First ever Traeger Vs Traeger | Cook off between Timberline XL and The New Woodridge Pro

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 43

  • @typoViz
    @typoViz 18 днів тому +3

    I've been looking for someone to do this video, thanks for making it!

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  18 днів тому +1

      @@typoViz your welcome - hope u enjoyed it or was helpful

  • @evolscott
    @evolscott 18 днів тому +3

    Great comparison! Thanks for the relevant content 👍

  • @bubbabailey1984
    @bubbabailey1984 18 днів тому +3

    Ordering the Woodridge Pro tomorrow, thank you for the comparison and GO VOLS

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  18 днів тому +1

      Yay. Go Vols. your a VOLS fan I assume? East TN by chance. Can't be a good $1000 Pellet Grill

    • @bubbabailey1984
      @bubbabailey1984 18 днів тому +1

      @ No sir I’m in GA, I would like to end up in East Tennessee before it’s all said and done. I’m not sure if it will be the best grill on the market but I can live with what it does and $1k is way better in my budget than $3-4k+

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  18 днів тому +1

      @ Honestly - I have cooked on it a few times and it’s a very good grill. Maybe not as booszzy as the timberline xl but at $1000 good price

    • @bubbabailey1984
      @bubbabailey1984 17 днів тому +1

      @ yea sir I agree totally. I’ve bought the Flatrock and absolutely love it so I figure the Woodridge will be comparable or better at the least

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  17 днів тому

      @@bubbabailey1984 How do you like the Flatrock? Working on getting one for early spring!

  • @markwoodside2650
    @markwoodside2650 17 днів тому +1

    Great video. I have a Timberline XL and love it. I would not have expected a difference in the cook so no surprise there. My previous grill was about the Woodbridge size (which is 860 sq in cooking area) and I then got the Timberline XL because I just wanted bigger (It is 1320 sq in cooking area which is 53.5% larger) and I did want the induction cooktop and the storage cabinet. Yes a lot more money for the same cook but I did want the size and I know the bells and whistles don’t cook any better (like having the wireless meater thermometer built in) but when I fill it up with different meats all at the same time (and I do fill the whole thing up sometimes) I really just wanted the size and I must admit I do enjoy bells and whistles too even though I pay too much for some. Great smokers no matter which you choose. Cheers, Mark

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  16 днів тому

      @@markwoodside2650 Mark - I agree with you my friend. Size and Bells are what I enjoy the most about mine as well

  • @chrisb321
    @chrisb321 17 днів тому +1

    Thanks for this, it's a good reality check when getting a bit carried away with the bells and whistles on these pellet grills. Woodridge pro and a spare 3K it is!

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  17 днів тому

      @@chrisb321 your welcome - glad it was helpful

  • @fresnobear559
    @fresnobear559 3 дні тому +1

    Great video

  • @trestongonzales6853
    @trestongonzales6853 15 днів тому +1

    Mine is getting delivered within the week. Got the woodridge pro!

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  15 днів тому +1

      @@trestongonzales6853 that’s awesome my friend

  • @charlessims2021
    @charlessims2021 16 днів тому +1

    ive got the xl, and i think its the best smoker ive ever had

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  16 днів тому

      @@charlessims2021 It’s is a really good smoker without a doubt. How many years you have owned it?

  • @melgarcia91945
    @melgarcia91945 18 днів тому +1

    Good video my friend but the truth is the cooking chambers are almost identical to each other. What you get are bells and whistles from the Timberline XL that makes it about $2500 more in price. With the Timberline you get an induction cooktop, a full color digital display and a full cabinet underneath. I'm sure I'm probably missing some other items as well and that is what makes it more money. Whether that's something people want to pay for or not I don't know. I personally bought the Ironwood XL, it fit what I wanted at that price point. I like the Super Smoke mode and keep warm mode on my Ironwood. Also, the Woodridge was not out yet when I bought my Ironwood.

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  18 днів тому

      Thanks bro - wanted to compare capabilities and not necessarily features but to see if there was a difference - Thanks Bro. Another video coming Friday

  • @plaze88
    @plaze88 16 днів тому +1

    Great vid, could u do one using the super smoke mode vs woodridge with out n seeing if there a diffeence

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  16 днів тому

      @@plaze88 I could have but wanted apples to apples in smoke capabilities

  • @TheJmc77
    @TheJmc77 5 днів тому

    I was looking at either the woodbridge pro or ironwood . But today I came across a timberline at 1200 off so 2500 and lets just saying Im itching to just pull the trigger and go all out! Lol

  • @MrBtown101
    @MrBtown101 17 днів тому +1

    what a lot of other reviewers are saying is the smoke flavour is lacking the new woodridge, and im surprised you never mentioned it either. maybe its just the use of super smoke on other higher model units.

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  17 днів тому

      @@MrBtown101 I didn’t use super smoke. I actually did mention the smoke flavor. You didn’t listen carefully near the end.

  • @fishbone937
    @fishbone937 3 дні тому +2

    easy bake oven off, pellet grills are so easy to use but they give no smoke flavor.

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  2 дні тому +1

      @@fishbone937 You must have never used a traeger

    • @fishbone937
      @fishbone937 2 дні тому +1

      @ I have owned two traegers, Weber smoke fire and camp chef. Tier list goes. Offset > Kamado > Kettle > Pellet > Oven. The difference between pellets and Kamados is staggering. Between kamados and offsets equally as staggering. Do a real world test, you’ll never look back.

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  2 дні тому

      @ I have a Kamado myself, a 250g reverse flow stick burner and Traeger for a pellet grill still works great.

    • @fishbone937
      @fishbone937 2 дні тому

      @@CookitwithTim then you already know lol, the pellets are great for ease of use. But lack any meaningful smoke flavor. I had a reverse flow before a traditional offset. I miss the reverse flow, held better temps and cooked faster.

  • @kevinkalina4288
    @kevinkalina4288 18 днів тому +2

    Did you use the super smoke setting?

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  18 днів тому

      I did not - kept everything the exact same and they even used the same amount of pellets.

    • @charlessims2021
      @charlessims2021 16 днів тому +1

      with my xl you dont even need to use, it smokes the whole area up!!!!!!

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  16 днів тому

      @@charlessims2021 agreed Charles

  • @BBQ-Rookie
    @BBQ-Rookie 18 днів тому +1

    How long did it take for your Woodridge pro to ship?

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  18 днів тому +2

      @@BBQ-Rookie less than a week had there not been any weather delays but snow caused it to be delayed by 6

    • @BBQ-Rookie
      @BBQ-Rookie 14 днів тому +1

      @ Mine is now due Wed. Mine was also delayed due to the snow. I ordered a week ago as of today. Any must have accessories for this grill?

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  14 днів тому

      @ it depends! Is this your first grill? Is it a second?

    • @CookitwithTim
      @CookitwithTim  14 днів тому

      @@BBQ-Rookie definitely the pop and lock storage bin and the paper towel dispenser and or the same for butcher paper