They're taking all the money, even if we had only 1 president he would still eat up all the money. They're just... out politicians are the most corrupt I know of.
We'll it's better to have one thief than two.. ^_^ I guess all countries have the same problem,. In our country they want to change the form of government to federalism , increasing the bureaucracy and also adding more politicians to the system.
You see, then a Croatian president would never get elected because the Croats are the least big of the 3 peoples. Also, all politicians here are nationalists so if a Serbian president gets elected then guess what happens! Some good old indoctrination and discrimination.
Guess what, in federation there are 10 cantons, meaning 10 more presidents, 10 more parliamens, 10 more ministry amd 10 everything else that goes with it. And it's all naturally founded by country's budget. There is tenfold bureaucratic leaches there. When you consider corruption of all Balkan politicians, it's almost impossible to grasp levels of scams that are in play in the Bosnia. Total of 14 complete governments in a single country, thousands upon thousands of bureaucrats getting they salary (disproportionately high compared to average salary in the country) and not generating any income to the budget. And people still wondering why it's hard to live in Bosnia? It's because so much money that goes to the administration that it's insane. Imagine what that amount of money could do if transferred into factories over over time. And factories and other economic infrastructure exists in Bosnia, but they are questionably privatized and huge amount of them is closed. That's why youth is leaving Bosnia, but that is also why youth is leaving Croatia, Serbia, Macedonia and Montenegro as well, corrupt governments who have destroyed our industry, our banking system, who are paying millions of € for a 1 meter of highway (money laundering on expert level). And it's all encouraged by the EU so that they will get cheap laber force to come into they countries and that they companies could built their factories where laber is even cheaper. So I say carry on Serbs, Croats, Bosnians and everyone else, keep hating each other, keep listening to politicians who are selling you this hate, soon here won't be anybody to hate, won't be anybody to love either. Won't be anybody at all...
Papi Uno swapping minorities? You do realise that 50% of Bosnia is consisted of Serbs and Croats that are majority on 75% of the Bosnian territory. The only true solution is to have a loose federation of three entities that should have a right on independecy referendum in 5-10 years. The country as it is is not self-sustainable, and bringing people closer together is not a solution since the hate is greater now than before the war.
This is incredible. Never heard of such a complicated governmental structure. Makes me wonder if there are other countries with hierarchies this complex as well.
swiss system is clearly federal though, and it only has a bi-cameral parliament and a gov't at the federal level, no constitutional courts and no higher presidency. Indeed it's simpler than the US and germany.
Saaduddin Ansari I ALWAYS TELL BOSNIANS, HOW WOULD THEY HANDLE A COUNTRY LIKE THE US THAT HAS MANY RELIGIONS AND ETHNIC GROUPS LIVING SIDE BY SIDE BUT YOU DONT SEE A WAR IN THE US RIGHT NOW! DO YOU?
@@philthefinadelphian4830 It's still real to the many Croatians and Serbians there. Your message of ethnic kumbaya failed in tbe 90's and is failing now. One has to acknowledge the fact that there can be no nation built out of Bosnia and Herzogvina; and that separation is for the best.
Bosnia - 3 elected presidents. Qatar - 30 elected assembly members, 15 appointed by the king + 1 ruling family which chooses the king in their inner circle without consulting the public.
Birk Undae You also forgot that most of Qatari residents (almost 90 percent) could not vote as they are expatriates. So, the Qatari emir and 10 percent of population makes all the decisions.
@@adnan37h This video is made by a channel sponsored by Qatari government. Non-democrats should first work on their own democracy before giving advises/opinions about functioning democracies. It's like a homeless guy would give tips how to handle a job interview - just ignore it.
The reason there are presidents for Serbs and Croats is cause they could not stop the Serbians short of giving them not 1, but 2 presidents and they would not have Croats as their allies without giving them one as well. Bosniaks simply don't have the power to rule over the country but are willing to do anything to keep it from falling a part, if they could they would subjugate both Croats and Serbs and take away their presidents and parliaments violently. But since they can't the only way to maintain even superficial political stability is to give them all these rights.
Because countries such India or Indonesia are post-colonial countries which is marked just by border rather than ethnicities, China was an empire then turn become Republic, while in Europe, countries are being built by its distinct history and ethnicity especially in the Eastern Europe, where the ethnic border form the border of country
@@__Man__ the only thing that benefit Indonesia is if there are representatives from eastern Indonesia. Out of our 7 presidents, only 1 of them are from eastern Indonesia, and that is Habibie from Celebes. Which by the way elected emergencily after the decline of Suharto. So yeah, practically that is not true democracy. Other than that, mostly our presidents are Sumatran or Javanese. I guess Indonesia only need 1 president, but with another candidates from East Indonesia.
No you have croatia but bosniaks have nothing to call home you are Bosnian first then Croats and serbs, your genocide make you long before it Croats were less then they are now
@iqbal sahibil Yo UAE is worst among the gulf countries where they were begging Americans to Transfer their base from Qatar to UAE and they will pay all the money,Also Saudi,UAE and Bahrain are more repressive than Qatar, u can look at how many political prisoners are there in Saudi,UAE and Bahrain. Compare that to Qatar which has improved since blocked
At least they have money and only 'ONE' supremo unlike 3 presidents. Most Gulf kings are corrupt, yes, but they have enough money to afford it. Democracy can be equally corrupt where the spoils are shared by multiple politicians and businessmen. Welcome to my country India.
Binu Jasim That money will run out soon as the world starts using solar energy. Are you saying that India should become a dictatorship like China? In India, there are still checks and balances, and most people can vote. Meanwhile in Qatar, only 10 percent of the population (Qatari citizens) can vote, and even then, the Emir has the final say.
But bosnia and herzegovina is a parliamentary republic. So their president only have seremonial role, and their real political leader is the prime minister.
Chairman of the Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Council of ministers do not have real power, any disputed decision by entity members, is sent back to entity governments for final decision.
@@milutinj i think that basicly what a federal state is.
3 роки тому+2
@@milutinj E jesi i dosadan sa entitetima.Sta ce nam bezveze.Ovi politicari ovoliki samo mlate lovu i narod radi za njihove plate.Treba postaviti jednog predsjednika neka je i rom sto se mene tice,ukinuti entitete,imati samo opstine..e tada bi se zivjelo juh
I'm Malaysian... FYi, All goverment decision and policy made by prime minister and his 32 ministers .. The 9 rotation King just a symbol of people unity... that's all
Everyone who speaks the Stokavian dialect (that mysterious language that people call Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin) has a Serbian ancestry as Serbs were the only ones historically to speak that language (Croats spoke Chakavian). Literally the only way to solve the problem in the west Balkans is for Croats, Bosniaks and Montenegrins to accept their Serbian identity and create a country with Serbia, otherwise this region will be the laughingstock of the world forever.
If you are gonna have 3 presidents, you might as well split the country into 3: Croat majority areas to Croatia Bosniak majority area remains Bosnia Serb majority area to Serbia
The 100 well bosnia was a country for hundreds of years so why end it now?? Might aswell keep moving forward because eventually these old minded and old nationalistic people will die and the new generation will change how things are right now.
Kristijan Car lol my grandmother is from there. They hanged her uncle and burned all the Serbian churches in the war. That’s why there are croats there now.
@@Православл And that's why almost all the Serbian monasteries and churches were built after the Turkish incursion?! The Turks used typical divide and conquer tactics on the Croats through muslim conversion (Bosniaks) and colonization by Orthodox (Vlachs and Serbs).
So you are saying that Serbians wen't into Bosnia one day, started a war and after war they just stayed there and inhabited that land? Or more logical thinking could be that Serbs lived there for a long time and eventually when war broke out for whatever reason ppl started killing each other like in every war.
I'm sure the system can be changed, but it'll probably require that all self-identified ethnicities carry identification with said ethnicity written somewhere so that the right ballot is given. Having multiple executives aren't actually an impossible system for example Switzerland has 7 and they also have multiple linguistic and cultural groups working together for the better of all.
The problem with this entire system is that we who identify ourselves as ethnic Bosnians are not considered as a part of any constituent people. This is a problem because we do not have the right to run for presidency and change the Bosnian governmental system more effectively and finally make a citizen state. I sincerely hope we make progress.
Quite the contrary, the population is very divided with extremely slim chance to ''unite'' and act as a single unit to oppose the system which we call strait-jacket. It's a primary example of divide and conquer(rule)!
I think they're doing things as well as they can. Unless you're from Bosnia you have no idea how complex our history really is. The fact that no war has erupted in the past 25 years is encouraging enough. I remember people saying in the late 90s that it will take at least half a century before things are even somewhat back to normal. Imo this 3 president thing is complicated but necessary if we are to eventually rebuild into a healthy country
I hear you, and I agree that the Dayton Peace Agreement has implemented peace, but this peace is just partial and hatred is still stirring in the background. I personally believe that the peace accord was very hastily done and its main “architects” did not fully understand Bosnia's history. Yes, I know, “who cares about history?” I hear people say all the time, but when you realize that division only escalated, the country’s national anthem is a cut-out of another piece and does not have its own lyrics, and the country’s flag is a clear smack in the face of Bosnia's history. Bosnia needs to become a republic, a country of its citizens and not its religious groups. Here is where the current system fails.
As pakistani shia Muslim we also victims of salafiism and wahabiism and you should know we did not sents salafi wahabi Saudi preachers to bosnia herzegvina must think?
@iqbal sahibil being Muslim and human we should not hijjack islam and kill innocents in reality islam is the name of peace,love,tolerance,help,duty, equality and humanity
@iqbal sahibil 'love and respect' 'we dont want your love and respect you evil Men!' And here i was thinking only in fiction would exist people so cartoony ironic. You would think people would look at what they wrote and think 'hey, that doesnt seem right' but no, this right here is proof mankind can always sink even lower in the hole
Seems like independence was not solution for total ethnic segregation ,so sad. We share your pain too. Love you Bosnia and Herzegovina from Turkmensitan🇹🇲🇧🇦
Which I find irritating. I do not understand how this many ethnic fights occur over in Central Asia when all of them except Tajiks are Turkic sharing history, culture and linguistics.
@Crow29Darkness So what Qatar is an Islamic country and islam doesn't allow homosexuality The world doesn't revolve around you and different believes = different perspectives and laws
Now think about this, Iran is a geographical area which is home to up to 30 ethnic groups! And people with different ethnicities been living together for 2500 years and we all proud to be Iranian above our ethnic background.
We are talking about The Land where the first World war began. So It's not that simple, there is much more than ethnic, and indeed we lived in one country with one Ruler it was very good Could not last for long
@@Adam-nw1vy I’m not a “Farsi”. Farsi (Persian) is a language not ethnicity first of all. Secondly, I’m ethnically Turkish. Discrimination is everywhere you cannot control it. Depends on what you focus on. In İran, we focus on our commonality more than our differences. So those kind of ethnic propaganda doesn’t work on us. We’ve been a nation for 2500 years and will remain so.
@@nikankhamisi1175 I beg to differ. The Iranian regime is extremely oppressive as we have seen from the recent protests. How could anyone dare show any dissent or have pride in their culture in a totalitarian regime like that? I've seen many people, specially from Balochistan, who don't want to be part of Iran. In any case, I personally don't mind if the whole world unites. What matters is justice, regardless of whether people are together or apart.
@@Adam-nw1vy Who was talking about the regime? Regimes come and go but our Iranian identity continues to be. This kind of material that you’re talking about doesn’t work in İran.
Falls fact: "Bosniaks and Croats are stripped of their rights to run for presidency in Republika Srpska". Bosniaks and Croats do have the right and are running for presidency in RS, Ramiz Salkic (Bosniaks) was a candidate. And BiH does not have 3 presidents, rather 3 members of presidency where each 6 months they rotate as presiding of the presidency.
My solution would be a parliamentary system with President as ceremonial position. If a bosniak becomes PM, then a serb would become president and a croat would become chairman of upper house. A bosniak cannot be PM and president. The ministries in cabinet would be divided in three and the PM can choose which ethnicity can have which ministry.
Very small states that would end up like Kosovo. Not sure it's a good idea. I like the idea of a federation more. But yes indipendence still better than the current situation.
No because everything is mixed up, you can't just cut something off and create a new country. Plus croats and serbs would just annex themeselves to croatia and serbia, than bosnia would be a realy smal landlocked country
makomaro> then Americans also should go back to Ireland , Scotland, Portugal, Spain, Russia etc, because they are occupiers as well! Americas were under the Red Indians, Aztecs and Maya and Inka race of people!!
scorpioninpink What do you mean go "back" That is their indigenous land. Bosnia is not a nation state, it's borders are simply a left over of the Ottoman colonialism. And therefore the so called "bosniaks" have no claim over these artificial borders
The sad truth is that all 3 confessions in bosnia and herzegovina belong to one nation, the Croatian nation. Nobody wants to admit this. Bosnia and herzegovina should be 2 regions of Croatia. The people there all speak the Croatian language. Unfortunately, after roughly 1000 years of foreign occupation of Croatian lands, the majority of the people of Bosnia and of Herzegovina, who were originally overwhelmingly Catholic, accepted different faiths, notably Islam and Orthodox Christianity. This happened under the 400 years of Ottoman occupation, where Catholics were seen as the No. 1 enemy (the West). Conversion of religion in and of itself is not even the problem. The problem is the subsequent manipulation and brainwashing of the local population by various powers and by the Serbian establishment that the local bosnian and herzegovinian populations are not of Croatian origin, when in fact, NOTHING could be further from the TRUTH! Whatever happens to Bosnia and Herzegovina, may PEACE prevail. 🙏
What would you do then? Yugoslavia was only Yugoslavia because communist lords kept patriotism and identity down. You cannot force people to live together. In the West you force people but this will eventually fall.
I'm skeptical since this is coming from quite the biased source, but I do agree on the end message (assuming everything they said in this video was true).
I am not from Bosnia & Hercegovina, nor do I (try to) have any political bias, but I think, the only way, this state can handle its problems (unemployment, the outdated political system, debt, corruption, ...) in a decent way, is to stop segregating the people by their ethnicity. Only united this state can make proper progress. Greetings from 🇦🇹 (the northernmost Balkan country 😉) to all Bosniaks, Croats and Serbs in BiH and elsewhere! 🇧🇦 🇭🇷 🇷🇸
Do you agree ( 👍 ) or disagree ( 👎 ) with what the Serbs have done to thousands of Bosniak women and young girls,during that aggression on Bosnia, ( Stretch Them Out ) by force,and do you agree or disagree that i deserve a girl even know many called me ugly when its not my fault,and lied to , me ,many were really mean to me ,mostly my own kind….and how would they feel if we Bosniaks would be little devils like them and do it to their women and young girls??
@@angrybutgoodbosniak9128 The catalyst for the atrocities that Serbs committed was the Bosnian side ignoring the pleas of the Serbs and Croats, despite not having a majority, to unilaterally declare independence. You reaped what you sowed. This is the result of what happens, when you wish to seek freedom, at the expense of other people's freedom.
It makes me think that local governance with fairly weak nations is likely a better way to go. In Canada the Federal government is fairly weak while provinces have more power and municipalities have a fair bit of power as well. There is a balance that needs to be struck between simplicity and autonomy that is always tricky. But I really think that local governance is always best. If this crazy sounding system creates that and prevents war then hey I guess that is a good thing!
Same in Pakistan. Provinces are un more power than federal capital Islamabad.
6 років тому+6
Bosnia is a country of over 1,000 years of history and heritage. When Bosnia had government and was developing culture and art, America wasn't yet discovered and Gulf countries were only desert (both are today preaching us). Bosnia shouldn't dissolve, because it is a sovereign country that has lived through all wars, empires, conquests and occupations. It is surely gonna live through this complicated system (caused by Serbia, Croatia and international community) and finally live to see its future, as an united and free country.
Bosnia is a land with over 1000 years of history but not a country, it can barely scrap 50 years of functioning as a country and a majority of that is in the middle ages, and not even once in it's history was it in any way independent from it's neighbours.
@@Luka-zf2ye you can make the same claim for most balkan nations as most of them has been subjugated by some major nation in the region let it be roman, byzantine, turk or austrian our identity as we know it today was formed in the ideals of nationalism in the 19th and 20th century
Bosnians are not to blame for the complexity of our government. During the war of the 90s world community did everything in it's power to disable Bosnians to defend themselves against military aggression of serbia and croatia. Against all the odds Bosnian managed to get the upper hand and just before the aggressors where forced to run for ther lifes the world powers decided it's time to stop the war. If Bosnians were let to finish the job our country would have a simple government now. The complexity of our government is simply the fault of UN EU and the world so don't make the fun of it. We suffered in the war and we are still suffering just because of the "civilised world" shame on them.
I'm Malaysian... FYi, All goverment decision and policy made by prime minister and his ministers .. The King just a symbol of people unity... that's all
BiH needs to change its constitution so that people are NOT defined by their religion/nationality, rather whoever is born in BiH is considered a BiH citizen. Problem solved.
Switzerland has a federal council that has 7 members who rotate the presidency. Works fine for the Swiss. This system can work if one puts a mind into it.
Serbs and Croats don't want it to work, they want open borders and trade with Serbia and Croatia, Bosniaks on the other hand push for complete independence from their neighbours, the only reason the country is together is because Serbs and Croats are constantly threatened with war and violence from Bosniaks, EU and NATO if they act out on their secessionist tendencies.
Let's just keep peace in Bosnia. There is no need for Serbians to join Serbia, or Croatians to join Croatia, because nothing will change. Those three countries are literally the same. Same language, same ethnic group, same economy, same metality of the people.
If the ethnic tension is so bad that you need a government this complicated, seems like you need to work on the tension. Nothing is going to get better before the tension does.
There can not be any work on the tension, NATO has thrown it's full support behind the Bosniaks, since they are their allies they will support them in full no matter what they do and in turn completely alienate the Serbs and Croats. NATO will never get tough on the Bosniaks and extend any support to the Serbs for example because the Serbs are friends to Russia. And if there is one main NATO policy it's that there is no compromise with Russia.
Just elect 1 President! You are just promoting divisiveness in a country who’s actually divided in the first place. Allow the three region to elect 1 person.
Democracy?! 😂 Yeah right....you know,on election day many people wait to see their dead relatives,cus they saw their names on voted list,even tho they are dead for looong time 😂 Democracy my as*
*Disclaimer: Only an idea.* Why not a single president with 2 deputies from native parliaments from the other ethnicities? Example: President is a Bosniak, 2 deputies will be a Croat and a Serb. - Anyone can be president no matter the ethnicity. - Deputies will represent the ethnicity and chosen from their native parliament. (Tripartite parliament instead, but similar to US states system and UK devolved government). They may not be in the succession. - National Parliament is for all representatives (no matter the ethnicity) voted in districts and such. May be bicameral or unicameral. - Courts will be subject to depending on the state. A Supreme Court does major and national related cases. - Executive cannot exceed 49% single ethnicity staff of his own ethnicity, as well as the other ethnicity. - Supreme Court staffed equally among the 3 ethnicities. A Chief Justice is chosen by candidacy through a Judicial board that confirms justices. Chief Justice role is equal among the others. - If districts are considered unethnically gerrymandered, courts may deem it illegal and redistrict it equally and properly. If other Justices protest, they may send it to the Hague. - Native Parliaments will make laws regarding their own ethnicity or states. Deputy is chosen from here. - Native laws can be struck down by the Supreme Court if deemed unconstitutional or plainly offensive to the other ethnicity. This way, a tripartite presidency is effectively abolished and deputies will instead be the voice of the 2 other ethnicities to the executive Deputies will perform consultative/advisory roles. They will also be included in the National Security Council.
3 presidents indeed are too much, but maybe 1 president is just too little. You then get unrighteous nonsense like in Lebanon with a Chistian president. Bosnia also can work with 2 presidents just like the SPQR's 2 consul system or the EU. Bosnia namely has the Croats and Bosniaks which can cooperate and the Serbs on the other hand.
They should stop the seperation and unite. I think Bosnia is the only country where religion determines your ethnicity. They should all be just bosnians regardless of religion. Problem solved
Nikola Milosevski that was the whole purpose of the war. Bosniaks wanting it unitary, Croats and Serbs wanting it a confederation. 100 000 people died and in the end they got something in between that nobody is happy with.
This happend because of Amercians. when we declerd indpendent and serbia declerd a war. After 3 years we started winning a war. But Amercians threaten to Bosnia if bosnian army started to returns its territories they will bomb bosnia. And we then got 3 presedents. A ruined economy that is falling apart even more. Republika Srpsak wonts indpendent (50% of Bosnian territory). Thanks America a lot.
The only reason the war went into a stalemate was due to Western NATO intervention. They pressured Croats to join you, renege their alliance with the Serbs and that is when the Serb offensive went into a stalemate. But you could not win. Srpska should be independent, if that is what its people want. Just as you wanted to be independent from Yugoslavia.
If the Serbs would realize they live in Bosnia this wouldn’t be an issue. If you want to live in Serbia it’s right across the border they got plenty of space. But it’s not about that it’s all about religion and nothing will change till the youth gets older and makes the changes. Older Bosnians will never forget the war and it will keep holding the country back. It’s a real shame honestly.
its a total mess, but better than war eh? I think the Federal republic of Bosnia-Herzogovina should join Croatia with autonomous rule and superior rights for Bosnians. republika srbska should be given a choice to join Serbia, on the condition of recognising Kosovo and normalising relations. anyway something along those lines...
@@abdurahmansaeed2111 bosniaks are the majority. If croats dont like Bosnia they can go live in Croatia. It's that simple.. if you dont like the country you live in just move..
Why not bosnia and hertz implementing cycle system of presidency, which means for first 5 year, president from Bosniak ethnic is elected to be president, then in another next 5 year election, Croats elected and Serbs elected in the next 5 years after Croats. So people of bosnia and hertz only got a president only but every ethnic can be the president by using cycling system. You can refer on the presidency system in Singapore as recently they vacant the president seat only for malay community as their govt had reformed the constitution where, 'president seat need to be specialize on an ethnic if there's no people from that ethnic is elected to become the president of singapore'. Bosnia should do this system, it's an effective and equal for all ethnics in this country.
This country is practically making money to give salary to these politicians.. Too much bureaucracy is bad for any country..
Im Bosniak and i agree with u
They're taking all the money, even if we had only 1 president he would still eat up all the money. They're just... out politicians are the most corrupt I know of.
We'll it's better to have one thief than two.. ^_^ I guess all countries have the same problem,. In our country they want to change the form of government to federalism , increasing the bureaucracy and also adding more politicians to the system.
You see, then a Croatian president would never get elected because the Croats are the least big of the 3 peoples. Also, all politicians here are nationalists so if a Serbian president gets elected then guess what happens! Some good old indoctrination and discrimination.
Guess what, in federation there are 10 cantons, meaning 10 more presidents, 10 more parliamens, 10 more ministry amd 10 everything else that goes with it. And it's all naturally founded by country's budget. There is tenfold bureaucratic leaches there. When you consider corruption of all Balkan politicians, it's almost impossible to grasp levels of scams that are in play in the Bosnia. Total of 14 complete governments in a single country, thousands upon thousands of bureaucrats getting they salary (disproportionately high compared to average salary in the country) and not generating any income to the budget. And people still wondering why it's hard to live in Bosnia?
It's because so much money that goes to the administration that it's insane. Imagine what that amount of money could do if transferred into factories over over time. And factories and other economic infrastructure exists in Bosnia, but they are questionably privatized and huge amount of them is closed.
That's why youth is leaving Bosnia, but that is also why youth is leaving Croatia, Serbia, Macedonia and Montenegro as well, corrupt governments who have destroyed our industry, our banking system, who are paying millions of € for a 1 meter of highway (money laundering on expert level). And it's all encouraged by the EU so that they will get cheap laber force to come into they countries and that they companies could built their factories where laber is even cheaper.
So I say carry on Serbs, Croats, Bosnians and everyone else, keep hating each other, keep listening to politicians who are selling you this hate, soon here won't be anybody to hate, won't be anybody to love either. Won't be anybody at all...
One President is bad enough. My heart goes out to these people.
that is the least important position in the country actually
Hahaha good one
Papi Uno swapping minorities? You do realise that 50% of Bosnia is consisted of Serbs and Croats that are majority on 75% of the Bosnian territory. The only true solution is to have a loose federation of three entities that should have a right on independecy referendum in 5-10 years. The country as it is is not self-sustainable, and bringing people closer together is not a solution since the hate is greater now than before the war.
Their president is only seremonial leader. Their real leader is their prime minister.
This is actually good
By doing this no one group can come in power
This is incredible. Never heard of such a complicated governmental structure. Makes me wonder if there are other countries with hierarchies this complex as well.
yeah there is you should look at lebanons parlament
Switzerland system is also pretty complicated itself. So much that most of Swiss people cant fully comprehend it.
The US
swiss system is clearly federal though, and it only has a bi-cameral parliament and a gov't at the federal level, no constitutional courts and no higher presidency. Indeed it's simpler than the US and germany.
Belgium.
A country like that has no chance of improving when everything is gridlocked among ethnic lines
Oh they'll Prosper alright and even prove this will work...
They speak the same language, and are only separated by a few facial genomes. Nationalism is a tool for great powers to use, to divide and conquer.
Saaduddin Ansari I ALWAYS TELL BOSNIANS, HOW WOULD THEY HANDLE A COUNTRY LIKE THE US THAT HAS MANY RELIGIONS AND ETHNIC GROUPS LIVING SIDE BY SIDE BUT YOU DONT SEE A WAR IN THE US RIGHT NOW! DO YOU?
Damir Hajrulahovic serbians just have lobby groups in America. That’s how they achieve that goal. Plus they have Serbian American politicians here.
@@philthefinadelphian4830
It's still real to the many Croatians and Serbians there.
Your message of ethnic kumbaya failed in tbe 90's and is failing now.
One has to acknowledge the fact that there can be no nation built out of Bosnia and Herzogvina; and that separation is for the best.
Bosnia - 3 elected presidents.
Qatar - 30 elected assembly members, 15 appointed by the king + 1 ruling family which chooses the king in their inner circle without consulting the public.
Birk Undae You also forgot that most of Qatari residents (almost 90 percent) could not vote as they are expatriates. So, the Qatari emir and 10 percent of population makes all the decisions.
@@artman7780 I honestly didn't know that. Now I do.
Qatar is an Emirate, not a Republic.
And what does that have to do with the video's content?
@@adnan37h This video is made by a channel sponsored by Qatari government. Non-democrats should first work on their own democracy before giving advises/opinions about functioning democracies.
It's like a homeless guy would give tips how to handle a job interview - just ignore it.
Lived in Bosnia for my whole life and I'm still lost on what's happening. No video can help💀
@Just Infinite are u Serbian?
@Just Infinite forreal,no offense to them 🤷🏻♀️
Čekaj, Stvarno?
REVOLUTION
Wonder if China, Indonesia, India has 1 president each ethnicity. There will br hundreds of president in the country.
The reason there are presidents for Serbs and Croats is cause they could not stop the Serbians short of giving them not 1, but 2 presidents and they would not have Croats as their allies without giving them one as well. Bosniaks simply don't have the power to rule over the country but are willing to do anything to keep it from falling a part, if they could they would subjugate both Croats and Serbs and take away their presidents and parliaments violently. But since they can't the only way to maintain even superficial political stability is to give them all these rights.
well they had croats as their allies before tudjman decided to go on a drink with milosevic and backstab them
Fortunately there's no benefit of doing such in Indonesia.
Because countries such India or Indonesia are post-colonial countries which is marked just by border rather than ethnicities, China was an empire then turn become Republic, while in Europe, countries are being built by its distinct history and ethnicity especially in the Eastern Europe, where the ethnic border form the border of country
@@__Man__ the only thing that benefit Indonesia is if there are representatives from eastern Indonesia. Out of our 7 presidents, only 1 of them are from eastern Indonesia, and that is Habibie from Celebes. Which by the way elected emergencily after the decline of Suharto. So yeah, practically that is not true democracy.
Other than that, mostly our presidents are Sumatran or Javanese.
I guess Indonesia only need 1 president, but with another candidates from East Indonesia.
Honestly, as a native Bosnian, even to me it's confusing at times :(
As a bosnian that lives in Sweden, this is confusing to me too
A channel run by a muslim royal family preaching about democracy...Lmao...!!! AJ promotes "democracy" everywhere except in their own country.
Well Qataris are happy so whats ur problem
@-IDidn'tEatYourDoritos12 - love you bosniaks brothers 😊😘😍
LONG LIVE CROATIAN REPUBLIC HERZEG BOSNIA!!!!!🇭🇷 🇭🇷 🇭🇷 🇭🇷
No you have croatia but bosniaks have nothing to call home you are Bosnian first then Croats and serbs, your genocide make you long before it Croats were less then they are now
ZDS..................... GO TO TURKEY, YOUR PLACE
@@aaryanqureshi5326
We don't have to choose. We're Croats from Bosnia. Just as there are Croats from Dalmatia. Bosnia is a region, not an ethnicity.
Meanwhile most of the gulf countries are ruled by kings
Who are puppets of the West
@iqbal sahibil Yo UAE is worst among the gulf countries where they were begging Americans to Transfer their base from Qatar to UAE and they will pay all the money,Also Saudi,UAE and Bahrain are more repressive than Qatar, u can look at how many political prisoners are there in Saudi,UAE and Bahrain. Compare that to Qatar which has improved since blocked
But are more stable.
At least they have money and only 'ONE' supremo unlike 3 presidents. Most Gulf kings are corrupt, yes, but they have enough money to afford it. Democracy can be equally corrupt where the spoils are shared by multiple politicians and businessmen. Welcome to my country India.
Binu Jasim That money will run out soon as the world starts using solar energy. Are you saying that India should become a dictatorship like China? In India, there are still checks and balances, and most people can vote. Meanwhile in Qatar, only 10 percent of the population (Qatari citizens) can vote, and even then, the Emir has the final say.
Pozdravi iz albanci
Bosna❤❤
When you don't trust each other but you're still neighbors
But bosnia and herzegovina is a parliamentary republic. So their president only have seremonial role, and their real political leader is the prime minister.
Bosnia does not have a prime minister! The real political leaders are presidents of two Entities: Republic of Srpska and Federation of BIH
@@milutinj so who is denis zvizdić?
Chairman of the Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Council of ministers do not have real power, any disputed decision by entity members, is sent back to entity governments for final decision.
@@milutinj i think that basicly what a federal state is.
@@milutinj E jesi i dosadan sa entitetima.Sta ce nam bezveze.Ovi politicari ovoliki samo mlate lovu i narod radi za njihove plate.Treba postaviti jednog predsjednika neka je i rom sto se mene tice,ukinuti entitete,imati samo opstine..e tada bi se zivjelo juh
...three-headed.....In Bosnia we call it "troglava aždaha"
Malaysia will always be friends with Bosnia.. Don't worry.. Malaysia had 9 king!!
Thank you. Finally someone friendly here.
😍
I'm Malaysian... FYi, All goverment decision and policy made by prime minister and his 32 ministers .. The 9 rotation King just a symbol of people unity... that's all
Malaysia has 9 kings, but all of them are Malays. Imagine having president coming from three different ethnic groups
Croats, Bosniaks, Serbs... They're the SAME: they speak the same language and they belong to the same ethnic group.
terioze9 split by religon and historical states
While they do belong to the same group called Slavs, they are very much different nations. Historically and in the end, culturally.
Yugoslavians
Everyone who speaks the Stokavian dialect (that mysterious language that people call Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian, Montenegrin) has a Serbian ancestry as Serbs were the only ones historically to speak that language (Croats spoke Chakavian). Literally the only way to solve the problem in the west Balkans is for Croats, Bosniaks and Montenegrins to accept their Serbian identity and create a country with Serbia, otherwise this region will be the laughingstock of the world forever.
@@andrejvidovic1 Hahaha samo ti sanjaj
al jazeera arabic would say:"imagine electing..."
No thanka
We don't want to elect clown lie Trump and Modi...
1:51 pusti covjeka da prica
i am a german MUSLiM, May ALLAH heLp the isLamic-Bosnian Akhis
If you are gonna have 3 presidents, you might as well split the country into 3:
Croat majority areas to Croatia
Bosniak majority area remains Bosnia
Serb majority area to Serbia
The 100 well bosnia was a country for hundreds of years so why end it now?? Might aswell keep moving forward because eventually these old minded and old nationalistic people will die and the new generation will change how things are right now.
And then what? We carve up your country among ethnic lines too? City block by city block?
Kristijan Car i hope you agree that Republika Srpska should be serbian
@Kristijan Car no it won't..
Kristijan Car lol my grandmother is from there. They hanged her uncle and burned all the Serbian churches in the war. That’s why there are croats there now.
After watching this, I understand why the serb leader wants to break away.
They are the ones who indirectly caused this problem in the first place. Never accept Serbs in large numbers into your country, I warn you.
Anar S. Serbs never invated the country the serbs has always lived there.
Anar S. before Bosnia existed that area belonged to serbia
@@Православл And that's why almost all the Serbian monasteries and churches were built after the Turkish incursion?! The Turks used typical divide and conquer tactics on the Croats through muslim conversion (Bosniaks) and colonization by Orthodox (Vlachs and Serbs).
So you are saying that Serbians wen't into Bosnia one day, started a war and after war they just stayed there and inhabited that land? Or more logical thinking could be that Serbs lived there for a long time and eventually when war broke out for whatever reason ppl started killing each other like in every war.
I'm sure the system can be changed, but it'll probably require that all self-identified ethnicities carry identification with said ethnicity written somewhere so that the right ballot is given. Having multiple executives aren't actually an impossible system for example Switzerland has 7 and they also have multiple linguistic and cultural groups working together for the better of all.
The problem with this entire system is that we who identify ourselves as ethnic Bosnians are not considered as a part of any constituent people. This is a problem because we do not have the right to run for presidency and change the Bosnian governmental system more effectively and finally make a citizen state. I sincerely hope we make progress.
@@ib368
Me too, from the Americas.🌎
Why Bosnia have 3 presidents, beacuse it is Yugoslavia 2.0, independance war of 90' was useless...
True
U mean 3.0?
Bosnian civill war was for freedom
A perfect place to start a revolution!!!
Perfect balance to stop another war.
Quite the contrary, the population is very divided with extremely slim chance to ''unite'' and act as a single unit to oppose the system which we call strait-jacket.
It's a primary example of divide and conquer(rule)!
yes, qatar is very good place to do it
I think they're doing things as well as they can. Unless you're from Bosnia you have no idea how complex our history really is. The fact that no war has erupted in the past 25 years is encouraging enough. I remember people saying in the late 90s that it will take at least half a century before things are even somewhat back to normal. Imo this 3 president thing is complicated but necessary if we are to eventually rebuild into a healthy country
I hear you, and I agree that the Dayton Peace Agreement has implemented peace, but this peace is just partial and hatred is still stirring in the background. I personally believe that the peace accord was very hastily done and its main “architects” did not fully understand Bosnia's history. Yes, I know, “who cares about history?” I hear people say all the time, but when you realize that division only escalated, the country’s national anthem is a cut-out of another piece and does not have its own lyrics, and the country’s flag is a clear smack in the face of Bosnia's history. Bosnia needs to become a republic, a country of its citizens and not its religious groups. Here is where the current system fails.
No this Dayton agreement is bullshit.
Great information thanks
Burek nije sirnica.
Love and respect for bosnia Herzegovina from Islamic republic of pakistan
Why tf would any nation want love or respect from a nation like Pakistan?
As pakistani shia Muslim we also victims of salafiism and wahabiism and you should know we did not sents salafi wahabi Saudi preachers to bosnia herzegvina must think?
@iqbal sahibil being Muslim and human we should not hijjack islam and kill innocents in reality islam is the name of peace,love,tolerance,help,duty, equality and humanity
@iqbal sahibil
'love and respect'
'we dont want your love and respect you evil Men!'
And here i was thinking only in fiction would exist people so cartoony ironic. You would think people would look at what they wrote and think 'hey, that doesnt seem right' but no, this right here is proof mankind can always sink even lower in the hole
@iqbal sahibil good thing he was preaching hate, otherwise your comment would make no sense at all.
Wait. He wasnt. You make no sense.
Seems like independence was not solution for total ethnic segregation ,so sad. We share your pain too. Love you Bosnia and Herzegovina from Turkmensitan🇹🇲🇧🇦
Which I find irritating. I do not understand how this many ethnic fights occur over in Central Asia when all of them except Tajiks are Turkic sharing history, culture and linguistics.
@@khagan5951 the same for Bosnia. everyone is south slavic people, and yet they all hate each other
I travelled to Mostar, Herzegovina on late July this year! Amazing country with amazing people, too bad it's still suffering from the scars of war.
One day herzegovina will be free
So Qatar is now democracy? equal right to women as of men? Labour rights???
@Mohd Khalid India and Thailand are ten times better than 100's of countries.
Seriously what are you comparing them to? Come out of that cave yet?
@Crow29Darkness good
@Crow29Darkness Gotta go live in Qatar, They can Have all my money...
@Crow29Darkness
So what Qatar is an Islamic country and islam doesn't allow homosexuality
The world doesn't revolve around you and different believes = different perspectives and laws
@@jarvisb.6013 No wonder y in Qatar there are millions of Thais and Indians
This country should learn from Indonesia.
What
Now think about this, Iran is a geographical area which is home to up to 30 ethnic groups! And people with different ethnicities been living together for 2500 years and we all proud to be Iranian above our ethnic background.
We are talking about The Land where the first World war began. So It's not that simple, there is much more than ethnic, and indeed we lived in one country with one Ruler it was very good Could not last for long
You're probably a Farsi. I've others like Kurds, Balochs, Arabs, etc are subjected to enormous discrimination.
@@Adam-nw1vy I’m not a “Farsi”. Farsi (Persian) is a language not ethnicity first of all. Secondly, I’m ethnically Turkish. Discrimination is everywhere you cannot control it. Depends on what you focus on. In İran, we focus on our commonality more than our differences. So those kind of ethnic propaganda doesn’t work on us. We’ve been a nation for 2500 years and will remain so.
@@nikankhamisi1175 I beg to differ. The Iranian regime is extremely oppressive as we have seen from the recent protests. How could anyone dare show any dissent or have pride in their culture in a totalitarian regime like that? I've seen many people, specially from Balochistan, who don't want to be part of Iran.
In any case, I personally don't mind if the whole world unites. What matters is justice, regardless of whether people are together or apart.
@@Adam-nw1vy Who was talking about the regime? Regimes come and go but our Iranian identity continues to be. This kind of material that you’re talking about doesn’t work in İran.
Falls fact: "Bosniaks and Croats are stripped of their rights to run for presidency in Republika Srpska". Bosniaks and Croats do have the right and are running for presidency in RS, Ramiz Salkic (Bosniaks) was a candidate. And BiH does not have 3 presidents, rather 3 members of presidency where each 6 months they rotate as presiding of the presidency.
My solution would be a parliamentary system with President as ceremonial position. If a bosniak becomes PM, then a serb would become president and a croat would become chairman of upper house. A bosniak cannot be PM and president. The ministries in cabinet would be divided in three and the PM can choose which ethnicity can have which ministry.
The states should separate and move on. No Federation.
Mark Paintner either that or a war, or worse a never ending democratic process.
Fully agreed with your opinion. That is the only way to solve the issue.
Very small states that would end up like Kosovo. Not sure it's a good idea. I like the idea of a federation more. But yes indipendence still better than the current situation.
I agree with you.
Croats join Croatia, Serbs join Serbia and Bosniaks can figure out what to so with the leftovers
split em up into 3 countries and let then rule over each
No because everything is mixed up, you can't just cut something off and create a new country. Plus croats and serbs would just annex themeselves to croatia and serbia, than bosnia would be a realy smal landlocked country
Or better, one president.
@@BinuJasim One president only can be in your dreams.
makomaro> then Americans also should go back to Ireland , Scotland, Portugal, Spain, Russia etc, because they are occupiers as well! Americas were under the Red Indians, Aztecs and Maya and Inka race of people!!
scorpioninpink What do you mean go "back"
That is their indigenous land.
Bosnia is not a nation state, it's borders are simply a left over of the Ottoman colonialism. And therefore the so called "bosniaks" have no claim over these artificial borders
The sad truth is that all 3 confessions in bosnia and herzegovina belong to one nation, the Croatian nation. Nobody wants to admit this.
Bosnia and herzegovina should be 2 regions of Croatia. The people there all speak the Croatian language.
Unfortunately, after roughly 1000 years of foreign occupation of Croatian lands, the majority of the people of Bosnia and of Herzegovina, who were originally overwhelmingly Catholic, accepted different faiths, notably Islam and Orthodox Christianity. This happened under the 400 years of Ottoman occupation, where Catholics were seen as the No. 1 enemy (the West).
Conversion of religion in and of itself is not even the problem. The problem is the subsequent manipulation and brainwashing of the local population by various powers and by the Serbian establishment that the local bosnian and herzegovinian populations are not of Croatian origin, when in fact, NOTHING could be further from the TRUTH!
Whatever happens to Bosnia and Herzegovina, may PEACE prevail. 🙏
imagine doing a law exam leave alone history exam.
Best explained 👍
Well articulated
DIVERSITY IS A STRENGTH
Especially when everyone shares a common language
Not if you live in Balkans ☺
RS is just a entity in Bosnia ❗️ long live bosnia and the bosniaks ❗️
Three Leaders Just like
Kim il-Sung
Kim jong-il
and Kim jong-un
Are you trolling?
They are not perfect, but 1000x more human than Kim Jong.
What to do? Yugoslavia just break up, despite having similarities with each other, a minor difference becomes a major difference.
What would you do then? Yugoslavia was only Yugoslavia because communist lords kept patriotism and identity down. You cannot force people to live together. In the West you force people but this will eventually fall.
I'm skeptical since this is coming from quite the biased source, but I do agree on the end message (assuming everything they said in this video was true).
I am not from Bosnia & Hercegovina, nor do I (try to) have any political bias, but I think, the only way, this state can handle its problems (unemployment, the outdated political system, debt, corruption, ...) in a decent way, is to stop segregating the people by their ethnicity. Only united this state can make proper progress.
Greetings from 🇦🇹 (the northernmost Balkan country 😉) to all Bosniaks, Croats and Serbs in BiH and elsewhere! 🇧🇦 🇭🇷 🇷🇸
Do you agree ( 👍 ) or disagree ( 👎 ) with what the Serbs have done to thousands of Bosniak women and young girls,during that aggression on Bosnia, ( Stretch Them Out ) by force,and do you agree or disagree that i deserve a girl even know many called me ugly when its not my fault,and lied to , me ,many were really mean to me ,mostly my own kind….and how would they feel if we Bosniaks would be little devils like them and do it to their women and young girls??
@@angrybutgoodbosniak9128 The catalyst for the atrocities that Serbs committed was the Bosnian side ignoring the pleas of the Serbs and Croats, despite not having a majority, to unilaterally declare independence. You reaped what you sowed. This is the result of what happens, when you wish to seek freedom, at the expense of other people's freedom.
Well at least they have democracy unlike........................ Qatar
Aditya Malladi nah, Croats still cant pick their own president
@@miamarinovic933 and that's okay
@@miamarinovic933 bosnian croats can annex federation of bosnia less than 6 months
3 presidents and 1 eu appointed dictator above them all. Next time try to tell the full story :)
Who's the appointed dictator?
This is an insane system!
I didn't' know anything about this, thanks for the explanation!
Bosnia is so rich they can afford 6 presidents
Just when you thought democracy couldn't get any worse
It makes me think that local governance with fairly weak nations is likely a better way to go. In Canada the Federal government is fairly weak while provinces have more power and municipalities have a fair bit of power as well.
There is a balance that needs to be struck between simplicity and autonomy that is always tricky. But I really think that local governance is always best. If this crazy sounding system creates that and prevents war then hey I guess that is a good thing!
Same in Pakistan. Provinces are un more power than federal capital Islamabad.
Bosnia is a country of over 1,000 years of history and heritage. When Bosnia had government and was developing culture and art, America wasn't yet discovered and Gulf countries were only desert (both are today preaching us). Bosnia shouldn't dissolve, because it is a sovereign country that has lived through all wars, empires, conquests and occupations. It is surely gonna live through this complicated system (caused by Serbia, Croatia and international community) and finally live to see its future, as an united and free country.
Bosnia is a land with over 1000 years of history but not a country, it can barely scrap 50 years of functioning as a country and a majority of that is in the middle ages, and not even once in it's history was it in any way independent from it's neighbours.
@@Luka-zf2ye you can make the same claim for most balkan nations as most of them has been subjugated by some major nation in the region let it be roman, byzantine, turk or austrian our identity as we know it today was formed in the ideals of nationalism in the 19th and 20th century
GO TO TURKEY CLOWN
Bosnians are not to blame for the complexity of our government. During the war of the 90s world community did everything in it's power to disable Bosnians to defend themselves against military aggression of serbia and croatia. Against all the odds Bosnian managed to get the upper hand and just before the aggressors where forced to run for ther lifes the world powers decided it's time to stop the war. If Bosnians were let to finish the job our country would have a simple government now. The complexity of our government is simply the fault of UN EU and the world so don't make the fun of it. We suffered in the war and we are still suffering just because of the "civilised world" shame on them.
the system like malaysian king..having 9 state with their own king every 5 years the different king will rule the nation ..
I'm Malaysian... FYi, All goverment decision and policy made by prime minister and his ministers .. The King just a symbol of people unity... that's all
They are not killing each other, therefore it works.
BiH needs to change its constitution so that people are NOT defined by their religion/nationality, rather whoever is born in BiH is considered a BiH citizen. Problem solved.
Wow....a great key point....
Switzerland has a federal council that has 7 members who rotate the presidency. Works fine for the Swiss. This system can work if one puts a mind into it.
Serbs and Croats don't want it to work, they want open borders and trade with Serbia and Croatia, Bosniaks on the other hand push for complete independence from their neighbours, the only reason the country is together is because Serbs and Croats are constantly threatened with war and violence from Bosniaks, EU and NATO if they act out on their secessionist tendencies.
Let's just keep peace in Bosnia. There is no need for Serbians to join Serbia, or Croatians to join Croatia, because nothing will change. Those three countries are literally the same. Same language, same ethnic group, same economy, same metality of the people.
It will change, serbs and croats would finally breath without turks.
Same economy? What?
Technically Lebanon is also sort of like that where the President, PM and Speaker of Parliment have equal power.
If the ethnic tension is so bad that you need a government this complicated, seems like you need to work on the tension. Nothing is going to get better before the tension does.
There can not be any work on the tension, NATO has thrown it's full support behind the Bosniaks, since they are their allies they will support them in full no matter what they do and in turn completely alienate the Serbs and Croats. NATO will never get tough on the Bosniaks and extend any support to the Serbs for example because the Serbs are friends to Russia. And if there is one main NATO policy it's that there is no compromise with Russia.
Just elect 1 President! You are just promoting divisiveness in a country who’s actually divided in the first place. Allow the three region to elect 1 person.
I never imaging when indonesia like that
REPUBLIC OF SERBOSCRO
PRESIDENT : SERBIA
PRIME MINISTER : BOSNIA
MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS : CROATIA
Semi autonomous regions with their own presidents to satisfy each ethnic group and a national president everyone can vote for.
Dragon of Bosnia is rolling in his grave.
My head ia spinning, any one else....??
At least Bosnia has democracy however flawed it is unlike Qatar
Democracy?! 😂 Yeah right....you know,on election day many people wait to see their dead relatives,cus they saw their names on voted list,even tho they are dead for looong time 😂 Democracy my as*
Democracy but poor
While Qatar Emirate but Ruch
:)
We understand you like democracy but plz stop forcing it on people, not everybody wants what you want.
I am malaysia ....malay , chiness,india .....
and i thought my country's politics is already a mess...
*Disclaimer: Only an idea.*
Why not a single president with 2 deputies from native parliaments from the other ethnicities?
Example: President is a Bosniak, 2 deputies will be a Croat and a Serb.
- Anyone can be president no matter the ethnicity.
- Deputies will represent the ethnicity and chosen from their native parliament. (Tripartite parliament instead, but similar to US states system and UK devolved government). They may not be in the succession.
- National Parliament is for all representatives (no matter the ethnicity) voted in districts and such. May be bicameral or unicameral.
- Courts will be subject to depending on the state. A Supreme Court does major and national related cases.
- Executive cannot exceed 49% single ethnicity staff of his own ethnicity, as well as the other ethnicity.
- Supreme Court staffed equally among the 3 ethnicities. A Chief Justice is chosen by candidacy through a Judicial board that confirms justices. Chief Justice role is equal among the others.
- If districts are considered unethnically gerrymandered, courts may deem it illegal and redistrict it equally and properly. If other Justices protest, they may send it to the Hague.
- Native Parliaments will make laws regarding their own ethnicity or states. Deputy is chosen from here.
- Native laws can be struck down by the Supreme Court if deemed unconstitutional or plainly offensive to the other ethnicity.
This way, a tripartite presidency is effectively abolished and deputies will instead be the voice of the 2 other ethnicities to the executive
Deputies will perform consultative/advisory roles. They will also be included in the National Security Council.
3 presidents indeed are too much, but maybe 1 president is just too little. You then get unrighteous nonsense like in Lebanon with a Chistian president. Bosnia also can work with 2 presidents just like the SPQR's 2 consul system or the EU. Bosnia namely has the Croats and Bosniaks which can cooperate and the Serbs on the other hand.
How does it work? It doesn´t.
what a medieval system!
I think medieval system better than this
Medieval system? This is a modern, democratic bullshit of a system.
Ahhh..Medieval system,or war...:(
monarchy is a medieval system. just like qatar have, lmao.
@@banahezzer4632 So sad that bosniak ortodox and chatolics dont want unity and make some strong country
8 Hours Duty 8*3=24
one president Sleeping Other One wakeup
They should stop the seperation and unite. I think Bosnia is the only country where religion determines your ethnicity. They should all be just bosnians regardless of religion. Problem solved
I totally agree!
They can divide the country into 2 and each can have their independence. just like North Korea& South Korea. Or Sudan& South Sudan
B&H should become unitary state. It is more functional and cheaper.
Nikola Milosevski that was the whole purpose of the war. Bosniaks wanting it unitary, Croats and Serbs wanting it a confederation. 100 000 people died and in the end they got something in between that nobody is happy with.
This happend because of Amercians. when we declerd indpendent and serbia declerd a war. After 3 years we started winning a war. But Amercians threaten to Bosnia if bosnian army started to
returns its territories they will bomb bosnia. And we then got 3 presedents. A ruined economy that is falling apart even more. Republika Srpsak wonts indpendent (50% of Bosnian territory). Thanks America a lot.
The only reason the war went into a stalemate was due to Western NATO intervention. They pressured Croats to join you, renege their alliance with the Serbs and that is when the Serb offensive went into a stalemate. But you could not win. Srpska should be independent, if that is what its people want. Just as you wanted to be independent from Yugoslavia.
Bosnia and Herzegovina: The Country with Three Presidents
Switzerland: Am i a joke to u
Bosnia & Herzegovina have 3 presidents. *Meanwhile, the Swiss has 8 presidents*
But does the country have a prime minister or is it the 3 presidents who head the government?
If the Serbs would realize they live in Bosnia this wouldn’t be an issue. If you want to live in Serbia it’s right across the border they got plenty of space. But it’s not about that it’s all about religion and nothing will change till the youth gets older and makes the changes. Older Bosnians will never forget the war and it will keep holding the country back. It’s a real shame honestly.
Have you guys woken up with this fact? We all know this
its a total mess, but better than war eh?
I think the Federal republic of Bosnia-Herzogovina should join Croatia with autonomous rule and superior rights for Bosnians.
republika srbska should be given a choice to join Serbia, on the condition of recognising Kosovo and normalising relations.
anyway something along those lines...
Why would we join Croatia when Bosnia outdates it..?
+Bosnian Kingdom bc Bosnia is not viable on its own, AND Bosnians ans Croats are already living together in a federation. its not bad is it?
@@abdurahmansaeed2111 bosniaks are the majority. If croats dont like Bosnia they can go live in Croatia. It's that simple.. if you dont like the country you live in just move..
Nah we dont been Bosnia ty
More democratic solution is exactly what Bosnia needs . What's more democratic then letting people vote in what country they wanna live ?
Are the presidents not only the heads of state?
🇧🇦
3 presidents /3 Pms / 3 Armys/ i think number 3 lucky number of bosnian people
1 army but 3 nation in army
Only Zlatan Ibrahimovic can be the ONE President that nobody will dare to question !!!
THERE WASN'T A WAR HERE IN THE 1990'S IT WAS AN AGGRESSION ON BOSNIAKS PLEASE PAY ATTENTION AT WHAT YOURE SAYING
@15 1 u talk too much falsehood.
An aggresion if a form of war
This is not a true. Bosniaks and Croats can vote for their candidate in Republica Serbska and u are saying that can't. A scam video
Bosnia is the only Country in the World that has won the War and lost half of the Country Land ...
support bosnian brothers and sisters from Pakistan
The familly of Alcapone and Corleone is kitty smoke for 3 presidents of Bosnia
A small complicated country.
Why not bosnia and hertz implementing cycle system of presidency, which means for first 5 year, president from Bosniak ethnic is elected to be president, then in another next 5 year election, Croats elected and Serbs elected in the next 5 years after Croats. So people of bosnia and hertz only got a president only but every ethnic can be the president by using cycling system. You can refer on the presidency system in Singapore as recently they vacant the president seat only for malay community as their govt had reformed the constitution where, 'president seat need to be specialize on an ethnic if there's no people from that ethnic is elected to become the president of singapore'. Bosnia should do this system, it's an effective and equal for all ethnics in this country.