What the federal budget means for you | The Big Story

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 кві 2024
  • In the weeks leading up to Tuesday's budget announcement, the federal government has been hammering a message that this document would make life more affordable for Canadians.
    Does it accomplish that? What's in here that will matter to your wallet in the months to come? What takes aim at trying to bring down the cost of living over the next several years? And who's going to end up paying for all this?
    GUEST: Jim Stanford, economist and Director of The Centre for Future Work
    Episode link: play.headliner.app/episode/20...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 201

  • @glenfetterley1347
    @glenfetterley1347 Місяць тому +70

    Freeland is astonishing. Those who work harder and make good choices are penalized. She is despicable.

    • @davidperri8862
      @davidperri8862 Місяць тому

      She's a Fascist. The whole government is.

    • @commisioner0514
      @commisioner0514 Місяць тому +6

      She has to be able to afford that amphetamine addiction somehow.

    • @Section5_CdnIntelService
      @Section5_CdnIntelService Місяць тому +1

      Privet, comrade! Kak pozhivayet prezident Putin?

    • @MuSTea849
      @MuSTea849 Місяць тому +2

      Nobody is penalized. Super rich people have to pay taxes from their hefty profits too, get used to it. The government has a duty and responsibility to decrease income gap and make sure to provide basic needs and rights to people in need as well.
      Central Bank creates the money out of thin air, as long as they spend in the own currency, there is no issue. However, they need to stop favoring their super rich buddies who are causing the inflation over high percentage of low and middle income population. It has been going faulty for far too long.

    • @commisioner0514
      @commisioner0514 Місяць тому

      @@MuSTea849 lol, you think 250k is rich?

  • @skbuydens7717
    @skbuydens7717 Місяць тому +30

    More bad news. Does government ever lower taxes?

  • @gy5240
    @gy5240 Місяць тому +16

    They really don't want investors in Canada.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      Bahahahahaha...YOu obviously didn't listen clown! New start ups are excepmt

  • @chrisministerofsmartarsery3322
    @chrisministerofsmartarsery3322 Місяць тому +23

    How? We don’t have enough people in the trades to build all the required houses. For every 5-6 trades people soon retiring we have 1 young person entering.

    • @whatdoyouwantfromme1029
      @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Місяць тому +2

      " there are millions of places and solutions to housing people in Canada but politicians are not serious about it 👈

    • @chrisministerofsmartarsery3322
      @chrisministerofsmartarsery3322 Місяць тому +8

      @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Millions of places? Canada lets in over a million people a year & builds just over 200,000 homes. Where are these millions of places?

    • @whatdoyouwantfromme1029
      @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Місяць тому +1

      @@chrisministerofsmartarsery3322 The problem is not finding places to rent but the rent being charged $3000 a month 🙏😑👎🏻🇨🇦

    • @chrisministerofsmartarsery3322
      @chrisministerofsmartarsery3322 Місяць тому +5

      @@whatdoyouwantfromme1029 If you rented out a property & your mortgage recently doubled, would you increase the rent on your property? Or eat the cost?

    • @whatdoyouwantfromme1029
      @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Місяць тому +5

      @@chrisministerofsmartarsery3322 I repeat 🔁 there are plenty of places to live in Canada but they are unaffordable to most people 😑👍 " would you pay $1500 a month for a room not bigger than a box? 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @aetherfox4404
    @aetherfox4404 Місяць тому +34

    The interest on the national debt payments are now up to 54 Billion dollars a year. We are losing over a billion dollars a week to interest payments alone now, good job you crooks...

    • @jeremyfitzpatrick7772
      @jeremyfitzpatrick7772 Місяць тому +1

      Who does the intrest payments go to?

    • @ryans1623
      @ryans1623 Місяць тому +5

      @@jeremyfitzpatrick7772 Private banks, such as bank of Canada.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому +1

      And how does that effect you? Not at all!!

    • @beefwellington7791
      @beefwellington7791 Місяць тому +7

      @@jamesbrennenman8671 You do not understand economics very well do you?

    • @OvechkinRbk9k
      @OvechkinRbk9k Місяць тому

      @@jamesbrennenman8671 You are a loser

  • @ArKay-nj2nh
    @ArKay-nj2nh Місяць тому +12

    Twitchia Frauland, another 40 Billion in Dept.

  • @user-kv4kp4co1r
    @user-kv4kp4co1r Місяць тому +11

    Initially I was under the impression that the only positive aspect of this budget was its potential to curb mortgage fraud. However, upon a detailed examination I learned, "Budget 2024 announces the government's intention to consult with the mortgage industry on making available a tool through the Canada Revenue Agency to complement the existing strategies of financial institutions to verify borrower income for mortgages." So, it's just an intention to consult, not an actual thing. It seems like it’s all talk and no action. Now it's high time to talk about voting them out?

  • @whatdoyouwantfromme1029
    @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Місяць тому +17

    " $200 dollars a month to helping disabled people 🇨🇦👈 shameful Canada always discriminating against the most vulnerable people in Canada 🇨🇦👎🏻

    • @Platos-Den
      @Platos-Den Місяць тому

      You know how many lazy people are scammers and are getting disability checks????

    • @dianneferraro7969
      @dianneferraro7969 Місяць тому +4

      They don't have enough money, they gave a large portion to Ukraine instead of Canadians.

    • @nervosadustbolt9642
      @nervosadustbolt9642 Місяць тому

      You're more vulnerable than a baby? I don't think so.. A baby can't even type, but here you are doing it just fine.

    • @whatdoyouwantfromme1029
      @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Місяць тому +4

      @@nervosadustbolt9642 thanks for your compassion towards disabled people siir or ma'am 😑👍

    • @whatdoyouwantfromme1029
      @whatdoyouwantfromme1029 Місяць тому +4

      @@dianneferraro7969 exactly 👍 our hard working people taxes being sent to other countries 🇨🇦😑👎🏻

  • @FranklinFleming-lm1yu
    @FranklinFleming-lm1yu Місяць тому +20

    Just here to say we haven't had a budget in about a decade.. this was no different.

  • @l8knight845
    @l8knight845 Місяць тому +10

    Capital gains are just luck!!! You heard it here first!!!😂

  • @huggy1712
    @huggy1712 Місяць тому +25

    This is why All Canadians need to make a stand we All need to say No to the Lie-berals

  • @MARIALOPES-hy2vp
    @MARIALOPES-hy2vp Місяць тому +46

    Useless budget for middle class people. There is shortage of trades people, so there is no way that millions of houses will be built. This budget is to lure people to vote for the Liberals. What about the deficit? How can any country prosper with such a huge deficit? Freeland is insane. Does she have any knowledge on how to balance the spending? She and her cronies need to go away for good.

    • @alancarter2489
      @alancarter2489 Місяць тому +12

      They cancelled the parliamentary Disney Plus account to compensate for the extra spending!

    • @73cupcake
      @73cupcake Місяць тому +6

      Now is when they bring in the pods to live in. There will be a shortage of sea cans next 😅

    • @createone100
      @createone100 Місяць тому +5

      You are clearly a Conservative voter who bought into Poilievre’s rantings.

    • @LockedInWithLovebirds
      @LockedInWithLovebirds Місяць тому

      @@createone100 listen man, nobody is buying these fake posts supporting the Liberals out of control spending. One would have to be a genuine idiot to support this at this point. You're either a bot, paid for influencer, or part of the money train because im doubtful you're just an idiot, but either way you're part of the problem.

    • @MuSTea849
      @MuSTea849 Місяць тому

      Budget deficit in the own currency doesn't matter. The Central Bank can create the Canadian Dollar out of thin air and transfer to the treasury, and the treasury never has to pay the debt in the own currency. The important part is how they are spending it, and if they are spending it for people in need as well in order to reduce the income gap.
      If government borrows in different currency and uses that money for inefficient projects or to favor some rich, that causes the real problem. The government or banks do not need to balance the spending as they can create money in their own currency without backing it up with gold or anything in modern monetary system.

  • @adohmnail6445
    @adohmnail6445 Місяць тому +4

    The new budget means higher inflation and higher taxes, yet again. All of this equals hardship for Canadians.

  • @jkb358
    @jkb358 Місяць тому +8

    We are f*cked.

  • @crazyralph6386
    @crazyralph6386 Місяць тому +3

    She was completely doped up. Drug testing needs to be mandatory in Parliament.

  • @LockedInWithLovebirds
    @LockedInWithLovebirds Місяць тому +12

    If this doesn't cause Canadians to all rise up to throw this walking disaster out of office now, nothing will.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      Ya because Dental Care and Pharmacare are bad!! Shut up!!

  • @Islandwaterjet
    @Islandwaterjet Місяць тому +24

    The fed budget means more debt and more frivolous wasteful spending on nonsense we do not need and do not want.

    • @MaryanneBrownLegere
      @MaryanneBrownLegere Місяць тому

      A good chunk of our tax money is going to foreign countries!😡 Soon Canadian's won't even own Canada!

  • @jeremyfitzpatrick7772
    @jeremyfitzpatrick7772 Місяць тому +5

    Who does the interest payments go to ?

  • @maureenallen416
    @maureenallen416 Місяць тому +14

    Carbon. Taxes. Is a big joke. What happen to
    2.5 billion dollars. It What missing. Why.

  • @williamterrymasters1934
    @williamterrymasters1934 Місяць тому +17

    Ephesians 6:12
    King James Version
    12 For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places.

  • @MaryanneBrownLegere
    @MaryanneBrownLegere Місяць тому +2

    He's only trying to get Reelected .....if he really cared about Canadians, he wouldn't have sent us all to the poor house!

  • @VikingMale
    @VikingMale Місяць тому +12

    Marxism

  • @critter9857
    @critter9857 Місяць тому +4

    no the bill/budget wont help us

  • @RavenRuled
    @RavenRuled Місяць тому +1

    The problem is you have a ton of people paying for programs for other people who for the most part are lazy, trying to game the system or aren't even Canadians. There are lots of scams where money is funneled into other countries. Who pays? Tax payers. Canada is constantly dumping billions into other countries who will only come back for more. Gov't constantly gives money to people with no strings attached. Its a spending problem not a revenue problem.

  • @steveswhirld
    @steveswhirld Місяць тому +3

    VOTE "PRACTICAL" PARTY !!!

    • @hatter5834
      @hatter5834 Місяць тому +1

      What does that mean?

    • @steveswhirld
      @steveswhirld Місяць тому +1

      @@hatter5834 thanks for asking . i am running for prime minister ! its an all new party in the making . the old ways/libs and cons havent worked out . we are not conservative ,liberal or communist , we are practical . for more info please read my comments and replies to others .

    • @hatter5834
      @hatter5834 Місяць тому

      @steveswhirld while that is a great sentiment and everyone knows we need something new and more people in politics, you have to publicize your actual policies. What does "practical" mean in this sense. What are you planning to do differently that current parties aren't doing? What expertise do you have that makes you a candidate with better understanding? Marketing yourself as something different is simply what the other parties have been doing for generations at this point. To be different, you actually have to be different. Do you have a website/resource that outlines your policies?

    • @steveswhirld
      @steveswhirld Місяць тому +1

      @@hatter5834 i politely replied for you to see my comments,you didnt even read the comment youre replying too ,they have and will explain my self and party . i have to start from somewhere . right ? as for experiance ,i am a real person ,not an out of touch with reality politician !

    • @hatter5834
      @hatter5834 Місяць тому

      @steveswhirld I have read your comments and many comments you've posted across this comment section, and none of them have detailed your policies. That's why I asked what do you mean so you have a chance to actually talk about them or point to a place where that information can be found. Simply being different or "not a politician" is not enough. That's fluff. Yes, everyone has to start somewhere, but without concrete policies and ideas, you're simply like every other person in politics right now. What are your beliefs? Be concrete, transparent, and actually be different instead of running on contrarianism. If you're serious about this anyways

  • @sampellettieri5823
    @sampellettieri5823 Місяць тому +15

    This guest and host don’t understand how govt created this problem Come on

    • @OttawaInHD
      @OttawaInHD Місяць тому +1

      The so called “economist” gave the budget a ‘B’ 🤦🏿‍♂️ That’s all we need to know and stop listening to this

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      He's the economist not you boy!! He knows the truth unlike you PP fanboy who just regurgitates right-wing talking points that are false!!

  • @westockfarmsltd6339
    @westockfarmsltd6339 Місяць тому +1

    The only reason why there wasn’t a recession is because the feds grew the public sector by thousands and they are fudging the inflation numbers. Do the numbers on stats can. Very curious there weigh scale

  • @spritPA2024
    @spritPA2024 Місяць тому +3

    Jagmeet Singh is a child. He cares not about interest on the deficit drawing more money than healthcare itself. NDP you need to find a new leader and NOW!

  • @philliplegare1899
    @philliplegare1899 Місяць тому +1

    Misery and pain!

  • @Jura77jura
    @Jura77jura Місяць тому +2

    rip Canada

  • @millerpestcontrol5364
    @millerpestcontrol5364 Місяць тому +1

    Best budget is absolute trash for Canada’s economy and wealth

  • @ChrisReher
    @ChrisReher Місяць тому +6

    Wish gov would weigh in on health care. Paid taxes all my life and now I don't have a doctor. My vote will go to whoever seems to have a plan to stop the Premiers' dangerous and underhanded schemes to privatized health care.

    • @steveswhirld
      @steveswhirld Місяць тому

      consider voting ''practical'' party thank you

    • @ZenCorvus
      @ZenCorvus Місяць тому

      Government health care is failing all-over and you literally whine to fight and keep what's not working while vilified something we don't even have.
      Thanks for wrecking this country.

  • @yos9862
    @yos9862 Місяць тому +2

    drive all investors to other country! and then put more tax on mid class, make this country to 3rd word . This the teacher working hard to make it true.

    • @hatter5834
      @hatter5834 Місяць тому

      You do realise most 3rd world countries don't tax their businesses and wealthy, right. The whole point of being a "more developed" country is better division of resources

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      You're clueless!! New businesses are excempt!! Plus, taxing the 1% for speculation is fair!!

  • @ashbuckle9218
    @ashbuckle9218 Місяць тому

    This effectively makes investing via Limited Partnerships the way to go holding assets in your own name instead of using holdco/trust structures. Problem is that anyone using one of these structures will get a personal tax hit to transfer interests out. Real tax bill based on a paper value shift. Kind of a tricky situation

  • @ahsan101
    @ahsan101 Місяць тому +1

    NOTHING Trudeau has done has helped my cost of living. I'm a middle class 9-5 worker

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      Free Dental Care doesn't help?? Just stop

    • @ahsan101
      @ahsan101 Місяць тому +1

      @@jamesbrennenman8671 already covered under work plan. So no it didn't help me.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      @@ahsan101 But it's helping millions of others but you only care about yourself like most conservatives

  • @PhuPhillipTrinh
    @PhuPhillipTrinh Місяць тому +2

    What’s with all the blackpill comments? This was a good discussion for sureb

  • @kenmck7802
    @kenmck7802 Місяць тому +1

    These "leaders" who are ..suupppossseedd to be sooo highly educated( hence the biiiiggg pay AND PENSION , you know) annnndddd alllll they ALL got ...ever is..."RAISE the TAXES, make up some NEW taxes". Yeah sure why not ? Do WE ALL not make...Trudeau money? Hey people vote for ME. I'll ONLY raise your taxes HALF as much as the other ones AND PAY me HALF. That would be GENEROUS enough for...ME.

  • @joycegifford8826
    @joycegifford8826 Місяць тому

    “The definition of equity comes for the public administration literature it was written by a man named George Frederickson and the definition is an administered political economy in which shares are adjusted so that citizens are made equal. Does that sound like anything you’ve heard of before? Like SOCIALISM. They are going to administer an economy to make shares equal. The only difference between equity in SOCIALISM, is the type of property that they redistribute. The type of shares they’re going to redistribute is social and cultural capital in addition to economic and material capital.” James Lindsey(European Union Speech) Wake up Canada before it is too late.

  • @johnhess9443
    @johnhess9443 Місяць тому +2

    It means this country has been done for a while. Since around the takeover, when the coalition started with the two of the lowest voted parties from our last mess of an election formed a majority govt without public concent.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      You are clueless. It is called democracy. A majority of people are getting a say!!

    • @piouspigeon9327
      @piouspigeon9327 Місяць тому +3

      @@jamesbrennenman867130% of the country voted for him then they combined with NDP…. So not really…

    • @johnhess9443
      @johnhess9443 Місяць тому

      @jamesbrennenman8671 two parties who lost the popular vote joining to secure majority powers without public concent? Insulating them from any accountability while persecuting whistle-blowers, political opponents and blocking investigations into their corruption.
      That's not democracy. You're clueless. Watch your mouth and try to learn something about what's being done to your country.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      @@piouspigeon9327 If you add up the votes between the 2 parties you get a majority

    • @piouspigeon9327
      @piouspigeon9327 Місяць тому +3

      @@jamesbrennenman8671 oh cause the people who voted NDP meant to vote liberal all along? Cause that’s how it works lol

  • @73cupcake
    @73cupcake Місяць тому +3

    The income you work for should only be taxed once. If you take what's left over and invest it and get lucky, there should be no second round of taxes. The govt misspends it anyway.

  • @Thomasgogouakriwele
    @Thomasgogouakriwele Місяць тому

    we support tanks for all

  • @tommacdonald3142
    @tommacdonald3142 Місяць тому +3

    Singh you better wake up and put trudeau out you will be nexted

    • @ThinkPolisComing4Me
      @ThinkPolisComing4Me Місяць тому +1

      he’s good, he will be rich and have a full pension. This is what politics are about.

  • @daviddunning8357
    @daviddunning8357 Місяць тому +8

    More taxes…

  • @enderwiggen3638
    @enderwiggen3638 Місяць тому

    It means higher taxes, more erosion of middle class … and a bunch more poor people who will get token handouts that don’t really help.
    But because of the new programs the federal government will need to hire people which will make a minister a larger empire which will allow them to get paid more and all their new staff will get the same gold retirement packages. And Canada will be one step closer to where people will be paying more than 50% of their income to taxes (property tax, income tax, sales tax, provincial tax, plus all the increases to those same taxes)

  • @dougfoley6175
    @dougfoley6175 Місяць тому +1

    Burger flippers have no skin in the game, so they won't be skinned, is that it then?

  • @greatlambrini8722
    @greatlambrini8722 Місяць тому +3

    I gave after 5 minutes of clips and talking.

  • @73cupcake
    @73cupcake Місяць тому +2

    This guy's hatred of rich people is obvious.

    • @ZenCorvus
      @ZenCorvus Місяць тому

      Most on the far left hate what they don't have.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      Oh just stop!! Liberals AND Conservatives are schills for the rich

  • @BudzzableRides
    @BudzzableRides Місяць тому +8

    The carbon tax increase will increase inflation, this budget does nothing to help people.

    • @user-xm4wk1hk6c
      @user-xm4wk1hk6c Місяць тому +1

      They want us to starve, it’s that simple. The Trudeau diet! 🧅

  • @francie5161
    @francie5161 Місяць тому

    I don't think anyone here has bothered to listen to this report! Or you wouldn't be griping. Poilievre Parrots.

  • @budoshi1981
    @budoshi1981 Місяць тому +1

    couldn't care less, raise the salaries of middle class , lower the taxes across canada and trudeau needs to quite, the rest are air to me .

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      The governement doesn't set wages Eistein...Corporations do

  • @reggosse3901
    @reggosse3901 Місяць тому +1

    Government spending more money than they earn helps no one because it causes inflation. You're expert does not know what he speaks. The budget gets an F if you understand anything about economics. Think!

  • @williamterrymasters1934
    @williamterrymasters1934 Місяць тому

    Look at people that preach on the streets that don’t Believe the Cross and think their GOD 😂

  • @philipsimmonds1103
    @philipsimmonds1103 Місяць тому +10

    💩..>>.. liberal budget.

    • @Liberal_From_Prairies689
      @Liberal_From_Prairies689 Місяць тому

      Russian bot. You call programs to help low income and modest income Canadians "sh*t"? Typical conservative. Only cares about the wealthy.

    • @CommonClowns
      @CommonClowns Місяць тому +1

      💩= your brain

    • @aetherfox4404
      @aetherfox4404 Місяць тому

      @@CommonClowns Name checks out, get back under Justins desk knob gobbler.

    • @ZenCorvus
      @ZenCorvus Місяць тому

      Ya hearing the far left comment on anyone's brain is laughable.
      Commonclown you are.

  • @matthewhodge9748
    @matthewhodge9748 Місяць тому +4

    20:35 the word is not angry anymore. its enraging.
    21:19 thats a joke.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      Imagine....giving the people cheaper prescriptions and free dental is enraging...shut up!!

    • @matthewhodge9748
      @matthewhodge9748 Місяць тому

      @@jamesbrennenman8671 stop taking my money and pay for it yourself. you want dental? maybe brush your teeth. or get a job with benefits. stop relying on others to get what YOU want. and certainly stop putting YOUR hands in MY pockets.

    • @jamesbrennenman8671
      @jamesbrennenman8671 Місяць тому

      @@matthewhodge9748 OH shut up loser!! Dental was supposed to be included under our universal health care deal back in the day. Finally we have it and you are mad?? What a loser!! No on has their hand in your pocket you selfish goon!! You'll be thankful the next time you're at the dentist and it doesn't cost you anything!! What a selfish goof you are...typical conservative!!

  • @marks.2909
    @marks.2909 Місяць тому +1

    LOL ,.

  • @LiplessEagle
    @LiplessEagle Місяць тому +3

    It means keep gathering weapons

    • @CommonClowns
      @CommonClowns Місяць тому

      Tin foil a good investment? You quack.

  • @queenbigb
    @queenbigb Місяць тому

    This podcast is so misleading… if I sell a house like a cottage that is 500000+++ dollars I will have to pay more in capital gains on that sale.

  • @williamterrymasters1934
    @williamterrymasters1934 Місяць тому

    Practical is a man a male in the flesh and a woman a female in the flesh by Christ

  • @steveswhirld
    @steveswhirld Місяць тому +1

    vote "PRACTICAL' party .CANADA FIRST

  • @kylehutchinson5016
    @kylehutchinson5016 Місяць тому +2

    Watch: “X-Factor winner reveals world’s secret religion by Altiyan Childs.” The documentary is five hours long.

  • @greatlambrini8722
    @greatlambrini8722 Місяць тому

    Could you just get on with it!

  • @williamterrymasters1934
    @williamterrymasters1934 Місяць тому

    You people that Believe flat earth draw a Cross attach the 4 comers of the earth by Christ 😂

  • @williamterrymasters1934
    @williamterrymasters1934 Місяць тому

    Everything is for a reason the world is powered and controlled by Spirit not flesh and blood 😂

  • @Meeksballs
    @Meeksballs Місяць тому +5

    0:56 they don't understand or care! And they are going to do nothing to help besides spew empty promises

  • @JahBreed
    @JahBreed Місяць тому

    To me? Listening to a majority whine and cry about whatever media gives them too while I wait to die behind being volunteered to sacrifice everything to serve the provincial budget here on Manitoba.😀The same thing I've done everyday since about Xmas 2021.

  • @MaryanneBrownLegere
    @MaryanneBrownLegere Місяць тому

    Too Little, Too Late ...and I didn't hear anything mentioned about breaks for seniors!!

  • @SkyPlayz12366
    @SkyPlayz12366 Місяць тому

    OMG I hate her she is so annoying