Zero Drop Shoes Vs. Barefoot Shoes. Is There a Significant Difference?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 34

  • @debbied9997
    @debbied9997 Місяць тому +4

    LEMS barefoot shoes cured my planter fasciitis immediately. I have never returned to pointy-toed, heavily cushioned, tons of support shoes. They ruined my feet for over 40 years, and now, for the last 2 years, I have walked many miles pain-free in LEMS and XERO barefoot shoes.

    • @scoobychau
      @scoobychau 3 дні тому

      While Barefoot shoes cured ur planter fasciitis ..... Dr. Andrew Shc. said barefoot/zero drop shoes should not be worn by people with planter fasciitis...... dam....

  • @mccartyzoe
    @mccartyzoe 2 місяці тому +2

    Thank you so much! It’s good to hear from an expert!

  • @parrobo
    @parrobo 10 місяців тому +4

    I started jogging in minimalist shoes made by pure step. It helped me jogging comfortably in zone 2. However after 4 months of jogging i developed plantar fasciitis and the pain disabled me for weeks. My heel is still not 100%. I think there are not robust scentific evidence in favour of minimalist shoes.

    • @kizarumelon2477
      @kizarumelon2477 2 дні тому

      u progressed too quickly

    • @parrobo
      @parrobo 2 дні тому

      @@kizarumelon2477 It seems you know me significantly more than a podiatrist who met me in person and conducted a lot of testing and ultra-sound scan of my heel.

  • @Jessica-zi1en
    @Jessica-zi1en 4 місяці тому +3

    I’ve been wearing the Hykes Pinnacle barefoot shoes, and I always tell my friends, imagine wearing a pair of pants that did all the supporting for you. If your muscles didn’t have to work, they would slowly weaken, leading to countless problems. The same goes for your feet. Since switching to the Hykes Pinnacle, my feet have become incredibly strong, and I never experience foot pain anymore. I can’t imagine ever going back to restrictive, conventional shoes. These barefoot shoes have truly transformed my foot health.

  • @Jessica-zi1en
    @Jessica-zi1en 4 місяці тому +1

    I have the Hykes Pinnacle, and I also say to my friends, imagine wearing a pair of pants that's did all the support for you and you used no muscles, your muscles will slowly stop growing and that will lead to endless problems, same with the feet, I am using Hykes Pinnacle barefoot shoes and I will never ever go back to regular restricted shoes. My feet are so strong now and never experience foot pain, etc

  • @CraigWrightStraygoat
    @CraigWrightStraygoat Місяць тому

    I’ve been wearing barefoot shoes for a while and like them for general walking around. However, for cardio in the gym (elliptical, treadmill) I find they hurt my feet. Mostly it is the arch that hurts the most, feels like my foot has been overstretched. I have high arches.
    Now considering a zero drop shoe for that instead, something like an Altra. Not sure if it is the best/right approach. Anyone got experience of similar?

  • @craigatkinsonstudio
    @craigatkinsonstudio 5 місяців тому +1

    I've used 'barefoot' shoes for 6-7 months for all aspects of daily life, including running. My feet are generally tired, which I guess is from them working harder. Very stiff feet in the morning for example. I'm wondering whether zero drop would be better, and also for prevention of fat pad loss. What would you suggest from experience?

    • @BadgerWolf-19
      @BadgerWolf-19 5 місяців тому +1

      Same, I purchased a pair of Within Zero Drop running shoes. Ill give you a update next week after a few 5ks.

    • @espencapable
      @espencapable 3 місяці тому +1

      Would suggest not using them everyday! Especially when your feet are telling you they are tired. I use barefoot shoes 3-4days per week. No soreness or tiredness. Also never have shin splints when running in normal running shoes anymore. Due to barefoot shoes strengthening my calves.

    • @Fr4nkSanchez
      @Fr4nkSanchez 3 місяці тому +1

      @@espencapable I think I have strong calves but I do get peroneous longus or peronus brevis pain, I have been using cushion running shoes so I am thiking switching to barefoots due stability. I did twisted my ankle with my adidas ultraboost 22 and for running fast and specially in uneven terrain is very unstable.

    • @espencapable
      @espencapable 3 місяці тому +1

      @@Fr4nkSanchez Also not liking too comfy shoes in the terrain. I’ve been doing ok with the HOKA Torrent as they are the least cushioned shoes HOKA has and had worked great for trail/mountain running. The older I get, the more off days I need. Often take 2d off running to let my feet heal.

  • @kimshermam8844
    @kimshermam8844 8 місяців тому

    Which would you recommend for someone wanting weight lifting shoes when you don't want to go barefoot in a gym?

    • @BadgerWolf-19
      @BadgerWolf-19 5 місяців тому +1

      I would recommend using barefoot shoes for weight lifting. Zero Drop for running.

  • @petercunnington6808
    @petercunnington6808 12 днів тому

    Dude, what are you talking A narrow toe box is the very reason.People get bunions and other problems like that.Barefoot, you allow you to be natural and fix these problem.

  • @lightningspike4452
    @lightningspike4452 8 місяців тому

    Are you sure that all people with flat feet are better off avoiding barefoot shoes for ever?

    • @Bigj9070
      @Bigj9070 6 місяців тому +5

      I am like 97% flat footed and love my barefoot and zero drop shoes

    • @byronfury2664
      @byronfury2664 6 місяців тому

      I believe he means if you have flat feet and have plantar fasciitis, you should avoid barefoot shoes for running and should wear motion control shoes until you feel better then once healed can wear barefoot shoes.

    • @timivers8823
      @timivers8823 2 місяці тому +1

      I have very flat wide feet. My altras have been my best investment. Had Hoka, but no more.

  • @dancan6622
    @dancan6622 Рік тому +1

    I am so confused by this video. First off you seem to confuse zero drop with minimalist. Minimalist shoes do offer zero drop but also zero support and padding which leads me to ask, what are barefoot shoes? There is a clear contradiction here. you cannot be barefoot if you are wearing shoes. just trying to understand. I am no foot doctor but just wonder, why not just go barefoot?

    • @DrAndrewSchneider
      @DrAndrewSchneider  11 місяців тому +6

      Sorry for the confusion. Zero drop are not minimalist. For instance, Altra is zero drop but has support (depending on the style). A barefoot shoe is one that mimics barefoot walking. No support and a very thin sole for protection. Think the Xero shoe or Vibram 5 fingers. Hope this helps.

    • @dancan6622
      @dancan6622 11 місяців тому

      @@DrAndrewSchneider Kind of but i still dont understand how a shoe can be barefoot. A shoe is still a shoe no matter what the maketing name is and as soon as you put it on you are no longer barefoot, right?

    • @DrAndrewSchneider
      @DrAndrewSchneider  11 місяців тому +2

      @@dancan6622 you are right. Even the thinnest sole is going to dull the sensation of the ground. It’s a shoe. Not barefoot.

    • @ljbrodnax
      @ljbrodnax 11 місяців тому

      So zero drop is not good for someone with fascitis?

    • @shweinnabhurtun8331
      @shweinnabhurtun8331 6 місяців тому +2

      Wow.. you're..not bright

  • @kromsnavelfun
    @kromsnavelfun 7 місяців тому

    You don't look as if you are a runner...

    • @marykatan7324
      @marykatan7324 6 місяців тому +4

      He's a doctor/ podiatrist

    • @kromsnavelfun
      @kromsnavelfun 6 місяців тому

      @@marykatan7324Thanks. I already thought he's not worth watching.

  • @Jay-nq1wh
    @Jay-nq1wh Місяць тому

    You’re incorrect. Zero drop shoes allows the foot to provide natural arch support. Regular shoes cause people to be flat foot. God designed humans without the need for shoes or braces for our teeth too❤💯💯💯💯