a distant place. Definitely not the image they try to portray. A bit wacky? Sure, but isn't Vegas or New York or Paris, London etc not wacky either? I mean, come on, who are we westerners to decide what's weird? Thanks for posting this eye-opening documentary 😉
I have just watched some U tubers filming quite openly there . They didnt go into the history of the country .
They did visit Merv ( probably the wrong spelling ) ,as well as a very empty capital . Few cars and people eventually meeting and joining in with a wedding party . The children they met spoke a little English as the were taught it at school . Its interesting to see both videos as they had great fun there
Looks like he invested heavily into the countries infrastructure with a very artistic style.... blend of old world with new world. Architecture like this is rarely replicated in the west. It's what's possible when corporations don't invade a country and steal their resources.
He's got free energy structures old and new.
At least the dictator is spending money on people.I did not see homeless people on roadside, drunk lying outside the pubs,or intravnous drug users as we see in America.The roads were more cleaner than we see in New York city.
i have this weird fascination with the country and I would love to see an updated documentary about how it is today with Arkadag
I’m from Turkmenistan. I agree the country’s pretty bad compared to most of Europe, but it’s nothing like North Korea. Statistics say that no one their owns a phone, but my Grandma, Aunt, Aunt’s husband, Uncle, and Uncle’s wife all own a telephone. The building there are much prettier then the ones in Europe. What is more beautiful a giant stick (Ifel tower) or a cathedral made of marble. Freedom is limited though. The people are really nice, they don;t shoot up schools every month like American’s.
Yeah i totally agree, its not a paradise and its not like Europe in some things, but it has much better things and much nicer people than the west. But Turkmenistan's image has been ruinned by western media and propaganda
where do you live now?
@Dias06 it happens too often 💯
Turkmenistan is hell on earth ✅
Bro UA-cam allowed?
This was informative, insightful and funny. Not often I see a great documentary that also makes me laugh.
18:09 the black caviar in the video is 'imitation' made of fish-meat. The description is in Russian. So 25 pounds for those jars is not cheap - they sold you 'phoney' caviar, not comparable to the offering at Selfridges.
So Turkmenistan litterly rick rolled this guy.
@@lifeenjoyereyren You mean trolled?
@@radimgabaj4263 Yeah. I meant to say trolled.
But you aren't allowed to bring them into the Uk for quarantine reasons or Turkmenistan won't let you take them?
The only thing that I agree on turkmenbashi with is banning circuses.
Clowns are getting a lot of bashing .
@@SI-ln6tc bruh lol
I'm here for more John Oliver's cake
This country's ideals make me smile. They're unorthodox sure, but they're doing something right. Live and let live. This country is harmless and beautiful.
The upbeat music at the end when it said he died caught me off guard 💀
Have seen this doc for 3 times just to have fun 👍🏻
Looks like a beautiful place. I would like to know more about the food culture.
when does this documentary take place? There are others that are very recent showing the capital looking very different. Trying to get some bearing on when this documentary was filmed.
I never knew we had another North Korea
It looks beautiful to me. The host was condescending in my opinion. The leader and his self-obsession is not a reflection of the history, rich culture or the people of a nation. (Turkmenbashi looked like Wayne Newton on that bottle🤣)
Yes, but he opened up in the latter bit
But dictators deserve condescension by the A-380 load. What else do they deserve, apart from overthrowing?
yes thank you!! I really dislike this western (specifically native english speaker) 'ohh look at my extremely risky trip into the land of these primitive people' style of reporting
Michael Jones Thats why I said it was how he “came across”. I could’ve misinterpreted, I admit that but to me he had an attitude about him.
Why would you travel all the way to another country just to make fun of it? I have been to Turkmenistan and it was a great experience. The people are very hospitable, welcoming and very kind. Of course freedom is limited in Turkmenistan, but their culture is ancient and very interesting and they have a lot to offer a tourist. Once you get use to the way things work in Turkmenistan, there are a lot of fun things to do in that country. I really like the marble buildings, they are more beautiful than any building I have seen in the UK and even all of Europe. This video is totally one sided and not fair to the people of Turkmenistan.
Free Turkmenistan! Who cares? Politicians all over the world are totally nuts and much worse!! The answer to a lot of questions lies in the heart of the people you met traveling. Once I leave here, I would like to go to lots of countries ending with ...stan. Take care..
It's not making fun of the people. It's making fun of the government and president.
*10 manat have been deposited in your shill account
Saparmurat Niyasov died in 2006. The current president & "Turkmenbashi" is Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedow. I have a feeling, in this video the two of them get mixed up. Or was this video made before 2006?
Peter Müller yh it was made in like the 90s, because all the hotels are luxurious in turkmenistan
@@lipton5428 but he mentioned a note from 2003, and the launching of the Ruhnama
@@everettduncan7543 it was made in early 2006 have a look at the Reading football shirt with Little on the back start by checking when he played for Reading.............. Reading shirt is at 26minutes 50 seconds
@@meichong8278 ok thank you
Made in 2006 end of the film says that niyazov died shortly after filming
Selamu Alekum
From a irapi Turkmen
Hi friend, what is the name of the song 18:40
@@Lubsana86 ua-cam.com/video/1_S-PPYnvbE/v-deo.html
Sorry i didn't have see your message
@@menturkmenem9595 do you live in Turkmenistan?
Ailekum Salaam from Scotland.
Don't mind as long as they're happy, cost of energy almost free, and they got bunch of beauties...
The guy driving claims there are eight different types of desert in Turkmenistan.
But it all looks the same to me.
It´s a very long drive, which give me plenty of time to attack the Ruhnama.
Beautiful lines.
I highly enjoy the way you guys film docs.
I came here because I was tootling around Turkmenistan on Google maps, which doesn't have street view but has a some photos. I was surprised at how modern a lot of it was. I "landed" in front of a cafe and the signage was in English. Probably because of English-speaking businesspeople. The inside was very welcoming. I think that was in Mary. All the restos I saw were impressive, and the carpets are crazy! But I was surprised this didn't mention what I saw most commented on: you hardly see anyone on the street. One reason given was actually a result of the free fuel: people keep their ovens on all the time to conserve matches needed to light the ovens. So when fuel is free, matches become scarce?! I guess every home had to have someone there to tend to it. Really strange! BTW I also read that some of the free stuff had been discontinued with the new president.
Strange Country.Strange vedio.
I heard it’s too hot to be outside until nightfall then everyone comes out.
As a Muslim even I think it still feels wrong to call Turkmenistan an Islamic country, but I can see that the leader takes some fundementals from the Quran and the prophet's sayings, later puts them in his own book, albeit in a very absurd way.
As Bill Wurtz would say: "We could make a religion out of this!"
Does it make you angry how he basically blasphemies your religion worse than anyone else?
Thank you for this fine work!
The women look genuinely relaxed and happy (with a relaxed attitude to the arbitrary make-up ban i see)
Its Turkmen culture, default mode is optimism howver government is still former Soviet Union remnants hence dictatorship
I stopped there when going to India the airport was gold
Not a bad video. Not a fan of the (typically) condescending British commentary though. Thank God everyone thinks I'm from somewhere else when I'm abroad 🤣
I agree. A decnt video, butvthe typical british is classic British leftism. Go to a coubtrybthey don't like and shout about it. Weird
@@garrybarry2268 "British Leftism" LMAO
@@garrybarry2268 I didn't see a problem at all. I mean it's meant to be semi comical/doco as well.
@@garrybarry2268 who weirdo
This video resetting my thoughts
I think 🇹🇲 is better then 🇰🇵
Thanks 🙏
I call it NoKor-lite!
Would rather go here than NK.
What is the song starting at 36:06? Thank you!
I’ve actually wanted to visit this place for awhile. I ride horses and they are known for their Akhal Teke horses, so I’ve wanted to do a horse trekking trip through here.
Good luck, you can't even enter the country unless you're on a government ran tour that doesn't include horses and only includes the main city.
@@ajack1312 not entirely true. There are a few companies that have government approval for horse trekking tours! A friend of mine went a few years ago and had a blast.
@@ajack1312 In most cases, that would probably be true. However, there are always exceptions; like, how a group of motorists from New Zealand managed to make a motorcycle-tour across the Korean Peninsula, from Mount Paektu to Jeollanam-do, at the tip of South Korea, across from the Jeju Island.
Very good doc. It’s important to understand that people can be happy in other forms of regimes apart from democracy. We may disagree with his ways, but it truly seems that he is not punishing his people even halfway as what the US (long-term imprisonment for the smallest of reasons) or China, nor spending huge budgets on Iraq intervention such as UK. Ideal rule is what we imagine. Also, don’t expect much from the dictator, he is a politician afterall.
P.S. Maybe if he had walked those stairs as well, he wouldn’t have died from heart attack
Okay this country is half the size of Los Angeles county. It's a bit easier to manage than a free country of 340,000,000 people, that the world's economy depends on. It all looks great until you refuse to read the book, to get a drivers license.
In a huge country like America... you have all religions, all races, all sexualities, etc.... it's a completely different thing, altogether.
@Joe Hamilton ...You are correct, I should have said population instead of size. And its interesting the things you point out... I cant disagree.
Ehhh still, I feel like in the Western world we take rights such as Freedom of Speech for granted. They don’t have that over there because they’re not aloud to talk about their leader disparagingly. I find it hard to believe the same people who say “oh no don’t judge another person’s lifestyle” would be ok with not being able to critique Trump or Clinton or whoever you put as the U.S. or any other countries’ president.
I met an actual Turkmen guy who got himself into Europe. He says the place is pretty much like North Korea, and it hasn't improved with the new president.
@@Tuppoo94
Why
"now, I'm not the kind of guy to break the law!"
(insert Lenny face here)
Great video, had me transfixed from beginning till end, very interesting.
I guess to appreciate the beauty of living in such a place one has to spend some time there with no right to leave, just reading Ruhnama, cheering and glorifying the leader and generally speaking just doing as told..... than.... you will no longer think this place is jolly and charming
This is the kind of nonsense I was told from childhood about Soviet Russia - in truth many dissidents were asked to leave and did so. A number of people I met waited years to get permission to go to the US, (worried about a political risk by doing so), and a number I met returned as they preferred life in the Soviet Union, what with excellent education, safe society, proud stoicism and a deep humour. I'm not supporting that regime, but let's put it into perspective... and when people rant about the poverty of Russians it was often true, but then consider what had happened to their country in WW2 - it was crushed, wrecked, from end to end, then wracked by sanctions, so that whatever system had come about post war would not have been a bed of roses.
@@Oberkommando even so, I'm having a hard time to find any optimism of living in such a place. Evolution seem to have had much fun in creating this region of no opportunity
@@washubrain well, would you rather live in a country where a dozen groups of armed and ruthless men try to get into power and hold it for longer than a year, meanwhile the Chinese and US exploit all your resources and get richer than anyone while you are left in a war torn dump struggling to afford food?
Turkmenistan is not a good place, sure, but the post-soviet dictators at least keep the never ending civil wars out.
Heck Iraq was not a great place if you were against the gov under Saddam, Lybia wasn't heaven either if you spoke up against Ghadaffi - but both Iraqis and Lybians now mourn their once hated dictators as they now have to walk to school among mine fields.
@@washubrain
It's a rich country
@@slayedclaw317 not the riches reach common folk
We should all be aware that it is definitely my actions and yours that contribute to the economic growth and economic excellence of Turkmenistan....So develop and prosper your country
29:30 the elephant story was told by Mowlana, Iranian poet, about 800 years ago. I know the poetry in Farsi (Persian) by heart. Mowlana says, as humans, our perception of the truth is like touching different parts of an elephant. Apparently even his book is fake.
Copyright
Not really fake; just copied.
Westerners always criticise other country’s cause it’s foreign to them the people there seem more happier and more humble then any western country I think there leader has done well and it looks like a beautiful country
In the UK one can get plenty of souvenirs with a picture of HM The Queen, there are loads of homeless people, police with no numbers on their uniforms who smash in doors illegally (and nothing happens to them), the UK armed forces use torture chambers in other EU countries to work on unconvicted, untried people, social services circumvent the court system to adopt children away from parents with no trial, nor proof of abuse, yet the children are never returned (they tried this on some families with dual nationalities, the children were soon returned when their embassies kicked up a fuss, but British people have no such protection!) - yet nothing happens even after corruption and power abuse is published even on the front of national newspapers - and ALL our electronic comms are spied on by GCHQ. Are you *seriously* trying to put down Turkmenistan by comparison when a hotel is bugged in the most rudimentary fashion, 80s Soviet style? Wake up mate...!
The current president is similar to the one in this video. For a new country it will be difficult to stay peaceful unless you have a dictator as a leader. He is working for his people for example building TAPI which is a gas pipeline that will take Turkmen gas an export it to Afghanistan, Pakistan and India. A new rail line connects it to the Afghan province of Faryab which can then be connected to South Asia. He wont be in power forever, but at least he is working on big projects that will generate billions for his country.
They are smaller brother of us in Azerbaijan. I believe they will do a lot better in the future
Maybe you should focus on stopping the war crimes that your soldiers keep committing
@@g10z31 cry
@G10 Z what war? Azerbaican is a peaceful country that never invades anyone
@@GhostOfAMachine Azerbaijan has liberated its own Internationally recognized homeland. End of story
It never ceases to amaze me the crazy things man will do to stay in power!
Best documentary hands down 🙌 this needs more views
34:00 The earthquake some of his family died in was a 7.3 on the Richter Scale, not a 10. The highest recorded was a 9.5. There is not a fault known on the planet long enough to cause a 10 magnitude quake on the Richter Scale.
Amazing documentary and commentary
Beautiful people, beautiful country.
I'm from the UK,4yrs ago I worked in Ashgabat for 3 months, no need to go into much detail I will keep it simple,it's just like North Korea but in central Asia, the place is absolutely bonkers.
The son of the dentist didn't change anything?
Ironic that he's pointing out the president is on the banknotes and on everything, when he is British... does he not realize Q Elizabeth is on everything in his country too?
to be fair the queen doesnt have that much power.
Right??? And they'd only had one president so who else would be on it?
Not really. She's only on the coins and notes. There aren't pictures of her anywhere else.
@@flashmanfred Pretty sure she's still on the stamps too
My dad traveled to Ashgabat as a guest of the leader & his hotel room was bugged, camera’s memory card removed by secret service, and calls listened to.
Your country doesnt monitor your calls or internet activities? ....
Very obscure country. Not Much Info on this County
"County" or "Country"?
Your sound guy is called Mic?
Well, Turkmen women are beautiful. Surprisingly Beautiful !!!
That's so male gaze. Sigh.
Im American, but Akhal-Teke horses are the love of my life and I'd put up with just about anything to live in the royal stable. If anyone knows the president, let him know! Lol
Notice how they keep nervously glancing at the camera
9:01
16:12
19:54
20:31
22:16
33:33
i know... it kinda makes me worried for what theyre doing. They've probably figured them out but i hope not
22:16 is not worried they're smiling
Good Informative Video.. Thank You 👍😍
Anyone else here from John Oliver ?
Yess
Hopefully then you now know that this country never had democracy, it went from being part of the USSR to being ruled by Turkmenbashi and then when he died the new guy is just as bad
The edict not to go to war or partner with anyone wanting to go to war is a very strong statement.
Very Nice and well done I'm a big fan of Turkmanbashy 😂 gonna look for his book I have a good idea what the content will be Qadafi has a similar book 😂
I love this video, dude cracks me up
When you want to make a documentary about Nort Korea but youre actually too scared to go to NK
You are killing me ,man ,with that photo of the president ,every 5 min....😁
Imagine living in this countries and seeing this face 24/7
Besides some odd infrastructure and a city in the middle of no where, the people seemed happy. And for an impromptu non state visit that would be pretty hard to fake so it can’t be that bad