Similar Bengali Songs in Bollywood

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024
  • This Episode is about the Bengali songs used in Bollywood
    I do not own any of the footage I use for my videos. They are just fan-made and solely for the purpose of entertainment, they don't belong to me.All the Songs or the Clips belong to their rightfull owners Like T-Series,Tips,HMV,SVF,Shemaroo,Venus,Captain ETC
    Like Me on Face Book
    / theshortfilmdirector
    Instagram
    / palatteradhyankidharhai
    Best Camera for making You tube best quality Videos
    Canon Camera EOS 1200 D 18MP Digital SLR Camera. (Affiliated)
    amzn.to/2kcLx5E

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @ardhendubose2520
    @ardhendubose2520 5 років тому +282

    Those who know both the languages will understand that Bengali versions are more philosophical and cerebral and sweetly musical while Hindi versions are more lively and peppy. It is truly amazing to savour the taste of both the versions in their own distinct grandeurs.

    • @AmitPrabhu2000
      @AmitPrabhu2000 3 роки тому +27

      I am a Konkani working in North Bengal. I have picked up Bengali quite a bit. Yes they have deeper meaning in Bengali.
      My favourite being "Chirodini tumi je amaar juge juge ami tomari". Also love "Amaar Shopno Tumi"
      Heard this song first time in Durga Pooja Orchestra.

    • @sarthak.roy013
      @sarthak.roy013 3 роки тому +12

      The simple reason is bollywood was and still is mainly a business! Bengali film atleast 30 years ago was not made to just 'Sell"

    • @nibeditaroy2876
      @nibeditaroy2876 3 роки тому +1

      Bangalider mach r macher ghilu kheya ja matha seta onno to pawa mushkil tobae Netaji Shubhash bose,Rabindra nath tagore,bankim chandra,raja ram mohan roy aro na jani koto unlimited nam ache,hoto na,banglar jol r mateer aladai kotha,saurabh ganguli,mithunda koto koto nam

    • @nibeditaroy2876
      @nibeditaroy2876 3 роки тому +1

      Banglar literature atulonio

    • @TheSomnathchatterjee
      @TheSomnathchatterjee 3 роки тому +1

      Thik tai aliro kotha sune bokul hase... line tar kono tulonai nei

  • @umeshdixit2085
    @umeshdixit2085 Рік тому +16

    Bengali music is heart of Indian movie music.Musical masteros S.D.Burmanji, Salildadaji,Hemantdada And Panchamdada's contribution is memorable ,alongwith ,evergreen Kishoredadas vocal and Golden Melodies are excellent examples of Bengal glory

  • @madanmohanmandal2329
    @madanmohanmandal2329 4 роки тому +15

    There are a lot of other super duper hit Bengali songs which have Hindi versions also. Like --
    1) Bengali: Ei path jodi na sesh hoy (এই পথ যদি না শেষ হয়) ( Hemanta Mukhopadhyay & Sandhya Mukhopadhyay)
    Hindi: Ek baar zara fir kehe do ( Hemanta Mukhopadhyay & Lata Mangeshkar)
    2) Bengali : Aamay proshno kore Neel dhrubatara ( আমায় প্রশ্ন করে নীল ধ্রুবতারা ) ( Hemanta Mukhopadhyay)
    Hindi : Kahin door jab din dhal jaaye ( Mukesh)
    3) Bengali : Ja re, ja re ure ja re pakhi ( যা রে, যা রে উড়ে যা রে পাখি) ( Lata Mangeshkar)
    Hindi : Ja re, ja re ur ja re panchhi ( Lata Mangeshkar)
    4) Bengali : Prem ek baari esechhilo nirabe ( প্রেম একবারই এসেছিল নীরবে) ( Lata Mangeshkar)
    Hindi : Aaj rona pada to samjhe ( Kishore Kumar)
    5) Bengali : Ke jas re bhati gang baiya ( কে যাস রে ভাটি গাঙ বাইয়া) ( S D Burman)
    Hindi : Sun re pawan, pawan purabaiyaa ( Lata Mangeshkar)
    6) Bangali : Banshi shune aar kaaj nai ) ( বাঁশি শুনে আর কাজ নাই) ( S D Burman)
    Hindi: Neend churaye chain churaye ( Lata Mangeshkar)
    7) Bengali : E ki holo, keno holo ( এ কী হল, কেন হল) ( Kishore Kumar)
    Hindi : Ye kya hua, kaise hua ( Kishore Kumar)
    8) Bengali : Dhitang Dhitang bole , ke madole taan tole ( ধিতাং ধিতাং বোলে, কে মাদলে তান তোলে) ( Hemanta Mukhopadhyay)
    Hindi : Dhitang Dhitang bole, dil tere liye dole ( Lata Mangeshkar)
    8) Bengali : Tumi je amar ( তুমি যে আমার) ( Geeta Dutt)
    Hindi : Chale hum kahan ( Geeta Dutt & Hemanta Mukhopadhyay)
    9) Bengali: Shing nei tobu naam tar Singha ( শিং নেই তবু নাম তার সিংহ) ( Kishore Kumar)
    Hindi: Khul sim sim khullam khulla ( Kishore Kumar)
    And many other songs ........

    • @noyonsinha758
      @noyonsinha758 4 місяці тому

      Jodi hoi chorkanta oi sarir bhaje and tere gale ko chumo sona rode megher and sona kore jhilmil like is on the list

  • @joydutta5351
    @joydutta5351 3 роки тому +180

    How could we miss Shreya Ghoshal??? She is the best... What a magical voice she has.

  • @अगदीमनातलं
    @अगदीमनातलं 4 роки тому +34

    Wow bengali classic sounds soulful.. I am not even bengali.. Still loved it!😊

  • @RajChakrabortyVoice
    @RajChakrabortyVoice 7 років тому +186

    Bangla Amar Gorbo...Bangla amr Sob.. Proud to be a Bengali.. awesome work Brother

    • @pronaybarua1996
      @pronaybarua1996 5 років тому +3

      Ami o gorbito bangali .r kothatei ache AJ Bangla jeta vabe varot seta Kal vabbe

    • @123lightmovies
      @123lightmovies 5 років тому +1

      dhur copy baaz raj chakraborty

    • @abhisheksamanta4499
      @abhisheksamanta4499 5 років тому +1

      Vai stti gaye kata diye othe purano sorry evergreen gan gulo sunte

  • @rajanbhatia8156
    @rajanbhatia8156 5 років тому +909

    Salute to Bengal and Bengalis

  • @sayantanroy6560
    @sayantanroy6560 5 років тому +291

    Manna Dey
    Hemant Kumar
    SD Burman
    Salil Chowdhury
    All are Bengali too.

  • @ialisufyan
    @ialisufyan 3 роки тому +78

    Thank you Bengali brothers for giving us beautiful song's

  • @nabishadrishyaan3998
    @nabishadrishyaan3998 3 роки тому +37

    Proud bengali. These all songs, singers and music directors r legendary. ❤️❤️
    Great work.

  • @samreensindhi4591
    @samreensindhi4591 7 років тому +201

    Kishore daa is ever green singer. Hats off for him.

  • @SrimanDeadpool
    @SrimanDeadpool 7 років тому +140

    great
    proud to be Bengali
    great video

  • @shounakdas4654
    @shounakdas4654 7 років тому +437

    Hemanta Mukherjee's voice is just pure gold..

  • @HMRANA-ei9vv
    @HMRANA-ei9vv 4 роки тому +87

    আমি নিজেকে নিয়ে গর্ববোধ করি কারণ আমি একজন বাঙালি

  • @techgautam422
    @techgautam422 3 роки тому +10

    Here I would like to mention that, almost all bengali songs of great composer & poet Salil Chowdhury have been re sung in hindi, tamil, telegu, malayalam etc.

  • @ramjoshi137
    @ramjoshi137 5 років тому +183

    Bengal always has ruled over the music industry all over the world. Great. I am very proud of My favourite music director Panchamda. My God.

    • @nabinroy2051
      @nabinroy2051 4 роки тому +4

      He's from our state, our pride.. Tripura Shree R.D. Sir..

    • @shrikantpawar6832
      @shrikantpawar6832 4 роки тому +11

      Bengal was always ruled in literature also

    • @ramjoshi137
      @ramjoshi137 4 роки тому +2

      @@shrikantpawar6832 true

    • @ramjoshi137
      @ramjoshi137 4 роки тому +6

      MARATHI IS ALWAYS SUPERB AND EXCELLENT

    • @ramjoshi137
      @ramjoshi137 4 роки тому +3

      @@shrikantpawar6832 OUR MARATHI IS ALWAYS SUPREME

  • @sylvesteramaldrozario5650
    @sylvesteramaldrozario5650 5 років тому +15

    Great effort !! There are so many more of them. Missed out an all time classic...Jete jete pothe holo deri by R.D. Burman, which is in hindi...Tere bina Zindegi se koi shikwa to nahi !

  • @ankanmondal989
    @ankanmondal989 7 років тому +370

    Manna Dey was Also a Bengali Singar

    • @voiceofreason3101
      @voiceofreason3101 5 років тому +11

      shreya ghosal?

    • @doyelburman7699
      @doyelburman7699 5 років тому +10

      Shreya ghosal too

    • @chandanlahiri7648
      @chandanlahiri7648 5 років тому +7

      না না, মাফ চাইতে হবে না। একটু ভালো লোকের সাহায্য নিয়ে আরো একটু ভালো research and home work করে এ ধরনের অনুষ্ঠান করলে এর ত্রুটি গুলো ঢাকা পড়ে যায়। সত্যি তো মান্না দে, শ্রেয়া ঘোষাল, এদের নাম বাদ পড়াটা কি মানা যায়? একটু সতর্ক হয়ে মনোযোগী হয়ে আরও ভালো ভাবে এ ধরনের প্রোগ্রাম করুন। অবশ্যই সবার শুভেচ্ছা পাবেন।

    • @kaustubhbasu2839
      @kaustubhbasu2839 5 років тому +2

      The great Hemant Kumar

    • @sanjibmandal5242
      @sanjibmandal5242 5 років тому

      He is a assames

  • @indranilghosh932
    @indranilghosh932 4 роки тому +7

    Great job done!
    I really appreciate...
    *8:32 it's not Palak, it's Pulak!

  • @ItzNico25
    @ItzNico25 3 роки тому +6

    Sahil bhai, there are numerous songs those could be included in this list. Truly music has no boundaries. One of the reasons for popularity of movies, specially hindi, was exceptionally melodious, rethmic tunes, great composer & writers and the great singers like Md Rafi, Lata Mangeshkar, Mukesh, Kishore Kumar , Hemant Kumar , Asha Bhosle etc.Alas! those days are gone. Thanks.

  • @sandiptagain6302
    @sandiptagain6302 7 років тому +495

    Ami Gorbito Ami Bangali!!!! Proud to be Bangali......

    • @asfaquekhalid
      @asfaquekhalid 7 років тому +4

      Amio :)

    • @shadmansaqib9022
      @shadmansaqib9022 7 років тому +2

      +Sandipta Gain, we're proud

    • @snigdhachakraborty2110
      @snigdhachakraborty2110 7 років тому +6

      bangali wala hajar guna behtar lag raha hai.

    • @RajChakrabortyVoice
      @RajChakrabortyVoice 7 років тому +2

      yess proud to be a Bengali

    • @suronjonahoda3524
      @suronjonahoda3524 7 років тому +3

      me too bengali and also proud of Bengali
      আমি গর্ভিত বাংলার উপর এবং আমি তোমাকে ভালোবাসি.......

  • @plt7915
    @plt7915 6 років тому +37

    I'm Still listening Hemanta Mukherjee's songs. Specially his olir o kotha sune bokul dake. Ohhhhhh amazing

  • @susantaghosh8176
    @susantaghosh8176 7 років тому +42

    Bengali musicians and their music always Rocks.long live bengali.ami gorbito Ami bangali.

  • @mariamtee
    @mariamtee 3 роки тому +57

    Even as someone who understands no Bengali, I think the Bengali versions sound much superior

    • @rejoanbary2155
      @rejoanbary2155 3 роки тому +4

      Both are good.

    • @dmartha3850
      @dmartha3850 3 роки тому +3

      @@rejoanbary2155 no only original

    • @sarthak.roy013
      @sarthak.roy013 3 роки тому +5

      I think it is because bengali people created those, one creates his/her best version of work in his/her mother tongue because it comes more naturally, if it were the opposite, the hindi versions would be superior, that being said, bengali's in general were and still are a bit more artistic than the rest of the country!

    • @Imrd123
      @Imrd123 2 роки тому

      🙂🙏

    • @anweshchatterjee7595
      @anweshchatterjee7595 2 роки тому

      Even for me songs often sound better if I don't understand the words. The tune is same though so they should sound very similar even if you don't understand Bengali.

  • @oceanofinformation14
    @oceanofinformation14 Рік тому

    Aha! Olir katha sune ...... unforgettable.This is Hemanta Mukherjee, soft melodious rendering voice

  • @Jawakaithkuna
    @Jawakaithkuna 5 років тому +18

    Filmi dunya ka aur sangeet ka Shuru wat hi bangal se shuru hua,
    KYC dey, Pankaj Mullick,
    Aur bhi nam aapne miss kiya, Anil Biswas singer & composer, Parul Ghosh hes sister, Suman Kalyan puri, Manna dey, Shreya Ghushal....

  • @page21twentyone
    @page21twentyone 5 років тому +9

    I'm one of Bangladeshi fans of ur channel. As a Bengali, feeling proud after watching the vdo,,,,,Tnx a lot,,,,Lots of Love from Bangladesh.🇧🇩

  • @HelenandLolly
    @HelenandLolly 5 років тому +35

    Thank you for this wonderful tribute and recognition to our Bengali talent. I have always appreciated international music. You will probably need to do a part 2 as some big names were left out. Thank you. 🙂

  • @Mogli01
    @Mogli01 4 роки тому +5

    Thank you for the beautiful comparison. Just like to rectify 1 name of the Lyricist of Chirodini is Pulak Bandyopaddhay . (The Pronunciation is Poolock)

  • @IndraKumar-md9ut
    @IndraKumar-md9ut 4 роки тому +6

    Very well researched. I appreciate your hard work, that too not being a Bengali yourself (am I correct, or are you?) Similarly, you can make videos on many Hindi films which were remakes of or based on earlier Bengali ones. I can suggest few examples below (there are many more):
    1) Sagarika 1956 into Prem Patra 1962.
    2) Sabar Upare 1955 into Kala Pani 1958.
    (The leading pair in the above 2 Bengali films were the legendary Uttam Kumar & Suchitra Sen).
    3) Deep Jwele Jai 1959 into Khamoshi 1970.
    4) Uttar Falguni 1963 into Mamta 1966.
    5) Saat Pake Bandha 1963 into Kora Kagaz 1974.
    (The heroin of the above 3 Bengali films was again the legendary Suchitra Sen)
    6) Basu Paribar 1952 into Hum Hindustani 1960.
    7) Kalo Chhaya 1948 into Apradhi Kaun 1957.
    8) Surya Tapa 1965 into Kati Patang 1971.
    9) Nishipadma 1970 into Amar Prem 1972.
    (The hero of the last 2 Bengali films was the legendary Uttam Kumar).
    10) Many films with same title in Bengali and Hindi, the cast and year of making are different, e.g.
    Lal Pathar 1964 and 1971. Saheb Bibi Ghulam 1956 and 1962 etc.
    Plus many others...

    • @sharmichakraborty
      @sharmichakraborty Рік тому +1

      He is certainly not a bengali, evident from his pronunciation

  • @dr.bapanpaul2657
    @dr.bapanpaul2657 7 років тому +143

    I am a Bengali...proud to watch this vedio... but Sir you forgot to mention the legendary singers Hemanta Mukherjee, Manna Dey, Shreya Ghoshal, Monali Thakur.

    • @abhijitkundu1484
      @abhijitkundu1484 5 років тому +8

      Monali Thakur kab se Legendary singer ban gaye vai??

    • @adarshtamang969
      @adarshtamang969 5 років тому +1

      He mentioned Hemanta Mukherjee .

    • @abhijitkundu1484
      @abhijitkundu1484 5 років тому

      @@adarshtamang969 ji, he mentioned Monali Thakur also. He added the name of Monali Thakur with legends list.

    • @adarshtamang969
      @adarshtamang969 5 років тому

      @@abhijitkundu1484 bhai listen he meant legendary Hemanta Mukherjee and manna dey .

    • @adarshtamang969
      @adarshtamang969 5 років тому

      Don't worry bro in later years Monali will become a legendary singer.

  • @Jawakaithkuna
    @Jawakaithkuna 5 років тому +49

    Theres another popular song from the movie KATI PATANG "ye sham Mastani"
    "Akash keno dake"
    Also another song from Sahib bibi aur Ghulam
    "Meri baat rahi mere man mai"
    "Ami dur hote tumare dekhechi"

    • @SaptarshiGupta
      @SaptarshiGupta 4 роки тому +2

      Even " Na Jao Saiyaan chhura ke baiyaan"
      "Aliro katha shune bokul hashe "

    • @abhishekdas8313
      @abhishekdas8313 3 роки тому +2

      Akash keno dake is from Bengali version of Kati Patang right😐

    • @swarnali7635
      @swarnali7635 3 роки тому

      There is also a bengali version of the song 'Na koi umang hai' from Kati Patang..

  • @leohaq360
    @leohaq360 5 років тому +243

    You missed Legendary Manna Dey & Shreya Ghoshal the 'Lata ji of modern era'...

    • @ritushukla9284
      @ritushukla9284 4 роки тому +11

      Haimanti shukla-who sang the song Kahan se aaye badra is also Bengali.... she's melodious of all. Even more melodious than lata ji.

    • @gautambanergee2307
      @gautambanergee2307 4 роки тому +2

      I AGREE WITH YOU

    • @ANACONDA99574
      @ANACONDA99574 4 роки тому +9

      No man , lata ji is lata ji no shreya no xyz can match ever .
      Plz dont take it in a bad way

    • @sanjeebchakraborty1775
      @sanjeebchakraborty1775 4 роки тому

      Wright

    • @bijoytv6569
      @bijoytv6569 4 роки тому +11

      Shreya ghosal is 1st shreya ghosal not second lata ji... I think shreya ghosal is much better than some ways from lata mangeshkar..

  • @shashibhushanroy3615
    @shashibhushanroy3615 Рік тому +1

    ना जेओ ना,रजनी एखोनो बाकी... बोले रात जागा पाखी... ना... के ट्यून को हिन्दी चलचित्र 'परख' में दुहराया था सलिल चौधरी ने ' ओ...सजना, बरखा बहार आई, रस की फुहार लाई, अँखियों में प्यार लाई, ओ....सजना.....

  • @programsolve3053
    @programsolve3053 3 роки тому +1

    Very nice presentation!! I suppose you need another few episodes to cover the topic!! A lot more common and very popular songs are there!! Looking forward towards new episodes!! Thank you very much!!

  • @sibusattwikraha6757
    @sibusattwikraha6757 7 років тому +19

    I am very happy. because no body agree about bengali artists tallent and theirs stand in whole India. pure gold tallent is aslo available till today in Bengal. Thankyou to Palat tera dhyan kidhar hai.

    • @sayantikasanyaldipa5021
      @sayantikasanyaldipa5021 7 років тому +4

      sibusattwik raha 1st & only oscar winner indian director Satyajit Roy
      Bangalies are best forever

  • @shaikhimtiazbrands6164
    @shaikhimtiazbrands6164 5 років тому +176

    west bengal is the land of singers

    • @manasen6
      @manasen6 4 роки тому +17

      বাংলাদেশকে বাদ দিলে হবে না,,,কারণ বেশিভাগ শিল্পীর জন্ম বাংলাদেশে। শচীনদেব বর্মন, রাহুল দেব বর্মন,, লালন শাহ,আব্দুল আব্বাস, হাসন রাজা,রাধারমণ, লিখতে গেলে শেষ হবে না।তাই শুধু পশ্চিমবঙ্গ বলে ভুল করবেন না।

    • @sitaramroy8690
      @sitaramroy8690 4 роки тому +4

      @@manasen6 কিন্তু বেশিরভাগ শিল্পী র জন্ম পশ্চিম বঙ্গে

    • @minaraakhter2383
      @minaraakhter2383 3 роки тому +6

      @@sitaramroy8690 amra kn Bangladesh vs West Bengal suru kori.ami Bangali atai amar gorbo

    • @Abhishekaditya91
      @Abhishekaditya91 3 роки тому +2

      And EAST BENGAL, land of G-haadis.

    • @আমিকিছুকোমুনা
      @আমিকিছুকোমুনা 3 роки тому

      @@manasen6 শচীন দেব আর রাহুল দেব বাদে আর কেউকে বাংলাদেশের বাইরে কেউ চেনেই না ....

  • @debjyotimandal4927
    @debjyotimandal4927 5 років тому +43

    Not Palak it's Pulak Bandyopadhyay. Pulak(ecstasy) derives from Sanskrit and also used in Hindi as in the form Pulakit ( ecstatic ).

  • @sukhendughosh3815
    @sukhendughosh3815 4 роки тому +1

    What an excellent job you are doing. Yours is the first kind of channel dedicated to some serious and informative news related to Indian cinema. All the best and continue to entertain us . Thanks a lot.

  • @anupacharya8731
    @anupacharya8731 Рік тому +1

    Excellent presentation 👏👏👏 Thanks 🎉 Love from Bengal 😊❤

  • @stevenphilip5073
    @stevenphilip5073 5 років тому +20

    You forgot to mention one of the most super duper hit Bengali to Hindi version song "kya yehi pyar hai" by kishore Kumar and lata Mangeshkar from the movie Rockey.

  • @ranusultana5972
    @ranusultana5972 5 років тому +46

    Bengali language is best in worldwide.
    So so sweet voice.

  • @lyfisgud6984
    @lyfisgud6984 4 роки тому +5

    Am lucky to b a bengali... I enjoy both versions of these soulful evergreen songs.... Pure golds!! The song Chirodini tumi je amar z still very popular in bengal...nd frankly it's way better than d hindi version. There r actually many many songs that were composed both in hindi n bengali like
    1. Yeh Nayan Darey Darey's(from Kohra) bengali version is Ei Raat Tomar Amar(from d movie Deep Jeley Jai); both being sung by the legend Hemanta Mukhopadhayay.
    2. Yeh Shaam Mastani's (from Kati Patang) bengali version z Aakash Keno Daakey n both these songs r by the great R.D Burman n sung by another great Kishore Kumar.
    3. Shikwa Koi Tumse's bengali version being Kotha Hoye Chhilo Tobu Kotha Holo Naa. The singer in both the cases being Ashaji.
    There r many more...

  • @anirbanchakraborty9833
    @anirbanchakraborty9833 4 роки тому +10

    Kishore Kumar, S D Burman, Hemant Kumar, Manna Dey, Salil chowdhury, Geeta Dutta, R D Burman, Bappi Lahiri, Swapan Chakraborty, Kumar Sanu, Abhijeet, Babul Supriya, Shaan, Shreya Ghoshal, Arijit Singha, Pritam........... Bengalis are really heart of Bollywood music industry.

  • @santoshkotnis7639
    @santoshkotnis7639 Рік тому +1

    Very good information.
    No boundaries for music lovers.

  • @kalipadajagaddeb3829
    @kalipadajagaddeb3829 5 років тому +18

    3:59, pure pure magic of SD Burman.

  • @maheshkumaar4975
    @maheshkumaar4975 5 років тому +28

    In 70s alone there were about 11 to 12 songs that were earlier hit in Bengali versions- like "meri bhigi bhigi si"
    "tum bin jaun kanha" etc
    In fact bollywood music was very much influenced by Bengali music

  • @royindrajeet75
    @royindrajeet75 5 років тому +85

    I am a Bengali . And proud to have sweetest language of world and I also like to sing

  • @Monikaa_Shill
    @Monikaa_Shill 3 роки тому +50

    Geeta Dutt was born in Madaripur district, Bangladesh
    As a Bangladeshi, proud to have a talent like Geeta ji ❣️🥰.

  • @krishhhavi9438
    @krishhhavi9438 Рік тому

    बहुत बढिया वीडियो है। Very exciting one . All songs are superb both Hindi and bengali. Hoping to see some more videos of this kind. Thank you so much. All the best👍🏻👍🏻

  • @chenuruaparna857
    @chenuruaparna857 5 років тому +4

    Both language songs are awesome
    Old is Gold....🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
    Bengali is world sweetest language ❤
    Bongs are fatafati....nc video....

  • @divineshotru2506
    @divineshotru2506 5 років тому +35

    Hemanta Mukhopadhyay’s one is the best...

  • @mitali7900
    @mitali7900 5 років тому +58

    Manna Dey, hemanta Mukherjee, Shreya Ghoshal, monali thakur, Antara dutta ( gerua) also are bengalis

  • @singeraaryan
    @singeraaryan Рік тому +2

    "Tasveer Teri Dil Mein" both Hindi & Bengali version my most favourite ❤️

  • @boi1859
    @boi1859 4 роки тому +6

    Salil Chowdhury was an underrated legend ...hats off

  • @sudipto1969
    @sudipto1969 5 років тому +7

    I do respect your work as the intention regarding the preparation of each video is to convey due respect & regards to the artists. Request you to make a video on Manna Dey & Mehdi Hassan. Thank you

  • @sumantadas5951
    @sumantadas5951 5 років тому +6

    Bengali culture is a rich culture.Our national anthem 'Jana gana' , was written by Tagore.. National stotra 'Bandemataram', was also written by a Bengali, Bankim Chandra Chatterjee. Swamiji , Netaji, Ramkrishna Paramahans all were born and brought up in Bengal. Nandalal Bose, a bengali artist decorated the main book of Indian Constitution.

  • @Resterinpeace
    @Resterinpeace 7 років тому +57

    only in 90's????...huh!!... they copy now a days even...from Bengali..

  • @pankajconstantine
    @pankajconstantine 4 роки тому +1

    My favorite of all:
    Hindi- Ye Nayan dare dare - by Hemant Da
    Bengali- Ei raat tomar - by Hemant Da
    Inlike the haunting melody of the Bengali version more..

  • @horrorripples3332
    @horrorripples3332 2 роки тому +2

    Heard all of the songs..love the originals ..amazing lyrics amazing singing amazing emotions n the best part is..the voices are so beautiful

  • @rakeshsahoo3705
    @rakeshsahoo3705 6 років тому +5

    Chirodini is one of my favorite song....I really loved it.... it's a heart touching song....

  • @debabrataghosh2676
    @debabrataghosh2676 4 роки тому +6

    old songs are divine, so much peace and tranquility

  • @debabratasarkar4493
    @debabratasarkar4493 6 років тому +41

    We are legend...
    Ami gorbito ami bangali...

  • @nilalohitapanigrahi
    @nilalohitapanigrahi 3 роки тому +1

    One more to add Kahin door jab din dhal jaaye (Hindi) By Mukesh -> Amaye prosno kore neel dhruva tara (Bengali) By Hemant Kumar..

  • @dealingfailure5379
    @dealingfailure5379 2 роки тому +3

    আমি গর্বিত আমি একজন বাঙালি।।।
    I'm proud to be A Indian 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳Bengali....

  • @sarmanram6729
    @sarmanram6729 5 років тому +127

    Bengali industry are most underrated

    • @biswajitsabui9282
      @biswajitsabui9282 3 роки тому +3

      Yes, but mostly every year Bengali film got national award

    • @shikha.dey.2047
      @shikha.dey.2047 3 роки тому +3

      Aplog dekha karo na tabhi toh underrated nahi rahega. Aplog South ki movies dekthe ho jabki Bengali movies nahi dekthe. Dekha jaye toh Bengali is very very similar to Hindi. Lekin aplogo ka kya hai after Hindi only south matters with Hindi dubbing.

    • @bablidasshill6989
      @bablidasshill6989 3 роки тому +1

      Haan isiliye th 50% Hindi serials Bengali serials se inspired hote h 😎😎

    • @PrashantSingh-yp4zd
      @PrashantSingh-yp4zd 3 роки тому

      National awrds are mainly won by bengali film industry

    • @Rmusico933
      @Rmusico933 2 роки тому

      Kon bola underatted...jisko sirf bandhuk or hatiyaro se mar pitna action dekhna hai woh bollyood dekhe....jo content dekhta hai woh south and bengali dekho...

  • @pratapsarkar2296
    @pratapsarkar2296 5 років тому +9

    Bongs are Rock. I'm a 80's kid. so I've got the chance to attatch with all of those epic singers. Proud to be a Bengali & Indian

  • @bonggirlwarriorrightwinger7604
    @bonggirlwarriorrightwinger7604 6 років тому +10

    I love it..
    Being a bengali it's feel awsmm
    From...*nabanita*

  • @hefzurrahman1151
    @hefzurrahman1151 4 роки тому +10

    The best thing about you is your humble attitude and gentle presentation. Best of luck for you.

  • @tapansahoo7233
    @tapansahoo7233 3 роки тому +1

    Proud to be বাঙালি 😇💙Sir add Shreya Ghosal and Monali Thakur...And lots of love for you sir ..keep making video

  • @kaustubhbasu2839
    @kaustubhbasu2839 5 років тому +7

    The Great Hemant Kumar and Manna Dey along with musician great SD Burman and Salil Chowdhury

  • @dvdd1139
    @dvdd1139 5 років тому +24

    Beta tune samundar me haat ,payer,muh dal diya...
    There are unlimited number of hindi songs matched with Bengali original songs.bcoz their creators were Bengali.
    Jai Hind, Jai Bangla.
    Bengali is a complete nation around the world.
    Proud to be a Bengali..

    • @amitsinghi4285
      @amitsinghi4285 Рік тому

      He is being very respectful towards Bengali songs musician and culture. The least you can do is be a little respectful towards him. You definitely are not a true Bengali because they are very humble and respectful towards others. Pehle khud Sonar Bangla ka achcha beta banne ki koshish karo phir kisike ko beta bulana

  • @BikashSardar
    @BikashSardar 5 років тому +10

    Really, I'm feeling proud to be a Bengali and thanks to you sir. 🙏

  • @tapanvlogs9357
    @tapanvlogs9357 Рік тому +2

    I am Bengali,really lucky to enjoy both versions,bengali films are realy world class every Indian must must see.

  • @bipulbikasdas3911
    @bipulbikasdas3911 14 днів тому

    Bengali song 'O nadire ekti khata.....' also used in the Indo-American English film 'Siddhartha'. Which directed by Conrad Rooks and released on 18th July 1973. Another Bengali song 'Pather klanti bhule......' of old bengali film 'Maru tirtha Hinglaj' also used in the film 'Siddhartha'. All the film music by Hemanta Mukhopadhyay.

  • @veeraaa6344
    @veeraaa6344 7 років тому +32

    S.D.burman is Bengal's greatest contributions to music industry.

    • @peachNplum
      @peachNplum 3 роки тому

      Ethnicity of SD is Tripuri from Tripura not W Bengal..

    • @sauravMAitra96
      @sauravMAitra96 3 роки тому +1

      @@peachNplum sd burman was self proclaimed bengali..even married to a bengali..rd burman alwyas claimed himself as a bengalo. also Sachin dev verma used his name as Sachin Dev burman

    • @peachNplum
      @peachNplum 3 роки тому

      @@sauravMAitra96 , both SD and RD are Tripura natives!! Kindly don't change ethnicities to show some demography metrics!! Married to a Bengali does not change the ethnicity for them. Amitabh Bachan married Jays Bhaduri he did not change into Bengali. He is still from UP ethnicity!!

    • @sauravMAitra96
      @sauravMAitra96 3 роки тому +1

      @@peachNplum hello I am not changing anything, I gave you the interview link in my last comment..watch that, R D Burman himself said he is a bengali..and his mothertounge ia bengali , His mother is a bengali..kindly go through the video..

    • @peachNplum
      @peachNplum 3 роки тому

      @@sauravMAitra96 links are not allowed in UA-cam... If RDs ethnicity is w Bengal then a memorial would be constructed there and not in Tripura!!

  • @JasminasVlogs22
    @JasminasVlogs22 7 років тому +8

    I love ur all videos.. Thanks.
    Channel ka tittle music amazing hain

  • @ajitanag1577
    @ajitanag1577 7 років тому +250

    where is shreya ghoshal???!!!

    • @aishikgupta
      @aishikgupta 6 років тому +5

      Ajita Nag lol. missed her. even I was wondering

    • @caadvice4597
      @caadvice4597 5 років тому +1

      @Prashant Mujumdar then kishor from MP khandwa.

    • @caadvice4597
      @caadvice4597 5 років тому +1

      @Prashant Mujumdar Netaji from odisha cuttack.

    • @yashwantdhole7645
      @yashwantdhole7645 5 років тому +3

      With her husband right now.

    • @birendranathdas651
      @birendranathdas651 5 років тому +5

      @Prashant Mujumdar their language /mothertongue is Bangla for that reason they are Bangali/Bengali region doesn’t matter.Regions can't erased the language from heart.Where he live or born it doesn't matter the fact is their language+their voice+their heart is bangla,then he is a bengali

  • @ArtCarnivalWithSubrata
    @ArtCarnivalWithSubrata 4 роки тому +5

    I'm belong to Bengali family
    I feel very proud of that😍😍

  • @indranil1202
    @indranil1202 4 роки тому

    I have become a great fan of yours ...excellent R&D work in all your posts ..KUDOS !!!

  • @soumiklahiri5907
    @soumiklahiri5907 7 років тому +98

    Bollywood never won an Oscar... wer as Bengali film already done it

    • @soumiklahiri5907
      @soumiklahiri5907 7 років тому +10

      Pather pachali

    • @GameandFoodTech
      @GameandFoodTech 7 років тому +5

      Soumik Lahiri Satyajit Ray won Oscar for his Film in International Film festival google it.

    • @i2_04_sworjjomoypathak7
      @i2_04_sworjjomoypathak7 5 років тому +14

      We didnt won one.satyajit Roy got it for lifetime achievement not for pather pachali

    • @curiousaboutanything2454
      @curiousaboutanything2454 4 роки тому +2

      ভুল স্বীকার করে নে।

    • @ankanghosh975
      @ankanghosh975 4 роки тому

      But bollywood entertains people....Bengali art films are just for some people and not interesting

  • @amitmalik2926
    @amitmalik2926 5 років тому +21

    Bengal is the best also director because great Satyajit Roy,Hrittick Ghotok,Mrinal Sen

  • @shuvenus4616
    @shuvenus4616 7 років тому +53

    Also Shreya Ghosal.

  • @VharpEntertainment
    @VharpEntertainment 4 роки тому

    Purani yaaden taza ho gai
    Jb calcutta main they tb kai song sune Or dekhe
    Redio Or doordatshan pr
    Song ke alawa filmen bhi same 2 same
    Bs hero heroine all Artist change
    They

  • @kishwerchaudary1340
    @kishwerchaudary1340 Рік тому

    S.D. Burman_O Re Maajhi Mere Saajan Hain Us Paar (Bandini; Shailendra; 1963), SO BEAUTIFUL, ALSO SONGS OF MOVIE "GUIDE(WAHEEDA REHMAN AND DEV ANAND)

  • @narayanamurtygundala1795
    @narayanamurtygundala1795 7 років тому +9

    Excellent information. Great work

  • @SDHOFSubhamGhosh
    @SDHOFSubhamGhosh 6 років тому +35

    Most hindi songs of Jeet Ganguli are remake of his own bengali songs..including Ashiqui 2 songs

  • @prasenjitsengupta3675
    @prasenjitsengupta3675 6 років тому +8

    Good initiative indeed. Music is in the DNA of the Bengalis.

  • @sahiryogeshgosavi343
    @sahiryogeshgosavi343 4 роки тому

    Sahil bhai .....aapke puraane videos baar baar dekhne par utnaahi aanand dete hai .....palat tera dhyaan kidhar hai jaise segment kaafi kum hai UA-cam par ...hum PTDKH par naye vedios dekhnaa chaahte hai .....krupayaa thoda samay is channel par bhi de....

  • @komolmia6159
    @komolmia6159 3 роки тому +5

    I m from Bangladesh Im proud to be bangali🥰🇧🇩

  • @rc0085
    @rc0085 7 років тому +26

    You forgot the songs from Bengali movie "Anusondhan & hindi movie "Barsat ki ek raat"

  • @Kartikchunara
    @Kartikchunara 7 років тому +16

    West Bengal Ne Ache Ache Music Director Bhi Diye Hain...Jaise Bappi Lahiri,Jeet Ganguly,Pritam Chakroborty Etc....

    • @Kartikchunara
      @Kartikchunara 7 років тому +1

      PALAT TERA DHYAN KIDHAR HAI Yup Bhai :)

    • @gauravdey4163
      @gauravdey4163 6 років тому +1

      Kartik Chunara Khali music director hi Nahi Bollywood Ahada Bengali aur Punjabi se Chalti Hai Nahi To Doob Gayi Hoti music directors writers songwriters film directors technician jitne bhi le le bhai

    • @ynr044930
      @ynr044930 5 років тому +2

      lots of writers scientist models and freedom fighters were also from bengal

  • @nooralimran4643
    @nooralimran4643 5 років тому +9

    What a beautiful compilation of sweet and immortal songs! Love it!!! FYI: Dil mein ho tum aankhon mein tum was sung by South Indian singer S. Janaki.

  • @PremKumar-td9mi
    @PremKumar-td9mi Рік тому +2

    Bengal has given us both The National Anthem and The National Song!It's incredible but true!Proud to have this as my mother tongue ❤
    According to UN,it's the most sweetest language of all over the Globe❤❤❤

  • @AB-mz5yq
    @AB-mz5yq Рік тому

    bhai....jane sae pahele..you are awesome. Thanks for all the effort you put.....

  • @rakeshgamer1227
    @rakeshgamer1227 5 років тому +31

    You forgot Shreya Ghoshal, Hemanta Mukhopadhyay,manna Dey,Shan,bappi Lahiri

  • @ayansengupta1980
    @ayansengupta1980 5 років тому +48

    8:33 not Palak Bandyopadhyay it's Pulak Bandyopadhyay.

    • @deyayona
      @deyayona 4 роки тому

      I was about to comment the same. thanks.
      They missed Babul Supriyo too... who is distantly related to Pulak Bandhopadhyay

    • @cinemacafe2467
      @cinemacafe2467 3 роки тому

      True

  • @rupeshruper1600
    @rupeshruper1600 7 років тому +31

    ah i like this vedio and i am from nepali

  • @Amitabhsworld
    @Amitabhsworld 4 роки тому

    My favorite same tune diff language songs are: 1) tum bin jaun kahan---- ek din pakhi ure by Kishore da 2)chala jata hoon-cholechi eka by Kishore da.3)ye shaam mastani-Akash keno daake - by Kishore da 4)diye jalte hai by Kishore da -deke deke koto by Rd pancham da ---- 5)baat Jo Dil mein chupi hai--tumi aacho eto kaache Tai by Kumar Sanu da.

  • @prasenjitdeyinvincible
    @prasenjitdeyinvincible 3 роки тому +3

    Very sad! How can you miss the legendary singer Manna Dey