Clinique Dramatically Different vs Moisture Surge | Review and Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 чер 2024
- "Which is the best Clinique moisturiser?" is a question I get asked a lot. So today, I decided to put Clinique's 2 best selling moisturisers, the Dramatically Different moisturising lotion+ and the Moisture Surge 72-hour auto-replenishing hydrator to the test to find out which one is truly superior (in my opinion!) by trying them both on different sides of my face for a week and seeing what happens.
As always, this is just my own opinion and experience, so please leave yours in the comments too!
PRODUCTS USED/MENTIONED*:
My top: rstyle.me/+nMD6domUAFQ7ri5r8g...
Clinique Moisture Surge 72-hour auto-replenishing hydrator: rstyle.me/+XRJ0md1-mQiREYiNiJ...
Clinique Dramatically Different Moisturising Lotion (for dry skin): rstyle.me/+OmRiGfdZD_v8MXw73s...
Clinique Dramatically Different Moisturising Gel: rstyle.me/+POen-afX9YAtmNByr8...
Clinique foaming sonic facial soap: rstyle.me/+pyvCp9zF0QIjJe-OnZ...
Alternative sonic brush: rstyle.me/+xVhzMVwVNSeSdvgNLJ...
Clinique clarifying lotion: rstyle.me/+nKzAy76lRj6HylP6-7...
* These are affiliate links, which means that if you shop through these links, I will earn a small percentage of commission, at no extra cost to you. If you do choose to purchase through these links, thank you. You are directly supporting the money and time I put in to creating these videos.
VIDEOS MENTIONED:
Dramatically Different Hydrating Jelly Review: • Clinique Dramatically ...
Dramatically Different BB Gel Review: • Clinique Dramatically ...
Dramatically Different Tone-Up Gel Review: • Clinique Dramatically ...
Clinique Moisture Surge Review: • Clinique Moisture Surg...
WATCH THIS NEXT:
My everyday makeup routine: • my everyday makeup rou...
ASOS Try-On Haul: • ASOS Try-On Haul | Spr...
Chatty GRWM: • my psychic dreams & ot...
Weekly vlog: • Renovations and Roofto...
Trying EVERY Clinique Foundation: • Trying EVERY Clinique ...
Clinique Best & Worst Skincare Products: • Clinique | Best & Wors...
Let's chat on other platforms!
Twitter: / amyastrid
Instagram: / amyastrid
d
Facebook: / amyastrid96
Your skin is gorgeous and you have a really warm, kind energy!
I've used the Dramatically different lotion for like 15 years and it's literally the ONLY moisturizer that doesn't cause any sort of breakouts or flesh bumps or anything. Literally perfect for my normal skin, gives it a glow and I actually feel like it firms my skin.
Try out The ordinary moisturizer.
@@viktorija7512 Why? She just told you that DDML is perfect. After forty years of using it, I have to agree.
Same. I can only use Clinique because it works well and no acne. I put it on after soaking in my warm bath, for best results!
I got a sample of the one on the right & it gave me hives!!!
Same i’ve been using it for years .
Ok this IS THE BEST REVIEW VIDEO FOR THESE PRODUCTS*! Thank you so so much 🌸
Thank you so much! I’m glad you liked it 💗
Hi Amy, I discovered your videos a few days ago and was so pleased to find a fellow Clinique fan! I used to have type 3 skin and used the relevent 3 step set, and found the DDML to be nice but no anti-aging properties which I felt I needed, so began to layer the old green Superdefense over it after a using a couple of bottles of DDML on its own. The combo of 2 creams was great for a couple of years, then my skin suddenly changed just over 5 years ago to very dry, with peeling, cracking eylids and lips in Feb 2015. Switched to Extra Mild soap and 1.0 Clarifying lotion. Past 4-6 weeks I have been trying the hydrating jelly with blue cartridge like you, but find there is not enough moisture; I found I had samples of the Moisture surge and have been layering it over the top for the past 3 days and my skin feels much better. I haven't found a good eye cream for dark circles and fine lines, but I will try your tip for the fine lines! If you ever find a good dark circle eye cream, not one of those ones hide it, I would be so grateful!!! I love your videos, and sorry for the long post :-)
I found your channel a few weeks ago and I’m so happy I did. Clinique is such an underrated brand. I have really bad cystic acne and started using Trentinoin which has dramatically cleared my skin, but it’s left my skin irritated and extremely dry. I have naturally dry skin anyways, I use the dramatically different lotion during the day and moisture surge at night, it has saved my skin I only use Clinique skin care now except for my cleanser I use cerave. Now anytime I try anything different my skin goes nuts and I have to go back to Clinique to repair it. Thank you for actually having Clinique reviews they’ve been so hard to find
Great videos Girl. Love your work. I put the surge over my dramatically different gel. Love them both. Thank you. You look like Cinderella in that gorgeous top 💗
Thank you angel! You’re so right actually about the top hahah it’s very Cinderella-esque 😂🤍
Thanks for the tip for eye cream. I use clinique all about eyes rich and love it. I have combination oily skin and I had the opposite opinions of you. The moisture surge to me was sticky on my skin, where the dramatically different made my skin feel silky. I know I am a few years late to the party lol but I just discovered your channel and have to say, you are so awesome. Thanks for making these videos. ❤️
I had a sample of Moisture Surge in my “unused” makeup drawer. Before putting it on my skin I wanted to make sure I was applying it properly. This video answered all of my questions and more. Thank you for testing the products for a week before giving your final opinion. Very helpful. You and your dress are super cute!
Thank you so much! So glad I could help ❤️ hope you love the Moisture Surge as much as I do
I subscribed only after a minute into your intro. Just because of the sweet vibe and how nicely you formulate your sentences. Underrated!
You gave me a good feeling that your videos will be honest so I'll check some out. 🤗
Just switched to the Moisture Surge today and found this very useful video--wish I'd seen it 3 yrs ago! Very good commentary and honest feedback. Thank you!!
I love both, the Intense one even more ......my two favorites ❤️ must try the tone-up one!
I’ve been using All About Eyes by Clinique for the last month and it made a huge improvement on my eye area. I’m just starting the moisture surge for the rest of my face. Hoping it works just as well!
Clinique is worth every penny I used to use la neige but Clinique has clinical grade products and it makes a huge difference! ❗️💕
Thanks so much Amy for making this decision so much easier for me. I am going with the Moisture Surge 72 hour moisturizer vs the Dramatically Different :) Shout out from Boston, Massachusetts!!!
How did it go? I find it peeling off of my face😂 like literally feel it’s comes off when I touch my face!
Thank you for your support reviewing ❤
Thank you! Very helpful. Also going to try under eyes . Been looking for something to help that!
Thank you for your videos, they are wonderful!!!! I personally love the moisturizing gel because I have mild skin. The moisture surge is wonderful as well, but I personally don’t like using it on my face, it makes it feel a little sticky. I tend to use it on more dryer areas like my elbows or knees.
Thanks for the suggestion. I have a few samples of the moisture surge that made my face sticky but i have EXTREMELY dry elbows so I'm gonna try it on them tonight.
I love your Clinique videos please keep them up
I have very dry skin. Just started using moisture surge. I love it! Super hydrating. Makes the skin better as the day wears on.
I used to use all of Clinique skin care products and I wear makeup daily before the pandemic and got many compliments. Don't know why I stopped and I see the difference. I have more breakouts and eye puffiness and burned my skin with astringent. I going back to my old Clinique routine to repair my skin.
You’re so pretty by the way ! 🤍🤍🤍
Thank you angel 😘
Great video - thanks for sharing,. I used to use Clinique then I changed to a natural skin care brand and it’s totally messed my skin up 😟😟 so I’ve gone back to Clinique - just ordered both as I’ve never tried the dd lotion - always been a fan of the moist surge. To be honest the moisture surge has been the only moisturise that made my skin happy 🤩🤩🤩😍😍
I have to say I have tried both moisturisers and prefer moisture surge as I find my skin just feels soft smooth hydrated and makeup seems to go on much better, and I find the dd moisturiser leaves my skin a little sticky and my skin is on the dry side but tends to look shiny after a few hours but it's not oily or acne prone
I have used the three-step program for forty years. I just switched from the number 2 to the milder number 1 toner as I got older and dryer. It’s not an either/or situation. You always use the three steps. Then the Moisture Surge is simply a supplement to that. When I had samples, I would add it at night after the DDML. Last year I bought the Moisture Surge CC cream to protect my skin during the day and even out my colour.
Clinique product never disappoints me. I have been using since I was in high school.
Great video dear!! Helpful 😘😘
suuuper helpful ,gorgeous!!
Glad I could help! 💕
Thanks for the video. A bit late I just invested in some Clinique goodies today. Super glad I watched this cause I have no clue what I am doing and put on both the DD and the surge tonight 🤣 so this was a very helpful video. Going to try using the surge sample I got till it's finished. Pity I didn't watch this first cuz I bought a big bottle of DD. 🥺
I just stumbled across the moisture surge hydro boost and I am in love too.
I just started using the lotion facial cleanser and clarifying lotion for a month now. Just got the moisturizer surge two days ago. So far I like it
Thanks for this video. It has helped me in making a decision..... going for the moisture surge.
Glad I could help. I hope you love it! 💗
Omggg i really love your accent
I’ve tried the moisturize surge and agree. I love it and I’m 56 years old
I know Im kinda off topic but does anybody know a good place to watch newly released series online ?
@Joaquin Yehuda try FlixZone. You can find it on google :)
Im 52 and really struggling with my skin. Im going to try this hopefully it helps. I’m glad you hear you love it to
Hi, Amy!! I've just discovered your channel. So far I've seen only two videos, nevertheless I liked them 🙂 I'm going to see more!
Just wanted to say that I also use both (but dramatically gel not lotion) and I prefer to use the yellow one at night and the pink one during the day... but... As you conclued, I think I prefer moisture surge. Btw when I used dramatically gel without cartdrige I think it worked better that with one on it.
Greetings from México!!! 😉🙂👐
Ah that’s cool! Thank you for sharing your experiences ☺️
Thanks for your sharing!😍 I already have the moisture surge.. and is considering to buy the dramatically gel since I have oily combination skin.. I will try your way! Using one in the morning and the other at night ❤️
What color was your cartridge? It’s strange that the gel alone performed better...
I had a very dry feel using the gel with the orange cartridge, so I changed to the white one and it has been terrific
Thanks this was a great comparison and review. I have used DDML for close to 30 years but now I'm going to try the MS instead
You can use both, DDML first and MS on top
Hi amy first time to watch ur vlog. Im fr the phils.
Hi Ellen, that’s so cool! Welcome to my channel 🥰
There isn’t bad things about this product. Everything about this product is perfect.
Hey just came across your beautiful channel, loads of love from india😘 can you please let me know, I have combination skin and now in winters I am feeling my cheeks very dry, which one should I go with?
I recently was gifted the dramatically different moisturiser by a friend and I suffer from severe facial allergies to almost anything I put on. Especially around my eyes. and now, I've never had any issues
I used to use Clinique all the time and some how got away from it. Over 50 more and my skin needs help. It’s so dry and redness🙄 going to look at this moisture surge stuff, great video
beautiful make up❤
was thinking of purchasing the Clinique Dramatically Different Moisturising Gel but if it's supposed to make skin 'glowy' it will probably end up looking oily on my Indian brown skin tone..and it's too pricy here in India to risk it,too
I will get the surge for my eyes. Thank you :)
I'm SO glad you made this video! I have dry-combination skin and for a while I was using both. I used the lotion in the morning (along with toner serum essence UV, the works) and I used Moisture Surge at night at the end of my routine (almost like a sleeping mask) and it did wonders. I was also using the Kiehl's eye cream but now I feel like I should have just dabbed a little extra MS instead haha.
Glad you liked the video! Ooh I’ve never tried the Kiehl’s eye cream (or anything from them actually!) is it any good?
@@AmyAstridBeauty They're pretty good! I tried the Midnight Recovery eye cream but honestly it didn't do much for me. Their Vit C serum is effective though. I almost bought the Clinique Repairwear Laser eye cream but I wasn't sure if it's any good. Have you tried it?
Kuro Neko I like the sounds of the serum! No, I’ve never tried anything from the repairwear range actually
Should i buy dramaticly gel as i have oily skin?is it good ?plz rep
My skin loooooooves Moisture Surge 72 hour. DDML kept me away from Clinique for years because I used my sister's and it made my face break out (when I was a pimply teenager). I like a light/gel textured non greasy moisturizer. I can hear my skin SLURP UP the Moisture Surge 72 hour.
I have both the dramatically different lotion and moisture surge products.
Can it be used together? Or best to use one at night and the other at day?
Im really not sure on how to get the best results using both
I like Clinique a lot. Used it for years and then recently got "bored" and tried a new routine. My face was not happy..irritation, burning, etc. Went back to Clnique and satisfied again. Haven't had a single pimple in 15+ years.
This is probably a stupid question but how often do you use the moisture surge moisturizer? It says it last 72 hrs, do you still use it daily or less often?
No such thing as a stupid question! I still apply daily 💗
Do you have videos on Roscea?? I have it and I am 67. I use the Climate products. I use the. Leander for my face and the green cover-up before you put makeup on. I have trouble with my makeup not going on smooth its like it rolls up in little beads even though I have used moisture surge for my face. Any thoughts??
I have dry skin and the Moisture surge gel was not so nice to use. I tried it ,but don't like the tacky feeling on my skin. I like the DDML much more and it absorbes much better in to my skin.
Sane here, except I have combination oily skin.
Love your videos. you look like a fairy in this video!
Well that’s my favourite compliment ever 😂 thank you! Glad you like the videos x
Amy Astrid what I really like about your videos is you show the product and application on your skin!
Now that I have bought both mosturiser lotion Id and mosturiser surge and eye cream. Pls tell me when to apply as I have dusky and dry skin.
Pls which of the Clinique product can I use for my body
Hi, thanks for your reviews. I typically use the dramatically different lotion. I have tried moisture surge as well, but I find that it doesn't hydrate enough for me, or it doesn't lock in moisture or something, because it's water based as opposed to oil based? I have dry combination skin (I use type 2 toner). I have also tried the new jelly, as it says is for all skin types, I find that it's also not hydrating enough.
I think the jelly could be good for the summer or oiliy skin, I like the gel
@@florgutierrez1469 same
Yes I want to know about it
So the dramatically different lotion and gel is actually meant to be used as a base to prep your skin for extra moisture. So therefore is to be used first and after your favorite moisturizer!
Oh, that’s interesting! I was always told when I worked at Clinique that it is the 3rd and final step in your skincare routine.
I use both at same time I use for long time I like use both at same time
Thank you 😊
Sales person told me to use both at the same time! Do I?
* hears the accent * I’m staying
I could listen to her all day! Robert and James welsh too, all their voice are very soothing and make the videos a bit better 😁
@@lauraspangler5179 Cus they’re British?!
How so you use the 72 hr with the hydrating lotion and the supercharged concentrate? What order...2 of them say in instructions to use on clean skin so which first? Thank you
I wouldn't use the Moisture Surge and the Dramatically Different lotion at the same time. I think I'm right in saying that the supercharged concentrate should go first because it targets the deeper layers of your skin and then I'd choose one of the moisturisers to go on top as the last step :)
THANKYOU
The moisture surge 72 hrs,I bought ,I used on dry skin not wet,is this ok?also Is it a moisteriser to use alone or should I use a moisteriser on top?thankyou
Banana yes that’s fine! I put it on dry skin too. And it’s a moisturiser x
@@AmyAstridBeauty great thanks for prompt answer! I've only started today, but am surprised how nice and moisterisering this feels.im very sensitive skin prone to reddness and breakouts on cheeks (think roscea ) I was told not to use oily cream and find cheaper brands aggravate my sk7n,I've tried lrp ,cerave, avene. None suitable. I'm hoping this is a winner. So far so good ,and I tried the nutragena hydra boast fragrancefree moisteriser. It felt thicker going on ,but very soon after I felt like all the water was sucker from my skin and red cheeks. It has beeswax and sodium hydroxide which don't and gree with my skin. Lately I have found any moisturiser burns a little after I cleanse, I think my skin more sensitive these days, but even though it happened with this to,it settled quite quickly. I usually know if stinging persists,that something dosent suit me
What do you mean when you say plumb ? Underneath my eyes I have bags underneath my eyes which honestly I hate. Tbh I just bought the Clinique clarifying lotion 2 ( which was burning my eyes when I was applying it on my face :( ) and bought the dramatically different moisturizer however am not satisfied with the products :(
Plump.
I like dramatically than surge.
Is the clinique moisture surge good for teenagers? Around 15 years old like that
In my opinion, yes! I’ve used it since I was a teenager. It’s great because it’s lightweight and oil-free but still super hydrating so great for teenage skin.
Who would leave a moisturizer on for three days solid though? Ive got the DDML at the moment, thinking of the Jelly next, but not too sure
I never wash off my moisturiser so me I suppose 😂
My skin is combination to dry which one I can use?
you are so beautiful maigaaaaatt
Great review! Thank you so much) I'm looking for a lightweight moisturiser right now as can't get my staple superdrug moisturiser due to lockdown (their simply pure serum), thinking of ordering Clinique moisture surge online, although it's pricier but seems like it fits the bill and I don't know what else to get 🙈
Thank you! I’m glad it was helpful. Ah that’s so frustrating. I’m guessing you’re not able to get the Superdrug one online? I definitely would recommend trying the moisture surge if you can ☺️
@@AmyAstridBeauty yes the superdrug one is out of stock online and in my local store( I still can't decide between the moisture surge and dramatically different to be fair 😅 I just need the light texture and good hydration)))
How can I get a better skin ? With clinique products
A lot is genetic
I definitely agree when you said the Moisture Surge "feels like you're touching your skin and not product". It also left my combo oily (very prone to blackheads naturally + whiteheads from heavy product) with a VERY 'dewy' appearance that eventually mattified. But when you're used to having shine control issues, dewy ain't the look you want 😂.
The DD Gel is my ROCK though. On days when my skin is irritated, red, had enough of the salicylic acid etc. the DD Gel always makes my skin feel moisturized and 'calm'.
Hello maybe you can help me im 62 years old in I have this few wringkel in my face. What moisturizer I can use to my face plz help me my name Angela thank you
PLEASE HELP
I really wanna know what is the difference between the packaging green and pink one in Clinique moisturizer. As the details are same mentioned something like 72 hydrator
I’m not sure which one you mean by the green one?
The package colour is green and other is pink
@@iaasthamazumdar what’s the green one called?
i must be the only dude watching this lol
I like it
Which one do you think is better for teenage skin? I’m still deciding which to use because I’m looking for a light moisturiser to use morning and night after my serum
Personally, I preferred the moisture surge for teenage skin. It’s oil-free and super lightweight and leaves your skin feeling bouncy and soft.
Amy Astrid Thank you! Would I be able to use the moisture surge as a moisturiser after the Vichy serum?
น้อง' บีมม'มม I’ve never used the Vichy serum so I’m not sure x
Amy Astrid Thank you so much, have you tried the Kiehls ultra facial cream
I used Clinique moisturiser and made my face BURN
Marie nurse
5:40 is this product good for oily skin and fungal acne?
I have fungal acne on forehead but also dryyyyyyy skin which causes my acne in all other areas of my face... i find this to be one of the few products that help both. Along with their oil cleanser before hand.
Hello thank you for the videos I have both and I have understand that I’m supposed to work both can you please help me my name is Monica
Hi Monica, thanks for your comment. I suppose it’s down to personal preference. When I worked for Clinique I was told that one was enough and I found that in the areas of my face they overlapped, I was very prone to break out so I wouldn’t use them both together personally. But if you’ve found a routine that you like and that works well for your skin then that’s what matters ☺️
Is the surge thicker than the dramatically different
No I’d say it’s a thinner texture actually
My skin is oily to normal can I use it ?
Sounds like we have similar skin! Moisture surge, yes. Dramatically different I’d recommend using the gel instead of the lotion 😊
@@AmyAstridBeauty thanx 💓💓
Clinique moisture surge burn my skin i feel like i have wounds
Moisture surge is awesome
Totally agree with you there!
do u know if it’s good for oily skin?
I could literally see an imaginary line right through middle of your face.
This should’ve bin compared to the gel rather than cream it’s different consistency gel an cream.
Absolutely, the consistency is different! I wanted to compare the ‘original’ of both products which is why I used the dramatically different cream and then the moisture surge gel ☺️
Amy Astrid okay so maybe u can help me. Which is best i have really reactive sensitive skin dehydrated an congested. But oil content tends to irritate me. I’ve tried the cream it has broken me out. So which is best between the ddmg an surge 72 h ? I’ve got texture goin on my skin just bin really irritated lately. Was looking into Biologique brand. But I’m scared. Still doin research on that brand. But i love Clinique bin goin bk to it for years an years. I like their cleanser mild. Have u tried the lotion 1.0 cuz I’ve just went through. Bottle of lotion 2 it was very drying didn’t nothing but irritated me more an lotion 1 is the same. Bin reading up on their acne serum too.
This is what is in DDMG (and DDMG-ID).
"Saccharomyces lysate is a probiotic yeast obtained by fermentation. Its by-products, known as postbiotics, can help normalize skin's microbiome by curbing the proliferation of microorganisms that can trigger signs of impaired skin."
"The antioxidants in laminaria saccharina soothe congested skin by maintaining healthy levels of collagen, fighting against free radicals, and combating the effects of dirty, polluted air found in the cities."
"Polygonum cuspidatum root extract is a plant whose root is a good source of the potent polyphenolic antioxidant trans-resveratrol, which is considered the most bioavailable form of resveratrol."
"What does Lactobacillus ferment do for skin?
"In skin care, lactobacillus helps calm and comfort skin to instantly relieve the dry, tight, bothered sensations that come with irritation. Yes, lactobacillus soothes and balances your skin just like probiotics can do for your stomach. When it comes to upset skin, it's pretty much a lifesaver."
and then they used this complex to comfort the skin, soothe it and balance its' hydration levels.
* Cucumis Sativus (Cucumber) Fruit Extract , Hordeum Vulgare (Barley) Extract\Extrait D'Orge , Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seedcake , Caffeine , Trehalose , Sodium Hyaluronate , Tocopheryl Acetate*
this is why this stinkin ddmg always worked for me cos clinique uses ADVANCED ingredients. let alone, their other more high performance moisturisers (which are even more costly) but quality.
It has cause me allergies 😢😢😢 makes my eyes sore.