I am a huge Star Wars fan, it is actually my favorite movie ever, but It definitely does not deserve to be on this list over movies like the Good the Bad and the Ugly
@@madpeace1764 or its just a list , actually I don't even care how they position movies , I just take notes of many movies mentioned to than give me a chance to watch movie which I never even heard about it , but yeah I wouldn't pick star wars either
TGTHBATU drags in places. Tell me you don't get bored in the civil war scenes, especially with the expanded cut. Nah the best one was right before - For a Few Dollars More. It's a tighter story, a more interesting villian, a funkier bunch of outlaws, and the stagecoach robbery scene is the best thing Leone ever filmed. TGTBATU has a better soundtrack of course, but that's about it.
The Outlaw Josey Wales should have definitely been on the list , you could tell He learned a lot acting in previous westerns , he showed in directing this movie that he had what it takes to be a renowned director which he has become with numerous Academy awards. The Josey Wales movie had so many memorable characters.
10) The Shootist 09) Red River 08) Broken Arrow 07) The Sons of Katie Elder 06) Shane 05) The Gunfighter 04) Open Range 03) The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly 02) The Magnificent Seven 01) The Big Country Honorable Mention - A Fistful of Dollars, For a Few Dollars More, The Searchers, The Outlaw Josie Wales, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence, Silverado, Unforgiven, Rio Bravo, High Noon, and The Ox Bow Incident
I'd make the title "List of pretentious movies designed to impress the common folk with our obscure choices that only us elites could understand and appreciate the nuances of, while leaving the commoners who preferred movies like The Good, the Bad and the Ugly to feel somehow culturally inferior ". Or maybe I'm just a paranoid conspiracy theorist.
@@BrendanJSmith Westerns are a bunch of Crap .The only Great, and Real western IS ," High Noon". People are COWARDS just like, "Mark Twain" said. John Wayne is No actor. The best thing that HE ever did IS, " He became a Catholic at the end of his life.
Cards5Rock It got a mention but in the end cinefix picked "Once upon a time in the west" over that movie. I guess they didn't wanted to pick 2 Sergio Leone movies for this list...
Or The Ox-Bow Incident. Or the original Magnificent Seven. Or the other Unforgiven movie called The Unforgiven starring Burt Lancaster and Audrey Hepburn. Or Tombstone.
The Good, The Bad And The Ugly is an amazing film. Easily the best in the dollars trilogy, but nothing holds a candle to Leone's next western Once Upon A Time In The West. It's one of those movies where every second is brilliantly executed.
Yes friend, I agree with you. Greetings. ua-cam.com/video/EqIyEgx6rjk/v-deo.html *THE GOOD THE BAD AND THE UGLY* Western Guitar cover by *The Ventures*
Rio Bravo, The Searchers, River of No Return, Young Guns and Tombstone are my personal Top 5. Spent a lot of time as a kid watching Westerns with my Dad. Great memories.
Was rated as the best western . But in the 1990' it was replaced by the Searchers . Both excellent films that captured the feel of the west . A third film , The Unforgiven based on Alan LeMay's novel of the same name and staring Burt Lancaster , Audie Murphy , Audrey Hepburn and a young Doug McClure was another that captured the era . The Shootist
Was also good but being set in 1908 was more about the end of the western era and settlement . There are many good films and many more just hype to cash in on the genere . Of course many tell a good action tale . Jeremiah Johnson was good as was Across the Wide Missouri as tales of the early west and fur trade .
The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly is hands down the best western and action movie of all time. It works on so many levels, its a heist movie, war movie, comedy movie, buddy movie, historical movie, quest movie all rolled into one with great characters and character interactions all played to one of the greatest most inventive musical scores ever composed. Star Wars has many of these same qualities and Once Upon A Time in the West may be more poetic, but you just can't beat the sheer entertainment and rewatchability factor of The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly. Clint Eastwood, Eli Wallach and Lee Van Cleef are quite possibly the coolest trio ever assembled on screen.
ComicBook Ninja eh I wouldn't say its an action flick though. Great flick no doubt, and one of the best westerns of all time but action? Can't say it os
"C'era una volta il West", "il buono, il brutto e il cattivo ", "per un pugno di dollari " e "per qualche dollaro in più ", sono capolavori in assoluto e senza tempo del grande genio Sergio Leone e con musica straordinaria del mitico e immortale Ennio Morricone, due leggende...
I kinda knew they were gonna screw up on #1 when they put Unforgiven and Rio Bravo further down the list than they should have been. But I didn't think they'd screw up that badly. In my view, they went badly off the rails at #2.
Maybe not, but being that is a .44 Magnum in his pocket, the most powerful handgun in the world and would blow his head clean off, he'll have to ask himself one question: "Do I feel lucky?"
My personal favorite western is The Ten Commandments with Charlton Heston, followed closely by Terminator 2. Well done @cinefix! You really showed up for this one.
How about Dirty Harry? A modern western? For me it's a police story. I would be disappointed if I wanted to see a western and they showed something different like some Japanese film or Star Wars, for me Star Wars is Sci-Fi. These people are trying to be too clever.
You know, my favorite Western of all time is Once Upon a Time in the West, but I'll always say the best objective Western is The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. How it doesn't make a list of best westerns, but Star Wars is #1, baffles the mind. Hell I love Star Wars. And I know it takes some inspiration from Westerns. But it is not a Western... and certainly not the #1 Western of all time.
You know I love CineFix but I agree it just feels like they were trying to be smart with they’re choices but it just came off as stupid, and even though there are western themes the reason it’s not the best western film is because it’s not a western Star Wars is a sci-if movie because even though like I said there are themes for every blaster toting outlaw who doesn’t fit in there’s also ancient space samurai who use laser swords where as TGTBATU is a full on spaghetti western and a damn good one at that.
@@joejohnson5242 I'm do 100% agree with you. But to me Star Wars is not even a Scifi movie it a fantasy movie. Yes it is set in space and have space ships but it also have space wizards and stuff.
Tried to be clever? Star Wars is a space opera, based on western films, but with fancy space hardware instead of horses and guns. The clever ones were the makers of this garbage.
Obviously picked by someone who went to a post-modernist film school (probably in California) trying to destroy and subvert the genre by deconstructing it. So... the list is basically a verbose piece of crap trying to prove their own cleverness.
I realize it wasn't a movie, but a mini-series, but Lonesome Dove is the greatest western of all time. You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll celebrate, and you will be thankful you saw it. It's a one-of-a-kind type of show that never gets old and stands the test of time. It's a love story, it's a friend's story, it's a taming the frontier story, it's a good guys vs bad guys story, and it's brutal picture of the old west and old times story. Never have I gone through ALL the extremes of emotion as I did watching Lonesome Dove. Nothing comes close.
I just saw it for the first time and enjoyed it tremendously but it was really just a series of adventures based on the McMurtry book. You could practically hear the pages turning. The dialog is probably the best though. Duvall and Jones were perfect co-stars and built to a very touching ending.
Going with the reasoning they used to pick Star Wars, then they clearly overlooked Lawrence of Arabia, it fits the bill perfectly and has better horses.
Tracy Stubblèfield I was wondering about Jeremiah Johnson? Is it a western? Or a pre-western western? I think it takes place in the 1840s. As for Star Wars being included in this list, I believe CineFix is just trying to provoke a reaction from its viewers without thought of damage to its credibility.
Yeah. I don't know anybody, and I know hundreds of folks, who doesn't think that TGTBATU is the top Western of all time. Even one of the top MOVIES of all time, never mind that it was a western. Vast panoramic vistas, unparalleled cinematography, fantastic acting ( Eli Wallach deserved a best supporting actor oscar), a smash-hit soundtrack, great plot and story-line. "Blonde....blondie!...you know what you are?...just a dirty #@^&$ %$&^@#! !
@@jeremypnet Don't die Blondie! Don't die like that pig! I'm your friend, I go get water. Here, no! don't drink, it's no good for you! That's an excellent point Jeremy, I've never heard anyone posit it before. But now that you do, it makes a lot of sense. I wonder what everybody else thinks. Rigt now, I say that Clint is the leading role, with Eli 2nd and Lee 3rd. But a reasonable argument might change my mind.
@@st_orlieOk sir. I quiver in your supreme intelligence. I shall not juxtapose facts on Cinefix no longer. I'll dedicate more time to the little things like friends and taking care of my family rather than disturbing the UA-cam comment Gods as yourself.
X) Tom Horn 9) Unforgiven 8) McCabe & Mrs Miller 7) Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid 6) The Good the Bad & the Ugly 5) Once Upon a Time in the West 4) Two Mules for Sister Sara 3) Jeremiah Johnson 2) The Outlaw Josey Wales 1) Honey I Shrunk the Kids
Absolutely true Quentin Tarantino is right The Good, the Bad and the Ugly is not only the best western of all time It's the best movie of all time Eli Wallach clearly deserved an Oscar for it
P Pipe I know, right!!!!! Jeremiah Johnson is an awesome western!!! Blazing Saddles is a western farce and a spoof of all westerns made by Mel Brooks! Why was it even mentioned in this list???
Partly his fault! - J. Elam got offered to play the evil gunslinger in "Shane", but he declined saying it had not enough lines for him! - And so, a black panther like Jack Palance made Shane into a classic ! -
@@jameshouser7283 You fools don't even know about the entire concept of "Space Westerns" do you? Do some work, Space Westerns have been around since the 30's and many of them you know, Outland, Westworld, Buck Rogers, Flash Gordon, Lost in Space, Star Trek, yes Star Wars, and Solo:A Star Wars Story etc., to those I am sure only a few know of like Northwest Smith, etc.
@@toddstevens13 , yes but you say Star Wars A New Hope is the Best Western of all time is not credible. Not saying it isn't possibly a decent Western. It is a sci-fi fantasy with Western elements. Certainly not enough to be labeled higher than The Good The Bad and The Ugly. Ridiculous.
"Wupped em again Josey." "We have a saying to the winner goes the spoils, we also have a saying don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining ." Look its JOSEY WALES. 😂😂
My thoughts exactly. Lucas may have combined patterns from old westerns and samurai movies set in a sci-fi motif, but Star Wars itself is NOT a western. It’s sci-fi. A space opera. Not western or samurai. So, yeah. There’s no way that counts.
"Sometimes not all westerns take place in the west" well... they kinda do or else they wouldn't be westerns, they sure as shit don't take place in a galaxy far far away
The Western is more of an idea created by films than an actual physical location. Example? Django Unchained. Set in the South, not the West. But it’s clearly a Western. In style, in plotting, etc. No Country for Old Men is a pseudo-Western despite being set in 1970s Texas.
ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST is the number 1 Western that has ever been made. The texture of it, the styling, the slow studied pacing, even the action is artistically drawn. It has superb tension throughout the film without horror gimmicks or fast cut chases. The music, the sound effects, characterization, visuals, situations, all work together to achieve the tension. Leone used the juxtaposition of power and vulnerability to create threat. All with classic Italian romance where it has to look good. The film is a work of art and is superior to all the rest in my humble opinion.
People in the comments obviously have no idea how CineFix designs lists: Their "Top Tens" are never really in order. They choose ten different categories of a certain type of film and then choose the best film in that category. They had a section on the 50s Golden Age, they had one on Revisionist westerns, they had one on Spaghetti westerns (of which Once Upon a Time in the West barely edged out over The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly), hell they even had one on the crazy relationship between Japanese Samurai films and the American Western (that's why Sukiyaki Western Django is "#2"). So for that last category, the "#1" spot, they decided they wanted to stretch the definition of a Western as far as they could and see what other films that are not technically "westerns" use similar themes and ideas. To them, Star Wars fit the bill, and I could really see how they came to that conclusion. After all, what is a Western but a call to adventure, the exploration of new lands, and the neverending struggle between "good" and "evil"?
Westerns are arts works (films, books, television shows, and paintings right off; see Frederic Remington; we focus on movies) devoted to telling romanticized tales of the American West (see Westward Expansion in History of the United States). While the western has been popular throughout the history of movies, as the United States progresses farther away from the period depicted, the western has begun to diminish in importance, though (as of August 2003) it has been revived with the Kevin Costner western Open Range. The fundamental plots of Westerns are simple. Life is reduced to its elements: there are no computers, no cellphones, no cars, no electricity. None of the complications and technology of modern life. You have: The clothes on your back. Your gun, and Your horse. And that's usually it. The horse may be optional. The art of the Western takes these simple elements and tell simple morality stories, setting them against the spectacular scenery of the American West. The best Western directors practically made / make the scenery an unpaid star of the movie. Definition of Western aka nothing to do with Star Wars
Yeah, I hear ya. But that doesn't make this list suck any less..... First of all I think that is a terrible way to make a 'best of' list. If I wanted to know what the best 'revisionist sci-fi musical western' was, then I would watch that top ten list!!! Just list what you think are the top ten and if the top 5 happen to be 'samurai westerns' ...so be it
Yes, The Quick And The Dead is definitely one of my all time favorites! Walmart had it on dvd for about $3.00 late last year and I snagged that sucker up and skipped some stuff on the grocery list to buy it! Gene Hackman and Diane Lane are superb in that one!!!
@@TheRomaduce I saw it but don;t recall it at all. I'll hafts go back and watch it again. Rooster Cogburn was his character originally right? So True Grit was a take off from that movie and character? I gotta go watch it now. You piqued my curiosity. :)
I'm surprised Quigley Down Under didn't get a mention. A great example of a western story which takes place in another part of the world. It's classic all the way through with an awesome ending.
@@nonfinale685 Actors matter far more than that. Eastwood, Wallach and Van Cleef were essential to the GBU. Eastwood to all three films. The director may be the head, but actor is the hands. It's collaborative on every level. There is just something about Wayne's goofy, hokey persona I can't get by. Eastwood's cold, soft spoken persona is what I personify the western antihero to be. And Lee Van Cleef is one of the most underrated actors ever.
@@nonfinale685 I agree with most of that, but I'm not so sure the Dollars trilogy would have hit like it did without Eastwood. I don't see him as expendable there. And on the flip side, I don't think it would have hit like it did if Leone wasn't helming it. I read that Charles Bronson had turned down that role...not sure which...can't see it having the same impact. He sure changed his tune for Once Upon a Time in the West didn't he? Haha. I definitely prefer the Spaghetti Westerns to the American westerns at the time, with the exception of Peckinpah's Wild Bunch and Ballad of Cable Hogue.
@holykuhrap ohh man your so lucky how was it I’ve always wanted to go since I’m a huge fan of the west and history and it would be a dream come true if I got to visit Tombstone
@VSJ 1987 OK Val Kilmer was cheesy thank you for the information not val Kilmer plying doc was probably one of the most iconic western characters ever not even talking about how many quotes val produced from that one movie
Not necessarily a fan of every choice, but very fond of the process used to come up with the list. Breaking down Westerns into subcategories allowed the creator to showcase many films beyond the 10 and defend their picks from the subcategories. Additionally, the creator of the list gets around the most obvious weakness of the approach (more than one movie in a category belonging on the list), by introducing a tie in that category…. Brilliant!
@Samsung McKone if you get a chance check out the original 3:10 to Yuma, the Remake was great however the original with Glenn Ford and Van Heflin is totally worth your time.
I couldn't watch this after they said Searchers was number 10. I can understand it maybe not being number one, especially taking into account I don't believe anybody at this channel is over the age of 40. But number 10? Couldn't continue to watch.
High Noon, Gary Cooper, The Seachers John Wayne, Shane Alan Ladd,High Plains Drifter Clint East Wood, The man who shot the liberty Valence James Stewart, John Wayne and Lee Marvin, My darling Clementine, Henry Fonda, Victor Mature ad the List goes ON and On.
I love how you do your Top 10: Divide a genre in 10 categories and pick the #1 from each categorie. Some people will hate you for it, but I think it's the best way to cover a genre to any person, from the neophyte to the hardcore fan.
It's amazing how many regular viewers haven't picked up on that. Hence all the "I can't believe [MOVIE] didn't make the list!" comments that plague the comments section each vid.
Mike O'. I just recently got into westerns and lists like this help a lot. But I already own all but Shane and Pat Garret and Billy the Kid. Haven't watched them all yet, but I will eventually. Haha
I'm a huge fan of westerns. What I'm a fan of is John Ford/John Wayne in Stagecoach (1939) and The Searchers (1956), Henry Fonda in My Darling Clementine (1946) and The Ox Bow Incident (1943), and especially Clint Eastwood in The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly (1966), For A Few Dollars More (1965), and A Fistful of Dollars (1964). All of which are great movies.
This is probably one of the best movie based UA-cam channels. Of everything of theirs I've seen, this is by far the strangest. Granted I do understand some of the odd choices, they are abrasive.
how many lists have you watched by this channel? They make lists which talk about a topic, how far its influence can reach, or how far it can be artistically manipulated. This isn't a list saying "these are the ten best westerns", this is a list saying that "these are ten examples of the western, today, now and into the future. These are examples of how they have grown, died, and revived in a multitude of forms. This is the power of the creative mind." If you got pissed off by some of their inclusions then that's OK, but realize that it's not meant to be a top ten list in the classic sense, more of an accessible (and clickbait-y) mould to sneak a video essay about westerns into. You should be more pissed that they tricked you into getting film school'd.
Silverado is so underrated, with great actors about to hit their primes, and chemistry usually reserved for actor who've done theater together for some time. Its A great balance of fun, action, sadness, and comedy rolled into a movie that didn't need to be 3 hours long to tell the story...
I think you're a bunch of idiots. Lonesome Dove was probably the best western ever made with Unforgiven coming in a close second. Did any of you ever watch a western before you came up with this list?
It was fun to watch and you showed a lot of my favorite oaters. Having grown up in the fifties and sixties on black and white cowboy flicks, both at the movies and on weekend TV, there will always be a place in my heart for a good western. I think you got quite imaginative in cross dressing the genres and I really don't mind, nor does the order you have chosen to put them in. Just seeing most of my favorites ( Treasure of the Sierra Madre somehow got lost in the editing) was a real treat. Thank you for this Vid
Yeah, I think that's the worst part of it. I skipped through a lot because the narrator went on and on and on...well, you get the picture. Picking Star Wars as number 1 was kind of a silly thing to do, not edgy or deep as CineFlix may think. And having it at number 1, then doing a, "Oh, you SciFi fans were made it wasn't on our list, see, we put it on this one" trope was just, I don't know, the term "elitist" comes to mind. That and, "we're just being jerks."
There's two kinds of people my friend...those who think that "the good, the bad and the ugly" is the best western movie in all times and those who included "star wars" as a western movie....
I love once upon a time in the west and the good, the bad and the ugly, they deserved to be in the list together. Even if spaghetti westerns only have one spot in the list, that was a shame.
Steffen Ackermann yeah corbucci and his movie django is a favourite in my house. And another good film by Sollima would be La resa dei conti, a great movie for Lee Van Cleef.
@@nan16cd np. I was in agreement with you, but wanted to see what made them think so highly of it. I'm glad I did. The only problem is the heavy japanese accents can be difficult to understand. It's free on youtube. That's where I watched it.
They already had Peckinpah with Pat Garett and Billy the Kid - but I agree, the Wild Bunch is a better film altogether, exploring similar themes, but with a more energetic style to t
Can’t believe you left out Silverado. In the early 80’s, when everyone was saying that the western was a dieing art form, this movie came along and just about singlehandedly saved the genre. From the very start, to the finish, Lawrence Kasdan, with the help of an all star cast, and a majestic film score, brought us a rip snortin, shootem up that pulled the genre from the scrap heap, and reminded everyone just how much pure fun a western can be. The final showdown between Kevin Kline, the reluctant gunslinger with a heart of gold, and Brian Dennehy’s crooked town sheriff, with Kline’s backdrop - a church, and Dennehy’s - an empty semi desert, was the perfect metaphor for the fight between good and evil that nothing does better than the western.😃👍🏻
I could not take Silverado seriously, especially the main bad guy Brian Dennehy. Dennehy just treated his Cobb character like a joke. He did a better job in First Blood as Sherriff Will Teasle who hasseled Rambo. But in Silverado, as I pointed out, I really couldn't take him seriously. Kevin Costner was also a joke in that movie. He acted like such a clown . I'll never understand why people thought it was so great. It had the same basic western plot with no surprises. It was actually slow and boring. Dannt Glover was probably the best part in that whole movie and that was it.
Silverado was cool. Kevin Costner has some awesome westerns under his belt like Dances With Wolves, Open Range, Hatfield McCoys, Yellowstone, even Wyatt Earp was good despite being overshadowed by Tombstone.
@@wiseguymaybe well aren't you pleasant, the reason Costner's character acted as a reckless clown is because he was young and reckless, so that's how he portrayed the character on screen...
The Big Country. Best acting and best actors. Best written and all the elements mentioned and then some. Best Music! Awesome scenes. Burl Ives deservedly won an Oscar for his complex portrayal. Gregory Peck, Charlton Heston, Jean Simmons, Carol Baker and a villainous Chuck Conners. Watch it and see for yourself.
One of my absolute favorite movies of all time is the remake of 310 to Yuma. I didn't expect it to make the list but an honorable mention would have been cool.
Ben Foster made one of my favorite villains in that film. I thought he was going to go on to big things after that, but people seemed to fail to notice him. Hopefully he'll get better roles after his great turn in Hell Or High Water.
Sarcasm is hard to convey on the internet, especially when making a simple statement. You can't just expect people to be able to read your mind or intent. That's what emojis are for.
Now I understand how Leslie Nielsen and Priscilla Pressley came out laughing hysterically out of the movie theater that had just shown Platoon. This Star Wars pick as the best Western made me laugh as well.
1) The Good The Bad and The Ugly & The Searchers (Share top Spot) 2) Once Upon A Time In The West 3) True Grit 4) Silver-ado 5) The Outlaw Josey Wales 6) The Oxbow Incident 7) Unforgiven 8) The Wild Bunch 9) Winchester 73 10) Magnificent Seven & Heavens Gate (Share 10th spot)
Any western with Clint Eastwood. Silver dollar, Lonesome dove (series), Into the West (series), 3:10 to Yuma, Young Guns & Young Guns II are honorable mentions.
Luckily, this is the first ranking list I've ever seen from CineFix. I say luckily because I can only imagine how much time it has saved me in looking up your other content, which I can only assume is equally ludicrous. But at least you feel clever. And you can't put a price on that...
![Top 20 BEST Western Movie Duels [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kiEOcFBFbvQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m just going to pretend that they mispronounced The Good the Bad and the Ugly terribly and it sounded like Star Wars
Lol
ditto
Preach
Any of the Spaghetti Westerns. One should have made it.
utoobia Did you watch the video???
I am a huge Star Wars fan, it is actually my favorite movie ever, but It definitely does not deserve to be on this list over movies like the Good the Bad and the Ugly
Trust Me Bro...
THEY KNOW!!!
They Just Pull Crap Like This
Because They Think It Makes
Them Seem "EDGY"
@@madpeace1764 I think it also generates more discussion therefore more comments and therefore more Traffic/views
@@madpeace1764 or its just a list , actually I don't even care how they position movies , I just take notes of many movies mentioned to than give me a chance to watch movie which I never even heard about it , but yeah I wouldn't pick star wars either
TGTHBATU drags in places. Tell me you don't get bored in the civil war scenes, especially with the expanded cut. Nah the best one was right before - For a Few Dollars More. It's a tighter story, a more interesting villian, a funkier bunch of outlaws, and the stagecoach robbery scene is the best thing Leone ever filmed. TGTBATU has a better soundtrack of course, but that's about it.
@@bobdouglass8010 the civil war scenes are part of the anti war message
Of course Star Wars is the best western of all time.
Just like the Good The Bad and The Ugly is the best science fiction movie ever.
lmaoo
Of course, of course! And the "Seventh Seal" is the best comedy.
And CineFix is the best circus
😂😂🤣
Yeah no, the original comment of this was hilarious, you're just desperate
The Outlaw Josey Wales should have definitely been on the list , you could tell He learned a lot acting in previous westerns , he showed in directing this movie that he had what it takes to be a renowned director which he has become with numerous Academy awards. The Josey Wales movie had so many memorable characters.
"Endeavor to persevere!"
One of the best lines in movies and useful in real life 😅
The best thriller? Meet the Parents. Best historical movie? Reservoir Dogs. Best comedy? Schindler's List.
Here, I can make random top 10's too.
Saddest movie: Lego Movie 2
Best kids movie: Hacksaw Ridge
Best family movie: The Human Centipede
Say you're not far off. 'Schindler's List' is a work of fiction after all.
Best kids movie? Inglorious Basterds.
That 'The Good, the Bad and the Ugly' did not make this list makes this rating a sham.
It was on the segment with several other Leone films. I agree that Once Upon A Time In The West is Leone’s masterpiece Western.
Yup, it’s rigged.
I think Star Wars are also the best James Bond movie!!!
And The best documentary
And the best depiction of stop motion animation ever
Star Trek into darkness is my favorite rom com from National georgraphic. Very dark and violent
@@ryeguy2256 How about Rocky !!!!
🤔🤔🤔
10) The Shootist
09) Red River
08) Broken Arrow
07) The Sons of Katie Elder
06) Shane
05) The Gunfighter
04) Open Range
03) The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
02) The Magnificent Seven
01) The Big Country
Honorable Mention - A Fistful of Dollars, For a Few Dollars More, The Searchers, The Outlaw Josie Wales, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence, Silverado, Unforgiven, Rio Bravo, High Noon, and The Ox Bow Incident
Finally someone that knows their westerns👍👏
Have you seen The Wild Bunch and McCabe & Mrs. Miller though?
I disagree but I appreciate the Big Country at #1. I love that film so much!
Good list but The Shootist. Ick. A tired vehicle for a tired John Wayne.
Nope,
Your nr.3 is the clear and ONLY nr.1 of the westerns. No sane person would challenge this.
The title should be: A random list of 10 movies with sand
luca alberetto I don’t like sand. It’s coarse and rough and irritating-and it gets everywhere.
I'd make the title "List of pretentious movies designed to impress the common folk with our obscure choices that only us elites could understand and appreciate the nuances of, while leaving the commoners who preferred movies like The Good, the Bad and the Ugly to feel somehow culturally inferior ". Or maybe I'm just a paranoid conspiracy theorist.
@@terrydactyl4350 seriously, who thinks star wars is a western??
@@BrendanJSmith Westerns are a bunch of Crap .The only Great, and Real western IS ," High Noon". People are COWARDS just like, "Mark Twain" said. John Wayne is No actor. The best thing that HE ever did IS, " He became a Catholic at the end of his life.
Terry Dactyl it sounds like you just haven’t watched that many westerns
Absolute tragedy the Good the Bad and the Ugly isn't on here
^^^
Cards5Rock It got a mention but in the end cinefix picked "Once upon a time in the west" over that movie. I guess they didn't wanted to pick 2 Sergio Leone movies for this list...
Once Upon a Time in the West is wayyyyy better anyway. GBU isn't even the best Dollar trilogy film (A few dollars more is.)
They took the better one, so no problem.
Or The Ox-Bow Incident. Or the original Magnificent Seven. Or the other Unforgiven movie called The Unforgiven starring Burt Lancaster and Audrey Hepburn. Or Tombstone.
The question can only be "what's the best Western after the Good, Bad, Ugly"
The Good, The Bad And The Ugly is an amazing film. Easily the best in the dollars trilogy, but nothing holds a candle to Leone's next western Once Upon A Time In The West. It's one of those movies where every second is brilliantly executed.
@@ragejoona431 fistful of dollars better than good bad ugly no cappity
Idk the original true grit hold up pretty well
Yes friend, I agree with you. Greetings. ua-cam.com/video/EqIyEgx6rjk/v-deo.html *THE GOOD THE BAD AND THE UGLY* Western Guitar cover by *The Ventures*
Star Wars
Rio Bravo, The Searchers, River of No Return, Young Guns and Tombstone are my personal Top 5. Spent a lot of time as a kid watching Westerns with my Dad. Great memories.
Good list . But for the top westerns of all time for over forty years 'Shane
Was rated as the best western . But in the 1990' it was replaced by the Searchers . Both excellent films that captured the feel of the west . A third film , The Unforgiven based on Alan LeMay's novel of the same name and staring Burt Lancaster , Audie Murphy , Audrey Hepburn and a young Doug McClure was another that captured the era . The Shootist
Was also good but being set in 1908 was more about the end of the western era and settlement . There are many good films and many more just hype to cash in on the genere . Of course many tell a good action tale . Jeremiah Johnson was good as was Across the Wide Missouri as tales of the early west and fur trade .
Star Wars is a good western, but to be honest, I liked Titanic better.
😂😂😂
nah bro the Lego Movie is the best
What about the Angry Birds movie. Great western Second only to Ford versus Ferrari movie
The best western is obviously shrek 2.
Titanic was an Eastern.
The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly is hands down the best western and action movie of all time. It works on so many levels, its a heist movie, war movie, comedy movie, buddy movie, historical movie, quest movie all rolled into one with great characters and character interactions all played to one of the greatest most inventive musical scores ever composed. Star Wars has many of these same qualities and Once Upon A Time in the West may be more poetic, but you just can't beat the sheer entertainment and rewatchability factor of The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly. Clint Eastwood, Eli Wallach and Lee Van Cleef are quite possibly the coolest trio ever assembled on screen.
Maybe not #1 in my book, but valid points one and all. :-)
ComicBook Ninja eh I wouldn't say its an action flick though.
Great flick no doubt, and one of the best westerns of all time but action? Can't say it os
Why? because it takes place in the old west? Is Raiders of the
lost ark a war movie or an action movie?
ComicBook Ninja action, adventure, war
GBU is an over rated spag Western. Once Upon a Time is way better, High Plains Drifter is way better.
Star Wars is a pretty good western! But have they ever seen Home Alone 2?
Lol clearly you haven't watch 21 Jump Street
Screw Home Alone 2, Cars is the best western
Any top 10 westerns list without Blade Runner is a joke.
Everybody knows that Mary poppins is the best Western!
Was that sam elliot or Kirk Douglass in star wars..?
"C'era una volta il West", "il buono, il brutto e il cattivo ", "per un pugno di dollari " e "per qualche dollaro in più ", sono capolavori in assoluto e senza tempo del grande genio Sergio Leone e con musica straordinaria del mitico e immortale Ennio Morricone, due leggende...
Agreed
Si
Don’t understand but think I do. Thank you.
6:38 "We think we're pretty GOOD pickers, actually..."
Precedes to pick something like "Star Wars" as #1...
Yep. You nailed it. Shit job. The Magnificent 7 is arguably no.1 but I love Eastwood so his movies always high on list. STAR WARS...give me a break.
They maybe good at picking their nose but movies its awful
I kinda knew they were gonna screw up on #1 when they put Unforgiven and Rio Bravo further down the list than they should have been. But I didn't think they'd screw up that badly. In my view, they went badly off the rails at #2.
Star Wars a Western! And there was me thinking it was a romantic comedy. Doh…
Naythen Lowe I though so too is anyone disappointed Clint Eastwood or Trinity isn’t on here?
BACK TO THE FUTURE: PART 3 more western then STAR WARS
Have to love the "wake up juice" from that movie!
True
Tell Clint Eastwood the best western is Star Wars and make it back alive.
amirhossein tootooni damn straight
oohhh boiiiiiii!!!
He's 87, I know you might have romantic notions about him but he's not going to be beating anyone up anytime soon.
amirhossein tootoon
Maybe not, but being that is a .44 Magnum in his pocket, the most powerful handgun in the world
and would blow his head clean off, he'll have to ask himself one
question: "Do I feel lucky?"
My personal favorite western is The Ten Commandments with Charlton Heston, followed closely by Terminator 2. Well done @cinefix! You really showed up for this one.
How about Dirty Harry? A modern western? For me it's a police story. I would be disappointed if I wanted to see a western and they showed something different like some Japanese film or Star Wars, for me Star Wars is Sci-Fi. These people are trying to be too clever.
The reply needed. Thank you.
I had to check the upload date to see if this was an April Fools joke.
Star wars?? Wtf?! I can see how they tried to be clever comparing the similarities to westerns but come on!!!
You know, my favorite Western of all time is Once Upon a Time in the West, but I'll always say the best objective Western is The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. How it doesn't make a list of best westerns, but Star Wars is #1, baffles the mind. Hell I love Star Wars. And I know it takes some inspiration from Westerns. But it is not a Western... and certainly not the #1 Western of all time.
You know I love CineFix but I agree it just feels like they were trying to be smart with they’re choices but it just came off as stupid, and even though there are western themes the reason it’s not the best western film is because it’s not a western Star Wars is a sci-if movie because even though like I said there are themes for every blaster toting outlaw who doesn’t fit in there’s also ancient space samurai who use laser swords where as TGTBATU is a full on spaghetti western and a damn good one at that.
@@joejohnson5242 I'm do 100% agree with you. But to me Star Wars is not even a Scifi movie it a fantasy movie. Yes it is set in space and have space ships but it also have space wizards and stuff.
Tried to be clever? Star Wars is a space opera, based on western films, but with fancy space hardware instead of horses and guns. The clever ones were the makers of this garbage.
Obviously picked by someone who went to a post-modernist film school (probably in California) trying to destroy and subvert the genre by deconstructing it. So... the list is basically a verbose piece of crap trying to prove their own cleverness.
Ah yes, Jabba the Hutt, my favourite gun-slinging cowboy...
Once Upon A Time in the West is a movie that can never be remade. Fonda, Robards and Bronson are irreplaceable with any actors today.
Nobody but Leone could take America's leading man....Henry Fonda ....and cast him as a degenerate baby killer!!
Don't forget Strode and Elam!! The first 2 guys shot in that movie are LEGENDS!!
Robards is so good in this movie.
That was a weird movie set in a western setting. Did not like it.
@@Kwawzeye00 Wow. Woody Strode. Amazing!
My favorite western is Jurassic Park. Because you know Alan Grant wears a cowboy hat...
Very funny😝
And there is sand
Good Point
👏👏👏
Top 10 Westerns according to Hellen Keller
Ouch
Once Upon A Time In The West has indescribably gorgeous cinematography and music. It can still make tears well up in my eyes over 50 years later.
This list made tears of anger well up in my eyes...
Its soooooo gooooood
Such a great movie. Gets better every time I see it.
I’m so glad to see others that believe Once Upon A Tim In The West is superior to The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly.
@@74camarolt The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly is the best western ever made followed by The Wild Bunch.
I realize it wasn't a movie, but a mini-series, but Lonesome Dove is the greatest western of all time. You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll celebrate, and you will be thankful you saw it. It's a one-of-a-kind type of show that never gets old and stands the test of time. It's a love story, it's a friend's story, it's a taming the frontier story, it's a good guys vs bad guys story, and it's brutal picture of the old west and old times story. Never have I gone through ALL the extremes of emotion as I did watching Lonesome Dove. Nothing comes close.
Lonesome Dove is as good as it gets
I just saw it for the first time and enjoyed it tremendously but it was really just a series of adventures based on the McMurtry book. You could practically hear the pages turning. The dialog is probably the best though. Duvall and Jones were perfect co-stars and built to a very touching ending.
Going with the reasoning they used to pick Star Wars, then they clearly overlooked Lawrence of Arabia, it fits the bill perfectly and has better horses.
and is 100 times a better movie!!
Picking the top westerns is like picking the top movies. Unless a big fat *IMO* is added.
While I see your point it’s still a war film.
@@christopherharvie8716 then call it a "best war films" list.
When Star Wars is your pick for the best western of all time, you lose all credibility. Full stop.
What floydoid said. This was the sorriest and most intellectually constipated countdown of movies I have ever seen.
Couldn't say it better ... throws a real doubt over how serious this video is beyond click-bait.
Absolutely. A junk list. Star Wars? Sukiyaki? F*** off!
@N Red River is in my top #2. Great choice.
@N Red River is my #1. Will Penny is my #2.
You pick Star Wars for a western ??? WTF !
My personal favorites are Outlaw Josie Wales and Jeremiah Johnson .
My favorite westerns are: the good, the bad, and the ugly. High Plains Drifter. Tomb stone. I'll be your huckleberry. Lol
@@frankspikes4867 I like the cut of your jib. (Good list.)
@@greense65 Thank you sir, or mam. Which ever you happen to be.
@@frankspikes4867 You're welcome. (A sir, FWIW.)
Tracy Stubblèfield I was wondering about Jeremiah Johnson? Is it a western? Or a pre-western western? I think it takes place in the 1840s. As for Star Wars being included in this list, I believe CineFix is just trying to provoke a reaction from its viewers without thought of damage to its credibility.
There’s 16.02 minutes I’ll never get back.
Top Sci-Fi of all time...Tombstone 🙃
LMAO
The Good, Bad and The Ugly IS THEE BEST...Period
Yeah. I don't know anybody, and I know hundreds of folks, who doesn't think that TGTBATU is the top Western of all time. Even one of the top MOVIES of all time, never mind
that it was a western. Vast panoramic vistas, unparalleled cinematography, fantastic acting ( Eli Wallach deserved a best supporting actor oscar), a smash-hit
soundtrack, great plot and story-line. "Blonde....blondie!...you know what you are?...just a dirty #@^&$ %$&^@#! !
@@colkilgore100 Eli Wallach gets more screen time the Clint Eastwood. It's really his story.
@@jeremypnet Don't die Blondie! Don't die like that pig! I'm your friend, I go get water. Here, no! don't drink, it's no good for you!
That's an excellent point Jeremy, I've never heard anyone posit it before. But now that you do, it makes a lot of sense. I wonder what everybody else thinks. Rigt now, I say that Clint is the leading role, with Eli 2nd and Lee 3rd. But a reasonable argument might change my mind.
I wouldn't say it's the best, but it's a good western for sure. Top 20
I like most of Clint Eastwood's other westerns more than GB&U. High Plains Drifter, Josie Wales and Pale Rider especially.
Cinefix: We are a group of professional film historians and critics.
Also Cinefix: The best westerns are set in space.
All of the choices were in categories, star wars is only the best non-western western you nit-wit.
@@st_orlie Was that insult necessary?
@@elijahwilliamson3623 what else is an insult for besides use on a person who can't understand simple things?
@@st_orlieOk sir. I quiver in your supreme intelligence. I shall not juxtapose facts on Cinefix no longer. I'll dedicate more time to the little things like friends and taking care of my family rather than disturbing the UA-cam comment Gods as yourself.
@@elijahwilliamson3623 ok.
X) Tom Horn
9) Unforgiven
8) McCabe & Mrs Miller
7) Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid
6) The Good the Bad & the Ugly
5) Once Upon a Time in the West
4) Two Mules for Sister Sara
3) Jeremiah Johnson
2) The Outlaw Josey Wales
1) Honey I Shrunk the Kids
The list should be:
1.The good the bad and the ugly.
Every other western
Absolutely true
Quentin Tarantino is right
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
is not only the best western of all time
It's the best movie of all time
Eli Wallach clearly deserved an Oscar for it
@@robertwiesler381 "there's only 2 kinds of people in this world, my friend".
@@tonym994 exactly
Just make sure that you are
the one with the loaded gun
Greetings from Austria, my friend
any list that doesn't include Lonesome Dove a joke, and no mention of the outlaw Jose wales.... ridiculous .
@@robertwiesler381 ganz genau! lG aus Polen
The Good, The Bad, And the Ugly. That is bae!
NET Alliance - Star Wars Fun exactly!
100% Agree.
This top 10s bullshit.
*NET Alliance - Star Wars Fun* why are you calling it shit? because Bae is the danish word for shit you know.....
Agreed. I love star wars, but #1 in a top 10 best westerns........come on
P Pipe
I know, right!!!!!
Jeremiah Johnson is an awesome western!!!
Blazing Saddles is a western farce and a spoof of all westerns made by Mel Brooks!
Why was it even mentioned in this list???
When hipsters make a best western list
🧔
🧔♂️
I bet someone really wanted to place T2 Judgement Day for number 1 as the most western movie survey
Jack Elam does not get enough recognition. He has played supporting roles in so many westerns
Don't forget the Gunfighter & so many .ore....
Partly his fault! - J. Elam got offered to play the evil gunslinger in "Shane", but he declined saying it had not enough lines for him! - And so, a black panther like Jack Palance made Shane into a classic ! -
# 1 and #2 are absolutely ridiculous to be included in a list of the best "westerns". Which then makes you entire list not credible.
Agree, completely invalidates this whole thing........key word here was "Westerns".
@@jameshouser7283 You fools don't even know about the entire concept of "Space Westerns" do you? Do some work, Space Westerns have been around since the 30's and many of them you know, Outland, Westworld, Buck Rogers, Flash Gordon, Lost in Space, Star Trek, yes Star Wars, and Solo:A Star Wars Story etc., to those I am sure only a few know of like Northwest Smith, etc.
so on point!!
@@toddstevens13 , yes but you say Star Wars A New Hope is the Best Western of all time is not credible. Not saying it isn't possibly a decent Western. It is a sci-fi fantasy with Western elements. Certainly not enough to be labeled higher than The Good The Bad and The Ugly. Ridiculous.
@@shawne7228 Sorry I never said it was the best of all time, please go back and check, I was just giving a group of Space Westerns. Cheers.
No "The magnificent seven" and no "The good, the bad and the ugly"? It must be a joke...
atrompazos74 along with “The Cowboys”. I can name several others that could out do this guys top 10
Tombstone > Magnificent 7
@@thedeeareee785 I really like "Tombstone", and it could easily be in my westerns' top10 list, but not over "The magnificent 7".
I have never been drunk enough to consider Star Wars as a western, you guys must have had some good stuff.
Jim Ward Star Wars is a western if you are stone drunk. Therefore I’m sure those guys must have been drunk.
Toughest moonshine in all of the 134 states
@@nan16cd No it isn’t it is inspired by the western but isn’t one would you call Kurosawa films westerns because they were inspired by them ?
Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid is iconic the chemistry of Newman Hollywood Royalty & Redford will never b forgotten
A top ten without The Outlaw Josie Wales, Jeremiah Johnson, The Wild Bunch, and The Magnificent Seven is a joke. No credibility whatsoever.
Totally with you on Outlaw Josie Wales - second best western ever after the Searchers.
"Wupped em again Josey." "We have a saying to the winner goes the spoils, we also have a saying don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining ." Look its JOSEY WALES. 😂😂
James Selbach and without any Dollar Trilogy movies
Not to forget Pale Rider, a favorite Eastwood of mine.
Silverado, Open Range, Lawman, Invitation to a Gunfighter, Warlock , 3:10 to Yuma, Red River , ....
No.1 & 2 is a Joke! “The Wildbunch” is my personal Favorite Western
Definitely
@@gregthoms5232 One Eyed Jack's
Marlon brando
Hayden I disagree. But either way tho list is ignorant.
Star wars. You must be joking!
My thoughts exactly. Lucas may have combined patterns from old westerns and samurai movies set in a sci-fi motif, but Star Wars itself is NOT a western. It’s sci-fi. A space opera. Not western or samurai.
So, yeah. There’s no way that counts.
maybe if you are under 10 ?
@ watch Chantos Land, thrn come talk to me.!
Bro did us dirty in the end with whatever I heard.
"Sometimes not all westerns take place in the west" well... they kinda do or else they wouldn't be westerns, they sure as shit don't take place in a galaxy far far away
😂👍
The Western is more of an idea created by films than an actual physical location.
Example? Django Unchained. Set in the South, not the West. But it’s clearly a Western. In style, in plotting, etc.
No Country for Old Men is a pseudo-Western despite being set in 1970s Texas.
How about Cowboy Bebop?
@@YungM.D. O.K. BUT STAR WARS. THAT IS LIKE SAYING THE GOD FATHER IS A COMEDY, BECAUSE SOMEONE LAUGHED IN IT
Well no, we could hpwerver say the godfather was a comedy if they used the same structual design, tropes and ideas as comedies do.
ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST is the number 1 Western that has ever been made. The texture of it, the styling, the slow studied pacing, even the action is artistically drawn. It has superb tension throughout the film without horror gimmicks or fast cut chases. The music, the sound effects, characterization, visuals, situations, all work together to achieve the tension. Leone used the juxtaposition of power and vulnerability to create threat. All with classic Italian romance where it has to look good. The film is a work of art and is superior to all the rest in my humble opinion.
That movie has like 20 minutes if great stuff, surrounded by uncharismatic conversations and one really hot lady
But another western movie of all time is The Magnificent Seven, The Good, The Bad & The Ugly, Unforgiven, Red River & underrated comedy Cat Ballou.
@@azimisyauqieabdulwahab9401 The greatest comedy western of all time is Brook's Blazing Saddles. IMO
@@spencerhjalseth7288 agree like it but blah....searchers or the man who shot liberty valance by far....mind you love war wagon too
Sound design was incredible but "For A Few Dollars More" was my favourite of the Leone westerns.
My favourite western of all time will always be Citizen Kane.
Blade Runner is far superior, idiot.
@@agi238 dude Spiderman 3 it's a superior western
@@gerarquiaFM nah birth of a nation is
Guys come down, that’s his opinion we all know that best will always be a wrinkle in time
@@jamesleodelacruz facts
People in the comments obviously have no idea how CineFix designs lists:
Their "Top Tens" are never really in order. They choose ten different categories of a certain type of film and then choose the best film in that category. They had a section on the 50s Golden Age, they had one on Revisionist westerns, they had one on Spaghetti westerns (of which Once Upon a Time in the West barely edged out over The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly), hell they even had one on the crazy relationship between Japanese Samurai films and the American Western (that's why Sukiyaki Western Django is "#2"). So for that last category, the "#1" spot, they decided they wanted to stretch the definition of a Western as far as they could and see what other films that are not technically "westerns" use similar themes and ideas. To them, Star Wars fit the bill, and I could really see how they came to that conclusion. After all, what is a Western but a call to adventure, the exploration of new lands, and the neverending struggle between "good" and "evil"?
Westerns are arts works (films, books, television shows, and paintings right off; see Frederic Remington; we focus on movies) devoted to telling romanticized tales of the American West (see Westward Expansion in History of the United States).
While the western has been popular throughout the history of movies, as the United States progresses farther away from the period depicted, the western has begun to diminish in importance, though (as of August 2003) it has been revived with the Kevin Costner western Open Range.
The fundamental plots of Westerns are simple. Life is reduced to its elements: there are no computers, no cellphones, no cars, no electricity. None of the complications and technology of modern life. You have:
The clothes on your back.
Your gun, and
Your horse.
And that's usually it. The horse may be optional. The art of the Western takes these simple elements and tell simple morality stories, setting them against the spectacular scenery of the American West. The best Western directors practically made / make the scenery an unpaid star of the movie.
Definition of Western aka nothing to do with Star Wars
I know, but its a no sense
Yeah, I hear ya. But that doesn't make this list suck any less.....
First of all I think that is a terrible way to make a 'best of' list.
If I wanted to know what the best 'revisionist sci-fi musical western' was, then I would watch that top ten list!!!
Just list what you think are the top ten and if the top 5 happen to be 'samurai westerns' ...so be it
1 the good, the bad and the ugly
2 Once upon a time in the west
3 The outlaw Josey Wales.
4 Django unchained
5 the quick and the dead.
i loved the remake of true grit that little girl was amazing and the support cast was fabulous
Yes, The Quick And The Dead is definitely one of my all time favorites! Walmart had it on dvd for about $3.00 late last year and I snagged that sucker up and skipped some stuff on the grocery list to buy it! Gene Hackman and Diane Lane are superb in that one!!!
@@TheRomaduce I saw it but don;t recall it at all. I'll hafts go back and watch it again. Rooster Cogburn was his character originally right? So True Grit was a take off from that movie and character? I gotta go watch it now. You piqued my curiosity. :)
This is 16 minutes and 2 seconds of my life I’m never getting back...
God damn this top ten fell apart. What an insult to those who love westerns.
@Stellvia Hoenheim baah baah
@Stellvia Hoenheim Baaaaaaaaaah
Agreed, who picked the top 3
@Stellvia Hoenheim OK boomer
You knew you were in trouble when Shane was number nine
I'm surprised Quigley Down Under didn't get a mention. A great example of a western story which takes place in another part of the world. It's classic all the way through with an awesome ending.
It would have been had it not been for ‘Star Wars’, the western😂
Quigley is so underrated.
The reason you could not surpass the John Wayne-Clint Eastwood era in westerns is because few after could compare, and you know it.
I'll take Eastwood and especially Lee Van Cleef over Wayne anyday.
You are so right! I can't get enough of a good western.....
@@nonfinale685 Actors matter far more than that. Eastwood, Wallach and Van Cleef were essential to the GBU. Eastwood to all three films. The director may be the head, but actor is the hands. It's collaborative on every level. There is just something about Wayne's goofy, hokey persona I can't get by. Eastwood's cold, soft spoken persona is what I personify the western antihero to be. And Lee Van Cleef is one of the most underrated actors ever.
@@nonfinale685 I agree with most of that, but I'm not so sure the Dollars trilogy would have hit like it did without Eastwood. I don't see him as expendable there. And on the flip side, I don't think it would have hit like it did if Leone wasn't helming it. I read that Charles Bronson had turned down that role...not sure which...can't see it having the same impact. He sure changed his tune for Once Upon a Time in the West didn't he? Haha. I definitely prefer the Spaghetti Westerns to the American westerns at the time, with the exception of Peckinpah's Wild Bunch and Ballad of Cable Hogue.
@@nonfinale685 I absolutely LOVED Van Cleef in the Big Gundown.
Let’s talk about tombstone... it ain’t here Goddamn it it’s one of the most amazing westerns
OF ALL FUCKING TIME
@holykuhrap ohh man your so lucky how was it I’ve always wanted to go since I’m a huge fan of the west and history and it would be a dream come true if I got to visit Tombstone
@VSJ 1987 OK Val Kilmer was cheesy thank you for the information not val Kilmer plying doc was probably one of the most iconic western characters ever not even talking about how many quotes val produced from that one movie
Probably THE best
I’ll be your huckleberry
15 minutes to find out your best western is Star Wars, it's been two days now and I haven't stopped laughing. Unsubscribe.
Not necessarily a fan of every choice, but very fond of the process used to come up with the list. Breaking down Westerns into subcategories allowed the creator to showcase many films beyond the 10 and defend their picks from the subcategories. Additionally, the creator of the list gets around the most obvious weakness of the approach (more than one movie in a category belonging on the list), by introducing a tie in that category…. Brilliant!
Instead of the searchers being number 10 it should be first and
No mention of 310 to Yuma. That's not right
I agree. searchers is the greatest western of all time.
@Samsung McKone if you get a chance check out the original 3:10 to Yuma, the Remake was great however the original with Glenn Ford and Van Heflin is totally worth your time.
I couldn't watch this after they said Searchers was number 10. I can understand it maybe not being number one, especially taking into account I don't believe anybody at this channel is over the age of 40. But number 10? Couldn't continue to watch.
High Noon, Gary Cooper, The Seachers John Wayne, Shane Alan Ladd,High Plains Drifter Clint East Wood, The man who shot the liberty Valence James Stewart, John Wayne and Lee Marvin, My darling Clementine, Henry Fonda, Victor Mature ad the List goes ON and On.
I love how you do your Top 10: Divide a genre in 10 categories and pick the #1 from each categorie. Some people will hate you for it, but I think it's the best way to cover a genre to any person, from the neophyte to the hardcore fan.
It's amazing how many regular viewers haven't picked up on that. Hence all the "I can't believe [MOVIE] didn't make the list!" comments that plague the comments section each vid.
dessfred I understand and appreciate their methodology, but this list is still very poor.
dessfred I agree. Every time a new list video is dropped I grab a note pad and jot down the movies that look interesting they mention.
Justin McDonald - I noted down four to watch later, myself... and I don't really even like westerns.
Mike O'. I just recently got into westerns and lists like this help a lot. But I already own all but Shane and Pat Garret and Billy the Kid. Haven't watched them all yet, but I will eventually. Haha
I'm a huge fan of westerns. What I'm a fan of is John Ford/John Wayne in Stagecoach (1939) and The Searchers (1956), Henry Fonda in My Darling Clementine (1946) and The Ox Bow Incident (1943), and especially Clint Eastwood in The Good, The Bad, and the Ugly (1966), For A Few Dollars More (1965), and A Fistful of Dollars (1964). All of which are great movies.
Star Wars on a western list. This is quite clearly a channel that's not to be taken seriously.
Indeed. I've noted not to watch anymore of their content. Plus The Good, the Bad and the Ugly didn't make their list.
This is probably one of the best movie based UA-cam channels. Of everything of theirs I've seen, this is by far the strangest. Granted I do understand some of the odd choices, they are abrasive.
how many lists have you watched by this channel?
They make lists which talk about a topic, how far its influence can reach, or how far it can be artistically manipulated.
This isn't a list saying "these are the ten best westerns", this is a list saying that "these are ten examples of the western, today, now and into the future. These are examples of how they have grown, died, and revived in a multitude of forms. This is the power of the creative mind."
If you got pissed off by some of their inclusions then that's OK, but realize that it's not meant to be a top ten list in the classic sense, more of an accessible (and clickbait-y) mould to sneak a video essay about westerns into.
You should be more pissed that they tricked you into getting film school'd.
You owe me 14:34 of my life back.
The fact that none of the dollars trilogy featured voids this list
At least he put Once upon a time in the west on this list which is good right?
Right?
Right?
Right????????
They were mentioned in the segment on Leone when OUATITW was selected as the top Leone western. I have to agree.
The Mona Lisa is the number 1 greatest photograph of all time
Silverado and Quigley down under are two of my favorites.
Silverado is so underrated, with great actors about to hit their primes, and chemistry usually reserved for actor who've done theater together for some time. Its A great balance of fun, action, sadness, and comedy rolled into a movie that didn't need to be 3 hours long to tell the story...
There’s a difference between being a western and being INSPIRED by westerns. This channel clearly doesn’t know the difference....
I think you're a bunch of idiots. Lonesome Dove was probably the best western ever made with Unforgiven coming in a close second. Did any of you ever watch a western before you came up with this list?
YES! EXACTLY!
Star Wars, Guardians of the Galaxy, others: being *inspired* by westerns is the correct description and way of putting it.
In the immortal words of John McEnroe. "YOU CAN'T BE SERIOUS!!!"
It was fun to watch and you showed a lot of my favorite oaters. Having grown up in the fifties and sixties on black and white cowboy flicks, both at the movies and on weekend TV, there will always be a place in my heart for a good western. I think you got quite imaginative in cross dressing the genres and I really don't mind, nor does the order you have chosen to put them in. Just seeing most of my favorites ( Treasure of the Sierra Madre somehow got lost in the editing) was a real treat. Thank you for this Vid
Well there's 15 minutes of my life I won't get back. Stars Wars FFS?
Amen to that
Yeah, I think that's the worst part of it. I skipped through a lot because the narrator went on and on and on...well, you get the picture. Picking Star Wars as number 1 was kind of a silly thing to do, not edgy or deep as CineFlix may think. And having it at number 1, then doing a, "Oh, you SciFi fans were made it wasn't on our list, see, we put it on this one" trope was just, I don't know, the term "elitist" comes to mind. That and, "we're just being jerks."
I'm don't know who 'we' is, but 'we' surely doesn't know much about Westerns
I would put Blazing Saddles on this list waaay before ever putting Star Wars on it.
Lol, kids whining that The Good, the Bad and the Ugly isn't #1 because it's the only western they've ever seen. I love you Cinefix
Gawk gawk gawk
There's two kinds of people my friend...those who think that "the good, the bad and the ugly" is the best western movie in all times and those who included "star wars" as a western movie....
You dig.
And I bet the half-wits who made this list don't realize you're using a Good the Bad and the Ugly pun right there.... nice work
I love once upon a time in the west and the good, the bad and the ugly, they deserved to be in the list together. Even if spaghetti westerns only have one spot in the list, that was a shame.
Steffen Ackermann yeah corbucci and his movie django is a favourite in my house. And another good film by Sollima would be La resa dei conti, a great movie for Lee Van Cleef.
I totally agree with this.
Vicente Ortega Rubilar Agree. Cinefix missed the mark by a mile on most of this list
I think Once Upon a Time is perfect and is Leone's best film.
Mike Martin, well.......
Top Two (2) picks here are INSANE! The title is TOP TEN "WESTERNS"
Clovis Mossey I agree 100%
I just watched sukiyaki western django.
It's DEFINITIVELY a western. It's also reeeeeeaaaally weird, and I loved it.
Gerit Flesner Thanks for the tip. I will try to catch it.
@@nan16cd np. I was in agreement with you, but wanted to see what made them think so highly of it. I'm glad I did. The only problem is the heavy japanese accents can be difficult to understand.
It's free on youtube. That's where I watched it.
Gerit Flesner Thanks again I did not think that it would be on UA-cam
My dad had a DVD of "Once upon a Time in the West". I watched it, and it's what got me interested in westerns.
The Wild Bunch should have been on the list!
They mentioned it, but not nearly as much as I think it deserves. *Sigh* Can't thumbs-up more than once for this comment, tho!
They already had Peckinpah with Pat Garett and Billy the Kid - but I agree, the Wild Bunch is a better film altogether, exploring similar themes, but with a more energetic style to t
At number one!
Hands down! One of the 3 best ever made. Josie Wales, and Once Upon a Time in the West.
Can’t believe you left out Silverado. In the early 80’s, when everyone was saying that the western was a dieing art form, this movie came along and just about singlehandedly saved the genre. From the very start, to the finish, Lawrence Kasdan, with the help of an all star cast, and a majestic film score, brought us a rip snortin, shootem up that pulled the genre from the scrap heap, and reminded everyone just how much pure fun a western can be. The final showdown between Kevin Kline, the reluctant gunslinger with a heart of gold, and Brian Dennehy’s crooked town sheriff, with Kline’s backdrop - a church, and Dennehy’s - an empty semi desert, was the perfect metaphor for the fight between good and evil that nothing does better than the western.😃👍🏻
"That ain't right."
-Mal
I could not take Silverado seriously, especially the main bad guy Brian Dennehy. Dennehy just treated his Cobb character like a joke. He did a better job in First Blood as Sherriff Will Teasle who hasseled Rambo. But in Silverado, as I pointed out, I really couldn't take him seriously. Kevin Costner was also a joke in that movie. He acted like such a clown .
I'll never understand why people thought it was so great. It had the same basic western plot with no surprises. It was actually slow and boring.
Dannt Glover was probably the best part in that whole movie and that was it.
"Goodbye Cobb."
"Goodbye Paden."
Two friends parting ways...
Silverado was cool. Kevin Costner has some awesome westerns under his belt like Dances With Wolves, Open Range, Hatfield McCoys, Yellowstone, even Wyatt Earp was good despite being overshadowed by Tombstone.
@@wiseguymaybe well aren't you pleasant, the reason Costner's character acted as a reckless clown is because he was young and reckless, so that's how he portrayed the character on screen...
The Big Country.
Best acting and best actors. Best written and all the elements mentioned and then some. Best Music! Awesome scenes.
Burl Ives deservedly won an Oscar for his complex portrayal. Gregory Peck, Charlton Heston, Jean Simmons, Carol Baker and a villainous Chuck Conners.
Watch it and see for yourself.
You are right. Not mentioned enough.
Great film but I'd argue that it's too similar to Shane.
This dude really put some random Japanese movie and a sci fi spectacle over Once upon a time in the west
well there' goes a wasted 15 mins of my life that I'll never get back......
once upon a time in the west is # 1 on my list, not just for a western but one of the greatest pictures ever made.
You had me till your top two.. Come on star wars???
You forgot to say. "REALLY!!!"
9 westerns better than The Searchers? No way.
You have a point.
One of my absolute favorite movies of all time is the remake of 310 to Yuma. I didn't expect it to make the list but an honorable mention would have been cool.
Ben Foster made one of my favorite villains in that film. I thought he was going to go on to big things after that, but people seemed to fail to notice him. Hopefully he'll get better roles after his great turn in Hell Or High Water.
Erik Dresner It's a crime he's never been nominated. For either that movie or Hell or High Water. He was much better than Bridges in that movie.
Benny Ren 100% agree, just re-watched last week. I love it, definitely in my top 10 westerns.
Benny Ren j
I love that movie !!
You obviously forgot about the Muppets Take Manhattan.
Best comment.
And dont forget, Pee Wees big adventure!
This Muppets comment is HILARIOUS !!!
lololol
Everyone who had anything to do with the making of this top 10 list should be permanently banned from UA-cam.
Nonsense. We all need something to laugh or complain about occasionally.
cdeford Thanks for that sobering reality-check. Speaking of ‘laughter’, are you by any chance familiar with the concept of sarcasm?
Sarcasm is hard to convey on the internet, especially when making a simple statement. You can't just expect people to be able to read your mind or intent. That's what emojis are for.
@@cdeford W
Cinefix is run by a bunch of clowns, this video must be the joke of century.To think these films were reviewed and voted for from credible sources...
Now I understand how Leslie Nielsen and Priscilla Pressley came out laughing hysterically out of the movie theater that had just shown Platoon. This Star Wars pick as the best Western made me laugh as well.
Once Upon a Time in the West is my favorite. The initial 20 minutes are perfect.
I'd add the twenty after that as well. Jill's introduction and the scene at the bar are beautifully done as well
Well I will go on and add 20 more minutes...
I'll add another 20 minutes more
Lame story & very movie it is👎
Stars Wars?? Unsubscribed!!
Sorry to see you go, enjoy WatchMojo and their Top 10 Really Obvious Lists Of Films Everyone's Heard Of, Mostly From The Last 5 Years.
1) The Good The Bad and The Ugly & The Searchers (Share top Spot)
2) Once Upon A Time In The West
3) True Grit
4) Silver-ado
5) The Outlaw Josey Wales
6) The Oxbow Incident
7) Unforgiven
8) The Wild Bunch
9) Winchester 73
10) Magnificent Seven & Heavens Gate (Share 10th spot)
Any western with Clint Eastwood. Silver dollar, Lonesome dove (series), Into the West (series), 3:10 to Yuma, Young Guns & Young Guns II are honorable mentions.
Now that's a list i can at least have a sensible conversation over.......I would have Jose Wales at #1
There was a movie about angels having a cookout. It was called...Heaven's Grate.
A Cinefix list where the comments are outraged... First time i see this
What ah jipp....none of Clint Eastwoods trilogy made it? Stupid list...
Right?! I wouldn't have called Once Upon a Time in the West as better than The Good The Bad and the Ugly.
My favorite Eastwood is The Outlaw Josie Wales.
Oh, he just mentioned it.
@@ricosuave6898 Well I would have, so there's that
@@72Kraken Well, there's no accounting for taste.
@@ricosuave6898 and in the end, taste is just subjective. But putting Star Wars at the top of the list should be consider a hate crime
Luckily, this is the first ranking list I've ever seen from CineFix.
I say luckily because I can only imagine how much time it has saved me in looking up your other content, which I can only assume is equally ludicrous.
But at least you feel clever. And you can't put a price on that...
You top it with Japan and Starwars? Smoke another one and try again.
A Japanese movies would have been fine, if you know, it was an actual decent movie like seven samurai
The entire Dollars trilogy should be on here