GOLD but Black and White??? [Pentatonix Reaction to Shallow]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 38

  • @sandrawalkerhaliburton1884
    @sandrawalkerhaliburton1884 Місяць тому +2

    For a feel good time listen to "Sing" and "Wizard of Ahh" In all of the recordings, there are hidden messages. In Bohemian there were 4 falling stars and 4 lights.

  • @vidsorama2
    @vidsorama2 Місяць тому +2

    Great reaction. Thank you. I love this Pentatonix video. The whole vibe is awesome. Pentatonix made another beautiful video that same day for "Waving Through A Window". It is from the musical "Dear Evan Hansen". Please add it to your future reactions list.

  • @edsartistry
    @edsartistry Місяць тому +5

    In every song they do a cover of they always pay some sort of homage to the original and in this one it is the black and white and the bright touches of gold. LOVE, Love, love Mitch's solo part and the gritty growl at the end of it is just .....EPIC! Kirstie's belting is unparalleled. And one can Never say enough about Kevin and his talents. If Matt and Scott weren't in the mix you would just lose the whole foundation of the song. These five multitalented people have done SO MUCH in their music careers that no other group or band can come close to the boundaries and levels they have broken and reset. They are truly one in a million!! The only bar they have yet to break and reset is the one of "time". How long can they keep the group together and how long can they keep making astounding music without crashing and burning out. Only "Time" will tell. I wish them ALL the best and God bless them as well. LONG LIVE PENTATONIX !!!

  • @davephillips7209
    @davephillips7209 Місяць тому +6

    THEY ARE REDICULOUSLY TALENTED, JUST REDICULOUSLY SO!! Kevin has made the Cello my favorite instrument. Kirstie and her eyes ...nuff said lol.

  • @Gwennedd
    @Gwennedd Місяць тому +13

    Love the way they portrayed this song. Apparently they used the colour scheme from the movie posters that used black white and touches of gold. Plus a vintage art deco design for the "room". Kirstie's belting in this is phenomenal...and yes, Scott vocals are way better than Bradley's.

  • @jonathanwetherell3609
    @jonathanwetherell3609 Місяць тому +2

    The impact of that sudden cut off ending. Very clever.

  • @cindynolan899
    @cindynolan899 Місяць тому +1

    And Kevin’s beatboxing while playing the cello. Chelloboxing

  • @9012505
    @9012505 Місяць тому +3

    I'm going to suggest that you also react to their Hollywood bowl live stream version of this. They nail the emotions live.

  • @lovesmusic0845
    @lovesmusic0845 Місяць тому +2

    Their live version at Hollywood Bowl 2022 is so incredible. Love this one too. ❤

  • @celiachristman104
    @celiachristman104 Місяць тому +3

    Great reaction. I look forward to more of your PTX reactions.

  • @daleenengelbrecht4861
    @daleenengelbrecht4861 Місяць тому

    Can not get enough of PTX. Thank you A for your reaction. Greetings from South Africa

  • @lisalong9393
    @lisalong9393 26 днів тому

    Floor Jansen of Nightwish has covered this song on a show in the Netherlands called Beste Zangers...
    Pentatonix has done the best cover (upgrade) I've heard so far though.

  • @PtxXtp
    @PtxXtp Місяць тому +1

    The harmonies and chord progression they did at 7:28 was a nod to lady Gaga's song Bad Romance. Every choice they make is deliberate. Just a small thing but if you have a music ear you can hear it. They even did the same thing way back when they were on the sing off. Threw in a tiny bit from a boys to men song on one of their arrangements since one of the judges was a member of Boys to Men. It was only a few notes but enough for shawn stockman to notice.

  • @rogerramjet5214
    @rogerramjet5214 Місяць тому +4

    Also jewelry is gold

  • @Badger77722
    @Badger77722 Місяць тому +3

    The color scheme in the video is a nod to the movie posters. They were all done in black-and-white photography, with the only color on them being the gold lettering of the title, A Star Is Born.
    I thought it was interesting that Matt took the low musical line, rather then Kevin's cello. Often when a cello plays it is the lowest musical tone that you hear, but in this case Kevin stayed up just a bit and Matt took the bass line. There's even a spot (about 7:10 in your reaction video, right where Kevin starts beatboxing) where Kevin has stopped playing, and if you aren't careful, you'll still hear the cello playing - because Matt sounds so much like a cello, it's a little weird!

    • @A-AronReacts
      @A-AronReacts  Місяць тому +1

      Oh got it, makes sense...thanks!!!

  • @pjb3583
    @pjb3583 Місяць тому +2

    I haven’t seen this version of the movie, but of course I’ve heard the song. I love how passionate they can be when the occasion calls for it, as they also were in Say Something. And, as someone who was a photographer for a short time, I would love to know how they single out the gold accents. I suppose it’s a technology thing, which wasn’t even a gleam in someone’s eye back when I was actively shooting. If you’re also a film buff, the Barbra Streisand and Kris Kristoferson version of A Star is Born is also worth watching. Loved your reaction! Peace …

  • @df5199
    @df5199 Місяць тому

    Recommend their cover of The Prayer.

  • @elainedavis9053
    @elainedavis9053 Місяць тому

    Awesome Rection - Thanks so much!

  • @marablemorgan8292
    @marablemorgan8292 Місяць тому

    Always ear candy!

  • @mjbartholomew5317
    @mjbartholomew5317 Місяць тому

    You really need to react to their version of Gold.

  • @ruth2141
    @ruth2141 Місяць тому

    You should react to more live versions. In recent years, PTX has had some performances professionally recorded for pay-per-view streaming, and fans have captured excerpts. Also fans' concert video quality gets better every year. The 2022 Hollywood Bowl concert has some really good live performances; the concert was kind of a 10-year retrospective, so a lot of their biggest songs are included. And there are a lot of fan videos from last year's world tour.

  • @marablemorgan8292
    @marablemorgan8292 Місяць тому

    ⚡⚡⚡⚡🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥⚡⚡⚡⚡

  • @slhoog8164
    @slhoog8164 Місяць тому +1

    They do such a great job with this one! As others have mentioned, the coloring is a nod to the original cover of the soundtrack and movie posters. If you listen carefully, there's a very brief riff from "Bad Romance" thrown in there as a nod to Lady Gaga (it's at 7:27 or so on your video). Just for your own fun (not necessarily to react to), there's a fun behind the scenes from shooting the video for this in one of the PTXperience videos. It also includes BTS from the Waving Through a Window video because they shot both of those videos on the same day in the same location. ua-cam.com/video/Ri7nUYCDWSg/v-deo.html

  • @marablemorgan8292
    @marablemorgan8292 Місяць тому

    Remember, PTX doesn't do covers... They do upgrades!

    • @A-AronReacts
      @A-AronReacts  Місяць тому

      Love that! I just did Creep today at the masked singer. Yikes. Should have it edited in a day or so. It will be available to members right away but publicly will be available in ~ 1 week

  • @helgarichter1296
    @helgarichter1296 Місяць тому +1

    hi i‘ m also a great fan of pentatonix and superfruit. please look and hear the video - hallelujah.
    and i think creep and man in the mirrow from brian justin crum is fantastic and i hope you make a reation
    sorry my english is not good
    greetings from germany. have a good time and take care

    • @A-AronReacts
      @A-AronReacts  Місяць тому

      Hi thanks. I can't react to Hallelujah as it was one of the few I had already seen of them. That said, I just did Creep from Ptx..will be released soon

  • @lesaahrenstein6360
    @lesaahrenstein6360 Місяць тому

    I heard Bradley Cooper was very nervous and hesitant about singing because he knew that he was maybe a really good amateur. That might be a paraphrase but you get the point

  • @simsweechuah9753
    @simsweechuah9753 Місяць тому

    Great reaction. Thanks. 90s Dance Medley and Come Along are fun videos. If u haven't done so, check them out

    • @A-AronReacts
      @A-AronReacts  Місяць тому

      I did 90s dance medley. Check out my PTX playlist (and Super fruit if that interests you)

  • @tadeostodullo4587
    @tadeostodullo4587 Місяць тому

    😀😀😀😀😀

  • @davidbangtson3109
    @davidbangtson3109 Місяць тому

    Better than the original!

  • @ruth2141
    @ruth2141 Місяць тому

    I'm not sure how much input PTX puts into their video designs; maybe some of the other fans know. I have a feeling they hire a videographer and let them do their thing, though I'm sure there are discussions and PTX can veto anything they aren't comfortable with.

    • @9012505
      @9012505 Місяць тому +1

      They give the track to multiple people and they all pitch their ideas to them. Then they pick the one they like best.

  • @rogerramjet5214
    @rogerramjet5214 Місяць тому +1

    Christine Aguilera sang this