Strange Airplane NOISES! Boeing vs Airbus
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- Use the link www.nordvpn.org/pilot and the Coupon code "pilot" to get 70% OFF on NordVPN and one month for FREE!
Have you ever wondered about why the Airbus A320 gives out the Howling noise when it flies over you on approach? Or what that barking sound is as you have just pushed back? Maybe you have been flight-spotting and wondered about why the Boeing 737 and the Airbus A320 sound so different during takeoff?
In todays videos I will be explaining a few of these phenomenons and I think you will be surprised!
To join continue discussing this and anything else, aviation related, get the FREE Mentour Aviation app. Use the link below to download it and join a fantastic community of 22000 monthly users. 👇
📲
If you like what you see on the channel and you want to support my work by joining my Patreon crew, use the link belo. Thank you! 👇
/ mentourpilot
If you are interested in following my everyday work, and see pictures from my life, my cockpit etc, use the following link 👇
/ mentour_pilot
I want to send out a special "Thank YOU" to the videos and channels that were featured in todays video. Check them out below and show them some love! 👇
Horizon Productions SFL (Airbus A320 vs Boeing 737 takeoff sounds)
• {TrueSound}™ Airbus A3...
Becker Aviation (Howling A320 on approach)
• HOWLING Sky Airline Ai...
PlaneSpottingBerlin Aviation videos (Longest Barking A320 ever)
• LONGEST Airbus A320 BA...
Check out the Nord VPN deal in the video using www.nordvpn.org/pilot for a free month plus 70% discount. There is also a special anniversary deal on right now, check it out
Mentour Pilot I like the deal, but $125.00 at a time is way too hard for me.
nah its nord vpn man
the way they handled that situation is a no go for me
The way they handled their server breach was shady. Sweeping it under the rug hoping no one notices.
That’s a no-go for me too.
@@springbok4015 wouldnt mind using them if they didnt try to cover it up.
every major service will and has been "hacked", it's just a part of the information age.
(this is why you should not use the same password for everything, and if you get an email from a service you use saying that you should reset your password, RESET YOUR PASSWORD)
how these companies deal with this is the beef ive got
Mentour Pilot how did you get your pilot license
I'll be totally honest that the howling noise from an overflying A320 actually sounds quite cool. Probably the coolest noise a jet makes actually.
Rolls Royce jet engines are so smooth and quiet
I disagree. A departing 787 sounds so AWESOME!
@@cockatoo010 Alright bro, go listen to an A320 take off with Pratt & Whitneys. Come back and tell me what you think then.
BAE146 has a unique cool noise after takeoff due to its flap design
Not sure if you'd think that if you lived close to an airport...
I love your canine co-pilot’s reaction to the “woof” sound from the A-320!
One of my dogs goes nuts if she hears barking in videos. I use headphones to watch dog videos. :)
🙄
0:20 That barking sound, dog looks up😁😁
Saw that.😂😂
Lol saw it as well 🐕
How can you resist petting your wonderful little woofers??
I've been a technical training developer, trainer and evaluator for over 35 years. Few people understand how difficult it is to simply explain complex subjects to a non-technical audience. You do a magnificent job sir. 5/5. You understand your material and target audience, and consistently maintain your discussions at that level. For those that are not professional trainers; it is VERY difficult to train technical subjects without level jumps and slipping into using technical jargon without explanations. I commend you sir for a great channel with interesting and educational content.
I have been hearing this kind of whining sound for like 10 years now (since my home is right below an approach path), and it's till this moment I know they're actually the A320
I am a frequent but nervous flyer; you’ve helped me substantially understand the routines of commercial flight, making for much more pleasurable flights. Thank you.
Keep up the good work
Until you recognize red alarm clues during flight 😂😂😂
Don’t ask me how i know :)
I'm an aviation enthusiast living near a busy airport, and I can now tell a Boeing apart from an Airbus, just by sound. Thanks. ;)
Cant hear anything from baby crying in 8th row and crazy lady screaming in row 16
Hahaha!
Crazy lady? Haven't had one of those yet. We'll, not the screaming kind. I did have one on hello kitty slippers some time ago.
@@Hans-gb4mv Holy crap... Did they actually let someone on a plane with hello kitty slipers? Damn, I rather have the Corona cirus that that!
Simple solution, stop flying RyanAir
@@poruatokin could be easyjet too
You forgot the noise made by the airline's accountants when they realize they had an A380 run into a headwind...
That’s an incredibly different type of whining.
Yep, little did they know that their combined painful sighs could have repelled the wind if it was aimed properly.
Can someone explain the joke for a newcomer to the airplane world
@@RAiNfORAiNbOW my guess: A380 = high (absolute) fuel consumption, because big ass plane. Headwind: more fuel consumption.
What Tom said. Someone has to worry about the cost of that fuel...
Everyone thought I was crazy because I could tell there was an A320 overhead by the noise! Glad to know that it IS an actual thing and I'm not crazy.
Oh my friend you’re not crazy. I work in ground handling at my local airport and I always know what kind of aircraft is taking off without looking. I only realised I’d subconsciously learnt this when I spooked my entire team when the 787-800 landed but I had no way to see it from my position and remarked. “Oh the Dreamliner is down.” (The common name of the 787.)
I finally know what the Bus whine on approach is - thank you. I work at an airfield over which eastbound aircraft fly on approach to Boston. They typically are at 9500 or so according to FR24 so a bit higher then you mention. I finally identified the Airbus as the noise maker after repeated tracking of individual flights. Had now idea what that noise was.
Do those many people actually dislike that howling sound? Growing up, that was the sound that got me excited in aircraft. Such an alluring sound.
I don’t get it either. One of the biggest benefits I have from working at an airport is that if my supervisors or managers have been stupid and I’m now cranky, I can just go outside to the pedestrian areas of the airfield and just watch the planes takeoff and land. It isn’t long before I’m soothed back into a good mood.
I like how you tell us to check out Captain Joe’s videos, because you’re showing that you 2 aren’t rivals, and it’s just very considerate of you! :)
Hilarious timing captioning right above your dog's head as you were talking about the barking noise. 😂
Here's one I heard recently. From the emergency exit door, right at rotation and touch down, a loud whistling sound that rose in pitch, ending with a pop. I thought maybe it had to do with cabin air pressure and a leak in the exit door seal. I told the attendant when I disembarked.
That’s very likely correct!
Ive heard that one before, it whistles higher and higher until it stops, I assumed that it was just the door getting seated with internal pressure until it finally seals.
For the barking sound I was always picturing ground crew with a giant handsaw cutting cargo holds open ;)
Funny how I'm always looking to see what the dogs are doing in the background. I love dogs
dogs are the fury clowns of the world 🐶
The howling noise from an A320 is COOL.
Looks like a jet fighter or at least something powerful
Exactly my thoughts on it, reminds me a bit of the sound of huge capacitors charging up on something like a big pulse laser or a railgun or coilgun! The high pitched sound of that power building gives me goosebumps every time! About a month ago on my commute home from work I had the good luck to pass Cleveland's airport right as a jet (even though the highway is right next to the airport and they fly right over as they land, there are ofc way less flights these days) flew directly over me to land! My windows were down and it made that incredibly powerful noise, so now I know it was an Airbus!
It is a powerful machine regardless. ^.^
Boeing: Adds chevron to engines to reduce noise.
Airbus: *howls*
Boeing: Adds chevron to engines to reduce noise.
Airbus: howls
*Vulcan:*
@@deep.space.12 roars
Which is hilarious to me considering it's usually Europe that whines about airplane noise, compared to the US. XD
I think the A320s high pitched whining sound sounds awesome, anyone agree? I've been tempted to set it as my phone ringtone 😂
😂
I like it too. 😊
Inbound call (whistle)
No it sounds pretty terrible. It sounds like metal rubbing. Not a good sound.
i like the 330s sound more.
but the 320 sounds decent at full power
You are simply a genius when it comes to aviation knowledge! I had long been searching for answers related to the Airbus A320's unique flyby noises and you finally answered it! Thanks a ton sir! Your fan forever!
Glad to be able to help!
Fascinating! Mind you, the "barking dog" sounds to me like someone sawing wood.
Yes, like sawing wood to me also.
Nobody at all:
Airbus 320: Whooo, I'm a Stuka in disguise, hear me whine!
Your channel has been so fascinating to me over the last couple months. I'm someone terrified of flying but your videos help relieve that anxiety by teaching how these incredible machines work.
Two years late but if you want to know the insane levels of effort we ground handlers put into helping make the aircraft safe I’m happy to answer or explain. And if I don’t know the answer, give me a couple days and I can just ask some of the engineers and pilots. They’re used to my curiosity by now.
i thought it was somekind of airbrake engaged when i heard that howling noise....:D and the engines on the airbus sound way coooler...
This comment is like saying you are putting a GE90 on the new 777x and saying the GE90 sounds better on the 777x. The a320 has the same engines as the 737.
I love when your dogs talk : )
roger that.
I love that the FlyByWire team for the A320NX mod in MSFS2020 added a lot of these sounds. Even the ground crew call horn works. It's by far my favorite jet to fly because of all the improvements they did with it.
Thank you for sharing this with everyone! Great video! When I have to ride in back on the bus i find myself looking around from where I’m sitting just to watch people’s expressions when the “dog barks”. Well thank you again, and all the best from the west coast of Florida USA!!!
The ghostly howl from the underwing apertures on the A320 are very clear when that plane comes over my house at 10,000ft and 350mph (thanks Plane Finder and Flightradar24). I’ll miss that sound
Yeh same it comes over about 3,500 - 5,000 ft I used to hear it a lot especially when I was younger , but not really anymore as hardly any flights and EasyJet don’t fly to Newcastle much anymore
thank you ... always wondered about the "barking" though I refer to as "Manually cranking the hamster wheel in the engines"!
I asked this question on the APP and it was answered quickly, I was on a Thomas cook last year before they went under so keep up the good work👍
Hi petter , yes your app is fabulous my husband who dislikes flying has gained a lot of comfort knowing all is good , perfectly normal then sit back and enjoy ! As I always do ! Thanks
That’s great to hear!
The howling sound of the A320 series is quite distinctive, where I live many of our flights are A319 or A321s. I have also noticed a howling sound (but of different tone) on CRJ-200s and Challenger jets upon landing. Good video Mentour Pilot
me flying before I knew @mentour : "hopefully the flight will be very quiet without scarry noises today". Me flying since I know the mentour channel: hopefully today something special happens at the flight or I hear new noises that I get aware of new functions.
Last time when I was flying to Oslo from Budapest, the plane was almost empty, so the cabin was really quiet. I was sitting in the 6th row, I could hear when the pilot disconnected the autopilot before landing :D
You can hear it very clearly on an Airbus from the first few rows not so much in a boeing !
I’ve heard an engine fire test on pushback a few times.
@@uzaiyaro That is part of the engine start procedure engine fire test 1 and 2 it's normal procedure though the alarm can sound scary for nervous flyers !
Xavier Lignieres Yeah, it was an A321 neo, with very quiet engines :)
6:24 The dog 🐕 is leaving the chat.
I have heard that barking sound and I thought it was the flaps.
Me too!
I thought a dog was chasing the plane as they do cars.
@@boraxsopanic2670 Lol
I thought the brakes...maybe the engine brakes
hahaha, the thumbnail picture is so great 👍👍👍👍😂😂😂
Congratulations ! Mentour Pilot is one of the most informative and interesting productions anywhere. Definitely recommended for all those who fly and who take an interest in aviation !!
Thank you! So glad you think so
Loved the reasoning and explanation over the A320 whining on approach. Having lived under the LHR flightpath and now under FLN approach I know this noise! Brilliant to know why 👍
Very familiar with the PTU pump noise too 🙂
I remember watching the CaptainJoe video on the "bark" sound and instantly thought of this at the start. I love how you linked to his video & provided links to everyone else's videos in the video description. You're obviously such a smart guy already but it's nice that you also spread the credit out to everyone else as well. UA-cam is full of people who just recycle other peoples videos and try make out it was their original idea in the first place but you're not like that.
"As Always......" keep up the great videos :D
Mentour Pilot, thank you! You are a rare gem: among the thousands of pilots out there, you are one of the very few to explain these things! So thank you again. This shows also your passion for everything that flies.
I thought this video would be about cockpit noises when I clicked on it. WOOP WOOP PULL UP and AIRSPEED LOW. You should do one of those.
Love the extra “comments” from the pup. 😊 I really enjoy your informative videos!
I have heard it" The barking" on Air New Zealand's A320's when I have been flying. I never could make out what was making that noise on approach but thanks to you, mystery solved.
When it comes to whining and howling nothing can beat an F104 Starfighter.
Great info as usual,Thanks Bill
Very informative video!! Thanks for posting
Thank you. Always wondered about these sounds.
I really loved this video. I live near an airport, I imagine in the direction of the final approach or the take off direction. Every day I hear the engines' noises. It's a true symphony. I'll start paying attention to the noises, check if I can listen to an A320.
I love how you guys cross pollinate each other. I am a huge fan of this channel, Capt Joe, Dutch pilot girl, Juan the Blancolirio guy, the 74 gear guy, and Alex the A380 guy. As a whole you guys do so much for the aviation community. It makes it 100 times better to trust you when you all are lockstep about knowledge, conspiracy theories (no!), and appropriate references and sources.
Just another amazing video from Captain. Thanks a lot for your efforts to explain in such simple terms very complex aviation issues. Thanks once again!!!!!
Friday AND a new video?! Thoroughly enjoyed and smashed the hell out of the like button Captain.
Great video very informative which is why I love this channel…….loved the captions on your doggo too. :)
On the last point about the high pitched sound that the A320’s vents make, I think it’s similar to the whistle P-51 Mustangs make when they’re doing acrobatics. Apparently, the whistling comes from air moving over the gun ports during certain angles of attack.
Liked the sound of the flap/slat extender motor on the 737-200.
I live in Asunción, were lots of A320 from LATAM, Avianca and recently JetSmart operates, you can hear that whinning noise at certain speeds, not only on approach but on take-off also and i always been curious about that particular noise on A320's but no on 737 or others. I first tought it was the V2500 engine, then they operated the CFM's an got that noise too, i thought it was the Wingfences, then they brought the Sharklets but still making that lovely nice sound, but my anwser finally came with this video. I love that sound, i love your channel.
When I hear a flight above me, then I check flightradar24. Most often it is comercial aircraft about to land at EKCH 22 L.
I did not notice if Airbus or Boeing.
Thanks for video. Now I will notice companies not careing about noise when landing close to populated areas.
Your videos make me so calm ☺️
After over half a year I finally subscribed hahaha! I watch your videos (as well as other air disaster videos and other aviation videos) so much that I couldn’t tell that I wasn’t subscribed!
Lol wish you made this video before my Brazil flight ! We were so thrown off by that Taxi sound !! Thanks MENTOUR pilot !
Very informative, really enjoyed this vid!! 😉👍👍✌
Loved this explanation. Thank you Mentour!
When I hear that howling noise I take a look in Flightradar24 and it's always a British airways Airbus 319/32x. Approaching GOT from London. But I thought it was the engines, so thanks for explaining it is the holes.
Came here to learn about the PTU barking sound, but also was pleasantly surprised to see the sound I hear so often (14:07) explained. I live under one of the final approach paths for MAN about 15nm away, so I hear it pretty much daily, depending on the wind directions.
Very informative video. Thank you for posting.
Never gave it much thought how much I enjoyed listening to all those 3 noises, mostly the first two while flying
Best video thumbnail yet! Haha. Great video as usual.
Brilliantly explained Petter!
I always thought the barking sound was the pilot testing the rudder. Oh well, you learn something new every day! I also live in the approach path of Manchester, and I like the howling sound, didn't realise it was only the a320 until today. 🙂
The coolest thing I ever saw while flying was seeing the shadow of denser air on top of a wing.
Great video as always... thank you
"Strange Airplane NOISES! Boeing vs Airbus"
Boeing: "Pull up, pull up"
Airbus: .....
Hahaha...
Too soon
@@francislane4833 Thats what she said
I didn't understand hahaha
@Brummiewellington Boeing : too low terrain too low terrain pull up pull up.
Gravity. How hard can it be ?
Hello Mentour, great video as usual. One thing that wasn't covered which could worry some nervous flyers is why the engine noise, particularly in front of the engines, changes from a whine or roar into more of a 'Buzzsaw' at high power (such as takeoff and climb). My understanding is that it happens when the fan blades spin supersonic. Is that correct?
Great video Captain, very enlightening 👌🙂
There is a particular sound that i always hear on every a330 when i am sitting close to the wings (it sound like a metallic clunking noise followed few seconds later by a low pitched hiss) but i never found out what it is but my theory is that it might be something to do with the landing gear. it does that every two minutes or so when the plane is taxing . i would be curious to know what that sound is.
A very interesting and well=explained video - thanks Mentour!
Great explanations
Thanks a lot for the technical explanations. Always fascinating even for an engineer.
Glad you liked them!!
I would love a follow up on how that FOPP system works, can't find any details about it online and it seems really interesting. Good video as always, learned a new bit of trivia about airplanes regarding the FOPP VG :D
LOL, re-watched this video after you mentioned it in your most recent Mentour Now video, and literally had an A320 go over the final approach path above my house right after you finished explaining it! XD Nobody around here has bothered doing the upgrade it doesn't seem like.
Great explanation as always tks
Thank you for your detailed explanation
I always thought the C-5 Galaxy aircraft sounded pretty cool flying over. I can always recognize hearing it before I see it.
Interesting and clearly explained ❤️
The Airbus high whine on approach is the sound of my childhood living under an approach path
Dear Mentor Pilot , is there any extra reserve of power on takeoff that can be extracted from the engines in an emergency, or are you at 100% and that’s it , you used to here of extra boost that could be drawn on old piston engines for say for 5 minutes. Great channel keep up the good work.👍
A little bit is still there if we fire-wall the thrust. Up to around 103%
David Watt There’s a customer option on the 737-800 whereby an additional 1000lbs of thrust can be used for takeoff. If available, it can be selected in the FMC and is labelled ‘27k bump (TO-B)’.
If one of the engine is a bit off, why do you still want to lift off? Unless there are thousand of zombie running at your Six.
@@cyrilchui2811 Maybe because you crossed V1
@@MentourPilot many thanks , often wondered if the was a bit in reserve, now l know . 👍🇬🇧
Mentour Pilot: "alright?"
Me: *nods*
Mentour Pilot: "ok?"
Me: *nods*
Mentour Pilot: "with me so far?"
Me: *nods*
Mentour Pilot: *thumbs up* "great"
My Cat: "you know it's a recording, right? he cant see you."
Me: ... "did you just... nah, must be my imagination."
My Cat: *looks around* ... "meow."
i just cant stop nodding in acknowledgement every time you say those things.
This made me laughed my ass off
haha!
Lol same
I noticed that too... why is he asking me if I got it? He can’t see me! What if I said NO could you elaborate? 😆
pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis
DC-10/MD-11 CF6 engines at take-off power. The sound is awesome!
Finally an explanation to #2! ¡¡¡Muchas gracias!!!
This was awesome to watch/listen to. The 737 and A320 are the only commercial jets that come into Queenstown (despite it being an intl airport...yay mountains and mad terrain), and I live not far from the end of the runway, and this clarifies how I can tell who/what's taking off or landing far more clearly than my educated guessing!
Awesome video
I used to fly for work alot in the 90's and 2000's. Most of the flights were MD80's. I always wondered what the sound was during landing from below that sounded like a pump or something. It was like a mediumlow pitch siren sound.
I had thought the "barking" sound under the wings was screw gears moving as the landing gear were being deployed. So, even though I was wrong about it, I was still thinking it's a typical sound from normal operations. Lol
Finally found the Airbus "barking" sound explanation. First heard it on China Eastern airline, it was making one single longer noise, like a huge windshield wiper or a squeegee.
Glad you enjoyed the video!
I've missed these kinds of videos! :D
thanks for a very interesting video,
15:10 wow thanks heard this sound so often,thanks for the explanation thats super interesting!
I am a bit of a nervous flyer, so your videos are really great for me to understand what is going on! I used to be really afraid of flying when I was a kid (afraid of heights combined with travel sickness), but once I got on a 'testflight' for firsttime flyers it has been a lot better. (Little cityhopper going from Amsterdam to Zurich and back). Yeah sure, I still get nauseous when hit with bad turbulence and if I am not able to see an horizon when the plane takes a turn... but at least I can sit back and be comfortable most of the time.