As a Charmed fan this is one of my favorites, the humor is on point, you can get a kick out of the Halliwells dialogue and the episode is just having a lot of fun with the camp. This is an episode that showcased how much fun was missing later on. Honestly bad outfits were my favorite thing about the show, I think that even if another Charmed related media comes out again (if they do) and it's well written I'd still want there to be tacky outfits, you can't have Charmed without them. For me I consider this one a good Halloween themed episode given the focus on horror parody.
I haven’t watched the reboot. Bc there didn’t need to be a reboot and one can only take so much girl power. Anyway, I suspect that they combed the previous seasons in search of any man hating arrogance they may have left out. It was already over the top, I can’t begin to imagine how bad it is now.
Always becomes a great day when a charmed rewind gets posted! Also i heard a podcast with James Comer (he's worked on Charmed and various Star Treks) and he mentioned how actors playing the sisters would leave set before filming wrapped for the day and that would end up leaving like guest stars or other actors to act opposite stand ins or whoever and the two star trek guys worked with Scott Bacula on Enterprise were like appalled that the stars of the show would do that and sang Scott's praises for his commitment to the show as their leader in universe and on set.
"Paige. Piper. Phoebe. Prue. Long ago, the four Charmed Ones lived together in a flawed but sometimes average show. Then, everything changed when the Executive Producers attacked"
"And Then There Were Two" is honestly the only line I can remember from this episode word for word. Even back then at 14 years old I thought it was a weird thing to say.
Of all the options in the poll, this was the only episode I'd never seen. I still want to see Phoebe in the Cinderella dress someday! Nevertheless, this one was very funny. I particularly like a demon who just shows up, tosses Phoebe around, smashes a grandfather clock and then just...leaves. "Yeah, I'm done. No bigger plan right now. See ya!"
listening to this podcast now makes me think the demon should have been called The Demon of Fantasy. Maybe pulls characters out of books. then he summons Billie by accident. and this inspires him to pull out movie monsters. the wizard during the evil source/queen phoebe arc had better illusions. and people have done anger better like thet demon of anger in season 3 that caused the sisters to lose their powers temporarily. and the demon of repression in the lady godiva episode. it was just done better ironically in later episodes for using anger or illusions. and rethinking the leo/piper/dan love triangle just made me realize how bad piper has treated both of them. it'd kinda of been funny if leo and dan started dating each other. fine line between love and hate. and piper forced to watch both of the guys she likes find happiness. even if it didn't work out they could be dating other people. leo/dan just would be fun even it was only temporary.
Hey Alison! I would love to see you tackle some of the more serious star trek episodes and to see your take on them. I found your video on the inner light a nice change of pace from the light-heartedness of the manic episodes (tho I still love the manic episodes). Might I suggest some more niche episodes such as DS9: "Paradise" or TNG: "Frame of Mind". I feel you would have some amazing things to say about them and I know you would be able to bring some of your characteristic good humor and balance it well with a nice deep dive into the subject matter. This would be awesome and your content has always been top shelf. Thanks for reading my comment!
I just got off work not long ago and was about to re-watch another Charmed rewind, I have seen them all several times 😂😂😂but then I saw this!!! Thank-you!!!! ❤❤❤
Charmed Rewind !!! My favorite podcast for cleaning the appartment, when im watching the original show i cant help thinking whos the Margoyle of every episode
I am so happy! New charmed rewind! I am watching the video and listening to it on Spotify. Charmed rewind is my most listened to podcast this year. Thank you for brightening my day.
"And then there were two" He followed Pheobe home from the movies thinking he could kill one witch but when he came in, suddenly, there was Prue. Now he has to deal with two witches. Hence^^
Here we go again. Time to take an hour and 20 minute break from work! Don’t remember this episode at all but I barley remember the early seasons. Thanks again for the awesome podcast ! 😊
I'm imagining a film where a young woman's father keeps murdering guys she went on bad dates with without her knowing about it. "You made her pay the bill!" *chop*
The mysterious line could have made a great line to introduce a Patreon Tie with the Phoeberella epiosde, But it seems that even in Charmed Rewind. That line will be forever shrouded in enigmatic incomprehension. "And Then There Were Two!"
'And then there were 2,' 100% refers to Phoebe and Prue. He followed Phoebe home because his spell didn't work on her and then Prue showed up and kicked his ass. He never saw Piper.
Okay, see the problem is "and then there were [number]" is a phrase that is pretty much always used subtractively , so it's initially confusing for him to say that because he just found out there were actually two people instead of one.
@@mastermarkus5307 If there was initial confusion that's one thing but it's been days later and they are analyzing the episode and they STILL can't figure out what he meant? Like come on. This show is often badly written but this one is on them.
Actually it was axe husb... dammit, she found out ;) Thanks for another great podcast. Although I can't possible beat Phelans Carman, I'll give my two cents: Margoyle: lonely "kill it before it dies" watcher, going into every showing of this horribly boring movie, where apparently the best scene is the annoying blond girl crying for Billy. Carman: That's tough this episode, but I'll give props to Derryl. He had a horrible day, dealing with violent theater audiences and brutally murderd people all over town, while nobody at Halliwell manor cared at all. Have some great holidays and I'm looking forward to more episodes in 2024! =)
I think Dan touching Prue's hand was supposed to be him saying goodbye to her? Because now that he and Piper aren't dating, they aren't going to be hanging out or whatever.
"So she freezes everything" Oh, yeah, that was something Piper could do. I was just listening to the previous Charmed Rewind, which was a Season 7 episode, so I had nearly forgotten that Piper could do anything other than commit explosive homicide and complain about baby-related things.
1:16:20 LMFAO at Allison losing it when Phelan gave the Demon of Illusion the Carman. I cry-laughed as much as the original Margoyle supercut from Hulkus Pocus.
i'd say the demon is supposed to be talking in pop culture references ("and then there were none" by agatha christie, trix are for kids, etc.) but it doesnt make any sense if he's supposed to be an illusion demon. im guessing it was a tv demon or something in an previous version of the script but they never bothered making it make sense
I'm assuming that the demon of illusion probably used to hide in books or painting before the invention of movies. If he was around today, he'd probably be hanging out inside of Shudder or Netflix.
I just watched another charmer video of urs and I genuinely can’t tell if you actually like the show or not😅 u take the piss out of it for the most part so im assuming not lol it was my favorite show growing up and I still love it idgf
They said he hid in horror movies because people who watch them are more prone or vulnerable to violence, I think. He wanted to spread the violence and anger. I think, it's been a while since I've watched this one. I thought Leo ordered an appetizer that was just nuts or something like that. Like a mixed bowl of cashews and peanuts or something.
The funny thing is, Cole appears in a later episode in “Kill it before it dies” saying he learned the trick from the Demon of Illusion. Apparently they were buddies 😂 Correct me if I’m wrong Charmanders, but when the Demon of Illusion flings Phoebe he says “get up you miserable witch” so it seems he followed her cause he knew she was a witch. When Prue flings him he says “and then there were two” cause he realized she was a witch as well.
Hey, your subspecies retrospectives are AMAZING and if u havent done one for Bloodrise yet, PleEEEEEEZ do......or else i will cry more than Michelle(if thats even possible:) Great work!!!!!!
Allison have you checked the lattest Shannen Doherty podcast with tons of info on the whole charmed drama? Gosh I do hope hext charmed rewind is about some juicy season 3 episode
I always ponder Kill it Before it Dies. I imagine that if the monster dies naturally it replicates like the mogwais in Gremlins. But if you kill it it won't. I don't know....
Apparently "This episode was one of the most difficult episodes to film because of the movie, and its interaction with the characters" if Charmed Wiki is any indications. I haven't the faintest idea what that's supposed to mean.
I'm starting to develop something for Shannen Doherty so this podcast was nice to listen to... I just need to figure out what that thing for Doherty is...
Allison I love you and Phelan please never go away, you guys are so effing funny. Please you and Phelan review Shannen's podcast JUST TO BE CLEAR W Shannon Doherty w Holly, where she reveals being fired from show and what Holly had to say. Please sweet lord, we need your HOT take on this. I don't want to live in a world wo it. Merry Christmas to you both.☃️🧸🪆🔔🎄🎅🤶
Piper and prue shouldnt technically be able to use their powers on characters when their out of the screen? Unless the demon used his magic, but what prevent Piper from sucessfully freezing like she would with a tv playing???
I don't get why a generic ax murder...why couldn't they have done Jason? Or Chucky? Or like you said. Pull them into the movie, and maybe their powers dont work, so they have to do a piwer of 3 spell, or potions?😊
According to my google search, Doodie is apparently Detroit slang for friend 🤷 it has to come from dude...I hope, otherwise yeah it's a very specific type of feces, then again they are siblings, calling each other little hard shits would be on brand
So if the fictional characters are killing are there actors going to get for murders what if one of the actors don't have a good of alibi is that person is just going to go to prison forever.
I'm being stalked by psycho killers and I hide in the SHOWER? favorite line of the series tbh
That's a good one.
Is pretty cool that they Spotlight a episode from the early Shannen Doherty seasons.
Speaking of Shannen Doherty, I do hope Allison and Phelan talk about the 2000 remake of Satan's School for Girls remake some day on Movie Nights.
"There was a good idea and they didn't execute it very well."
Charmed in a nutshell, lol
As a Charmed fan this is one of my favorites, the humor is on point, you can get a kick out of the Halliwells dialogue and the episode is just having a lot of fun with the camp. This is an episode that showcased how much fun was missing later on. Honestly bad outfits were my favorite thing about the show, I think that even if another Charmed related media comes out again (if they do) and it's well written I'd still want there to be tacky outfits, you can't have Charmed without them. For me I consider this one a good Halloween themed episode given the focus on horror parody.
I haven’t watched the reboot. Bc there didn’t need to be a reboot and one can only take so much girl power.
Anyway, I suspect that they combed the previous seasons in search of any man hating arrogance they may have left out. It was already over the top, I can’t begin to imagine how bad it is now.
Always becomes a great day when a charmed rewind gets posted!
Also i heard a podcast with James Comer (he's worked on Charmed and various Star Treks) and he mentioned how actors playing the sisters would leave set before filming wrapped for the day and that would end up leaving like guest stars or other actors to act opposite stand ins or whoever and the two star trek guys worked with Scott Bacula on Enterprise were like appalled that the stars of the show would do that and sang Scott's praises for his commitment to the show as their leader in universe and on set.
You guys trying to make sense of Charmed each rewind is adorable.
It's good for Allison and Phelan's sanity to review an episode from before the executive producer credit fire nation attacked
"Paige. Piper. Phoebe. Prue. Long ago, the four Charmed Ones lived together in a flawed but sometimes average show. Then, everything changed when the Executive Producers attacked"
I felt relief that this was an episode from Charmed's earlier season. At least the Halliwells will be nice(r) than naughty this time.
"DAMMIT PHOEBE, I'M TRYING TO WATCH BUSHWACKED!"
"And Then There Were Two" is honestly the only line I can remember from this episode word for word. Even back then at 14 years old I thought it was a weird thing to say.
Of all the options in the poll, this was the only episode I'd never seen. I still want to see Phoebe in the Cinderella dress someday! Nevertheless, this one was very funny.
I particularly like a demon who just shows up, tosses Phoebe around, smashes a grandfather clock and then just...leaves. "Yeah, I'm done. No bigger plan right now. See ya!"
Adding the Pheobe sound of her going UGH is amazing lmao
listening to this podcast now makes me think the demon should have been called The Demon of Fantasy. Maybe pulls characters out of books. then he summons Billie by accident. and this inspires him to pull out movie monsters.
the wizard during the evil source/queen phoebe arc had better illusions. and people have done anger better like thet demon of anger in season 3 that caused the sisters to lose their powers temporarily. and the demon of repression in the lady godiva episode. it was just done better ironically in later episodes for using anger or illusions.
and rethinking the leo/piper/dan love triangle just made me realize how bad piper has treated both of them. it'd kinda of been funny if leo and dan started dating each other. fine line between love and hate. and piper forced to watch both of the guys she likes find happiness. even if it didn't work out they could be dating other people. leo/dan just would be fun even it was only temporary.
supernatural babies make our *NIGHTMARES* come true
Hey Alison! I would love to see you tackle some of the more serious star trek episodes and to see your take on them. I found your video on the inner light a nice change of pace from the light-heartedness of the manic episodes (tho I still love the manic episodes). Might I suggest some more niche episodes such as DS9: "Paradise" or TNG: "Frame of Mind". I feel you would have some amazing things to say about them and I know you would be able to bring some of your characteristic good humor and balance it well with a nice deep dive into the subject matter. This would be awesome and your content has always been top shelf. Thanks for reading my comment!
I just got off work not long ago and was about to re-watch another Charmed rewind, I have seen them all several times 😂😂😂but then I saw this!!! Thank-you!!!! ❤❤❤
Charmed Rewind !!! My favorite podcast for cleaning the appartment, when im watching the original show i cant help thinking whos the Margoyle of every episode
This video was a good laugh, I am glad you was able to mention Cole with the Kill It Before It's Dead comment
An early Christmas gift from my favourite husband-and-wife Charmed reviewing duo!
And then there were two…reviewers venting about Charmed
My margolye is Dan's date who Piper thought was just a coworker. I don't think it's a coincidence that she was never heard from again.
Yes! You made my regular Tuesday off spectacular ! I see Angels around both of you :)
I am so happy! New charmed rewind! I am watching the video and listening to it on Spotify. Charmed rewind is my most listened to podcast this year. Thank you for brightening my day.
Aw thanks!
"And then there were two"
He followed Pheobe home from the movies thinking he could kill one witch but when he came in, suddenly, there was Prue. Now he has to deal with two witches. Hence^^
Here we go again. Time to take an hour and 20 minute break from work! Don’t remember this episode at all but I barley remember the early seasons. Thanks again for the awesome podcast ! 😊
It’s party on Tuesday, guys🥳
Axe husband makes more sense (ex-husband) but I like Axe dad better because it's dumber thus funnier which fits Charmed
I'm imagining a film where a young woman's father keeps murdering guys she went on bad dates with without her knowing about it. "You made her pay the bill!" *chop*
Piper coming out of the screen to hunt you down would be an incredibly terrifying event...
Every now and then when you say "Billy", I thought Billie from Season 8 went back in time to an earlier episode. Very common name in Charmed.
The mysterious line could have made a great line to introduce a Patreon Tie with the Phoeberella epiosde, But it seems that even in Charmed Rewind. That line will be forever shrouded in enigmatic incomprehension.
"And Then There Were Two!"
Pleasantville took a dark *TURN*
Throughout the episode, I just had a feeling "Billie" should be a girl's name...and then I realized it because BILLEE PIPER xD
'And then there were 2,' 100% refers to Phoebe and Prue. He followed Phoebe home because his spell didn't work on her and then Prue showed up and kicked his ass. He never saw Piper.
It wasn't even complicated lol
Okay, see the problem is "and then there were [number]" is a phrase that is pretty much always used subtractively , so it's initially confusing for him to say that because he just found out there were actually two people instead of one.
@@mastermarkus5307 He was attacking one witch and then he was attacked by a second witch. It was not that hard to figure out.
@@mastermarkus5307 If there was initial confusion that's one thing but it's been days later and they are analyzing the episode and they STILL can't figure out what he meant? Like come on. This show is often badly written but this one is on them.
Actually it was axe husb... dammit, she found out ;)
Thanks for another great podcast. Although I can't possible beat Phelans Carman, I'll give my two cents:
Margoyle: lonely "kill it before it dies" watcher, going into every showing of this horribly boring movie, where apparently the best scene is the annoying blond girl crying for Billy.
Carman: That's tough this episode, but I'll give props to Derryl. He had a horrible day, dealing with violent theater audiences and brutally murderd people all over town, while nobody at Halliwell manor cared at all.
Have some great holidays and I'm looking forward to more episodes in 2024! =)
No better way to celebrate my birthday than with a new Charmed Rewind ❤
Happy birthday!
Haha, I've left a comment on this video! Andthenthereweretwo!
I think Dan touching Prue's hand was supposed to be him saying goodbye to her? Because now that he and Piper aren't dating, they aren't going to be hanging out or whatever.
And Then There Were Two !
"And Then There Were Two" could be foreshadowing? I mean, they get Paige eventually, but for a while after Prue died, there were just two.
"So she freezes everything" Oh, yeah, that was something Piper could do. I was just listening to the previous Charmed Rewind, which was a Season 7 episode, so I had nearly forgotten that Piper could do anything other than commit explosive homicide and complain about baby-related things.
Probably one of my favorite episodes. The humor and the wit was on point, almost like a Buffy episode.
1:16:20 LMFAO at Allison losing it when Phelan gave the Demon of Illusion the Carman. I cry-laughed as much as the original Margoyle supercut from Hulkus Pocus.
Maybe if everyone didn't keep invalidating Piper's interest in fighting demons in the beginning, she would care more about it later on.
i'd say the demon is supposed to be talking in pop culture references ("and then there were none" by agatha christie, trix are for kids, etc.) but it doesnt make any sense if he's supposed to be an illusion demon. im guessing it was a tv demon or something in an previous version of the script but they never bothered making it make sense
I'm assuming that the demon of illusion probably used to hide in books or painting before the invention of movies. If he was around today, he'd probably be hanging out inside of Shudder or Netflix.
I just watched another charmer video of urs and I genuinely can’t tell if you actually like the show or not😅 u take the piss out of it for the most part so im assuming not lol it was my favorite show growing up and I still love it idgf
They said he hid in horror movies because people who watch them are more prone or vulnerable to violence, I think. He wanted to spread the violence and anger. I think, it's been a while since I've watched this one.
I thought Leo ordered an appetizer that was just nuts or something like that. Like a mixed bowl of cashews and peanuts or something.
Did the bad guy follow that one movie around because he also fancies Billy?
I;m amused at Allison saying those socks are ugly, and they're just plain white socks.
They're dirty
The funny thing is, Cole appears in a later episode in “Kill it before it dies” saying he learned the trick from the Demon of Illusion. Apparently they were buddies 😂
Correct me if I’m wrong Charmanders, but when the Demon of Illusion flings Phoebe he says “get up you miserable witch” so it seems he followed her cause he knew she was a witch. When Prue flings him he says “and then there were two” cause he realized she was a witch as well.
Hey, your subspecies retrospectives are AMAZING and if u havent done one for Bloodrise yet, PleEEEEEEZ do......or else i will cry more than Michelle(if thats even possible:) Great work!!!!!!
Allison have you checked the lattest Shannen Doherty podcast with tons of info on the whole charmed drama? Gosh I do hope hext charmed rewind is about some juicy season 3 episode
Oh, neighbor Dan...
And then there were two… plates of food for Leo
I always ponder Kill it Before it Dies. I imagine that if the monster dies naturally it replicates like the mogwais in Gremlins. But if you kill it it won't. I don't know....
I miss the early days of Charmed when the girls weren’t whiny shrill demons
I wonder if I'd have liked that episode more if Last Action Hero didn't show you can do so much more interesting things with the concept.
if poop heads was spoken in the reboot it would be YASSSSSSSSSSSSSS Caca Queens
Apparently "This episode was one of the most difficult episodes to film because of the movie, and its interaction with the characters" if Charmed Wiki is any indications.
I haven't the faintest idea what that's supposed to mean.
I'm starting to develop something for Shannen Doherty so this podcast was nice to listen to...
I just need to figure out what that thing for Doherty is...
37:20 - I think that was the plot of Last Action Hero
Allison I love you and Phelan please never go away, you guys are so effing funny. Please you and Phelan review Shannen's podcast JUST TO BE CLEAR W Shannon Doherty w Holly, where she reveals being fired from show and what Holly had to say. Please sweet lord, we need your HOT take on this. I don't want to live in a world wo it. Merry Christmas to you both.☃️🧸🪆🔔🎄🎅🤶
Piper and prue shouldnt technically be able to use their powers on characters when their out of the screen? Unless the demon used his magic, but what prevent Piper from sucessfully freezing like she would with a tv playing???
Maybe they are like parfait?
Doodie sounds like a family nickname I am unaware of. ...I don't think poop though...
Villain recruits horror film killers and brings them to the real world? They ripped off Last Action Hero!
Why not more popular killers, or the movie? Also, i thought bloody mary was supposed to move like that lol.
I don't get why a generic ax murder...why couldn't they have done Jason? Or Chucky? Or like you said. Pull them into the movie, and maybe their powers dont work, so they have to do a piwer of 3 spell, or potions?😊
Howdie Dudie? Like the olde puppet cowboy? But that was old in my parents time.
According to my google search, Doodie is apparently Detroit slang for friend 🤷 it has to come from dude...I hope, otherwise yeah it's a very specific type of feces, then again they are siblings, calling each other little hard shits would be on brand
Maybe the in-joke is instead of saying "howdy", they're saying "doody" in reference to the old show "Howdy Doody".
Sooo the "Duty" or "doody" idk how they spell it 😂 but i guess it was an inside joke with the actors that came out while filming?
So what I'm getting is that this episode would have been better if it were "Last Action Hero."
So if the fictional characters are killing are there actors going to get for murders what if one of the actors don't have a good of alibi is that person is just going to go to prison forever.
What is purple cairo
A Woody Allen movie
XD
Picking on Charmed again . How sad . I liked Charmed ( and I'm straight ) !
Love you guys ,
John from Pittsburgh
Congrats on being a straight fan of Charmed!
Every single time I watch one of these I'm reminded "yeah, their job is to protect.... The innocent?"