Purolator Boss PBL14476 Oil Filter vs. Wix XP 51394XP Oil Filter Cut Open Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 чер 2024
- Oil Filter Inspection. #Mobil #Motorcraft #Supertech #Wix #Fram
Today we'll compare this Purolator Boss oil filter to a Wix XP oil filter.
Purolator Boss PBL14476 oil filter : shop.advanceautoparts.com/p/p...
Wix XP 51394XP oil filter : www.oreillyauto.com/detail/c/...
Welcome!
► Want to become part of a Great Story? Please consider donating to this Great Organization. Thank You and God Bless! www.shrinershospitalsforchild...
► Hope you like the video, Please don't forget to Like,👍 Subscribe, and Hit the Bell 🔔 to See Future Videos. Thanks for Watching 👀, and Keep on Wrenching 🔧. Take Care!
► Subscribe: / whipcitywrencher
► Follow on Facebook: Whipcitywren...
► Music: www.bensound.com/
►Disclaimer: This video is for entertainment purposes only. Any information and content contained in this video are for entertainment purposes only. I ( WhipCityWrencher) shall not be liable for any injury, damage, loss, or even death to any person or property resulting from watching this video. Duplicating anything in this video is doing so at your own risk. Fram,
Mobil,
auto oil filter,
AutoZone,
Rockauto,
Advanced auto parts,
best oil filter,
Fram oil filter,
automotive,
Champion oil filter,
oil filter cut open,
Fram,
car filter,
Supertech,
K&N,
used filter,
metal end caps,
silicone valve,
Bosch,
anti-drain back valve,
Walmart,
filter media,
Mobil oil filter,
micron rating,
micron,
Purolator,
Purolator boss,
Purolator one,
adv,
pleats,
ultra,
Fram ultra,
Walmart Supertech,
Supertech,
Pennzoil,
fuel cleaner,
injectors,
Blackstone Lab,
Wix, - Авто та транспорт
Thanks, Pete, awesome job! They are nice and clean, except for the baseplates, they look like they came out of the same assembly line. You could swap the filter media in each without knowing the difference. I guess the Boss filter has a nicer paint job. I'd give the edge to the XP just for the baseplate, but I do have a boss on the Matrix right now and I am glad I do. I have an XP on the shelf and I will put it in the next time I change the oil. Great to have the peace of mind knowing I did put a good filter in. That car is her bread and butter.
You're Welcome Jim
Yep, I think either one of these oil filters is a good filter for your Matrix.
Thanks for the oil filters👍💯
@@WhipCityWrencher Thanks for cutting them up! Nice to know they are doing their job!
Yup, definitely the same!! You're right Pete in the end I would go with the wix. Cheers 🇨🇦
Good Idea have Pete open those two oil filters up James! Now we all know! Btw I’m on my 2nd oil Change now, using the 15w40 Royal Purple with a qt of Seafoam. It’s running amazing. I put a K&N Reusable Oil Filter on it. There were expense back in the day $400-$500. But they are great Oil Filters. And they have a magnet in them. Thank you again for the suggestion. It’s working great
@@colindubord4239 Thanks! I'll be honest, I won't buy a new brand of filter unless I get Pete to inspect it first! You are very welcome.
They look identical except for the base plates.👍👍
Saved me 11 minutes.
Both brands belong to Mann + Hammel, so we are talking about the same product with a different name and price with minimal differences.
The spring boing, boing makes me so happy!!!!!!! Lol I always want to know whats in the bag papa? Lol
The fist commerical oil filter was a roll of toilet paper..in a can ... we've came a long way 😆 thanks for sharing 🇺🇸
Bahahaha, basically described a orange can of death FRAM 💀 🧻🛢
You're Welcome👍
Wix and Purolator are both great.
The white residue on the WIX anti-drain back valve is probably a mold release agent.
It’s a sort of lubricant/not-sticky coating that gets sprayed into the mold so that the parts don’t stick to the metal mold.
In my opinion, the only thing that really matters is the media and bypass spring. Some of the build quality stuff appears a little betterthen others but I have never had an issue with can thickness, failed o-ring, or threads. I want a great filtering filter with a bypass valve that opens and closes properly and doesnt leak. I watched another video of filters being tested and oil was get through the bypass valve with clean fluid, clean filter, and warm oil. So not cold oil or plugged filter. If they come out of the same factory or manufacturer, the Boss could have better filter rating due to the slightly thicker media. Im not an oil or filter expert but I do own a company with hard use commercial vehicles and have been through tens of millions of mile in oil changes.
I think the larger inlet holes are worth the extra dollar, but I'd feel safe using either one.
I agree😊
I used WIX filters until their parent corp Mann+Hummel moved production outside the USA. I switched to Mobil 1 since those are made in the USA and have tested well in different reviews.
The Mobil oil filters are made by Mann +Hummel also, but you're right they are made in the USA.
Both are great filters. The Boss is overpriced though. Over the past several years, I’ve found the Wix XP are the best for the money. I usually order off off Rock Auto.
Hey thanks for sharing that! I'll go check out rockauto for the XPs when I need to buy more.
Makes sense that they would be very similar since Purolator and Wix are now owned by the same parent company Mann-Hummel. In fact the last few purolator air filters I bought have been re-boxed wix filters.
Thanks for Sharing👍
I'm running that same Purolator with Valvoline 0W-16 right now on my Camry. Usually go 8-9 thousand miles per oil change. These are all highway miles. 60mph
I think it's a very good oil filter!
Thanks for Sharing👍💯
Ok good to have a back up for my regular purchases of THE BOSS. The last time I went to buy filters, they didn’t have a Boss for my truck so I got a Fram Titanium. Next time I’ll find the Wix.
I can't explain why I like your vids so much😅😅😅. Keep them coming. Thank you.
You're Welcome😊
Yeah I want to send him all of my used filters.
Been using the Boss filters for years now. Is my go to filter. Even knowing the 2 are pretty much identical, next week the wix could be different, so i just stick to a sure thing. Boss filter, penz ultra plat and a little lubeguard biotech, best quality vs price.
Both made by Man Hummel. Those look identical minus the baseplate.
I have used both Purolator Boss filters and the Wix XP filters on my vehicle. In this case, I would probably go with the XP but both are about the same.
Hi Jeff
I agree about the same, can't go wrong with either one.
Both very similar. Boss made by Purolator (Fayettville NC), XP could be made at Wix plant, but hard to say 100%. XP baseplate is Wix design, flat spring bypass on both, long time Purolator design. M&H is moving Wix design more towards Purolator. Both look well-made, polymer backing works well. Like both US made. Good filters, imo. Thanks for the vid. 👍
Both are Mann and Hummel. Same plant, just different production dates, hence why only the base plates and gasket are a little different.
You're Welcome faxmen09👍💯
@@OfficialNakatsuMegami While M&H own Puro and Wix, both operate out of different plants in NC. Wix in Gastonia, not near Purolator plant In Fayettville. Baseplates are diffident because XP classic Wix design, Boss class Purolator. Only Purolator has and identifiable Purolator date code starting with F. So your conclusion both made in same plant without proof nothing more than speculation at this point.
The Purolator Boss 25 Micron rating is based on their PBL30001 oil Filter if you go to their website. So I’m guessing they are both 35 Microns. Awesome Video! I’d go with the Boss.
There are some small differences but they look like the same manufacturer made them both. Nice work my friend.
Thanks👍💯
Awesome comparison, thank you for cutting these filters up and even showing us what the filter media looks like under a microscope!
You're Welcome and Thanks for Watching👍
Nice comparo Pete. I’ll take that Wix. It’s not a racing filter, don’t need the heavier base plate on the Boss. Marketing boys, “Boss”, make it heavier so it feels premium. Well, the marketing boys can go fly a kite.
Thank You👍
The Wix and Napas are made in Mexico now. No more USA. 😢. GOOD video Pete. Happy Easter.
Thanks, John, Happy Easter👍
For years the wix/Napa 1334 was exclusively built in NC and we purchased them by the cases. Now, with MH at the helm they’re all coming out of China. I actually got banned from giving product reviews for Amazon because I said that I wouldn’t recommend buying them anymore because of the location of their production. I got an email saying that they banned me for hate speech. Whatever, I’m not going to support a Communist Regime whenever I have the option to buy something from the United States or another country.
The last Napas I got were made in china 🤢🤢
@@justinlee2642 the 51334 filters have been switched to China as well as others that were previously produced in North Carolina. I used to be a huge supporter of Wix filters in my shop but not so much since MH purchased them. If I have any other options available I will not buy from the CCP regardless of who’s brand is on the box.
Thanks for the review. They look like would both do the job. But the price is high.
You're Welcome👍
I remember back when the Purolator Boss was introduced, it was advertised as "only available at" the specific retailer. I don't think it's still exclusive, but the altered baseplate seems like a way to use mostly the same parts to make two "different" filters so that exclusivity could be claimed.
I like the price and paint color better on the Purolator Boss, but for functionality, I'd go with the Wix XP, only because of the larger baseplate holes.
Geez... I feel like I'm late to the party! I always look forward to Oil Filter Friday mornings!
Great video, Whip...
👍🏾
Thank you!👍
Wish the Purolator had the larger inlet holes. The filter media does appear the same visually, but the Brand Ranks video showed that the Purolator did a significantly better job at filtering small particles. It must have like an extra layer of fine media in there or something, despite looking the same. Maybe there is some variation in other filter sizes.
Some of the Purolator base plates have elongated inlet holes other sizes don't 🤔
The larger inlet holes would most likely increase flow. With that increase in flow it could possibly force larger particles through the filter.
That's my thoughts on why they have different particle ratings.
Theoretically, it wouldn't change the rating because they use the same filter media?
► Top Tier Gasoline list: www.toptiergas.com/gasoline-brands/
► Find the cheapest TopTier gas in your area. www.gasbuddy.com/home
► Thanks For Watching and Please hit the 👍 button!
I try and make an oil filter inspection video every Friday on this UA-cam channel, Thank You!
The Florida pool pump motor repair guy 32750 approved ! that was good info & see WCW
Thanks, Jay👍
I would bet most filter media actually filters better than its rated for. 🤠
I love the motomaster oe at canadian tire . I think it's a castrol cas but branded motomaster . Way more affordable
Hey, Whipman: You could check out the 1st. 5 numbers on the Barcode; if they're manufactured by the same Co., those 5 numbers will coincide!
Nope, I just checked the barcodes, the numbers don't match.
Similar to each other. You always do such a good job with your reviews Pete. A happy and blessed Easter to you and your family ✝
Thanks, Merri
Have a Blessed Easter to you and your family also.🙌
Think you wouldn't go wrong with either one. Thanks 👍
Happy Easter ✝️
Thanks,
Happy Easter🙌
Hi friend great sharing 👍
I’d say the slight mil difference on the material dictates the advertised flow rate other wise same filtering media.
This guys reviews make me so happy 🎉
Thank You!👍
I'm glad you like the videos, I appreciate it.😊
Thanks for keeping these vids coming bc things change every year. Purolator and wix are both owned my Mann now. So they are probably more similar than ever!
You're Welcome!
You got that right, these oil filters are changing all the time! Thanks👍
Great review Pete! Thank for sharing. Have a Happy Easter!
Thanks, Dan!
Have a Happy Easter😊
I guess the one that was on clearance at rockauto would be the one I would buy. Some times they have boss filters for less than a buck.
Right now, I would choose the Boss because it is being exclusively produced in the USA at their Fayetteville, NC plant. That could change at any time with MH ownership. They have no loyalty whatsoever to American workers…or any other workers for that matter.
Boss base plate is heavier and thicker than the Wix. That appears to be the only substantive difference between the two filters. *Edit: And the gasket material. Boss is better.
Guess it would come down to cost at this point since they are both the same.
so I have an oil filter cutting tool and as i suspected, the wix xp 51348XP is not a synthetic filter and it has zero wire or mesh backing at all, and I was able to tear the filter media by hand. The box it came in says its a wix xp superior filtration for full synthetic oils and the filter matches whats pictured on the box. I also just cut open a 57502XP and it has a synthetic filter media and I ordered both filters from rock auto. I don't understand why they would get rid of the synthetic filter and the wire or mesh backing and still call it a wix xp made. Both also say made in usa. I guess I might make a qick video or something or post a picture on social media?
I've heard they are changing as well, lets see if they all change.🤔
Great video WhipCityWrencher,
Thanks, WrenchingMafia👍💯
The Wix looks like a slightly cheaper version. Brand Ranks did an extensive & extremely scientic test on both these filters the Purolator Boss is by far superior. It's the best filter they have ever tested. The wix is ranked #7, and after personally using both filters the Boss is better.
Twins of the same except for the baseplates & gaskets
Wix is a relabeled Boss since Mann and Hummel took over
I used to be a WIX fan...until I found the Microgard Select. Not a fan of louvers or the WIX trend as of late.
80 happy Easter
Happy Easter🙌
Thanks for your videos. Wix ❤
You're Welcome👍
👍
I think the Wix has a slight edge but both are fine filters.
The filter media "might" be the same. The Boss was rated at 99% at 25mm, whereas the Wix was rated at 99% at 35mm. In your measurements, the Boss was a little thicker. Could that just be normal variation on thickness of any filter media? Maybe! I wouldn't guarantee that the Boss filters out smaller particles, but my guess is that it probably does. Hm. Either way, two really good filters. Great comparison.
Thank You👍
Great review! How about Fram Ultra or Endurance vs Purolator Boss? Which one wins the vote?
I just did a Fram Endurance and Wix XP a week ago. ua-cam.com/video/gTWVSSzyrow/v-deo.html
The same and that is the way things go.
I stopped using the Wix filters 2 1/2 years ago as the quality of the particular ones I was using slipped too much. Most of any of these filters you really need to compare them all number by number. Even though they're owned by the same parent corp, early on in the purchase, they both had separate tooling, supply sources and manufacturing. As one would expect, Mann would begin over time through attrition or aging, streamlining or consolidating the supply materials and processes of both brands. Wix was always in Gastonia as far as I can remember. Purolator ended up in Fayetteville more recently. This is all too common when these large trans national conglomerates buy up the competition. Late stage Capitalism.
End stage capitalism is making everything harder for consumers because the bottom line matters not quality, I'm looking in Boeing's direction.😐
@texavery711 Without quality, the bottom line doesn't exist with consumer purchasing power.
@@jack11224 they spend less on parts use inferior parts inflate the price the consumer pays they get their money you get junk.
Sorry gang, but no 'Cheese Grater' oil filters for me. Only lots of round holes. More oil pressure? I really would like the nylon cage center tube if they were made out of metal.
The Boss got top honors as best all around oil filter in an engineers test of oil filters (it included the Wix): ua-cam.com/video/0ReYsM9OMuI/v-deo.html
What's the micron rating????
Click here, 6:07
I’d like to send you a Baldwin from a diesel with 45k on the filter. Would you be interested in something like that?
What size is it?
Roughly 11x5 inches
@@bucket611 Someone else sent me a huge used oil filter I'll have to see how that one goes. Thanks!
Between the two it pretty much depends on the cost ! Save a $1 and buy the purolator or spend a $1and buy the wix ! I say the wix is worth the xtra buck ! Better baseplate ! The 35 micron rating has to be a typo ! What always gets me is the advertising made for synthetic engine oil is %100 gimmicky ! conventional oil will work just fine ! Lol ! 😝
Title needs changed filter number should be PBL14476
Fixed, Thank You😊👍💯
Both Identical. It's a Draw.
You said clearly that you would go for the wix but they both idénticas and Boss has the thiner bubber where the filter sits on the oil housing of the car and wix is thicker But as usual you missed the microscopic quality example of the filter mesh being more solid and sticky when the xix was more spread lose noticeble on the screen. Again you need get after 5k syntetic oil test on both cut-open and you will be really surprised how ugly the wix turns out. Plus the metal quality of the wix is as much as Fram. Go figure!
The only difference I saw between the two is the base plates.
@@WhipCityWrencher Base plate made out of scrapped recycle metal
Well on your next filter review you should address these concerns. Looking forward to your video effort 😊
👍