'The Squid and the Whale' | Critics' Picks | The New York Times
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 січ 2011
- A. O. Scott looks at Noah Baumbach's family drama set in Brooklyn in the 1980s.
Subscribe to the Times Video newsletter for free and get a handpicked selection of the best videos from The New York Times every week: bit.ly/timesvideonewsletter
Subscribe on UA-cam: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
Watch more videos at: nytimes.com/video
---------------------------------------------------------------
Want more from The New York Times?
Twitter: / nytvideo
Facebook: / nytimes
Google+: plus.google.com/+nytimes/
Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch. On UA-cam.
'The Squid and the Whale' | Critics' Picks | The New York Times
/ thenewyorktimes - Розваги
The scene where he says ''déguelasse'' is so great, it crystallizes the fact that the father is so pretentious and clumsy : at that point where his whole family is shaken, instead of using the occasion to bring the family closer, he makes an obscure pedantic quote that his wife doesn't understand and even he doesn't, i.e., dégeulasse means disgusting, not bitch. Great writing, great pacing, great movie.
I also got a kick out of that scene - he's so absorbed in literature and cinema that he couldn't help but quote Godard's "Breathless." It's the same deal when he offered an original copy of Mailer's "The Naked and the Dead" to his son in the hospital. Baumbach did a great job of showing how the arts and letters can divorce people from reality.
@@konami1979 bang on! I think this is so true of anything in the entertainment / knowledge sector (books, movies, plays, musicals, heck even science: pyschology, biology, economics - they all try to explain or portray human behaviour and sometimes (I definitely have) consciously or unconsciously individuals try/do mimic these behaviours because it's within their recollection/memory or they think they're supposed to. Some of it's pretentious and some is not, which in my opinion is what divorces people from the external reality and the internal reality - how we authentically act and how we fabricate actions/reactions.
@@konami1979 Excelent observation
One of the best movies about "after divorce " post trauma, profoundly sensitive about the children's view of separation reality ....
And good view of the parents getting lost, confused, and aggressive,....in spite of loving their sons....
Very well acted movie but Jeff Daniels blew me away. Underrated actor. Great movie.
I think The Squid and The Whale and The Ice Storm are the best movies about being raised amidst an exploded family nucleus.
those are the best!!
Spot on. I’d add Igby Goes Down.
One of my favorites by far. That script
This movie may be the prequel to Marriage Story starring Adam Driver and Scarlett Johansson that came out last month. Both movies were directed by the same director, and maybe a retelling of his life. This movie is on my bucket list but Marriage Story was fantastic story telling.
Just watched the Squid and the Whale and I can say Marriage Story is a polished Squid and the Whale.
@@luismarioguerrerosanchez4747 The Squid and the Whale is more about the kids and their reaction to the separation and how that affects their relationships with their parents. Marriage Story is primarily about the couple's relationship. They both deal with divorce, but they're much different stories.
@@seanmatthewking Yeah, it reminds me of a quote by François Truffaut where he says that making L'Enfent Sauvage was a revelation to him by being the first film where he identified with the adult figure in contrast to Les 400 Coups where he identified with the kid.
I believe The Squid and the Whale is Baumbach's cry from his parents divorce and how it affected him whereas Marriage Story is him becoming the father he once resented and understanding the hard time they had trying to raise the children after the marriage is over.
So while I liked Squid and the Whale alot I think Marriage Story is more mature and better written (I think the second act of Squid is subpar with the rest of the film).
So Eisenberg basically plays the same character he always plays?
Mark Bladt yeah, but he plays it very well
this was the first time he played it
pretty much.. I do not even have to see the movie to answer this hahaha.
I would say he elevated those things in Social Network.
no he’s less awkward, more likeable and more layered
This is one of my favorite movies. I'm gonna revisit it
0:50 Just now realizing that thumb to the mouth thing is a reference to Godard's "Breathless" when Jean-Paul Belmondo does the same thing then says "bogie" while looking at a poster of Humphrey Bogart
Producer: Wes Anderson💜
This movie is so critical for understanding the 50% of American marriages that end up in divorce. We have to take care of the health and mental health of these kids whose world has been fractured by the greatest idols we have- our parents. Broken emotional issues tend to pass from generation to generation unless a proactive response is taken like victor frankel describes in man’s search for meaning. I had a college professor which took these basic relationship principles on as either altruistic and authentic or the self interested pursuit of personal gain. It’s sad to think that people are with their own self interest self promotion and sunk cost in relationships and look past things like true altruism and true love. Noah bomback is a genius of screenplay and dialogue. Power affection and the pursuit for infinite freedom of our youth are so eloquently captured in this flick. We have a whole generation that has been taught to just distract themselves and “go play on their devices “ instead of this newly formed sense of pain with the human skill of conversation and the art of conversation.
@jackrumorz: I agree. The rest of the cast are great too: Jeff Daniels, a pre-"Social Network" Jesse Eisenberg, Owen Kline (Kevin and Phoebe Cates's kid), Anna Paquin and Billy Baldwin.
Brilliant movie, so amazing!
@MadScout Definitely
Short and wonderful film.
Great movie, the lesson for all parents
Very good movie
I wish I had watched this before seeing the movie!
Why? For me its just the opposite, I'm glad I did NOT watch it, it would have given away too much, I would not have had the same experience of having my eyes gradually be opening to what was REALLY going on in this marriage, family, kid ...
Watched it on crackle..... wonderful film 😃
Good Movie.
@jackrumorz She's a great actress.
Jesse Eisenberg!
This flick masterfully encapsulates the worldly eccentric jew.
Is his fourth movie, please new york times, do your homework
He did Pulp Fiction on his website.
*This is a Another one of the Movies that has all this Random Ideology going on and you are somehow suppose to know what the interpretation is....Meanwhile the rest of us are getting board waiting for the point...I saw a Howard Stern show that had Dave Grohl on it and they were going to play the song "My Hero" and Howard,Robin start saying what the meaning of the song is..and after everybody says what they "know " the song is about....Dave says No its not about that..its about this...Just because you think you know ...Doesn't mean you do*
Eisenberg is sufferable
I love Laura, she's simple yet pretty.
A simple beauty is the best kind of beauty
I can't figure out who's the squid and who's the whale? 😅
Best guess, man's the squid and woman is the whale.
Barf
Blarf