I was there in that crowd. Every word you said is right. That was a true masterpiece at every level. The whole concert was the experience of a lifetime and I still get goosebumps and tear up when I see videos of it, and I'm 75 and seen nothing to compare with Pink Floyd. As for David Gilmour, he is just a genius.
I have watched literally hundreds of reactions to this performance and it never gets old. I choked up and shed tears listening to the music and watching your reaction, just like I always do. You're 100% right, this is more than music. This performance taps into something deep inside all of us, and creates a world we can all lose ourselves in. This is an experience like no other. Pink Floyd was a band like no other. At 78 years old and nearly a decade after PF officially disbanded, David is still selling out huge arenas like Madison Square Garden. I will be there with my son (27) and daughter (29) on November 9. I want them to experience what it's like to see David Gilmour live on stage while there is still a chance. I can't wait.
Response was absolutely beautiful and you were right on point with your review… I love your enthusiasm and I know it comes from your heart also… Two different songs one is sorrow and the other one is High Hopes from the same concert. You will not be disappointed in either one love you, my brother.
Same concert...Sorrow, Coming Back To Life, Wish You Were Here, High Hopes, Run Like Hell, Shine On You Crazy Diamond, The Great Gig In The Sky and many more.
As someone else said.you cant close your eyes. Its a concert video. Pink Floyd isnt only auditory its visual as well with the lights and effects. It adds value to the music itself.
Thank you so much for reacting to this. I was in high school when this song first came out in 1979. I remember it well. My girlfriend and I at the time loved attending concerts. It was one of the things we loved doing together. There were a huge number of wonderful groups at the time and concerts were not very expensive to attend. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Boston, Journey, Lynyrd Skynyrd, Triumph, 38 Special, Foreigner, and many others. I can not describe to you what a wonderful time it was to be young then. We were happier, relationships were closer, life was more carefree, and the music was spectacular. My heart just aches that young people will not get to experience life as we did as teenagers in the 70’s/80’s. Again, thank you so much for posting this video. It was a wonderful treat.
Speaking of expressing what's in your heart, you're pretty good too, using your voice face and body to let us see into your soul. Beautifully analysed.
Hello from Sweden! When I saw that you are a bassist, I thought that maybe you would realize how incredibly beautiful DG's solo is... and you did - thanks for a wonderful reaction 💜💜💜
Many people claim, this has the "best guitar solo ever", they can't just agree, if they mean the first or the final solo! ;-) I think, they belong together...
Yes! David Gilmour has the most emotionally eloquent guitar on the planet. Remember I mentioned "High Hopes" on your Nightwish reaction - High Hopes is originally a Pink Floyd song - maybe you could react to both versions!?
You are one of the best reviewers. Not only in what seems to be the love you have for great music but your ability to describe what that music does emotionally….and not to forget your knowledge of the technicalities surrounding the instrumental delivery. Well done sir. Well done. Subscribed.
Totally agree with you. I am a bass guitarist too.brilliant solo probably one of the best solos of all time. Loved the repetitive riff that started half way through a bar and went on for a couple more bars.
Great reaction ! What counts is the music...the way a brilliant Gilmour formed every single note on this magic sound carpet. Happens once in a lifetime. Greetings from another bass player from germany. And yes....I (also) mostly keep my eyes closed on Pink Floyd songs. Light effects are outstanding....but I don't need them to understand the music. Keep going ✌
@@eddybassreacts 🖖Likewise. Bass player (and his drumer) always needs to understand the song basics, the core message (so the frontline get all the cheers). That's bass player fate 😉 Happy to see that PF keeps alive nowadays. I'm in that PF rabbit hole for over 40 years now. And it still gives me goosebumps
Welcome to the very deep rabbit hole that is Pink Floyd. Your journey is just beginning when/ if you get a little more time please continue to react to other tracks from their rather large catalog. You will like some more than others but you will enjoy it all . Some earlier comments suggest watching the video while listening saying your missing half the experience and they are right. But it’s your choice. Maybe try it a couple of times?
The Floyd is definitely an experience all their own. I was lucky enough to see them a few times before they quit it. A few of the best shows I've ever seen. Like you said, the music speaks to your heart & grabs your soul. The only live experience that came close to them was Stevie Ray Vaughan & Double Trouble live. Be sure to check this monster trio out sir. Stevie will grab you by the soul & take you for a ride. God Bless 🙏
Thanks my friend, I know how you feel. I’m a British 68 year old Man cooking in the kitchen. I’m not afraid to say I was choked up with tears in my eyes. My wife came in and said, Bob are you okay. I said,fine, it must the onions I’m chopping up. Lol Love to you. I’m now subscribed. I love me Rocksteady and Dub too Bud. ❤️👍
Back when I could still play, "COMFORTABLY NUMB" was always my warm-up song when I'd pick up my bass to practice. A year ago, I had a couple of back-to-back strokes and am no longer able to play, but this was the song. I sure miss playing it. Pink Floyd had several really great "bass player" songs, do keep going. As one bassist to another, be sure to check out the bass line in Frankie Goes To Hollywood's "WELCOME TO THE PLEASURE DOME" ua-cam.com/video/WzOGLKTmeuY/v-deo.html. Even as a little kid, I was always drawn to the bass in songs. The bass in that song made me want to be a bassist. Just found and subscribed to your channel, looking forward to more.
Great reaction! Are you from Jamaica? I was watching the new Bob Marley documentary today, so good. More Pink Floyd suggestions: Dark Side of the Moon album in two reactions, side 1 then side 2. Also, Echoes live at Pompeii, 1971.
Wait till this guy reacts to "The Great Gig in the Sky" from the same concert. That oughta blow his socks off ;) Think I'll subscribe just to see that.
As a bass player you should listen to Sorrow from the same show. Guy Pratt does some great work on that track, you thought David Gilmours solo was good on this song...just wait...
Great reaction. For another mind-blowing live Pink Floyd masterpiece, be sure to check out the 25-minute long epic "ECHOES." (ua-cam.com/video/zrProK5R7ms/v-deo.html) The song is a brilliant and deeply emotional musical "conversation" between Gilmour's guitar and Rick Wright's keyboards (and their voices), and when Wright died in 2007, Gilmour stated that he'd never perform it live again. So this video, from the final night of Gilmour's 2006 tour, is literally the last performance ever. Enjoy! I look forward to seeing your reaction.
I don’t want to spoil your enthusiasm, but the solo was played practically the same (at least in the two Earl‘s court live concerts). The solo on the CD and the solo on the video is not exactly the same, but 98% identical - so it is clear, it is composed.
You might be surprised to discover that these are the two best guitar solos ever done. Listen to them and see if you don't agree: ua-cam.com/video/ljNLSCSYFL0/v-deo.html And: ua-cam.com/video/h75__yIYwHk/v-deo.html
Sorry to say that but... you just cannot close your eyes for Pink Floyd live.... Maybe you will be disturbed from the music a bit but Pink Floyd live is not just music.... the experience is much more complete eyes wide opened, even if you can't process all that gets through you.
Absolutely agree. I was practically begging that he open eyes during some of the best visuals not only of David Gilmour but the entire stage production. Floyd has always had mesmerizing live shows but Pulse pretty much best all around IMHO🙂
I don't think "Pulse" is the best representation of Pink Floyd. I love their remastered originals, then "some" of their live shows, Gdansk, Royal Alpert Hall and others.
The original edit of this is better than this re-edited version - even if the audio IS the same. Also, this is a concert - so please keep your eyes OPEN. Pink Floyd live is as much a visual experience as it is an auditory one. Sure, you can keep them closed with the studios version but NOT for a live version.
Probably missed seeing 95% of the visual experience. Wouldn’t it be great if all Pink Floyd live performances would automatically stop if the viewer closes their eyes longer than the time it takes to blink?
What a shame you missed half the visuals because you had your eyes closed. Floyd is not just about the music, it's a visual and spiritual experience. If you close your eyes you may as well listen to a CD.
I was there in that crowd. Every word you said is right. That was a true masterpiece at every level. The whole concert was the experience of a lifetime and I still get goosebumps and tear up when I see videos of it, and I'm 75 and seen nothing to compare with Pink Floyd. As for David Gilmour, he is just a genius.
Wow, 75 and shining like a diamond 💎…😀
David’s Stratocaster is plugged directly into his soul! He also never wastes a note! Great reaction!
@@user-audioTec76 so true.
He not only never wastes a note, he finds stray ones on the street, and gives them a home.
I love to watch you young people get to enjoy our music back before cover songs and Auto-Tune. This was creative talent.
Awesome talents
Pink Floyd are brilliantly different .
True
I have watched literally hundreds of reactions to this performance and it never gets old. I choked up and shed tears listening to the music and watching your reaction, just like I always do. You're 100% right, this is more than music. This performance taps into something deep inside all of us, and creates a world we can all lose ourselves in. This is an experience like no other. Pink Floyd was a band like no other. At 78 years old and nearly a decade after PF officially disbanded, David is still selling out huge arenas like Madison Square Garden. I will be there with my son (27) and daughter (29) on November 9. I want them to experience what it's like to see David Gilmour live on stage while there is still a chance. I can't wait.
Wow.. Love and Light sir! Kind regards to them family ❤️
Response was absolutely beautiful and you were right on point with your review… I love your enthusiasm and I know it comes from your heart also… Two different songs one is sorrow and the other one is High Hopes from the same concert. You will not be disappointed in either one love you, my brother.
Thank you soo much, Appreciate you ❤️
Thanks
Imagine, I was 15 when this music was published and I'm 57 now. It was revolutionary then, and it is still now.
Transcends time and generations!
We cried together. Such intensity is sublime.
Very intense..
Best band ever. You can't go wrong with Pink Floyd.
Try The Great Gig in the Sky from Pulse. It will blow your mind.
Yea, I will.. Great band
Same concert...Sorrow, Coming Back To Life, Wish You Were Here, High Hopes, Run Like Hell, Shine On You Crazy Diamond, The Great Gig In The Sky and many more.
Great tracks
As a Bass player you really need to watch "One of These Days" from the Pulse concert... I guarantee you won't be disappointed!
Okay.. I’ll definitely check that out
As someone else said.you cant close your eyes. Its a concert video. Pink Floyd isnt only auditory its visual as well with the lights and effects. It adds value to the music itself.
Okay noted
Thank you so much for reacting to this. I was in high school when this song first came out in 1979. I remember it well. My girlfriend and I at the time loved attending concerts. It was one of the things we loved doing together. There were a huge number of wonderful groups at the time and concerts were not very expensive to attend. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Boston, Journey, Lynyrd Skynyrd, Triumph, 38 Special, Foreigner, and many others. I can not describe to you what a wonderful time it was to be young then. We were happier, relationships were closer, life was more carefree, and the music was spectacular. My heart just aches that young people will not get to experience life as we did as teenagers in the 70’s/80’s. Again, thank you so much for posting this video. It was a wonderful treat.
Awesome. From your words, I can imagine how it would have been then.. Love and light from Africa ❤️💡
Speaking of expressing what's in your heart, you're pretty good too, using your voice face and body to let us see into your soul. Beautifully analysed.
Thank you for the kind words 👍🏽
Amazing reaction brother!
Thanks bro 👊🏽 i appreciate
Your views of the band are very genuine and kind. I get chills listening to him play!
Thank you soo much, and thanks for watching.
Hello from Sweden! When I saw that you are a bassist, I thought that maybe you would realize how incredibly beautiful DG's solo is... and you did - thanks for a wonderful reaction 💜💜💜
Thank you soo much for watching 🙏
You pretty much described how most of us feel. If you can't understand you just don't have a soul for David to connect with.
Thank youuuu😀
Many people claim, this has the "best guitar solo ever", they can't just agree, if they mean the first or the final solo! ;-) I think, they belong together...
Right..
Yes! David Gilmour has the most emotionally eloquent guitar on the planet. Remember I mentioned "High Hopes" on your Nightwish reaction - High Hopes is originally a Pink Floyd song - maybe you could react to both versions!?
Wow... Yea sure, I will
My man,
I love seeing people react to this song for the first time for this exact reason!
That solo is the voice of his!
Thanks bro … I had such a great experience 💯👍🏽
Nice to see Sam Brown as background singer for the "Pulse" concert in 1994. The other two are also very good, that's Pink Floyd, only the best.
Great Great Pink Floyd ❤️
David goes crazy,haha amazing👍👍👍
That's the word Fam "Amazing"
You are one of the best reviewers. Not only in what seems to be the love you have for great music but your ability to describe what that music does emotionally….and not to forget your knowledge of the technicalities surrounding the instrumental delivery. Well done sir. Well done. Subscribed.
Thank you so much I really appreciate your compliment and for subscribing 🙏
You summed it up very well, Eddy! Great reaction!
Thank you soo much..
That concert was performed 30 years ago
It will remain as one of the greatest ever.
For 30 millenia to come.
❤
Awesome..
You absolutely understood that music.Thanks.
Thank you soo much ❤️
Pink Floyd "One of These Days" Live Pulse Concert
Bass gets the track moving on this (mostly) instrumental 😉
Can’t wait to check that out .
thank you no need to explain more
😆 Thanks for watching..
Heck yeah. Great reaction.
I appreciate you 👍🏽
I recommend listening to "Echoes" from Pink Floyd Meddle.
Will check that out
Greatest solo of all time m8 fair play
Truly..
Also listen to Sorrow live from the Pulse Concert
Yea, already reacted to that.. Will be posted soon
Great Reaction! Watch Sorrow from pulse concert, Money , Time, Wish You Were Here all from pulse concert
Thank you soo much! Done reactions on Sorrow and Time.. Will be posted soon😀
Totally agree with you. I am a bass guitarist too.brilliant solo probably one of the best solos of all time.
Loved the repetitive riff that started half way through a bar and went on for a couple more bars.
Great to meet you mate!
Likewise my friend
Great reaction ! What counts is the music...the way a brilliant Gilmour formed every single note on this magic sound carpet. Happens once in a lifetime. Greetings from another bass player from germany. And yes....I (also) mostly keep my eyes closed on Pink Floyd songs. Light effects are outstanding....but I don't need them to understand the music. Keep going ✌
Awesome... Good to meet you mate 🙏
@@eddybassreacts 🖖Likewise. Bass player (and his drumer) always needs to understand the song basics, the core message (so the frontline get all the cheers). That's bass player fate 😉 Happy to see that PF keeps alive nowadays. I'm in that PF rabbit hole for over 40 years now. And it still gives me goosebumps
Welcome to the very deep rabbit hole that is Pink Floyd. Your journey is just beginning when/ if you get a little more time please continue to react to other tracks from their rather large catalog. You will like some more than others but you will enjoy it all . Some earlier comments suggest watching the video while listening saying your missing half the experience and they are right. But it’s your choice. Maybe try it a couple of times?
Yea sure
The Floyd is definitely an experience all their own. I was lucky enough to see them a few times before they quit it. A few of the best shows I've ever seen.
Like you said, the music speaks to your heart & grabs your soul. The only live experience that came close to them was Stevie Ray Vaughan & Double Trouble live. Be sure to check this monster trio out sir. Stevie will grab you by the soul & take you for a ride.
God Bless 🙏
Oh wow.. Thanks for your recommendation and thanks for watching.
Thanks my friend, I know how you feel. I’m a British 68 year old Man cooking in the kitchen. I’m not afraid to say I was choked up with tears in my eyes. My wife came in and said, Bob are you okay. I said,fine, it must the onions I’m chopping up. Lol Love to you. I’m now subscribed. I love me Rocksteady and Dub too Bud. ❤️👍
Thank you soo much sir 🙏 good to have you on here... Blessings and Love to you from Africa 🌍
If you loved this: check out „keep talking“ or „high hopes“ from the same concert!
Gotta watch the show at the same time. lol
Next time
The gods that are Pink Floyd. They will
Live forever ❤️🙏
They will..
The lights were computerized, fully automated to fit to the track. 30 years ago(!!). They were ahead of everything.
True, Ahead of everything..
Interview he said he can express himself with 2 notes than 50 words
Wow
Open your eyes bro you missed the show
Next time
You should react also, to Comfortably Numb live in Pompeii 2016 with Gilmour. 22 years later and at around 70, not bad at all!
Will do..
@@eddybassreacts 👍🏻
Back when I could still play, "COMFORTABLY NUMB" was always my warm-up song when I'd pick up my bass to practice. A year ago, I had a couple of back-to-back strokes and am no longer able to play, but this was the song. I sure miss playing it. Pink Floyd had several really great "bass player" songs, do keep going. As one bassist to another, be sure to check out the bass line in Frankie Goes To Hollywood's "WELCOME TO THE PLEASURE DOME" ua-cam.com/video/WzOGLKTmeuY/v-deo.html. Even as a little kid, I was always drawn to the bass in songs. The bass in that song made me want to be a bassist. Just found and subscribed to your channel, looking forward to more.
Lovely, I hope you pick up the bass again..
@@eddybassreacts Thanks, man. Best wishes with the channel!
Can't go wrong with more PF
True
try "high hopes" fropm the same concert
Sure will
Great reaction! Are you from Jamaica? I was watching the new Bob Marley documentary today, so good. More Pink Floyd suggestions: Dark Side of the Moon album in two reactions, side 1 then side 2. Also, Echoes live at Pompeii, 1971.
I'm from Nigeria.. Thanks for watching!
Watch David Gilmore play Comfortably Numb live at Pompeii in 2016 when he was 70 years old - it will give you chills
Wow... Will do. Thanks!
Wait till this guy reacts to "The Great Gig in the Sky" from the same concert.
That oughta blow his socks off ;)
Think I'll subscribe just to see that.
Already done but yet to be uploaded 😀.. I was blown away..
@@eddybassreacts Cool..ill look forward to watching it.
David Gilmour, Live in Pompeii 2016. Both are good but I like Pompeii better.
As a bass player you should listen to Sorrow from the same show. Guy Pratt does some great work on that track, you thought David Gilmours solo was good on this song...just wait...
Wow.. I am so looking forward to it.
David Effing Gilmour!! 🎸
Awesome Guy!!!
As one bass player to another…if you’re not familiar with Jaco Pastorius then UA-cam him when you can :)
I know Jaco, he's the greatest
You'll like song Sorrow same concert. Gilmores maybe even one step up on solo. Back to back classics. Check it out. Pulse Sorrow
Thanksss.. Done a reaction on that already😀. Dropping soon
Telling us what we want to hear to get likes
Ok
Great reaction. For another mind-blowing live Pink Floyd masterpiece, be sure to check out the 25-minute long epic "ECHOES." (ua-cam.com/video/zrProK5R7ms/v-deo.html)
The song is a brilliant and deeply emotional musical "conversation" between Gilmour's guitar and Rick Wright's keyboards (and their voices), and when Wright died in 2007, Gilmour stated that he'd never perform it live again. So this video, from the final night of Gilmour's 2006 tour, is literally the last performance ever. Enjoy! I look forward to seeing your reaction.
Wow.. Thank you soo much for the recommendation..
I don’t want to spoil your enthusiasm, but the solo was played practically the same (at least in the two Earl‘s court live concerts). The solo on the CD and the solo on the video is not exactly the same, but 98% identical - so it is clear, it is composed.
You might be surprised to discover that these are the two best guitar solos ever done. Listen to them and see if you don't agree:
ua-cam.com/video/ljNLSCSYFL0/v-deo.html
And:
ua-cam.com/video/h75__yIYwHk/v-deo.html
Will check them out..
Sorry to say that but... you just cannot close your eyes for Pink Floyd live.... Maybe you will be disturbed from the music a bit but Pink Floyd live is not just music.... the experience is much more complete eyes wide opened, even if you can't process all that gets through you.
Okay
Absolutely agree. I was practically begging that he open eyes during some of the best visuals not only of David Gilmour but the entire stage production. Floyd has always had mesmerizing live shows but Pulse pretty much best all around IMHO🙂
I don't think "Pulse" is the best representation of Pink Floyd. I love their remastered originals, then "some" of their live shows, Gdansk, Royal Alpert Hall and others.
Oh wow
The original edit of this is better than this re-edited version - even if the audio IS the same.
Also, this is a concert - so please keep your eyes OPEN. Pink Floyd live is as much a visual experience as it is an auditory one. Sure, you can keep them closed with the studios version but NOT for a live version.
Okay
hi mate, re-watch it this time keep both eyes open. you missed easily half of the show and keep your head still!
Okayyy
Probably missed seeing 95% of the visual experience. Wouldn’t it be great if all Pink Floyd live performances would automatically stop if the viewer closes their eyes longer than the time it takes to blink?
That solo is actually not improvised!
Oh really!!!
Well rehearsed but not like the album version nor any other live version!
… „Time“ Solo is better! 🎸🎸🎸
I think so too
What a shame you missed half the visuals because you had your eyes closed.
Floyd is not just about the music, it's a visual and spiritual experience.
If you close your eyes you may as well listen to a CD.
OK
Playing a live video with your eyes closed. Why?
Good question, because the Blind can enjoy a live video too...
They can enjoy a recording not a video
So this is how our taxes are being spent- free pcs for boaties to land and pass the time... (Not even been here a month.)
Alien, are you in Pluto or Mars... There's "A great gig in the sky" coming...
@@eddybassreacts Must be self-analysing because there's only one alien here- enjoy it while you still can...
Yea right, the one that has his passport photograph on..😆🤣😂
@@eddybassreacts At least I HAVE a Passport in hand- NOT at the bottom of the Channel!
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻