NHL 24 Review - The Final Verdict
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 чер 2024
- NHL 24 takes steps to put the intense feel and physicality of ice hockey right into the hands of players. New gameplay systems such as the Exhaust Engine add a fresh tactical dimension to proceedings, and with brutal body checks and skill moves now mappable to the controller’s face buttons taking to the ice in NHL 24 is as exhilarating as ever.
However, there are still certain game modes that demand a refresh at this point, and some of NHL 24’s touted new innovations, such as Vision Passing, aren’t new at all. The jury’s out on whether some of these new systems are even required at all. Still, NHL 24 is a solid entry in EA Sports’ ice hockey franchise, and worth diving in if you haven’t played a recent NHL title. - Ігри
As an annual NHL title player I can tell everyone that if you can wait just 30 days after release. Right around mid to late November every single year the game goes on sale for at least 50% off! Its been that way for the last 3+ years and I expect the same this year. I have waited and have been okay with paying $30-$50 rather than $80+
I'm on the waiting game myself here... but damn its hard. Just want to dive into Franchise Mode. I love that players develop x-factors now
I have been doing the same, you are 100% correct. They do this for Black Friday and Cyber Monday, the offer lasts for like a week.
Thanks for throwing that out there, useful info. That’s what I will do. 👍
better yet... just wait til it comes out on gamepass
For offline players like myself....this game isn't even worth the black Friday purchase...I'm totally skipping this year & if they go another year next year without making any changes to offline modes mainly be a pro I'll be skipping that one as well...I'm no longer supporting this monopoly....either they make changes or I just won't support the game...I'll prolly go buy nhl 2k11 for PC or something idk but this train of supporting non sense stops here
Congratulations to MLB TS ‘23 for standing alone as the only good sports game
Bs that is worse this year nhl actually is fun to play this year
False all sports games suck and are all unplayable scams mlb has fallen off the worst bungie call the shots on ps now
Ufc is a pretty playable game
@@Zbgaming23🤡🤡🤡🤡 bro I played about 1-2 days worth of time on HUT, EASHL, and franchise mode and the only game mode remotely fun is Franchise Mode
Rocket League has entered the chat…
This is not just a reskin , they totally messed up all the fundamentals , stick handling , passing , hitting are all glitchier and more rough around the edges this year , majority of goals scored are ugly broken plays or weak shots dribbling through the goalie
And the pressure system is pretty much the infamous ice tilt on steroid, they are just not hidding it anymore.
Yeah changing the controller buttons was just stupid. Only reason why they did that was in order to make it feel like a new game.
The hits are disgustingly unrealistic. It’s so sad to see them take a step back
@@itsarnoldbruh the hip checks are so overpowered it's a joke
@@Dx-so7jm yea dude forreal
Something happened really bad from PS3 to PS4...the evolution of the games really got sidetracked in 2014...its maddening and sad.
I miss the lobbies in 2014😢
Can’t bring myself to buy any EA games anymore. It’s definitely been a good 5 years. It’s a shame because they used to be mandatory purchases.
So wyd now cause I need my EA & 2k fix im only a Madden gamer frfr but I get all the sports titles from wwe to ufc… if its on sport’s center & comes in a game im getting that shit
😂😂😂😂
We don’t buy from EA sports it’s that simple
I'm glad they added checking over the boards but I hate how they make it seem like a new feature. There constantly putting this stuff in the taking it away the next game. I remember when one of the big selling features was the goalies fighting eachother which was cool, then the next game it was gone, same with checking people into the bench, or through the glass, or breaking the glass etc. They just take it out then a few year's later add it back in like it's a new feature. Just leave all that stuff in already! I really wish other developer's still made sport's game's besides EA. Competition is a good thing but when you are the only one making sport's game's you get too comfortable & lazy like EA!
No mention of how goalies and their new animations are over the top and react badly in situations where it isn't needed. Presentation in general feels the same minus a louder crowd, new announcer, and hearing sandstorm 50+ times a game. Depending on the arena, the light show can be absolutely terrible and can't be modified in any way (Good luck in Edmonton). Intros are the same as last year. HUT is essentially the same in every negative way minus moments which still doesn't help it.
Gameplay can be "good" but if there is no depth, why bother playing? Another 8 out of 10 score review from yet another location where they really don't deep dive into the game. Gotta make EA happy to get them review copies.
This review right here is exactly how you know these reviews are paid for....how would this game be a 8/10 when they literally made no changes to any offline modes they barely made changes to online modes other then taking away hockey bags like be real this game is a 3 at best and ir you & ea actually listened to the community you'd kno we've been asking for changes to be a pro especially for 4 years they didn't even remove the old cutscene's hell that would be a improvement by its self
before said andromeda was good now this game no pc release aged gfx i see frame drop as well a 8 haha im unsubscribing
@gtf2584 right behind you
Heard they're giving us the option to go back to hybrid control buttons in next update
I hope so. I’m just disappointed that they had to make the game easier for people who can’t play. I get making it easier but come on 😂
I dont even care that they changed the hitting system, but you cant do that and take away the controls ive used for 15 years. I cant not know how to hit + constantly be hitting the wrong pass button.
Playable warm ups sounds like a cool idea, but realistically we'd all skip it after the first handful of games
some of us take those moments to eat chips
NHL 24 just doesn't feel good to play imo. Everything feels kinda sloppy. The pressure system is very easy to exploit as well.
What do you mean you don't like the ai making mistakes for you lol. Terrrible idea from the start.
Garbage
It’s been sloppy since 2014. No idea why people keep buying trash
@@Reagles8NHL 14 is arguably one of the best releases in the franchise. God, you’re doing some real hard drugs man... You’re insane to say that lol.
i hate that crap
The pressure meter is ugly and stupid. Who is playing hockey that doesn't know about offensive pressure? or any similar scoring sport. It's something you can feel, it naturally happens. You don't need a meter for it. Is this for people playing for the first time? ugh
I tried the EA trial and I could only stomach about five minutes before I uninstalled the trial from my ps5
Both teams wearing home jerseys in the Ari/Pit gameplay hurts my brain 😅
The pressure system has such potential.
However
the visual effects on the ice take me away
from the realism they have been trying to
achieve for years. The pressure system can
be in effect without the meter being visual
on the ice. It could be added to the boards
Or in my opinion nowhere at all. You will
know you have filled the meter to the max
once you see the defending team struggling
Since the playtest I’ve been saying they have to get rid of the pressure metter on the ice. It’s stupid
have you seen the ESPN hockey broadcasts? they put a floating name above whichever player has the puck in the offensive zone like a video game. its all starting to come full circle
The pressure system needs to be nerfed , if you get a whistle or you clear the zone it should be reset , way too overpowered and does not resemble how pressure works in hockey
@jaken6462 I have. And you are not at all wrong. However, I still would personally like the meter to have a toggle on or off.
@@jaken6462your statement has no value. Espn did that. Okay? And? ESPN did this, that means it’s okay!
Your logic is flawed.
Does anyone know if this game has online Co-op season or franchise mode? none of those one off games
It doesn't....
Franchise mode? did I miss where they talk about it?
Been playing for about a month with pro career. I've come to realize the basics. If the game wants you to lose you will lose. The frequency of goals scored against your team when you aren't even on the ice is ridiculous. If you cause a penalty the other team almost always scores. Your defense often does not engage and allows them to skate right down the middle to the net. Your goalie won't grab a puck sitting right next to him and sometimes doesn't even attempt to move when the other team is shooting and also flails out of positon for the easiet of shots to defend.
Amazing to all of you who buy this every year. It's essentially a $70 patch every year.
It’s not a patch the gameplay actually changed this year it is okay if you hate it but let people be this is a wayy better game
@@Zbgaming23 dude it's a patch, minus updated rosters and the tiniest amount of gameplay changes. The goalie still move twitchy like they have for the last 8 years. When they properly animate the goalies I'll look into buying it again
@@justinbezaire8115that’s how they allow people to score. If the goalie control was operator friendly than people would score half as much at best, and you know what that would result in. No sales.
@dimehighify well...considering alot of people canceled pre orders or like myself not even attempting to buy the game since nothing really changed for offline modes I'm sure sales will be down anyways
@@justinbezaire8115lmfao this game the goalies actually move well 😂
Im not buying it untill the price drop or untill it ends up on gamepass months later. I just dont know
I'll stick with NHL 22. I bought it last year on eBay for $7.85.
i'll stick with NHL Hitz
luckily you also mention the presentation because there is still a lot to be done in the future
The entire idea of zone "pressure" is not real. You can't accumulate "pressure energy" in a game you can only control the puck and tire out the defenders. There is no actual "pressure" force, you either control the puck or you don't.
Just got the $100 dollar version for 30 bucks. First. NHL I’ve gotten since 20. Hopefully it’s good
Same
Unfortunately it is bad
Its atrocious
Hitting sucks. That was the best part of 23. Naturally they take it away.
Just gotta time it right now.
Don’t worry they will put it in nhl 25 as a new updated feature . It’s never a mistake with them it’s all planned
If your on Playstation 5 there is 2 hits 1 is Circle and a crazy kool hit is square so try that.
Horrible game
seriously lol@@tmozzz
Haven't played a hockey game since NHL 97. 93 and 94 were awesome as well.
“World Of Shell” Lol I’m dying
Xfactor edition is down to 30 bucks on psn is it worth buying ???
If you don't have the NHL 23, Yes
The gameplay now, for me, it's ok
I wish you could take off the pressure, it’s so bad! No full presentation and the controls suck
I'm debating between this and 23? Are the controls better in 23?
i wouldn't buy 24@@Guy-mx4fb
23 over 24. @@Guy-mx4fb
The pressure system is a cool addition to the game, but they have completely revamped surrounding mechanics in a not great way. Passes in front of the net are near impossible eliminating the one time opportunities when pressure hasn't built up which makes no sense. If anything a two on one break away or any break away for that matter should be a likely scored goal. Not the case this year, granted there will probably be updates tweaking game mechanics and creating new meta for scoring, but the current state of affairs makes the game play feel scripted and stiff. Computer players are complete mavericks on the ice making passes to ghosts, or leaving position completely opening up chances for breakaways. Hitting has potential to be great when they add patches, but as of now its glitchy at best. It seems that there are three or four major builds people are using to abuse these mechanics right now but that's nothing extremely new. It does become a bit annoying when you run into your fifth team of the night running giant grinders just trying to sit behind your net and score a Michigan. They have brought back vision passing allowing you to specifically pass to players via button ala Madden but your better off direction passing with the stick as button passes go crazy 15% percent of the time. All in all its somewhat of an improvement slightly over previous years with things like easier access to customization menus, but give this one a wait till around mid November when the price drops. Some comments have already touched on it but EA typically does a huge sale in November digitally with price drops around 50%, bide your time and enjoy 23 until then.
I would love this game to be on pc for once
Buy NHL 09 PC lol
Giving it an 8 while also saying it’s not worth it to purchase is actually crazy
Taking away the NHL ‘94 controls is stupid, especially since it’s the 30th anniversary of the game
Long story short: Stop giving EA your money.
Wait for the day they actually let us play a season online with friends 😅
I love this franchise but it seems to be just a reskin of the game the year before. I got the PS5 version NHL23 because I needed a hockey game for my new console.
It's a great game
@@gtibro6799 NHL24 or the franchise as a whole? I agree with you on the franchise I've been playing it on and off since 1994.
theres no ea game that deserves a 8 in the last 5 years
This s** is rigged bro
If you get the pressure up all the way you’ll score 100% of the time
8 out of 10 sounds waaaay to high according to me... If this was their first ever nhl game I could maybe accept that score but since this is basically the same game we've had since the beginning of the current console generation I would deduct at least a whole point or maybe even two!
I stopped at like NHL 12 and this looks identical still 😂
Well hockey is gonna look like hockey. It's not gonna become a FPS.
@@dr.loomis4221 this freaked me out I’m currently watching OG Halloween 😆
I stopped at NHL 10. The trophies are just way too stupid.
@@dr.loomis4221clunky movement & completely unnatural looking movement seems identical though
so u need play ps2 and no online ? lol
NHL 25 needs line brawls plz and thank you
Also needs to be made by someone other than EA.
Who else got this recommended to them after it just came out on game pass 😂
I will stick to playing franchise hockey manager.
can anyone tell me honesty 100 percent is it worth not getting or getting I'm looking for a new game other than spider man madden or nba to play I haven't played nhl in about 2 years
Wait 2 more years between your EA hockey purses, otherwise its just a roster update while it's flaws stays untouched.
Bring back 94 controls for the gen x ers 😂
I only buy these games for franchise tbh. It’s kinda ass but I love gm mode in sports games
Does anyone else have an issue with your teammate randomly putting the puck in their own net almost on a game to game basis? Its borderline embarrassing.
I haven't played any NHL games in a decade. Is this worth $50?
no
I just bought the 100$ X factor version on ps5 for 30 $
game is loaded with bugs and glitches
50 no, 30 is ok
Is the fighting good?
No. I normally play as an enforcer, and I lose damn near every fight in 24. In 23 and 22 I was winning every game
arn anderson?@@dantefilms3170
They haven't touched the fighting refs,benches,on ice player reactions in about a decade
4:10 - Does that create a player have a cigarette?
That’s his mouth piece dummy
Again no net-physics. Such a shame. A relatively easy thing to implement and it would add a lot of realism.
too bad i cant play this on pc...
That fukin pressure bullshht thing on the ice gotta go is so distracting
You can't turn that off? Wow that sucks
I’ve been trying to win one single faceoff for the last 3h. I’m about to destroy my tv please someone help me i don’t know what the fuck i’m doing wrong. Never had that problem with any nhl game before
Timing, pull the right stick fast backwards when the ref drop the puck, don't bother with the rest of the buttons. Aim that face off pass with left stick. Or push it forward to try to lock up your opponent and hope to whatever deity you pray to that the AI is to your favor that day.
I remember NHL93 or something back on genesis. That was the best
Oh, yeah, with the blue ice. That was the best. I owned NHL 95 as a kid and put hundreds of hours into it.
I loved ‘97
This game is pure crap. Hasn't felt like a hockey game since NHL 14
Sorry but there is no way this deserves an 8. I played the trial and while some things have improved, the gameplay still doesn't feel like hockey. They've done nothing to the offline modes and the pressure meter that disappears after the timer even though you're maintaining the same amount of offensive pressure doesn't make any sense. The celebrations after goals are horrible and the loading screen you get after the puck goes into the net is immersion breaking. The franchise mode is playable but it's still got the same bugs and player/roster/contract issues from last year. Not to mention the goalies are garbage letting in easy shots yet again. It's crazy that NBA 2k games from over a decade ago still manage to beat the modern EA offerings.
I might get the game
Play through the EA play Trail first it's ok but it's not worth the full $70....maybe on black Friday but not full price & if your a offline player it's not worth it at all to upgrade honestly especially if you play be a pro
This is the worst version of this game ever. The full pressure system is absolute dogwater. If you put hitting buttons in the game why would you leave the right stick hit in so when you try a one timer you get penalized for hitting a defender? Also the ridiculous amount of unpenalized hitting on players that aren't anywhere near the puck by the defensive team in the o zone is laughable.
8 out of 10 give me a break. More like 4 out of ten. The game is trash. The first roster update didn’t have Bedard in Chicago. The game is lazy like usual.
He'll be in the next one, I think they have to wait till he's played a game, has something to do with licensing and the NHLPA I believe. But, I agree it's a 4 out of 10.
Or you could just let people have their opinions
@@Rowec Same for you!
That happens just about every year and is usually added in the first or second update once the season starts. Where have you been lol
Every play feels the same it should be different speed and movement style s
The game is now on sale in ps store for like 30 bucks...I almost bought it until i read the bad reviews. Such a shame. I would like to Platinum a NHL one day....😢 Guess its not going to be this year. I have NHL 22 but the online trophies are unobtainable now.
is it still? I only see the X-Factor Edition for $130... whatever that is
@@KrisOO17 no, it was only till 6th of January unfortunately.
@@KrisOO17 additonal to my last reply: in the PS store you can select different editions. The standard ediotion is about 80 euro. Too expensive for me but cheaper than the X factors edition
the announcing sucks now too will be passing on this one
However good or bad this game is - since EA refuses to bring this franchise back to PC (while all the other sports games they offer are on PC now) I couldn't care less about the game anymore. Game looks great (mostly), and looks like it plays decently well still. But again, not on PC. Don't care anymore. Thanks EA.
Seriously? It's not on PC? That sucks.
@@CAPTEINRIGGS Nope, hasn't been on PC since NHL 14 I think? Maybe 13, or maybe 15. I don't remember actually lol
@@LordLOC 09 was last NHL game on PC.. 😢
They would be worried the PC modders fix their game, and keep it going after the release of the next game, which would cut into their profits taking 140$ each year from everyone. So piracy is a bullshit excuse, it all has to do with money.
@@neojay80 Yeah, but they already deal with that for Madden and FIFA (or whatever it's called now) so that's not even an excuse they could use lol though I agree - especially since only last year did they release their games in parity with the console versions. 2K still gives us the last gen garbage ports of NBA etc after all.
Screeching in the commentary. What’s not to love?
I am gonna wait until the NHL does what major-league baseball did, which is fire EA from ever making another video game for their sport. Let Sony take over. Let them do what they did with hockey like they did with baseball.
This reviews sounds like an AI wrote it “the ice hockey”
8? I'll never trust your reviews again
Idk I played offline last year just playing through seasons and this is the most realistic sport simulation game....
So much shit flashing around the screen on the ice, on the boards etc
Hitting is way over the top and needs an update big time. But other than that, I love it
This game is EFFED! Random goals from terrible scoring areas…. You can score 10 goals in a game for no reason.
Yup. NO competition on something like Semi-Pro but go up a level and it's like playing God or something.
But no matter the case YOUR goalie is the worst to ever put on pads unless you hold opponents to
I'm Concerned about The Game Controller Settings.
The other PlayStation Controller Settings has the(94 Controls Settings) but on The NHL PlayStation 4 2024 The (94 Control Settings) are not there and how the NHL 2024 settings are set I find That NHL 2024 Is unplayable.
There was not even a Manual in The Game box in the NHL 2024 box above all.
Now May Concern is What Do I Do With This Game and Get My $$ Money back.
Sue The PlayStation Company or Can I sell it on-line to get My $$ Money back.
No way Im buying this game. EA should be ashamed of themselves. Their games used to be a mandatory buy, now they’re just sending out the same game and slapping the new year on the cover as well as a roster update. This should be illegal. We have no other option but to play their shitty game or nothing at all. I have to edit my sliders so much just to have a shred of fun. NHL 23 I have 6 feet of clear ice in every direction around me, yet i get poke checked between the legs from behind and not only do I lose the puck, they steal and control the puck. I lowered the poke checking to a ridiculous nearly nothing and I still lose the puck. My pass assist and pass accuracy is almost maxed out. Nearly all my sliders are maxed out or lowered to 0 and it makes very little difference. Im so damn tired of this joke of game, and every other game they make.
Not until we all UNITE and refuse to buy this POS product they have to nerve to release will we get an attempt at a better game. It’s not like they don’t see the reviews, they know their games are trash. EA is literally 80% of the games I buy since I was a kid, but im done with them. Absolutely embarrassing and shameful the stuff they put out. Probably laughing at us as they become rich while they copy and paste year after year after year.
I dont like the controls, the pressure gimmick isnt something im impressed by. The soundtrack is aweful.
Looks like NHL 19
Here's why NHL will never work the way it is, at least in franchise mode. There's no flow or feel to the game. There's no me taking out the other team's captain, and I'm getting run at for the rest of the game, or the next game, or more fights because everybody's amped up.
In game, when I score a huge goal, everybody just stops skating. The fights haven't changed in years, and I always get an unsportsmanlike when the other guy doesn't fight. Etc....etc.
.etc....
This game looks so dope but I've tried year after year to play and I'm so green😂..this shii ain't for everyone no cap u have to be good or u won't have much fun
I stopped after 2023 because 23 was terrible. I actually just play 21 still until I think one is worth buying again
The game is dead because its been the same for 15 years but this year woc cosmetics are locked behind a $10 paywall BOYCOTT
I didn't even buy the game my boycott begins today !and if they don't fix be a pro next year I won't be buying that either
2 weeks old game and we struggle to find an opponent in eashl. Its pathetic
that's because nobody bought the game there's nothing and no reason to buy it honestly like the game is boring truthfully @@samreinhart8983
had a hard time taking this review seriously. why on God's green earth are you playing with the "on ice trainer" . made me cringe so hard. no one that plays with that on is remotely good at the game , also, 8/10 LMFAO. yeah a game with animations on par with a 2011 indie game, reused assets from 2015, and some of the most atrocious presentation in modern gaming. the replays , cutscenes and menus are indescribably bad and the entire flow of the game is so choppy and unpolished. still the same horrible crowd as NHL 15 too, and utter cringe commentary . yeah, 8 out of 10 🤣
Congrats ea. u destroyed the game.
Still playing NHL 2k5, by far a superior game
Naslund!
@@VisibleEnd great player! My favorite player of all time is another Swede, Peter Forsberg.
@@jayjayson9613 haha I was saying naslund is the cover star of nhl 2005. My fav player all time is ovechkin
@@VisibleEnd oh yeah, reading your comment at first I thought "Martin St Louis was on the cover of NHL 2k5, he must like Naslund" lol hence my comment. Rooting for Ovi to break the goal record, I want to witness history
@@jayjayson9613 same here bro. It’s not looking to great but hopefully he gets hot soon
Final verdict from me is: wish I'd never wasted my time.
Terrible mechanics. Players move like they were made out of Lego bricks. Passes are all over the place. Checking is next-to-impossible but of course the AI targets you like the Terminator. And forget about goaltending: no matter the skill level it's awful. One minor deke and it's in your net. EVERY. TIME. Pass on this worthless trash.
The game is now on sale in ps store for like 30 bucks...I almost bought it until i read the bad reviews. Such a shame. I would like to Platinum a NHL one day....😢 Guess its not going to be this year. I have NHL 22 but the online trophies are unobtainable now.
lol I tried the early access at my friends house for about 10 minutes. Instantly called PlayStation and got a refund on my pre order. Worst NHL game in YEARS. They really had to try to make it this bad this year.. let’s take all the fundamental controls away that I’ve been learning for 15 years so that people who suck at the game can be better and keep up….
& some people will try and say “not everyone has the time to sit around and learn all the controls…” well then don’t play online. Get better at the game offline first. Don’t change the entire controls for people who don’t even “have time” to play the game…
EA pay you....??, Baaad....
Looks like same and the commentary is the same.
An absolute disappointment…
Waiting, waiting, waiting… all i want is to play a damn hockey game! The loading & constant searching is downright pathetic!!!
Biggest bull shit games ever made in the history of video games!!!
Gamingbolt has just lost all credibility... the hitting is atrocious
8/10? lmao come on. Most goals are accidental passes, own goals after the puck bounces in front of the net and your goalie/defenders can't pick it up, cross crease (fine) or far side while bringing it out from the corner. It's rare to see a nice snipe anymore and very fumbly to try and dangle on a breakaway.
Passing the puck out with your goalie is worse.
Errant passes happen far more often.
Poke checking is way too effective.
Hitting is way too effective.
Hip checks are way too effective.
Goaltending is extremely inconsistent from one game to the next.
Changing lines on the fly is basically impossible with the new control scheme.
This game is the worst NHL EA has put out in probably a decade.
It looks like shit... I have nhl 18. I can't really see the difference 😭
same with nhl 21.
To me I don't care I had nhl 23 had a hard time scoring even under rookie level so I will not buy nhl 24
the rookie AI literally just lets you skate in a straight line for an automatic breakaway anytime you want lmao
August 2023, omg!!! The new DEVS seems to care bla bla.....ya! The care about HUT, no offline mode were touch. 0/10
haha them ea devs dont give 2 damns
Ah yes the offline modes that 90% of the player base don’t care about should be a focus 😂
This game is truly awful. Waited till April to try the free trial and was not amused. By no means is NHL 23 a great game but compared to 24 it feels twice as good. Terrible AI, bouncing off players when I go to hit, and the worst set of challenges for HUT I’ve seen so far are just some of the more infuriating aspects of this game.
Thinking about buying NHL 24 on PS4? Take $60 out of your wallet, go in the bathroom, and flush it down the toilet. It'll be a better use of the money.
I wish EA would give up or lose the NHL license, and let the people who make the MLB The Show games take over.
Boring horrible controls...don't buy ...play blades of steel on Nintendo
This game…. I swear I turn it off k can’t enjoy it. The scoring is sooo fkn badd!!
*This game is trash just like the others that were released within the past decade. This one takes the cake though, it isnt worth the price. I wouldnt even spend 20 dollars on this game... Never could find a game, its just loaded and loaded. So glad this game was borrowed to me! I couldn't imagine spending 100+ dollars on such game*
This is the worst NHL yet