Fram Ultra XG10060 Oil Filter vs. Wix 57060XP Oil Filter Cut Open Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 222

  • @WhipCityWrencher
    @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +12

    Hello Friends, If you've posted a comment and it disappeared, "Please post it again". I saw some comments that went to my spam folder that shouldn't have. UA-cam sometimes deletes posts for No reason. Thank You!

    • @faxmen09
      @faxmen09 Рік тому +2

      Yep, I've had posts deleted by yt quite a few times replying on Whip's vids. I know they don't let me post outside yt reference links so given up on that. A few times had posts deleted with no outside link. Seems yt thinks many comments are spam and deletes them.

    • @SlikLizrd
      @SlikLizrd Рік тому +2

      No explanation is necessary, Pete -- because no explanation will suffice.

    • @mmjay7078
      @mmjay7078 Місяць тому

      Who cares if the insides are trash

  • @michaelcinaz
    @michaelcinaz Рік тому +3

    A few days ago I bought the Fram ultra synthetic XG3614 at Walmart for $8.97, along with the Fram ultra premium engine air filter and Valvoline full synthetic high mileage 5W 30 oil. I was going to AutoZone and buying the exact same oil, along with the STP S3614XL for $9.99. The STP is a good filter and engineered to last up to 10,000 miles, but the Fram XG is engineered to last up to 20,000 miles and it’s at a lower price. No matter what products I use, I always change the oil every six months or within 5000 miles. I appreciate your videos.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +2

      You're Welcome,👍
      I think the Fram Ultra and Valvoline oil is a great combo for a 5K oil change interval😊
      Thanks!

  • @javieracevedo4406
    @javieracevedo4406 Рік тому +14

    I like and have used the Fram Ultra for years with zero issues. I also like that you can get it anywhere.

    • @bigdavedayday1581
      @bigdavedayday1581 Рік тому +3

      Yep walmart sells them for 8 bucks cant beat it

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому +1

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them.

    • @journeyman291
      @journeyman291 4 місяці тому

      Can't find xg for toyota hybrids

  • @beverlyhurd8556
    @beverlyhurd8556 Рік тому +10

    All I know that in over 50 years of using Fram oil filters I have never had an problem. So if you are one of those that has an issue with them then use something else. Simple as that.

  • @Lifegoeson-nv9jv
    @Lifegoeson-nv9jv Рік тому +4

    Wix XP better filter then fram, fram is like last resort,wix XP is if you want your vehicle in good shape

  • @kalapanas
    @kalapanas Рік тому +39

    I really like that exterior grippy coating that Fram does on their filters. Why can't everyone do that?

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +7

      I like it too!👍

    • @faxmen09
      @faxmen09 Рік тому +8

      I dislike the grippy stuff on the Fram. Makes using a cap wrench to remove filter sometimes impossible. The caps wrench slips on the coating. I prefer to use a cap wrench, so coating a no bueno for me.

    • @SlikLizrd
      @SlikLizrd Рік тому +7

      Actually, everyone COULD put that "Grippy Stuff" on there -- but, THANKFULLY, they DON'T !!
      That's why God made Oil Filter Wrenches.

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому +1

      I wonder if Fram patented that. Maybe the Fram web site has information about that.

    • @junboo8730
      @junboo8730 Рік тому +2

      @@WhipCityWrencher I like it too but only when you work on your car. It makes the grip so much better when tightening by hand.

  • @WhipCityWrencher
    @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +8

    ► Thanks For Watching! and Watch an oil filter inspection video every Friday on this UA-cam Channel, Thank You!

  • @robshaw2990
    @robshaw2990 Рік тому +5

    Merry Christmas Whip
    And to all of us oil heads that watch this every time Whip drops a new video

  • @Erdie5
    @Erdie5 Рік тому +20

    Wow, I've never been on the Fram wagon and have used Wix XP for years. I noticed the Fram gasket has concentric rings as well, which help make a better seal. Never had an issue there, but it's something. Didn't realize Wix cheapened up the XP so much. Between the better micron rating, the thicker can and the grippy coating, I'm thinking my days of ordering Wix XP off rockauto and paying a bunch on shipping are over when the Ultra appears nearly identical if not superior in quality and is available anywhere.

  • @jonathannance5086
    @jonathannance5086 Рік тому +20

    Thanks, Pete
    Both filters are top shelf choices. Price wise, Fram but the build quality to the Wix. The Wix had excellent media spacing. I don't think you could make a bad choice running either of these filters. Merry Christmas to you and your family Pete.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      You're Welcome, Jonathan!
      Merry Christmas to You and Your Family Also!🎄

    • @jackle842000
      @jackle842000 8 місяців тому

      Fram had less pleats but each one was much wider which is why the filter media's was longer with so many less pleats.

  • @tariqbhatti6584
    @tariqbhatti6584 Рік тому +14

    They are both great filters, but for the price, I’d go with the Fram XG. I know the Boss has the same filter media, but XP should also have the same micron rating of 20 like the boss. Great Video🎉

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +4

      Thanks, Tariq!
      The Purolator Boss is a good oil filter, the micron rating on the Boss is 99% at 25 microns.

  • @PatriotPaulUSA
    @PatriotPaulUSA Рік тому +3

    Thanks So much for doing this. These are the 2 filters I use. I am using the 20 micron Fram in the warm months, and the 35 micron Wix in the cold months when oil is thick like syrup at startup, in sub zero temps. The can and baseplate are slightly better on the Fram. On everything else, the Wix beats it, except for the Micron rating of Wix's 35 vs Frams 20 because of the paper media I would bet. The filter media spacing was terrible on the Fram. The 20 micron Fram would also be more restrictive to Oil flow. Also, the Wix center metal tube has so much more oil flow thru all the perferations. 95 to 101 sq inches is a toss up to me but U could say Fram is the winner. I think its negligible to have 5% more filter area but it needs all it can get with its more restriction to flow. ( If they were made with identical media a 20 micron would be more restrictive than a 35 from the start. ) These 2 have different media types though. The drainback valve is also slightly better in the Wix imho.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      You're Welcome!
      Glad you liked the comparison, Thanks👍

  • @LarryReynolds591
    @LarryReynolds591 Рік тому +6

    Seems like Fram has really upped their game and just bare brand preference is the only reason ppl are choosing hte Wix in the comments here. I still use OEM mopar on my hemi but videos like this are really openingi my mind up on the idea that the brand isn't always the best indicator.

    • @memopadilla5931
      @memopadilla5931 Рік тому +1

      Yes it is obvious they just like the name.. They have no clue what they are voting for with the loser .35 filtration rating and .3 mm material.. $6 filter at most.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +2

      Thank You!

  • @Jay388
    @Jay388 Рік тому +5

    Hate to see my Fram Ultra looking sloppy 😢lol
    That's my go to for my 08 F150, XG2 .
    Nice video as always!
    Thanks! 😎👍👍🤙

  • @Gsnoop440
    @Gsnoop440 7 місяців тому +1

    I always use Fram Tough Gaurd on all my vehicles my wife drives alot for work so I go through them pretty quick. I have never had a problem with them and I like it that they are always in stock. Also as have have said the grip ring is great!

  • @drumtwo4seven
    @drumtwo4seven Рік тому +11

    I'm going with the FRAM ULTRA on this one...
    Although I think the WIX was pretty good too.
    FRAM had a much better micron rating 20 microns vs Wix 35 microns that's nearly double that of FRAM potentially letting more harmful debris through.
    Surface area 5" (5.7x") difference between the two so I don't think that was much of a factor.... Thickness of the actual filter media I gave to the FRAM.
    Pressure relief valve design I prefer the WIX but not as important as micron rating. And lastly the inlet holes I give to FRAM one more than Wix plus FRAMs were elongated.
    Nice comparison. Sweet video 👍
    Merry Christmas ⛄🎄

  • @ellalamont6943
    @ellalamont6943 Рік тому +4

    How nice of Jason! YaY! Another great filter review! Merry Christmas! ✨🎄✨Happy and Healthy Holidays to All! 🥰

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      Thanks, Ella, and Merry Christmas!🎄
      Also Thank You, Jason!

  • @LoydChampion
    @LoydChampion Рік тому

    Over the years I've used all sorts of oil filters on street cars all of the way to full on racing engines. Since 1973 I've had 2 oil filters fail, and both were from Fram. One was on a street car, a PH8A on a 302 Ford in the 1990's and the other on a racing engine that I was forced to use a Fram Filter from the auto parts store. Both of them internally imploded.
    The street 302 filter I think imploded as the result of something coming apart in it, but it didn't cause any engine damage. I knew something had happened because the vehicle had an oil pressure gauge and it started acting funny. So I looked into it when I got home and found the filter was imploded inside. Put on a new filter and added some oil and all was good with the vehicle for another 60,000 miles or so until I sold the car.
    The racing engine issue I felt was from the larger volume of oil that the dry sump system was able to move. Since the engine was being shifted at 8,500 RPM, it was moving a lot of oil, and it just failed. The driver saw the oil pressure drop in half so he came in and told the crew about it. Fortunately it happened during a Thursday practice session. They got a WIX from a parts trailer and everything worked fine for the rest of their weekend. As a result, I made an oil filter adapter to permit the use of an HP Filter to prevent that from happening again.
    In my engine life I have had engines fail in racing. Each time whatever filter was on the car captured lots of stuff until it couldn't any more and the bypass opened. But most of the crap was in the filter.

  • @PapiDoesIt
    @PapiDoesIt Рік тому +3

    The only time I would use a Fram is when I have a really sludgy engine and I'm cleaning up the crankcase with Sea Foam. It's cheap enough to use to catch the initial crud, but after that I change the oil and use a Wix.

  • @Jayda08
    @Jayda08 11 місяців тому +1

    Ive used orange can Fram filters since the 1990s on 8 different brands of vehicles with zero issues, except on Porsche and BMW (which required their own filters ).
    An oil filter that can filter particles greater than 20 microns like the Fram in the video, is a great filter in my book. 35 microns is not ideal, that's where particles start to damage the engine over time.

  • @lukeWiz44
    @lukeWiz44 Рік тому +10

    I would definitely go with the fram, being at the wix XP has a nominal micron rating of 35.

    • @memopadilla5931
      @memopadilla5931 Рік тому

      I cannot believe they are putting material that thin on the Wix. . and they want $17 for this horrible thin material with micron 35 like a jobber filter.

  • @riceburner4747
    @riceburner4747 Рік тому +3

    🎄Merry Christmas!🎄 Nothing against Wix but I've never used. Saying this, this Wix looks well made! The pleats on Fram is sad. Thank u for all your videos! 🇺🇸

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      You're Welcome Rice, and have a Merry Christmas!🎄

  • @faxmen09
    @faxmen09 Рік тому +5

    Excellent comparison of the feared louvered center tube to the Fram tube. The louvered tube has significantly more openings than the tube with holes. Not sure how much one can trust the O'R site efficiency rating for the XP (Napa Platinum) when Wix is very tight lipped and lists nothing on the box. That, even though O'R shows nothing great. Same as the Platinum, it looks well made. Too expensive though. A shame First Brands has cheapened the media on the Ultra, not near the filter it used to be. So, neither filter really interests me at their current price. Thanks for the vid. Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays Whip.

  • @shericharboneau5721
    @shericharboneau5721 Рік тому +9

    Thanks!! The Wix won in my opinion for better filter material structure when magnified, it looks a lot more regularly woven and spaced. The Fram looks clumped and less orderly. The oil should flow better through the WIX as long as it doesn't get too clogged from catching all those fine particles.

    • @conner474
      @conner474 Рік тому +2

      The Fram Ultra micron rating is 99% at 20 microns and the WIX is 30 microns .

    • @shericharboneau5721
      @shericharboneau5721 Рік тому +1

      @@conner474 The oil flow was my main concern as the lifters rely heavily upon this, when it drops down due to any obstruction it reduces engine life, and just like an HVAC filter, if the filtration is too heavy, it back-feeds the HVAC pump, I'm seeing a similar issue in my dodge charger where the WIX filter appears to provide better flow for the engine. FYI.
      👍

    • @conner474
      @conner474 Рік тому +1

      @@shericharboneau5721 Th Fram has a better flow rate .I know where you are coming from as far as HVAC .But Fram Ultra is NOT obstructive . Both are good filters and you cant go wrong with either. But for the money im putting a Ultra on my car. Bob the oil guy has many threads on his site about this.Look up Ascent Filtration Testing.. Fram ultra beat every filter they tested..

    • @shericharboneau5721
      @shericharboneau5721 Рік тому +1

      @@conner474 right on thanks for the feedback, the Wix filter appears to not collapse under the pressure like the Fram did when I tried it, it caught more but also clogged in less than 5000 miles blocking flow and causing damage to the engine. I haven't seen the same flow cut-off with the WIX extreme series. FYI.

    • @shericharboneau5721
      @shericharboneau5721 Рік тому +1

      @@happydogg312 depends on the oil, a master mechanic friend of mine suggested using any oil and just changing it every 1000 miles as he had done. He owned a 1978 honda and it ran great and didn't burn oil at all. he said the concrete dusts from the roads polish the inside of the load bearing surfaces in the rotating assemblies such as the bearings and he said due to this they won't hold oil at the highest stress and pressure points after a while as well as the dusts tend to essentially grind the engine down like a lapidary paste. So Fram... yeah I used that for years in my Hondas without issue till I got my 2.7L demonic Dodge engine which takes special cares such as the WIX filter that I found appears to allow for more oil flow, better preserving the engine. The heads for example are over $1000 each used, something I don't want to replace any time soon. 167,000 miles so far.

  • @budblack3588
    @budblack3588 Рік тому +5

    I choose the Wix filter, the media looks better and the assembly quality is better.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      Hi, bud
      Thanks for the feedback and Happy Holidays!

    • @kellismith4329
      @kellismith4329 6 місяців тому +1

      Roughly double the price though, where I live anyway - to me the fram ultra is good enough for me as I change the oil very regularly

  • @kellismith4329
    @kellismith4329 6 місяців тому +1

    Those are both good filters, I used to use the wix xp all the time, but for the price of the fram ultra synthetic I have switched over

  • @michaelbutler9528
    @michaelbutler9528 Рік тому +5

    Wix XP..........Ford Truck / wife's Subaru Legacy / Husquvarna Lawn Tractor / Mustang Boss 302 / Daytona Coupe Replica, Ford 363 crate motor.......Hey, just trying to stay consistant..............

  • @scottymoondogjakubin4766
    @scottymoondogjakubin4766 Рік тому +6

    The fram ultra is still the best bang for the $ !

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them.

    • @scottymoondogjakubin4766
      @scottymoondogjakubin4766 Рік тому +1

      @@Balticblue93 thanks brotha ! I'll have to try that out ! 😊

  • @defaultdriftco00
    @defaultdriftco00 Рік тому +7

    Never have trusted a Fram filter on my vehicle. Even the “better” filters, such as this.
    Definitely would choose the Wix.
    Thanks for the comparison and merry Christmas to you and yours!

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +2

      Merry Christmas Mark!🎄

    • @GT-mn3bx
      @GT-mn3bx Рік тому +3

      I'd get a 6 dollar Wix Regular with the better microm rating. XPs are terrible IMO.

    • @johnqpublic2949
      @johnqpublic2949 Рік тому +1

      Very Nice filter by Wix, but Thier Costs Keep Rising every 6 months... At the Auto Parts Store out here by us,( Hold On to your hats Folks) it's Still a "Western Auto" the Wix filter goes for close to $20 bucks with tax... I use Fram Ultra or on the older vehicle,I can't beat the Super Tech price point, for Thier 10,000 mile rated filter... When we go way into town... But to each his own, if I had my choice and cost is no object, a Purolator Boss for extended OCI range or A K&N filter for Thier stout micron rating...Mérry CHRISTmas 🌞

    • @CL-yp1bs
      @CL-yp1bs Рік тому +1

      The fram performs better. Way better

  • @1RobHunter1
    @1RobHunter1 Рік тому +3

    I like the Wix build quality, but the micron rating needs to be at 20 level.

  • @patrickhenry2845
    @patrickhenry2845 7 місяців тому +1

    The Fram FE oil filter Series is as good as any oil filter on the market today. Not cheap though.

  • @scottrussell6717
    @scottrussell6717 Рік тому +2

    Almost makes me want to try a fram ultra instead of my usual napa gold oil filter... another great job Peter...suggestion.... do some lawn mower filters.. just an idea

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Thanks, Scott
      I have done a couple in the past, here's one. ua-cam.com/video/ehpiU1cJUs0/v-deo.html&ab_channel=WhipCityWrencher

  • @CJ-wc6lf
    @CJ-wc6lf Рік тому +1

    My opinion is they are both great, and you can't go wrong with either one, so go with the cheapest one, your vehicle probably won't know the difference.

  • @Kfcfranchises
    @Kfcfranchises Рік тому +11

    The Fram XG is just a way better value and quality than the Wix XP is now, kinda sad to see Wix fall below Fram

  • @spectrexiii5529
    @spectrexiii5529 Рік тому +2

    Yeah, the Wix XP looks like a better made filter in many ways, but man.... nominal micron rating of 35... not that your engine would even care, just seems the Fram would be much better at nominal micron rating of 20, and even does decent at 15 where as XP drops to 50% at 20. Im really not a fan of Fram honestly, but their ultra line seems to do well.

  • @jp-nq5wd
    @jp-nq5wd Рік тому +1

    I've been using the Wix XP for some time. No issues. The one that fits my Accord is under $9 at Rock auto.

    • @bassheadlife492
      @bassheadlife492 7 місяців тому

      But then you have to pay for shipping 🚢

  • @johnqpublic2949
    @johnqpublic2949 Рік тому +11

    In a Wink of an Eye, it'll be 2023, and I still keep hearing, Fram is this, Fram is that, I'd never use a Fram, because,blah blah blah!!! Good thing the multi Millions that have and do use them, keeps Fram probably the largest filter seller in the world, (at least the USA) My eyes don't decieve me, that is one high quality Fram filter, especially for Under $10 in this inflation driven economy! Love 😘 Filter Friday, my mundane life, gets a big charge out of PETE'S hard work and his filter knowledge... Happy Jesus's two thousandth and twenty second Birthday ✝️🥳✝️Stay Warm Fellow Midwesterners and everywhere else that is struggling against the Frozen Tundra 👌

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому +1

      If there was only the choice between these two filters, I couldn’t justify spending $7 more on the Wix XP. I would use the Fram.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +2

      Hi John,
      Thanks for your feedback, and Thanks for reminding us why we celebrate this time of Year!
      Merry Christmas!

    • @darianthompson5975
      @darianthompson5975 11 місяців тому

      A year later

  • @lg9853
    @lg9853 Рік тому +5

    Both seem pretty good. I know I'd take the Wix over the fram basic filter. Happy holidays to you WCW

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      Happy Holidays, LG!

    • @SlikLizrd
      @SlikLizrd Рік тому +2

      WHAT "fram basic filter !?? There is nothing "basic" about the Fram Ultra .

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому +2

      @@SlikLizrd I believe L G is comparing the standard Wix (or the Napa Gold) against the lowest end Fram with the fiber endcaps.

  • @hondaelsinore1974
    @hondaelsinore1974 Рік тому +5

    Wix all the way!

  • @adkfoothills1973
    @adkfoothills1973 Рік тому +7

    For me the Fram wins this one, but I'd probably use either one. Thanks for the videos, Whip and have a Happy Holiday!! 🎀🎁

  • @kirkdunn1379
    @kirkdunn1379 Рік тому +1

    Just change your oil more often if you want it to last as long as possible....clean oil is key

  • @jeffkortsch8276
    @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому +9

    Based on the micron rating and the similar square inches of filter media, I don’t see a reason to spend $7 more for the Wix XP unless you plan on running the XP to much longer than most oil change intervals. The Ultra looks to be built to a much higher quality than the low-end cardboard endcap Fram oil filter.
    I’m sure someone here can point out more information about the Ultra on the Fram website - I have been told it is full of information and some of it might actually be there.
    Happy holidays!

    • @GT-mn3bx
      @GT-mn3bx Рік тому

      I'd spend less on sale for Wix Regular/Napa Gold.

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому

      @@GT-mn3bx If you catch them on sale, they might be less than the Fram.
      I think the standard Wix/Napa Gold/Purolator One are the sweet spot in the Mann+Hummel oil filter offerings.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      Hi Jeff,
      Happy Holidays!

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому +2

      @@WhipCityWrencher Thanks. Happy holidays to you.
      May your oil filters all have silicone anti-drainback valves and coil springs in the new year.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      @@jeffkortsch8276 👍

  • @daewooparts
    @daewooparts Рік тому +5

    Dang ,the FRAM is like the Stacy Adams of filters, look at those unsightly gaps 😄

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +2

      LOL

    • @maximusn8392
      @maximusn8392 Рік тому +1

      I'm wondering if those gaps on the Ultra will be a problem. I really liked the original Ultra media. Sad that they changed what was once very highly praised oil filter on BITOG.

    • @Generaider
      @Generaider Рік тому

      @@maximusn8392 iirc Fram Titanium still uses the original Ultra synthetic, wire-backed media

  • @ivanmitchell3876
    @ivanmitchell3876 Рік тому +1

    had no idea the wix advanced filter had such a high price.?.not a great price 4 the fram but better.👍👍 great video & happy holidays.🌚

  • @charleswynn9920
    @charleswynn9920 Рік тому +3

    If you change your oil and filter every 5k miles then stick with fram oil filter for saving your money

  • @kenj.8897
    @kenj.8897 Рік тому +3

    Good video . The wire backed grams are still floating around . Bought 5 this week at Walmart, new printing on box but all had wire still .

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +3

      Good deal, Ken
      Some like the New ones, but I prefer the wire-backed version.

    • @faxmen09
      @faxmen09 Рік тому

      Buy a lottery ticket, you got lucky. Most OG media Ultra long gone now.Titanium following too.

  • @GT-mn3bx
    @GT-mn3bx Рік тому +3

    Sadly, Fram Ultra isn't available for tons of popular vehicles like Duramaxes or even most GM boat engines. 496, 502 etc. Tons of others. So Wix Regular/Napa Gold is the go to.

    • @faxmen09
      @faxmen09 Рік тому +1

      And sadly, the Ultra not the filter it used to be either. That is, not two layer full synthetic wire backed media of the OG Ultra. First Brands has seriously cheapened the media now.

    • @clydeespinosa6286
      @clydeespinosa6286 Рік тому

      I’m running a Fram Ultra XG9100 on my 08 GMC Duramax purchased at NM Walmart. It seems to be working ok.

  • @SimpleTastyFood2024
    @SimpleTastyFood2024 Рік тому +1

    So nice of Jason! Both look good. Fram may be better. TFS Pete and Merry Christmas! 🎄 Merri :)

  • @mikebradshaw8530
    @mikebradshaw8530 Рік тому +1

    If the fram was longer along the tape measure, than with all measurements being equal except for length the fram should cover more in square inches.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      But it's not as wide so it comes out to have less square inches but not by much. I wouldn't even worry about that small of a difference.

  • @kruelzombieful
    @kruelzombieful Рік тому +5

    That Wix filter looks a lot like a Boss filter. Could it be possible that Purolator now makes those? No more metal mesh but a plastic one. I mean they both are owned by the same company. Oh and the last 3 Wix filters I purchased have had the louvers not cut open correctly. The louvers are indented but not pierced thru. And all were purchased in different locations and at different times.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +3

      It could be made on the same machines? But I think they are made slightly different. I know the bypass valve and the micron rating are not the same, Purolator usually but not always have elongated inlet holes. I would take the Boss over this XP.
      I prefer the holes but if a filter has louvers, definitely inspect them with a flashlight. I know it's a hassle but maybe you could bring them back, that way they'll know they are making junk, and we won't buy them. Thanks for Sharing!

    • @vincemajestyk9497
      @vincemajestyk9497 Рік тому

      The Wix and the Purolator Boss are made at separate locations on different lines. All of these oil filters are made on automated equipment that require attention to ensure it is operating properly (to design and QC standards). If you have a poorly trained or inattentive workforce you're going to have production problems that involve hundreds to thousands of finished products. Most of these plants only sample 1 in 1000 (or more) finished products in a run. It's hard to get a filter that's completely representative of the entire product line. In spite of the problems with both, the Fram looks like the better value. That plastic screen is just as functional in this application as the old metal screen, plus it can be fused to the media. It's all around cheaper for manufacturing which I'm sure they like. The cellulose backer on the Fram serves the same purpose but also adds a degree of filtration.

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      That is correct, the Boss, Bosch and Purloator are all made by Mann-Hummel. The Fram, Amsoil, Royal Purple and Mobil1 are all made by Champion Labs. And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over most of them.

  • @HoldenMcRotch
    @HoldenMcRotch Рік тому +3

    Efficiency rating on the WIX is pretty poor compared to other premium oil filters! I'd definitely pass on it. Why do 99%@35 microns when you can do 99%@20 microns for less money? It's a no brainer for me!

    • @rhyno514
      @rhyno514 Рік тому

      Even the synthetic blend mobil is at 30 , it's doesn't make any sense lol

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them.

  • @davidnelson6893
    @davidnelson6893 Рік тому +1

    Yes you got that right Peace out

  • @johnd4348
    @johnd4348 4 дні тому

    The only true test is to push oil thru them and see what the flow rate is and then measure how much contaminates each filter pickes up.

  • @404notfound.....
    @404notfound..... Рік тому +2

    Great video whip! I will give the can to fram, but everything else wix!! Happy holidays & merry Christmas. 🎄🇨🇦

  • @holeshot26
    @holeshot26 11 місяців тому

    looks like the wix xp wins to me! price cant beat quality & the weights of the can are irrelevant. also you dont need that textured grip if you installed the filter correctly

  • @Moxzot
    @Moxzot 11 місяців тому +1

    Curiosity killed the cat, why does the fram have more filter but less sq inches, pleats shouldn't play that big of a difference the wix was smaller and thinner.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  11 місяців тому

      You can recheck the measurements at the 7:17 mark, but here they are,
      The Fram is 1.80" wide x 53" long = 95.40 sq.in. The Wix is 2.11" wide x 48" long =101.28 sq.in.

    • @Moxzot
      @Moxzot 11 місяців тому +1

      @@WhipCityWrencher Ahh thank you for the reply, missed the diameter, just assumed they were the same.

  • @mudpuddle2658
    @mudpuddle2658 Рік тому +3

    Thanks, Pete.

  • @LarryCook1960
    @LarryCook1960 Рік тому

    Several, but not all, of the details between these two filters seem very similar to the Supertech vs Mobil 1 comparison. Perhaps Wix makes Mobil 1 and Fram makes Supertech.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      Hi Larry,
      It's complicated.
      Here's some of what I know about who makes what. Champ Labs. makes Supertech oil filters.
      Mann and Hummel own Wix, Purolator. Mobil and some others.
      First Brand makes the Fram oil filters. First Brand also owns Champ Labs which makes a lot of other oil filters.
      Thanks!

  • @chrisbehan6451
    @chrisbehan6451 Рік тому +1

    I'm no longer a big Wix fan. But before everyone runs and buys the Fram based on micron rating, keep mind that highly efficient media is still utilized within Fram's flawed design, which can let dirty unfiltered oil bypass the media through the gap between that stamped metal spring and the open metal end cap. This is the same design flaw that has been carried across the entire Fram line for decades.

    • @bigdavedayday1581
      @bigdavedayday1581 Рік тому +1

      Not really i've personally open up these filters. The fram bottom metal end caps where the leaf springs by pass valve meets .have a ruber type seal on them

  • @mark8684
    @mark8684 Рік тому +3

    I’d like to purchase a filter opener tool. Which tool has worked well for you?

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      I've been using the same one now for a few years, here's a link to the one I use.
      www.speedwaymotors.com/Speedway-Engine-Motor-Oil-Filter-Cutter-Tool,2618.html

  • @memopadilla5931
    @memopadilla5931 Рік тому +3

    Surprised the new Fram XG still won this one.. The Wix with .3 mm thickness is just not acceptable IMO and at almost TWICE the price.. it just is not worth it IMO. .. That Wix should be around $7 with that ultra thin material.

  • @TargaWheels
    @TargaWheels Рік тому +2

    Was the polymer backing on the WIX filter on the inside or the outside of the filter?
    Merry Christmas. 👍

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Merry Christmas!
      The polymer backing is on the inside towards the inner core.

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them with a wire mesh backing and fully Synthetic media.

  • @freedomliberty7611
    @freedomliberty7611 Рік тому +2

    Great job Pete. Merry Christmas 🤶

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Thank You, Freedom, and Merry Christmas!🎄

    • @freedomliberty7611
      @freedomliberty7611 Рік тому +1

      @@WhipCityWrencher this is Dwayne by the way

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      @@freedomliberty7611 Hi Dwayne, Thanks for reminding me.
      I knew you sent me a filter, and I had forgotten your name. I tried looking up your name in my old emails but I didn't see it because I was looking under your screen name.LOL Found it now though, how's the Escape running?

  • @smokinhalf
    @smokinhalf Рік тому +1

    The fram comes off easy AND goes on easy no tools ... sandpaper grip at the bottom

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them with a wire mesh backing and fully Synthetic media.

  • @spankyham9607
    @spankyham9607 Рік тому +1

    Preference vs cost vs convenience but I think either filter is more than adequate for the job. Wix probably edges out the Fram IMO but not enough that I care to spend the extra money on it.

    • @bigdavedayday1581
      @bigdavedayday1581 Рік тому +2

      How was wix edges the fram, fram have thicker cans, has the grip textures, pretty much both similar filter media, you can buy these fram almost anywhere Walmart sells them for $8, also made in the USA Fram wins

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      @@bigdavedayday1581 And Now the Fram Endurance walks all over both of them for $12.97 at Walmart.

  • @stevenwright248
    @stevenwright248 Рік тому +5

    Good Morning Pete!
    Thanks again for your insight on all these filters! I’d have to go with the Fram on this one!
    Keep up the good work, Sir !
    Wishing you a Merry Christmas 🎄!!
    Take care and Be Safe!!

  • @poolmotorrepairguyFL
    @poolmotorrepairguyFL Рік тому +2

    Jay the Florida pool pump motor repair guy. When Service Calls Longwood approved ! that was good info 2 see👨‍🔧good job !! WCW

  • @SilverSergeant
    @SilverSergeant Рік тому +2

    For me, Fram wins.

  • @GereDJ2
    @GereDJ2 Рік тому +1

    Would a filter with a lower micron rating be better than a higher number? e.g., 20 would be better than a 30 micron rating because it filters out smaller particles?

  • @tssci6774
    @tssci6774 Рік тому +1

    Fram uses slight of terminology that people miss. Instead of saying 99% @ 20 microns, they greater than 20. Does that mean filters 99% of all particulates of 20.1 microns in size. No. They just say that at some size greater than 20 microns, they achieve that efficiency. That could be 30, 40 or even 50 microns. WIX is specific and say at 30 microns they are able to achieve that efficiency. For Fram, at 20.1 microns they are possibly only 97%. Be wary of filters with high number of pleats, or dense folds. Once saturated and under pressure the media expands and closes off the outer folds, leaving top outer edges. I have a cartridge WIX XP where it swelled up, restricted oil flow and caused lifter noise on cold starts. Replaced with oem and problem solved.

  • @Naterbomb88
    @Naterbomb88 Рік тому +1

    Merry Christmas!!!

  • @danhambrick6331
    @danhambrick6331 Рік тому +1

    Merry Christmas Whip City Wrencher....

  • @vacuumtube1954
    @vacuumtube1954 Рік тому

    Excellent video my friend. At the moment I'm using the WIX XP. Next one I will use will be the Purolator Boss.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Thank You Vacuumtube!
      The Boss is a good well-made oil filter👍.

    • @vacuumtube1954
      @vacuumtube1954 Рік тому

      @@WhipCityWrencher I am looking forward to using the Boss. Please keep your videos coming WCW !👍

  • @stevenchen1156
    @stevenchen1156 Рік тому

    Did you see the spot under the gasket. That is the reason why it may leaking

  • @CL-yp1bs
    @CL-yp1bs Рік тому +4

    The lower line Frams are cheap crap but in this regard the Fram eats the wix for lunch.

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them with a wire mesh backing and fully Synthetic media.

  • @johnjubie7144
    @johnjubie7144 Рік тому +1

    The Wix XP just isn't in the same league as the Fram, 99%@ 35 microns? Rock catcher.

  • @jamesyarbrough4777
    @jamesyarbrough4777 Рік тому +1

    i think fram xg wins on micron rating alone.

  • @patt693
    @patt693 Рік тому +4

    Wix pleats are spaced much better than Fram

  • @missysass1806
    @missysass1806 Рік тому +1

    Hi friend catching up 👍🐕

  • @twinforce_fusion6560
    @twinforce_fusion6560 Рік тому +1

    Do you have a mail box to send you used oil filters? got a few trucks and cars with high mileage (oil change at every 5K). With different oil filters (Eco labs, Champ, Champions, Mahle, etc.)

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Yes, I do Send me an Email with what you have! Poker4me007@gmail.com

  • @XenomorphLV426
    @XenomorphLV426 Рік тому

    Merry Christmas 🎄

  • @SlikLizrd
    @SlikLizrd Рік тому +1

    A very Merry Christmas and a Joyous Holiday Season to all !! Great comparison !! 2 top-of-the-line filters -- Both very popular, if not for the same reasons.
    Slight differences between the 2 -- no deal-breakers -- EXCEPT the HUGE difference in Micron Ratings.
    35 Microns is 175% of 20 Microns -- and we have no way to know which filter actually performs better in the field -- as per usual, it's a big-ass guessing game. 😁
    No reason for me to buy either of these filters, because of my 5,000-mile OCIs -- the Bosch Premium, with it's "Made in U.S.A." and "AT 20-Micron" rating, suits me perfectly.
    In passing:
    Polymer = Plastic = Polymer.
    The thicker gasket gives no advantage.
    Wix has best Core Tube design. -- Spiral-wound core with Louvers.
    Fram has larger hole area in Base Plate -- for smoother, more even flow.
    The trend today is toward Extended OCIs of 15-20,000 miles -- it's f**king scary -- NO WAY would I leave oil and filter in there for 20,000 miles.
    The famous 95 MERC is 27 years old -- and is now elegible for Old Age Benefits, including the warm, Arizona "Valley of the Sun" Winters.
    Freezing your ass off !?? NAH -- it's all in your mind -- Remember, our disgraced, 2wice-impeached, tax-cheating, pu$$y-grabbing, ex-president told us : "It's all a Democrat hoax !"

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Merry Christmas, Chuck!

    • @SlikLizrd
      @SlikLizrd Рік тому +1

      @@WhipCityWrencher Thank you, Pete -- and may you and yours enjoy the Christmas/Holiday season -- free of want and worry.
      Thanks again for the interesting comparison/review.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      @@SlikLizrd 👍

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому

      Hopefully Santa brings you a big box of stamped leaf retainer springs and you are using garland rated at 99% for partridges down to 20 microns.

  • @gcash2074
    @gcash2074 Рік тому +2

    Fram Ultra seems a little better.

    • @Balticblue93
      @Balticblue93 Рік тому

      And now Fram has the Endurance line at Walmart for $12.97 and walks all over both of them.

  • @msclecarcrzy
    @msclecarcrzy Рік тому +4

    To me the fram ultra has downgraded since they did away with the wire backing. The wix xp media looks better and at least it's backed and doesn't tear as easy. Wix XP for the win on this one 👍

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому +1

      Thanks for the feedback!👍

    • @SlikLizrd
      @SlikLizrd Рік тому +4

      The trend has been toward the elimination of the bulky Wire Screen Backing -- to make room for MORE PLEATS and a larger filtering area -- less likely to clog.
      The Polymer Mesh Backing is thin and stiff, which is all that's needed to prevent tearing of the media.

    • @jeffkortsch8276
      @jeffkortsch8276 Рік тому +1

      @@SlikLizrd The Fram has the all-important stamped leaf retainer spring as prescribed by the Fram website. A winner!

    • @faxmen09
      @faxmen09 Рік тому

      You are correct, The Ultra media has been significantly cheapened from the OG two ply full synthetic wire backed media it had. The wire backing was needed for support of full synthetic media. Now it uses a thin blended media to back the thin synthetic layer. XP/(Platinum) media does 'look' much more substantial.

    • @SlikLizrd
      @SlikLizrd Рік тому

      @@faxmen09 I'm curious to know what effect the elimination of the Wire Screen Backing had on the Micron Rating when compared to the Polymer-Backed media with More Pleats.
      Anybody know the Manufacturer's Stated Reason for the elimination of the bulky Wire Mesh Screen ?
      What problems were solved by adding the Wire Screen ?
      What problems were they trying to solve by removing the Wire Screen ?
      Seems like we can only GUESS -- 'cause they don't wanna tell us what their intentions are.

  • @DannerPlace
    @DannerPlace Рік тому

    Great comparo.

  • @PurpleDreki
    @PurpleDreki Рік тому +8

    Greetings oilheads..

  • @freddyflintstoned913
    @freddyflintstoned913 Рік тому +1

    Fram about half price. These go into the trash at about 3000 miles. Why pay more.

  • @bigjim5551212
    @bigjim5551212 Рік тому +2

    Pretty even. Wix has more filter. Wix

  • @rickbrown7067
    @rickbrown7067 Рік тому +2

    I’m disappointed about the wix filter. They have gone down hill since Mann Hummel bought them. No coil spring, and filtration level = to toilet paper and high prices. Not worth it. I’d rather run Walmart filters.

  • @skelafeti
    @skelafeti Рік тому

    oil filter is cheap compared to a new engine. I'll take wix all day every day, and I do. Unless you're on of those guys that change vehicles like their boxers and than this doesn't apply to them. The only thing Fram has going for it is it's slick marketing these days, riding on their coat tails from days gone by when it use to be the game of the town.

  • @RM.....
    @RM..... Рік тому +3

    20,000 miles that’s hilarious. No car should be going 20,000 miles on an oil change.

    • @WhipCityWrencher
      @WhipCityWrencher  Рік тому

      You got that right!👍

    • @clarkkent1521
      @clarkkent1521 Рік тому

      20k mile rating doesn't mean you should use it for 20k miles. Just like 200-300 HP cars. People are never going to use the full 300 HP. Probably use just 100-150 or less HP because they only do commute driving. But it's better to buy a car with more horsepower than you need so it doesn't struggle than a car with just enough horsepower that needs to use all its power. So it's better to buy a 20k oil filter and change it at 10k than to buy a 10k oil filter and change it at 10k. Like a tow strap rated for X pounds. You don't want to put X load on it, you want to put on a load that is less than X.

  • @AaronPunkoney
    @AaronPunkoney 2 місяці тому

    SuperTech for me

  • @phlfly10
    @phlfly10 9 місяців тому

    Well no where to find a pressure drop vs flow rate !!! It can be better filtration but higher pressure drop when pump is not ready compensate for a pressure drop. So your assessment is just mechanical design nothing more. People don't trust more or less filtration as pressure drop is a key

  • @cassymars4298
    @cassymars4298 Рік тому +1

    🐕👍

  • @mickeyhammons7927
    @mickeyhammons7927 6 місяців тому

    That was not the synthetic fram filter you showed at the end that was a different filter it was all old and dirty come on dude

  • @richardmerriam7044
    @richardmerriam7044 Рік тому +1

    Fram products are junk.