The 2017 band sounded amazing also, pretty much Atticus swapped with Pino, with Alessandro doing a little bass. Add Pino to that unit with both Atticus and Alessandro on electronics would be the perfect mix of tight rhythm section and improvisation on the electronics.
Pino, one of the most talented bassists out there, NIN is famous for using pre-sequenced Synths/keyboards. Pino's talent is keeping up with the synths and keeping the bottom end down with the amazing drummer... what a rhythm section!
I just realized Pino was in the in house bassist for a lot of what D’Angelo, The Roots, and everyone in that camp was doing around the time. That’s wassup.
New CD at the time. People weren't as familiar with some songs. Still they had an awesome set list on the tension tour. Greatest hits from every era. From Pretty Hate machine to hesitation marks
+Edgar Casrelán You must have never been to a NIN show....... Just for your basic information, there are three sets of lights, one in front, one in the middle, one in the back. They all produce a different light effect. You shouldn't speak when you're not spoken to...
+Sheila Doll your beyond RIGHT!! "TRENT REZNOR"!! IS A TRUE GOD!! nobody tops trent!! his brain is to smart for any body on this planet! ! people today are fucken beyond stupid!! there's no true "TALENT THESE DAYS"!! new n.i.n record 2017!!!!! Trent will destroy any band!! get ready for some REAL TALENT MUSIC COMING SOON..2017!!!!
Best 9 inch nails concert ever. One of the best bands and musicians talents period. Trent always has amazing light show effects in his concerts, but this concert trumps them all. Never seen a band with a light show even close to Trent's. Light show must of been close to a million bucks alone or more. Plus his concerts seem far better sounding then the album version of the songs. The addition of those 2 amazing female vocalists, just added huge as well. I watch this whole concert easily once a week. It's just that awesome. Now over 3 years old and Trent is still jammin' on. Love it!
There's actually a behind-the-scenes video somewhere I saw about the production of this show and it looks like Trent was very obsessive about every detail, and it shows. Incredible from start to fiinish.
I remember the NIN gig I had the fortune to see. unlike at the others when I storm moshpits and break limbs, I stood still during this. But it was because of having a continuous eargasm. That was timeless.
The strut; the grip; the bounce; the distance from that stand; the disappearing; the reappearing; the presence; the lights; REZNOR Stop saying “history like Bowie”! @treznor you are history Trent Reznor NIN and “other stuff” Celebrate these men!!!! @NIN
Feel ya but kinda this is where the charm is....making it work on CD (studio version) and then the mental exercise of translating the essence into a live performance....bet many a sleepless nights for Trent in order to get a live like this
@@Jizzlewobbwtfcus funny I was saying the same thing recently. I wish I saved and treated all my CDs from the 90s better. When you could burn them I started just throwing them around, giving them away, losing them whatever. Could always burn another one right? Now they're all gone :(
@@Hatemode_NJ Start going car boot sales and charity shops. U will be AMAZED at what you can find there mate. Sure, going to those places may make you feel like an old fart but once u regain those classic items back u will feel young again ; ]
Woah, I didn't expect this to quickly become one of my favourite live NIN moments. It's great hearing a raw take on this song, something I'm ashamed about not finding sooner! Trent's vocals here make me nod my head with approval. Everything just seems to be on top form here
Still coming back through live NIN from time to time. Each time i watch this clip...I find the two chorists absolutely nailed it, gives it a nice touch compared the album version. And all this people on stage might be the best lineup Trent could have found in terms of "tight AF".
This is on repeat again, and again. Along with Copy of A, and the Beside You In Time and Tension 2013 concerts. Would be epic to see these guys live! Gets me amping and ready for work in the morning, and cures any bad days at work at night. So much passion in this performance.
The visual "cage" in this concert is really something special- & I agree with NIN: they told me not to tell- [you don't know me] I also cannot help myself! Careful where you wander...
Dios... Se me ocurren pocos grupos con canciones tan jodidamente buenas como las de Nine Inch Nails... Lo mismo, o más, podría decir de lo que deben de ser sus directos (no quiero morir sin verlos, al menos, una vez) y qué hombre, Trent... Cómo me pone, ufff...
Trent gets it. Im an addict wit a slew of problems including PTSD (not from combat) an its hard not to feel 90% of his work. Fuckin mind blowing aint it?
@@brianmiller6340 well, you're part of the cogs in the machine, the military industrial complex. You call them insurgents, but may I remind you that the USA was and STILL is the invader in an offensive, illegal "war" in countries that didn't attacked you. "Insurgents" that the very own USA created to create perpetual war, to sell weapons, in a economy of death. Nothing to be proud of bro... Enjoy your PTSD.
I love(ed) NIN and was dragged to a show where Soundgarden opened for them. 1. I forgot how much I loved Soundgarden. 2. I found a new respect and love for NIN live. Much like the grateful dead they are actually better live. They put it out there 100% and it was one of the best live shows I've seen. I'm more of a punk rock man so my best show ever was OFF! in San Jose California at the Usual owned by the ex-pro skater Corry O'Brian.
Personally I think this has a lot more life to it than the album version, Pino is really driving this song, as composed and cool as he looks, the man is a beast on Bass. Some songs won't change than much, Listen to Piggy if you want an example of something that is completely different live.
![NIN: Discipline live at rehearsals, July 2008 [HD]](/img/n.gif)
Shoutout to Hideo Kojima for reminding everyone how much Hesitation Marks era NIN rules
Oh yeah? What did that man did?
Yeah what's the link
The synths in this performance sound fucking terrific.
Indeed
Pure Italian Craftsmanship! Cortini my man!
Probably the tightest NIN have ever sounded; mainly due to the addition of Pino Palladino on bass.
Art is of the artist.
There is nothing that man can't do!🤘
@@trembling3674 Or Justin.
I saw this live, Pino's live bass sounds like it's a pre-recorded digital track. He is magic.
The 2017 band sounded amazing also, pretty much Atticus swapped with Pino, with Alessandro doing a little bass. Add Pino to that unit with both Atticus and Alessandro on electronics would be the perfect mix of tight rhythm section and improvisation on the electronics.
Not many things in this world are as amazing as a NIN show.
Damn, that bass line is awesome.
Pino is a legend
@@Skippymoogoose90 i think best bass player ever in NIN history !
@@Skippymoogoose90 Cardiff Boy!
Pino
Pino, one of the most talented bassists out there,
NIN is famous for using pre-sequenced Synths/keyboards. Pino's talent is keeping up with the synths and keeping the bottom end down with the amazing drummer... what a rhythm section!
The synths are trying to keep up with Pino 😝
I just realized Pino was in the in house bassist for a lot of what D’Angelo, The Roots, and everyone in that camp was doing around the time. That’s wassup.
Crowd is not dead, they're hypnotized with the show!
Exactly
Sometimes all you can do is stop, stare and listen. Dare I say... mesmerized?
To me watching them live would be like an amazing high. God I wish to them one day😭😭
@augmentedreality very energetic
New CD at the time. People weren't as familiar with some songs. Still they had an awesome set list on the tension tour. Greatest hits from every era. From Pretty Hate machine to hesitation marks
There's no better light shows that NIN! Amazing!
muse
+Edgar Casrelán You must have never been to a NIN show....... Just for your basic information, there are three sets of lights, one in front, one in the middle, one in the back. They all produce a different light effect. You shouldn't speak when you're not spoken to...
+eric proulx you should watch the lastest muse tour.
+giorgioskb and u are right, they are diferent, but both of these guys are Amazing!
+Sheila Doll your beyond RIGHT!! "TRENT REZNOR"!! IS A TRUE GOD!! nobody tops trent!! his brain is to smart for any body on this planet! ! people today are fucken beyond stupid!! there's no true "TALENT THESE DAYS"!! new n.i.n record 2017!!!!! Trent will destroy any band!! get ready for some REAL TALENT MUSIC COMING SOON..2017!!!!
Best 9 inch nails concert ever. One of the best bands and musicians talents period. Trent always has amazing light show effects in his concerts, but this concert trumps them all. Never seen a band with a light show even close to Trent's. Light show must of been close to a million bucks alone or more. Plus his concerts seem far better sounding then the album version of the songs. The addition of those 2 amazing female vocalists, just added huge as well. I watch this whole concert easily once a week. It's just that awesome. Now over 3 years old and Trent is still jammin' on. Love it!
Imagine me seeing for first time now after discovering them last year-Soundtrack of life & keep Discovering more& inspiredso much by Trent
There's actually a behind-the-scenes video somewhere I saw about the production of this show and it looks like Trent was very obsessive about every detail, and it shows. Incredible from start to fiinish.
must *have
Agreed, I feel lucky enough to have seen one of the best NIN live in NY 2017
the combined genius and vision of Rob Sheridan and Trent
The ladies on back-up vocals rock \m/
theyre not standing in the back either i like that.
they have incredible timing. super groovy and right on the money every time
Trent is all about timing and crafting his music, spot-on-perfect.
They do not rock they industrial rock! :P
Levi Bell he brought the CHURCH!!!! Yup! Industrial Metal yeahhhhhh
I can honestly say ABSOLUTELY NOTHING I've ever heard on youtube compares to this. Put on your earbuds , open it up and see.
There’s a live version of NiN - Wish with Josh Freese on drums that’s dope AF.
🎧🎶🤯
Believe me this isnt even the best Version of this song
@@Jewell_cars Which would you say is?
@crunchmunch3172
I'm haunted by that bass line!!
I remember the NIN gig I had the fortune to see. unlike at the others when I storm moshpits and break limbs, I stood still during this. But it was because of having a continuous eargasm. That was timeless.
So so good! That’s quality! I wish we could hear more with this exact line up. It’s lush 🤤😍
The strut; the grip; the bounce; the distance from that stand; the disappearing; the reappearing; the presence; the lights;
REZNOR
Stop saying “history like Bowie”!
@treznor you are history
Trent Reznor NIN and “other stuff”
Celebrate these men!!!! @NIN
i already listened to this song so many times, and yet i came back haunted. in an extremely positive way.
Absolutely
I wish NIN would re-release their CDs with live band versions.
Feel ya but kinda this is where the charm is....making it work on CD (studio version) and then the mental exercise of translating the essence into a live performance....bet many a sleepless nights for Trent in order to get a live like this
Such a shame CDs and collector's products are a thing of the past. Everything is non-tangible cost-cutting no-personality digital cud now :[
@@Jizzlewobbwtfcus funny I was saying the same thing recently. I wish I saved and treated all my CDs from the 90s better. When you could burn them I started just throwing them around, giving them away, losing them whatever. Could always burn another one right? Now they're all gone :(
@@Hatemode_NJ Start going car boot sales and charity shops. U will be AMAZED at what you can find there mate. Sure, going to those places may make you feel like an old fart but once u regain those classic items back u will feel young again ; ]
Addicted to this track, blasting it right now!
Woah, I didn't expect this to quickly become one of my favourite live NIN moments. It's great hearing a raw take on this song, something I'm ashamed about not finding sooner! Trent's vocals here make me nod my head with approval. Everything just seems to be on top form here
Damn, I can't get enough of that bassline and its distortion.
It’s sick. I love how menacing it sounds.
@@Jlyblylvragreed…fuckin vacuum cleaner
This live performance is so fucking badass!!! That fucking LED wall tho!!!
Me too!
@@msladyj1037 you too-what?
Fuck yeah! Love the backing vocals and bass
Still coming back through live NIN from time to time. Each time i watch this clip...I find the two chorists absolutely nailed it, gives it a nice touch compared the album version. And all this people on stage might be the best lineup Trent could have found in terms of "tight AF".
Probably my most favorite LIVE recorded NIN performance on stage
awesome performance.....Nine Inch Nails just gets better & better
The sound and recording techs that made this possible deserve a huge thank you. Its perfect
I hate vevo but couldn't help it, it is soooooooo good, the backing vocals just make it even more awesome.
Those lovely ladies have voices like angels in hell or devils in heaven. Amazing.
I still can't believe how good he sounds live.. amazing Trent Reznor!
I don't know how you manage to explain what getting high feels like long after you got sober that's a real gift that keeps on giving.
The job of Alessandro on synthetizers, this guy is truly talented, devoted.. Amazing
Reznor has always done amazing shows. And how he highlights the other band members when their doing solos is amazing
Absolutely love the guitar solo on this song.
So glad I saw this live!!! NIN doesn’t disappoint!
the background singers give trents music alot more soul trent is a genius
This needs more views! My goodness this song is amazing!
Fucking amazing.
amazing fuck too
This is on repeat again, and again. Along with Copy of A, and the Beside You In Time and Tension 2013 concerts. Would be epic to see these guys live! Gets me amping and ready for work in the morning, and cures any bad days at work at night. So much passion in this performance.
Absolutely the best sounding show I ever was at. Could not believe you could get that quality at a live show
The visual "cage" in this concert is really something special- & I agree with NIN: they told me not to tell- [you don't know me] I also cannot help myself! Careful where you wander...
I thought this song was basically perfect but the backing singers add another layer. Amazing.
Got lucky & saw them this tour. Rafters busting sound & that light show was beyond incredible along with seeing Trent & band. 🤘
Trent is ridiculous good live!
Love this track!. It sounds more powerful played live like this but it's one of those songs that resonated with me as soon as I heard it.
Gosh darn it, Trent. Dudes like the finest of wines...👏🏽
I know this is a super old video… but Robin’s dancing always kills me on this song haha
better live than on the cd.
Always!
Real drums, multiple voices, yes!
Ladies are awesome ! Especially in Even Deeper !
Their fucking jamming.
Perfect performance and music from the NIN as always.
Dios... Se me ocurren pocos grupos con canciones tan jodidamente buenas como las de Nine Inch Nails... Lo mismo, o más, podría decir de lo que deben de ser sus directos (no quiero morir sin verlos, al menos, una vez) y qué hombre, Trent... Cómo me pone, ufff...
Pino’s fretless bass line has been haunting me for the longest
This is the most amazing concert stunt I've ever seen. Leave it to Reznor to give the fans a little something extra, WOW~!
Glad there's UA-cam. Love your music. Will never see you in concert.
The crowd seems dead... Shit, id be jumpin around! The song is incredible! I would love to see nine inch nails live!!!!
the light show was stunning..
MsPonderthat1 that makes two of us, ugh I'd sell my organs to see them live
love his concerts hes the best
Between this song and The Becoming, Trent has perfectly described what has happened to my brain since my two deployments to Iraq.
Trent gets it. Im an addict wit a slew of problems including PTSD (not from combat) an its hard not to feel 90% of his work. Fuckin mind blowing aint it?
Is it scrambled from killing one million innocent civilians?
dieubermensch probably not 1,000,000. I’m only responsible for roughly 20 armed insurgents
@@brianmiller6340 well, you're part of the cogs in the machine, the military industrial complex. You call them insurgents, but may I remind you that the USA was and STILL is the invader in an offensive, illegal "war" in countries that didn't attacked you. "Insurgents" that the very own USA created to create perpetual war, to sell weapons, in a economy of death. Nothing to be proud of bro... Enjoy your PTSD.
dieubermensch I was just following orders, much like your Soros following friends.
Came back haunted ( love it ) by the fretless bass line.
one of my all time favs. .absolutely perfect
Addictive.
This was awesome!!! I’m late to NIN but I’m enjoying my ride discovering
If you don't like nin then I feel sorry for you.
andrew150380uk hold up!! The band or actual 9 inch nails into ones skull? 🤘
That's it! XD
@@DravensPit Yes!
@Ch Pe they probably wouldn't be? What's your point?
@Jamis Ins grow up
This song is God Tier fucking good. Listen with ear buds or head phones. So amazing...🤘
this is literally giving me goosebumps
0:00 - 0:18
Boards of Canada - Heard From Telegraph Lines
No it isn't. It's the synth line to the chorus of this song. However they share the same chords!
Best visual concert concept of decades.
Amazing in every way!!!
My life's anthem 🙌
This is one of the few instances where you don’t want to be front row cos you probably don’t get to enjoy the cool light effects !
I love this song it's very very personalized n thankfully still here!!❤
3:37 that whole last verse just blows mee away! 🤘🏻
I love(ed) NIN and was dragged to a show where Soundgarden opened for them. 1. I forgot how much I loved Soundgarden. 2. I found a new respect and love for NIN live. Much like the grateful dead they are actually better live. They put it out there 100% and it was one of the best live shows I've seen. I'm more of a punk rock man so my best show ever was OFF! in San Jose California at the Usual owned by the ex-pro skater Corry O'Brian.
They rock hard as they come back
love!!!!!!!
🎶Just can't stop. Came back haunt haunt haunted.
Could be.
Other than Trent Reznor playing a tambourine onstage, I would definitely say the guy's doing real well for himself these days.
Glad i got to hear this live... this performance is absolutely perfect though.
This song gives me chills. Love it
I thought I was at a NIN’s concert once, turns out the acid kicked in and it was just the cop lights flashing. I met Big Bird that night also
Wow! Assumed not possible, but EVEN BETTER LIVE!
Reminds me of the Navy.
Pure awesomeness!
Thank you for sharing the whole show on youtube. Amazing set. I knew I would never disappointed by NIN.
The whole show isn't on UA-cam. The concert had 28 songs in its set!
edub77
Damn. I knew there was no way they wouldn't include Closer in the set list
edub77 No way! Really? WHERE CAN I GET THE FULL SET?!
I haven't seen one yet but hopefully the full set is available when it's released in spring of next year
Impresionantes en vivo ...que bárbaro !!!
!Qué sonido más sublime!
Absolutely AMAZING version
That base line 🤘🏼
This tour was ground breaking ... The visuals were insane..
♥ so in love with this band ♥
pino is a fucking machine. between this and the opening of march of the pigs hes been playing things that are typically synths.... DAMN
still just amazing..
nin never misses it's actually scary
haunting jam!
such a up beat dark song. so danceable.
These concerts sound so damn similar to the album and are so professionally done it's almost unbelievable... I wonder how much money went into them?
Personally I think this has a lot more life to it than the album version, Pino is really driving this song, as composed and cool as he looks, the man is a beast on Bass. Some songs won't change than much, Listen to Piggy if you want an example of something that is completely different live.
1:13 Spongebob when he tasted *”Snail Po”*
Just perfect!
I love this!
This is nothing but the best!
Great song
I love everything about this video!
You feel that? I feel that. :)